Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A(J) No.02 of 2023
Sri Sanjit Rudra Paul alias Sanju, son of Sri Rabindra Rudra Paul, resident of
Betbagan, Dolubari, P.S. Ambassa, District- Dhalai Tripura
.........Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
.........Respondent(s)
and
Crl.A(J) No.03 of 2023
Sri Krishna Ch. Debroy alias Maran, S/O- Lt. Mohanlal Debroy, of Dolubari,
P.S- Ambassa, Dist.- Dhalai Tripura
.........Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
.........Respondent(s)
Crl.A(J) No.04 of 2023
Sri Prasanta Deb alias Jiban, S/O- Lt. Parimal Deb, of Dolubari, P.S.- Ambassa,
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura
.........Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
.........Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Biswas, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. B. Deb, Advocate,
Mr. R. Nath, Advocate,
Mr. Victor Ghosh, Advocate,
Ms. Rumpa Dey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Public Prosecutor.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Dates of hearing: 21.08.2023 & 31.08.2023
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment & Order: 29.09.2023
Whether Fit for Reporting: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
All these three appeals arise out of the common impugned
judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 11.11.2022 passed by the
learned Special Judge (NDPS), Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa in Special
(NDPS) 29 of 2019 whereby accused Sanjit Rudra Paul alias Sanju (hereinafter
referred to as ‘S’) [appellant in Crl.A(J) No.02 of 2023] has been convicted
under Section 21(b)/25/29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as „NDPS Act‟) and sentenced to suffer
rigorous imprisonment for 5(five) years for the commission of offence
punishable under Section 21(b) of the NDPS Act and to pay a fine of
Rs.50,000/- only for the said offence with a default sentence of 6(six) months.
He has also been sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3(three) years
for the commission of offence punishable under Section 25 of the NDPS Act
and to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- only for the said offence with a default sentence
of 6(six) months. He has been further sentenced to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for 2(two) years for the commission of offence punishable under
Section 29 of the NDPS Act and to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- only for the said
offence with a default sentence of 6(six) months; the other accused persons i.e.
Surendra Debbarma (hereinafter referred to as ‘SD’) [has not preferred appeal],
Prasanta Deb alias Jiban (hereinafter referred to as ‘P’) [appellant in Crl.A(J)
No.04 of 2023] and Krishna Charan Debroy alias Maran (hereinafter referred
to as ‘K’) [appellant in Crl.A(J) No.03 of 2023] have been convicted under
Section 29 of the NDPS Act and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for 2(two) years for the commission of offence punishable under Section 29 of
the NDPS Act and to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- only for the said offence with a
default sentence of 6(six) months.
2.
Prosecution story, as alleged in the FIR lodged by Sub-Inspector
Sri Manoj Kumar Pal on 24.09.2019 [Exhibit P-7, P-7/1] along with complaint
petition [Exhibit P-6, P-6/1, P-6/2] inter alia alleged that on 24.09.2019 at
about 1305 hours, a secret information was received at Ambassa Police Station
that some drug peddlers assembled in the house of accused S of Betbagan
(Dolubari) for selling drugs. Accordingly, the matter was entered in Ambassa
PS GD Entry No.21, dated 24.09.2019 and the same was informed to the higher
authority seeking permission to conduct search/raid in the house of accused S.
Based on such information, the complainant along with SDPO, Ambassa,
Executive Magistrate, Ambassa, SI Subir Saha and other police personnel went
to the house of accused S located at Betbagan, cordoned the western vity hut of
accused S and found the four accused persons namely SD, P, K including
accused S. On reaching the spot, SI Manoj Kumar Pal prepared pre-search
memo in presence of SDPO, Ambassa, Executive Magistrate and independent
witnesses and entered into the hut. On observation of the body language of the
accused persons, it was suspected that they might have carried any contraband
goods with them for illegal selling. The detained persons were asked whether
they desired to be searched by police in presence of a gazetted officer.
Thereafter, the informant searched all the four persons namely S, SD, P and K
with a prior consent, in the presence of SDPO, Ambassa, Executive Magistrate
and independent witnesses. Before search of their body, the bodies of the police
team were got self-searched by witnesses. During search in presence of
witnesses, informant recovered 131 numbers of small vial wrapped with a
plastic packet from the pocket of accused S which contained powder based
brown/yellow colour Heroin. On asking, accused S confessed that he is a
wholesaler of Heroin in and around Ambassa area and 3(three) other FIR
named accused persons came to purchase Heroin from the accused S for selling
in the local market. Accordingly, complainant SI Manoj Kumar Pal seized the
contraband Heroin along with 131 numbers of vial and mobile phone of
accused S under a proper seizure list in presence of witnesses. Thereafter, the
accused persons were arrested and after return to police station, the complainant
lodged a Suo Motu complaint which was registered as Ambassa Police Station
case No.2019 ABS 053 dated 24.09.2019 against the accused persons for the
commission of offences punishable under Section 22(b)/25/29 of the NDPS
Act. The case was endorsed to SI Subir Saha for investigation.
3.
Investigating Officer Sri Subir Saha [PW 9] visited the place of
occurrence, prepared hand sketch map with separate index and examined the
witnesses under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. He also seized a message and details
report was sent to SP, Dhalai relating to search, recovery and seizure of
contraband. He then approached the learned Court below to draw samples of the
seized contraband and for certification of correctness of inventory of the seized
contraband, and also for certifying the photographs. The representative and
control samples were thereafter drawn and certificate of correctness was issued
by the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Ambassa. After preparation of
inventory on 26.09.2019, he kept the seized contraband items in the District
NDPS godown and obtained receipt voucher. On 27.09.2019, he arranged to
send the samples to State Forensic Science Laboratory for examination through
SDPO, Ambassa. He also collected report from SFSL, Narsingarh. After
completion of investigation, he submitted charge sheet against all the accused
persons for the offences punishable under Section 22(b)/25/29 of the NDPS
Act. Cognizance was taken by the learned Court below for all these above
offences. Police papers were supplied to the accused persons under Section 207
of Cr.P.C. Thereafter, charges were framed under Section 20(b)(ii)(B)/29 of the
NDPS Act against the accused persons. The contents of charges were read over
and explained to the accused persons in Bengali language in open Court to
which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. The following charges
were framed against the accused persons:
“That, on or about the 24th day of September, 2019 at any time
before 1350 hours at Betbagan, Dalubari in the house of accused Sanjit
Rudra Pal alias Sanjo under Ambassa Police station, all of you in
contravention of the provision of Section 8(c) of the NDPS Act, 1985 have
possessed 68.30 gram Heroin in 131 numbers of vial with intend to sell
Heroin in and around Ambassa area and thereby all of you have
committed an offence punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of the NDPS
Act, 1985 and within the cognizance of this Special Court.
Secondly, that, on or before 24-09-2019 at any time at Betbagan,
Dalubari in the house of accused Sanjit Rudra Pal alias Sanjo under
Ambassa police station, all of you were party to a criminal conspiracy to
commit an offence punishable under Chapter-IV of the NDPS Act and
thereby all of you have committed an offence punishable under Section 29
of the NDPS Act, 1985 and within the cognizance of this Special Court.”
