Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.540 of 2024
Sri Padma Mohan Tripura,
Son of Sri Kharendra Tripura, resident of Chatakchari, P.O. Sonai
Bazaar, P.S. Sabroom, Dist. South Tripura, PIN 799145.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by its Principal Secretary, Public Works
Department (R&B), Govt. of Tripura, P.O. Secretariat, P.S.
New Capital Complex, Dist. West Tripura, PIN 799010.
2.
The Deputy Secretary, Public Works Department (R&B),
Govt. of Tripura, P.O. Secretariat, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Dist. West Tripura, PIN 799010.
3.
The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (R&B),
Govt. of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, Dist.
West Tripura, PIN 799001.
4.
Engineering Officer to the Chief Engineer,
Public Works Department (R&B), Govt. of Tripura, P.O.
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, Dist. West Tripura, PIN 799001.
5.
The Principal Secretary, Social Welfare and Social
Education Department,
Govt. of Tripura, P.O. Secretariat, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Dist. West Tripura, PIN 799010.
6.
Sri Dharmendra Reang,
Son of Unknown, Presently serving as Junior Overseer in the
Office of the Sub-Divisional Officer (Asst. Engineer), Water
Resource Sub-Division, Kanchanpur, Govt. of Tripura, P.O. +
P.S. Kanchanpur, Dist. North Tripura, PIN 799270.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate.
Ms. I. Chakma, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
14th August, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. for the Staterespondents.
[2]
was
The case of the petitioner is that in the year 2000, he
appointed
as
Work
Assistant
vide
Memorandum
dated
23.10.2000 (Annexure 1) and after about 23 years there from he
was promoted to the post of Junior Overseer (Group-C Technical)
vide Memorandum dated 30.11.2023 (Annexure 4). By said
promotional order, total 100 persons were promoted though as per
the counter affidavit submitted by the respondents, there were only
83 numbers of total vacant posts (UR-49, ST-19, SC-15). But, as
the Department decided to give promotion to total 100 nos. of
employees, 17 nos. of employees were promoted by creating
supernumerary posts. After such promotion order was issued, it
was detected that 3(three) nos. of Work Assistant under PH
category namely, Sri Manindra Debnath, Sri Dharmendra Reang,
(ST) i.e. respondent no.6 and another Smt. Sabita Debnath were
missed out from promotion due to inadvertent mistake, rather in
their place, other three persons (one from SC category and two
from UR category) were promoted who were junior to them. The
Department
thereafter
examined
the
matter
afresh
and
recommended promotion of said 3 (three) persons against PH
category
alongwith
(one) candidate of SC category. The
respondents while going to accommodate these 4(four) persons in
the promotional list and simultaneously to maintain the total
number of promotees to be 100, ultimately cancelled the promotion
order of the present petitioner vide said Memorandum dated
17.02.2024 (Annexure 5) along with promotion of said three
persons who were promoted earlier against PH category of posts.
The
petitioner,
as
stated,
was
actually
promoted
against
supernumerary post and was at the bottom of the promotional list
as ST candidate and while going to accommodate said PH category
of candidate i.e. respondent no.6 who is also a ST candidate, the
petitoner was excluded from the promotion list. For purposeful
reference, the entire notification dated 17.02.2024 is extracted
hereunder:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (R&B)
TRIPURA, AGARTALA
No.F.6(40)-PWD(E)/2023/18606-86
Dated,Agartala, 17/02/2024
NOTIFICATION
In pursuance to Notification No.F.2(24)-GA(P&T)/2021 dated
22.06.2021 of the Deputy Secretary GA(P&T) Department, Govt. of
Tripura & subsequently modification of Notification No.F.6(38)PWD(E)/2023/13,029-114 dated, Agartala 30th November, 2023.
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) is pleased to appoint the
following Work Assistant, (Group-C, Technical) to the post of Junior
Overseer (Group-C, Technical) (Non-Gazetted) on ad-hoc basis in the
pre-revised pay scale of Rs.5,700-24,000/- in PB-2 having Grade Pay
Rs.2,800/- i.e., at level-9 of the Tripura State Pay Matrix 2018 of
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) First Amendment Rules,
2018 with effect from 30.11.2023 retrospectively subject to final
income of SLP(C) No.19765-19767 of 2015 pending in the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
Junior Overseer, (Group-C, Technical) (Non-Gazetted)
Sl. No.
Name
Category
1.
Sri Rakesh Das
SC
2.
Sri
Manindra
(PH)
Debnath
UR
3.
Sri Dharmendra
(PH)
Reang
ST
4.
Smt. Sabita Debnath (PH)
UR
1.
The above officials shall continue to hold the charges of the
post presently held by them until further order.
2.
Their pay etc. shall be fixed as per normal rules.
3.
The appointment on promotions are purely on ad-hoc basis
subject to final outcome of SLP pending before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
4.
No inter-se seniority is determined/published in respect to this
ad-hoc promotion.
