Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.498 of 2023
1. Prasenjit Banerjee (age- 50 years)
S/O Sri Sukhamoy Banerjee, resident of Banerjee Para,
PO: Agartala, Pin- 799001, District- West Tripura.
2. Smt. Tandra Shil (age 49 years)
W/O Sri Swapan Roy, resident of Nandan Nagar,
PO- Nandan Nagar, District- West Tripura.
3. Smt. Mitali Das, (age-47 years)
W/O Sri Narayan Rudra Paul,
resident of Lanka Mura (Near Panchayat).
4. Smt. Jhutan Debnath (age- 43 years)
W/O Sri Samiran Majumder, resident of Shiv Nagar, PO- Agartala,
College, Pin- 799004, District- West Tripura.
5. Smt. Arati Datta (age- 47 years)
W/O Sri Asish Das, resident of Town Indra Nagar, Dhaleswar, Road
No.3, PO- Dhaleswar, Pin-799007.
6. Smt. Khela Dey (age- 48 years)
W/O Sri Samir Datta, resident of Vill.- Sidhai, PO-Kalagachia,
Mohanpur, District- West Tripura.
7. Sri Soumitra Chakraborty (age- 37 years)
S/O Sri Sushen Chakraborti, resident of Indranagar, PO-Indranagar,
Vill.-Indranagar, District- West Tripura.
8. Smt. Uma Deb (Roy) (age- 47 years)
W/O Sri Subrata Roy, resident of East Dukli, PO- East Pratapgarh,
PS- Amtali, District- West Tripura.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
to be represented by the Secretary, Health Services,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
PO- Secretariat, West Tripura, Pin-799010,
Agartala District- West Tripura.
2. The Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex,
PO- Secretariat, Pin- 799010,
Agartala, District- West Tripura
3. The Director of Health Services
Government of Tripura, PN Complex,
Gurkhabasti, PO- Kunjaban, Pin-799006,
District- West Tripura.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order :
Mr. C.S. Sinha, Advocate
None
Whether fit for reporting
Yes
:
14/09/2023
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. C.S. Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners. None appears for the respondents.
2.
By way of filing the instant writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the petitioners have urged this Court for directing the
respondents to consider regularization of service of the petitioners from the
dates of their joining in the service with all consequential benefits.
3.
Put it shortly, it is the case of the petitioners that they were
engaged as Civil Defence Volunteers in the office of the Director of Civil
Defence(DM & Collector) on different dates starting from 1995 to 2001 and
since their engagement they were rendering their service.
4.
It is also the case of the petitioners that the Joint Secretary to the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura by a communication dated
26.06.2012 addressed to the Director of Civil Defence(DM & Collector, West
Tripura District) and the Director of Health Service had informed that the
Finance Department in principle agreed to consider the representation of the
petitioners treating them as DRW and requested the Directors of Civil
Defence and Health Services to send proposal of those Civil Defence
Volunteers who were enrolled as C.D. Volunteers upto 31.03.2003 to the
Finance Department for taking further necessary steps. Extract of the
communication reads thus:Page 2 of 13
“Subject:- Regarding representation of Civil Defense Volunteers for
declaration of Civil Defencse Volunteers as Casual Worker.
Sir,
The undersigned is directed to inform that Finance Department in principle
agreeable to consider C.D. Volunteers as DRW, who were enrolled as CDE
Volunteers up to 31-02-2003, and who were presently deployed at AGMC &
GBP Hospital & IGM Hospitals, Agartala under Health Department and at the
State Emergency Operation Centre(previously State Control Room), Agartala
Circuit House(Protocol Cell) and District Control Room under Revenue
Department.
2. The undersigned is also directed to request the concerned department to
send proposal, for taking those C D Volunteers who were enrolled as C D
Volunteers up to 31-03-2003 only and presently deployed under their
Department, to Finance Department for further order.”
5.
Thereafter, the Director of Health Services, Government of
Tripura vide order dated 07.12.2012 engaged the petitioners as DRW(GroupD) purely on temporary basis from the dates of their joining.
6.
It is the further case of the petitioners that in the year 2016, the
Government of Tripura in the Health & Family Welfare Department by a
communication dated 11.05.2016 had taken a policy decision that the casual
workers who are having qualification of Madhyamik passed and above shall
be treated as Casual Worker(Group-C) and those who do not have
qualification of Madhyamik passed, shall be treated as Casual Worker(GroupD).
7.
