The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 12.2010 (Annexure-E to the writ petition) requires interference so far its effect is concerned. It has been clearly declared that the said memorandum will receive effect w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and the pay of the Heavy Vehicle Drivers should be fixed accordingly in terms of the provisions of the ROP Rules, 1999. But in the case of the petitioner, as is evident, that has not been done. True it is that the petitioner has approached this court belatedly but in view of State of M.P. Vs. Yogendra Srivastava, reported in (2010) 12 SCC 538 where the apex court after considering the precedents has clearly observed that in the matters of pay and allowances, the deprivation continues and every month a person is affected by the action of the respondents as the said person gets lesser pay or the lesser benefits. As such, the objection relating to the belated filing cannot come as the roadblock for granting relief to the petitioner. As such, the respondents, particularly TRTC-respondents, are directed to fix the pay of the petitioner in the scale of pay of Rs.4000-7890/- w.e.f. 01.01.1996 in terms of the ROP Rules, 1999. Since the petitioner has approached this court belatedly the payment of arrears has to be restricted to a date three years preceding the date of institution of the writ petition, i.e. 15.11.2018. As such, the petitioner will get the actual financial benefits from 15.11.2018. The …
15. 11.2018 shall be fixed notionally. It is also clarified that if in the meanwhile, the benefits of Career Advancement Scheme or Assured Career Progression Scheme were entitled to the petitioner that shall be allowed and pay of the petitioner shall be fixed accordingly. Such exercise shall be completed within two months from today as it has been reported by Ms Purakayastha that the petitioner is slated to retire very soon. In terms of the above, this petition stands allowed and disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs. lodh
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 816 of 2021
For petitioner(s)
:
Ms R Purakayastha, Adv
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K De, Addl. GA
Mr. KC Bhattacharjee, Adv
Mr. S Saha, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
27.04.2022
Heard Ms R Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. K De, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
respondents No. 1 and 2 and Mr. KC Bhattacharjee, learned counsel along
with Mr. S Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 3 & 4.
The controversy in this writ petition falls within a short compass.
Indisputably, the petitioner was appointed as the Driver Grade-II (Heavy
Vehicle Driver) under the pay scale of Rs.1020-6210 by the order No.
F.1(100)-TRTC/ESTT/OFFER/87/1639
dated
19.08.1992.
It
has
been
contended by the petitioner that the post of Driver Grade-II is synonymous or
the same post of Heavy Vehicle Driver. In this regard, the respondents have
not raised any controversy.
By the Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 1999 [ROP
Rules, 1999 for short] as published on 06.02.1999 in the Extra Ordinary Issue
of Tripura Gazette, the said pay scale[Rs. 1020 – 6210] was initially revised to
Rs.3300-7100 but later on, the competent authority in the TRTC Ltd. had,
with due sanction from the Nodal Department, modified the scale of pay of
Rs.3300-7100 to Rs. 4000-7890 for the Heavy Vehicle Driver, as would be
evident from the memorandum dated 27.12.2010 (Annexure-E to the writ
petition).
In the said memorandum, it has been noted that the financial
benefit that may accrue for the modification of the pay scale of Rs.3300-7100
to Rs. 4000-7890 will be from 01.12.2010 and no arrear of pay and
allowances will be given to the Heavy Vehicle Driver of the TRTC. It may be
noted that the said memorandum was issued on 27.12.2010 meaning within a
month from the date when the said notification of the pay scale came into
effect. Therefore, it is not at all a case where the arrears would emerge.
However, the date of effect was challenged in writ petitioner
being WP(C) 452/2012 (Dipak Das Vs. State of Tripura & Ors.). by the
judgment dated 04.12.2015 as delivered in WP(C) 452/2012, this court had
occasion to observe as under:
“Having regard to these aspects of the matter and on the
analogy under which the petitioners were granted the scale of
pay of Rs. 4000-7890/- or the benefits of the subsequent
revisions, this court is of the view that the petitioners are
entitled to get the scale of Rs. 4000-7890/- and/or its
restructured pay band w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and their pay with the
Grade pay shall be fixed in terms of the provisions of the ROP
Rules, 1999 in the same manner as adopted by the TRTC.
However, the respondents may defer the payment for
reasonable time but by any rate not beyond 12 months from
today.”
