The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 08.2021 passed by the Commandant is against the principles of natural justice, and the same is accordingly set aside and the matter is remanded back to the respondents for continuing with the inquiry from the place where it stood during COVID period. The same shall be done as expeditiously as possible. However, it is made clear that in the course of the inquiry, the petitioner shall strictly adhere to the terms of service rules and conditions. It is agreed by the counsel for the petitioner that the notices be served on the address of the petitioner through the concerned Police Station or SHO in the residential address which is mentioned in the service record of the petitioner.
7. With the above observation and direction, this instant writ petition stands disposed of. Stay order, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stand closed. CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING) suhanjit
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.896 OF 2021
Sri Prasenjit Singha Barua(50 years)
No.91010681 Ex. Havildar(GD),
S/o- Sri Prakash Kusum Barua,
Resident of Vill-Subash Nagar,
P.O. & P.S.- Kanchanpur,
Dist- North Tripura.
……… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
1. The State of Tripura.
Represented by the Secretary,
Home Department, Govt. of Tripura,
P.O.- New Capital Complex,
District- Tripura(W), Agartala.
2. The Inspector General of Police(TSR),
Police Head Quarters,
Fire Brigade Chowmohani,
Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Deputy Inspector General of Police,
A.P.(ADM & TRG), Tripura,
A.D. Nagar, Agartala,
Dist- West Tripura.
4. The Commandant,
8TH Bn. Tripura State Rifles (IR-III),
Lalcherra, Chailengta,
Dist- Dhalai Tripura.
5. The Enquiry Officer,
D.P. No.01/2021,
8th Bn, Tripura State Rifles(IR-III),
Lalcherra, Chailengta,
Dist- Dhailai Tripura.
……. Respondent(s).
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mrs. S. Deb(Gupta), Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 24.02.2023
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
The brief fact leading to this instant writ petition is that
the petitioner entered into service as Rifle Man(GD) in the year
1991 under 1st Bn. Tripura State Rifle. He was promoted to the
post of Havildar (GD). On 03.04.2016, respondent No.4 issued
a suspension order to the petitioner under Rule 10(1) of the
Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
read with Rule 43 of the Tripura State Rifles (Discipline,
Control, Service Condition etc.) Rules 1986. On 19.04.2016,
respondent No.3 issued a corrigendum and modified the
suspension order dated 03.04.2016. In the said corrigendum,
respondent No.3 issued an order to the petitioner not to leave
the DIGP, A.P.(Ops), A.D. Nagar, Agartala instead of Battalion
Head Quarter Lalcherra. On 06.05.2016 & 23.06.2016, the
petitioner
submitted
a
prayer
to
respondent
No.3
and
contended that due to serious illness, he was not able to report
to him and prayed to allow him to report after total cure of his
health. On 22.06.2016, the petitioner submitted a prayer to
respondent No.3 praying for clarification of some points and
also prayed for allowing him to remain in his house. On
17.07.2019, after three years and four months, respondent
No.4 revoked the suspension order of the petitioner dated
03.04.2016. On 04.08.2019, the petitioner received the said
revocation order dated 17.07.2019 and on 07.08.2019, the
petitioner
joined
his
duties
under
respondent
No.4.
On
12.10.2019, respondent No.4 issued a punishment order to the
petitioner
and
he
was
removed
from
service
without
disqualifying his future employment under the Government as
dies none. On 23.11.2019, the petitioner filed an appeal before
respondent No.3 against the punishment order of the removal
from service dated 12.10.2019. On 21.01.2020, respondent
No.3
revoked/set
aside
the
punishment
order
dated
03.04.2016. On 26.01.2020, the petitioner received the order
dated 21.01.2020. Accordingly, on 07.02.2020, the petitioner
joined
under
respondent
No.4
as
Havildar
(GD).
On
08.02.2020, respondent No.4 issued an order to reinstate the
petitioner into service in compliance with the order of the
Appellate
Authority
dated
21.01.2020.
On
08.02.2020,
respondent No.4 issued a memorandum with an Article of
Charges. On 17.06.2020 a provisional punishment order was
issued by respondent No.4 asking the petitioner to submit
representation against the provisional order of punishment
proposing
removal
from
service
which
shall
not
be
a
qualification for future employment under the Government. On
01.07.2020, the petitioner submitted the representation. On
17.07.2020, final punishment was passed by the respondent
wherein the petitioner was removed from service which shall
not be a qualification for future employment under the
Government. On 26.08.2020, the petitioner filed an appeal
before respondent No.2. The said appeal was disposed on
31.12.2020.
Respondent
No.3
set
aside
the
order
of
punishment dated 17.07.2020 passed by respondent No.4 and
remanded back the matter to respondent No.4 and allowed the
petitioner to defend his case by engaging defence assistant as
per norms. The petitioner was again reinstated in the same
post after the order of respondent No.3 dated 31.12.2020. On
20.01.2021, respondent No.4 issued a memorandum and the
same set of charges. On 04.08.2021, a provisional punishment
was passed by respondent No.3. On 17.08.2021, the petitioner
submitted representation against the provisional punishment
order dated 04.08.2021. On 24.08.2021, respondent No.4
without
considering
the
representation
of
the
petitioner
imposed major punishment of removal from service which shall
not be a qualification for future employment under the
Government. On 15.09.2021, the petitioner filed an appeal
before respondent No.3 against the punishment order dated
24.08.2021 passed by respondent No.4. On 23.11.2021,
respondent No.3 dismissed the appeal of the petitioner.
