Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.893 of 2022
Sri Pranab Deb, son of Sri Pranesh Deb, Katlamara, P.O. Simna, P.S. Sidhai
Mohanpur, District- West Tripura, Pin-799212.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura represented by Secretary cum Commissioner,
Education Department, Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. Director of School Education, Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, Pin799001.
3. The Headmaster, Ishanpur Higher Secondary School, Ishanpur, P.O. Sidhai,
District- West Tripura, Pin-799212.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. A.L, Saha, Advocate,
Mr. K. Nandi, Advocate,
Mr. Soham Paul, Advocate,
Mr. S. Bhowmik, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General,
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
Mrs. Ayantika Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Date of hearing and judgment : 26th September, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. A.L, Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and also heard Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General appearing
for the State-respondents.
[2]
This Full Bench has been constituted in view of the reference
made by one of us (Arindam Lodh, J) in the order dated 30.05.2023 in
WP(C) No.893 of 2022. Since learned counsel for the petitioner herein relied
upon a judgment passed in WP(C) No.334 of 2021, the learned Writ Court
after respectfully disagreeing with the decision rendered in WP(C) No.334
of 2021 by one of us (T. Amarnath Goud, J) referred the matter before
Hon‟ble the Chief Justice of this Court to constitute an appropriate Bench to
decide the matter.
[3]
Hon‟ble the Chief Justice of this Court in exercise of the
residuary powers under Rule 15 of Chapter V of the High Court of Tripura
Rules, 2023 and all powers vested in him, therefore, has constituted a Full
Bench to hear the matter also taking into consideration that at present this
Court is functioning with a strength of 3 Judges only out of the sanctioned
strength of 5.
[4]
The appointees to the post of teacher under the advertisements
of 2002, 2006 and 2009 appear to revive the issue relating to the termination
of their employments even after the issue has attained finality by virtue of
the judgment rendered by a learned Division Bench of this Court in the case
of Tanmoy Nath and others versus State of Tripura and others reported in
(2014) 2 TLR 731 and other analogous matters and affirmed by the Apex
Court in its judgment dated 29.03.2017 in SLP(C) Nos.18993-19049/2014
and other analogous matters.
[5]
Briefly stated the entire selection process to the post of teachers
(Undergraduate, Graduate and Postgraduate) under the advertisements of
2002, 2006 and 2009 were in question before this Court in the case of
Tanmoy Nath and others (supra) on, inter alia, a number of grounds, the
main ground being the legality and vires of the Revised Employment Policy,
2003 under which the selection process had been undertaken. A perusal of
the paragraphs 4 to 8 of the judgment in case of Tanmoy Nath and others
(supra) would show that the appointment of all the 10,323 teachers i.e.
Undergraduate, Graduate and Postgraduate were under question before this
Court in case of Tanmoy Nath and others (supra). The learned Division
Bench of this Court after comprehensively dealing with the matter and the
rival contentions of the parties, inter alia, set aside the entire selection
process by declaring the Revised Employment Policy of 2003 as
unconstitutional. Paragraphs 121 to 129 of the judgment containing the
operative direction are extracted hereunder:
“121. It has been urged that even if we set aside the selections,
our judgment should be prospective in nature. It has also been urged by
Mr. Sankar Deb, learned Sr. Counsel for the petitioners, that those portions
of the policy which are bad may be severed and those portions which can
be upheld may be retained, but the appointments already made need not be
disturbed. Reliance has been placed on the judgments of the Apex Court in
A.P. Public Service Commission v. K. Sudharshan Reddy and others,
(2006) 5 SCC 505, AIR 1957 SC 628, (2000) 7 SCC 719. These judgments
have no applicability to the cases in hand and we are not all in agreement
with this submission. The selections have been totally unfair. The
selections have not been made in a transparent manner. The citizens of this
country have not been treated equally. Most of the clauses of the policy are
illegal and unconstitutional. The entire policy is bad because it gives no
guidelines and, therefore, the entire selection will have to be, must be and
is accordingly set aside.
122. Though we have set aside the selections, we are
concerned with the education of the small children who are innocent and
have no concern with the illegalities of the selection. We, therefore, direct
that the teachers whose selections have been set aside shall continue to
function in their present place of postings till 31-12-2014, i.e. the end of
the academic session of this year.
123. The State on or before 31-12-2014 must complete a
fresh process of selection of teachers in all categories. In view of the
discussions held above, we direct that the State should frame a new
Employment Policy within two months from today and shall carry
out selections in accordance with the fresh policy as early as possible
and not later than 31-12-2014.
124. It is not for this Court to frame guidelines but if the
State does not frame any guidelines, then the State shall follow the
following directions while making selections. If the State frames its
own guidelines, it must ensure that they are in tune with the law laid
down by the Apex Court as discussed by us above and in light of the
directions given hereinafter.