The contents of the separate charge framed against accused Sanjit
Rudra Pal @ Sanjo read as follows:“That, you on or about the 24th day of September, 2019 at any time
before 1350 hours at Betbagan, Dalubari under Ambassa Police station
being the owner and occupier of a house knowing fully permitted the said
house to be used by the other three charge-sheeted accused persons
namely, 1. Shri Surendra Debbarma, 2. Shri Prasanta Deb and 3. Shri
Krishna Charan Debroy alias Maran for the commission of an offence
punishable under Chapter-IV of the NDPS Act and thereby you have
committed an offence punishable under Section 25 of the NDPS Act, 1985
and within the cognizance of this Special Court.”
4.
A request was made by the Special P.P to alter the charge so
framed against the accused persons, as there was a defect in the charge under
Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of the NDPS Act read with Section 29 of the said Act. On
the request of the learned Special P.P. to modify the charge, the Special Court
heard the Special P.P. as well the defence counsel on the point of alteration and
modification of charge. After hearing both sides, fresh charge under Section
21(b) of the NDPS Act read with Section 29 of the said Act was framed against
the accused persons which were read over and explained to them in Bengali
language in open Court to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be
tried. Charge under Section 25 of the NDPS Act against the accused S remained
as before. However, the learned counsel for both sides did not pray for denovo
trial on the alteration of charge. The altered charge read as follows:
“That, on or about the 24th day of September, 2019 at any time
before 1350 hours at Betbagan, Dalubari in the house of accused Sanjit
Rudra Pal alias Sanjo under Ambassa Police station, all of you in
contravention of the provision of Section 8(c) of the NDPS Act, 1985 have
possessed 68.30 gram Heroin in 131 numbers of vial with intend to sell
Heroin in and around Ambassa area and thereby all of you have
committed an offence punishable under Section 21(b) of the NDPS Act,
1985 and within the cognizance of this Special Court.
Secondly, that, on or before 24-09-2019 at any time at Betbagan,
Dalubari in the house of accused Sanjit Rudra Pal alias Sanjo under
Ambassa police station, all of you were party to a criminal conspiracy to
commit an offence punishable under Chapter-IV of the NDPS Act and
thereby all of you have committed an offence punishable under Section 29
of the NDPS Act, 1985 and within the cognizance of this Special Court.”
5.
Prosecution adduced 9 (nine) witnesses which are as under:
(i) PW-1:- Shri Asish Dasgupta,
(ii) PW-2:- Shri S. Curzon Halam,
(iii) PW-3:- C/6903 Shri Nirode Lal Das,
(iv) PW-4:- Shri Suman Kumar Chakraborty,
(v) PW-5:- Shri Ashim Paul,
(vi) PW-6:- Shri Rupak Rudra Pal,
(vii) PW-7:- Shri Manoj Kumar Pal,
(viii) PW-8:- Shri Himadri Sarkar,
(ix) PW-9:- Shri Subir Saha,
6.
Several documents were exhibited by the prosecution during trial,
which are as under:
“(i) Exhibit P-1:- Pre-search memo,
(ii) Exhibit 1/1:- Signature of PW-1 on the pre-search memo,
(iii) Exhibit 1/2:- Signature of PW-2 on the pre-search memo,
(iv) Exhibit 1/3:- Signature of PW-5 on the pre-search memo,
(v) Exhibit 1/4:- Signature of PW-6 on pre-search memo,
(vi) Exhibit 1/5:- Signature of PW-7 on the pre-search memo,
(vii) Exhibit 2/1:- Signature of PW-1 on the seizure list,
(viii) Exhibit 2/2:- Signature of PW-2 on the seizure list,
(ix) Exhibit 2/3:- Signature of PW-5 on the seizure list,
(x) Exhibit 3:- Forwarding note dated 05.11.2019,
(xi) Exhibit 4/1:- Signature of PW-3 on the seizure list dated 08.10.2019,
(xii) Exhibit 5(i) & 5(ii):- SFSL report dated 18.10.2019,
(xiii) Exhibit P-6:- Suo-motu complaint,
(xiv) Exhibit P-6/1:- Signature of PW-7 on the suo-motu complaint
(xv) Exhibit P-6/2:- Registration endorsement of PW-8,
(xvi) Exhibit P-7:- Printed FIR,
(xvii) Exhibit P-7/1:- Signature of PW-8 on the printed FIR,
(xviii) Exhibit P-8 (As a whole):- Hand-sketch map,
(xix) Exhibit P-9 (As a whole):- Index of hand-sketch map,
(xx) Exhibit P-10 (As a whole):- Inventory,
(xxi) Exhibit P-11 (As a whole):- Photographs,
(xxii) Exhibit P-12 (As a whole):- Certificate of correctness of the
inventory, sampling and photographs,
(xxiii) Exhibit P-13 (As a whole):- Godown receipt along with signature
of godown In-charge,
(xxiv) Exhibit P-14 (As a whole):- Detailed report with signature of PW9,”
No defence exhibit was adduced. The accused persons also did not
adduce any witness on their behalf. They were examined under Section 313 of
the Cr.P.C in respect to the incriminating materials elicited during evidence, to
which they denied and claimed themselves to be innocent. The learned Trial
Court framed the following issues for determination:
“12. (i) Whether the accused persons on 24.09.2019 at any time before
1350 hours at Betbagan, Dolubari in the house of accused Sanjit Rudra Pal
@ Sanjo were found in possession of 7.60 grams of Heroin without any
valid document and or licence?
(ii) Whether the accused persons were assembled in the house of
Sanjit Rudra Pal @ Sanjo on the aforementioned date, time and place for
the purpose of selling and distribution of drugs followed by a conspiracy
hatched by them in the commission of offence?
(iii) Whether the accused Sanjit Rudra Pal @ Sanjo being the
owner of his hoiuse on the aforementioned date, time and place permitted
other accused persons namely, Surendra Debbarma, Prasanta Deb @ Jiban
and Krishna Charan Debroy @ Maran to use his house premises for the
purpose of consumption, selling and distribution of drugs?”
7.
Learned Trial Court, after consideration of the material evidence
on record and the provisions of Section 35 of the NDPS Act and the offending
provisions under which they were charged and also upon hearing learned
counsel for the prosecution and the defence, proceeded to render a finding that
accused S is the main peddler and supplier of drugs and other three accused
persons are the consumers and distributors of drugs in the locality and all the
accused persons conspired for the purpose of selling and distribution of drugs in
the locality. The accused S used his house premises for the purpose of illegal
trade of NDPS in collusion with the other accused persons. Based on these
findings, the accused S was convicted under Section 21(b)/25/29 of the NDPS
Act, and the other accused persons i.e. the other two appellants namely P and K
and one non-appellant namely SD were convicted under Section 29 of the
NDPS Act. Learned Trial Court however, also held that the prosecution had
failed to prove the offences under Section 21(b) against the other 3(three)
accused persons namely P, K and SD. The learned Court thereafter proceeded
to pass the order of sentence against the accused persons on 11.11.2022 as
referred to hereinabove.
8.
Heard Mr. P.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. R.