Pursuant thereto, the Under Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Health & Family Welfare Department by issuing a memorandum
dated 27.01.2017 converted the job status of the petitioners from
DRW(Group-D) to DRW(Group-C). Extract of the Memo. dated 27.01.2017
is reproduced hereunder for convenience:
“In pursuance of the concurrence vide U.O. No.1676/FIN(G)/2016 dated
30.12.2016 of the Finance Department, Government of Tripura, the undersigned
is directed to order that the job status of the following 24(twenty-four) Daily
Rated Worker(DRW) who had acquired Madhyamik passed qualification as on
or before the date of engagement is converted from DRW(Group-D) to
DRW(Group-C) and entitled to existing wages rate of DRW(Group-C) subject to
revision of wages rate from time to time. This will take immediate effect.”
Noticeably, in the said Memo. dated 27.01.2017, the dates of
engagement of the petitioners were shown as 07.12.2012 and 12.11.2013.
8.
The bone of contention of the petitioners is that since the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura by issuing communication dated
26.06.2012 had agreed in principle to consider the Civil Defence Volunteers
as DRWs, who were enrolled as C.D. Volunteers upto 31.03.2003, so they are
entitled to be regularized from the next date of completion of ten years from
the dates of their engagement, in terms of Memo. dated 31.07.2018. It would
be apposite to reproduce the Memo dated 31.07.2018 issued by the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura, for convenience, in extenso:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated:- the 31st July, 2018
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Policy decision of regularization of service of DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. Workers in
Government Establishment and State PSUs and Autonomous bodies including AMC/NPS.
Finance Department has issued instructions from time to time as given for regularization of service
of DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. workers on the date completion of 17 years/15 years/10 years of
services. The memorandums are as follows:
Sl.No.
Memo No.
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 04.03.2006
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 22.02.2007
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/08(part),
Dated 01.09.2008
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/ 08(part),
Dated 21.01.2009
No.F.34(3)-Fin(G)/2012,
Dated 04.09.2012
2.
No.F.10(12)-Fin(G)/7(part-1),
Dated 07.11.2012
Issues
Regularization of DRWs/Contingent
etc. workers on
completion of 17 years of service as on 31.03.2005 allowing
effect from 01.02.2006
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers on
completion of 15 years of service as on 31.03.2006 allowing
effect from 01.01.2007
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers on
completion of 10 years of service as on 31.03.2008 allowing
effect from 01.07.2008
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers from
the next date of completion of 10 years of service
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent
etc. workers
working in State PSUs and Autonomous bodies including
AMC/NPs on completion of 10 years of service
Engagement of PTWs etc. as DRWs (Group-D) working in
different Departments of the Government for 2/3/4 hours who
were engaged on or prior to 31.03.2003 and have completed 10
years of service w.e.f. 01.12.2012
Recently, the matter has been further reviewed it has been observed that there are some shortcoming
in these instructions for regularization of the service of DRWs/Casual/contingent staff affecting
institutional efficiency and individual productivity due to different reasons.
3.
With a view to ensure transparent public employment policy for engagement of staff for such services,
all the memorandums as mentioned above is repealed.
4. All the concerned are required to ensure the implementation of above decision with immediate effect.
Under Secretary to
Government of Tripura
Finance Department”
9.
In the aforementioned background facts and circumstances, Mr.
Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioners has urged this Court for directing the
respondents to regularize the service of the petitioners as DRW(Group-C)
from the dates of their joining in the post with all consequential service
benefits.
10.
In the context of the case, it will be worthy to take note of the
decision of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in State of
Karnataka and Ors. Vs. Uma Devi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 whereby and
whereunder directed the Central and State Governments to formulate schemes
for regularization of the services of those employees who were
engaged/appointed irregularly, but not illegally and further held as under:“43. In M.P. State Coop. Bank Ltd. Bhopal vs Nanuram
Yadav and others, reported in (2007) 8 SCC 264, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that: [SCC pp. 274, 275, Para 24]
“24) It is clear that in the matter of public appointments, the following principles
are to be followed:
1) The appointments made without following the appropriate procedure under
the Rules/Government Circulars and without advertisement or inviting
applications from the open market would amount to breach of Arts. 14 & 16 of
the Constitution of India.
2) Regularisation cannot be a mode of appointment.
3) An appointment made in violation of the mandatory provisions of the statute
and in particular, ignoring the minimum educational qualification and other
essential qualification would be wholly illegal. Such illegality cannot be cured by
taking recourse to regularization.
