Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.606 of 2024
Sri Rajib Goswami,
S/o-Sri Brajalal Goswami,
R/o-Shyamalima Apartment, New Capital Complex, Block No.1, Flat No.104,
A3/A4, P.O.-Agartala Secretariat, P.S.-NCC, Dist.-West Tripura.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
National Institute of Technology Agartala, represented by the Director,
Barjala, Jirania, District-West Tripura, PIN-799046.
2.
The Director, National Institute of Technology Agartala, Barjala, Jirania,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799046.
3.
The Registrar, National Institute of Technology Agartala, Barjala,
Jirania, District-West Tripura, PIN-799046.
4.
Prof. Richi Prasad Sharma, Chairman, Interview Board, National
Institute of Technology Agartala, Barjala, Jirania, District-West Tripura, PIN799046.
5.
Col.(Dr.) Ashish Badola, Registrar, NIT Agartala and Member, Interview
Board, National Institute of Technology Agartala, Barjala, Jirania, District-West
Tripura, PIN-799046.
6.
Shri Tanmay Ghosal, Deputy Registrar, NIT Agartala and Member,
Interview Board, National Institute of Technology Agartala, Barjala, Jirania,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799046.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. K. D. Singha, Advocate
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
16.12.2024
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By way of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed
for quashing and setting aside the impugned Advertisement dated 04.09.2024
issued by the respondents-National Institute of Technology inviting applications
for filling up of the post of Legal Advisor on contract basis without cancelling
the earlier selection process.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that National Institute of
Technology(for short, NIT), Agartala had issued an advertisement dated
13.10.2023 for filling up the post of Legal Advisor on contract basis where
essential qualifications were mentioned in the advertisement and a format which
a candidate must fill up was also mentioned in the said advertisement. In terms
of the advertisement, the petitioner submitted his application and duly filled up
all the columns in the format for the said post. Having satisfied with the essential
qualifications as mentioned in the advertisement, the respondent-NIT called him
to appear before the Interview Board. The Interview Board was constituted by a
number of experts. The petitioner appeared before the Selection Committee on
the stipulated date and time. The Selection Committee interviewed him on
27.02.2024. All on a sudden, the petitioner had noticed that the respondent-NIT
issued another advertisement for filling up of the same post of Legal Advisor on
contract basis vide Advertisement dated 04.09.2024 without publishing the result
of the interview. The petitioner submitted a representation on 11.09.2024 to the
Director, NIT Agartala stating inter alia that the issuance of a new advertisement
for the same post on similar and identical terms without cancelling the earlier
one created procedural irregularities. The previous process of selection was not
cancelled at all before the publication of new advertisement inviting applications
from willing candidates for filling up the same post of Legal Advisor. It is
further stated in his representation that one of the fundamental principles of
public administration is transparency. The said representation was not responded
to by the respondent-NIT, compelling the petitioner to approach this Court by
way of filing the instant writ petition.
3.
In the present writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for completing
the earlier selection process by means of publication of result of the interview
and to complete the selection process forthwith and also to appoint suitable
candidates. He has also prayed for compensating him adequately. The petitioner
has also challenged the issuance of fresh advertisement for filling up the post of
Legal Advisor without cancelling the selection process in which he had
appeared.
4.
On the aforesaid background of facts, I have heard Mr. K.D.
Singha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B.
Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondent-NIT. I have also
interacted with Col (Dr.) Ashish Badola, Registrar, NIT Agartala who is present
before this Court today.
5.
Mr. Singha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that in every recruitment process, the employer must follow the
doctrine of fair play and fairness. At no point of time, during the process of
selection, the respondent-NIT found loopholes in the application or in the
information furnished by the petitioner. Having satisfied with the essential
qualifications as mentioned in the advertisement, the petitioner was asked to
appear before the Interview Board on 27.02.2024(Tuesday) at 3:00 p.m. sharp in
the Registrar’s Conference Room, Admin. Building(3rd Floor), NIT Agartala
vide communication dated 22.02.2024(Annexure-F to the writ petition).
5.1.
The petitioner appeared before the Interview Board at the scheduled
time and venue when he performed very well despite being faced intense
questioning. Thereafter, he was awaiting for the result of the interview and
further action on the part of the respondent-NIT. But, all on a sudden, the
petitioner noticed that the respondent-NIT had re-advertised to fill up the same
post of Legal Advisor on contractual basis. The petitioner having noticed the
said advertisement, submitted representation requesting the respondent-NIT to
complete the ongoing selection process as was undertaken by the respondentNIT under advertisement dated 13.10.2023, but, the authority concerned of the
NIT did not respond to the said representation. Mr. Singha, learned counsel for
the petitioner has further drawn the attention of this Court to the statements
made in the counter affidavit filed by the respondent-NIT wherein they have
stated at para 5 that the respondents found the petitioner not suitable. The
relevant portion is reproduced hereunder:
“5…… The Petitioner appeared before the selection panel duly constituted
to conduct walk-in-interview for the post of Legal Advisor on contractual
basis. But he was not found fit as per requirement of the Institute. The
answering respondents wants to submit that petitioner is well known about
the fact that decision of the appointing authority in all matter relating to
eligibility, acceptance or rejection of applications will be final and binding
on the candidates and no enquiry or correspondence will be entertained in
this matter.”
