Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.PETN. NO.04 OF 2024
1. Shri Naresh Chandra Deb,
Son of Late Pramod Chandra Deb ,
Aged about 65 years resident of 79 Tilla,
Opposite of Housing Board Quarter Complex,
P.O- Kunjaban, Sub-Division- Sadar, Agartala,
P.S.- New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura,
Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. Shri Dulal Chandra Deb,
Son of Late Pramod Chandra Deb, aged about 63 years,
Resident of 79 Tilla, Opposite of Housing Board Quarter
Complex, P.O.- Kunjaban, Sub- Division- Sadar, Agartala,
P.S.- New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, Tripura,
Pin- 799006.
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. State of Tripura,
2. Sri Jahar Lal Debbarma,
TPS GR-II, Investigating Officer of NCC P.S. Case No.2022 NCC
167, New Capital Complex Police Station, P.S.- Kunjaban-799006,
Agartala, West Tripura, Attached as A/C (DAR) West, A.D. Nagar
Police Lines, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
3. The Officer-in-Charge, New Capital Complex Police Station ,
P.S.- Kunjaban 799006, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Officer-in-Charge,
Dhumacharra Police Station, Unttar Dhumachhara, Dhalai,
Tripura, Pin-799275.
5. Smt. Chinamuni Marak, wife of late Rakesh Marak, D/o late
Satish Marak, resident of Prabhatdangshu Para, P.O- Kanchanpur,
P.S.- Damcherra, District- Dhalai Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sarker, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
Mr. V. Poddar, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 19.03.2024.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 21/03/2024
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This present criminal petition has been filed under
Section 482 of the Code of criminal procedure, 1973, for invoking
the inherent powers of this Court, for quashing/setting aside the FIR
of New Capital Complex P.S. Case No. 2022 NCC 167, dated
24.12.2022 registered under Sections 465, 468, 471, 420 and 120B
of the Indian Penal Code and Section 3(1)(f)(g) of the Scheduled
Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989,
against the petitioners and others.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that respondent No.5
lodged a written complaint before respondent No.4, alleging inter
alia that she belongs to the member of Scheduled Tribe community
and her grand-father, namely, Sakindra @ Makindra Garo, is the
owner of a land located at Nandannagar, Agartala. She alleged that
the land was mutated as C.S. Plot no. 54 under Khatian no. 12,
corresponding to Hal Plot No. 140 and Hal Khatian no.5053/1 and
5053/2 of Mouja- Indranagar, Tehsil- Indranagar, Revenue CircleAgartala East, measuring 03.23 acres. She also stated that on
01.01.1959 her grand-father expired leaving behind four sons and
three daughters. Thereafter about 5/6 months ago, it has come to
their
knowledge
that
FIR
named
accused
persons
i.e.,
the
petitioners herein in connivance with the revenue staff committed
forgery and changed the map and mutated the land in their name
even though the land is under their possession. She also alleged
that she contacted the accused persons and asked them to produce
the Deed, but they refused to produce the same. Thereafter, vide
letter dated 25.10.2022, she asked the petitioners to produce the
Sale Deed whereby they purchased the land from the legal heirs of
Sakindra Garo. She also alleged that she issued another notice, but
the accused persons did not give any reply to her notice.
Thereafter, she approached the Settlement Authority to know how
the land was recorded in the name of the accused persons, but the
Settlement Authority did not give any reply. She also alleged that
she approached the In-charge of the Map Section for correction of
the map, but after elapse of 15 days, the same was not corrected.
3.
On receipt of the aforesaid written complaint,
respondent No.4 registered Zero FIR dated 20.12.2022 under
Sections 465, 468, 471, 420, and 120B of the Indian Penal Code
and Section 3(1)(f)(g) of the SC & ST Act, 1989, and forwarded the
same to the respondent No.3. On receipt of the same, the
respondent No.3 registered a case vide NCC PS case No. 167 of
2022 under Sections 465, 468, 471, 420 and 120B of the Indian
Penal Code and Section 3(1)(f)(g) of the SC & ST Act, 1989.
4.
After registration of the case, the police started the
investigation, and the first Investigating Officer issued a notice
dated 20.02.2023 under Sections 41A(1) Cr.P.C. and asked the
petitioners
to
appear
before
him
between
26.02.2023
and
28.02.2023. In furtherance thereof, they appeared before him.
Thereafter respondent No.2 was entrusted with the investigation of
the
case
as
Investigating
Officer.