Nath, learned counsel for the appellant S and Mr. B. Deb, learned counsel
assisted by Mr. Victor Ghosh, learned counsel for the appellants K and P. The
impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence upon the appellant S
has been assailed inter alia on the following grounds:
(1) That the informant, SI Manoj Kumar Pal [PW-7] has stated in
his examination-in-chief that he lodged a Suo Motu complaint on 24.09.2019 on
receiving a secret telephonic information that few drug peddlers assembled in
the house of the appellant S and were dealing with drugs. He further stated that
the said information was recorded in GD Entry No.21 dated 24.09.2019 and
reduced in writing and the matter was informed to the Officer-in-Charge,
Ambassa PS and to the higher authority. He took permission for the next course
of action, but did not say the exact copy of the information received by him
through telephone was sent to the superior police officers. As such, the
prosecution failed to comply the mandatory provision under Section 42(2) of
the NDPS Act. The prosecution did not even produce the copy of GD Entry in
which the information was received by him and recorded. Further, PW 1 who
was the SDPO also did not say that he received the exact copy of information
reduced into writing that was sent to him by PW 7. PW 9, who was the IO, has
remained completely silent about the copy of GD Entry in which information
was received by PW 7 and reduced into writing. In this regard, reliance has
been placed upon paragraphs 8, 12, 14 and 15 of the decision of the Apex Court
in the case of Darshan Singh v. State of Haryana reported in (2016) 14 SCC
358.
(2) PW 1-SDPO, Ambassa PS stated in his examination-in-chief
that he interrogated all the accused persons who denied the presence of any
contraband drug in their possession and then the police personnel expressed
their intention to search the bodies of the above named 4(four) accused persons
in his presence and that of PW 2-Shri. S. Curzon Halam, DCM, Ambassa. PW 1
also stated that when all the 4(four) persons gave their consent, they searched
the bodies of the 4(four) persons including the appellant S in presence of
independent witnesses, but in cross-examination, he has stated that he did not
obtain consent of the accused persons in writing. He also stated that the consent
was taken verbally and their signatures were obtained in the search memo.
However, this witness nowhere stated that he informed the accused S and other
accused persons that they have a right to be searched in presence of gazetted
officer or in presence of a Magistrate which is the mandatory requirement under
Section 50 of the Act. PW 2-DCM, Ambassa also stated that the police officer
prepared one search memo in presence of accused persons and other
independent witnesses and obtained his signature on that search memo. The
police officer accompanied by other police personnel conducted search and
recovered alleged contraband articles from the possession of the appellant S;
but this witness did not say about compliance of Section 50 of the NDPS Act.
PW 5 has stated that the contraband items were recovered from the dwelling hut
of the appellant S, claiming himself to be an eye witness of the search; but he
did not say that these articles were seized from the person of the appellant. PW
6 stated that he learned that some illegal substances were recovered and the
police personnel present there, asked him to put signature on paper; but he did
not know the contents of the seizure. PW 7 has also stated that personal search
was conducted in presence of SDPO, Ambassa, Executive Magistrate, Ambassa
and independent witnesses; but did not say that the consent of the accused
persons were taken before being searched or they were informed as of their
right to be searched in presence of a Magistrate. There is no evidence on record
that the accused persons gave consent of their personal search. Therefore, the
provisions of Section 50(1) have been violated and the appellant S is entitled to
be acquitted of the charges. In this regard, reliance has been placed at
paragraphs 9 and 11 of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Harchand
Singh and another v. State of Haryana reported in AIR 1974 SC 344 on the
proposition that when two sets of contradictory evidence are there on an issue
of fact, they are not trustworthy to be believed.
(3) PW 9-the IO, in his examination-in-chief, stated that he
prepared inventory of the seized contrabands and other materials and produced
it before learned Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Ambassa which is
marked as Exhibit P-10. According to the prosecution, the incident took place
on 24.09.2019 at 1305 hours, but PW 4 has stated that the samples of
contraband were sent by the office of SDPO, Ambassa- PW 1 on 27.09.2019 in
connection with Ambassa PS Case No.2019 ABS 053 dated 24.09.2019. PW 1
did not say where those samples were kept and in whose custody they remained
till 27.09.2019. They also did not say on which date they were packed and
sealed and how it had gone to the office of SDPO, Ambassa from the end of
Officer-in-Charge of the PS. PW 4 has stated that there was no reference in the
face of the sealed packet regarding date and time when the sealed packet was
handed over to Shri Buddha Debbarma from the office of SDPO, Ambassa. The
prosecution was bound to bring on record the evidence showing that those
contrabands were kept in malkhana with receipt of malkhana mentioning the
mode of packing and the date of packing. The prosecution is completely silent
on this aspect. Learned counsel for the appellant S has also placed reliance on
paragraph 27 of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Pradeep Kumar
v. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2023) 5 SCC 350. Reliance is also placed
on the judgment and order dated 28.04.2023 of the Coordinate Bench of this
Court in the case of Shri Mithu Kumar and another v. The State of Tripura
passed in Crl.A(J) No.03/2022. It is submitted that if the consent was not taken
in a format before personal search and there was no scoring out of the options
expressed in the words “I require/do not require”, the prosecution had failed to
comply the mandatory requirement under Section 50 of the NDPS Act making
the accused aware of his right to be searched before a gazetted officer or a
Magistrate. As such, the conviction was set aside as being vitiated for noncompliance of Section 50 of the NDPS Act and the accused were acquitted of
the charge.
9.
Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel for the appellant S further
states that confession of the appellant was recorded, but no such confession has
been brought on record nor can it be treated as a substantive piece of evidence.
In this regard, he has placed reliance at paragraph 7 of the decision rendered by
the Apex Court the case of The State of Bombay v. Rusy Mistry and another
reported in AIR 1960 SC 391. Learned counsel for the appellant S has also
referred to the provisions of Section 52-A of the Act and submitted that the
inventory was not properly prepared.
10.
On these grounds learned senior counsel for the appellant S has
prayed that the findings of the learned Special Court suffer from serious errors
of law and non-appreciation of evidence; and moreover, the prosecution has
failed to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt. The prosecution has also
failed to undertake mandatory compliance of Section 42(1) and Section 50(1) of
the NDPS Act which has vitiated the entire trial. As such, the appellant S may
be acquitted of the charges.
11.
Mr. B. Deb, learned counsel for the appellants K and P have
adopted the arguments advanced by learned senior counsel for the appellant S.