5.2.
Lastly, Mr. Singha, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the respondent has failed to explain as to why he was not found fit and what
requirements the petitioner could not fulfill.
6.
Opposing the submissions of learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondent-NIT
has contended before this Court that the respondent-NIT maintained all
transparency in the entire process of selection.
7.
It is pertinent to mention herein that when this matter came up for
the first time, this Court granted interim protection to the petitioner directing the
respondent-NIT not to proceed with the selection process to be undertaken in
view of the later advertisement dated 04.09.2024. The respondent-NIT have also
come up with an application for vacating the interim order dated 23.09.2024.
Drawing my attention to the statement made in the interim order, Mr. Majumder,
learned Dy. SGI has submitted that the petitioner has secured 45 marks out of
100 marks in the interview and for that reason, he was not found eligible or
suitable for appointment to the post of Legal Advisor. Mr. Badola, Registrar,
NIT Agartala also has submitted that there was only one candidate who appeared
before the interview and he secured 45 marks out of 100 marks and not found
suitable.
8.
At this juncture, Mr. Singha, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that this statement is neither found in the counter affidavit nor in the
application for vacating the interim order dated 23.09.2024.
9.
In view of this submission, I have gone through the statements
made in the application for vacating the interim order and this statement is not
found. However, Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI has furnished the result sheet
of the petitioner separately in an envelope.
10.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing for
the parties and have perused the documents enclosed with the writ petition as
well as the counter affidavit filed by the respondent-NIT.
11.
It is an admitted position that the respondent-NIT did not publish
the result of the interview and they issued fresh advertisement for filling up the
same post of Legal Advisor on similar terms and conditions without cancelling
the previous selection process which was almost completed. The petitioner
submitted representation, but, that even was not responded to. It is the specific
plea taken by the respondent-NIT that they have the right to cancel the selection
process and nobody has a right to question it, as it appears from the statements
they made in para 5 of the counter affidavit.
12.
Here, in my opinion, the action of the respondent-NIT suffers from
clear arbitrariness. It is settled proposition that reasons are the soul of all fair
administrative actions. It is true that there is no precise statutory or other
definition of the terms “arbitrary”. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of East
Coast Railway and Anr. vs. Mahadev Appa Rao and Ors, (2010) 7 SCC 678
while dealing with the meaning of the term “arbitrariness” observed thus: (SCC
p 686-687, para 23)
“23. Arbitrariness in the making of an order by an authority can manifest itself in
different forms. Non-application of mind by the authority making the order is only
one of them. Every order passed by a public authority must disclose due and
proper application of mind by the person making the order. This may be evident
from the order itself or the record contemporaneously maintained. Application of
mind is best demonstrated by disclosure of mind by the authority making the
order. And disclosure is best done by recording the reasons that led the authority
to pass the order in question. Absence of reasons either in the order passed by the
authority or in the record contemporaneously maintained is clearly suggestive of
the order being arbitrary hence legally unsustainable.”
13.
In the instant case, even the result of the interview was not
published or communicated to the petitioner. No record has been placed before
this Court that before starting the selection process, the respondent-NIT made
the candidates aware of the minimum marks to be secured to make them eligible
or qualified for selection to the post of Legal Advisor.
14.
I have noticed the result-sheet, which is reproduced here-in-below:
Sl.
No.
Name of Candidate
Past
Experience
(10)
Presentation
(20)
Subject
Knowledge
(50)
Attitude
(20)
Total Marks
obtained out of
(Col.3+4+5+6)
Remarks/
Rank
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
Rajib Goswami, S/O.
Sri
Braja
Lal
Goswami,
Shyamalima
Apartment,
New
Capital
Complex,
Block No.1, Flat
No.104, A3-A4, P.O.
Agartala Secretariat
Pin-799010
rajibgoswami6666@
gmail.com
1.
Not
recommended
15.
From the above result-sheet, it becomes clear that the Selection
Committee even before starting the process of interview had not informed the
petitioner that the interview would be conducted out of 100 marks qua the
minimum mark a candidate was required to secure in the interview to make him
eligible for the post. No minimum mark of eligibility was prescribed/mentioned
neither in the advertisement nor before the commencement of interview. In the
remark column, it is only stated “not recommended”, but the reason has not been
given why he was not recommended.
