The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 10.2020 praying for enhancement of monthly remuneration of contractual staffs of EDUSAT Network of Tripura, as 6 Nos. of EDUSAT Staff were at par with monthly remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha. Thereafter, respondents initiated a proposal to enhance the monthly remuneration of the petitioner from Rs.23,967/- to Rs.27,711/- as per decision dated 15.09.2022 with effect from 01.09.2022. Petitioner was, however, neither accorded the said enhanced monthly remuneration with effect from 01.04.2020, nor any arrear on account thereof was paid to him. The writ petition was disposed of on the first date itself while setting aside the memorandum dated 21.09.2022 by which the claim of grant of higher pay of Rs. 53,800/- to the petitioner was negated. The matter was remanded back to respondent Nos. 4 and 5 to pass a speaking order with regard to extending the benefits to the petitioner at par with the said employee i.e. pro-forma respondent since petitioner had alleged discrimination. [3] Thereafter, the State had filed a Review Petition No.31/2023 which was disposed of vide order dated 16.01.2024. The learned review Court though restored the memorandum dated 21.09.2022 which was earlier set aside vide order dated 17.03.2023 in WP(C) No.69/2023 but rest of the order passed in the writ petition was kept intact. The respondents were granted three months time to communicate the decision o…
22. 04.2024 and also sought direction for enhancement of monthly remuneration of Rs.27,711/- with effect from 01.07.2020 where the monthly remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical Assistant, was enhanced along with arrears thereof. [5] Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the enhancement of remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha was a pay upgradation treating his performance as outstanding on the basis of his efficiency and positive attitude. The periodical review and grant of annual increments to a government servant are permissible under established legal principle. Any assessment of extraordinary performance by a government servant cannot result in discrimination in such periodical review, allowances and yearly increments, admissible to other similarly situated government servants. If a higher pay scale is accorded in favour of one of the selectees, it is obligatory on the part of the government/employer to grant the same & similar higher pay benefits to other similarly situated selectees, applying the same parameters like pay matrix, pay band, multiplier etc. Non-grant thereof would result in violation of the equality doctrine. Therefore, non-grant of enhanced monthly remuneration of Rs.27,711/- in favour of the petitioner, with effect from the date from when monthly remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical Assistant w…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.394 of 2024
Sri Ramapati Chakraborty, son of Ram Kumar Chakraboty, resident of Rama
Tilla, Kamalasagar, PO-Kamalasagar, PS-Madhupur, District- Sepahijala
Tripura, PIN-799102.
.……… Petitioner (s).
Versus
1) The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary,
Elementary Education Department, Government of Tripura, having his
office at Secretariat Building, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
District West Tripura, PIN- 799006.
2) The Commissioner & Secretary, Elementary Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN799006.
3) The Director, Elementary Education, Government of Tripura, having his
office at Shiksha Bhawan, Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN799001.
4) The Director, State Council of Educational research and Training, having
his office at Abhoynagar, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
5) The State Project Director, Samagra Shhiksha, Tripura.
.…… Respondent(s).
For Petitioner (s) :
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Pranabindu Chakraborty, Advocate,
Ms. R. Debnath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
ORDER
04/10//2024
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Pranabindu Chakraborty, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate for the
respondents.
[2]
Petitioner have approached this Court in the present writ
petition on account of rejection of his claim relating to extending the benefits
at par with Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical Assistant vide impugned
order dated 22.04.2024 (Annexure-17).