5.
Joining should be completed with immediate effect.
Further, ad-hoc promotion to the post of Junior Overseer
(Group-C, Technical) was offered in respect to Smt. Chandana Das
(SC, PH), Sri Chandan Datta (UR, PH), Sri Anupam Debnath (UR, PH)
& Sri Padma Mohan Tripura (ST) shall be treated as cancelled.
Sd/Deputy Secretary, PWD”
[3]
The petitioner thereafter issued legal notice to the
respondents against which from the Office of respondent no.3, a
reply was given on 06.05.2024 (Annexure 8) showing the above
said reason for exclusion of the petitioner from the promotional list.
The relevant paragraphs of the said communication is also
extracted hereinbelow:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ENGINEER (R&B)
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
No.F.6(40)-PWD(E)/2023/868
Dated. 06/05/2024.
To
Sri Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate
High Court of Tripura
Chamber No.6, High Court of Tripura
Kunjaban, Agartala, Tripura(W).
………………………..
…………………………
………………………..
Of late 3(three) no's Work Assistant under PH category Shri
Manindra Debnath (UR), Shri Dharmendra Reang (ST) & Smt. Sabita
Debnath (UR) of this Department had submitted their representation
for promotion to the post of Junior Overseer, Group-C (Technical)
with retrospective date 30.11.2023, where similarly situated persons
have been promoted.
Accordingly, Department had examined their representation
and observed that the name of 3(three) candidates Sri Manindra
Debnath (UR), Sri Dharmendra Reang (ST) & Smt. Sabita Debnath
(UR) were appears at Sl.No. 217, 218 8219 respectively in the
seniority list published on 29.09.2023 & were not considered as PH,
resulting which they could not promoted to the post of Junior
Overseer, Group-C, (Technical), on ad-hoc basis and their Junior
Work Assistants belongs to PH category appears at Sl.No 620,621 &
622 in the same seniority list have got promoted to the post of Junior
Overseer, Group-C (Technical), (Non Gazetted) on ad-hoc basis.
Accordingly, Department had rectified the Seniority List of
the Work Assistant which was published vide Memorandum
No.F.3(17)-PWD/2020/14571-654 dated 26.12.2023. Based on the
Seniority List published on dated 26.12.2023, further review
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meeting was held on
12.02.2024 at 4.00 P.M in the office Chamber of the Chief Engineer,
PWD(R&B), Agartala.
Accordingly, Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) had
recommended 4(four) left out of Work Assistant (UR-2(PH), ST-1(PH)
& SC-1) namely Sri Manindra Debnath (UR, PH). Sri Dharmendra
Reang (ST, PH) & Smt. Sabita Debnath (UR, PH) whose position
appears at SL.No.217,218 & 219 in the seniority list of Work Assistant
& may be considered for promotion to the post of Junior Overseer,
instead of Smt. Chandana Das (SC, PH), Sri Chandana Datta (UR, PH)
& Sri Anupam Debnath (UR, PH) who were promoted earlier vide
order dated 30.11.2023. So, the promotion order dated 30.11.2023
by which Smt. Chandana Das (SC, PH), Sri Chandan Datta (UR, PH) &
Sri Anupam Debnath (UR.PH) was promoted to the post of Junior
Overseer (Group-C, Technical) stands cancelled.
Further, one PH candidate belonging to ST category Shri
Dharmendra Reang ((ST, PH) (SL-218)] was considered for
promotion vide Notification dated 30.11.2023. Due to non- availability
of ST posts occupied by (ST, PH) candidate, the ad-hoc promotion of
Shri Padma Mohan Tripura (ST) vide Notification No.F.6(38)PWD(E)/2023/13029-114 dated 30.11.2023 has been cancelled.
…………………………………………..”
[4]
Now challenging the said order of cancellation of
promotion of the writ petitioner, he has filed the writ petition.
[5]
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner
strongly argues that petitioner was never promoted against any
regular
vacant
post
rather
his
promotion
was
against
one
supernumerary post and therefore, when such supernumerary post
was created only for his promotion, no person can exclude him for
said post. Learned counsel referring to the seniority list published
vide Memorandum dated 28.06.2023 (Annexure 3) submits that
the seniority position of the petitioner is at serial number 98
whereas the seniority position of the present respondent no.6 is at
serial number 225 and therefore, the promotion of the petitioner
ought not to have been disturbed while going to promote another
person who was much junior to him, more particularly when the
promotion of the petitioner was against one supernumerary post.
On the above said grounds, Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel earnestly
prays for quashing the Notification dated 17.02.2024 (Annexure 5)
so far it relates to cancellation of promotional order of the present
petitioner.
