The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. This issues with the approval of Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure), vide their ID No.28/2/2018-E.II(B) dated 18.01.2019 and as vetted by Integrated Finance Division of this Ministry vide their Dy No.3437419 dated 22.01.2019. Sd/Under Secretary to the Govt of India” [12] It appears that the pre-conditions for entitlement of additional HRA are that the transfer of the person concerned should be on any non-family locations like North Eastern region, Sikkim, Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep Islands etc. and second condition is that person concerned shall have to vacate the Government quarters allotted to him in his previous place of posting after 3 years of retention period and he will be thereafter entitled to get such additional HRA. [13] In the case in hand, admittedly, the petitioner retained the quarters from 11.07.2018 to 19.06.2021 at Seema Nagar, South Bengal i.e. for a period abit less than 3 years but on that ground the claim of the petitioner was not rejected by the respondents. Even in the Memorandum dated
02. 09.2022 (Annexure R/2A) framing the scheme for such quarter at Clause 22, the term “initially for a period of three years from the date of allotment or till the date of posting out (emphasis laid)” is also incorporated. The basic reason for denial of such additional HRA by the respondent was that he vacated the allotted quarters one day prior to his release from said previous place of posting. The aforesaid Memorandum of 22.01.2019 does not lay any such precondition that if a person is posted out prior to completion of 3 years of service in the station and thereby he vacates his quarters prior to the date of his release, he will not be entitled to any such additional HRA. In fact, additional HRA is to be counted from the date of his joining in new place of posting and not from the date of his release from previous place. [14] In view of above, the ground of rejection of the claim of the petitioner regarding his entitlement of additional HRA is not found to be convincing and acceptable. In consequence thereof, the writ petition is allowed. [15] The respondents are directed to release additional HRA in favour of the petitioner from the date of his joining in Tripura i.e. w.e.f. 02.07.2021 till he remain posted in Tripura, as arrear within 3 (three) months from today. Consequently, the related letters dated 09.10.2023 and 18.09.2024 issued by the respondents to the extent of rejec…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.713 of 2023
Sri Oshihar Prasad,
Son of Sri Akshay Lal Mahto, Assistant Commandant (Adm), C/O
Inspector General, Border Security Force, Frontier Headquarter
Tripura, P.O. Salbagan, P.S. Capital Complex, Salbagan, Agartala,
Tripura 799012.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India, North Block, Central Secretariat, New
Delhi 110001.
2.
The Director General, BSF,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110003.
3.
The Financial Advisor, Border Security Force,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110003.
4.
The Inspector General, Border Security Force,
Frontier Headquarter, Salbagan, Agartala, Tripura, 799001.
5.
The Commandant (Coordinator), BSF,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110003.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mrs. Sujata Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of hearing
& delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
14th February, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard
Mrs.
Sujata
Deb
(Gupta),
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned
Dy. SGI appearing for the respondents.
The admitted facts involved in this case are that the
[2]
petitioner was originally posted at 84 Bn BSF, Seema Nagar, South
Bengal. He was relieved from the said Battalion vide movement
order dated 20.06.2021 on his transfer to Tripura and he joined at
Headquarters Tripura Frontier BSF, Salbagan on 02.07.2021. While
posted in 84 Bn BSF at Seema Nagar, South Bengal, the petitioner
was allotted Government Type-III quarter at Seema Nagar by the
authority of 84 Bn BSF from 11.07.2018 till he vacated the same
on 19.06.2021 and on vacation of his Government quarter, he
shifted his family to his own house at New Delhi.
[3]
Thereafter, on 31.08.2021, the petitioner submitted one
application for grant of additional HRA (Annexure 6) for shifting his
family from last place of posting to New Delhi on his transfer to
non-family locations like North-Eastern region. Petitioner claimed
additional
HRA
on
the
basis
of
Office
Memorandum
dated
22.01.2019 issued by the Under Secretary to the Govt. of India,
Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi (Annexure 5). Said petition was
turned down by the Commandant (Coord) vide communication
dated
08.09.2022
Directorate
(Annexure
General
of
7)
Border
issued
from
Security
the
Force
office
and
of
was
communicated to the Frontier Headquarter, Border Security Force,
Tripura.
Then
again,
he
submitted
another
application
on
14.10.2022 to the Inspector General, Ftr HQ BSF, Tripura vide
Annexure-9
claiming
such
grant
of
additional
HRA
w.e.f.
02.07.2021 and again the same was rejected by the Department
vide communication dated 09.10.2023 (Annexure 11).
[4]
The sole ground for such rejection was that before
relinquishing his charge at 84 Bn BSF of Seema Nagar, South
Bengal on 20.06.2021, he vacated the quarters one day prior to the
same i.e. on 19.06.2021. Said fact was also communicated by
another communication dated 18.09.2024 (Annexure 13) issued
from the Directorate General Border Security Force, Ministry of
Home Affairs to H.Q., Special DG, BSF (Eastern Command).
