Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
WP(C) No. 626 of 2022
1.
Sri Prabhat Chandra Sil, son of late Rai Mohan Sil, near Matarbari
Block, P.O. Matarbari, P.S. R. K. Pur, Udaipur, Gomati-District,
Tripura, PIN-799120.
…..Petitioner
-V E R S U S-
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala,
West Tripura.
2.
The Secretary, Department of Home, Government of Tripura, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura.
3.
The Director General of Police, Government of Tripura Police
Headquarter, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, Agartala, P.O. Agartala,
P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura.
4.
The Superintendent of Police, Sepahijala District,
Bisharamganj, P.S. Bishramganj, Sepahijala District.
5.
The Inquiry Officer of the D.P. No.02 of 2017 Sri Asish Debnath,
In-Charge Additional Superintendent of Police, Dhalai District.
6.
The Superintendent of Police (RSV), Dhalai District, Jaharnagar,
Disciplinary Authority.
7.
The Deputy Inspector General of Police, Northern Range,
Kumarghat, Tripura, Appellate Authority.
P.O.
….. Respondents
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. A. K. Pal, Advocate.
Mr. D. C. Roy, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
18.01.2024
:
:
22.01.2024
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. A. K. Pal, learned counsel and Mr. D. C. Roy,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner also heard Mr. M. Debbarma,
learned Addl. G.A. and Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
The present petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for challenging the memorandum of article of
charges vide memorandum dated 09.05.2017 and also petitioner
challenged the inquiry report, provisional punishment order, final
punishment order and order of the appellate authority before this Court
for setting aside the said article of charges and orders of the respondents.
Further, to set aside the false inquiry proceeding against the petitioner.
[3]
Brief facts of the case are that the while the petitioner was
posted at Boudhjungnagar P.S. in the capacity of Officer-in-Charge, then
the contraband items like contraband drugs (Phensedyl) and other were
seized by the police of the said P.S. and those articles were kept in the
Malkhana of the P.S. and after transfer of 6(six) months from the said
P.S. to Kalamchaura P.S., the respondents initiated a false and fabricated
departmental proceeding against the petitioner and others police staffs
including Malkhana In-charge for misappropriation of said seized
contrabands articles from the Malkhana of the P.S. and the respondents
bring article of charges No. 1 to V against the petitioner and others staffs.
During the inquiry, except the petitioner all other police staffs of the said
police station were discharged from article of charges levelled against
them.
[4]
But the respondents as well as Inquiry Officer falsely and
illegally gave the punishment to the petitioner withholding 3(three)
increments with cumulative effect and after receipt the punishment order
the petitioner filed an appeal before the appellate authority challenging
the final punishment order issued by the Disciplinary Futurity, but
without any hearing the same was rejected without any reason.
[5]
Hence the petitioner filed this writ petition before this Court
for setting aside the said illegal punishment order as the petitioner is
innocent and he is not involved in the said crime.
[6]
Mr. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that when the petitioner was posed at O/C of Boudhjungnagar
police station, the contraband articles were seized. The petitioner as an
O/C of the P.S. was not In-Charge of Malkhana of the seized articles, but
the respondents illegally and arbitrarily initiated departmental proceeding
against the petitioner. The petitioner was transferred and released from
the Boudhjungnagar P.S. on 04/07/2016 from Boudhjungnagar P.S. to
Kalamchura P.S. and joined at new place of posting at Kalamchura P.S.
vide order UD No. 11432-33/16 dated 02/06/2016 of the higher
authority.
[7]
But after lapsed of near about one year from the date of
transfer of the petitioner the respondents initiated a departmental
proceeding against the petitioner and others police staffs of the P.S. vide
D.P. No. 02/2017 dated 09/05/2017 and during the period from the date
of transfer and date of starting departmental proceeding, the seized
contraband articles in the Malkhana of Boudhjungnagar P.S. may be
misappropriated in absence of the petitioner by the Malkhana In-charge
and others, but at the time of handing over charges, all the seized articles
lying in the Malkhana was handed over to his reliever who has taken the
charge of O/C of Boudhjungnagar P.S. from the petitioner.
[8]
As such, there is no question of misappropriation of seized
contraband articles during his duty period at Boudhjungnagar P.S. and
the reliever of the petitioner has not raised any question in respect of the
seized Malkhana articles when he received the charged from the
petitioner as O/C of the P.S. So the petitioner submits that he is innocent
and he is not involved in the said article of charges brought against him
illegally and arbitrarily by the respondents in view of harassing him and
it is also mentioned that the other charged officers of the said
departmental proceeding along with the petitioner were involved in the
article of charges by the respondents.
