Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.654 OF 2023
Sri Dipak Rudra Paul
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and ors.
.......Respondent(s)
WP(C) NO.655 OF 2023
Sri Prakash Paul
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and ors.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. R. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. R. Datta, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 14.08.2024.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
Both the writ petitions are heard and taken up
together for disposal since common questions of law and facts are
involved.
2.
The brief facts of WP(C) No.654 of 2023 if that for
filling up four posts of Junior Scientist, the respondent-Tripura State
Pollution Board (in short „TSPSB‟)
issued an advertisement,
maintaining the same qualifications, as stipulated in the Notification
dated 06.05.2011. Being allured by the said advertisement, the
petitioner applied for the said post. Thereafter, the petitioner was
called in to appear before the Selection Committee, for facing the
interview for appointment to the said post. Accordingly, the Member
Secretary TSPCB issued a Memorandum dated 28.11.2012, thereby
offering an appointment, to the petitioner, to the post of Junior
Scientist (Group-B) on purely temporary basis. The merit list that
was prepared for selection to the said post of Junior Scientist,
TSPCB was also furnished to the petitioner under RTI Act,
wherefrom it transpires that the petitioner was placed at Serial No.1
of the said merit list. The Member Secretary, TSPCB issued a
Memorandum
dated
27.12.2022,
thereby
publishing
a
Draft
Seniority List of Junior Scientists of the TSPCB, whereby, the
petitioner was placed at Serial No.2, and the private respondent
was placed at serial no.1. Feeling aggrieved by his placement at
Serial No.2 of the Draft Seniority List, as was noted in the
memorandum dated 27.12.2022, despite his placement at Serial
No.1
in
the
merit
list,
the
petitioner
representation
dated
24.01.2023,
inter
submitted
alia
a
referring
detailed
to
the
attendant facts and circumstances and various decisions holding the
field. Without paying any heed to the issues raised by the
petitioner, by the above representation dated 24.01.2023, and
without recording any reason therefore, the Member Secretary,
TSPCB issued a Memorandum dated 19.09.2023, thereby publishing
the Final Seniority List of Junior Scientist of TSPCB, thereby
affirming the seniority position, as obtaining on 27.12.2022,
wherein, the petitioner was placed at Serial No.2. But the private
respondent was placed at Serial No.1 thereof. Hence, this writ
petition.
3.
The brief fact of WP(C) No.655 of 2023 is that for
filling up of six posts of Junior Environmental Engineer, the
respondent-TSPCB issued an advertisement, maintaining the same
qualifications, as stipulated in the Notification dated 06.05.2011.
Being allured by the said advertisement, the petitioner had applied
for the said post. Thereafter, the petitioner was called in, to appear
before the Selection Committee, for facing the interview for such
appointment
to
the
said
post.
He
emerged
out
successful.
Accordingly, the Member Secretary, TSPCB issued a Memorandum
dated
28.11.2012,
thereby
offering
an
appointment
to
the
petitioner, to the post of Junior Environmental Engineer (Group-B),
on purely temporary basis. The merit list that was prepared for
selection to the said post of Junior Environmental Engineer, TSPCB
was also furnished to the petitioner, wherefrom it transpires that
the petitioner was placed at Serial No.1 of the said Merit List. The
Member,
Secretary,
TSPCB
issued
a
Memorandum
dated
27.12.2022, thereby publishing a Draft Seniority List of Junior
Environmental Engineers of the TSPCB, whereby, the petitioner was
placed at Serial No.3, and the private respondent Nos. 5 & 6 were
placed at Serial Nos.1 & 2 respectively thereof. Feeling aggrieved
by his placement at Serial No.3 of the Draft Seniority List, as was
noted in the Memorandum dated 27.12.2022, despite his placement
at Serial No.1 in the Merit List, the petitioner submitted a detailed
representation
dated
24.01.2023,
inter
alia
referring
to
the
attendant facts and circumstances and various decisions holding the
field. Without paying any heed to the issues raised by the
petitioner, by the above representation dated 24.01.2023, and
without recording any reason, the Member Secretary, TSPCB issued
a memorandum dated 19.09.2023, thereby, publishing the Final
Seniority List of Junior Environmental Engineer of TSPCB affirming
the seniority position, as obtaining on 27.12.2022, wherein, the
petitioner was placed at Serial No.3, but the private respondent
Nos. 5 & 6 were placed at Serial Nos.1 & 2 respectively thereof.
Hence, this writ petition.
4.
Heard
Mr.
Somik
Deb,
learned
Sr.
counsel
appearing for the petitioners as well as Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned
Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for
private respondents and Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for
respondents-TSPCB and Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, learned
G.A. appearing for the State-respondents.
