Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.772 of 2023
1. Sri Partha Pratim Das
S/O: Late Kusum Kr. Das,
R/O: Ramnagar Road No.-1, Near 3rd crossing, PO: Ramnagar,
PS: West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799002.
2. Sri Sutanu Das,
S/O: Late Satyendra Mohan Das,
R/O: LN Bari Road, Besides Sphulinga Club, Banamalipur,
P.O: Agartala, PS: East Agartala, Dist: West Tripura, Pin-799001
3. Sri Samir Sarkar,
S/O: Late Satyaranjan Sarkar,
R/O: Down Town Apartment, First Floor, IC Block –A,
78, Purbayan Road, Kathgola, Panihati,
North 24 Paragana, West Bengal-700110.
4. Sri Anjan Banik,
S/O: Late Satyendra Ch. Banik,
R/O: Maharanipur, Kalibari Road No.2, P.O- Chakmaghat,
P.S – Teliamura, District – Khowai, Pin – 799205.
------ Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by its Secretary, PWD (R & B),
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
PO- Secretariat, PS- NCC,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Chief Engineer, PWD (R & B),
Government of Tripura, Agartala, Government of Tripura,
PO-Secretariat, PS-New Capital Complex,
District-West Tripura, Pin- 799010.
3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
P.O- Secretariat, P.S- New Capital Complex,
District-West Tripura, Pin- 799010.
------ Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G. A.
Date of hearing
:
10.01.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
20.01.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The present petitioners have filed this writ petition seeking
the following reliefs:
i) Issue notice upon the Respondents.
ii) Call for the records.
iii) Issue rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why the Petitioners shall not be granted the benefit of
ACP-II from the date of completion of 17 years of service
upon upgradation to the Post of Junior engineer (Electrical)
(Grade-I) along with all arrears of financial benefit.
AND
Issue rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why the Petitioners shall not be granted the benefit of
MACP-III from the date of completion of another 8 years of
service upon grant of ACP-II benefit in terms of the prayer
above alongwith all arrears of financial benefit.
AND
Issue rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why appropriate direction shall not be issued for fixation
of pay of the Petitioners upon grant of ACP-II and MACPIII benefits and further issue appropriate Writ to grant the
Petitioners arrears of such financial benefit.
iv) And after hearing the parties, be pleased to make the
rule absolute.
AND/OR
Pass any other Order/Orders as deemed fit and proper.
AND
For this act of kindness your humble petitioners as in duty
bound shall ever remain grateful.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. A. Bhaumik appearing for the
petitioners and also heard Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. M. Debbarma
appearing for the State-respondents.
3.
The facts of this writ petition are, in short, is that the
petitioners were appointed as Junior Engineer (Electrical) (Grade-II)
vide office order dated 03.04.1989 under the PWD (R & B),
Government of Tripura on the recommendation of Tripura Public
Service Commission in the pay scale of Rs.1450-3710 plus admissible
allowances. Thereafter, the petitioners rendered their service to the
utmost satisfaction of their authorities.
4.
The Finance Department, Government of Tripura issued one
addendum on 30.03.1989 wherein it was provided that the Junior
Engineer, Grade-II upon completion of their 4(four) years of service in
the pay scale of Junior Engineer (Grade-II) will move to the pay scale
of Junior Engineer (Grade-I) along with the designation of Junior
Engineer (Grade-I). As such, in view of the said addendum dated
30.03.1989, the present petitioners on completion of their 4(four)
years of service as Junior Engineer (Electrical) (Grade-II) were
designated as Junior Engineer(Grade-I) and accordingly the pay scale
of Junior Engineer(Grade-I) i.e. Rs.2100-4530 was extended to the
petitioners vide office order dated 31.05.1993 w.e.f. 04.04.1993,
04.04.1993, 12.04.1993 and 04.04.1993 respectively and since then
the
petitioners
were
designated
as
Junior
Engineer(Grade-
I)(Electrical) and were serving in the said pay scale of Rs.2100-4530
as revised from time to time.
