Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 677 of 2024
Sri Pintu Das, son of late Jagabandhu Das, resident of Gandhighat, P.S.
West Agartala, P.O. & Sub-Division- Agartala, District- West Tripura
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary, General
Administration (AR) Department, Government of Tripura, New Capital
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.New Capital Complex, Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
2. The
Secretary,
General
Administration
(AR)
Department,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.New
Capital Complex, Agartala, District- West Tripura
3. The
Secretary,
General
Administration
(P&T)
Department,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. New Secretariat, P.S.
New Capital Complex, Agartala, District- West Tripura
4. The Chief Secretary, Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, District- West
Tripura (Appellate Authority)
5. District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala
6. Sub Divisional Magistrate, Sadar, District- West Tripura
7. Commissioner of Departmental Enquiries, Secretariat Annexe,
Pandit Nehru Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District- West Tripura
8. Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by its Secretary,
A.K. Road, near Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.S. West Agartala, Agartala,
District- West Tripura
9. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, A.K. Road, near
Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura
….Respondents
For Petitioner (s )
:
For Respondent (s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery :
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate
Mr. SM Chakraborty, Adv. General
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. K. Pandey, Advocate
09.01.2025
Yes
Page 2
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
1.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
following reliefs:
“i. ISSUE RULE, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, for calling for the records, lying with the respondents, for rendering
substantial and conscionable justice to the petitioner, and for quashing/setting
aside the impugned Order of Punishment No.F.11(1)-GA(AR)/2014/721-23,
dated 18.07.2024 (Annexure- 13 supra), and the Appellate Order No.F.11(1)GA(AR)/2014/1028-29, dated 01.10.2024 (Annexure-15 supra), and thereafter,
release all the pecuniary benefits;
ii. ISSUE RULE, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, for mandating/directing the respondents to revoke/rescind the impugned
Order of Punishment No.F.11(1)-GA(AR)/2014/721- 23, dated 18.07.2024
(Annexure-13 supra), and the Appellate Order No.F.11(1)-GA(AR)/2014/102829, dated 01.10.2024 (Annexure-15 supra), and thereafter, release all the
pecuniary benefits;
iii. CALL FOR THE RECORDS, appertaining to this petition;
iv. After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the RULE ABSOLUTE in
terms of i. & ii. above;
v. COSTS of and incidental to this proceeding;
vi. Any other RELIEF(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court may deem fit and
proper;”
2.
Short facts emanated from the records relating to the present writ
petition are that, a disciplinary proceeding was initiated against the writ
petitioner. In course of proceeding, altogether 5(five) numbers of Articles
of Charge were framed against him. The proceeding was concluded, with
order of withholding 3(three) increments with cumulative effect. The said
penalty order was confirmed by the appellate authority. Being aggrieved,
the present writ petitioner filed a writ petition before this Court which was
registered as W.P.(C) 835 of 2021. The said petition was allowed and
disposed of vide judgment and order dated 07.01.2023 with the following
directions:
“i. The Articles of Charges framed under Charge No. V is set aside;
ii. The penalty of withholding 3 (three) increments with cumulative effect is
modified and reduced to the extent of withholding 1(one) increment with
cumulative effect, which is treated to be a major penalty;
iii. The petitioner is entitled to full pay and allowances for the period he
remained under suspension;”
Page 3
3.
Feeling aggrieved, the respondents-State preferred intra-court
appeal. While disposing of the appeal, a Division Bench of this Court had
passed following direction upon the State-respondents vide order dated
02.04.2024:
“11. ………Imposition of withholding of three increments with cumulative
effect amounted to a major penalty [See Kulwant Singh Gill Vs. State of
Punjab, (1991) Supp (1) SCC 504]. In that case, the right course for the
learned Writ Court would have been to remit the matter to the Disciplinary
Authority to pass a fresh order on the quantum of penalty considering the
gravity of the charges established against the writ petitioner. The learned
Writ Court however, proceeded to substitute the penalty by withholding of
1[one] increment with cumulative effect which is to be treated as a major
penalty. We, therefore, are inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment
and order to that extent. The matter is, therefore, remitted to the Disciplinary
Authority to pass a fresh order on the quantum of penalty to be imposed
upon the writ petitioner for the established charge. ……….
