Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.544 of 2024
1.
Sri Prasenjit Sarkar, son of Sri Ranjit Sarkar of Durga Colony, Ishanchandra
Nagar, West Tripura, PIN-799003.
…..Petitioner
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
The Union of India, represented by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of
India.
2.
The Central Industrial Security Force, represented by the Director General, Office
at Block No.13, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, Delhi-110003.
3.
The Deputy Inspector General, Central Industrial Security Force, KRTC, Mundali,
Odisha, 754013.
4.
The Commandant, Central Industrial Security Force, KRTC, Mundali, Odisha,
754013.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and
Judgment
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
:
:
12.02.2026
NO
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI, appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
This present writ petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India directing the respondents for quashing the impugned decision
of the respondents, communicated to the petitioner by letter dated 05.05.2022 to the
effect that the petitioner has been found to have defective colour vision CPIV and
on this basis, the provisional offer of appointment of the petitioner had been
cancelled finding him unfit for employment and further, to re-instate the petitioner
in his original post.
[3]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
“1) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature there-of, shall not be
issued, for quashing/setting the impugned decision of the Respondents,
communicated to the petitioner by letter dated 05.05.2022 (Annexure- F), to the
effect that the petitioner had been found to have defective colour vision- CP IV
and on this basis, the provisional offer of appointment of the petitioner had
been cancelled finding him unfit for employment.
II) Issue rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why Writ of Mandamus, and/or in the nature, shall not be issued,
for mandating/directing the respondents, to re-instate the petitioner in his
original post.
III) Call for the records appertaining to this petition;
(IV) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the rule absolute in terms of i
and ii above;
V) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding.”
[4]
The facts in brief are that vide notice dated 21.07.2018, an
advertisement was issued for recruitment to the post of Constables (GD) and on
11.05.2021, the petitioner had been issued offer of appointment. Accordingly, the
petitioner had joined to CISF RTC Mundali, Odisha on 17.06.2021. During
continuation of his training, he had been again subjected to medical examination.
After completion of his medical examination by letter dated 05.05.2022, the
petitioner had been informed that he had been found to have defective colour
vision- CP IV and on this basis, the provisional offer of appointment of the
petitioner had been cancelled finding him unfit for employment. The petitioner
most humbly submits that the petitioner is not suffering from any defective colour
vision- CP-IV and it has been examined by the concerned doctor of IGM Hospital.
[5]
Being aggrieved, the petitioner had submitted representation dated
07.08.2022 before the respondent No.3 for allowing him to join in CISF but by the
impugned letter dated 03.09.2022 his prayer for joining had been turned down.
This impugned finding against the petitioner to the effect that the petitioner being
medically unfit as well as the impugned cancellation of the appointment of the
petitioner by the respondents is highly illegal and beyond terms and condition of
the offer of appointment dated 11.05.2021. Moreover, as per their notification/
medical guideline for CAPF job, CP-IV is allowed. Pursuant thereto he had
submitted representation on 04.06.2023 before the Deputy Inspector General,
CISF, KRTC Mundali, Orissa via email.
[6]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the same, the petitioner filed
the present writ petition before this Court for fair ends of justice.
[7]
Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that on 21.07.2018, an advertisement was issued by the Staff Selection
Commission [SSC, for short] whereby, the SSC declared the petitioner as selected
after following due procedure. Thereafter, on 11.05.2021, the petitioner had been
offer of appointment thereby recruiting him as Constable/GD in CISF and had
directed him to report to RTC
Mundali, Kharavela Recruit Training Centre,
Mundali, Orisha. Accordingly, the petitioner had joined to the same on 17.06.2021
for completion of his CISF CT/GD basic training.
[8]
During continuation of his training, he had been again subjected to
medical examination. After completion of his medical examination by letter dated
05.05.2022, the petitioner had been informed that he had been found to have
defective colour vision CP IV and on this basis, the provisional offer of
appointment of the petitioner had been cancelled finding him unfit for employment.
It has been contended that the petitioner is not suffering from any defective colour
vision CP-IV. This finding against the petitioner to the effect that the petitioner
being medically unfit as well as the impugned cancellation of the appointment of
the petitioner by the respondents is highly illegal and beyond terms and condition
of the offer of appointment dated 11.05.2021 and as such, not tenable in the eye of
law.
[9]
As per Clause-XIV of the offer of appointment, it has been
specifically and clearly mentioned “You will be subjected to fresh medical
examination at the time of reporting to RTC, if the validity period of 18 months
from the date of fitness to joining service is over in terms of recruitment medical
guidelines issued by MHA vide UP dated 20.05.2015 and MHA UP dated
16.04.2021. In such a situation, you will be allowed to the join the post after being
found fit in fresh medical examination”; which interalia means that if the duration
between last medical examination during the process of selection and date of
joining is more than 18 months, then only, after joining to service fresh medical
examination of the candidate has to be conducted.
[10]
It is pertinent to mention here that the re-medical examination of the
petitioner had been conducted on 05.10.2020 and the petitioner joined in CISF on
17.06.2021 which interalia means that the intervening period is less than 18
months and thus the impugned examination of the petitioner and thereafter the
impugned declaration of him being unfit and thereafter the impugned cancellation
of the appointment of the petitioner is grossly illegal and not tenable in the eye of
law. The notification dated 16.04.2021 issued by the Under Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Police-11 Division(PF-VI Desk),
it had been specifically mandated that the validity period of the opinion of the
Recruitment Medical Board had been extended for a period of 18 months from the
date of fitness to joining of services in respect of all candidates of Constable (GD)
in CAPFs, NIA, SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles Examination, 2018
whose detailed medical examination was conducted during the period from
09.01.2020 to 13.02.2020. The detailed medical examination of the petitioner was
conducted on 22.01.2020.