5.
According to the petitioners, on up-gradation to the pay scale
of Rs.2100-4530, the petitioners were treated as CAS-I consumed by
them. But after extension of the pay scale of the Junior Engineer
(Electrical) (Grade-I) which was considered as CAS-I consumed by the
petitioners, the petitioners did not get any promotion in their entire
service life and as such, the petitioners were entitled to the benefit of
ACP-II from the date of completion of 17(seventeen) years of their
service from the date of extension of the upgraded scale of Junior
Engineer (Grade-I) and thereafter on completion of another 8(eight)
years of service, the petitioners were entitled to the benefit of MACPIII. But the petitioners were not extended with the benefit of ACP-II
followed by MACP-III.
6.
It was further asserted that if 17(seventeen) years of
continuous service is counted from the date of up-gradation scale
then the petitioners would be entitled to the benefit of ACP-II w.e.f.
04.04.2010, 04.04.2010,12.04.2010 and 04.04.2010 respectively but
the said benefit of ACP-II was also denied to the petitioners by the
State-respondents and the petitioners would also be entitled to the
benefit of MACP-III from the date of completion of their another
8(eight) years of service upon grant of ACP-II as the petitioners
completed their 8(eight) years of service without any promotion but
said benefit of MACP-III was also denied to the petitioners. In the
mean time, the petitioner Nos.2 and 3 have already retired from their
service on 31.01.2023 and 28.02.2022 respectively without any
benefit of ACP-II and MACP-III and also without any single promotion
in their service career.
7.
It was further stated that similar issue arose with Junior
Engineer
(Grade-II)
(Electrical)
appointed
under
the
Power
Department, Government of Tripura and the said Junior Engineers
were given the benefit of auto up-gradation on completion of 4(four)
years of continuous service and extended with the benefit of pay scale
of Junior Engineer (Grade-I). However, said Junior Engineers were
also
denied
the
benefit
of
ACP-II
followed
by
MACP-III
and
accordingly,
the
Junior
Engineers
of
the
Power
Department
approached to this High Court by filing writ petition bearing No.WP(C)
No.488 of 2019 and other connected matters and vide judgment
dated 03.03.2021 passed in WP(C) No.488 of 2019, this High Court
observed that the said employees would be entitled to the benefit of
ACP-II from the date of completion of their 17 years of continuous
service from the date of auto up-gradation to the pay scale of Junior
Engineer (Grade-I) and also would get the benefit of MACP-III on
completion of their another 8 years of service from the date of
extension of ACP-II benefit.
8.
The petitioners further stated that since the petitioners were
appointed under the PWD Department so they are governed by the
Tripura Engineering Service Rules, 1987 and the Engineers appointed
under the Power Department are also governed by the Tripura Power
Engineering Service Rules, 1987 and both the service rules i.e. the
Tripura Engineering Service Rules,1987 and the Tripura Power
Engineering Service Rules, 1987 are “Pari materia statutes” and
therefore the judgment and order passed by this High Court as
mentioned above would also apply in the case of the present
petitioners.
9.
It was also submitted that highlighting the grievances the
petitioners made a representation before the Respondent No.2
through proper channel which was forwarded by the Executive
Engineer, Internal Electrification Division to the Superintending
Engineer vide forwarding letter dated 25.07.2023 but no response
was taken by the State-respondents.
10.
Thereafter, the present petitioners through their engaged
counsel served the legal notice upon the respondents on 14.11.2023
praying for grant of ACP-II and MACP-III benefit from the respective
dates
but
the
same
was also
not
considered
by the
State-
respondents. Hence the present petitioners have filed this writ petition
seeking the reliefs as stated earlier.
11.