[6]
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A., on the other hand,
argues that as per the provisions of the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016 and also in accordance with the guidelines
and modalities for effecting reservation for persons with benchmark
disabilities
as
issued
by
the
State
Government
vide
Office
Memorandum dated 09.01.2019 (Annexure 9), the respondent no.6
being
a
person
with
disabilities
came
within
the
zone
of
consideration of promotion and therefore, he was promoted later
on vide above said Notification dated 17.02.2024. Mr. Sarma,
learned Addl. G.A. also submits that vide earlier promotion order
dated 30.11.2023, other three persons of PH category (SC-1, UR-2)
were promoted but those persons were junior to the respondent
no.6 and other two persons who were promoted lateron. Said three
persons, Mr. Sarma continues, submitted representation to the
department for consideration of their promotion under PH category
and therefore, promotion of other three persons namely, Smt.
Chandana Das, Sri Chandan Datta and Sri Anupam Debnath who
were promoted vide notification dated 30.11.2023 as PH category
candidates were also cancelled and in that place, other three
persons i.e. respondent no.6, Sri Manindra Debnath and Smt.
Sabita Debnath were included in the promotion list against PH
category quota. Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. further tries to
clarify that as because by the subsequent promotional order dated
17.02.2024, respondent no.6 was promoted against ST reserved
post, the person who was the last candidate in the previous
promotional order i.e. the present petitioner was excluded from the
promotional list and accordingly, his promotion was cancelled. Mr.
Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. submits that all the above said process
was done strictly for the purpose of giving effect of the provisions
of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and therefore, no
illegality or irregularity was done by the Department. Mr. Sarma,
learned
Addl.
G.A.
also
submits
that
in
that
process,
the
supernumerary post which was created for giving promotion to the
present petitioner was also cancelled.
[7]
This
Court
has
given
due
consideration
to
the
submissions made by both sides and has also considered the
relevant documents placed by the parties.
[8]
It is not disputed that by virtue of the provision of
Section 34 of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, the
promotion of respondent no.6 will be against regular ST category
post. Therefore, by virtue of promotion, the respondent no.6 would
occupy 1 (one) ST post under PH category in the regular cadre but
the present petitioner was promoted against a supernumerary post
and not against any regular sanctioned post of ST category.
[9]
The State of Tripura issued one notification bearing no.
F.2(24)-GA(P&T)/2021 dated 22.06.2021 in view of pendency of
SLP(C) No.19765-19767 of 2015 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India, by framing a policy of ad-hoc promotion and the relevant
Clause 6 and 7 of said policy are reproduced hereunder:
“6. Now, the State Government hereby notifies the following
Promotion Policy, 2021 as follows:
(i)
Rule 9 of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992 and
the provisos thereto shall be read in such a manner that only those
SC & ST candidates who have qualified solely on the basis of merit
and have never taken the benefit of reservation, will be treated to be
own merit candidates and entitle to occupy the posts meant for
general category and reservation shall be made cadre-wise.
(ii)
100 point roster shall apply only where the number of posts
in the cadre is 4(four) or more.
(iii)
Where the post in the cadre are 3(three) or less, the
3(three) point replacement roster shall be followed.
(iv)
Single post or small cadres cannot be combined to make the
number of posts more than 3(three).
7. Following the above policy, the DPC will identify employees
eligible for promotion to a particular post against the available
vacancies. After this exercise, DPC shall consider another exercise
taking into account the procedure as stated in the Rule 9(2) of the
Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992. Due to such exercise, if any
candidate is found not considered in the process as stated in the
above process, then such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc
promotion by creating supernumerary post(s).”
[10]
As per said policy, while doing the promotional exercise,
the DPC is required to go for another exercise taking into account
the procedure as envisaged in Rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC & ST
Reservation Rules, 1992 and while doing such exercise if any
candidate is found to be not considered in the process, then such
candidate is required to be considered for ad-hoc promotion by
creating supernumerary post(s). Here, in the case in hand, due to
promotion of respondent no.6 who was junior to the present
petitioner, the petitioner has been excluded or rather has been
deprived from getting promotion against ST quota and therefore, as
per said policy, he is required to be promoted by creating 1(one)
supernumerary post. In the said promotional policy, no restriction
has been imposed in the matter of creating any number of such
supernumerary
post
according
to
need.
Therefore,
without
cancelling said supernumerary post which was created for the
present petitioner in the earlier exercise of promotion, could easily
be maintained by the Department specially on the ground that the
petitioner was senior to respondent no.6 in the seniority list.
[11]
In view of above discussions, the Court thinks it proper
to allow the writ petition and accordingly it is allowed. The
respondents
are
directed
to
restore
the
promotion
of
the
respondents w.e.f. 30.11.2023 by creating 1 (one) supernumerary
post in terms of said notification dated 22.06.2021 issued by the
State of Tripura. Consequently, the notification dated 17.02.2024
issued from the office of Chief Engineer, PWD (R&B) (Annexure 5)
is quashed only to the extent of cancellation of promotional order of
the present petitioner namely, Padma Mohan Tripura.
With such observations and directions, the writ petition
is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2025.08.20 17:48:08 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review