Accordingly, the instant appeal is allowed to the extent as indicated
above.”
4.
Following remission, the Disciplinary Authority revisited the
matter and passed an order dated 18th July, 2024 (Annexure 13 to the writ
petition) whereby and where-under the disciplinary authority held that
Article-IV and Article-V had been established, and imposed a major
penalty of withholding 3(three) increments with cumulative effect
alongwith an additional punishment of recovery of loss amount of
Rs.21,600/- only from the pay of Sri Pintu Das, the petitioner herein. For
convenience, the order dated 18th July, 2024, may be reproduced hereunder:
“NO 11(1)-GA (AR)/2014/721-23
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION (AR) DEPARTMENT
Dated, Agartala, the 18th July, 2024.
ORDER
WHEREAS, a disciplinary proceeding was drawn up against Shri Pintu Das, TCS, ExDCM, O/o the SDM, Sadar under Rule-14 of CCS(CC&A) Rules, 1965 vide Memo
No.F.11(1)-GA(AR)/2014/624-27 dated 26-04-2014;
AND
WHEREAS, after conforming all codal formalities contained in the CCS(CC&A) Rules,
1965 a major penalty of withholding 3(three) increments with cumulative effect was
imposed vide order of even number dated 15-02-2021 upon Shri Pintu Das. TCS, the
then DCM, O/o the SDM, Sadar, Agartala;
AND
WHEREAS, the Accused Officer, Shri Das filed an appeal petition WP(C)/835/2021
before the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura against the order dated 15-02-2021 of the
Disciplinary Authority;
Page 4
AND
WHEREAS, the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura passed the judgment and order dated
07-01-2023 reducing the punishment imposed upon the Accused Officer;
AND
WHEREAS, the State Government in GA (AR) Department, preferred a Writ Appeal
vide Case No. WA/108/2023 against the order dated 07-01-2023 of the Hon'ble High
Court;
AND
WHEREAS, the Hon'ble Court after hearing passed a judgement and order dated 0204-2024 with the following directions: "The matter is, therefore, remitted to the Disciplinary Authority to pass a fresh order
on the quantum of penalty to be imposed upon the writ petitioner for the established
charge. The Disciplinary Authority hority would take such decision within a period
of 12 (twelve) weeks from the receipt of the copy of this judgment and order"
AND
WHEREAS, in compliance of the said judgment of the Hon'ble High Court the case was
reviewed in totality w.r.t the framed charges and the findings thereon;
While conducting inquiry, following all prescribed procedure and rules of natural
justice, the Inquiring Authority indicated in Point No.2 that "The defence, in its written
brief of argument submitted to this court and tried to build justification for the said act of
the A.O. on the grounds that the PWI and PW2 had not verified the log book of the said
hired vehicle and still brought the charges of passing of false vouchers against the A.O. the defence has overlooked the fact that verification of log book is required to check the
accuracy of the billing amount and here the charges are framed against use of false
vouchers and as such log book verification cannot be the sole criteria here in ascertaining
the validity of the vouchers. The defence had further overlooked the fact the
misappropriation of the vehicle payment was not the issue to begin with, and hence the
submission of DW2, the owner of the hired vehicle and that he had received all his
payments does not absolve the A.O. of his fault in passing the vouchers, geminity of which
was doubtful on two major grounds, one, the vouchers were not submitted by the owner of
the vehicle and was done by a so- called agent of the owner and in the govt. payment
systems there is no role of any agent/middleman and secondly the said vouchers were
submitted by Shri Subhajit Parial who was engaged as data entry operator in the office but
had submitted the bills on the pretence of being the driver of the said vehicle, and both
these two major grounds were fully within the knowledge of the A.O. as he was posted in
the said office and was holding multiple charges there including that of the Head of
Office.