5.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned Sr. counsel appearing for
the petitioners submits that the question is whether joining before
would supersede the merit list because the petitioners topped the
merit list. In the offer of appointment issued to the petitioner dated
28.11.2012, the petitioners were directed to join the said post by
10.12.2012 and the petitioners joined the said post on 07.12.2012
and 05.12.2012 much prior to the date set out in their offer of
appointment. So as per the merit list/score list, the petitioners
ought to have been shown as senior to the private respondents in
the merit list.
6.
To prove this argument, learned counsel referred
following Judgments of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court.
6.1.
Chairman, Puri Gramya Bank and anr. Vs.
Ananda Chandra Das and ors., dated September 12 1994
reported in 1994 [1994] SUPP. 3 SCR, wherein it is stated thus:“The respondent and others were selected by direct
recruitment as managers of Rural Bank. His rank was No. 9 in the
merit list. He was directed to be given seniority on the basis of the
date of his reporting to duty. It is reported that the first respondent
is dead. The only question in this case is that what shall be the
ranking among the direct recruits? Is it the date on which they
joined duty or according to the ranking given by the selection
board? On comparative evaluation of the respective merits of the
candidates for direct recruitment, the Board has prepared the merit
list on the basis of the ranking secured at the time of the selection.
It is settled law that if more than one are selected, the seniority is
as per ranking of the direct recruits subject to the adjustment of
the candidates selected on applying the rule of reservation and the
roster. By mere fortuteous chance of reporting to duty earlier
would not alter the ranking given by the Selection Board and the
arranged one as per roster. The High Court, is, therefore, wholly
wrong in its conclusion that the seniority shall be determined on
the basis of the joining reports given by the candidates selected
for appointment by direct recruitment and length of service on its
basis. The view, therefore, is wrong. However, we need not
interfere with the order, since the first respondent
has died.
Para-18 of the reportable Judgment of Hon‟ble
6.2.
Supreme Court titled as Sudhir Kumar Atrey Vs Union of India
and ors, which is produced here-in-under:“18. We are also of the view that in the matter of
adjudging seniority of the candidates selected in one and the same
selection, placement in the order of merit can be adopted as a
principle for determination of seniority but where the selections are
held separately by different recruiting authorities, the principle of
initial date of appointment/continuous offication may be the valid
principle to be considered for adjuding inter se seniority of the
officers in the absence of any rule or guidelines in determining
seniority to the contrary.”
6.3
Para-17 and 19 of the Reportable Judgment of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court titled as Dharmendra Prasad and ors.
Vs. Sunik Kumar and ors., vide number Civil Appeal No.9248
of 2019:“ 17. We find that the method of giving appointment to the
senior most person of each category is only a fortuitus
circumstance as such appointments were made dehors the merit.
Regulation 20 mandates the appointing authority to make the
appointments from amongst the candidates in order in which they
stand in the list prepared under Regulations 16(2), 17 or 18. Any
appointment made by the Nigam in contravention of the statutory
Regulations
cannot defeat the rights of the appellants only
because they have not challenged the appointment of their juniors
at an earlier point of time. Regulation 23 provides that seniority of
persons appointed in any branch of service shall be made as per
substantive appointment. The appointment in Regulation 23 has to
be read in terms of Regulation 20 mandating the manner of
appointment. Therefore, irrespective of the date of appointment,
the seniority has to be fixed as per the merit of the candidates
determined by the Selection Committee.
19. We do not find any merit in the argument raised by the State
that the seniority has to be fixed as per Rule 5 of the Uttarakhand
Government Servant Seniority Service Rules, 2002. Such Rules
were not adopted to be applicable to the Nigam. The Rules were
approved by the Board of the Nigam on 24th September, 2007
proposing that the provision shall be made in the proposed service
regulations but the Rules were made applicable in the year 2011
only. Such is the finding recorded by the High Court which is not
disputed by the appellants or by the writ petitioners. Such Rules
have been framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution and they are not applicable to a creation under a
Statute. These Rules are applicable to government servants in
respect of whose recruitment and condition of service Rules may be
or have been made by the Government under the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution. Since the employees of the Nigam are not
government servants nor are their service conditions governed by
Rules framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution,
therefore, such Rules unless adopted by the Nigam cannot be
extended to the employees of the Nigam.”
6.4.