The State-respondents have contested the case by filing the
counter affidavit denying the assertions of the petitioners in their writ
petition and also took the plea that by way of up-gradation, the
present petitioners have consumed all the benefits. As such, the
petitioners are not entitled to get any benefit in this case. It was
further submitted by the State-respondents that under ACP scheme
mentioned in Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009,
[in short „TSCS(RP)‟], the benefits given to an employees in case of
promotion and benefits given in case of scale upgradation are
different. Further, the concept of promotion and that of scale
upgradation are not equated in the ROP rules and pay scale available
on promotion and pay scale payable upon the scale upgradation have
been consciously made different in the rules. As per Rule 10(7) of
TSCS(RP) rules, 2009, the benefit of next available Grade Pay shall be
the admissible benefit of financial upgradation. So, Rule 10(7) does
not speak that scale upgradation would mean the scale of the
promotion post. It simply speaks about the next available Grade Pay
which is reflected in Part-D of the Rules. Hence, the petitioners have
clouded their understanding considering that they are entitled to
higher pay of the promotion post due to ACP.
Further, as Rule 10(1) of TSCS (RP) Rules, 2009 limits the
number of scale upgradations to a maximum of 03 (three) in respect
of employees in PB-3 subject to condition that the concerned
employee had not already consumed 03(three) numbers of benefits of
scale upgradations including promotion already. Rule 10(2) also says
that each case of promotion or scale upgradation may be treated as
consumption of one ACP. If Rule 10(2) is studied with reference to
Rule 10(7), it would be clear that ACP suggests that each case of
consuming next available Grade Pay due to a single promotion
relative to Grade Pay of the initial post at the time of joining of
employee, is also a criteria for determining the remaining number of
entitlements of ACP. So, “promotion” and “scale upgradation” has
been consciously kept separate in the ROP Rules, thereby meaning
that each case of consumption of next Grade Pay availed with respect
to Grade Pay of the initial post at the time of his joining, shall also be
treated as one ACP. There is, however, no bar in consuming more
than one upgradations by way of promotion. In such case, the
number of scales consumed shall also be counted as ACP.
In the instant case, petitioners joined in the pay scale of
Rs.1450-3710/- [which has been revised to Grade Pay-Rs.4200/-, PB2 under TSCS (RP) Rules, 2009]. By way of scale upgradtion, they
were allowed the pay scale of Rs.2100-4530/- (which has been
revised to Grade pay-Rs.4800/-, PB-3 under ROP Rules, 2009). In
between Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- and Rs.4800/-, there were two more
Grade Pay i.e., Rs.4,400/- and Rs.4,600/-. Had the petitioners not
received the movement to Grade Pay of Rs.4800/- directly, they
would have received the next available Grade Pay of Rs.4400/- as
ACP-I and Rs.4600/- as ACP-II and followed by Rs.4800/- as ACP-III.
But, due to direct movement to Grade Pay of Rs.4800/-, the
petitioners have consumed both the Grade Pay of Rs.4400/- and
Rs.4600/-. The ACP scheme does not say that more than one Grade
Pay
cannot
be
consumed
due
to
promotion
but
each
such
consumption of scale upgradation has to be counted for calculation
the balance of financial upgradations. So, it can be said that the
Petitioners have already consumed 03(three) scale upgradation.
It is further added here that in the instant case, it can be said
that by way of scale upgradation, an employee moves to the next
higher pay scale but by way of promotion an employee can jump
multiple pay scales to reach the pay scale of the promotion post
without touching the intermediate pay scale. That does not mean that
the employee has not consumed the intermediate pay scales because
without climbing the ladders of intermediate pay scales the higher pay
scales cannot be achieved.