(i) Fresh applications shall be invited for all the posts;
(ii) Even those who have applied earlier will have to apply
again though they may be given relaxation in age and no fees may be
charged from them;
(iii) The State shall clearly set out the number of posts in
each category of teachers;
(iv) In case of undergraduate teachers, the State if it is so
advised may divide the posts sub-division wise so that the primary
school teachers are local people as far as possible;
(v) In respect of graduate teachers, the State may divide the
posts district wise;
(vi) In case of postgraduate teachers, there will be no zone
wise division of posts;
(vii) In case the State decides to make division of posts
region wise, as indicate hereinabove, then the candidates must be
asked to apply only for one region of their choice. It should also be
specified in the advertisements that once a candidate applies under
any category then he shall not be permitted to change his category
and the roll number should be allocated in such a fashion that the
category and region of each candidate is clearly depicted in the roll
number itself.
(viii) For each category of teachers, a written test preferably
an objective (MCQ) test must be held;
(ix) This test should be conducted by an independent body
like the Tripura Public Service Commission or the Tripura Central
University;
(x) The test should be multiple choice question and the
answer sheet should be checked through a computer keeping in view
the large number of candidates involved;
(xi) At least 50% of the total marks shall be awarded on the
basis of the performance in the written test, i.e. in case a candidate
obtains 70 marks out of 100 in a written test, 35 marks out of 50
shall be awarded to him towards the total assessment;
(xii) In the case of Post Graduate Teachers another 20 marks
shall be awarded for the marks received in the qualifying course, i.e.
B.A./B.Sc./B.Com (Honours) or post-graduation, i.e. M.A./M.Sc./
M.Com. Therefore, if a candidate has obtained 50% marks in the
qualifying course, he would get 10 out of 20 under this head. A
candidate, who has higher qualifications, for example he is an Hons.
Graduate and has also done his post-graduation or has done his postgraduation in 2(two) subjects, then he may be awarded 5 more.
Similarly 5 more marks shall be awarded to those candidates who
have obtained Ph. D. or similar qualifications. Since consistency has
an important role, 5 marks each i.e. 10 marks shall be awarded for
the marks obtained in Madhyamik and Higher Secondary
examination respectively. Therefore, if a candidate has 40% marks in
Madhyamik he will get 2 out of 5 and if he has 60% marks in Higher
Secondary he will get 3 marks. Out of the remaining 10 marks which
shall be awarded at the time of interview 5 marks shall be earmarked
for extra-curricular activities i.e. sports, music, drama or NCC etc.
but the State must lay down clear-cut guidelines as to how these
marks have to be allotted. Therefore, the interview board will have
the liberty to award 5 marks on the basis of oral interview.
(xiii). In case of Graduate Teachers, 50% marks shall be allocated
for the performance in the written test, 20% marks for the marks
obtained in the qualifying course i.e. Graduation, 5 marks on the
basis of marks obtained in Higher Secondary and 5 marks for the
marks obtained in Madhyamik and 10 marks shall be awarded on the
basis of percentage of marks for candidates when done post graduate.
Similarly, Out of the remaining 10 marks which shall be awarded at
the time of interview 5 marks shall be earmarked for extra-curricular
activities i.e. sports, music, drama or NCC etc. and 5 for
performance in interview.
(xiv). For Under Graduate Teachers 50% shall be allocated for
performance in the written test, 10 marks for the marks obtained in
Madhyamik, 10 marks for the marks obtained in Higher Secondary
and 15 marks shall be awarded to those candidates who are qualified
as per the NET guidelines i.e. they have passed TET or B. Ed or
2(two) years Diploma in Teaching. 5 Marks for higher qualifications.
Out of the remaining 10 marks which shall be awarded at the time of
interview 5 marks shall be earmarked for extra-curricular activities
i.e. sports, music, drama or NCC etc. and 5 for performance in
interview.
(xv). We may make it clear that 50% seats shall be filled in only
on the basis of merit. In the State of Tripura the reservation is as
follows :
Scheduled Tribe – 31%
Scheduled Caste – 17%
General Category - 52%
Therefore, if there are 1000 posts in a particular category of
„Teachers‟ at least 165 Scheduled Tribe candidates should be
selected on the basis of merit amongst Scheduled Tribes, 85
candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes be selected on the basis of
merit drawn out amongst the Scheduled Caste category and 260 out
of the unreserved/general category shall be appointed strictly on the
basis of merit drawn out as above.
(xvi). The State must also ensure that in accordance with the
Persons with Disability Act and the law laid down by the Apex Court
in a number of cases including Union of India and Anr. Vs. National
Federation of the Blind and Ors., [(2013)10 SCC 772] adequate
numbers of posts are reserved for persons with disabilities.
(xvii). In case the States so desires, it may reserve a small
percentage of posts for Ex-servicemen or wards of those who have
died fighting for the Country or have been severely disabled.
However, the reservation under this head shall be horizontal and not
above 5%. The number of posts in this category should also be
clearly defined.