As such, the charges of passing false vouchers against hired vehicle of the O/oSDM, Sadar by the A.O. has been established successfully by the prosecution."
Similarly, in Point No.3 of the findings, the Inquiring Authority categorically
viewed that "As it is established beyond doubt that in his letter addressed to the DM(W) dt.
26-11-2013, the A.O. had completely avoided / omitted to explain the matter/issue of Smt.
Nita Das, in spite of her being the central focus of the news item in 'Ajker Fariad' against
which the A.O. was offering his clarification to his authority, the same was not found und
in his letter to the SDM, Sadar dt. 7-12-2013, wherein he had specifically submitted his
clarifications in details about his relationship with Smt. Nita Das and as such two written
submissions, made against the same news item published in 'Ajker Fariad on 26-11-2013,
by the same person, i.e., the A.O.; in one omitting the most vital information and the other
submitting detailed clarification on the allegations can without doubt be treated as two
dissimilar submissions, made by the same person in connection with one incident. In
context of the written submission made by Shri Pintu Das, A.O. to the SDM, Sadar on 712-2013, for refusing the allegations brought against him by the news item of 'Ajker
Fariad' dt. 26-11-2013, the one submitted by the A.O. to the DM(W) dt. 26- 11-2013, can
be marked as deliberate non-disclosure of vital information to the controlling authority.
Hence the analysis on the charges of misrepresentation of facts by the A.O. is
established beyond doubt";
AND
WHEREAS, the charges in Article-IV & Article-V were established against the
Accused Officer in course of inquiry. The charge referred in Article-IV relates to
certification of false vouchers and Article-V deals with deliberate non-disclosure of vital
information to the controlling authority by the Accused Officer. Both the established
charges are of grave nature; one involving financial irregularities and the other relating
to concealment of facts or rather misrepresentation of facts before the higher authority.
The matter of false certification indicates the act of corruption with a view to gain
an undue advantage, which has got a pervasive impact on the efficient administration
Page 5
and frustrates the very essence of good governance. Corruption has got a demoralizing
effect on the honest public servants and thus warrants adoption of strict measures;
Besides, the act of concealment of facts or deliberate non-disclosure of vital
information to the controlling authority is a dishonest act, with a view to deceive the
authority and thus contributes to misconduct for which penalty proportionate to the
nature of misconduct needs to be imposed upon the concerned;
NOW, THEREFORE, in compliance of the order of the Hon'ble High Court
dated 02-04-2024, a major penalty of withholding of 3(three) increments with
cumulative effect and recovery of the loss amount of Rs. 21,600/- (Rupees Twenty- one
thousand Six hundred) only from the pay of Shri Pintu Das are hereby imposed.”
5.
The petitioner was given an opportunity to submit representation
against the said order (supra).
6.
Thereafter, the petitioner preferred statutory appeal before the
appellate authority. The appellate authority concurred the view of the
disciplinary authority and affirmed the penalty order passed by the
disciplinary authority vide Order dated 01.10.2024. The relevant portion of
the appellate order may be reproduced hereunder:
“ … Gone through the averments of the Disciplinary Authority, while reconsidering the case in compliance of the Hon'ble High Court's order and
drawing the inference about the penalty to be imposed upon Sri. Pintu Das. The
Disciplinary Authority has categorically analyzed the charges and the findings
to arrive at a decision imposing penalty, proportionate to the established
charges.
I have found no infirmity in that penalty order dated 18/7/2024 and also no
additional fact or evidence has been adduced from the side of the appellant.
After careful examination of all relevant aspects of the case, the Appellate
Authority upholds the punishment order vide No.F.11(1)- GA(AR)/2014/721-23
dated 18-07-2024 imposed upon the appellant Shri Das.
Hence, the appeal filed by Shri Pintu Das is rejected and disposed of.”
7.
