Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.674 of 2022
1. Sri Nilanjan Kanti Nath, S/o:Lt. Nani Ch. Nath, R/o: Vill.-Subhashnagar,
PO & PS-Kanchanpur, District-North Tripura, Pin-799270, (Age-33 years).
2. Sri Saroj Das, S/o: Sankar Lal Das, R/o: Vill. & PO-Panisagar, DistrictNorth Tripura, Tripura, Pin-799260, (Age-34 years).
3. Sri Prasenjit Debnath, S/o: Sukumar Debnath, R/o: Arabindu Colony,
Nutanbazar, Sub-Division: Amarpur, District: Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799104,
(Age-30 years).
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Department of
Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The State Level Nodal Agency (IWMP), Govt. of Tripura, Department of
Agriculture, to be represented by the Chief Executive Officer, State Level
Nodal Agency (IWMP), Ujan Abhoynagar, Near Buddha Mandir, Agartala,
West Tripura-799001.
3. The Chief Executive Officer, State Level Nodal Agency (IWMP), Govt.
of Tripura, Ujan Abhoynagar, Near Buddha Mandir, Agartala, West
Tripura-799001.
4. The Member Secretary, Society for Entrepreneurship Development
(SOFED), Entrepreneurship Development Institute of Tripura, ITI Road,
Indranagar, Agartala, Tripura 799006.
5. Sri Chandramouli Paul, S/o: Kanti Paul, Address-office of the Project
Manager, WDC-PMKSY 2.0, near Office of the Superintendent of
Agriculture, Bagafa, Santir Bazar, South Tripura, Pin-799144.
6. Smt. Arpita Sharma, D/o: Chiranjib Sharma, R/o: Near Gomati District
Hospital, Tepania, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, Pin-799120.
7. Sri Santosh Chakma, S/o: Kina Kumar Chakma, R/o: Vill.- Netajinagar,
PO & PS-Kanchanpur, Laljuri RD Block, North Tripura, Pin-799270.
8. Smt. Puja Das, D/o: Narayan Das, R/o: Udaipur, Near TFTI, PO & PS-R.K.
Pur, Pin-799120.
9. Sri Joydeep Dasgupta, S/o: Dhirendra Dasgupta, R/o: Vill.-Ambassa
Colony, PO & PS-Ambassa, District-Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799289.
10.Sri Biprajit Majumder, S/o: Basudeb Majumder, R/o: North Badharghat,
Near Swami Vivekananda Club, PO & PS-A.D. Nagar, Pin-799003.
11.Sri Sayan Ghosh, S/o: Kaushik Ghosh, R/o: West Bank of Amarsagar, Vill.Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura, PO-R.K. Pur, Pin-799120.
12.Sri Uday Debnath, S/o: Chanu Debnath, R/o: Vill.-Dhajanagar, POGakulpur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799114.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate
Ms. D. Paul, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
29.07.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioners have
challenged the selection and appointment of respondents no.5 to 12.
2.
Facts:
The official respondents had issued a recruitment notification
vide No.02/2022-23 dated 19.04.2022(Annexure-4 to the writ petition).
Under the said notification, online applications were invited from the eligible
candidates permanently residing in Tripura for the posts mentioned in the
said notification to place their services in the State Level Nodal Agency
(SLNA) under the Agriculture & Farmers Welfare Organization. One of the
posts includes Watershed Development Team Member.
2.2.
The posts and the requisite qualifications mentioned in the
notification may be reproduced hereunder in tabular form:
“Society for Entrepreneurship Development(SOFED)
(An ISO 9001:2015 & 10002:2018 Organization)
I.T.I. Road, Indranagar, Agartala-799006, Phone: (0381) 235 0799
Email.sofed_agartala@rediffmail.com, Visit us at www.sofed.in
No: SED/ESTT/SLNA/1(121)/2022/152
Date:19.04.2022
RECRUITMENT NOTIFICATION NO.02/2022-23
Online applications are invited from the eligible candidates permanently
residing in Tripura for the posts mentioned below for placing in the State Level
Nodal Agency (SLNA) under the Agriculture & Farmers Welfare with all Tripura
service liabilities.
Item
No.
