Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.929 of 2022
Sri Piklu Banik, S/O- Sri Gopal Banik, of North Maheshpur, Sepahijala,
Tripura, Pin-799131
………Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Union of India, Represented by the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India.
2. The Under Secretary, Staff Selection Commission, Block No.12, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi-110091
3. Staff Selection Commission represented by Chairman, Block No.12,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi110091
4. North Eastern Regional Office, Staff Selection Commission, Gauhati,
represented by Regional Director, Housefed Complex, West End Block,
Last Gate- Basistha Road, P.O.- Assam Sachivalaya, Dispur, Gauhati781006
5. Director General, CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force) (Recruitment
Branch) East Block-07, Level-4, Sector-01, R.K. Puram, New Delhi110066 (Ministry of Home Affairs)
6. Review Medical Examination Board, represented by the Presiding
Officer RME Centre, CH Shillong, Umpling, Mawarliang, Shillong,
Meghalaya, Pin-793006.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Rajib Saha, Advocate,
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Deputy SGI.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
28/06/2023
Heard Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel for petitioner and Mr.
Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy SGI for the respondents.
2.
Petitioner appeared in a selection process for appointment to
the post of Constable (GD) in Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs). His
name appeared in the final selection list. He was asked to undergo
medical test. In the medical test, the doctors under respondents-Union of
India found him “Unfit on account of Right Tympanic Membrane
Perforation”. Petitioner took reports of an opinion of the doctors of Indira
Gandhi Memorial Hospital, Government of Tripura, Agartala where the
doctors examined him and found that “Tympanic Membrane in both ears
appear normal”.
3.
Since appointment was denied to the petitioner, he
approached this Court in the present writ petition. By order dated
03.11.2022, notices were issued and respondents were directed not to fill
up one post of Constable (GD), CAPF till decision of this writ petition.
After filing of Counter Affidavit, the matter was taken up on 16.05.2023
when the following order was passed:
“Petitioner's candidature for the post of Constable (GD) in
Central Armed Police Forces was rejected on grounds of
medical unfitness. The Review Medical Board held on
28.09.2022 overruled two out of three defects found by the
Detailed Medical Examination (DME, for short) held on
20.09.2022 but accepted the defect about Tympanic Membrane
Perforation. The defects relating to fissure in anus and defective
distant visual acuity were, however, not found by the Review
Medical Board. Petitioner had got himself examined in two
Government hospitals of Tripura, i.e. Indira Gandhi Memorial
Hospital, Agartala, West Tripura on 14.10.2022 and in AGMC &
GBP Hospital, Agartala, West Tripura on 20.10.2022, (both
Annexure-H to the writ petition) where no such defect was
noticed.
Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel for the
petitioner, has relied upon clause 6(d) of the office memorandum
dated 31.05.2021 which, according to her, lays down that the
Review Medical Board may obtain opinion of concerned
specialists or super specialists of Govt. Medical College and
Hospital in case of any doubt. Therefore, in cases of rejection in
review medical examination, clinical findings should be
corroborated with confirmatory tests/investigations/opinion of
specialists/super specialists of Govt. Hospitals/Medical
Colleges/Govt. approved private medical centres, whichever and
wherever applicable (Annexure-I).
It is the case of the petitioner that no such opinion
of specialists/super specialists of any Govt. Medical College and
Hospital was taken into consideration before rejecting the
candidature of the petitioner by the Review Medical Board on
the aforesaid medical defect, i.e. Tympanic Membrane
Perforation.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy S.G.I.
appearing for the respondents, has pointed out that the standards
of examination in the DME or in the Review Medical Board are
different from that of the Government hospitals. As such, such
opinions obtained from Government Medical College and
Hospital are not worthy of rejecting the opinion of the Review
Medical Board which comprises of three doctors, one of them
being a specialist. As such, this Court may in exercise of writ
jurisdiction not examine the opinion of the experts which are
undertaken on a prescribed set of medical standards for
recruitment.
On consideration of the rival submissions of the
parties and the fact that the Review Medical Board has overruled
two defects out of three pointed out in the DME and that
petitioner has been found fit by the doctors of two Government
hospitals, i.e. Indira Gandhi Memorial Hospital, Agartala, West
Tripura and AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, West Tripura
subsequently on 14.10.2022 and 20.10.2022 and it is also
apparent that the Review Medical Board had not obtained
opinion of any concerned specialist or super specialist of
Government Medical College and Hospital in the background
that out of three defects, two had itself been overruled by the
Review Medical Board, this Court is of the view that the
petitioner should be subjected to medical examination by the
specialized hospital under the respondent-BSF. As informed,
such hospital is at Shillong named "Composite Hospital (CH),
CAPF, BSF, Shillong". As such, let the petitioner appear before
the Superintendent, Composite Hospital (CH), CAPF, BSF,
Shillong on 31.05.2023 at 10.30 a.m. The authorities, i.e. the
DIG (MED), at the Composite Hospital (CH), CAPF, BSF,
Shillong shall conduct a detailed medical examination of the
petitioner to satisfy whether the petitioner suffers from the defect
of Tympanic Membrane Perforation as found by the Review
Medical Board. One of the doctors should be the specialist in
ENT Department. Needless to say, the medical board should be
comprised of doctors/specialists other than those who conducted
the Review Medical Board. Let the report be submitted on the
next date by the learned Deputy S.G.I.”