(xviii). The State may, if it so desires, also out of this 50% give
some weightage to persons who have been waiting for the
appointment for a long time. Therefore, there can be additional 20
marks to be awarded for seniority i.e. 1 mark for each year of
seniority subject to a maximum of 20 marks. Similarly, the State may
also give some weightage to members of the needy families out of
these 50% posts and may allot 10 marks for those persons who
belonged to the needy category. Therefore, the remaining 50% of
posts the marking may be out of 130 i.e. 20 marks for seniority and
10 marks for need.
(xix). Effectively, those selected only on the basis of the merit shall
be graded out of a maximum of 100 marks but for those who are
given benefit of seniority and/or belonging to a poor family the
marking will be out of 130 marks. It is, however, made clear that the
State at the time of framing of the policy shall also lay down clearcut guidelines how the needy families are to be identified. (i) The
identification must be done on clearly set out criteria i.e. to say the
upper income limit should be clearly defined. (ii) It should be clearly
stated that no member of the family should be in
government/organized employment. (iii) It should be clearly stated
that the land of the family should be below a certain area. We also
make it clear that any certificate given to a person said to be needy
can be challenged by the unsuccessful candidates if they feel that this
certificate has been wrongly given.
125. We would also like to make it clear that other than the
benefits indicated by us above there can be no reservation/preference
on the basis of age. There shall be no preference to dependent
government servants or retired government employee or retrenched
employees etc. There can be no reservation for linguistic or religious
minorities or on area wise basis. It is further made clear that if the
persons who are selected in the previous selection are again selected
then the service rendered by them earlier shall be counted for the
purpose of seniority, pension and all other purposes.
126. We may make it clear that the benefit to the
candidates on the ground of being needy shall not be granted on the
basis of the BPL certificates since we have found that there are no
guidelines for issuing the BPL certificates. Other guidelines can also
be laid down so that the needy can be identified properly.
127. Since we have set aside the revised employment
policy which applies to a large category of posts and not merely to
teachers, we would like to make it clear that our judgment shall be
prospective in nature and shall not affect the appointments already
made unless the said appointments are already under challenge
before the Court on the ground that the employment policy is illegal.
128. We are also of the considered view that in future the
State should not wait for years on end to make the recruitments. In
each year before 31st July the State shall identify the number of
posts which shall fall vacant in every category of teachers on account
of retirements, creation of new posts etc. in the next calendar year.
To this 10 to 20% may be added as the posts for anticipated and
unforeseen vacancies which may occur due to resignation or death of
serving teachers. The test for these posts should be held every year
and Select List should be prepared by 31st December of every year
so that when the new academic year starts in January these teachers
are selected and no school is without a teacher at any given time.
While issuing this direction we are taking support from the judgment
of the Apex Court in Malik Mazhar Sultan and Anr. Vs. U.P Public
Service Commission and Ors., [2008 (17) SCC 703] wherein the
Apex Court passed time bound directions for recruitment of civil
judges. In our opinion, the requirement of adequate number of
teachers is even more important than that of Judges and no post of
teacher shall remain vacant. The „Select List‟ shall be valid for a
period of 1 or 2 years but before the validity of the „Select List‟
comes to an end the State must ensure that fresh test is carried out
and fresh selection is made.
129. All the writ petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid
terms. No order as to costs.”
[6]
The State and certain aggrieved writ petitioners went in appeal
before the Apex Court. As an interim relief, the operative directions at
paragraph 123 were, however, stayed by the Apex Court. By the impugned
judgment dated 29.03.2017, the Apex Court dismissed the Special Leave
Petitions, with certain modifications in paragraph 123 of the impugned
judgment. The judgment dated 29.03.2017 is quoted hereinbelow:
“We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record. We do not find any ground to interfere with the impugned
order. We do not find any ground to interfere with the impugned
order. While setting aside the selections, the High Court in Para 123
of the impugned order observed:
“123. The State on or before 31.12.2014 must complete a
fresh process of selection of teachers in all categories. In view of the
discussions held above, we direct that the State should frame a new
Employment Policy within two months from today and shall carry
out selections in accordance with the fresh policy as early as possible
and not later than 31.12.2014.”
While issuing notice in the present matters this Court by its
order dated 04.08.2014 stayed the directions contained in aforesaid
para 123 of the impugned order.
Since we do not find any ground to interfere with the
impugned order, the directions in para 123 now required to be
suitably modified. We, therefore, direct :
(a) New Employment Policy should be framed by the State by
30th April, 2017 if not already framed and advertisements for filling
up the vacancies may be issued latest by 31st May, 2017.
(b) The fresh selection process be completed on or before 31st
December, 2017 and till the fresh process is completed, the teachers
already appointed shall continue.
(c) The candidates who participated in the selection process
pursuant to the advertisements in question, whether selected or not,
will be allowed to participate in the fresh selection process by
relaxing their age but subject to their having necessary qualifications.
(d) The qualifications in the case of teachers governed by the
provisions of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009 shall be in conformity with the relevant
statutory provisions of the said Act.
(e) The qualifications of teachers employed for Classes IA
and above shall be strictly in compliance with the relevant provisions
concerning such appointments.