[9]
It has been further contended that the inquiry officer
illegally and arbitrarily submitted an inquiry report against the petitioner
that the article of charges No. 1 to 5 were proved against the petitioner
and the article of charge No.V was not proved against the petitioner.
[10]
After the receipt of the inquiry report from the Inquiry
Officer, the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner i.e. S.P. (RSV)
Dhalai District, Jawahar Nagar issued a provisional punishment order
vide no. 952/19 dated 30/05/2019 in connection with Dhalai District D.P.
No 01/2019 dated 08/02/2019 (Sepahijala District D.P. No. 02'/2019
dated 09/05/2017) drawn up against S.I Prabhat Ch. Sil of District Dhalai
and in the said provisional punishment order, the respondent no. 6,
Disciplinary
Authority
proposed
to
imposed
the
punishment"
withholding 3(three) scale increment with cumulative effect" and the
Disciplinary Authority given opportunity to make representation on the
penalty imposed upon the petitioner within 30 days from the receipt of
this order of provisional punishment order.
[11]
After receipt the provisional punishment order dated
30/05/2019, the petitioner submitted representation on 02/07/2019
against the said provisional punishment order to the respondent no.6 and
in the said representation, the petitioner stated that the charged framed
against the petitioner in article No. I to V are not genuine and fake and he
was prejudice and reasonable opportunity was not given him and the
inquiry have been vitiated as evidence and their examination and cross
examination and the charges were not proved and he prayed that he may
be exonerated from the all the charges brought against him for the
interest of principle and natural Justice.
[12]
The petitioner submitted written brief argument on behalf of
defence before the Addl. S.P. Sepahijala dated 11/12/2018 and in the said
written argument, the petitioner stated that there are no collaborating
witnesses to prove the said false and arbitrarily article of charges against
the petitioner. The petitioner also submits that after filing of charge sheet
of those NDPS cases, the seized contraband (Phensedyl) were destroyed
by the Drug Disposal Committee. But the In-charge of Malkhana namely
S.I Makhana Das made his concocted and false evidence against the
petitioner after thought. It is mentioned that the seized contraband was
not carried by the government vehicle from the P.S. to the Ld. Court.
Those were transported by engaged private vehicle, as such there is no
question to misappropriate the seized contraband drugs (Phensedyl).
[13]
During the departmental proceeding there is so many
witnesses given their statements have been recorded by the Inquiry
Officer in the Departmental Proceeding against the petitioner and in the
statement of witness S.I. (UB) Dilip Sarkar has stated that there is
nothing loss of the government money and there is no misappropriated
seized contraband articles from the Malkhana of the P.S. and he also
stated that, S.I Makhana Das was the Malkhana In-charge. Statement of
NK (AB) Safiul Azam in his statement as witness in the departmental
proceeding, he state that there is no contrabands items were
misappropriated and those seized articles were disposed by the Disposal
Committee and he also making videography of the said contrabands
items. He also stated that there is no loss from the side of the
government.
[14]
Mr. Pal, learned counsel has further contended that it reveals
from the statement of SI Jahangir Hossain that seized property were in
Malkhana and keys were in the custody of SI (UB) Makhan Das, I/C of
Malkhana and the said witness stated that there is no adverse witness
were made against the petitioner.
[15]
Witness SI (UB) Makhan Das who was the Malkhana In-
charge and custodian of seized contrabands items and at the time of
witness he falsely stated against the petitioner for save himself from the
charge levelled against him and the petitioner submits that Malkhana Incharge of said witness Makhana Das may be mis-appropriated the said
seized contrabands items from the Malkhana of the P.S. as he was
custodian and In-charge of the said Malkhana of the P.S. The respondents
also initiated departmental proceeding against the said S.J Makhan Das,
in- charge of Milkman, but during the proceeding of the departmental
proceeding said witness Makhan Das along with others were discharged
from the charge of article levelled against them. But only punishment
was given to the petitioner arbitrarily and illegally by the disciplinary
authority as there is no witness revealed that the petitioner is involved
and guilty in misappropriation of seized contrabands items and false
charge of articles were levelled against the petitioner by the respondents.