After
his
appointment
as
Investigating Officer, on several occasions, petitioners were asked
to appear before him. The petitioner thereafter approached the
learned Sessions Judge by filing an application under Section 438
Cr.P.C. for granting pre-arrest bail and the said application was
registered and marked as B.A. 227 of 2023. After hearing the
parties, learned Sessions Judge vide order dated 19.09.2023
rejected the bail prayer holding that the application under Section
438 Cr.P.C. is not maintainable as the same is prohibited under
Section 18 of the SC & ST Act. Thereafter, both the petitioners
jointly filed another application under Section 438 Cr.P.C. before
this Hon’ble High Court, and the same was registered and marked
as A.B. 27 of 2023. On 29.09.2023, when the pre-arrest bail
application was first time listed before this Hon’ble High Court, after
hearing both parties, this Court granted interim anticipatory bail to
both petitioners. Thereafter, on 16.10.2023 when the pre-arrest bail
was again listed before this Hon’ble High Court, the said pre-arrest
bail was allowed.
5.
After granting of pre-arrest bail, respondent No.2,
issued several notices under Section 41A(1) of Cr.P.C., and asked
both the petitioners to appear before him. It is further stated that in
connection with the disputed land, there was a civil litigation
between the petitioners in one hand and Sri Biru Chandra Saha and
Sri Niru Chandra Saha in other hand. In the said Civil suit, the
petitioners contended that the petitioners were the owners of the
suit land and Biru Chandra Saha and Niru Chandra Saha are illegally
occupying the land and prayed for eviction. The said suit reached up
to this Hon’ble High Court in a Second Appeal which was registered
and marked as RSA 5 of 2021. The same was disposed of vide
judgment and order dated 26.08.2021. This Hon'ble High Court vide
its judgment and order dated 26.08.2021 in RSA 5 of 2021 held
that Biru Chandra Saha and Niru Chandra Saha are in possession of
the suit land and the appellants failed to prove their title and hence
no order of recovery can be passed in favour of the petitioners.
6.
The petitioners by filing this petition prayed before
this Court to set aside and quash the FIR of New Capital Complex
P.S. Case No.2022 NCC 167, dated 24.12.2022 registered under
Sections 465, 468, 471, 420 and 120B of the IPC and Section
3(1)(f)(g) of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe(Prevention
of Atrocities Act, 1989 against the petitioner and discharge them
from the labiality of the instant case.
7.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by Mr.
S. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners as well
as Mr. R. Datta, learned Addl. P.P., appearing for the Staterespondents and Mr. S. Sarkar, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr.
V. Poddar, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.5.
8.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that the present case is a civil dispute and that
police ought to not have registered the criminal case against the
petitioners and others. As stated by respondent No.5, there are
some corrections in the record of rights, and the same was rejected
by the appellate authority. As such, the present matter comes
under revenue proceeding.
To support his argument, learned counsel relied
upon para-6 of the latest Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment titled
as Naresh Kumar and anr. Vs. The State of Karnataka and
anr., dated March 12 of 2024. The same is produced here-inunder:“6. In the case of Paramjeet Batra v. State of
Uttarakhand (2013) 11 SCC 673, this Court recognized that although the
inherent powers of a High Court under Section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure should be exercised sparingly, yet the
High Court must not hesitate in quashing such criminal proceedings which
are essentially of a civil nature. This is what was held:
“12. While exercising its jurisdiction under Section 482
of the Code the High Court has to be cautious. This power is tobe used
sparingly and only for the purpose of preventing abuse of the process of
any court or otherwise to secure ends of justice. Whether a complaint
discloses a criminal offence or not depends upon the nature of facts
alleged therein. Whether essential ingredients of criminal offence are
present or not has to be judged by the High Court. A complaint disclosing
civil transactions may also have a criminal texture. But the High Court
must see whether a dispute which is essentially of a civil nature is given a
cloak of criminal offence. In such a situation, if a civil remedy isb
available and is, in fact, adopted as has happened in this case, the High
Court should not hesitate to quash the criminal proceedings to prevent
abuse of process of the court.”