Therefore, the consumption of the pay scale of Grade Pay of
Rs.4400/- and Rs.4600/- while moving from Grade Pay of Rs.4200/to Rs.4800/- shall be treated as consumption of 03(three) scale
upgradations. Hence, the petitioners are not entitled to get the benefit
of 2nd Financial upgradation (ACP-2) on completion of 17 years
continuous and satisfactory service in the post of TES, Grade V(A) in
the light of TSCS (RP) Rules, 2009. And, for the same reason as
stated above the petitioners are not entitled to get the benefit of 3rd
Financial upgradation (MACP-3) on completion of 25 years of
continuous and satisfactory service in the post of TES, Grade V(A) in
the light of TSCS (RP) Rules, 2017 which came into force w.e.f.
01/04/2017
&
was
published
on
11/07/2017
vide
Finance
Department‟s Notification No.F.7(2)-FIN(PC)/2017.
So, finally the State-respondents prayed for dismissal of the
writ petition.
12.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the
petitioners in support of his submission in addition to the judgment
referred in the writ petition also relied upon some more other
judgments of this High Court passed in connection with case
No.WP(C) No.371 of 2014 dated 29.05.2015, W.A. No.191 of
dated
12.01.2021,
WP(C)
No.194
of
dated
03.05.2021, W.A. No.221 of 2021 dated 13.09.2021. Relying
upon those judgments of the High Court, Learned Counsel for the
petitioners submitted that the case of the present petitioners is
squarely covered by the principles of the said judgments. So, in view
of the said citations, the present petitioners are also entitled to the
same benefit in this case given in those cases.
13.
In the case at hand, all the petitioners were moved to the
post of Junior Engineer (Grade-I) from Junior Engineer(Grade-II) after
completion of their 4(four) years of service with scale up-gradation in
the year 1993 with the benefit of promotional scale along with revised
pay scale of pay applicable at the relevant point of time as per ROP
rules. Thereafter, the petitioner had completed 17 years of service
without promotion and after that, they also completed 25 years of
service without any promotion. As such, as per ROP rules of the State,
the petitioners would be entitled to the 2 nd and 3rd ACP as they had
served under the respondents for 25 years without any break-up but
the 2nd and 3rd ACP were denied by the State-respondents on the
pretext that the Finance Department, State of Tripura vide a
memorandum dated F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008 dated 14.09.2009 had
issued a clarificatory note which reads as under:
“7. Respondents stand is the clarification of the Finance
Department issued vide Memorandum dated 14.09.2009
(Annexure-II of the counter affidavit) and both side
referred Sl. No.10 of the said Memorandum, wherein the
clarification has been given as under:
Sl.
No.
10.
14.
Point
on
which
clarification sought
It is noticed that in a few
isolated cases in certain
Departments
an
employee entered in the
pay scale of Rs.33007100/- got promotion to
the scale of Rs.42008650/-. Thereafter he got
CAS benefit and moved to
the scale of Rs.500010,300/-. After revision
under TSCS(RP) Rules,
2009, and on completion
of 25 years
of service
without
further
promotion, if he claims to
get the benefit of 3rd ACP
for moving to the Grade
Pay corresponding to prerevised
pay
scale
of
Rs.5500-10,700/-,
whether it is permissible.
Clarification
The claim of 3rd ACP
in the instant case for
moving to the Grade
Pay
against
prerevised
scale
of
Rs.5500-10700/is
not admissible on the
ground
that
while
entering in the prerevised pay scale of
Rs.5000-10,300/-, he
has consumed 3 scale
upliftment
i.e.
Rs.4000-7890/-,
Rs4200-8650/-,
Rs.5000-10300/-.
The State-respondents also took the plea that the petitioners
availing so many intermediary pay scales had received the benefit of
scale upgradation, which disentitled them to get the benefit of second
and third ACP. In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for
the petitioners also relied upon Sub-rule-2 of Rule-10 of ROP Rules,
which reads as under:
“10(2). While determining eligibility of the Government
employees under this ACT, it should be considered how
many times the concerned employee got the benefit of
scale upgradation including promotion after his direct
entry into the service in the State Govt. or, as the case
may be, after his direct entry into the cadre service of
the State Govt. in which he is presently serving. Each
case of promotion or scale upgradation availed by him
after his direct entry into cadre where he is presently
serving or, as the case may be, in the post/service of a
Department will be treated as consumption of one ACT.
