Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.1066 of 2022
Sri Ranjit Bhowmik, son of late Surjya Mohan Bhowmik, resident of Flat
No.-“A” Block (Ground Floor), Laxmi Kunja, Ramnagar, Road No.6,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799002.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura , represented by the Commissioner and Secretary,
Public Works Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O-Kunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Commissioner and Secretary, Public Works Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.OKunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin799006.
3. The Deputy Secretary, Public Works Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O-Kunjaban, P.SNew Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
4. The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O-Kunjaban, P.S-New Capital
Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
5. The Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by its Secretary,
having his office at TPSC Bhawan, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala,
Sub-division-Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
6. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
TPSC Bhawan, P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, Sub-division-Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799001.
….Official Respondent(s)
7. Sri Jhutan Dey, son of not known, holding the post of TES, Grade-IV,
(Assistant Engineer) (Mechanical), under the PWED (R&B/WR/DWS).
8. Sri Sanjib Bhattacharjee, son of not known, holding the post of TES,
Grade-IV, (Assistant Engineer) (Mechanical), under the PWED
(R&B/WR/DWS).
….Private Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate
Mr. B. Majumder, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
20.09.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for
respondents no.1 to 4, Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel appearing for
respondents no.5 and 6 and Mr. B. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for
respondent no.8.
2.
The petitioner has filed the present writ petition challenging the
promotion of respondent no.7 and the order assigning the current charge
upon the respondent no.8.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that he is senior to both the
respondents in the service. For many years the promotion to the post of TES,
Grade-III, (Mechanical) (Degree) from the post of TES, Grade-IV,
(Mechanical) (Degree) was stalled due to litigations as regards reservation
policy now pending before Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. However, the
State-respondents had taken a policy decision to recommence the process of
promotion of the officers in view of administrative exigencies. Accordingly,
the State-respondents had issued a notification dated 22.06.2021 formulating
the criteria/guidelines for promotion of the employees of the State
Government on ad-hoc basis.
4.
On the basis of this policy, the State-respondents constituted
DPC for effectuating promotion of TES, Grade-IV (Mechanical) (Degree) to
the post of TES, Grade-III (Mechanical) (Degree) on ad-hoc basis. The DPC
after consideration all the guidelines considered the promotion of the
respondent no.7. To decide the present writ petition, the case of respondent
no.8 cannot be taken into account as he was not promoted, but, was given
the current duty charge. So, the petitioner is only concerned with the
promotion of respondent no.7 to the post of TES Grade-III (Mechanical)
(Degree).
5.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has drawn the
attention of this Court to Clauses 6 and 7 of the notification dated
22.06.2021. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has also brought to the notice
of this Court paras 6 and 11 of the minutes of the DPC(Annexure-7 to the
writ petition). According to learned senior counsel for the petitioner, the
petitioner was/is eligible for promotion to the post of TES Grade-III
(Mechanical) (Degree). Learned senior counsel has submitted that it is the
obligation of the State-respondents to create supernumerary posts if no
vacancy is found against the said promotional post.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA for the
respondents-State has submitted that the DPC minutes clearly postulate that
the members have taken into account all aspects to evaluate the merits of the
eligible candidates, and after such consideration, the list of the officers
entitled to be considered for promotion to the post of TES Grade-III
(Mechanical) (Degree) was prepared. So, no interference is called for upon
the decision of the DPC.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties.
8.
Keeping in view the submissions advanced by learned senior
counsel for the petitioner, it would be relevant to reproduce para 6 and para
7 of the notification dated 22.06.2021.
“6. Now, the State Government hereby notifies the following Promotion Policy,
2021 as follows:
(i)
Rule 9 of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992 and the
provisos thereto shall be read in such a manner that only those SC &
ST candidates who have qualified solely on the basis of merit and
have never taken the benefit of reservation, will be treated to be own
merit candidates and entitle to occupy the posts meant for general
category and reservation shall be made cadre-wise.
(ii)
100 point roster shall apply only where the number of posts in the
cadre is 4(four) or more.
(iii) Where the post in the cadre are 3(three) or less, the 3(three) point
replacement roster shall be followed.
(iv)
Single post or small cadres cannot be combined to make the number
of posts more than 3(three).
7. Following the above policy, the DPC will identify employees eligible for
promotion to a particular post against the available vacancies. After this
exercise, DPC shall consider another exercise taking into account the procedure
as stated in the rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992. Due
to such exercise, if any candidate is found not considered in the process as
stated in the above process, then such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc
promotion by creating supernumerary post(s).”
It is also relevant to reproduce para 6 and para 11 of the DPC
minutes which are as under:
“6. As per information made available to the Selection Committee through the
Self Contained Note and the Final Seniority list published vide Memorandum
No.F.F.6(35)-PWD(E)/92 dated 04-06-2021 the following Tripura Engineering
Service, Grade-IV (Mechanical) (Degree & Diploma) are coming in the zone of
consideration for promotion to the post of TES Gr-III (Mechanical) (Degree &
Diploma), since they have completed more than 7 years of service in TES Gr-IV
(Mechanical) (Degree & Diploma) and passed the Departmental Examination in
full:Tripura Engineering Service, Grade-IV (Mechanical) (Degree)
Sl.
Name of officer
No.
Date of
Whether
Whether
Whether
appointment
departmental
qualifying
initially
in TES Gr-IV
exam cleared
service
appointed the
or not
completed or
post meant for
not
SC/ST or
subsequently
availed
reserved post
1.