[16]
After
submission
of
reply
against
the
provisional
punishment order, the respondent No.6, the Disciplinary Authority
passed the final punishment order against the petitioner that punishment
is awarded against the petitioner "withholding 3(three) scale increment
with cumulative effect" and the petitioner submits that final punishment
order is at par with the provisional punishment order issued earlier
against the petitioner. But the Disciplinary Authority did not consider the
representation of the petitioner against the provisional punishment order
and the Disciplinary Authority did not peruse the statement of evidence
of the witnesses and while passing the final punishment order he did not
apply his judicial mind. So the final punishment order is bad in law and it
is not justified as there is no witness in support of article of charge
brought against the petitioner by the Disciplinary Authority. So the final
punishment order is liable to be set aside.
[17]
After receipt of the final punishment order from the
respondent No.6, the petitioner submitted an appeal against the final
punishment order passed by the respondent no.6 on 15.10.2019 to the
respondent No.7 i.e. Deputy Inspector General of Police, Northern
Range, Kumarghat throug proper channel for considering the appeal
petition of the petitioner and the petitioner also prayed that suspend the
execution of the impugned final punishment order and please to acquit
the petitioner from all the charges levelled against him falsely. But the
respondent no.7 passed the order on the appeal petition dated 15.10.2019
that the appeal petition is rejected and stand by order dated 17.12.2019.
[18]
It has been averred that the Disciplinary Authority has
brought the charge against the petitioner along with other staffs of
Boudhjungnagar P.S. including In-charge of Malkhana of the P.S., S.I.
Makhana Das, but during the departmental proceeding except the
petitioner all other staffs of the P.S. were discharged from the liability of
article of charges brought against them. But the Disciplinary Authority
illegally and arbitrarily given punishment of the petitioner that
"withholding 3(three) scale increment with cumulative effect of the
petitioner and after receipt of the final punishment order from the
Disciplinary Authority, the petitioner filed an appeal before the
respondent no.7 for set aside/quash the said final punishment order of the
petitioner. But the respondent no. 7 Appellate Authority rejected the
prayer of the appeal petition of the petitioner without any reasons.
[19]
The petitioner submits that without assigning any reasons,
the Disciplinary Authority passed the provisional punishment order as
well as final punishment order against the petitioner are not tenable in the
eye of law, as such the petitioner has challenged the said punishment
orders of the Disciplinary Authority against the petitioner before Your
Lordship for set aside/quash/cancel the said illegal and arbitrarily
punishment order passed against the petitioner and the petitioner is
innocent and he is not involved in the said misappropriation of seized
contrabands articles of the Boudhjungnagar P.S. while he was O/C of the
P.S.
[20]
Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for respondent has
submitted that SI(UB) Prabhat Chandra Shil, Sepahijala District Police is
charged for grass misconduct while working as O.C. Bodhjungnagar P.S.
West Tripura had misrepresented the location of storage of seized
contraband item in c/w Bodhjungnagar PS Case No 2016BJN 018, dated20-04-2016, U/s-22(c) of NDPS Act by entering details in the Malkhana
register, thereby wrongfully implying that such items were kept in P.S.
Malihana, but actual the items were kept in female lockup of
Bodhjungnagar PS in plain view of all P.S. staffs and by his action he did
not take adequate precautions to ensure that post inventory seals and
packing materials on the seized items were not tempered with and
thereby revealing gross negligence on his part.
[21]
While working as O.C Bodhjungnagar PS, West Tripura had
removed contrabands items kept in the PS Malkhana, Bodhjungnagar PS
of which he was custodian in official capacity without entering the fact in
any official PS records or any information to higher authority as is
clearly borne out by ex-post facto discovery of such action during
verification by State Drug Disposal Committee on 24-11-2016 and on
14-12- 2016 and thereby his act of omission of recording such fact
amounts to unbecoming of a Police officer.
[22]
SI(UB) Prabhat Chandra Shil, Sepahijala District Police is
charged for gross misconduct while working as O.C. Bodhjungnagar PS,
West Tripura had propose to recover the expenditure of transportation of
seized contraband drug in c/w Bodhjungnagar PS Case No.2016BJN 018,
dated 20-04-2016, U/s-22(c) of NDPS Act to the Court by adopting
dubious means of sale of seized and inventoried items instead of
furnishing bills for the incurred expenditures to the Superintendent of
Police for re-imbursement purpose as per appropriate accounting
procedures and thereby his action amounts to use of bad judgment in
office management and unprofessional conduct.
[23]
It has been further contended that the statement of Shri Har
Kumar Debbarma, IPS, the then Superintendent of Police (EB) while
conducted enquiry, statmenet of Shri Nirdes Deb, the then Dy. SP (CID),
statement of SI (UB) Jahangir Hossain, the then O.C. Bodhjung Nagar
P.S. Naik (AB) A. B. Azam, photographer SP (CID) Office corroborated
that the articles of charges No.I, II, III & IV framed against the petitioner
is well established.