[5]
In view of the above said facts, the sole question
emerges for decision in this writ petition is whether the petitioner is
entitled to
additional
HRA
in terms
of Memorandum
dated
22.01.2019 (Annexure 5) in the event he had vacated the quarter
before he relinquished his charge in the previous station.
[6]
Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel, strenuously
argues that in Memorandum dated 22.01.2019, there is no such
condition that quarters should be vacated after relinquishing the
charge of the previous station for entitlement to additional HRA and
therefore, the plea as raised by the respondents is not tenable even
in terms of said Memorandum dated 22.01.2019 itself. Mrs. Deb
(Gupta), learned counsel also refers to a movement order dated
19.06.2021 (Annexure-2) whereby the petitioner was directed to
depart on 20.06.2021 (afternoon) and submits that for compliance
or the direction as given in said movement order, the quarters was
vacated on 19.06.2021 itself.
[7]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI, however, contends
that before the petitioner was released from his previous station,
he voluntarily vacated the quarters at Seema Nagar and therefore,
in no way, he is entitled to get any additional HRA in terms of the
said Memorandum dated 22.01.2019. Mr. Majumder, learned Dy.
SGI also argues that during hearing of this writ petition on
01.08.2024, the matter was under consideration before the
Headquarters of BSF upon the recommendation of Kolkata Zonal
Office and the Court accordingly asked the respondents to bring the
decision on the petitioner’s request for such HRA on record.
Thereafter, on 26.09.2024, it was submitted by Mr. Majumder,
learned Dy. SGI, under instruction from his client that a written
instruction was received from the Deputy Commandant (Law), HQ
Tra Ftr, BSF that the proposal for grant of additional HRA on
transfer to North Eastern Region made by the petitioner was
examined in detail in consultation with the Finance Wing and Law
Dte, FHQ and the Finance Wing did not concur with said proposal
regarding admissibility of HRA (in addition to HRA admissible at the
new place of posting).
[8]
Learned
Dy.
SGI
also
further
contends
that
the
petitioner at the time relinquishing his charge at Seema Nagar,
South Bengal, never filed any application for retention of said
quarters and therefore, he cannot claim any additional HRA now.
[9]
This Court has given thoughtful consideration of the rival
contentions placed by the parties and also on the materials as
placed on their behalf.
[10]
From the side of respondents, the entire Scheme/Office
Memorandum dated 02.09.2022 issued by the Ministry of Home
Affairs dealing with the matter of retention of Departmental
accommodation and other allied matters are placed on record
under Annexure R/2A. Learned Dy. SGI also refers to Clause 22 of
said Memorandum and for useful reference, said Clause 22 is
excerpted below:
22. RETENTION OF ACCOMODATION
Events
Normal Tenure
Permissible period of Retention of
Residence
Initially for a period of three
years from the date of allotment
or till the date of posting out.
Further retention will be subject
to review on the basis of place of
posting of the allottee or extraordinary
circumstances
like
children appearing for board or
final
year
university
examinations.
Personnel posted to specified
extreme
hard
areas/hard
areas/high altitude areas/NorthEast/ANO/CI
ops
or
antiInsurgency
role/non-family
stations will be permitted to
retain accommodation already
occupied in previous location till
his
posting-out
from
such
locations/deployment or three
years whichever is earlier. Such
personnel be further directed to
seek allotment of Separated
Family Accommodation (SFA) and
shift there.
Personnel deployed in UN Mission
assignment
as
part
of
Resignation, discharge
(other
than
superannuation
&
VRS),
dismissal,
removal from service,
termination of service
or
unauthorized
absence
Superannuation/VRS
Death of allottee
Transfer to a place
other
than
his/her
priority
Leave
(other
than
refused leave, terminal
leave medical leave,
maternity leave)
Study leave within India
or abroad
Deputation
Leave
on
medical
grounds
Maternity leave
Leave
preparatory
to
CIVPOL/Special
Police
Unit
contingent will be permitted to
retain
the
accommodation
already occupied in previous
location till his return from such
assignment and further posting
out from the Holding Unit/HQ.
At normal rate of License Fee for one
month from the date on which allottee
was struck of strength.
At normal rate of License Fee for six
months.
At double License Fee for next four
months or till completion of academic
session of children whichever is
earlier.
Subject to condition that the retiree
does not own a property in the
geographical/revenue jurisdiction of
the city/town.
At normal rate of License Fee for 12
months from the date of death in
case of normal death & further
extendable by 12 months.
At normal rate of License Fee for 36
months from the date of death in
case of martyrs.
Subject to condition that the NoK
does not own a property in the
geographical/revenue jurisdiction of
the city/town.
At normal rate of License Fee for 02
months and at double Licence Fee for
next six months.
At normal rate of License Fee for Four
months and at double Licence Fee for
next six months.
At normal rate of License Fee for six
months.