Sri Shyamal Acharya
01-01-1986
Cleared
Completed
UR
2.
Sri Salil Bhattacharjee
25-06-1987
-do-
-do-
UR
3.
Sri Rajesh Reang
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
ST
4.
Sri Sankar Das
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
SC
5.
Sri Sanjoy Das
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
SC
6.
Sri Lalit Debbarma
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
ST
7.
Sri Bishu Debbarma
04-10-2008
-do-
-do-
ST
8.
Sri Manas Roy
20-12-2008
-do-
-do-
UR
9.
Sri Ranjit Bhowmik
27-12-2008
-do-
-do-
SC
10. Sri Jhutan Dey
28-02-2014
-do-
-do-
UR
11. Sri Apur Deb Barma
05-03-2014
-do-
-do-
ST
Tripura Engineering Service, Grade-IV (Mechanical) (Diploma)
Sl.
Name of officer
No.
Date of
Whether
Whether
Whether
appointment in
departmental
qualifying
initially
TES Gr-IV
exam cleared or
service
appointed the
not
completed
post meant for
or not
SC/ST or
subsequently
availed
reserved post
1.
Arun Kanti Das
24-04-2002
Cleared
Completed
SC
2.
Biswa Kr Jamatia
25-04-2002
-do-
-do-
ST
Denied Vigilance
Clearance
3.
Jayanta Chakraborty
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
UR
4.
Tanmoy Majumder
22-12-2007
-do-
-do-
UR
5.
Ranjan Kanti Bhowmik
04-10-2008
-do-
-do-
SC
11. The Selection Committee, have recommended the names of the following TES
Gr-IV (Mechanical) (Degree & Diploma) officers for promotion to TES GradeIII (Mechanical) (Degree & Diploma) on ad-hoc basis as one time measure
following various guidelines in Cabinet Notification No.F.2(24)-GA(P&T)/2021
dated 22-06-2021, subject to final verdict of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP
(C) No.19765 of 2015:(Mechanical) (Degree)
Sl. No.
Name of Officer
Recommended against
1.
Sri Shyamal Acharya (UR) as UR
UR
2.
Sri Salil Bhattacharjee (UR) as UR
UR
3.
Sri Rajesh Reang (ST) as ST
ST
4.
Sri Sankar Das (SC) as SC
SC
5.
Sri Sanjoy Das (SC)
Subject
to
creation
of
supernumerary post
6.
Sri Lalit Debbarma (ST) as ST
ST
7.
Sri Bishu Debbarma (ST) as ST
ST
8.
Sri Manas Roy (UR)
UR
9.
Sri Jhutan Dey (UR)
UR
10.
Sri Apur Deb Barma (ST)
Subject
to
creation
supernumerary post
(Mechanical) (Diploma)
Sl. No.
Name of Officer
Recommended against
of
1.
Sri Arun Kanti Das (SC)
SC
2.
Sri Jayanta Chakraborty (UR)
UR
3.
Sri Tanmoy Majumder (UR)
UR
4.
Sri Ranjan Kanti Bhowmik (SC)
Subject to creation of
supernumerary post
The serial number show in column No.1 of the table at para-11 above shall not
denote Inter-se-seniority.”
9.
From the DPC minutes it appears that the petitioner came
within the zone of consideration for promotion along with other
officers(para 6). On plain reading of para 11 of the DPC minutes it appears
that the Selection Committee recommended the names of the officers for
promotion to the post of TES Grade-III (Mechanical) (Degree holder) on adhoc basis as one time measure following various guidelines in Cabinet
Notification dated 22.06.2021subject to final verdict of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in SLP (C) No.19765 of 2015. The names of the officers considered
for promotion to the post of TES Grade-III (Mechanical) (Degree) have been
mentioned in tabular form here-in-above.
10.
From para 11 of the DPC minutes it also comes to fore that
though the petitioner came within the zone of consideration but his name
was not recommended by the DPC for promotion to the post of TES GradeIII (Mechanical) (Degree). The grievance of the petitioner is regarding the
promotion of the respondent no.7 Sri Jhutan Dey, who belongs to UR
category. It further reveals from the para 11 of the DPC minutes that two
candidates namely, Sri Sanjay Das(SC) and Sri Apur Deb Barma (ST) were
promoted by way of creation of supernumerary posts.
11.
On careful scrutiny of the DPC minutes, it comes to light that
DPC has considered all aspects required for promotion of TES Grade-IV
(Mechanical) (Degree) officers. There is no allegation of bias or mala fide
against the DPC. According to this Court, when the DPC has stated that they
have recommended the suitable candidates in accordance with the
guidelines, then, the Court has very limited power to re-examine and
interfere with the decision of the DPC, particularly when its action appears
to be bonafide.
12.
Again, the creation of supernumerary posts falls exclusively
within the realm of State policy, which the Court should refrain from
interfering with in the context of this particular case.
13.
In view of this, this Court refrains from issuing any direction
upon the respondents to consider the promotion of the petitioner to the post
of TES Grade-III (Mechanical) (Degree). However, since it is evident from
para 11 that two persons namely, Sri Sanjay Das and Sri Apur Deb Barma
were promoted by creating supernumerary posts, the respondents may
consider the promotion of the petitioner by creating supernumerary post of
TES Grade-III (Mechanical) (Degree), however, considering its necessity.
14.
The decision of the respondents may be communicated to the
petitioner within a period of 3(three) months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this judgment and order.
The instant writ petition stands disposed in the above terms.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.09.21
GHOSH 16:58:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review