Apart from that, he has also referred to the First Information Report and
submitted that there is no explanation as to why a search warrant could not be
obtained in terms of Section 41(1) of the NDPS Act before proceeding to search
the house of the appellant S. Learned counsel for the appellants K and P has
also referred to the deposition of PW 1, PW 2, PW 5, PW 6, PW 7 and PW 8. It
is submitted that PW 1, in his cross examination, has stated that he did not
obtain any search warrant before arrival to the place of occurrence. He even did
not obtain consent of the accused persons in writing. Even the provisions of
Section 100 of the Cr.P.C has not been complied with by the police personnel
as well as PW 7- the Complainant SI Manoj Kumar Pal who conducted the raid,
because no independent witnesses were called from the locality. The seizure list
witnesses i.e. PW 5 and PW 6 were not of the same locality of the accused
persons. If the evidence of the prosecution witnesses is seen in entirety, it would
be evident that no reason has been assigned by the police as to why they did not
obtain search warrant before conducting search in the house of the accused S in
violation of Section 42(1)(d) of the Act. He submitted that no recovery has been
made from the present appellants i.e. K and P of any contraband items. They
have been falsely implicated in the instant case on the basis of alleged
confessional statement made before the IO. The IO did not make any prayer
before the Court for recording confessional statement of accused S. Moreover,
PW 1 has nowhere stated about his tour diary which is required to be
maintained as per the Police Regulations of Bengal Rules. By referring to the
statement of PW 2-DCM, Ambassa, it is stated that from his evidence also there
is no single iota of evidence on record as to whether any independent witnesses
from the locality were called. PW 5-one of the seizure list witnesses, a resident
of Kamalacherra under Ambassa PS who stated that on 24.09.2019, he was
returning to the motor stand and reached near the house of accused S at
Betbagan, Dolubari under Ambassa PS where he noticed large number of
persons gathered in front of the house of the accused. He also went to know
about the incident from the police personnel present there besides an Executive
Magistrate and came to know that huge quantity of drugs was recovered from
the house of the appellant S. Police also showed him a polythene bundle
containing some plastic containers which contained powder like substances
supposed to be drug. Police asked him to put signature and obtained his
signature on two papers - on search memo and on seizure list which are Exhibit
1/3 and Exhibit 2/3. From his statement, it is clear that he is not a resident of the
locality and by the time he reached the place of occurrence, the police had
already recovered contraband items and there was a huge gathering. Therefore,
there is a violation of Section 100(4) of the Cr.P.C by not calling local
personnel to be as seizure list witnesses. In his cross examination, he has
categorically stated that contents of the documents on which his signatures were
obtained, were not read over to him and at the time of search in the house of
accused S, he was not present. Therefore, PW 5 was not a seizure witness
during search and seizure. Similarly, PW 6 is a resident of Kamalacherra and
has been adduced as seizure witness. He also has stated in similar manner that
when he reached the place of occurrence and stopped his vehicle, he learnt that
some illegal substances were recovered and the police personnel asked him to
put his signature on a paper which is marked as Exhibit 1/4. In his cross
examination, he has also stated that the documents were not read over to him on
which he has signed. However, learned trial Court, without considering all these
vital lacunae in the prosecution case, wrongly convicted the aforesaid appellants
without considering that both the PW 5 and PW 6 were not present at the time
of alleged seizure. Learned counsel has also referred to the deposition of PW 7
and submitted that the said witness had no explanation as to why he did not
obtain any search warrant which is in violation of Section 42(1)(d) of the NDPS
Act, nor did he prepare any post-search memo. He has also not stated as to why
the provisions of Section 57 of the NDPS Act, which are mandatory, were not
complied with. As such, there was total non-compliance of the procedure
prescribed under Section 42, 50 and 57 of the NDPS Act read with Section 100
of the Cr.P.C and Police Regulations of Bengal Rules. PW 9 is the IO of the
case who has submitted the charge sheet against the 4(four) accused persons.
From his evidence, it is seen that he had prepared interrogation report of the
accused persons, but no prayer was made for recording their confessional
statement before any Magistrate. As such, the statements of accused persons are
not admissible in the eye of law.
12.
Mr. B. Deb, learned counsel for the appellants K and P, has also
referred to Exhibit P-10 which is the inventory and referred to the statement of
PW 7 in cross examination where he has stated that inventory was not prepared.
It is submitted that these appellants have no criminal antecedents and as such,
they deserve to be acquitted of the charges on failure of the prosecution to apply
the mandatory provisions under the NDPS Act and on the basis of such
unreliable evidence. Reliance is placed upon paragraphs 90, 102 and 103 of the
decision of the Apex Court in the case of Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu
reported in (2021) 4 SCC 1.
13.
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned Public Prosecutor has inter alia made the
following submissions in support of the findings recorded by the learned Trial
Court and the truthfulness of the prosecution case:
(i) He has referred to the FIR recorded by PW 7-SI Manoj Kumar
Pal where in the first few lines itself it is stated that on 24.09.2019 at 1305
hours, he had received telephonic secret information that few drug peddlers had
assembled in the house of the appellant S and were dealing for drug selling
activities. The FIR also states that GD Entry No.21 dated 24.09.2019 was made.
The Officer-in-Charge, Ambassa PS and also the higher authority were
informed and he got permission for next course of action. The format of the FIR
at Column 3(c) also refers to the same GD Entry. The FIR was registered after
completion of the search. Though, FIR is not a substantive piece of evidence,
but it corroborates the evidence adduced by the prosecution witnesses during
trial. Reference is made to the statement of PW 7-SI Manoj Kumar Pal who is
the informant. It is stated that PW 7 had during course of his examination-inchief categorically stated that he had noted the matter in GD Entry No.21 dated
24.09.2019, reduced the information in writing in the GD Entry book and
informed the Officer-in-Charge, Ambassa PS and to the higher authority, and
took permission for next course of action. No question was raised by the
defence in the cross examination as to whether the GD Entry was sent to the
higher authorities and the Officer-in-Charge, Ambassa PS. He has placed
provisions of Section 42(1) and sub-section 2 thereof and submitted that the
informant, being an SI, was an empowered officer under Section 41(1) of the
Act, which has been substituted by Act 9 of 2001, and who had reason to
believe that such offence of drug paddling was being committed in the house of
the accused S. Therefore, he had reason to believe and the copy of the
information has to be submitted to the higher authority within seventy-two
hours as per Section 42(2) of the NDPS Act. Earlier the requirement was that
the information had to be sent forthwith. In this regard, he has relied upon
paragraphs 31, 36, 37 and 40 of the decision rendered by the Apex Court in the
case of Laxmibai and another v. Bhagwantbuva and others reported in (2013)
4 SCC 97 in support of the argument that when no doubt has been raised by the
defence by raising any query during cross examination regarding sending of GD
Entry during trial, such a point is not available to be raised during the appellate
stage. He has also pointed out that the GD Entry Number is specifically
mentioned in the search memo [Exhibit P-1, P-1/1, P-1/2, P-1/3, P-1/4, P-1/5]
and the seizure list [Exhibit P-2, P-2/1, P-2/3]. As such, there is full compliance
of Section 42(1) and sub-section 2 of the NDPS Act.
