Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.880 of 2022
Sri Rajesh Kumar Das
S/o Sri Molin Chandra Das, presently residing at Nutannagar,
Agartala, P.O. Nutannagar B.O, P.S.-Airport, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799009, permanent resident of village-North Joynagar, Agartala, P.S.West Agartala, P.O.-Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, P.O.-New Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital Complex, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Principle Secretary, Department of Transport, Government of
Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, P.O.-New
Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Secretary, Department of Transport, Government of Tripura, having
his office at New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, P.O.- New Secretariat, P.S.New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura, Pin799010.
4. Sri Anindya Kumar Bhattacharya, IAS, residing at A.D. Nagar, Near
Saint Paul‟s School, Agartala, P.O. & P.S.-A.D. Nagar, Sub-Division- Sadar,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799003.
5. Sri Laihlia Darlong, IAS, residing at Khakchang Residential Complex,
Near Auxilium Girls School, SDO Chowmuhani, Nandannagar, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
[[
:
:
:
….Respondent(s)
Mr. A. Pal, Advocate
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
18.10.2023
:
Yes
[[
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
[
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. A. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondentsState.
2.
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for quashing the report dated 04.05.2022 submitted by one Sri A.K.
Bhattacharya, Addl. Secretary, GA(AR) Department, Government of Tripura
who was appointed as One-man Committee to inquire into the following
issues:
(i)
Without proper planning MD, TRTC whimsically fixed a date of
inauguration without Government approval and attempted to
organize international programme of re-commencement of AgartalaKolkata-Dhaka Bus Services on 28 April, 2022 and failed to obtain
clearance from key stakeholders which resulted in postponement of
the programme causing huge embarrassment in presence of foreign
dignitaries and other dignitaries.The very purpose of organizing the
programme was lost due to absence of proper planning and
negligence.
(ii)
Due procedures and diligence have not been followed while
spending taxpayers‟ money in contravention of the provisions of the
Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950(for short, Act of 1950) and
the Delegation of Financial Powers Rules Tripura, 2019( here-inafter referred to as Rules of 2019).
3.
Briefly stated, while the petitioner was posted as Managing
Director, Tripura Road Transport Corporation(for short, TRTC) there was an
attempt for re-commencement of the Agartala-Kolkata-via Dhaka Bus
Service. Having made all arrangements necessary to be undertaken by the
Managing Director, i.e. the petitioner, he sought for approval of the Transport
Department, Government of Tripura. Approval had been given on top priority
which is evident from a communication dated 12.04.2022(Annexure 1 to the
writ petition). The subject content may be reproduced here-in-below:
“TOP PRIORITY
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT
SECRETARIAT
No.F.6(5)-Trans/2015/1055
Dated, Agartala, the 12th April, 2022
To
The Managing Director,
Tripura Road Transport Corporation
(A Govt. of Tripura Undertaking),
Krishnanagar, Agartala.
Sub: Agartala- Kolkata- via Dhaka Bus service.
Ref:- Your letter No.F.7(3)/MD/TRTC/VOLVO/BUS/2019/1120-25 dated 28/03/2022.
Sir,
I am directed to convey approval of the Transport Department in respect of your
proposal under reference for recommencement of Agartala-Kolkata-via Dhaka Bus service
from 15th April, 2022.
This is issued vide U.O. No.2138 MIN/AGRI/TOURISM/TRANSPORT dated
05.04.2022.
Yours faithfully
Sd/- illegible
[N.R. Dsas]
Deputy Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
4.
Thereafter, some communications had been made through
Whatsapp. Those communications have been enclosed in the writ petition
being authenticated by the Deputy Secretary, Transport Department,
Government of Tripura(Annexure RA/1 to the writ petition).
5.
Ultimately, the flag-off ceremony was organized on 28.04.2022.
but it was postponed since necessary clearance from the Union Government
and the Government of People‟s Republic of Bangladesh was not obtained by
the Transport Department, Government of Tripura.
6.
Due to disruption of the said programme, the Principle Secretary,
Transport Department, Government of Tripura, respondent no.2 herein had
appointed a One-man Committee comprised of Sri A.K. Bhattacharya to
inquire the circumstances under which the programme was organized. In
course of inquiry, the said One-man Committee under his report dated
04.05.2022 found that the petitioner violated the provisions of Rules of 2019
and further observed that due procedures and diligence were not followed
while spending taxpayers‟ money as provided under Act of 1950(Annexure 2
to the writ petition). The petitioner has challenged the said report dated
04.05.2022.