It has been further observed that the said memorandum dated
27.12.2010 (Annexure-G to the writ petition) was interfered with and set
aside to the extent of its effect. It was directed that the pay and allowances
of the petitioner shall be fixed within a period of three months from today. It
is made clear that the petitioners who have retired or would retire, their
payment shall be made within three months from today or with the
retirement benefits, whichever is applicable.
Since the effect was interfered with and the effect of the said memorandum
dated 27.12.2010 was given from 01.01.1996, the earlier date of effect has
become irrelevant and the TRTC respondents cannot take any decision of the
basis of the effect which was w.e.f. 01.12.2010.
Ms R Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner is similarly circumstanced, but since the
petitioner did not approach this court earlier, the respondents have not given
the said benefit to the petitioner in terms of the said judgment dated
04.12.2015.
Mr. KC Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the TRTC respondents
has submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to get any benefit. For this
purpose Mr. Bhattacharjee, has referred para 8 and 9 of the reply filed by the
TRTC respondents which are reproduced below:
“8.
That, with reference to the statements made in
paragraphs 2.1 and 2.2 of the petition it is stated by the
answering respondents that after introduction of Tripura State
civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1986, the petitioner was
appointed in the said post of HV Driver Grade II in the pay scale
of Rs.1020-2620/- which was subsequently enhanced to
Rs.4000-7890- after completion of 10 years of service. There is
no wrong in giving the revised pay scale of Rs.4400-7890/- to
the petitioner. Prior to ROP 1999, the Respondent Corporation
was to follow the ROP 1986 and according to the ROP 1986 the
petitioner was given the pay scale of Rs. 970/- for the post
meant for HV Driver Grade-II.
It is apparent on record particularly from the service
book of the petitioner, wherein it has been clearly mentioned
that the petitioner was temporarily appointed to the post of HV
Driver Gr-II in the scale of pay of Rs.1020-40-1260-50-2620/dated 19.08.1992. There was service break of the petitioner for
195 days from 03.12.1998 to 15.06.1999. Therefore, the
petitioner was granted 1st ACP in the pay scale of Rs.
4000/7890/- w.e.f. 22.08.2003 after 10 years of service. After
07 years of service from 22.08.2003, i.e. 17 years, 2nd ACP Was
granted in the pay scale of Rs. 5310-24000/- as per his entitled
as 17 years of service w.e.f. 01.07.2010. 3 rd ACT after 25 years
of service was allowed to the petitioner after 7 years of
continuous service from 01.07.2010 i.e. the petitioner was
allowed 3rd ACP after 25 years of service in the pay scale of Rs.
5700-24000/- with Grade Pay of Rs. 4200/- w.e.f. 22.08.2018.
9.
That with reference to the statements made in
Paragraphs 2.4-5 it is stated by the answering Respondents
that the petitioner has mentioned a Memo under File No.
F.1(39)-TRTC/ESTT/08/s/ROP/HVD/2010 dated 16.12.2010
said to have been approved allowing heavy vehicle driver of the
State government in fourth ROP 1999, instead of Rs.3300-7100
or that the pay order was issued accordingly vide No.F.6(5)FIN(PC)/PSU/2010 and the pay scale of the Heavy Vehicle
Driver of TRTC has been recommended as Rs. 5310-24000/- but
the financial benefit was allowed w.e.f 01.12.2010 and no
arrear of pay, allowance etc. would be given to the HV Drivers
of TRTC. The claim of the petitioner was to allow the financial
benefit of ROP, 1999 w.e.f. 01.01.1996.
The answering respondents most respectfully state that
as per ROP 1999 the petitioner was appointed in the post of HV
Driver Grade-II in the pay scale of Rs.1020-2620/-. It is
apparent on record that the petitioner was temporarily
appointed to the post of HV Driver Gr-II in the scale of payoff
Rs.1020-4-1260-50-2620/- dated 19.08.1992. After that there
was a service break of 195 days w.e.f. 03.12.1998 to
15.06.1999. Therefore, the petitioner was granted 1 st ACT in the
pay scale of Rs. 4000-7890/- w.e.f. 22.08.2003 after 10 years of
service and after 10+07 years of service from 22.08.2003, i.e.
17 years, 2nd ACP was granted in the pay scale of Rs. 531024000/- as per his entitlement w.e.f. 01.07.2010 and after 25
years of continuous service 3 rd ACP was allowed to the
petitioner w.e.f. 01.07.2017. the petitioner is not entitled to any
further relief.
The respondent Corporation by a Memorandum No.