(ii) Learned Public Prosecutor has also strongly refuted the
submission of learned counsel for the appellants that there was non-compliance
of Section 50(1) of the NDPS Act. He has again referred to the statement, made
in the FIR by PW 7- informant SI Manoj Kumar Pal, which shows that the
detained persons were asked if they wanted to be searched in presence of a
gazetted officer. Such statement is also corroborated by PW 1 during his
examination who is the SDPO, Ambassa. All the 4(four) accused persons gave
verbal consent to be searched. PW 2 is the DCM, Ambassa and a gazetted
officer, in whose presence the search was made. Learned Public Prosecutor
submits that there is no requirement for seeking consent in a written manner or
in a format as per Section 50(1) of the Act. In this regard, reliance is placed
upon paragraphs 23, 24, 29 and 30 of the decision of the Constitution Bench of
the Apex Court in the case of Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja v. State of Gujarat
reported in (2011) 1 SCC 609. The Apex Court has clearly held that it is not
necessary that information required to be given under Section 50 should be in a
prescribed format or in writing. It is further pointed out from the statement of
the accused persons under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C, that no questions or
objections were raised by the accused persons that they were not informed of
the right to be searched in presence of a gazetted officer, nor was any such
question put to PW 1 and 2 during cross examination. In this regard, he has
placed reliance upon paragraph 15 of the decision of the Apex Court in the case
of Prabha Shankar Dubey v. State of M.P. reported in (2004) 2 SCC 56. It is
submitted that the decision is on the very issue of compliance of Section 50 and
57 of the NDPS Act.
(iii) Learned Public Prosecutor has referred to the provisions of
Section 52, 52-A, 55 and 57 of the NDPS Act and submitted that they are only
directory in nature, as has been held in the case of Babubhai Odhavji Patel and
others v. State of Gujarat reported in (2005) 8 SCC 725. It is pointed out that
the seizure was made on 24.09.2019 and it was produced on 27.09.2019. The
inventory has been exhibited as Exhibit P-10. As such, any allegation regarding
non-preparation of inventory or non-compliance of Section 52-A of the Act is
not tenable on facts or in law. As regards the contention of the appellants that
no local witnesses were examined as seizure list witnesses, learned Public
Prosecutor submits that PW 5 was an independent witness. He has, during his
examination, admitted his signatures as Exhibit P-1/3 and P-2/3 on search
memo and the seizure list respectively. Learned Public Prosecutor for the
respondent-State submits that the GD Entry No.21 dated 24.09.2019 has been
duly produced before the Court from the case diary and police records and can
be looked into by this Court under Section 172(3) of the Cr.P.C which is the
unfettered power of the Court. In this regard, he has referred to the decision of
the Apex Court in the case of Mukund Lal & Anr. v. Union of India & Anr.
reported in (1988) SCR Supl.(3) 524. Learned Public Prosecutor submits that
the case of Darshan Singh (Supra) relied upon by learned senior counsel for
the appellant S, is on a different set of facts where no information was reduced
in writing in terms of Section 42(1) of the NDPS Act and only an FIR was sent
to the superior authority. Learned Public Prosecutor has also distinguished the
decision of learned Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sri Mithu
Kumar and another (supra) by referring to the ratio rendered by the Apex
Court in the case of Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja (supra) where it has been
held that it is not necessary that the information required to be given under
Section 50 of the NDPS Act should be in a prescribed format or in writing.
14.
As such, learned Public Prosecutor has submitted that the offences
under Section 21(b)/25/29 of the NDPS Act are serious in nature and are socioeconomic offences where the legislature has prescribed strict provisions such as
Section 35 of the NDPS Act which provides that the Court shall presume the
existence of such mental state in a prosecution for an offence under the Act and
it is for the accused to prove that he had no such mental state with respect to the
act charged as an offence. As such, the findings of the learned Trial Court are
sound, weighty and after due appreciation of the evidence on record. The
investigating agency has complied with the mandatory procedures under
Section 42(1) and Section 50(1) of the NDPS Act, and there is no infirmity in
the prosecution case which warrants interference by this Court in appeal. The
accused persons were found to have entered into a conspiracy for selling of
illicit and contraband drugs for which the legislature has provided rigorous
imprisonment which may extend to 10(ten) years with fine of Rs.1,00,000/under Section 21(b) of the NDPS Act. The appellant S has also been punished
for allowing his premises to be used for commission of an offence under
Section 25 of NDPS Act. The other two appellants have been found to be in
criminal conspiracy to commit an offence punishable under Section 29 of the
NDPS Act and, therefore, have rightly been convicted for the charge of
conspiracy by the learned Trial Court. Learned Public Prosecutor submits that
the appeals are, therefore, fit to be dismissed.
15.
I have considered the submission of learned counsel for the parties
at length and gone through the materials and the evidence placed from the lower
court records. I have also perused the impugned judgment and the decisions
cited by the rival parties.
16.
At the outset, it is appropriate to refer to the offending provisions
under which the prosecution was lodged against the accused persons under
Section 21(b), 25 and 29 of the NDPS Act. In this regard, it is apposite to refer
to the provisions of Section 21(b), 25 and 29 of the NDPS Act:
“[21. Punishment for contravention in relation to manufactured drugs
and preparations.— Whoever, in contravention of any provision of this
Act or any rule or order made or condition of licence granted thereunder,
manufactures, possesses, sells, purchases, transports, imports inter-State,
exports inter-State or uses any manufactured drug or any preparation
containing any manufactured drug shall be punishable,—
(a)
*
*
*
(b) where the contravention involves quantity, lesser than commercial
quantity but greater than small quantity, with rigorous imprisonment for a
term which may extend to ten years, and with fine which may extend to
one lakh rupees;
(c)
*
*
*
[25. Punishment for allowing premises, etc., to be used for
commission of an offence.— Whoever, being the owner or occupier or
having the control or use of any house, room, enclosure, space, place,
animal or conveyance, knowingly permits it to be used for the commission
by any other person of an offence punishable under any provision of this
Act, shall be punishable with the punishment provided for that offence.]
29. Punishment for abetment and criminal conspiracy.—(1) Whoever
abets, or is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit, an offence
punishable under this Chapter, shall, whether such offence be or be not
committed in consequence of such abetment or in pursuance of such
criminal conspiracy, and notwithstanding anything contained in Section
116 of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), be punishable with the
punishment provided for the offence.
(2) A person abets, or is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit, an
offence, within the meaning of this section, who, in India, abets or is a
party to the criminal conspiracy to the commission of any act in a place
without and beyond India which—
(a) would constitute an offence if committed within India; or
(b) under the laws of such place, is an offence relating to narcotic drugs or
psychotropic substances having all the legal conditions required to
constitute it such an offence the same as or analogous to the legal
conditions required to constitute it an offence punishable under this
Chapter, if committed within India.”
The NDPS Act has been enacted with stringent provisions for
control and regulation of operations relating to narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances and to provide deterrent punishments. Since stringent provisions
have been provided under this Act, there is an obligation on the prosecution for
strict compliance of the mandatory provisions. The NDPS Act also provides for
presumption of culpable mental state under Section 35, where the Court shall
presume the existence of such mental state in any prosecution for an offence
under this Act which requires a culpable mental state of the accused. But it shall
be a defence for the accused to prove the fact the he had no such mental state
with respect of the Act charged as an offence in that prosecution. The
explanation shows that “culpable mental state” includes intention, motive,
knowledge of a fact and believe in, or reason to believe, a fact. For the purposes
of this section, a fact is said to be proved only when the Court believes it to
exist beyond reasonable doubt and not merely when its existence is established
by a preponderance of probability.
17.