Name of the
Post with no.
of post
Watershed
Development
Team
Member
No. of Posts:
26 (UR-14,
ST-08, SC04)
Essential Qualification & Experience
B.Sc
Agri/Horti/Forestry/
BE/B. Tech (Civil/
Electronics/Agri
Engineering/
Computer
Science/Diploma in
Civil/Electronics/Water
shed
Management/Masters
in Rural management
from a recognized
university/Graduate
with certificate course
in CNC Turning &
Milling from a
recognized Tool Room
BE/B. Tech (CSE)
GIS Expert
No.
of
post:01(UR)
Community
Development
Expert
No.
of
post:01 (UR)
M.Sc in Agriculture
Extension/Master
Degree
in
Rural
Development
IT-Expert
No.
of
post:01(UR)
B.Tech/BE
in
IT/Electronics
&
Telecommunication
Monthly Gross
Contract Pay
Age
Limit
Essential:Candidates
should have at least 5
Yrs working
experience in Water
Shed Management
project.
Desirable:
The candidate should
have knowledge in
Geo-Tagging,
MIS/PFMS,
GIS/Remote Sensing/
Community
Mobilization and
Institution Building
Rs.20,177/- for
Degree/Masters
holder.
Rs.19177/- for
diploma holder
yrs
Essential:Candidates
should have at least 5
Yrs
working
experience in field of
Remote Sensing &
GIS.
Desirable:
The candidate should
have good technical
(programming)
knowledge
and
experience in GeoSpatial Technologies
for
planning
&
modeling
of
watershed
management projects.
Essential:Candidates
should have at least
Yrs
working
experience in field of
Watershed Projects in
State & National
Level
Desirable:
The candidate having
PhD in Agriculture
Extension will get
preference
Essential:Candidates
should have at least 3
Yrs
working
experience
in
software
development/MIS
Desirable:
Experience
in
software
development/MIS
Rs.28,249.00
yrs
Rs.28,249.00
yrs
Rs.28,249.00
yrs
Terms & Conditions:
1. The selected candidates would be appointed on Purely Contract Basis for a term
of 11(Eleven) months and may be extended on performance and requirement of
the project.
2. The selected candidates should come under an agreement as per the norms with
the SOFED.
3. The candidates shall be called for verification of their original documents for the
eligibility of the post/posts. Such date shall be communicated later on.
4. The candidates shall be selected through written examination or interview on
purely merit basis and the date of such test/interview shall be informed on due
course.
5. Age relaxation for ST/SC/PH candidates would be provided as per Govt. norms.
Application shall be submitted through online mode only in the website
www.sofedagartala.com up to 5:00 PM of 30th April, 2022. Incomplete
application shall be rejected without showing any clarification thereof. No
application shall be received physically or by post in any circumstances.
SD/MEMBER SECRETARY, SoFED”
2.3.
Pursuant to the said notification the petitioners applied for the
post of „Watershed Development Team Member‟ and participated in the
selection process. 14 posts were reserved for UR category, 08 for STs and 04
posts for SC category of candidates. The petitioners no.1 and 3 belongs to
UR category and petitioner no.2 belongs to SC category. After publication of
results, the petitioners no.1 and 3 found that their names did not appear
within first 14(forteen) number of posts. Similarly, the petitioner no.2 being
a candidate under SC category did not find place within first 4(four) number
of posts. The case of the petitioners is that the respondents no.5 to 12, i.e. the
private respondents herein neither have essential qualifications nor desirable
experiences. The official respondents had issued appointment letters in
favour of the selected candidates as per the selection list and the private
respondents accordingly joined to the post of Watershed Development Team
Member and have been discharging their duties. Having found themselves
unsuccessful in the selection process, the petitioners have filed the instant
writ petition expressing their grievances against the appointment of the
private respondents.
3.
In the above background of facts, I have heard Mr. P. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioners as well as Mr. Kohinoor N.
Bhattacharyya, learned GA appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners:
4.1.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has contended that
though the petitioners have both essential qualification and desirable
experience, they have not been considered for appointment to the post of
Watershed Development Team Member. Mr. Roy Barman has drawn my
attention to a certificate dated 26.04.2022 issued in favour of petitioner no.1
wherefrom it reveals that the petitioner no.1 had an experience of working in
the State Level Nodal Agency. Similar certificates had also been issued in
favour of other two petitioners, namely Sri Saroj Das and Sri Prasenjit
Debnath, respondents no.2 and 3 respectively. Further contention of learned
senior counsel is that the respondents no.5 to 12 had no experience in
working in Watershed Management Project, but they have been considered
for appointment.
4.2.