(emphasis supplied)
Relying upon the decision in Paramjeet Batra (supra),
this Court in Randheer Singh v. State of U.P. (2021) 14
SCC 626, observed that criminal proceedings cannot be taken recourse to
as a weapon of harassment. In Usha Chakraborty & Anr. v. State of West
Bengal & Anr. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 90, relying upon Paramjeet Batra
(supra) it was again held that where a dispute which is essentially of a
civil nature, is given a cloak of a criminal offence, then such disputes can
be quashed, by exercising the inherent powers under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure.”
Learned counsel further submitted that some of the
land in question was sold out and his client purchased the same.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. Raju Datta learned P.P.,
countered the submission made by learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners and presented before this Court Order dated
04.03.2024 wherein the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar, West
Tripura observed that the Opposite parties i.e. the petitioner herein
are unauthorizedly occupying the land measuring 4.45 acre under
Khatian No.5053/1 and 5053/2 of Mouja T.K. Indranagar without
any valid document and they were directed to vacate the land
completely from their possession with 30(thirty) days from the date
of that order and to hand over the possession of the land at
aforesaid khatian No.5053/1 and 5053/2 to the petitioners i.e.
respondent No.5. Learned P.P., further submits that notices under
Section 41A of Cr.P.C were issued against the petitioners thrice.
To support his argument, learned P.P., appearing
for the State-respondents cited paras-7, 8 & 9 of the Hon’ble Apex
Court Judgment reported in (2019) 14 SCC 350 titled as Kamal
Shivaji Pokarnekar Vs. State of Maharashtra and ors. The
same is produced here-in-under:“7. Relying upon the aforementioned judgments of this
Court, Mr. M. N. Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellant
submitted that the High Court acted in excess of its jurisdiction in setting
aside the order of the Trial Court by which process for summoning the
accused was issued. He further submitted that the evaluation of the merits
of the allegations made on either side cannot be resorted to at this stage.
8.
Mr. R. Basant, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Respondent
Nos.2 to 6 and 8 to 11 submitted that a proper evaluation of the material on
record would disclose that the complaint is frivolous. He submitted that the
dispute is essentially of a civil nature and the ingredients of the offences that
are alleged against the Respondent are not made out. By making the above
statement, Mr. Basant commended to this Court that there is no warrant for
interference with the judgment of the High Court.
9. Having heard the learned Senior Counsel and examined the material on
record, we are of the considered view that the High Court ought not to have
set aside the order passed by the Trial Court issuing summons to the
Respondents. A perusal of the complaint discloses that prima facie, offences
that are alleged against the Respondents. The correctness or otherwise of
the said allegations has to be decided only in the Trial. At the initial stage of
issuance of process it is not open to the Courts to stifle the proceedings by
entering into the merits of the contentions made on behalf of the accused.
Criminal complaints cannot be quashed only on the ground that the
allegations made therein appear to be of a civil nature. If the ingredients of
the offence alleged against the accused are prima facie made out in the
complaint, the criminal proceeding shall not be interdicted.
10.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
11.
In terms of the above submission and arguments as
advanced by both parties, it is clear that disputed questions of fact
are involved in this present case and proper investigation needs to
be done. Notices have been issued under Section 41A of Cr.P.C. and
the
petitioners
herein
are
expected
to
cooperate
with
the
investigating officer and submit sufficient records.
12.
Admittedly, the petitioners are non-Scheduled Tribe
persons, and the subject land and the complainant belong to the
Scheduled Tribe category. Accordingly, the land in question is
protected under Section 187 in The Tripura Land Revenue And Land
Reforms Act, 1960. The said Section is produced here-in-under:“187. Special provision regarding Scheduled Tribes.
No transfer of land by a person who is a member the Scheduled Tribes shall
be valid unless(a)the transfer is to another member of the Scheduled Tribes;
or(b)where the transfer is to a person who is not a member of any
such tribe, it is made with the previous permission in writing of the Collector;
or(c)the transfer is by way of, mortgages to a co-operative
society.”
13.
In view of the above fact, this Court is of the view
that prima facie it is a case which needs investigation. At this stage
of complaint and investigation, this Court feels that in the backdrop
of the present case, it is not proper for quashing the impugned FIR.
Accordingly, this present criminal petition stands dismissed.
14.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2024.03.22
SINGHA
13:39:06 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review