Subject to the aforesaid modifications, the view taken by the
High Court in the impugned order is affirmed and the special leave
petitions are dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
[7]
By virtue of the judgment dated 29.03.2017 the services of all
those teachers including the petitioner who was one of the selectees under
the same recruitment exercise as a Graduate teacher were terminated by
order dated 31.12.2017. The order of termination of the present petitioner is
at Annexure-5 which reads as under:
“Government of Tripura
Directorate of Secondary Education
Estt.(N.G.) Section
No.F.1(1-43)-SE/E[NG]/2017[Vol-II]
Dated, Agartala, the 23.12.2017
MEMORANDUM
Whereas, Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India vide order dated
23.03.2017 in SLP No.18993-19049/2014 has affirmed the order of
the Hon‟ble High Court of Tripura dated 07.05.2014 setting aside the
selection of teachers and directed amongst others in para (b) of the
said order that the fresh selection process to be completed on or
before 31.12.2017 and till such process is completed, the teachers
already appointed shall continue.
And
Whereas, Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in order dated 14.12.2017
in the aforesaid connected cases, directed that on 31st December,
2017, the tenure of the incumbents will come to an end. Thereafter,
their appointment will only for six months on ad-hoc basis on such
fresh terms as the State Government may impose and further
observed that “Thereafter, none of the said incumbents will
continue.”
And
In compliance of the aforesaid order dated 29.03.2017 and order
dated 14.12.2017 of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India, the service
tenure of the teachers, who were appointed as Graduate Teachers as
in the list enclosed at Annexure-A whose selection has been set
aside, shall come to an end on 31st December, 2017.
And
Now, therefore, in compliance of the order dated 14.12.2017, the
teachers whose names are listed at Annexure-A are hereby appointed
as Graduate Teachers on ad-hoc basis w.e.f. 01.01.2018 for a period
of 6 months on existing pay scale plus other allowances and
entitlements admissible as per rules.
The Graduate Teachers so appointed on ad-hoc basis will work in
their present place of posting.
S/d
(U.K. Chakma)
Director of Secondary Education,
Tripura.”
[8]
By virtue of the interim orders passed by the Apex Court on the
request of the State of Tripura, the teachers whose services were terminated
were appointed as Graduate teachers on ad-hoc basis with effect from
01.01.2018 for a period of 6 months which continued up to 31.03.2020 by
virtue of the order dated 01.11.2018 passed by the Apex Court in Contempt
Petition (Civil) No.1706 of 2017 in SLP(C) No. 18993-19049/2014 with
Misc. Applications and other connected matters. The order dated 01.11.2018
is also extracted hereunder for better appreciation.
“………. Having considered the matter, we are of the view that at
this stage, we ought to permit the State of Tripura to continue to
avail of the services of the terminated teachers until the end of the
academic session 2020, meaning the academic session 2019-2020.
The above direction has been issued in the peculiar facts of the case
and the circumstances which have confronted the State of Tripura
and above all the need to functioning of teaching activities in schools
in the State of Tripura remains unaffected……”
[9]
As per the above interim arrangement, these teachers including
the petitioner continued on ad-hoc basis till 31.03.2020. By the impugned
order dated 31.03.2020 (Annexure-11/A) the petitioner was informed that
his ad-hoc services were terminated with effect from 31.03.2020. Petitioner
has thereafter approached this Court in the present writ petition preferred on
10.10.2022 assailing the termination letter dated 23.12.2017 (Annexure-5)
and the termination letter dated 31.03.2020 (Annexure-11/A) issued by the
Directorate of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura. In order to
complete the narrative, it would also be proper to refer to another batch of
litigation on the same issue initiated by some of the teachers in case of Bijoy
Krishna Saha and others versus State of Tripura [WP(C) No.1040 of 2019]
and other connected writ petitions. In the said batch of writ petitions, the
petitioners though were beneficiaries of the same appointment process as
Undergraduate/Graduate/Postgraduate teachers claimed to be not bound by
the decision rendered in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) as affirmed by the
Apex Court, inter alia, contending that (a) those petitioners were appointed
in March, 2010 before which date they had already acquired the eligibility in
terms of notification issued by the State of Tripura as required under the
Provisions of the National Council for Teacher Education Act, 1993; (b) in
terms of the selection process undertaken by the State, the petitioners were
appointed as Graduate teachers; (c) The petitioners were never ever
informed of the pendency of any proceedings or impleaded as parties and
are, therefore, not bound by the decision dated 07.05.2014 rendered in the
case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) and (d) that their representations stood
summarily rejected.
[10]
The learned Division Bench of this Court of which one of us
(Arindam Lodh, J) was a member dismissed the writ petitions holding that
those bunch of writ petitions were an abuse of the process of law and
speculative in nature. The aforesaid contentions raised by the petitioners in
the case of Bijoy Krishna Saha & others were also squarely dealt with in
the body of the judgment. The grounds of non-impleadment as parties and
non-issuance of notice to them were also discussed at paragraphs 18, 19 and
20. Those petitioners had also raised the issue relating to protection relying
upon paragraph 127 of the judgment of Tanmoy Nath (supra). That
contention was also dealt with at paragraphs 23 to 27 of the judgment dated
03.10.2019.