During the course of hearing, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior
counsel has strenuously argued that the addendum dated 07.05.2022 issued
by the respondents was illegal and arbitrary because it changed the rule of
the game. It is the contention of learned senior counsel for the petitioners
that in the recruitment notification it is categorically stated that application
would be submitted through „online mode‟ only in the Website up to 5:00
pm of 30th April, 2022. The addendum was issued on 07.05.2022 i.e. after
expiry of the last date of submission of the application. Learned senior
counsel drawing my attention to the said addendum has submitted that in the
original recruitment notification it was made an essential qualification that
candidates should have at least 5 years of working experience in Watershed
Management Project and it was desirable that the candidates should have
knowledge in Geo-Tagging, MIS/PFMS, GIS/Remote Sensing/Community
Mobilization and Institution Building, but, under the addendum dated
07.05.2022 this essential qualification of 5 years of working experience in
Watershed Management Project had been removed and was made
“Desirable”, which was illegal and arbitrary, and thus, is liable to be
quashed. It is emphatically submitted that this change made in the midway of
the selection process is not permissible in law. The petitioners have both
essential qualification and desirable experience but the private respondents
have no such experience in working in Watershed Management Project for at
least 5 years.
5.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned GA has submitted that
there was no illegality or arbitrariness in issuing the addendum dated
07.05.2022. Learned GA has submitted that from the recruitment notification
dated 19.04.2022, it is clear that essential qualification is B.Sc,
Agri/Horti/Forestry/BE/B.Tech(Civil/
Electronics/Agri
Engineering/
Computer Science)/Diploma in Civil/Electronics/Watershed Management/
etc. By issuance of the addendum, the official respondents only removed the
word “Essential”, and instead of “Essential” it was made “Desirable”. It is
further submitted that the petitioners were not in any way prejudiced by the
issuance of the addendum as it was issued long before the interview and that
they also appeared and participated in the selection process as candidates
seeking selection to the post of Watershed Development Team Member
without raising any sort of objection. It is further contended that the
petitioners are estopped from challenging the selection process once they
appeared and participated in the entire process.
6.
Analysis and Conclusion:
6.1.
I have considered the rival submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties. I have also meticulously perused the
advertisement i.e. the recruitment notification no.02/2022-23 dated
19.04.2022 and the counter affidavit filed by the respondents.
6.2.
From the counter affidavit it is revealed that a merit list was
prepared from all the candidates seeking selection and appointment to the
post of Watershed Development Team Member under SLNA. Prior to that,
under notification dated 24.06.2022, two Interview Boards were constituted
to undertake the interview of eligible short-listed aspirants/candidates. It is
further revealed that there are altogether 26 numbers of posts out of which 14
posts of Watershed Development Team Member were meant for UR
category candidates, 8 posts for ST category candidates and 4 posts are kept
for SC category candidates. In total 162 numbers of applications were
received for the said post. The notification for constituting Interview Board
to undertake the interview was issued on 24.06.2022 and thereafter, the
personal interview for the post was undertaken on 28.06.2022. All the 162
numbers of candidates were called for attending the interview and out of
those following numbers of candidates attended the interview (Board Wise),
which is shown in the tabular form here-in-below:
Board-1(in two session) Board-1(in two session)
Total
Personal interviews for the above post were undertaken for 15
marks and the Board Members provided the marks individually based on the
performance of the interview. It is further stated in the counter affidavit that
the final score of the candidates have been made on the basis of the
following criteria:
(a) The percentage of marks secured by the candidate in personal
interview (PI) and equivalent percentage of marks from academic
performance has added for final evaluation.
(b) For example, if a candidate secured 10 out of 15 in PI, the
percentage is 66.66. If the academic performance of the same
candidate is 70%, from that 66.66% has been taken which would be
46.66.
(c) The final score of that candidate would be sum of marks of PI and
equivalent % of marks taken from the academic performance of the
individual candidate i.e., 15+46.66=61.66 of the above example.
The cut-off marks for the different categories of candidates for
final panel as stated in the counter affidavit may be reproduced in tabular
form as under:
7.
Sl No.
Category
Cut-off marks
1.
UR
65.00
2.
SC
60.00
3.
ST
50.00
Accordingly, a common merit list was published after
finalization and evaluation of the marks secured by a candidate against the PI
and the academic qualifications. Thereafter, separate merit lists were
prepared for UR category (Annexure-R/VI), ST category(Annexure-R/VII)
and SC category(Annexure-R/VIII) candidates.