7.
On the aforesaid background of facts, Mr. Pal, learned counsel
for the petitioner has submitted that Rule 2(g) of Rules of 2019 is not at all
applicable to the Government Undertakings. According to Mr. Pal, learned
counsel, TRTC comes within the ambit of the definition of „Government
Undertakings‟ and „Aided Institutions‟ which includes Corporations as
defined in Rule 2(j)(ii) of Rules of 2019. Learned counsel for the petitioner
has also drawn my attention to Sub-rule 4 of Rule 1 of Rules of 2019 which
stipulates the organizations which shall come within the purview of the Rules
of 2019.
8.
Mr. Pal, learned counsel for the petitioner has further submitted
that it was the obligation of the Government of Tripura to obtain necessary
permission or approval from the Union of India and Government of People‟s
Republic of Bangladesh. The petitioner being the Managing Director, TRTC
had no accessibility, to say the least, he was not the competent and authorized
person to obtain such sanction/approval neither from the Government of India
nor from the Government of People‟s Republic of Bangladesh. It was not
within his knowledge whether such approval was taken by the Government of
Tripura before according approval to him to proceed for recommencement of
the bus service.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for
the respondents-State has defended the action of the Government and he did
not find any fault with the appointment of One-man Committee to inquire into
the above two points. Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. GA has relied upon the
statements made in para 16, 17 and 18 and the Rule10(1), Rule 11(2), Rule15,
Rule 22(1), Rule 22(1)(d), Rule 22(15) of Rules of 2019.
10.
According to learned Addl. GA, all departments are bound to
obtain prior administrative approval from the concerned department,
Government of Tripura for spending more than Rs.2,00,000/-(Rupees Two
Lakh) as referred to Clause (z) of Rule 2 of Rules of 2019. Learned Addl. GA
has not seriously pressed issue no.1 as stated here-in-above and he mainly
emphasized on issue no.2 as indicated here-in-above.
11.
I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the parties. I have also perused the relevant documents relied
upon by the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
12.
At the outset, it would be useful to extract the relevant provisions
relied upon by the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
Rule 1 deals with Short Title, Extent and Commencement,
which reads as under:
“1. SHORT TITLE, EXTENT AND COMMENCEMENT:
(1) These rules may be called the „Delegation of Financial Powers Rules, Tripura,
2019‟.
(2) They shall come into force on and from the date of publication of this notification in
the Tripura Gazette.
(3) Save as otherwise provided in these rules, these rules shall apply to government
Departments as well as Government Bodies, as defined under Rule 2.
(4) Only Rule 9(1) (xxxiv) of DFPRT and any other specific Rule wherever mentioned
will be applicable to „Government Undertakings and Aided Institutions‟. The
administrative Department may, however, issue further orders for administrative and
financial control of Government Undertakings, if required.”
The expression „Department‟ is defined under clause (g) of Rule 2 of
the Rules of 2019, which reads as under:
“(g) “Department” means the Department of the State Government as notified from
time to time and for the purpose of these rules includes the Governor‟s Secretariat, the
Legislative Assembly Secretariat, the Tripura Public Service Commission, Tripura
Women Commission, Tripura Information Commission, Tripura Police Accountability
Commission, Tripura Human Rights commission, Tripura Electricity Regulatory
Commission and other Commissions and Government bodies set up by the State
Government;”
It would be apposite to again refer to clause j(i) and (ii) of Rule 2 of
Rules of 2019, which is as under:
“(j) (i) “Government bodies” means Statutory Commissions, Sub-ordinate & Attached
offices, Boards, Agencies etc. that are financed and administered by the Government;
(ii)“Government Undertakings and Aided Institutions” means Government
Companies, Corporations, Societies, Authority, Trusts, Autonomous bodies
including Local bodies, SPV, Joint ventures as well as Grant-in-Aid/ Sponsored
Institutions, which are fully or partly financed/aided or otherwise assisted by
Government.”
“Administrative Department” is defined under Clause (ff) of Rule 2 of
Rules of 2019, which reads as under:
“(ff) “Administrative Department” – wherever power is delegated to Department or
Administrative Department, it has to be exercised by Secretary with the approval of
Minister-in-charge of Department or Secretary of the Department himself if so
delegated by the Minister-in-charge.”