[11]
It also needs to be mentioned here that by order dated
06.02.2014 in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) notices were issued to all the
affected teachers through paper publication in the light of the principles
contained in Order I Rule 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC, for short).
The decision in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) was thus rendered in
respect of the entire selection process under the advertisements of 2002,
2006 and 2009 and conducted in terms of the new Revised Employment
Policy of 2003. The learned Division Bench in the case of Tanmoy Nath
(supra) found several illegalities and lack of proper guidelines in the Revised
Employment Policy which had resulted in blatant case of arbitrariness in the
selection process. It was therefore compelled to set aside the entire selection
process
undertaken
under
those
advertisements
relating
to
Undergraduate/Graduate/Postgraduate teachers.
[12]
When the termination of the ad-hoc services of some of the
teachers i.e. Sri Pradip Debbarma and two others in WP(C) 334 of 2021 by
the impugned order dated 31.03.2020 were brought before this Writ Court,
one of us (T. Amarnath Goud, J) after dealing with the rival contentions of
the parties found that the memorandum dated 31.03.2020 was not a speaking
order, rather an omnibus communication. Therefore, it was set aside with a
liberty to the respondents to pass a reasoned and specific order in the subject
matter relating to the petitioners. Petitioners, if aggrieved by the said
decision, were granted liberty to avail remedies under law. The State
preferred a Review Petition No.40 of 2023 against the said judgment which
was heard and decided by the Bench presided by one of us (T. Amarnath
Goud, J), inter alia, holding as under:
“6.
In view of the prevailing circumstances explained, the
clarification of the Order dated 03.05.2023 passed by this Court in
WP(C) No.334 of 2021 is given as under:i)
The said WP(C) No.334 of 2021 has been filed only by
three petitioners namely, 1. Shri Pradip Debbarma, 2. Moynal
Hossain and 3) Shri Kanai Lal Das.
ii)
This Court at Para-30 of the said order dated 03.05.2023
held as under:“30. According to this Court, the memorandum dated 31.03.2020
which have been issued by the respondents is not a speaking order
and it is an omnibus communication is set aside with a liberty to the
respondents to pass a reasoned and specific order in the subject
matter relating to the petitioners. If the petitioners are aggrieved by
the said decision, they can avail remedies under law”
In view of the above, it is clear that the said order passed is not in
“REM‟ but it is in „personam‟ confining the relief to the petitioners
of the said WP(C) No.334 of 2021 only and is not applicable to all
10,323 teachers.
iii) This Court has not granted any relief in favour of the writ
petitioners for providing them any appointment or to continue with
their services as teachers.
7.
Merely by setting aside the memorandum dated 31.03.2020
which was a non-speaking and omnibus communication, this Court
has granted liberty to the Government/respondents to issue a specific
and reasoned order to the petitioners and if aggrieved they would
assail the same in accordance with the law.
8.
In fact, no relief has been granted in favor of the writ
petitioners.
9.
With the above clarification, the present review petition is
accordingly closed. It is needless to observe that the Government is
at liberty to initiate steps against the concerned persons with its
investigating agencies for causing through media an unhealthy
atmosphere in society.
10.
Accordingly, with the above observation and direction, this
present review application stands closed.”
It was made clear that the Court had not granted any relief in
favour of the writ petitioners for providing them any appointment or to
continue with their services as teachers. This decision of Writ Court was
brought to the notice of the other Writ Court presided over by one of us
(Arindam Lodh, J) in the case of the present writ petitioner whereafter the
learned Court referred the matter to Hon‟ble the Chief Justice to constitute
an appropriate Bench to decide the reference. That is how the reference is
before us.
[13]
Mr. A.L. Saha, learned counsel for the petitioner has assailed
the impugned termination letters dated 23.12.2017 (Annexure-5) and
31.03.2020 (Annexure-11/A) inter alia on the following grounds:
(a) That the petitioner was not a party in the writ petitions
decided by this Court in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) and other
connected writ petitions dated 07.05.2014;
(b) That no notice was served upon the petitioner asking him to
submit his defence reply before the order of termination was passed. As
such, there is a violation of principles of natural justice. Learned counsel for
the petitioner has sought to rely upon the decision of the Apex Court in case
of Maneka Gandhi vrs. Union of India reported in AIR 1978 SC 597 in
support of his submission as regards requirement of compliance of principles
of natural justice as it entails adverse civil consequences.