As the prosecution story unfolds, PW 7-the informant, upon receipt
of secret telephonic information that few drug peddlers had assembled in the
house of the appellant S and were dealing for drug selling activities, made a
note in the GD Entry bearing No.21 dated 24.09.2019 and informed the Officerin-Charge, Ambassa PS and also to the higher authority, and got permission for
next course of action. The First Information Report at Column 3(c) also refers
to the GD Entry No.21 dated 24.09.2019 at 1305 hours. Similar reference of the
GD Entry is evident from the search and the seizure memo which are Exhibit P1, P-1/1, P-1/2, P-1/3, P-1/4, P-1/5 and Exhibit P-2, P-2/1, P-2/3. The
deposition of PW 7-the informant is worth reference at this stage as regards the
compliance of Section 42(1) of the NDPS Act :
“On 24.09.2019 I was posted as Sub-Inspector of Ambassa Police
Station.
On that day I lodged suo-moto complaint with the Officer-InCharge of Ambassa Police Station against the accused persons namely
Shri Sanjit Rudra Pal alias Sanjo, Shri Surendra Debbarma, Shri Prasanta
Deb and Shri Krishnacharan Deb Roy alias Maran for the commission of
offences punishable under Sections 22(b)/25/29 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
On 24.09.2019 at about 13.05 hours received a telephonic
information from reliable sources that few drug peddlers were assembled
in the house of accused Shri Sanjit Rudra Pal alias Sanjo of Betbagan
(Dolubari) and they were dealing with drugs in the locality.
Thereafter, we noted the matter in GD vide GD Entry No.21 dated
24.09.2019 and reduced the information in writing in the GD Entry Book
and the matter was informed to Officer-In-Charge of Ambassa Police
Station and to the higher authority and took permission for next course of
action.
Myself accompanied with SDPO, Ambassa, Executive Magistrate
and other Police Station staff went to Betbagan in the house of accused
Shri Sanjit Rudra Pal alias Sanjo and cordoned the house and collected
independent witnesses.
Before we conducted search in the house of the accused Shri Sanjit
Rudra Pal alias Sanjo, I prepared pre-search memo on the spot at about
13.50 hours in presence of the witnesses which bears my signature.
On identification the pre-search memo is marked as Exhibit P-1
and the signature of the witness on the pre-search memo is marked as
Exhibit P-1/5 respectively.
Thereafter, on suspicion the accused persons were offered to be
searched before any Gazetted Officer to which they answered in the
affirmative and accordingly I conducted search of all the accused persons
in presence of SDPO, Ambassa, Executive Magistrate, Ambassa and
independent witnesses and prior to that we have also got ourselves to be
searched by the independent witnesses.”
18.
The plea being raised regarding non-sending of the GD Entry at
this appellate stage, appears to be a novel argument, since no such objection or
question was raised to PW 7 during his cross-examination. The observation of
the Apex Court at para 13 & 14 of State of UP vs. Nahar Singh (Dead) & Ors;
(1998) 3 SCC 561 on this issue is extracted hereunder:
“13. It may be noted here that that part of the statement of PW 1
was not cross-examined by the accused. In the absence of crossexamination on the explanation of delay, the evidence of PW 1 remained
unchallenged and ought to have been believed by the High Court. Section
138 of the Evidence Act confers a valuable right of cross-examining the
witness tendered in evidence by the opposite party. The scope of that
provision is enlarged by Section 146 of the Evidence Act by allowing a
witness to be questioned:
(1) to test his veracity,
(2) to discover who he is and what is his position in life, or
(3) to shake his credit by injuring his character, although the
answer to such questions might tend directly or indirectly to incriminate
him or might expose or tend directly or indirectly to expose him to a
penalty or forfeiture.
14. The oft-quoted observation of Lord Herschell, L.C.
in Browne v. Dunn [(1893) 6 R 67] clearly elucidates the principle
underlying those provisions. It reads thus:
“I cannot help saying, that it seems to me to be absolutely essential
to the proper conduct of a cause, where it is intended to suggest that a
witness is not speaking the truth on a particular point, to direct his
attention to the fact by some questions put in cross-examination showing
that that imputation is intended to be made, and not to take his evidence
and pass it by as a matter altogether unchallenged, and then, when it is
impossible for him to explain, as perhaps he might have been able to do if
such questions had been put to him, the circumstances which, it is
suggested, indicate that the story he tells ought not to be believed, to
argue that he is a witness unworthy of credit. My Lords, I have always
understood that if you intend to impeach a witness, you are bound, whilst
he is in the box, to give an opportunity of making any explanation which is
open to him; and, as it seems to me, that is not only a rule of professional
practice in the conduct of a case, but it is essential to fair play and fair
dealing with witnesses.”
This aspect was unfortunately missed by the High Court when it
came to the conclusion that explanation for the delay is not at all
convincing. This reason is, therefore, far from convincing.”
19.
Ld. Public Prosecutor has also produced the Case Diary to show
that the same was sent by PW 7-the informant to the Officer-in-Charge,
Ambassa PS and also to the superior officer recording his reasons to believe.
Informant, being an SI of Police, is an Empowered Officer by the State
Government within the meaning of Section 42(1) of the Act. As such, the
contention of the appellants that the informant did not obtain a search warrant
for proceeding to search the premises of the appellant S, are not tenable as the
informant, being an Empowered Officer, has after recording the information
received and his reasons to believe, and after obtaining permission from the
superior authority including the Officer-in-Charge, Ambassa PS
had the
authority to proceed for search. The decision in the case of Darshan Singh
(supra) relied upon by learned senior counsel for the appellant S is not
applicable to the facts of the instant case, as the facts of the said case show that
no such information was recorded in writing by the informant; rather only the
copy of the FIR was sent to the superior officers. As such, the contention of the
appellants, that the mandatory requirement under Section 42(1) of the NDPS
Act has not been complied, does not merit acceptance.
The appellants have also alleged non-compliance of Section 50(1)
of the Act regarding their right to be informed and searched before a gazetted
officer. In this regard, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
requirement of obtaining consent should be in writing or in a format by striking
out the relevant particular. They have also relied upon the judgment of the
learned Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sri Mithu Kumar (supra).
However, this issue is no longer res integra in view of Constitution Bench
decision of the Apex Court in the case of Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja (supra).
Paragraphs 23 to 27 and 29 of the decision are extracted hereunder:
“23. In the above background, we shall now advert to the
controversy at hand. For this purpose, it would be necessary to recapitulate
the conclusions, arrived at by the Constitution Bench in Baldev Singh case
[(1999) 6 SCC 172 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] . We are concerned with the
following conclusions: (SCC pp. 208-10, para 57)
“(1) That when an empowered officer or a duly authorised
officer acting on prior information is about to search a person, it is
imperative for him to inform the person concerned of his right
under sub-section (1) of Section 50 of being taken to the nearest
gazetted officer or the nearest Magistrate for making the search.
However, such information may not necessarily be in writing.
(2) That failure to inform the person concerned about the
existence of his right to be searched before a gazetted officer or a
Magistrate would cause prejudice to an accused.