13.
On plain reading of the above definitions of the expressions
mentioned in the Rules of 2019, there should not be any quarrel that the TRTC
comes within the purview of the definition of „Government Undertakings‟ as
defined under Clause j(ii) of Rule 2 of the Rules of 2019.
It does not come within the definition of the „department‟ as defined
under clause (g) of Rule 2 of Rules of 2019. Sub-rule 4 of Rule 1 of the Rules
of 2019 is very clear as regards the extent of applicability of Rules of 2019.
Sub-rule 4 clearly speaks about that only Rule 9(1)(xxxiv) of DFPRT Rules
shall be applicable to Government Undertakings. Here, it would be useful to
refer Rule 9(1)( xxxiv), which reads as under:
“(xxxiv) Acceptance of Central schemes/Schemes of Financial Institutions/ NEC
having state share more than 10%.”
Clause (xxxv) also may be extracted herein to examine the controversy
whether prior concurrence of the Finance Department is necessary by the
Government Undertaking as provided under Rule 9 of the Rules of 2019,
which reads as under:
“(xxxv) Provision of clause (i), (ii), (iii), (iv), (v), (x), (xii), (xv), (xxi), (xxii), (xxiii),
(xxxiii) and (xxxiv) will apply to Government Undertakings including local bodies. The
non-applicability of other clauses is subject to availability of own resources to fund the
activity.”
14.
From the above provisions, it is clear that the subject in issue is
not related to acceptance of Central Schemes/Schemes of Financial
Institutions/NEC having State share more than 10% as provided under Clause
(xxxiv) of Rule 9 of Rules of 2019. The issues involved in the present writ
petition also do not attract any of the provision mentioned at clause (xxxv) as
quoted here-in-above.
15.
Most importantly, from the inquiry report it reveals that the
petitioner had utilized “own resource fund” of TRTC for its activity like
renovation of boundary walls of TRTC complex, Agartala, painting of the
office chambers of the entire building and it is also evident that the said
expenditure undertaken by the petitioner had been approved by the Board of
Directors in its 177th meeting(page 53 Agenda No.1 Annexure R1 to the writ
petition)
16.
I have noticed the statements made by the petitioner in this regard
at para 7 of the writ petition, where it is stated that:
“7) Lastly, the 'One Man Committee' report concluded that without
following DFPRT, 2019, the petitioner has spent an amount of Rs. 8,74,120 for
painting of TRTC International Terminus old and new building and another sum
of Rs. 5,75,230 for decoration of office chamber of MD, TRTC, from own
resource fund and further recommended recovery and disciplinary action against
the petitioner. The humble petitioner states that the TRTC being a Corporation is
guided by Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950, and the Board has the power to
take decisions regarding utilisation of own resource fund. The Board of TRTC
had approved the execution of the aforenoted works in the 175th Board Meeting
of TRTC held on 25.08.2021 which was presided over by the Hon'ble Chairman,
TRTC. Also Board of Directors of TRTC had approved the repairing,
maintenance and painting works of TRTC buildings in the 177th Board Meeting
held on 15.02.2022 before visit of Hon'ble Chief Minister, Tripura and Hon'ble
Minister, Transport to TRTC. The works were executed on an urgent basis as
there was a visit of Hon'ble Chief Minister, Tripura and Hon'ble Minister,
Transport to TRTC Complex, through Tripura State Co-operative Consumers
Federation Limited which is a State Government funded organisation.
Moreover, TRTC being a Corporation falls within the definition of "Government
Undertakings and Aided Institutions as per Rule 2(j)(ii) of DFPRT, 2019. Rule 9
of DFPRT, 2019, speaks of inapplicability of certain provisions of DFPRT, 2019,
in cases where a Government Undertakings uses own resources to fund the
activity and therefore, TRTC is not required to follow all provisions of DFPRT,
2019, when it uses own resource fund. Therefore, the conclusions as formed by
the One Man Committee headed by the respondent No.4 are erroneous and
legally unsustainable.”