2.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has filed this
instant appeal and prayed for the following reliefs:“ i. Admit the petition of the petitioner and call for
records relevant to the subject matter from the custody of the
respondents.
ii. As to why writ in the nature of certiorari and/or in
the nature thereof, for calling for records, lying with the respondents,
for rendering substantial and conscionable justice to the petitioner,
and for quashing/setting aside the impugned punishment order vide
No.TSR-8/Esst/DP (01/21)10933-52 dated 24.08.2021 (Annexure-18)
passed by respondent No.4, order dated 23.11.2021, vide
No.10438/42/F.Pers/PSB/Appeal/DIGP(AP & OPS)/19 passed by the
respondent No.3.
iii. As to why writ in the nature of mandamus and/or in the
nature thereof, for
mandating/directing the respondents to
revoke/rescind
the
impugned
punishment
order
TSR8/Esst/DP(01/21)10933-52 dated 24.08.2021 passed by the
respondent
No.4
order
dated
23.11.2021
vide
No.10438/42/F.Pers/PSB/Appeal/DIGP(AP&OPS)/19 passed by the
respondent No.3.
iv. As to why writ in the nature of mandamus and/or in the
nature thereof, for mandating/directing the respondents after
revoking
the
impugned
punishment
order
TSR8/Esst/DP(01/21)10933-52 dated 24.08.2021 passed by the
respondent
No.4
order
dated
23.11.2021
vide
No.10438/42/F.Pers/PSB/Appeal/DIGP(AP&OPS)/19 passed by the
respondent No.3 reinstate in service.
v. As to why writ in the nature of mandamus and/or in the
nature thereof, for mandating/directing the respondents after
revoking the impugned punishment order vide No. TSR8/Esst/DP(01/21)10933-52 dated 24.08.2021 passed by the
respondent
No.4
order
dated
23.11.2021
vide
No.10438/42/F.Pers/PSB/Appeal/DIGP(AP&OPS)/19 passed by the
respondent No.3 reinstate the petitioner in service and treat the total
period of unjustified suspension order vide No.F.131/TSR-8(IRIII)/Estt/11/3813-70 dated 03.04.2016 to 0708.2019 (3 years 4
months 22 days) as on duty and to treat the periods of first removal
of service w.e.f. 12.11.2019 to 07.02.2020(88 days), second removal
from service w.e.f.17.07.2020 to 14.01.2021 (122 days) for same
allegation and third removal from service for same allegation w.e.f.
24.08.2021 till reinstate in service on duty.
vi. Pass such other or further order/orders and
directing/directions as to your Lordship deem fit and proper having
regard to the facts and circumstance of the case.”
3.
Heard
Mrs.
S.
Deb(Gupta),
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioner as well as Mr. D. Sharma, learned
Addl. G.A. appearing for the State-respondents.
4.
Mrs. Deb(Gupta), learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner submitted that impugned punishment order was
passed without giving the petitioner adequate opportunity. The
petitioner herein has valid medical reason for his absence from
duty. Sri Gopal Krishna Nath, a retired inspector was engaged
as defence assistant of the petitioner but due to COVID-19
pandemic, the engaged defence assistant of the petitioner was
indisposed on many occasions.
Respondent No.4 i.e. the
Commandant did not consider the representation submitted by
the petitioner and imposed major punishment of removal from
service and respondent No.3 also whimsically dismissed the
appeal filed by the petitioner.
5.
On the other hand, Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl.
G.A. appearing for the respondents submits that the petitioner
herein was given ample opportunity to defend himself during
the proceedings. The petitioner herein did not obey the lawful
order of the authority. He remained on unauthorized absence
from duty for a long duration of time which is against the good
order and disciple of the Tripura State Rifle.
6.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record. It is seen from the record that the petitioner herein on
15.05.2021
made a request
indicating that
his
defence
assistant Mr. Gopal Krishna Debnath was 75 years old and he
was indisposed because of quarantine during the COVID-19
period. The said contention has also been made in the
representation
submitted
dated
17.08.2021
before
the
Commandant. Without dealing with the said contention, the
Commandant i.e. respondent No.4 passed the impugned order
dated 24.08.2021. Hence, this Court feels that the impugned
order
of
punishment
dated
24.08.2021
passed
by
the
Commandant is against the principles of natural justice, and
the same is accordingly set aside and the matter is remanded
back to the respondents for continuing with the inquiry from
the place where it stood during COVID period. The same shall
be done as expeditiously as possible.
However, it is made
clear that in the course of the inquiry, the petitioner shall
strictly adhere to the terms of service rules and conditions. It is
agreed by the counsel for the petitioner that the notices be
served on the address of the petitioner through the concerned
Police Station or SHO in the residential address which is
mentioned in the service record of the petitioner.
7.
With the above observation and direction, this
instant writ petition stands disposed of. Stay order, if any,
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stand
closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review