On the aforesaid background facts, I have heard Mr. S. Lodh,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. SM
Chakraborty, learned Advocate General assisted by Mr. Kohinoor N.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the State-respondents and Mr. K.
Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-TPSC.
8.
With reference to the aforesaid facts on record, Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the fresh penalty order
passed by the disciplinary authority and upheld by the appellate authority
are misconceived and cannot be sustained. According to learned counsel
Page 6
appearing for the petitioner, both the disciplinary authority and the
appellate authority have failed to understand the underlying direction
passed by the Division Bench of this court while remitting the matter
asking them to take a fresh decision as regards the quantum of punishment.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the Division
Bench has not interfered with the findings of the learned Single Judge as
regards setting aside the charges while maintaining that the Charge No. IV
has been established. It is further submitted that in the intra-court appeal,
the Division Bench only interfered with the decision of the learned Single
Judge to the extent that the court has very limited power to decide about the
quantum of punishment; rather, it is always better to remit the matter back
to the competent authority for taking a decision about the proportionality of
penalty to be imposed upon the government servant.
8.1.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has strenuously argued that the order
imposing penalty of withholding of 3(three) increments with cumulative
effect alongwith additional penalty of recovery of Rs.21,600/- on the charge
of causing loss to the government amounts to flouting the order passed by
both learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of this Court. According
to Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, the penalty order
issued by the disciplinary authority upheld by the appellate authority is
contemptuous, vis-à-vis aptly disproportionate.
8.2.
Having drawn the attention of this court to the Articles of Charge
framed against the petitioner at the time of conducting the disciplinary
proceeding, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has submitted that no Article of
Charge was framed against the writ petitioner alleging that he caused loss
of Rs.21,600/- to the government and thus, it just proves vindictive attitude
Page 7
of the respondents since the petitioner challenged the penalty order imposed
by the respondents before the Court of law. It is candidly submitted that the
penalty order passed against the petitioner cannot sustain and is required to
be interfered with by this court.
8.3.
In addition, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has submitted that the
court has ample power to decide the proportionity of penalty if it is found to
be perverse and hits the conscience of the court. In support of his
submission, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has relied upon the judgment
rendered in Union of India and others vs. Managobinda Samantaray,
reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 284, para-9. On the question of legality
of recovery of money of Rs.21,600/- without framing charge, Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel has relied upon the judgment rendered in Rafiq Husain vs.
Union of India and another, reported in 2004 SCC Online Allahabad
2032, particularly para 14.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. Chakraborty, learned Advocate General
appearing for the respondents-State has submitted that the court may pass
an appropriate order considering the direction passed by the Division Bench
of this Court vis-à-vis the impugned penalty imposed afresh by the
respondents upon the petitioner. However, Mr. Chakraborty, learned
Advocate General is very candid in his submission that the order passed by
the disciplinary authority affirmed by the appellate authority cannot be said
to be contemptuous.
10.
I have considered submissions of learned counsel appearing for
the parties, meticulously perused the documents and the order passed by the
Division Bench of this court.
Page 8
11.
Having careful consideration of the order of the Division Bench,
in my opinion, the court has not interfered with the findings of the learned
Single Judge regarding the sustainability of the Articles of Charge framed
against the writ petitioner. I have gone through the judgment and order
passed by this sitting singly while allowing the writ petition. Upon
examination, it comes to fore that learned Single held that out of 5(five)
Articles of Charge framed against the writ petitioner, 4(four) charges have
not been proved. It was categorically held that Article of Charge No. IV had
been proved. Having gone through the order passed by the Division Bench
in the related writ appeal, it is crystal clear that Division Bench nowhere
and in no way interfered with the findings of the learned Single Judge as
regards the decision that out of 5(five) Articles of Charge, 4(four) charges
have not been proved. In other words, this Court having held that only
Charge no.-IV has been proved reduced the penalty considering the extent
of gravity of misconduct and imposed penalty, which appeared to be
proportionate to me instead of remitting the matter back to the Disciplinary
Authority. The order of the Division Bench made it clear that learned Single
Judge ought to have remitted the matter to the authority concerned for
taking a fresh decision on the quantum of penalty imposed upon the
petitioner for the established Charge. According to learned Division Bench,
so far I understand, the Division Bench in its direction only interfered with
the judgment and order of this Court, as according to Division Bench,
learned Single Judge ought not to substitute the penalty imposed by the
Disciplinary Authority to take fresh decision on the quantum of penalty; to
say it otherwise, direction was limited to the extent of taking a fresh
decision only on quantum of punishment and that too on the “establishment
Page 9
charge”. The decision of the learned Single Judge setting aside 4(four)
charges out of 5(five) numbers of charges has not been interfered with.