7.1.
Petitioner no.1 and 3 herein belong to UR category and
petitioner no.2 belongs to SC category, which leads me to peruse the merit
lists prepared for UR category and SC category candidates. It is found that
the respondents have filled up the posts of Watershed Development Team
Member from the first 14 selected candidates under the UR category. From
the list it is found that the selected candidates have secured higher marks
than the marks obtained by the petitioners. The petitioner no.1, Sri Nilanjan
Kanti Nath has obtained 49.10 marks. The name of petitioner no.3, Sri
Prasenjit Debnath has not appeared in the merit list prepared for UR category
candidates. However, his name has appeared at serial no.31 of the common
merit list and it is found that he has obtained 52.20 marks. The name of
petitioner no.2, Sri Saroj Das has appeared in the merit list for SC category
candidates at serial no.5 and he has obtained 52.56 marks. From the merit list
of UR category candidates it is found that 14 posts of Watershed
Development Team Member were filled up from the first 14 successful
candidates on the basis of securing better marks than that of the petitioners,
namely Sri Nilanjan Kanti Nath and Sri Prasenjit Debnath amongst the UR
category candidates. Similarly, 4 posts were filled up under SC category
from the first 4 successful candidates who secured higher marks than Sri
Saroj Das, the petitioner no.2 herein. So, the merit list prepared for UR and
SC category candidates crystallizes that the private respondents having
obtained higher marks than that of the petitioners had been appointed to the
said post. There is no allegation of malafide or bias against the selection of
private respondents or against the members of Selection Committee.
8.
According to me, the methodology adopted by the members of
the Interview Board was reasonable and for this, the selection process cannot
be questioned.
9.
Now, coming to the submission of learned senior counsel that
the issuance of addendum after the expiry of the final date of submission of
online application has changed the rule of the game, I am unable to agree
with this submission of learned senior counsel.
9.1.
It is found that 5 years of working experience in Watershed
Management Project had been made “desirable” instead of “essential” under
the addendum dated 07.05.2022. No prejudice has been caused to any
candidates intended to participate in the selection process because there is no
change in essential qualification and the addendum was issued much before
the commencement of the actual selection process. Two interview boards
were constituted under notification dated 24.06.2022. So, the addendum was
published much before the conduct of the interview of the willing candidates
who applied against the post of Watershed Development Team Member. The
petitioners were made aware much before their participation in the selection
process. Furthermore, they did not challenge the change made under the
addendum dated 07.05.2022, which clearly justifies that they had no
grievance with the issuance of the addendum dated 07.05.2022. Only after
they found themselves unsuccessful they approached this Court challenging
the addendum dated 07.05.2022. Moreso, if the petitioners became
successful then they would have never come forward to challenge the said
addendum.
9.2.
In my view, the addendum dated 07.05.2022, modifying the
experience required for filling up of the post of Watershed Development
Team Member did not cause any prejudice to any of the candidates. Moreso,
knowingfullywell about the change made in the addendum, the petitioners
had participated in the selection process. There was an opportunity to
challenge the said addendum immediately after the issuance of the same on
07.05.2022, if they thought that it was prejudicial to them in any manner
whatsoever. But, without taking such course, they participated in the
selection process and having found themselves unsuccessful, they have
approached this Court with a plea that the addendum dated 07.05.2022 had
changed the rule of the game.
9.3.
Furthermore, the change made in the addendum, according to
me, is a mere clarification as regards the experience required for filling up
the post of Watershed Development Team Member and in my considered
view, the working experience for 5 years in Watershed Management Project
has not changed the rule of the game in any manner whatsoever being the
same was clarificatory in nature and that there was not substantial change.
Furthermore, the said addendum would have been interfered with if it
appears to be prejudicial to the interest of the petitioners. But, as I said
earlier, the petitioners were not prejudiced in any manner whatsoever with
the change made under the addendum dated 07.05.2022.
10.
On minute scrutiny of the records it comes to light that the
selection was made on the basis of evaluation of overall merits that included
personal interview(15 marks) and the academic qualifications. The formula
adopted by the Interview Board is in no way be said to be arbitrary when
there was no challenge to the said addendum.
11.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I do not find
any merit in the challenge made by the petitioners as regards the
appointment of the private respondents and accordingly, the instant writ
petition stands dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed
SAIKAT Digitally
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.08.28
KAR
15:57:26 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review