4) Those who come by back door should go through that door.
5) No regularization is permissible in exercise of the statutory power conferred
under Art. 162 of the Constitution of India if the appointments have been made
in contravention of the statutory Rules.
6) The Court should not exercise its jurisdiction on misplaced sympathy.
7) If the mischief played so widespread and all pervasive, affecting the result, so
as to make it difficult to pick out the persons who have been unlawfully
benefited or wrongfully deprived of their selection, it will neither be possible nor
necessary to issue individual show-cause notice to each selectee. The only way
out would be to cancel the whole selection.
8) When the entire selection is stinking, conceived in fraud and delivered in
deceit, individual innocence has no place and the entire selection has to be set
aside.”
44.
Again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vibhuti Shankar
Pandey vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., reported in
(2023)3 SCC 639 had set aside the order of learned Single Judge
of Madhya Pradesh High Court directing the State to regularize
the service of the petitioner who was appointed on daily rated
basis under a project and not against any sanctioned post as it
was
noticed
that
the
initial
appointment
of
the
petitioner/appellant was not made by the competent authority
and the appointment was not made against a sanctioned post.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vibhuti Shankar(supra) has
reiterated the principle laid down in Umadevi (supra). [SCC p
640 para 4]. As I said earlier, in the case in hand, the initial
appointment of the petitioners was not made by the competent
authority of the Corporation and there is no evidence that they
were appointed against sanctioned vacant post.
45.
In a recent decision, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Government of Tamil Nadu & Anr. vs. Tamil Nadu Makkal
Nala Paniyalargal & Ors., 2023 SCC Online SC 393, relying
upon the judgments of the Supreme Court in Chander
Hass(supra)
and
Maharashtra
State
Road
Transport
Corporation(supra) reiterated the principles that the creation of
posts is not within the domain of judicial functions and it pertains
to the executive or legislature. In the case of Government of
Tamil
Nadu(supra),
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
has
categorically held that in absence of sanctioned posts, the State
cannot be compelled to create the post and absorb the persons
who are continuing in service of the State.”
11.
The Supreme Court in State of M.P. Vs. Lalit Kumar Verma,
(2007) 1 SCC 575 has made a distinction between “irregular appointment”
and “illegal appointment” as under:“12. The question which, thus, arises for consideration, would
be : is there any distinction between “irregular appointment”
and “illegal appointment”? The distinction between the two
terms is apparent. In the event the appointment is made in total
disregard of the constitutional scheme as also the recruitment
rules framed by the employer, which is “State” within the
meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India, the
recruitment would be an illegal one; whereas there may be cases
where, although, substantial compliance with the constitutional
scheme as also the rules have been made, the appointment may
be irregular in the sense that some provisions of some rules
might not have been strictly adhered to.”
12.
Again, in Siraj Ahmed Vs. State of U.P. by judgment dated
13.12.2019 passed in Civil Appeal No.9412/2019, the Supreme Court reiterated the same principle and held as under:“12. It can thus be seen that this Court has held that the
distinction
between
irregular
appointment
and
illegal
appointment is clear. It has been held that in the event
appointment is made in total disregard to the constitutional
scheme and the recruitment rules framed by the employer, where
the employer is “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution of India, the recruitment will be illegal one. It has,
however, been held that where although, substantial compliance
with the constitutional scheme, as also the Rules have been made,
the appointment would become irregular inasmuch as some
provisions of some rules have been adhered to.
13. Subsequently, another Bench of this Court in State of
Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari [State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari,
(2010) 9 SCC 247 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826] also had an
occasion to consider the issue. The Court observed thus: (SCCp.
250, para 7)
“7. It is evident from the above that there is an exception to the
general principles against “regularisation” enunciated in
Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi(3), (2006) 4 SCC
12006 SCC(L&S) 753], if the following conditions are fulfilled:
(i) The employee concerned should have worked for 10 years or
more in duly sanctioned post without the benefit or protection of
the interim order of any court or tribunal. In other words, the
State Government or its instrumentality should have employed
the employee and continued him in service voluntarily and
continuously for more than ten years.
(ii) The appointment of such employee should not be illegal, even
if irregular. Where the appointments are not made or continued
against sanctioned posts or where the persons appointed do not
possess the prescribed minimum qualifications, the appointments
will be considered to be illegal. But where the person employed
possessed the prescribed qualifications and was working against
sanctioned posts, but had been selected without undergoing the
process of open competitive selection, such appointments are
considered to be irregular.”