[24]
Mr. Sarkar, learned counsel has submitted that ample
opportunity was given to the petitioner in his defence to cross examine
on each statement. The procedures laid down in relevant rules have been
complied with. The charges are serious in nature. There can be a serious
aftermath affect on other members of the working police if such activities
are encouraged upon and can easily vitiate the working environment. The
petitioner has been charged for gross misconduct in while working as
O.C. Bodhjungnagar P.S. purposefully removed and misappropriated
contraband drug seized by the police station on 20.04.2016 and kept in
police station Malkhana of which he was the custodian in his official
capacity as the officer in charge of the P.S. and substituted part of the
seized material to mislead the State Drug Disposal Committee and other
police officers at the time of handing over the charge upon district
transfer, thereby revealing misappropriation and thereby showing lack of
integrity and devotion to duty on his part.
[25]
In view of above submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and having gone through the material evidence
on record, this Court is of the opinion that to decide the matter the
evidences and the article of charges need to be discussed once again. For
the purpose of reference, the article of charges may be reproduced herein
below:
ARTICLE OF CHARGE NO.I
SI (UB) Prabhat Chandra Sil of Unarmed Branch, Sepahijala District
Police is charged for gross misconduct in that he, while working as O.C
Budhjungnagar PS, West Tripura purposefully removed and
misappropriated contraband drug (band Phensedyl) seized by the PS staff
on 20/04/2016 in connection with Bodhjungnagar PS case No. 2016BJN
018, dated 20/04/2016 U/s 22(c) of NDPS Act and kept in PS Malkhana
of which he was the custodian in his official capacity as the Officer-inCharge of the Police Station and substituted part of the seized material to
mislead the State Drug Disposal Committee and other Police Officers at
the time of handling over of charge upon District transfer, thereby
revealing misappropriation and thereby showing lack of integrity and
devotion to duty on his party.
ARTICLE OF CHARGE NO.II
St (UB) Prabhat Chandra Sil of Unarmed Branch, Sepahijala Dotrict
Police is charged for gross misconduct in that he, while working as OC
Budhjungnagar PS, West Tripura had called upon SI(UB) Apu Das,
SI(UB) Sitikanta Bardhan & SI(UB) Makhana Das all werking under him
and proposed that the expenditure for talang seized contraband drugs in
connection with case no 2016BJN 018, dated 20/04/2016 U/s 22(c) of
NDPS Act to the court for making inventory that was to be made up by
seized drug itself by substituting the originals and to which two
subordinate staff consented and thereby his actions amount to serious
misconduct and abuse of official position through persuasion of his
subordinate officers.
ARTICLE OF CHARGE NO III
SI (UB) Prabhat Chandra Sil of Unarmed Branch, Sepahijala District
Police is charged for gross misconduct in that he, while working as OC
Bodhjungnagar PS, West Tripura had removed contrabands items kept in
the PS Malkhana, Bodhjungnar PS which he was custodian in official
capacity without entering the fact in any official PS records or any
information to higher authority as is clearly borne out by ex-post facto
discovery of such action during verification by State Drug Disposal
Committee on 124/11/2016 and 14/12/2016 and thereby his act of
omission of recording such fact amounts to unbecoming of a police
officer.
ARTICLE OF CHARGE NO.IV
SI (UB) Prabhat Chandra Sil of Unarmed Branch, Sepahijala District
Police is charged for gross misconduct in that he, while working as O.C
Bodhjungnagar PS, West Tripura had misrepresented the location of
storage of seized contraband items inc/w Bodhjungnagar P.S. Case No.
2016BJN 018, dated 20/04/2016 U/s 22(c) of NDPS Act by entering
details in the Malkhana register, thereby wrongfully implying that such
items were kept in PS Malkhana, but actual the items were kept in female
lock up of Bodhjungnagar PS in plain view of all PS staff and by this
action he did not take adequate productions to ensure that post inventory
seals and packing materials on the seized items were not tempered with
and thereby revealing gross negligence in duty on his part.
ARTICLE OF CHARGE NO.V
SI (UB) Prabhat Chandra Sil of Unarmed Branch, Sepahijala District
Police is charged for gross misconduct in that he, while working as O.C
Bodhjungnagar PS, West Tripura had propose to recover the expenditure
of transportation of seized contraband drug in c/w Bodhjungnagar P.S.