(c) Learned counsel for the petitioner has also placed reliance
upon paragraph 127 of the judgment in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) in
order to submit that since petitioner was not a party in those writ petitions,
therefore, in view of the prospective overruling, the services of the petitioner
were saved. Learned counsel for the petitioner has, therefore, submitted that
the services of the petitioner have been terminated in violation of principles
of natural justice. Moreover, he was not a party or covered by the decision of
this Court in Tanmoy Nath (supra) or before the Apex Court where the
judgment was affirmed. The writ petition is not barred by delay as there is
no period of limitation for invoking writ jurisdiction. Moreover, his services
were continued till 31.03.2020. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also
referred to certain representations made and the applications for furnishing
information under RTI before the authorities of the State which have not
been heeded to. He has also referred to certain information obtained under
RTI from the Supreme Court Registry to the effect that the petitioner was
not a party in the SLP(C) No. 18993-19049/2014 before the Apex Court
arising out of the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra). In substance, it is the case of
the petitioner that the decision of Tanmoy Nath (supra) does not cover the
case of the petitioner and as such, his services could not have been
terminated without proper show-cause notice and without consideration of
his defence reply.
[14]
Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General has strongly opposed
the prayer. He submits that the petitioner has not been able to make out a
clear case on the basis of the pleadings of the writ petition that he was not
falling in the category of teachers i.e. Undergraduate, Graduate and
Postgraduate whose cases have been dealt with squarely at paragraphs 4 to 8
of the decision in Tanmoy Nath (supra). The writ petition is an abuse of the
process of law as petitioner has failed to show as to how his case is
distinguishable or segregated from rest of the teachers whose selection
process was set aside primarily on the ground that the Revised Employment
Policy of 2003 under which the recruitment exercise was undertaken under
advertisements of 2002, 2006 and 2009 were found to be arbitrary, illegal
and suffering from nepotism and favoritism. It is submitted that the decision
of Tanmoy Nath (supra) is a judgment in rem and no individual teacher can
claim to be excepted from its rigors which stands affirmed up to the Apex
Court. Petitioner can also not complain that no notice was served upon him
as vide order dated 06.02.2014 passed during the proceedings of the case of
Tanmoy Nath (supra), notices were issued to all such teachers through paper
publication in line with the principles contained under Order I Rule 8 of the
CPC. Learned Advocate General has also placed the Division Bench
judgment of this Court in case of Sri Bijoy Krishna Saha & others versus
The State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.1040 of 2019 where the same
contentions have been raised and squarely dealt with and answered by this
Court. It is submitted that the decision in Tanmoy Nath (supra) covers
10323 teachers. Petitioner is also one of them. As such, the plea of noncompliance of principles of natural justice or opportunity to show-cause does
not arise in the case of individual petitioner when the entire selection process
was set aside. Learned Advocate General has also sought to rely upon the
decisions which have already been referred to in the previous part of the
judgment.
[15]
We have given our anxious consideration to the rival
submissions of the parties. It needs to be mentioned at the outset that by
virtue of the judgment rendered in Review Petition No.40 of 2023 by one of
us (T. Amarnath Goud, J) it has been abundantly made clear that the Writ
Court had not granted any relief in favour of the writ petitioners for
providing them any appointment or to continue with their services as
teachers. The referral order dated 30.05.2023 passed in WP(C) No.893 of
2022 has elaborately referred to the judgments rendered by this Court in the
case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) dated 07.05.2014, Sri Bijoy Krishna Saha
and others dated 03.10.2019 and also the judgment of the Apex Court dated
29.03.2017 whereby the decision in Tanmoy Nath (supra) was affirmed with
certain modifications in paragraph 123 of the judgment in Tanmoy Nath.
However, since at the fag end of the order, the judgment passed in WP(C)
No.334 of 2021 of the coordinate Bench of the Writ Court was brought to
the notice of the learned Court, the matter was referred to Hon‟ble Chief
Justice to create Bench to decide the reference.
[16]
After hearing learned counsel for the parties at length and after
giving anxious consideration to the rival submissions of the parties and the
points raised, we are of the unanimous view that the issue of legality of the
appointments undertaken under advertisement of 2009 in terms of the
Revised Employment Policy of 2003 have attained finality by virtue of the
judgment rendered by the Apex Court dated 29.03.2017 whereby the
decision of the learned Division Bench of this Court dated 07.05.2014 in the
case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) has been affirmed. The relevant paragraphs of
the judgment in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) have already been quoted
hereinabove. The order of the Apex Court dated 29.03.2017 and the interim
order passed thereafter by virtue of which ad-hoc extensions were granted to
the teachers like the petitioner to continue till 31.03.2020 have also been
referred to hereinabove. The decision in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) is
a judgment in rem which operates as regards all the appointees, teachers
under the advertisement of 2009 and covers 10323 teachers of different
categories i.e. Undergraduate, Graduate and Postgraduate including the
present petitioner. It is not that proper notice was not issued upon all the
appointees/selectees under the aforesaid advertisement as by virtue of the
order dated 06.02.2014 in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) notices were
issued to all though paper publication in terms of Order I Rule 8 of CPC. It