This will mean that for those employees who entered
the cadre service through promotion, the benefit of this
promotion along with promotion/scale upgradation
availed by him before entry into the cadre service will
also be counted as consumption of ACP.”
15.
I have also perused the said rule. On bare perusal of Rule
10(2) of ROP rules, it is clear that consideration should be given as to
how many times the concerned employee of a cadre got the benefit of
scale upgradation including promotion after their direct entry into
service and each case of promotion or scale upgradation availed by
them shall be considered as one unit which means the scale
upgradation with promotion has direct nexus with the granting of
ACPs.
16.
This High Court in WP(C) No.371 of 2014 [titled as
Harisadhan Adhikari & Others v. The State of Tripura] at the
time of delivery of the said judgment interpreted the „clarificatory
note‟ issued by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura dated
14.09.2009 as follow:
“The above clarification issued by the Finance
Department of the Government of Tripura cannot
override the provisions of Rule 10(2) of the ROP Rules,
2009. Rule 10(2) has a force of law but the clarification
as mentioned above in Annexure-II to the counter
affidavit has no force of law. The clarification, therefore
cannot take away the right of the petitioners which is
prescribed by rules. Rule 10(2) clearly prescribes that
one ACP or one promotion should be considered as one
unit and because of one promotion the petitioners
jumped one pay scale they cannot be said that they got
the benefit of two scale upgradation and therefore they
shall be deprived of the second ACP.”
17.
More so, a division bench of this High Court dealing with a
similar issue in W.A. No.191 of 2020 [titled as The State of
Tripura & others v. Sri Bipul Ranjan De and Others] further
clarified the law in this regard as follows:
“6. It is well settled that the subordinate legislation
such as, statutory rules need not always cover every
aspect of the subject. Often times these rules leave
what is described as play in the joint where the
executive can always issue circulars and directions to
cover areas where the rules are silent. In that context, a
clarificatory circular may have one of the two purposes
to achieve. It may be in the nature of a clarification,
making explicit what is otherwise implicit within the
rules or may provide for filling a gap which is otherwise
left in the rules. In either case, exercise of executive
powers would be perfectly valid and legitimate.
However, when such a clarification runs head on
counter to the plain language used in statutory rules
and the reasonable interpretation thereof, the circular
would not have an effect of giving a different colour or
meaning to the rules. In this context, we may notice the
statutory provisions applicable.
7. The ROP, 1999 contained a Career Advancement
Scheme (Modified) which was later on substituted by
the Assured Career Progression Scheme provided in
Rule 10 of ROP, 2009. Relevant portion of Rule 10 of
ROP, 2009 reads as under:
10. Introduction of a new scheme titled Assured Career
Progression (ACP) Scheme with effect from 1st January,
2006 replacement of existing CAS introduced under
TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 1999.
***
***
***
8. Under sub-rule (1) of Rule 10 thus all Government
employees in Pay Bands 1 to 3 would be entitled to a
maximum of three financial upgradations, after 10, 17
and 25 years of service provided he or she has not got
up to three numbers of benefits of scale upgradations
including promotion already. In other words, the thrust
of sub-rule(1) of Rule 10 is to grant the benefit of three
number of scale upgradations which may also be
embedded in promotion.
9. Sub-rule(2) of Rule 10 further clarifies this position
when it provides when it provides that while
determining eligibility of the Government employees
under the said ACP scheme, it would be considered how
many times the concerned employee got the benefit of
scale upgradation including promotion after his direct
entry into the service of the State Government. Each
case of promotion and scale upgradation availed by him
after his direct entry in the cadre will be treated as
consumption of one ACP.