16.
There is no quarrel that the candidates who participated in the
selection process had no indefeasible right or absolute right to seek
appointment, but, it does not give an unfettered license to the competent
authority to act in an arbitrary manner by way of not declaring the result of the
examination. Without publication of the result of earlier examination or without
cancelling the process of selection, the competent authority cannot invite and
start another process of selection for the same post or posts.
[emphasis supplied]
17.
In the case of East Coast Railway(supra) Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held that while no candidate acquires an indefeasible right to a post merely
because he has appeared in the examination or even found a place in the select
list, yet the State does not enjoy an unqualified prerogative to refuse an
appointment in an arbitrary fashion or to disregard the merit of the candidates
as reflected by the merit list prepared at the end of the selection process. The
validity of the State‟s decision not to make an appointment is thus a matter
which is not beyond judicial review before a competent writ court. If any such
decision is indeed found to be arbitrary, appropriate directions can be issued in
the matter.
18.
In Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi and Ors. vs. State of U.P. and
Ors., reported in (1991) 1 SCC 212, the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained the
true import of the expression “arbitrariness”.(SCC p 243 para 36)
“36. The meaning and true import of arbitrariness is more easily
visualized than precisely stated or defined. The question, whether an
impugned act is arbitrary or not, is ultimately to be answered on the facts
and in the circumstances of a given case. An obvious test to apply is to see
whether there is any discernible principle emerging from the impugned act
and if so, does it satisfy the test of reasonableness……”
19.
In the instant case, the respondent-NIT has miserably failed to
explain or justify their action of not publishing the result of examination,
and further, what prompted them to issue another advertisement for the
same post of Legal Advisor on similar terms and conditions. Added to it, it
is surprising that after receipt of representation from the petitioner, the
respondent-NIT did not even respond to it, rather, in their counter affidavit
they have taken a plea that it was their absolute right or prerogative not to
declare the result and has clearly stated that nobody could question their
authority or action. According to this Court, this kind of action and attitude
of the respondent-NIT is unacceptable and fails to satisfy the test of
Wednesbury’s reasonableness.
[emphasis supplied]
20.
In my ultimate analysis, initiation of fresh selection process without
cancellation of the previous process for filling up the same post is per se illegal,
arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Another important aspect necessary to be noticed that the respondent-NIT
neither in their counter affidavit nor in the petition for vacating the interim order
has brought the fact that the petitioner was disqualified since he could not secure
the cut off/qualifying marks in the interview. In the petition for vacating the
interim order which was registered as IA No.2 of 2024 , the respondent-NIT has
stated that the petitioner did not possess requisite experience as was required (at
para 5 of the petition for vacating the interim order). The marks obtained by the
petitioner was placed before this Court only in compliance of the order passed
by this Court under order dated 08.10.2024. This action on the part of the
respondent-NIT raises serious doubt in the mind of this Court as regards the
purity and integrity of the plea of the respondent-NIT that the petitioner was
disqualified since he could not secure the qualifying marks in the interview. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of East Coast Railway(supra) had observed
thus:(SCC pp. 685, 686 and 687, paras 17, 18, 19, 20, 22 and 23)
17. It is trite that Article 14 of the Constitution strikes at arbitrariness which is
an antithesis of the guarantee contained in Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. Whether or not the cancellation of the typing test was arbitrary is
a question which the Court shall have to examine once a challenge is mounted
to any such action, no matter the candidates do not have an indefeasible right
to claim an appointment against the advertised posts.
18. What then is meant by arbitrary/arbitrariness and how far can the decision
of the competent authority in the present case be described as arbitrary?
19.Black's Law Dictionary describes the term “arbitrary” in the following
words:
“Arbitrary.—1. Depending on individual discretion; specif., determined by a
judge rather than by fixed rules, procedures, or law. 2. (Of a judicial decision)
founded on prejudice or preference rather than on reason or fact. This type of
decision is often termed arbitrary and capricious.”
20. To the same effect is the meaning given to the expression “arbitrary” by
Corpus Juris Secundum which explains the term in the following words:
“Arbitrary.—Based alone upon one's will, and not upon any course of
reasoning and exercise of judgment; bound by no law; capricious; exercised
according to one's own will or caprice and therefore conveying a notion of a
tendency to abuse possession of power; fixed or done capriciously or at
pleasure, without adequate determining principle, non-rational, or not done or
acting according to reason or judgment; not based upon actuality but beyond a
reasonable extent; not founded in the nature of things; not governed by any
fixed rules or standard; also, in a somewhat different sense, absolute in power,
despotic, or tyrannical; harsh and unforbearing. When applied to acts,
„arbitrary‟ has been held to connote a disregard of evidence or of the proper
weight thereof; to express an idea opposed to administrative, executive,
judicial, or legislative discretion; and to imply at least an element of bad faith,
and has been compared with „willful‟.”