The petitioner had earlier
approached this Court in WP(C) No.69/2023 on the plea that the SCERT had
enhanced the remuneration of one Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, pro-forma
respondent as he was considered “Outstanding” due to his efficiency &
positive attitude which was at par with remuneration of other Coordinators
of Samagra Shiksha. Being prejudiced thereby the petitioner along with
others had submitted a representation to the Director, SCERT dated
19.10.2020 praying for enhancement of monthly remuneration of contractual
staffs of EDUSAT Network of Tripura, as 6 Nos. of EDUSAT Staff were at
par with monthly remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha. Thereafter,
respondents initiated a proposal to enhance the monthly remuneration of the
petitioner from Rs.23,967/- to Rs.27,711/- as per decision dated 15.09.2022
with effect from 01.09.2022. Petitioner was, however, neither accorded the
said enhanced monthly remuneration with effect from 01.04.2020, nor any
arrear on account thereof was paid to him. The writ petition was disposed of
on the first date itself while setting aside the memorandum dated 21.09.2022
by which the claim of grant of higher pay of Rs. 53,800/- to the petitioner
was negated. The matter was remanded back to respondent Nos. 4 and 5 to
pass a speaking order with regard to extending the benefits to the petitioner
at par with the said employee i.e. pro-forma respondent since petitioner had
alleged discrimination.
[3]
Thereafter, the State had filed a Review Petition No.31/2023
which was disposed of vide order dated 16.01.2024. The learned review
Court though restored the memorandum dated 21.09.2022 which was earlier
set aside vide order dated 17.03.2023 in WP(C) No.69/2023 but rest of the
order passed in the writ petition was kept intact. The respondents were
granted three months time to communicate the decision on petitioner’s
representation. Thereafter, the impugned order dated 22.04.2024 (Annexure17) has been passed which reads as under:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
STATE COUNCIL OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH AND
TRAINING
Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura
……………………………………………………………………
File No.F.25(208)-DEE/LA/L-2/2023/53
Date 22/04/2024
Order
Whereas, Sri Ramapati Chakraborty, Cameraman had
filed a writ petition before The Hon'ble High Court of Tripura
vide no. WP (C) NO. 69 OF 2023 whereby the Hon'ble High
Court of Tripura directed the respondent"…..to pass a speaking
order with regard to extending the benefits to the petitioner herein
at par with the said employee i.e. pro-forma respondent herein..."
And Whereas, it is observed that the remuneration of Sri
Ramapati Chakraborty, Cameraman and Sri Kalyan Kishore
Saha, Technical Assistant were Rs.4000/- and Rs.6500/respectively at the time of their Joining in the Year 2007 in the
EDUSAT Network of SCERT, Tripura engaged on purely
Contractual basis for a period of one year.
And Whereas, The MHRD, Govt. of India placed one
time fund in the year 2006 for mitigating the expenditure of
EDUSAT activities and there after no fund was placed for this
purpose. Despite non continuation of the said EDUSAT Project
and non-continuation of fund from the MHRD, Govt. of India, the
Department chose to retain the petitioner on yearly basis with the
approval of the competent authority.
And whereas, since the said Post held by Sri Ramapati
Chakraborty and Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha are dissimilar by their
very nature, remuneration attached with the said posts are also
different.
And whereas, the said remuneration were revised from
time to time and presently fixed at Rs.27, 711/ for Cameraman
(Sri Ramapati Chakraborty) and Rs. 53,800/ for Technical
Assistant (Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha). At present their
remuneration is being arranged from the annual grant of SCERT
under Samagra Shiksha.
And whereas, since the said Posts are entirely dissimilar
and had different remunerations attached to them since the very
beginning, claim of Sri Ramapati Chakraborty for remuneration
at par with Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha appears inappropriate.
In view of the above facts, it has been decided not to
enhance the remuneration of Sri Ramapati Chakraborty,
Cameraman at par with Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical
Assistant.
This is issued in compliance with order of the Hon'ble
High Court of Tripura vide No. Rev. Petn. No. 31 of 2023 dated
16-01-2024.
Sd/(N.C. Sharma)
Director
SCERT, Tripura
[4]
Petitioner being aggrieved has assailed the said order dated
22.04.2024 and also sought direction for enhancement of monthly
remuneration of Rs.27,711/- with effect from 01.07.2020 where the monthly
remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical Assistant, was
enhanced along with arrears thereof.