4.
Petitioner has, thereafter, been subjected to Review Medical
Examination before the Composite Hospital (CH), CAPF, BSF, Shillong
on 31.05.2023. The Review Medical Examination report has been
furnished in a sealed cover by letter dated 03.06.2023 and has been placed
before the Court by learned Deputy SGI. The sealed cover has been
opened in Court and perused. Learned counsel for both the parties have
also perused the same. The opinion of the Review Medical Board
comprising 4(four) Medical Officers, one of them being an ENT
Specialist is extracted hereunder:
“BORDER SECURITY FORCE
FOR RECRUITMENT OF CT(GD)IN CAPFS, NIA, SSF AND
RIFLE MAN IN AR 2021
FORM NO-4
RESULT OF REVIEW MEDICAL EXAMINATION
(OF UNFIT CANDIDATES IN DME)
PHOTO
Roll No.
: 5601008783
Name of the candidate
: PIKLU BANIK
Gender
: MALE
Father’s/Husband’s name : GOPAL BANIK
Identification Marks
(i) BLACK MOLE ON LEFT SIDE UPPER PART OF NECK
(ii) BLACK MOLE ON DORSUM OF RIGHT HAND
Candidate’s Signature (In presence of the Board) – Sd/- Illegible
1.
2.
3.
Place
Date
Reasons for Medical Unfitness:- PERFORATION OF RIGHT TYMPANIC MEMBRANE.
Brief of Review Medical Examination & finding thereof:- The board having examined the hide
autoscopy conducted for both tympanic membrane and it was intact (No perforation found).
Rinnes test – Positive (both ear), Weber’s test- centralized (both ear). No visible scar around
the ear seen, photograph of both TM attached.
Final opinion :
(a)
FIT :
FIT
(b)
Unfit on account of :
X
: CAPF, CH-BSF, SHILLONG
: 31.05.2023
P.O.
…….. Sd/- Illegible
Dr. Kaushal Kishore
Chief Medical Officer (SG)
CAPF & CH BSF Patgaon
Member-1
……..Sd/- Illegible
(Dr. Dameshwa Paslein), AC (MO)
193 Bn BSF (With Seal)
Member-2
….. Sd/- Illegible
Dr. Valera Pasi, AC (MO),
110 Bn BSF (With Seal)
Co-opted Member-1
….. Sd/- Illegible
(Dr. Argya Jyoti Ghosh),
Contractual/(ENT Specialist)
172 Bn BSF (With Seal)
Result of review medical examination received
Sd/- Illegible
Signature of the candidate
NOTE: The decision of the Review Medical Board will be final. No appeal will be entertained
against the findings of the Review Medical Board in Review Medical Examination.”
5.
The report, unequivocally and unanimously opines that both
tympanic membranes of the petitioner were found intact and no
perforation was found. Petitioner has been declared medically fit by the
Review Medical Board. Having regard to the opinion furnished by the
Review Medical Board pursuant to the order dated 16.05.2023, the issue
has been resolved.
6.
Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits
that the respondents may be directed to consider the case of the petitioner
and appoint him on the post of Constable (GD) in the Central Armed
Police Forces as one post had been directed to be kept vacant till decision
of this case vide order dated 03.11.2022. Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned
Deputy SGI for the respondents, submits that writ petition may be
disposed of in the light of the opinion of the Review Medical Board
finding the petitioner medically fit with suitable directions upon the
respondent authorities to appoint him on the post of Constable (GD)
against the vacant sanctioned post.
7.
Having regard to the aforesaid facts and circumstances and
that the petitioner has been found medically fit by the Review Medical
Board which was the only reason for his non-selection, the claim of the
petitioner succeeds. Respondents are directed to offer him appointment
after due verification of his essential credentials and other norms under
the CAPF against the post kept vacant pursuant to the order dated
03.11.2022 passed by this Court within a period of 6(six) weeks from the
date of receipt of copy of this order.
8.
Writ petition is allowed in the manner and to the extent
indicated hereinabove. Let the report of the Review Medical Board be
kept along with the record.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pijush
MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2023.07.06 12:29:35 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review