22. Dealing with the principle governing exercise of official power Prof. De
Smith, Woolf and Jowell in their celebrated book on Judicial Review of
Administrative Action emphasised how the decision-maker invested with the
wide discretion is expected to exercise that discretion in accordance with the
general principles governing exercise of power in a constitutional democracy
unless of course the statute under which such power is exercisable indicates
otherwise. One of the most fundamental principles of the rule of law recognised
in all democratic systems is that the power vested in any competent authority
shall not be exercised arbitrarily and that the power is exercised that it does
not lead to any unfair discrimination. The following passage from the above is
in this regard apposite:
“We have seen in a number of situations how the scope of an official power
cannot be interpreted in isolation from general principles governing the
exercise of power in a constitutional democracy. The courts presume that these
principles apply to the exercise of all powers and that even where the decisionmaker is invested with wide discretion, that discretion is to be exercised in
accordance with those principles unless Parliament clearly indicates
otherwise. One such principle, the rule of law, contains within it a number of
requirements such as the right of the individual to access to the law and that
power should not be arbitrarily exercised. The rule of law above all rests upon
the principle of legal certainty, which will be considered here, along with a
principle which is partly but not wholly contained within the rule of law,
namely, the principle of equality, or equal treatment without unfair
discrimination.”
23. Arbitrariness in the making of an order by an authority can manifest itself
in different forms. Non-application of mind by the authority making the order is
only one of them. Every order passed by a public authority must disclose due
and proper application of mind by the person making the order. This may be
evident from the order itself or the record contemporaneously maintained.
Application of mind is best demonstrated by disclosure of mind by the authority
making the order. And disclosure is best done by recording the reasons that led
the authority to pass the order in question. Absence of reasons either in the
order passed by the authority or in the record contemporaneously maintained
is clearly suggestive of the order being arbitrary hence legally unsustainable.
21.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the case at hand, there cannot
be any quarrel to the proposition that while candidates have no indefeasible or
absolute right to seek appointments, at the same time, it does not give a license
to the competent authority to act at their own whims and sweetwill. Based
merely upon a clause in the advertisement for recruitment or making a statement
in the counter affidavit that it is the absolute domain or prerogative of the
employer not to declare the result and none has any right to question their
authority or actions. As a matter of re-iteration, I am constrained to observe that
it is settled that reasons are the soul of all administrative actions. In the cases of
Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India and another reported in (1978) 1 SCC 248
and Swadeshi Cotton Mills vs. Union of India and other connected matters
reported in (1981) 1 SCC 664, Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that the doctrine of
fairness inaction is essential requirement of Law to be followed while
discharging an administrative action. Doctrine of fairness is nothing but a duty
to act fairly and reasonably. It is a doctrine developed in the administrative
field. It is a doctrine that obligates a duty upon the authorities concerned to act
fairly and reasonably. The doctrine of fairness and fairplay developed in the
administrative field to ensure rule of Law and to prevent failure of justice where
an action is administrative in nature.
[emphasis supplied]
22.
In the instant case, the respondent-NIT has virtually failed to assign
any reason to initiate fresh selection process under the advertisement dated
04.09.2024
without
cancelling
the
previous
selection
process
under
advertisement dated 13.10.2023 for filling up the post of Legal Advisor in the
same terms and conditions. Added to it, in absence of any prescribed minimum
marks the candidature of the petitioner and his disqualification for appointment
to the post of Legal Advisor is illegal and arbitrary. Following the principle laid
down in East Coast Railway(supra) I aptly visualize the act of arbitrariness on
the part of the respondent-NIT, and for this reason, they are to compensate the
petitioner adequately and he is being dragged to the court under compulsion.
23.
In the light of above analysis on the proposition of law and
discussion made here-in-above, I direct the respondent-NIT to consider the
matter of selection of the petitioner in the post of Legal Advisor, which they
have sought for filling up under the advertisement dated 13.10.2023 before
undertaking fresh selection process to fill up the post of Legal Advisor.
Considering the extent of arbitrariness and for failure to discharge their expected
duty to act fairly, I direct respondents-NIT to pay a sum of Rs.50,000/- to the
petitioner as compensation.
24.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant writ
petition stands allowed and disposed of. The copy of the result sheet is kept on
record.
JUDGE
Snigdha
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
SAIKAT KAR Date: 2025.03.13
16:29:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review