appears that this petitioner despite valid notice did not choose to intervene in
the batch of writ petitions decided in the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) and
continued to enjoy the ad-hoc extensions to his service till 31.03.2020 in
terms of the interim order passed by the Apex Court. The present case of the
petitioner is not one where his services have been terminated on charges of
misconduct where the principles enshrined under Article 311 of the
Constitution of India are required to be followed. The entire selection
process was set aside as the Revised Employment Policy of 2003 suffered
from various illegalities, lack of guidelines, arbitrariness, favoritism and
nepotism in the process of recruitment. The learned Division Bench of this
Court had directed the State to frame a fresh employment policy and conduct
fresh selection process after giving age relaxation to the appointees whose
services were terminated. It, therefore, does not lie in the mouth of the
petitioner to contend that the impugned termination orders dated 23.12.2017
(Annexure-5) and 31.03.2020 (Annexure-11/A) are suffering from violation
of principles of natural justice and that petitioner is not covered by the
judgment of this Court in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) as affirmed by the
Apex Court. In fact, the contention of the petitioner relying upon paragraph
127 of the decision of Tanmoy Nath (supra) also has been squarely dealt
with by learned Division Bench of this Court in case of Sri Bijoy Krisnha
Saha and others. Paragraph 127 of Tanmoy Nath (supra) case, cannot be
read in isolation from the preceding paragraph starting from paragraphs 121,
122 and the directions passed by the Court contained in paragraphs 123 to
126 of the judgment. It is quite obvious that since several employments
could
have
taken place under
the Revised
Employment
Policy
of 2003 concerning other departments which were not before the Court in
the case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) (which covered the case of teachers under
Education Department only) the learned Court consciously clarified that this
decision would operate as regards the appointments made under the
advertisement dated 25.09.2009 unless any other employment made under
any other department was already under challenge on the ground that the
Employment Policy is illegal. As such, paragraph 127 does not confer any
benefit or leverage to the present petitioner to escape from the rigors of the
decision rendered by this Court in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) as affirmed
by the Apex Court. The litigation journey as observed at the outset has gone
for almost 12 years by now since the first writ petition was filed in the year
2011. The beneficiaries of that selection process like the present petitioner
ought to have obeyed the judgment of this Court in the case of Tanmoy
Nath (supra) as affirmed by the Apex Court dated 29.03.2017 instead of
raking up their grievances repeatedly on issues which have attained finality.
This Court, therefore, deprecates the approach of the petitioners in indulging
in abuse of the process of Court. The decision of this Court in Tanmoy Nath
(supra) has attained finality and none of the points raised herein are available
to be raised by the petitioner.
[17]
After going through the records thoroughly, it has come to light
that the petitioner Sri Pranab Deb has suppressed a material fact that he
along with another had approached this court by way of filing a writ petition
being WP(C) No.95/2021 titled as Sri Santanu Bhattcharjee & Anr. Vs. State
of Tripura & Ors.
[18]
The judgment and order (Oral) passed by a Coordinate Bench
of this Court [Akil Kureshi, CJ (as he then was)] in WP(C) 95/2021 is
reproduced herein below for convenience in extenso:
“[2] Before recording the contentions of the counsel for the
petitioners, a brief background leading to the decision in case of
Tanmoy Nath may be given. In the State of Tripura the State
Government had issued successive public advertisements for
appointment of large number of graduate, undergraduate and
postgraduate teachers in the years 2002 and 2006, however, the
selection process could not be completed. Yet another
advertisement was issued on 23.09.2009 inviting fresh applications,
however, providing that those who had already applied earlier, need
not apply afresh and their applications would be considered by
giving one-time age relaxation. After these selections were made
large number of petitions were filed challenging the appointments
on various grounds. Bunch of these petitions were disposed of by a
Single Judge of the Agartala Bench of Gauhati High Court by
common judgment dated 16.11.2011. The learned Single Judge did
not go into the merits of the allegations made by the petitioners but
remanded the matters back to the Government for thorough scrutiny
and examination by constituting a committee. This judgment was
challenged by private individuals as well as by the State
Government. The issue was thus placed before the Division Bench.
The Division Bench of this court in case of Tanmoy Nath held that
the new employment policy formulated by the State Government in
the year 2003 on the basis of which all the selections and
appointments were made, was defective on numerous counts. Entire
selection was set aside. While doing so, the Court was conscious
that terminating such large number of teachers at one-shot would
create a vacuum of teaching staff in Government schools which
would be detrimental to the education of young children. The
Court, therefore, issued certain directions for continuing these
teachers till fresh selections and appointments can be made within a
specified time. The judgment of Tanmoy Nath was carried in
appeal by the State Government. The Supreme Court initially
stayed the judgment. All the selected teachers who were under
threat of termination by virtue of the judgment of the High Court
continued in the same capacity. However, subsequently the said
appeal was dismissed. The judgment of the High Court in Tanmoy
Nath was confirmed. Only modification made was in the timelines
for completing the fresh selections with a further direction that the
existing teachers would get the benefit of age relaxation. These
timelines were also extended and revised from time to time and
eventually even this extension was not granted further. Many
teachers in the State thus faced terminations.”