[11]
After cancellation of his provisional appointment, the petitioner
returned to his home town at Agartala. After returning, the petitioner had requested
the respondents to allow him to rejoin. Pursuant to his requests, the eespondents
verbally informed the petitioner to recheck his vision and therefore, the petitioner
had undertaken medical examination of his eye at Indira Gandhi Memorial
Hospital, Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura as outdoor patient
wherein his colour vision had been found normal by the Medical Officer, Eye
OPD. From the officials of the respondents, the petitioner could know that as per
the guidelines issued by the respondents, the medical board shall decide every case
in consonance with the opinion of the doctor of the government medical hospital.
But the respondents most illegally had not considered the opinion of the
government hospital.
[12]
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has further contended
that as per their notification/ medical guideline for CAPF job, CP-IV is allowed.
Pursuant thereto the petitioner had submitted representation on 04.06.2023 before
the Deputy Inspector General, CISF, KRTC Mundali, Orissa via email. But in spite
of waiting for several months and a series of requests, the respondents have neither
allowed the petitioner to rejoin nor have responded to his request. Therefore he
could realize that he will not get the relief from the respondents and therefore,
ultimately he was left with no other option to approach this Court. But in the
meantime in the last part of the year 2023, the mother of the petitioner became
severely ill, almost in a bed ridden condition, and since the petitioner belongs to a
very poor family, out of acute financial constraint, he was not even in a position to
invest a penny towards approaching this Court. After the mother of the petitioner
had recovered, the petitioner managed the expenses for preferring writ petition and
therefore approached this Court.
[13]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents
has submitted that Para (2) (xiv) of Offer of Appointment in respect of the
petitioner lays down the condition for fresh medical examination, if validity period
of 18 months from the date of detailed medical examination to join in service is
over. However, it is pertinent to mention here that on reporting to CISF KRTC
Mundali for basic training of 44th batch of CT/GD, the petitioner was subjected to
medical examination in respect of color blindness only with all other candidates
reported for basic training of 44th batch CT/GD, which was done in accordance
with the directions issued vide CISF HQrs. New Delhi letter No. M20015(78)/CISF/Med. Dir/DVC/2017-1133 dated 22.09.2017. Para-I of the
aforementioned memorandum which should be read in conjunction with Para-4(f)
of policy guidelines dated 18.05.2012 clearly lays down the condition that colour
vision test should be done at the time of recruitment & later on at the time of basic
training. Since the petitioner was found with defective color vision (CP-IV), the
cancellation of offer of appointment falls in line with the lawful guidelines issued
in this regard & hence maintainable in the eyes of law.
[14]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and overall analysis, this Court is of the opinion that to go into the
root of the issue it is essential to extract the offer of appointment wherein, Clause(2) (xiv) held thus:
“You will be subjected to fresh medical examination at the time of reporting to
RTC, if the validity period of 18 months from the date of fitness to joining
service is over in terms of recruitment medical guidelines issued by MHA vide
UO dated 20.05.2015 and MHA UO dated 16.04.2021. In such a situation, you
will be allowed to the joint the post after being found fit in fresh medical
examination.”
[15]
In view of the same, his medical test according to the petitioner was
conducted on 05.10.2020 at the time of recruitment and found medically fit and the
offer of appointment was given. To the surprise of the petitioner, at the time of
basic training i.e. 20.06.2021, once again medical test for colour vision test was
done to check colour blindness and the offer of appointment of the petitioner was
stood cancelled on the strength of the report submitted by Dr. N. C. Hess, CMO
(NFSG) CISF, NIDA Hyderabad (Compat CISF KRTC Mundali) addressed to
Commandant/Adm.CISF KRTC Mundali, Cuttack, wherein, it is categorically
indicated that the petitioner, namely, Prasenjit Sarkar has defective colour vision.
[16]
Admittedly, as per 2(18), the test that said to have been conducted
within 18 months and when there is no specific condition for going for second test
within 18 months, the manner in which the cancellation of the offer of appointment
letter is found ultra vires and cancellation of the same, stands set aside. However,
since the selection of the petitioner pertains to CAPF/constable GD, the vision test
is very much essential and person with colour blindness or any vision deficiency
cannot be recruited since he will be holding a rifle and that would lead for wrong
judgment before he fires.
[17]
Internal correspondence shown by Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy
SGI i.e. the correspondence between the medical officer to the commandant and
also extension of 12 months to 18 months and conducting of test for the second
time, cannot have a bearing upon the offer letter since, the same is not indicated nor
there is any saving clause in this regard.
[18]
In view of the same, to clear the anomalies, this Court directs the
respondents to get the petitioner once again tested for colour blindness and in the
even if he is found fit, he may be provided suitable employment. In the event, if the
petitioner is found defective colour blindness, it is always open for the respondent
authorities to consider the case of the petitioner for providing any other alternative
employment, subject to the vacancies available.
[19]
With the above observations and directions, the present writ petition
stands disposed of.
[20]
As a sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2026.02.16 10:18:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review