10. A combined reading of sub-rules(1) and (2) of Rule
10 of ROP, 2009 would convince us that what is of
relevance and importance for grant or denial of the
benefit of ACP to an employee is a question whether he
has already availed of a particular stage of scale
upgradation or got the benefit of promotion. If answer
to this question is in the affirmative, the employee
cannot stake the claim for yet another scale upgradation
under the said ACP. This is significant since in case of
the petitioners they have admittedly received only one
promotion since their direct entry on a post in
Government service. It is wholly fortuitous that under
the relevant rules between the scale attached to the
promotional post and the feeder cadre there were two
intermediatory scales. Resultantly, when the petitioners
were promoted to the post of Naib-subedar, in plain
terms they received one promotion. In the process if
they have jumped over the intermediatory pay scales,
the same would be of no consequence so far as their
claim for the benefit of ACP under Rule 10 is concerned.
What the sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 10 require in
order to deny such benefit to the Government employee
would be that he or she has availed of multiple scale
upgradations. Under sub-rule (2) the legislature has
specifically used the words “it should be considered
how many times the concerned employee got the
benefit of scale upgradation including promotion……”
Thus, the emphasis on the number of times either the
promotion or scale upgradation has been made available
to the employee and not how many scale upgradation
incidentally happened under one single promotion.”
18.
More so, in another judgment dated 13.09.2021 the Division
Bench of this High Court dealing with a similar issue titled as The
State of Tripura & others v. Sri Akhil Dutta & others relying
upon the judgment of this High Court dated 12.01.2021 in case of
The State of Tripura v. Sri Bipul Ranjan De and others (supra)
also dismissed the appeal preferred by the State-respondents.
19.
Here in the case at hand, on perusal of the relevant papers, it
appears that the present petitioners, after the extension of pay scale
of Junior Engineer (Electrical) (Grade-I) which is considered to be
CAS-I consumed by the petitioners, they did not get any promotion in
their entire service life. Even inspite of completion of their 17 years of
service from the date of extension of the upgraded scale of Junior
Engineer (Grade-I) and thereafter on completion of further 8 years of
service, they were not extended the benefit of ACP-II and MACP-III as
per ROP rules of 2009 in view of the clarificatory note 14.09.2009 of
the
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Tripura.
Thus
the
clarificatory note as observed by this Court in the judgment as quoted
above cannot come in the way of second and third MACP to the
petitioners as they were not promoted at any point of time and their
scale upgradation in the intermediary scale cannot be said to be scale
upgradation on promotion. The increased pay scale under revised pay
structure cannot be equated to the scale upgradation on promotion in
terms of the scheme of Rule 10(2) of ROP rules, 1999 and 2009.
More so, this Court already held that the clarificatory note
dated 14.09.2009 of the Finance Department, Government of Tripura
has no force in the eye of law.
20.
Thus, in view of the settled proposition, I find no reason to
treat the petitioner in different manner then those of the petitioners in
the case of Harisadhan Adhikari(supra) and Bipul Ranjan
De(supra) and Akhil Dutta(supra). As such, I direct the Staterespondents to grant the benefit of second ACP followed by MACP-III
to the present petitioners for the reason that they have not promoted
during their service period to the higher post within the period when
they completed 17 years and 25 years of service.
21.
It is further made clear that the respondents cannot take the
plea of clarificatory note dated 14.09.2009 to deny the benefit of
second
ACP
Accordingly,
followed
the
relief
by
MACP-III
claimed
by
to
the
the
present
petitioners
petitioners.
as
stated
hereinabove as mentioned in the writ petition stands allowed. The
benefit of ACPs, as sought for hereinabove shall be paid to the
petitioners within a period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt
of copy of the judgment.
It is also further clarified that the State-respondents shall
extend all other ancillary benefits including pensionary benefits as
may be applicable to the petitioners, but without any arrears.
With the above
observations,
this
writ
petition
disposed of.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
DATTA
Date: 2025.01.21 16:52:09 -08'00'
stands
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review