(3) That a search made by an empowered officer, on prior
information, without informing the person of his right that if he so
requires, he shall be taken before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate
for search and in case he so opts, failure to conduct his search
before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate, may not vitiate the trial
but would render the recovery of the illicit article suspect and
vitiate the conviction and sentence of an accused, where the
conviction has been recorded only on the basis of the possession of
the illicit article, recovered from his person, during a search
conducted in violation of the provisions of Section 50 of the Act.
*
*
*
(5) That whether or not the safeguards provided in Section
50 have been duly observed would have to be determined by the
court on the basis of the evidence led at the trial. Finding on that
issue, one way or the other, would be relevant for recording an
order of conviction or acquittal. Without giving an opportunity to
the prosecution to establish, at the trial, that the provisions of
Section 50 and, particularly, the safeguards provided therein were
duly complied with, it would not be permissible to cut short a
criminal trial.
(6) That in the context in which the protection has been
incorporated in Section 50 for the benefit of the person intended to
be searched, we do not express any opinion whether the provisions
of Section 50 are mandatory or directory, but hold that failure to
inform the person concerned of his right as emanating from subsection (1) of Section 50, may render the recovery of the
contraband suspect and the conviction and sentence of an accused
bad and unsustainable in law.
(7) That an illicit article seized from the person of an
accused during search conducted in violation of the safeguards
provided in Section 50 of the Act cannot be used as evidence of
proof of unlawful possession of the contraband on the accused
though any other material recovered during that search may be
relied upon by the prosecution, in other proceedings, against an
accused, notwithstanding the recovery of that material during an
illegal search.”
24. Although the Constitution Bench in Baldev Singh case [(1999)
6 SCC 172 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] did not decide in absolute terms the
question whether or not Section 50 of the NDPS Act was directory or
mandatory yet it was held that provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 50
make it imperative for the empowered officer to “inform” the person
concerned (suspect) about the existence of his right that if he so requires,
he shall be searched before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate; failure to
“inform” the suspect about the existence of his said right would cause
prejudice to him, and in case he so opts, failure to conduct his search
before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate, may not vitiate the trial but
would render the recovery of the illicit article suspect and vitiate the
conviction and sentence of an accused, where the conviction has been
recorded only on the basis of the possession of the illicit article, recovered
from the person during a search conducted in violation of the provisions of
Section 50 of the NDPS Act. The Court also noted that it was not
necessary that the information required to be given under Section 50
should be in a prescribed form or in writing but it was mandatory that the
suspect was made aware of the existence of his right to be searched before
a gazetted officer or a Magistrate, if so required by him. We respectfully
concur with these conclusions. Any other interpretation of the provision
would make the valuable right conferred on the suspect illusory and a
farce.
25. As noted above, sub-sections (5) and (6) were inserted in
Section 50 by Act 9 of 2001. It is pertinent to note that although by the
insertion of the said two sub-sections, the rigour of strict procedural
requirement is sought to be diluted under the circumstances mentioned in
the sub-sections viz. when the authorised officer has reason to believe that
any delay in search of the person is fraught with the possibility of the
person to be searched parting with possession of any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance, etc., or article or document, he may proceed to
search the person instead of taking him to the nearest gazetted officer or
Magistrate. However, even in such cases a safeguard against any arbitrary
use of power has been provided under sub-section (6). Under the said subsection, the empowered officer is obliged to send a copy of the reasons, so
recorded, to his immediate official superior within seventy-two hours of
the search. In our opinion, the insertion of these two sub-sections does not
obliterates the mandate of sub-section (1) of Section 50 to inform the
person, to be searched, of his right to be taken before a gazetted officer or
a Magistrate.
26. The object and the effect of insertion of sub-sections (5) and
(6) were considered by a Constitution Bench of this Court, of which one of
us (D.K. Jain, J.) was a member, in Karnail Singh v. State of Haryana
[(2009) 8 SCC 539 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 887] . Although in the said
decision the Court did observe that by virtue of insertion of sub-sections
(5) and (6), the mandate given in Baldev Singh case [(1999) 6 SCC 172 :
1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] is diluted but the Court also opined that it cannot be
said that by the said insertion, the protection or safeguards given to the
suspect have been taken away completely. The Court observed: (Karnail
Singh case [(2009) 8 SCC 539 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 887] , SCC p. 553,
para 31)
“31. … Through this amendment the strict procedural
requirement as mandated by Baldev Singh case [(1999) 6 SCC 172
: 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] was avoided as relaxation and fixing of the
reasonable time to send the record to the superior official as well as
exercise of Section 100 CrPC was included by the legislature. The
effect conferred upon the previously mandated strict compliance
with Section 50 by Baldev Singh case [(1999) 6 SCC 172 : 1999
SCC (Cri) 1080] was that the procedural requirements which may
have handicapped an emergency requirement of search and seizure
and give the suspect a chance to escape were made directory based
on the reasonableness of such emergency situation. Though it
cannot be said that the protection or safeguard given to the
suspects have been taken away completely but certain flexibility in
the procedural norms were adopted only to balance an urgent
situation. As a consequence the mandate given in Baldev Singh
case [(1999) 6 SCC 172 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] is diluted.”
27. It can, thus, be seen that apart from the fact that in Karnail
Singh [(2009) 8 SCC 539 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 887] , the issue was
regarding the scope and applicability of Section 42 of the NDPS Act in the
matter of conducting search, seizure and arrest without warrant or
authorisation, the said decision does not depart from the dictum laid down
in Baldev Singh case [(1999) 6 SCC 172 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] insofar
as the obligation of the empowered officer to inform the suspect of his
right enshrined in sub-section (1) of Section 50 of the NDPS Act is
concerned. It is also plain from the said paragraph that the flexibility in
procedural requirements in terms of the two newly inserted sub-sections
can be resorted to only in emergent and urgent situations, contemplated in
the provision, and not as a matter of course. Additionally, sub-section (6)
of Section 50 of the NDPS Act makes it imperative and obligatory on the
authorised officer to send a copy of the reasons recorded by him for his
belief in terms of sub-section (5), to his immediate superior officer, within
the stipulated time, which exercise would again be subjected to judicial
scrutiny during the course of trial.
29. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the firm opinion
that the object with which the right under Section 50(1) of the NDPS Act,
by way of a safeguard, has been conferred on the suspect viz. to check the
misuse of power, to avoid harm to innocent persons and to minimise the
allegations of planting or foisting of false cases by the law enforcement
agencies, it would be imperative on the part of the empowered officer to
apprise the person intended to be searched of his right to be searched
before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate. We have no hesitation in holding
that insofar as the obligation of the authorised officer under sub-section
(1) of Section 50 of the NDPS Act is concerned, it is mandatory and
requires strict compliance. Failure to comply with the provision would
render the recovery of the illicit article suspect and vitiate the conviction if
the same is recorded only on the basis of the recovery of the illicit article
from the person of the accused during such search. Thereafter, the suspect
may or may not choose to exercise the right provided to him under the said
provision.”
20.