Here in my opinion, both the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate
Authority have misread or misconstrued the order of the learned Division
Bench.
12.
Now, coming to the merits of the penalty order passed by the
Disciplinary Authority upheld by the Appellate Authority, it is emerged that
both the authorities, not only maintained the previous penalty order
imposed upon the petitioner earlier, but, also imposed another penalty, for
the first time, by way of recovery of Rs.21,600/-, as regards the loss
allegedly suffered by the government. Ex facie, in my opinion, the order
dated 18th July, 2024 (Annexure 13 to the writ petition) passed by the
Disciplinary Authority and upheld by the Appellate Authority imposing
penalty of withholding of 3(three) increments with cumulative effect
alongwith recovery of Rs.21,600/-, is arbitrary and discriminatory and
suffers from non-application of mind. In the opinion of this court, the order
of penalty, as stated supra, is perverse.
13.
As a matter of repetition, the Disciplinary Authority in its
previous order imposed a penalty of withholding of 3(three) increments
with cumulative effect after he arrived at a finding that all the 5(five)
Articles of Charge had been proved against the petitioner. When in a writ
proceeding, the writ court held that out of 5(five) nos. of Articles of
Charge, 4(four) articles of charge have not been proved and only Article of
Charge no. IV has been proved, then, obviously the quantum of penalty
should have been considered keeping in mind that only 1(one) Charge has
been proved against the delinquent, the writ petitioner. While deciding the
Page 10
quantum of punishment, it is apparent that the disciplinary authority could
not visualize the true import of the decision of the court that out of 5(five)
articles of charge, 4(four) charges have been set-aside and only 1(one)
charge remained. So, the quantum of punishment should be proportionate to
1(one) proven charge only.
14.
Without entering into the merits of the submissions as to whether
the findings of the authorities is contemptuous or not, according to this
court, the order of maintaining the previous punishment with an additional
punishment and that too, in absence of any charge, is unauthorative and
arbitrary.
15.
While revisiting the Articles of Charge framed against the writ
petitioner, it comes to light that in course of disciplinary proceeding, no
charge was framed that the government had sustained a loss of Rs.21,600/for the alleged misconduct of the writ petitioner. In absence of specific
charge in this regard, in the opinion of this court, the punishment of
recovery of Rs.21,600/- stating the alleged loss suffered by the government
is arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of the well-established principles
of natural justice. Since there was no charge in this respect, no inquiry was
made as to whether the petitioner was responsible for the loss, allegedly
sustained by the government. Accordingly, this penalty imposed upon the
writ petitioner for recovery of Rs.21,600/- is unsustainable, and thus, setaside.
16.
Now, coming to the question as to whether the writ court can
decide the proportionity of penalty imposed upon the government servant in
a disciplinary proceeding, it is noticed as already discussed in the preceding
paragraphs that the Division Bench interfered with the decision of the
Page 11
learned Single Judge only to the extent of its decision as regards the
proportionity of penalty, and remanded the matter back to the authorities
concerned to decide the appropriate penalty keeping in mind the discussion
and observations of learned Single Judge. There is no quarrel to the
proposition that the writ court has very limited jurisdiction to interfere with
the quantum of penalty imposed by the Disciplinary Authority. There is no
manner of doubt that it is within the sole discretion and power of the
decision-making authorities, once the charge of misconduct is proved.