14. This court held in M. L. Kesari Case [State of Karnataka v.
M.L. Kesari, (2010) 9 SCC 247 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826] that
where the appointment are not made or continued against
sanctioned posts or where the persons appointed do not possess
the prescribed minimum qualifications, the appointment will be
considered to be illegal. However, when the person employed
possessed the prescribed qualifications and is working against
the sanctioned posts, but had been selected without undergoing
the process of open competitive selection, such appointments are
considered to be irregular.”
13.
Thus,
the
upshot
of
the
matter
is
as
to
whether
appointment/engagement of the petitioners was in consonance with the
mandate of Articles 14 and 16 as well as in the spirit of the law laid down in
Uma Devi (3)(supra) and subsequent decision cited here-in-above.
14.
In the instant case, after perusal of the documents annexed to the
writ petition, I find that the petitioners have failed to justify that they had been
appointed against any regular sanctioned vacant posts. It is revealed that they
have been appointed under a scheme only and their services were
discontinued thereafter by issuing a corrigendum which was, however,
withdrawn later on. There is no evidence to show that the petitioners had
possessed the requisite qualifications for holding the post they have sought
for. Moreso, the petitioners had been appointed illegally without following the
procedure prevalent at that time vis a vis de hors the constitutional schemes of
public employment.
15.
True it is, the petitioners’ right to claim regularisation was
ripened during the existence of the schemes, that is, prior to 31.07.2018 when
those schemes were repealed by the Government of Tripura after continuation
of long 10(ten) years. This Court and other Co-ordinate Benches had passed
orders directing regularization of many DRW/Casual/Contingent workers
without taking into account the various parameters and conditionalities
mentioned in the schemes as well as in total disregard to the spirit of law laid
down in Uma Devi (3) (Supra). 1As such, those judgments and orders cannot
be treated as precedent. Furthermore, in Uma Devi (3) (Supra), the Apex
Court strongly deprecated the idea of such irregular appointments and asked
the Central and State Governments to adhere to the constitutional schemes of
public employment as enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India in Government jobs, however, permitted the Governments to regularize
the services of such irregularly appointed employees as “one-time measure”
who had completed 10(ten) years of service or had been continuing in service
for more than 10(ten) years without the intervention of orders of the Court or
Tribunals in duly sanctioned posts. Here, it would be apposite to refer Para 53
of the judgment, which is reproduced hereunder:“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where
irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as explained in
State of Mysore vs. S.V. Narayanappa, reported in (1967) 1 SCR 128,
R.N. Nanjundappa vs. T. Thimmiah, reported in (1972) 1 SCC 409,
B.N. Nagarajan vs. State of Karnataka, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 507,
and referred to in paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified persons in
duly sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the
employees have continued to work for ten years or more but without
the intervention of orders of courts or of tribunals. The question of
regularization of the services of such employees may have to be
considered on merits in the light of the principles settled by this Court
in the cases above referred to and in the light of this judgment. In that
context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their
instrumentalities should take steps to regularize as a one time
measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who have worked
[underlined for emphasis]
for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of
orders of courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular
recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that
require to be filled up, in cases where temporary employees or daily
wagers are being now employed. The process must be set in motion
within six months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if
any already made, but not subjudice, need not be reopened based on
this judgment, but there should be no further by-passing of the
constitutional requirement and regularizing or making permanent,
those not duly appointed as per the constitutional scheme.”
16.
Moreso, the process of regularization undertaken by the
Governments in compliance with the directions passed in the case of Uma
Devi (3) (supra) is a kind of special drive to regularize irregularly appointed
Daily Rated Workers/Contingent Workers/Casual workers, etc under different
schemes.
17.
In the opinion of this Court, this special drive cannot be allowed
to continue for years together, which, needless to say, will defeat the
Constitutional schemes of public employment. In the process of regularization
under different schemes for long 10(ten) years, thousands of eligible job
aspirants have already been deprived of public employment through open
competition, and if such process is permitted to be continued in the years to
come, then, it will demolish the basic features of equality clauses as enshrined
in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, which will be enough to
ultimately create unrest in the matter of public employment. Obviously, this
was not the object of the case of Uma Devi (3)(supra). It is pertinent to
mention herein that the State of Tripura has continued with those special
schemes for long 10(ten) years till 31.07.2018. It must be stopped, so that
thousands and thousands of job aspirants can avail the opportunity of public
employment within the framework of the Constitution.
18.