Case No. 2016BJN 018, dated 20/04/2016 U/s 22(c) of NDPS Act to the
Court by adopting dubious means of sale of seized and inventoried items
instead of furnishing bills for the incurred expenditure to the
Superintendent of Police for reimbursement purpose as per appropriate
accounting procedures and thereby his action amounts to use of bad
judgment in office management and unprofessional conduct.”
[26]
It reveals from the record the Drug Disposal Committee
[DDC, for short] checked each items and found 2100 bottles of
Phensedyl were found genuine and the rest seized contraband items not
genuine. The DDC after checking the seized items again kept inside the
sacks and sealed it and kept inside the Malkhana without disposal as
discrepancy was found by the DDC. It also reveals from the statement of
Dy. SP Nirdesh Deb, presently posted as SDPO, Shantirbazar that all
phensedyl bottles present in 45 jute bags/sacks and found that only 2100
bottles were found to be genuine having single layer of labeling which
were of phensedyle and the rest 11,224 bottles were found with having
double layer of labeling with phensedyl in the outer layer and with Eskuf
in the inner label. So, a general question comes that what about the other
bottles i.e. 11,224. This aspect of the case has not been dealt with by the
appellate authority.
[27]
In the charge No.1 it is not specific that the necessary
particulars with regard to the date and time of removing and
misappropriating of contraband drug. In charge No.2 it is not containing
the necessary particulars with regard to date and time of calling of SI
Makhan Das, SI Apu Das and SI Sritikanta Bardhan in the chamber of
O/C BNJ police station for proposing them any illegal proposal.
[28]
Where is the finding with regard to the change of labels has
taken place during the tenure of the petitioner i.e. from April to July. It
could even from July to November anytime after his transfer. That has
not been discussed. Everything is in police station under his custody all
along but, other staffs are also there in the police station so, during what
time according to the respondent he has taken away or has changed the
labels of the bottles, what was the enquiry up onto this issue.
[29]
SI Makhan Das admitted during enquiry and evidences are
there to the effect that the seized contraband items were in his custody
being IC PS Malkhana. DDC came to dispose the seized contrabands
items while SI Jahangir Hossen was OC BJN Police station i.e. on
24.11.2016 and 14.12.2016. In cross it was asked that is there any loss
from the side of the government regarding changing of the label of the
seized items and to this count the answer was no loss from the side of the
government. But, according to this Court the loss is to the society when
thousands of bottles of narcotics are made available in the open market
unauthorizedly, what steps the concerned authority has taken to recovery
of all those contraband items.
[30]
It is very much surprising that may be in his tenure the
labeling of the bottles were changed but, the petitioner is not the only
person working in that police station. So many other staffs were also
present, whole station is under electronic surveillance and to this count
there was no finding from the appellate authority. Who has actually
committed the crime or changed the labels and what happened to the
other bottles which were changed and not recovered. As the SDPO
(NCC) approved to store the seized contraband items in female lockup
due to scarcity of space in the original PS Malkhana. The Addl. SP (W)
and SP (W) also visited PS and noticed where seized contraband items
are kept. So question of misrepresentation of location of storage does not
arise.
[31]
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of by setting aside
the order passed in appeal as the matter remanded back to the appellate
authority since the order in appeal is a non-speaking and unreasoned
order and is not dealt with the contention of the petitioner. This Court
after going through the matter in its entirety expresses concern; the
manner in which the respondents functioning in this case and frames the
following issues that are to be addressed by the appellate authority after
going through the records while would pass the order on priority basis,
thus:
(1) It is not specific that the necessary particulars with regard to the date
and time of removing and misappropriating of contraband drug.
(2) In charge No.2 it is not containing the necessary particulars with
regard to date and time of calling of SI Makhan Das, SI Apu Das and SI
Sritikanta Bardhan in the chamber of O/C BNJ police station for
proposing them any illegal proposal.
(3) Where is the finding with regard to the change of labels has taken
place during the tenure of the petitioner i.e. from April to July. It could
even from July to November anytime after his transfer.
(4) Everything is in police station under his custody all along but, other
staffs are also there in the police station so, during what time according to
the respondent he has taken away or has changed the labels of the bottles,
what was the enquiry onto this issue.
(5) The loss is to the society when thousands of bottles of narcotics are
made available in the open market unauthorizedly, what steps the
concerned authority has taken to recovery of all those contraband items.
(6) What was the reason that after lapse of near about one year from the
date of transfer of the petitioner the respondents initiated a departmental
proceeding against the petitioner?
[32]
In view of the above observations/issues, the present petition
stands disposed of by remitting back the matter to the appellate authority
for fresh adjudication.
In the light of the above, the instant writ petition stands
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
A.Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.22
11:20:07 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review