Para-7 of the Judgment of the Hon‟ble High Court
of Delhi titled as Sh. Adil Rashid Siddiqui Vs. Union of India
bearing No.WP(C) No.393 of 2012 dated 20.01.2012.:“7. The learned counsel for the petitioner in support of his
contention that the petitioner is entitled to seniority with reference to
the year of vacancy placed reliance on clause IV of the letter of
appointment of the petitioner, which, inter alia, stipulated that "the
seniority of the candidates should be fixed on the basis of the ranks of
the candidates in the examination and not on the basis of their date of
appointment". In our opinion, the reliance on the aforesaid clause in the
appointment letter is wholly misplaced. What the aforesaid stipulation in
the appointment letter means is that the seniority of those who were
selected along with the petitioner would be determined with reference to
their merit and not with reference to the date of their joining.To
illustrate, if five persons are selected together and the person at serial
No.1 joins after the person at serial No. 2 in the merit list, the person at
serial No. 1 in the merit list, would be placed above the person at serial
No. 2 irrespective of the date on which he joins. But, it does not mean
that they would get seniority with reference to the year in which the
vacancies against which they were appointed had arisen. We pointedly
asked the learned counsel for the petitioner as to whether any person
lower to the petitioner in the order of merit was placed above the
petitioner in the impugned seniority list. The learned counsel for the
petitioner frankly conceded that no person placed below the petitioner in
the order of merit was given seniority above the petitioner in the
impugned seniority list.
For the reasons given hereinabove, we find no merit in the
writ petition and the same is hereby dismissed, without any order as to
costs.
Relevant portion of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
6.5.
Judgment titled as Suresh Chandra Jha Vs. State of Bihar and
ors.,
bearing
No.Appeal(civil)
of
dated
10.11.2006:“There is no dispute that the appellant was ranked higher
to respondent no.8. There is also no dispute that in the appointment
letter the appellant was given six weeks time to join. Merely because
respondent no.8 joined earlier that did not in any way affected the merit
placement.”
7.
Stating the Judgments above, learned Sr. counsel
appearing for the petitioners submits that the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court consistently viewed that when a person selected has been
given time to join and within that period if he joins, regardless of
the fact that the person who is inferior in the merit list even if he
joins earlier, the selected person will be entitled to regain his
original merit list.
8.
Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-TSPCB submits that in the cases in hand, seniority has
been fixed on confirmation as their services are made on a purely
temporary basis and all the Judgments referred by the learned Sr.
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioners
relates
to
permanent
appointments, not temporary appointments. The respondent-TSPCB
follows guideline laid down in the office order dated 12 th July, 1960
which is a Government guideline.
In the said office order it is stated that “provided
that where persons recruitment initially on a temporary basis are
confirmed subsequently in a order different from the order of merit
indicated at the time of their appointment, seniority shall follow the
order of confirmation and not the original of merit.” Further, the
notification for advertisement was issued by the Government, not
by respondent- TSPCB.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr.
counsel appearing for the private respondents submits that the
official respondents are following the office order dated 12th July
1960 wherein it is stated that seniority shall follow the order of
confirmation and not the original order of merit. Learned Sr.
counsel further submits that there is no merit list in these present
cases as there was no written or selection test as there is only a
scorecard.
10.
In reply to the argument made, learned Sr. counsel
appearing the respondents, Mr. Somik Deb pointed out para-6.5 of
the affidavit-in-opposition of respondent-TSPCB wherein it is stated
that the merit list for the appointment is the post of Junior Scientist
has been prepared by the Selection Committee and in the merit list
the petitioners are placed above the private-respondents. Learned
Sr. counsel further submits that the memorandum relied upon by
the respondents is applicable to the State Government but the
respondent concerned herein which is an PSU i.e. an autonomous
body and there is nothing to record to show that they have followed
the said memorandum dated 12th July, 1960. A fair reading of the
office order dated 12th July, 1960 reveals that it would only apply to
the determination of seniority in Central Civil Services and Civil
posts under Tripura Administration and not to PSU/Autonomous
body.
11.
It is not a disputed that except for the scorecards, there
is no other merit list. The same has been confirmed by Mr. R.
Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-TSPCB.
Admittedly, both the petitioners and the un-official respondents
joined before the cutoff date and the consideration is expected to
be made based on the merit list, which is supposed to be the
scorecard and the same has not been disputed by the respondentTSPCB. The scorecard has not been disputed by the unofficial
respondents herein. According to the scorecard, the mark scored by
the petitioner of WP(C)654 of 2023, Sri Dipak Rudra Paul is 29 and
the mark scored by unofficial respondent No.5 i.e. Mr. Gautam
Ghosh is 27. In WP(C)655 of 2023, the petitioner Sri Prakash Paul
scored 37 and the unofficial respondent No.5, Sri Subrata Majumder
scored 27, and the unofficial respondent No.6, Smt. Satarupa
Sengupta scored 36. Though the learned Sr. counsel appearing for
the unofficial respondents has placed reliance on the General
Principle for determination of seniority of various categories of
person employed under Tripura Administration, they are only
applicable in the Central Civil Services and the Civil post under
Tripura Administration. To show that the said principles are also
applicable to the respondent-TSPCB is the grey area that has not
been substantiated to say that the same principles were adopted
and were applicable. It is also evident from the notification dated
11th March, 2019 that the name of the petitioner of WP(C) No.654
of 2023 i.e. Sri Dipak Rudra Pal is shown at serial No.6, and the
unofficial respondent is shown at serial No.7. Even if the respondent
No.5 in WP(C) No.654 of 2023 reported to duty on 05.12.2012 and
the petitioner on 07.12.2012 and respondent Nos.5 and 6 of the
WP(C) No.655 of 2023 reported to duty on 04.12.2012 and
05.12.2012 and the petitioner on 05.12.2012 as against the cutoff
date for reporting which is indicated as joining on or before 10th
December 2012, the unofficial respondents cannot take advantage
on the ground that they reported prior to the reporting of the
petitioner. It is settled law that if more candidates than one are
selected, the seniority is as per the rank of the direct recruits
subject to adjustments of the candidates selected applying the rule
of reservation and the roster. Mere fortuteous chance of reporting
to duty earlier would not alter the ranking given by the Selection
Board. The same is opined by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Chairman,
Puri Gramya Bank and anr. Vs. Ananda Chandra Das and ors
(supra).