The statements made in para 7 have been countered at para 16 of the
counter affidavit, where it is stated inter alia:
“16. That in reply to averments and/or contentions made in paragraph-7 of the
writ petition it is stated that, the petitioner while functioning as M.D., T.R.T.C.
during the period from 17/01/2022 to 30/06/2022 has incurred authorized
expenditure of Rs.8,74,120/-lakhs for painting of TRTC International Terminus, old
and new and to decorate, repair and maintenance of the old TRTC building
including the pantry of the boundary walls at T.R.T.C. complex, Krishnanagar in
violation of financial propriety, without observing codal formalities and approval of
the competent authority and in violation of existing Financial Rules (violations of
provisions of Rules under 21 & Rule 22 of General Financial Rules, 2017) issued by
the Ministry of Finance and as adopted by the Tripura State Government and
violations of provisions of Rules under Rule 10(1), Rule 11(2), Rule-15, Rule22(1),
Rule 22(1)(d), Rule 22(15) of DFPRT, 2019 and regulations issued by Finance
Department, Government of Tripura from time to time. According to the provisions
of Rule-11 of DFPRT, 2019 work above Rs.2.00 lakhs requires approval of the
administrative Department……….”
17.
I have considered the above pleadings made in the writ petition as
well as in the counter affidavit. After perusal of the provisions as mentioned at
para 16 of the counter affidavit, I have found that these are the rules which are
applicable to „government departments‟ as defined under Clause (g) and (ff)
of Rule 2 of the Rules of 2019.
18.
At the cost of repetition, TRTC being a Government Undertaking
has limited applicability to the Rules of 2019 as embodied in Sub-rule 4 of
Rule 1 of the Rules of 2019.
Again, for repetition, TRTC does not fall within the definition of
„department‟ as enumerated here-in-above.
19.
Learned Addl. GA for the respondents-State has failed to place
any record that the Government of Tripura has framed any guidelines to
regulate the administrative and financial control of Government Undertakings
as provided under Sub-rule 4 of Rule 1 of Rules of 2019.
20.
The One-man Committee has erroneously proceeded to the
inquiry into the matter considering the TRTC as a government department
which is absolutely baseless and in contravention to the provisions of Rules of
2019. It is found that One-man Committee has suggested to frame guidelines
for Government Undertakings for the purpose of use of own resource fund but
till today there is no record that Government of Tripura has formulated any
such guideline as regards the utilization of „own resource fund‟.
21.
The TRTC is set up under The Act of 1950. Section 27 of the said
Act of 1950 prescribes the mechanism of utilization of „own resource fund‟. It
reads as under:
“27. Fund of the Corporation :-(1) Every Corporation shall have its own fund
and all receipts of the Corporation shall be carried thereto and all payments by
the Corporation shall be made therefrom.
(2) Except as otherwise directed by the State Government, all moneys
belonging to that fund shall be deposited in the Reserve Bank of India or with
the agents of the Reserve Bank of India, [or with the corresponding new banks
constituted under section 3 of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and
Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970 (5 of 1970), or section 3 of the Banking
Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1980 (40 of
1980)] or invested in such securities as may be approved by the State
Government.”
22.
A bare perusal of the above provision makes it clear that every
corporation like TRTC would have liberty to use its own fund. It is pertinent
to mention herein that after meticulous perusal of the inquiry report, it is found
that the One-man Committee did not find any fault to the expenditures borne
by the petitioner, Managing Director for decorating and renovating the TRTC
complex. Only there are some allegations of violations of the provisions of
Rules of 2019 which has already been discussed in the preceding paragraphs
in detail wherefrom I may unhesitantly come to the conclusion that the
petitioner being the Managing Director has not violated any of the provisions
of Rules of 2019 and there is no such evidence wherefrom I can detect that the
petitioner was involved in committing financial irregularities in spending the
amount out of own resource fund for its required activities.
23.
After perusal of the records and the documents enclosed to the
writ petition as annexures and the communication made under Annexure
RA/1(Page 151-153 of the paper book), it cannot be disputed that necessary
approval was given to the petitioner to organize the program on the occasion
of the inauguration of recommencement of Agartala-Kolkata-via Dhaka Bus
Service on 28.04.2022.
24.
In the light of above discussions, I do not find any merit in the
report furnished by the One-man Committee as stated above.
Accordingly, the report dated 04.05.2022 is set aside and quashed.
As a sequel, the instant writ petition stands allowed and thus disposed
of.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2023.10.26 14:27:15 +05'30'
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review