[5]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the enhancement of remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha
was a pay upgradation treating his performance as outstanding on the basis
of his efficiency and positive attitude. The periodical review and grant of
annual increments to a government servant are permissible under established
legal principle. Any assessment of extraordinary performance by a
government servant cannot result in discrimination in such periodical
review, allowances and yearly increments, admissible to other similarly
situated government servants. If a higher pay scale is accorded in favour of
one of the selectees, it is obligatory on the part of the government/employer
to grant the same & similar higher pay benefits to other similarly situated
selectees, applying the same parameters like pay matrix, pay band, multiplier
etc. Non-grant thereof would result in violation of the equality doctrine.
Therefore, non-grant of enhanced monthly remuneration of Rs.27,711/- in
favour of the petitioner, with effect from the date from when monthly
remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha, Technical Assistant was enhanced
i.e. from 01.07.2020 along with arrears thereof, has resulted in violation of
the rights of the petitioner, guaranteed under Articles 14, 16, 19, 21 & 300A
of the Constitution of India and also the Statutory rights, guaranteed under
the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2017.
[6]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance
upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of K.T. Veerappa and others
versus State of Karnataka and others reported in (2006) 9 SCC 406 and
submitted that if the decision of the employer is unreasonable and
discriminatory vis-a-vis a section of employees, the writ Court can, in
exercise of judicial review, interfere in such administrative decisions
pertaining to pay fixation. Therefore, the impugned order may be set aside.
The respondents may be directed to enhance the monthly remuneration of
the petitioner commensurate with the increase granted to Sri Kalyan Kishore
Saha. However, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that since
both the posts are different, petitioner does not seek parity in enhancement
of remuneration on the same scale as that granted to Sri Kalyan Kishore
Saha. The enhancement of remuneration granted to the petitioner from time
to time are periodical revisions in contractual wages and not a financial
upgradation like that which has been granted to Kalyan Kishore Saha on
finding his performance as outstanding. Therefore, interference may be
made.
[7]
Mr.
Kohinoor
N.
Bhattacharyya,
learned
Government
Advocate has supported the impugned order. He has also referred to the
averments made in the counter affidavit. It is the case of the respondents that
initially engagement of the petitioner and other technical persons in the year
2007 was made under EDUSAT scheme on purely contractual basis for a
period of one year on a consolidated remuneration of Rs.4,000/- only. Clause
(viii) of the appointment reflects that the engagement would be treated as
terminated after one year from the date of joining automatically and this
engagement shall not accrue any claim for future absorption. It is further
stated that MHRD, Government of India had placed one time fund in the
year 2007 for meeting the EDUSAT activities but thereafter, no fund was
placed for this purpose nor was any formal communication made for closure
of the EDUSAT activities. The contractual persons engaged under EDUSAT
scheme have been continuing since their appointment and presently their
remuneration are being managed form the fund of MMER of Teacher
Education / Annual Grant of SCERT under Samagara Shiksha. It is further
stated that Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha was working in a different post of
Technical Assistant. He was initially granted the fixed remuneration of
Rs.6,500/- per month. The post and remuneration of the petitioner and Sri
Kalyan Kishore Saha are, therefore, dissimilar and different. At paragraph9 of the counter affidavit, the periodical financial enhancement of
remuneration granted to the petitioner at different stages, is furnished. It
shows that the petitioner got enhancement of his remuneration from
Rs.4,000/- in the year 2007 to Rs. 9,330/- with effect from 01.07.2010;
Rs.12,147 with effect from 01.10.2012; Rs.17,726/- and thereafter
Rs.23,967- with effect from 01.02.2018. The last enhancement was made on
01.09.2022 @Rs.27,967/-. According to the respondents no fund has been
placed by the government of India for continuing with the engagement of the
technical persons engaged under EDUSAT activities. Petitioners and others
are being made to work on purely temporary basis. As such, the case of the
present petitioner is completely dissimilar to that of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha
who was initially engaged on the post of technical assistant @Rs.6500/- per
month which has been periodically revised from time to time. Therefore,
petitioner’s claim that he should be treated at par with Sri Kalyan Kishore
Saha is not correct since petitioner and Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha are not
similarly situated. There is no basis to allege discrimination in the
enhancement of remuneration of both of them. Therefore, no case of
arbitrariness of discrimination could be made out by the petitioner vis-a-vis
the enhancement granted to Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha. Therefore, the
impugned order deserves no interference and the instant petition may be
dismissed.