Followed by allotment of alternate
accommodation of one type lower
thereafter.
At normal rate of License Fee for two
months
beyond
the
date
of
assumption of charge on deputation
tenure.
At the normal rate of License Fee till
completion of deputation tenure in
case of placement in non-family
station or foreign location.
At normal rate of License Fee for the full
period of leave.
At normal rate of License Fee for the
period of maternity leave plus leave
granted in continuation subject to a
maximum of five months.
At normal rate of License Fee for the full
retirement or refused
granted or Earned leave
granted to Govt servant
who retired under FR
56 (j)
On
proceeding
course or training
[11]
for
period of leave on full average pay
subject to a maximum 80 days in case of
leave preparatory to retirement and four
months in other cases, inclusive of the
period permissible in the case of
retirement.
At normal rate of License Fee for the full
period of course/training.
The related Memorandum dated 22.01.2019 (Annexure
5) as relied on by both the parties is also extracted hereunder:
“No.II-27012/29/2018-PF-I(CF No.3437419)
Government of India/Bharat Sarkar
Ministry of Home Affairs/Grih Mantralaya
Police II Division
(PF–I Desk)
North Block, New Delhi,
Dated, the 22nd January, 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub: Grant of additional HRA to CAPF personnel on their
transfer to non-family locations in the event of their
vacation of Government accommodation retained by
them after 3 years.
The undersigned is directed to say that a proposal for grant
of HRA of Old Station/Selected Place of Residence in addition to the
HRA admissible at the new place of posting, to CAPF personnel on
their transfer to non-family locations, viz North Eastern Region,
Sikkim, Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep Islands, State of
Jammu & Kashmir and Left Wing Extremist (LWE) areas, in the
event of their vacation of Government accommodation retained by
them after 3 years, as per Ministry of Housing & Urban Affairs OM
No.12035/4/2015-Pol.II dated 14.11.2017 and 01.08.2018, till
they remain posted in such non-family stations, was examined in
this Ministry in consultation with Ministry of Finance (Department
of Expenditure), and it has agreed to:(i)
allow HRA, on vacation of the Government accommodation
by families of CAPF personnel after 3 years retention period,
who are posted in non-family stations/locations (as defined
by M/o Housing & Urban Affairs in their OM dated
01/08/2018), in addition to the HRA admissible at the new
place of posting.
(ii)
relax the mandatory provision of keeping families of CAPF
personnel at last place of posting for allowing HRA at the
rate of Selected Place of Residence.
2.
This issues with the approval of Ministry of Finance
(Department of Expenditure), vide their ID No.28/2/2018-E.II(B)
dated 18.01.2019 and as vetted by Integrated Finance Division of
this Ministry vide their Dy No.3437419 dated 22.01.2019.
Sd/Under Secretary to the Govt of India”
[12]
It appears that the pre-conditions for entitlement of
additional HRA are that the transfer of the person concerned should
be on any non-family locations like North Eastern region, Sikkim,
Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep Islands etc. and second
condition is that person concerned shall have to vacate the
Government quarters allotted to him in his previous place of
posting after 3 years of retention period and he will be thereafter
entitled to get such additional HRA.
[13]
In the case in hand, admittedly, the petitioner retained
the quarters from 11.07.2018 to 19.06.2021 at Seema Nagar,
South Bengal i.e. for a period abit less than 3 years but on that
ground the claim of the petitioner was not rejected by the
respondents.
Even
in
the
Memorandum
dated
02.09.2022
(Annexure R/2A) framing the scheme for such quarter at Clause
22, the term “initially for a period of three years from the date of
allotment or till the date of posting out (emphasis laid)” is also
incorporated. The basic reason for denial of such additional HRA by
the respondent was that he vacated the allotted quarters one day
prior to his release from said previous place of posting. The
aforesaid Memorandum of 22.01.2019 does not lay any such precondition that if a person is posted out prior to completion of 3
years of service in the station and thereby he vacates his quarters
prior to the date of his release, he will not be entitled to any such
additional HRA. In fact, additional HRA is to be counted from the
date of his joining in new place of posting and not from the date of
his release from previous place.
[14]
In view of above, the ground of rejection of the claim of
the petitioner regarding his entitlement of additional HRA is not
found to be convincing and acceptable. In consequence thereof, the
writ petition is allowed.
[15]
The respondents are directed to release additional HRA
in favour of the petitioner from the date of his joining in Tripura i.e.
w.e.f. 02.07.2021 till he remain posted in Tripura, as arrear within
3 (three) months from today. Consequently, the related letters
dated 09.10.2023 and 18.09.2024 issued by the respondents to the
extent of rejection of the claim of the petitioner are hereby
quashed.
In terms of the above, the writ petition is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of.
JUDGE
SATABDI
DUTTA
Rudradeep
SATABDI DUTTA
Date: 2025.02.19
16:44:17 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review