In the present case, both the PW 1-SDPO, Ambassa- and PW 2-
DCM, Ambassa, a gazetted officer, were present at the time of seizure. The
accused persons have given verbal consent to be searched. No dispute has been
raised by the accused persons under Section 313 of Cr.P.C that they were not
informed of the right to be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer. No
such question was raised before PW 1 and PW 2 in their cross-examination. In
this regard, learned Public Prosecutor for the State has rightly relied upon
paragraph 15 of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Prabha Shankar
Dubey (supra) which is directly on the issue of compliance of Section 50 and 57
of the NDPS Act and is extracted hereunder:
“15. Additionally, it may also be noticed that while giving statement under
Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “the
Code”), the accused did not say that he was unaware of his rights or that he
was misled on that account in any manner. On the contrary, in general and
vague manner it was only said that he did not know or he had no idea of
the allegations. Though that by itself is not sufficient to convict the
accused in view of the procedural safeguards required to be observed by
compliance with the requirements of Section 50, yet that is of some
relevance in appreciating the grievance, now sought to be ventilated. There
is no infirmity in the impugned judgment to warrant interference. The
appeals are accordingly dismissed.”
As such, this Court, upon consideration of the materials on record
and the evidence adduced by the prosecution, is of the considered view that the
prosecution had followed the mandatory requirement of informing the accused
persons of their right to be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer and
they gave their verbal consent to be searched whereafter the search was
undertaken in the presence of the SDPO, Ambassa and PW 2-DCM, Ambassa ,
a gazetted officer. As such, the instant ground of challenge also does not appeal
to the Court.
21.
Appellants have taken a plea that there was a 3(three) day gap in
producing the seized article which is not in conformity with Section 52-A and
57 of the NDPS Act. In this regard, it is apposite to refer to the provisions of
Section 52-A, 55 and 57 of the Act :
“[52-A. Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances.—[(1) The Central Government may, having regard to the
hazardous nature, vulnerability to theft, substitution, constraint of proper
storage space or any other relevant consideration, in respect of any
narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify such narcotic
drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or conveyance or
class of narcotic drugs, class of psychotropic substances, class of
controlled substances or conveyances, which shall, as soon as may be after
their seizure, be disposed of by such officer and in such manner as that
Government may, from time to time, determine after following the
procedure hereinafter specified.]
(2) Where any [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyances] has been seized and forwarded to the officerin-charge of the nearest police station or to the officer empowered under
Section 53, the officer referred to in sub-section (1) shall prepare an
inventory of such [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyances] containing such details relating to their
description, quality, quantity, mode of packing, marks, numbers or such
other identifying particulars of the [narcotic drugs, psychotropic
substances, controlled substances or conveyances] or the packing in which
they are packed, country of origin and other particulars as the officer
referred to in sub-section (1) may consider relevant to the identity of the
[narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] in any proceedings under this Act and make an application
to any Magistrate for the purpose of—
(a) certifying the correctness of the inventory so prepared; or
(b) taking, in the presence of such magistrate, photographs of [such
drugs, substances or conveyances] and certifying such photographs as
true; or
(c) allowing to draw representative samples of such drugs or
substances, in the presence of such magistrate and certifying the
correctness of any list of samples so drawn.
(3) Where an application is made under sub-section (2), the
Magistrate shall, as soon as may be, allow the application.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 (1 of 1972) or the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of
1974), every court trying an offence under this Act, shall treat the
inventory, the photographs of [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances,
controlled substances or conveyances] and any list of samples drawn
under sub- section (2) and certified by the Magistrate, as primary evidence
in respect of such offence.]
55. Police to take charge of articles seized and delivered.—An
officer-in-charge of a police station shall take charge of and keep in safe
custody, pending the orders of the Magistrate, all articles seized under this
Act within the local area of that police station and which may be delivered
to him, and shall allow any officer who may accompany such articles to
the police station or who may be deputed for the purpose, to affix his seal
to such articles or to take samples of and from them and all samples so
taken shall also be sealed with a seal of the officer-in-charge of the police
station.
57. Report of arrest and seizure.—Whenever any person makes
any arrest or seizure under this Act, he shall, within forty-eight hours next
after such arrest or seizure, make a full report of all the particulars of such
arrest or seizure to his immediate official superior.”
The Apex Court has, in case of State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh
reported in (1994) 3 SCC 299 and followed in Babubhai Odhavji Patel (supra)
held that the provisions of Section 52 and 57, which deals with the steps to be
taken by the officers after making arrest or seizure, are themselves not
mandatory. If there is non-compliance or lapses like delay, the same has to be
examined to see whether any prejudice has been caused to the accused and such
failure will have a bearing on appreciation of evidence regarding arrest or
seizure as well as merits of the case.
The appellants have not been able to
show that any prejudice has been caused to them on account of the delay of 3
days in producing the seized articles before the learned Magistrate.
22.
Though the appellants have taken a plea that the inventory was not
prepared, but Exhibit P-10 is the inventory of the seized articles and is available
on the lower court records. The seizure was made on 24.09.2019, then the
reports were handed over to the Investigating Officer and it was produced
within 3(three) days on 27.09.2019 before the learned Magistrate. As such, the
allegation of gap in the production of seized articles and delay is not such,
which affects the prosecution case as to doubt its veracity. Moreover, as has
been held by the Apex Court, compliance of these provisions is only directory
in nature.
23.
Though learned counsel for the appellants have placed the
evidence of PW 5 and PW 6, who were the seizure list witnesses, to advance the
proposition that these witnesses are not of local area and do not fulfil the
conditions under Section 100(4) of Cr.P.C, and that the seizure was not made in
their presence; but both the witnesses have affirmed their signature on the
search memo and seizure list which are Exhibit P-1/1, P-1/2, P-1/3, P-1/4, P-1/5
and Exhibit P-2/1, P-2/2, P-2/3 respectively. Moreover, the testimonies of other
prosecution witnesses, such as PW 1, PW 2 and PW 7 testimonies corroborate
the factum of search and seizure. As such, the absence of local witness during
the search and seizure would not render the seizure vitiated. Moreover, PW 1 is
the SDPO of Ambassa and PW 2 is the DCM, Ambassa. As such, the
statements of PW 5 and PW 6, in their cross-examination, alone cannot
discredit the factum of search and seizure made in presence of the accused
persons and other prosecution witnesses and moreover, the accused persons
have also recorded their signatures on the search and seizure memo. As the
PW1 being the empowered officer had conducted the search after recording his
reasons to believe based on the secret information and obtained prior
permission of the superior office in terms of Section 42(1) of the Act, there was
no requirement or necessity to obtain a search warrant before proceeding to
search and seize the contraband.
24.
Taking into regard all these material evidence on record, this Court
is of the firm view that the prosecution has been able to establish the charges
beyond reasonable doubt. The learned Trial Court has, after due consideration
of the evidence on record, rightly convicted the appellant S for the charges
under Section 21(b)/25/29 of the NDPS Act and the other two appellants
namely K and P for the charges under Section 29 of the NDPS Act. As such, no
grounds for interference are made out on the part of the appellants herein.
25.
The appeals, being devoid of merit, are dismissed. Send down the
LCRs forthwith.
26.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
signed by MUNNA SAHA
Pijush/ MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2023.10.07 14:38:15 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review