However, it is also equally true that the writ court can definitely step into
where it finds that the discretionary power exercised by the authority
suffers from errors of law and when the decision is found to be perverse.
[underlined for emphasis]
17.
In the case of Managobinda Samantaray(supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has categorically held that the writ court exercising its
judicial power of review can examine whether the authority concerned acts
as a reasonable employer, and while imposing penalty has considered all
facts and circumstances, magnitude and the gravity of the misconduct. The
court has ample power to consider whether there is any error in decision
making process. In my opinion, when the decision of the decision making
authority appears to be perverse, suffers from non-application of mind,
considered irrelevant factors/matters, and further suffers from any logic,
Wednesbury’s principle of reasonableness, and appears to be grossly
disproportionate, the writ court will definitely intervene. Further, any
unfair or arbitrary action on the part of any of the executive authorities,
will tantamount to violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India; and
Page 12
when there is violation of well-enshrined doctrine of equality, the court
must step in to correct injustice.
[emphasis supplied]
18.
Added to it, while deciding on a punishment, courts must ensure
the penalty is proportionate and fair, taking into account the nature and
gravity of the offence. In the case of Ved Prakash Gupta vs. M/s Delton
Cable India (P) Ltd., reported in 1984(2) SLR 5, a three-Judge bench of the
Supreme Court, however, held that Article 14 of the Constitution can be
applied to cases of employer and employees with reference to the
punishment to be awarded for misconduct, the punishment awarded muct
be “shockingly disproportionate”. The Supreme Court observed at page 11
that “we, therefore, of the opinion that the punishment awarded to the
appellant is shockingly disproportionate regard being had to the charge
framed against him”.
[underlined for emphasis]
In the case of Bhagatram vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.,
reported in (1983) 2 SCC 442: AIR 1983 SC 453, this principle ensures that
penalties are not excessive or unfair in light of the misconduct committed.
It is settled proposition of law that in a disciplinary proceeding, punishment
must commensurate with the gravity of the misconduct.
[underlined for emphasis]
19.
In the context of the case, it is found that the learned Single
Judge as well as Division Bench of this court have held that Article of
Charge No.-IV has been proved out of 5(five) nos. of Articles of Charge. In
my opinion, in that case, penalty also should have been imposed on the
basis of the charge established against the delinquent government servant. It
Page 13
is apparent that on remission, both the Disciplinary Authority as well as the
Appellate Authority have failed to visualize this aspect that quantum of
punishment must not be the same when the Courts held that out of 5(five)
Articles of Charge only 1(one) charge is proved. The quantum of
punishment must commensurate to the magnitude or degree of misconduct.
To say it otherwise, the quantum of punishment must be proportionate to
the degree of misconduct. Since, on remission also the respondents failed to
comply this principle, and when the pervisity is obvious on the face of the
orders and records, particularly, when out of 5(five) Articles of Charge, the
court held that only 1(one) charge has been proved, the quantum of
punishment must be reduced. Accordingly, the penalty order dated 18 th
July, 2024 (Annexure 13 to the writ petition) of withholding 3(three)
increments with cumulative effect alongwith penalty of recovery of
Rs.21,600/- from the salary of the petitioner, passed by the Disciplinary
Authority and upheld by the Appellate Authority are interfered with being
not sustainable, and thus, order of punishments, stated supra, is accordingly
modified.
20.
In my opinion, considering the magnitude of misconduct, as it is
held that out of 5(five) Articles of Charge, only 1(one) charge, that is,
Charge No.-IV has been proved, in my opinion, withholding of 1(one)
increment with cumulative effect will be equitious and proportionate. It is
further made clear that if, in the meantime, any amount is recovered beyond
1(one) increment from the salary of the petitioner, it must be refunded to
the salary account of the petitioner within a period of 3(three) months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
Page 14
21.
The instant writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated
here-in-above.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed off.
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review