12.
The said principle has also been settled by the Hon‟ble
Apex Court in its Judgment passed in Sudhir Kumar Atrey Vs.
Union of India(supra). The para-18 of the said judgment is again
reproduced herein for reference:““18. We are also of the view that in the matter of
adjudging seniority of the candidates selected in one and the same
selection, placement in the order of merit can be adopted as a
principle for determination of seniority but where the selections are
held separately by different recruiting authorities, the principle of
initial date of appointment/continuous offication may be the valid
principle to be considered for adjuding inter se seniority of the
officers in the absence of any rule or guidelines in determining
seniority to the contrary.”
13.
The same is also again reiterated by the Hon‟ble Apex
Court in Dharmendra Prasad and ors. Vs. Sunil Kumar and
ors.,(supra). Paras-17 and 19 of the same are reproduced herein
again for reference:“ 17. We find that the method of giving appointment to the
senior most person of each category is only a fortuitus
circumstance as such appointments were made dehors the merit.
Regulation 20 mandates the appointing authority to make the
appointments from amongst the candidates in order in which they
stand in the list prepared under Regulations 16(2), 17 or 18. Any
appointment made by the Nigam in contravention of the statutory
Regulations
cannot defeat the rights of the appellants only
because they have not challenged the appointment of their juniors
at an earlier point of time. Regulation 23 provides that seniority of
persons appointed in any branch of service shall be made as per
substantive appointment. The appointment in Regulation 23 has to
be read in terms of Regulation 20 mandating the manner of
appointment. Therefore, irrespective of the date of appointment,
the seniority has to be fixed as per the merit of the candidates
determined by the Selection Committee.
19. We do not find any merit in the argument raised by the State
that the seniority has to be fixed as per Rule 5 of the Uttarakhand
Government Servant Seniority Service Rules, 2002. Such Rules
were not adopted to be applicable to the Nigam. The Rules were
approved by the Board of the Nigam on 24th September, 2007
proposing that the provision shall be made in the proposed service
regulations but the Rules were made applicable in the year 2011
only. Such is the finding recorded by the High Court which is not
disputed by the appellants or by the writ petitioners. Such Rules
have been framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution and they are not applicable to a creation under a
Statute. These Rules are applicable to government servants in
respect of whose recruitment and condition of service Rules may be
or have been made by the Government under the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution. Since the employees of the Nigam are not
government servants nor are their service conditions governed by
Rules framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution,
therefore, such Rules unless adopted by the Nigam cannot be
extended to the employees of the Nigam.”
14.
The same is again reiterated by the Hon‟ble Apex Court
in Suresh Chandra Jha Vs. State of Bihar and ors(supra). The
same is produced here-in-under:““There is no dispute that the appellant was ranked higher
to respondent no.8. There is also no dispute that in the appointment
letter the appellant was given six weeks time to join. Merely because
respondent no.8 joined earlier that did not in any way affected the merit
placement.”
15.
It has been the consistent view of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court that when the employer/department concerned
gives a date for joining and the person selected joined in the
stipulated cutoff date, then the seniority has been drawn upon the
merit list and date of joining in such circumstance cannot have any
primacy over the merit position.
In both the writ petitions the
cutoff date was the 10th of Decemer 2012 and the petitioners joined
on the 7th of December 2012 and 5th of December 2012. As such,
taking into consideration the array of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
Judgments as relied upon by the learned Sr. counsel appearing for
the petitioners, wherein it is viewed that if a person selected joined
in the stipulated cutoff date, then the seniority has to be drawn
upon the merit list and date of joining in such circumstance cannot
have any primacy over the merit position. Further, this Court is also
in terms with the submission of the learned Sr. counsel appearing
for the petitioners on the point of the merit list. In view of the
same, these present writ petitions stands allowed and thus
disposed.
16.
As a sequel, stay if any stands closed. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2024.09.06
SINGHA
16:28:21 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review