In my considered view, the petitioners being the entrants through
back door, if desirous to get the benefit of the schemes which were framed for
the purpose of regularisation of irregularly appointed employees “as one time
measure”, had to raise their claims within the realm and existence of the
scheme, and not after the schemes are repealed.
19.
There is yet another aspect, which is essential to notice in the
facts of the case in hand. The petitioners were appointed on different dates
between 1995 and 2001. Only in the year 2023 suddenly they woke up from
the slumber to claim regularisation after decades. Law will not come to the
rescue of those who are negligent and careless. It is well-recognized principle
of law that those who sleep over their rights and allow their rights to be
obliterated and that of others to be ripened into full fledged rights would not
be helped by the Courts in exercise of its discretionary jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Courts of Law will help those
who help themselves. The above view of mine is fortified by a decision of the
Supreme Court in State of Orissa Vs. Pyarimohan Samantaray and Ors.
(1977) 3 SCC 396 where their Lordships had observed that:“6. It would thus appear that there is justification for the argument of
the Solicitor General that even though a cause of action arose to the
petitioner as far back as 1962, on the rejection of his representation
on November 9, 1962, he allowed some eleven years to go by before
filing the writ petition. There is no satisfactory explanation of the
inordinate delay for, as has been held by this Court in Rabindra Nath
Bose v. Union of India, the making of repeated representations, after
the rejection of one representation, could not be held to be a
satisfactory explanation of the delay. The fact therefore remains that
the petitioner allowed some 11 years to go by before making a petition
for the redress of his grievances. In the meantime a number of other
appointments were also made to the Indian Administrative Service by
promotion from the State Civil Service, some of the officers received
promotions to higher posts in that service and may even have retired.
Those who continued to serve could justifiably think that as there was
no challenge to their appointments within the period prescribed for a
suit, they could look forward to further promotion and higher terminal
benefits on retirement. The High Court therefore erred in rejecting the
argument that the writ petition should be dismissed because of the
inordinate and unexplained delay even though it was “strenuously”
urged for its consideration on behalf of the Government of India”
20.
In this context of the case, I may also gainfully refer the case
reported in AIR 1987 SC 251, State of M. P. v. Nand Lal Jaiswal where it
was held that “It is well settled that the power of the High Court to issue an
appropriate writ under Art. 226 of the Constitution is discretionary and the High
Court in the exercise of its discretion does not ordinarily assist the tardy and the
indolent or the acquiescent and the lethargic. If there is inordinate delay on the part
of the petitioner in filing a writ petition and such delay is not satisfactorily
explained, the High Court may decline to intervene and grant relief in the exercise
of its writ jurisdiction. The evolution of this rule of laches or delay is premised upon
a number of factors. The High Court does not ordinarily permit a belated resort to
the extraordinary remedy under the writ jurisdiction because it is likely to cause
confusion and public inconvenience and bring in its train new injustices. The rights
of third parties may intervene and if the writ jurisdiction is exercised on a writ
petition filed after unreasonable delay, it may have the effect of inflicting not only
hardship and inconvenience but also injustice on third parties.”
21.
Following the aforesaid principles, it would not be wrong to hold
that the delayed approach and lackadaisical attitude of the petitioners would
not entail them to get the benefit of non-existent schemes. In the opinion of
this Court, this petition is absolutely barred by delay and laches. That apart to
re-iterate, the nature of appointment of the petitioners is not only irregular but
illegal.
22.
This Court while dealing with similar issue in WP(C) No.5 of
2023 titled as Sri Satya Ranjan Dey and Anr. Vs. The State of Tripura and 4
Ors. decided on 06.09.2023 had passed a detailed order referring many
judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court and held that the petitioners of that writ
petition were not entitled to get their services regularized, and dismissed the
writ petition.
23.
Before I conclude, I should say that we must not forget, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in a catena of decisions has categorically iterated and
ruled that regularisation of irregular or illegally appointed persons cannot
become an alternative mode of recruitment to public service. So, after
continuation of scheme for regularisation for long 10(ten) years and with its
repeal on 31.07.2018, in my opinion, the Government should not be asked to
reopen the scheme and to continue the same for uncertain period because we
cannot close our eyes to the fact that thousands of competent job aspirants are
waiting in the queue for participating in the fair competition.
24.
Like WP(C) 376/2023, I do not find any merit in the present writ
petition and the same stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Digitally signed
SANJAY
SANJAY by
GHOSH
Date: 2023.10.05
GHOSH 17:04:46
+05'30'
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review