[8]
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the attended materials facts placed from record. As
noted above, petitioner approached this Court on account of enhancement of
remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha to Rs.53,800/- claiming that other
employees of the EDUSAT scheme should also be treated at par with the
monthly remuneration of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha. After the matter was
finally remitted to the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner on
such claim by the order dated 16.01.2024 passed in Review Petition
No.31/2023, the respondents have vide impugned order dated 22.04.2024
rejected his claim on the ground that the post of Cameraman held by the
petitioner is dissimilar to the post of technical assistant held by Sri Kalyan
Kishore Saha from the very beginning. They have been receiving different
remunerations right from their initial engagement. While petitioner was
engaged as a cameraman @Rs.4,000/- per month initially for a period of
one year, Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha was engaged under the same EDUSAT
scheme @Rs.6,500/- per month initially also for a period of one year. It is
not that petitioner has not been granted enhancement in remuneration since
his engagement from time to time and lastly with effect from 01.09.2022
@ Rs.27,967/-. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has sought to
emphasize that the enhancement granted to the pro-forma respondent-Sri
Kalyan Kishore Saha, is in the nature of a financial upgradation like revision
in pay scale and that too on the basis of his outstanding performance as
assessed by the respondents but the remuneration of the petitioner has been
increased on an incremental basis and there is no such financial upgradation
in the scale of pay vis-a-vis that of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha and other
coordinators of the Samagra Shhiksha. On that basis the decision of the
respondents not to grant enhancement of remuneration to the petitioner has
been questioned relying upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
K.T. Veerappa and others (supra). However, this Court upon consideration
of the case of the parties and the conspicuous differences in the post held by
the petitioner i.e. cameraman and Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha i.e. technical
assistant right since their engagement in 2007 on contract basis, is of the
opinion that the claim of the petitioner based on parity set up before this
Court in the writ petition is not tenable. On the one hand, the petitioner has
got periodical enhancements of remuneration as furnished in paragraph- 9 of
the counter affidavit referred to hereinabove as well, Sri Kalyan Kishore
Saha, holding a totally different post of technical assistant, has got
enhancement of remuneration from time to time. The details of periodical
enhancement of Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha have not been furnished in such
tabular form by either of the parties. In such circumstances, this Court is of
the view that the claim of the petitioner based on grounds of parity with Sri
Kalyan Kishore Saha is not made out.
[9]
The Apex Court in the case of K.T. Veerappa and others
(supra) had observed that while it is true that fixation of pay and
determination of parity in duties is the function of the Executive and the
scope of judicial review of administrative decision in this regard is very
limited but it is also equally well-settled that the courts should interfere with
administrative decisions pertaining to pay fixation and pay parity when they
find that such a decision to be unreasonable, unjust and prejudicial to a
section of employees and taken in ignorance of material and relevant
factors. In the present case since the post held by the petitioner and that of
Sri Kalyan Kishore Saha are dissimilar having different remunerations and
have got enhancement from time to time, comparison between the two on
principles of parity would be misplaced. Therefore, a proportionate
enhancement of remuneration of the said person could not be a basis to
claim parity by the petitioner who holds a totally different post and has also
getting enhancement of remuneration from time to time. Therefore, the
decision of the respondents cannot be said to be unreasonable,
discriminatory and unjust so as to warrant interference by this Court in
matters relating to fixation of pay which are primarily in the domain of the
executive. Therefore, this Court does not find any reason to interfere in the
impugned order.
Accordingly, the instant petition is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Munna S
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review