F.1(39)-TRTC/ ESTT/ 08/ S/ ROP/ HVD/ 2010/ 1070, dated
27/12/2010 decided that the pay scale of heavy Vehicle Driver
of TRTC has been recommended as Rs. 5510-24000/-.Pursuant
to the Note in file No.F.(39)-TRTC/Estt/ 09/S/ROP/2010 HV
Driver it has been approved to give the scale of pay Rs.40007890/- (scale of HV Driver of the State government in 4th ROP,
1999) instead of Rs.3300-7100/- to the Heavy Vehicle Driver.
The pay revision committee cell of TRTC met thus calculates the
pay and allowances of the HV Driver, TRTC accordingly. The
financial benefit will be from 01.12.2010 and no arrear of pay,
allowances etc. will be given HV Driver of TRTC. Therefore, the
petitioner is not entitled to any further financial benefit in the
name of arrear whatsoever. It is apparent that the financial
benefit was restricted from 01.12.2010 and no arrear of pay and
allowance etc. was provided to the heavy vehicle drivers of the
respondent – Corporation.”
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has further submitted that
the petitioner has been paid in terms of the memorandum dated 27.12.2010
and the petitioner is not entitled to any additional amount.
It has been also stated that the said order dated 04.12.2015 of this court has
been implemented by TRTC, and that would be apparent from para 9
reproduced above. TRTC-respondents have contended that it is apparent that
the financial benefit was restricted till 01.12.2010 and no arrear of pay and
allowance etc. was provided to the heavy vehicle drivers working under
TRTC.
It is completely unacceptable, inasmuch as it shows that TRTCrespondents did not give due consideration to the said judgment which is
exclusively applicable only for the Heavy Vehicle Drivers, to which category,
the petitioner belongs.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has further submitted that
the scale of pay of Rs.4000-7890/- is the first ACP scale which has been
granted to the petitioner w.e.f. 22.08.2003 after 10 years of his service
22.08.2003. It is not understandable how TRTC-respondents can treat the
pay scale of Rs.4000-7890 as the higher pay scale vis-à-vis the pay scale of
Rs. 3300-7100. The very scale is the entry scale for Heavy Vehicle Drivers
and that scale had been modified by the said memorandum dated
27.12.2010. Hence, that cannot be treated as the scale for CAS-I.
This movement, if any, granted to the petitioner for purpose of financial
upgradation under CAS is required to revisited by this court as the
controversy raised in this writ petition is rooted in that aspect. The crux of the
controversy as raised by the petitioner is that he is entitled to the scale of pay
of Rs.4000-7890/- as the revised entry scale as the Heavy Vehicle Driver. The
substantial part of the controversy has been settled by the decision in Dipak
Das (supra) where it has been held that the said memorandum dated
27.12.2010 (Annexure-E to the writ petition) requires interference so far its
effect is concerned. It has been clearly declared that the said memorandum
will receive effect w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and the pay of the Heavy Vehicle Drivers
should be fixed accordingly in terms of the provisions of the ROP Rules, 1999.
But in the case of the petitioner, as is evident, that has not been done.
True it is that the petitioner has approached this court belatedly
but in view of State of M.P. Vs. Yogendra Srivastava, reported in (2010)
12 SCC 538 where the apex court after considering the precedents has
clearly observed that in the matters of pay and allowances, the deprivation
continues and every month a person is affected by the action of the
respondents as the said person gets lesser pay or the lesser benefits.
As such, the objection relating to the belated filing cannot come
as the roadblock for granting relief to the petitioner. As such, the
respondents, particularly TRTC-respondents, are directed to fix the pay of the
petitioner in the scale of pay of Rs.4000-7890/- w.e.f. 01.01.1996 in terms of
the ROP Rules, 1999. Since the petitioner has approached this court belatedly
the payment of arrears has to be restricted to a date three years preceding
the date of institution of the writ petition, i.e. 15.11.2018. As such, the
petitioner will get the actual financial benefits from 15.11.2018. The period till
15.11.2018 shall be fixed notionally.
It is also clarified that if in the meanwhile, the benefits of Career
Advancement Scheme or Assured Career Progression Scheme were entitled to
the petitioner that shall be allowed and pay of the petitioner shall be fixed
accordingly.
Such exercise shall be completed within two months from today
as it has been reported by Ms Purakayastha that the petitioner is slated to
retire very soon.
In terms of the above, this petition stands allowed and disposed
of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
lodh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review