[19]
On the aforesaid facts, the plea raised by the present petitioner
in WP(C)95/2021 may be reproduced hereunder:
“[3] The petitioners‟ services have been terminated as part of the
above process. They have filed these petitions challenging their
terminations on the grounds that they were never a party in Tanmoy
Nath case and their selections were not under challenge. Learned
counsel for the petitioners argued that the High Court in Tanmoy
Nath had specifically provided that the judgment would be
prospective and would apply only to those selections which were in
challenge before the High Court. In his opinion, since the selection
of the petitioners was not in challenge, the judgment in case of
Tanmoy Nath would not cover their cases and consequently the
State Government committed a serious error in terminating their
services relying on the decision in case of Tanmoy Nath.”
[20]
On hearing the learned counsel appearing for the present
petitioner and the counsels appearing for the State, the Hon‟ble Chief Justice
(Akil Kureshi, J) had held thus:
“[9] The decision of this Court in case of Tanmoy Nath thus was
clear on its sweep and implications. Entire selections made by the
State Government pursuant to the advertisement issued on 23rd
September, 2009 were set aside. This has been so stated by the
Court on various occasions as I have noted earlier. Very foundation
of the selection being a new recruitment policy which was declared
unconstitutional, the Court was persuaded to set aside all selections.
It did not refer to specific selections and appointments under
challenge as is sought to be canvassed before me by the counsel for
the petitioners. It is undisputed that the petitioners had also applied
in response to the said advertisement and were selected and
appointed under the same exercise which was scrutinized by the
High Court and declared as illegal. The observations of the Court in
paragraph 127 of the judgment noted earlier therefore must be
viewed from this background. This paragraph cannot be read in
isolation as to limit the effect of the judgment in case of Tanmoy
Nath to only those specific selections which the original petitioners
might have challenged before the High Court. What in paragraph
127 of the judgment the Division Bench had provided was that the
effect of the judgment would be limited to the selection of teachers
pursuant to the advertisement dated 23.09.2009 and not to any other
selections. This was necessary because the new recruitment policy
of the Government framed in the year 2003 may have been a source
of appointment of number of other Government posts. If the
decision of the Tanmoy Nath was utilized to reopen such
appointments, far reaching and widespread implications would be
felt in administration leading to chaotic situation. It was in this
background that the Court made its clarifications in paragraph 127
of the judgment.”
[21]
In the said judgment dated 26.02.2021 (in WP(C) 95/2021 and
WP(C) 96/2021) the learned Judge also referred to the case of Partha
Debnath & Ors Vs. State of Tripura & Ors [WP(C) 1219/2019] when the
question of non-issuance of individual notices before termination was also
dealt with and it was held that issuance of individual notices was not
necessary.
[22]
The petitioner was/is well aware of the contentions he raised in
the present writ petition and the decisions rendered by the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Partha Debnath (Supra). In spite of this, the
petitioner suppressing all those relevant facts has filed the instant writ
petition raising similar facts in issue and law.
[23]
It is aptly evident that the parties of the present writ petition
under reference and the parties in WP(C)95/2021, the grounds agitated in
WP(C) 95/2021 and the prayers made therein are similar and identical to the
present writ petition. As such, the present writ petition filed by the petitioner
Sri Pranab Deb is barred by res judicata as embodied under Section 11 of
the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 and thus, the same is not maintainable in its
present form and nature.
[24]
That apart, it is now well settled that “if the mischief played is
so widespread and all pervasive, affecting the result so as to make it difficult
to pick out the persons who have been unlawfully benefitted or wrongfully
deprived of their selection, it will neither be possible nor necessary to issue
individual show-cause notice to each selectee. The only way out would be to
cancel the whole selection.” It is also settled “when the entire selection is
stinking, conceived in fraud and delivered in deceit, individual innocence
has no place and the entire selection has to be set aside.” [Ref: MP State
Cooperative Bank Limited, Bhopal Vs. Nanuram Jadhav & Ors, (2007)
8 SCC 264].
[25]
Besides, principle of natural justice is not a straightjacket
formula. It depends upon various facets in the administration of justice and it
is established that there is exception to rules of natural justice. The present
case falls within such exception where rules of natural justice would not be
applicable because of large scale corruption, favouritism, nepotism and
arbitrariness found in the entire selection process. The entire selection
process was vitiated by fraud and arbitrariness which has already been
declared illegal and appointments of the persons so selected were
terminated.
[emphasis supplied]
[26]
The appointments of the petitioners and other teachers were
vitiated from the very inception which resulted in the issuance of their
termination orders and in that case, the principles of natural justice were not
violated, if no opportunity was given to the employees concerned to have
their say in the matter before their appointments were recalled and
terminated.
[27]
As an upshot of the above discussions and the reasons recorded,
we are of the unanimous view that no interference is called for in the
impugned orders whereby the services of the petitioners have been
terminated. The reference is answered accordingly. The instant writ petition
is dismissed with a cost of Rs.25,000/- to be deposited in the Tripura State
Legal Services Authority.
[28]
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
(T. AMARNATH GOUD) J
(ARINDAM LODH) J
signed
DIPESH Digitally
by DIPESH DEB
Date: 2023.10.12
DEB
16:49:32 +05'30'
Dipesh / Lodh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review