Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.145 of 2024
Jiban Debnath,
Son of Late Birendra Kumar Debnath, resident of village-Vidyapith Corner,
Belonia, PO & PS-Belonia, District-South Tripura, Pin-799155, Age-55
years.
...Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Education (School)
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, SubDivision -Sadar, District- West Tripura.
2. The Director of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura, Shiksha
Bhavan, Akhaura Road, PO- Agartala, PS-West Agartala, District- West
Tripura, Pin-799001.
3. The Managing Committee, Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School,
represented by its Secretary, Belonia, District- South Tripura.
4. The District Education Officer South District Office (Chairman of
DPC), Belonia, District- South Tripura.
5. The Secretary, Managing Committee
Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School (Member of DPC), Belonia,
District- South Tripura.
6. The Sub-Divisional Welfare Officer SDM, Belonia Sub-Division
(Member of DPC), Belonia, District- South Tripura.
…. Respondent(s)
Along with
WP(C) No.213 of 2024
Sri Sanjit Biswas,
S/O Lt. Gouranga Biswas, Resident of Vidyapith Tilla, Belonia, P.O. &
P.S.- Belonia, Pin-799155, District- South Tripura.
...Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary to the Department of School Education,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O.Kunjaban, P.S.-NCC, Agartala, District-West Tripura.
2. Director of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura, Shiksha
Bhavan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School, Represented by the
Headmaster, Belonia, P.O. & P.S.- Belonia, Pin-799155, District- South
Tripura.
4. Managing Committee, Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School,
Represented by the Secretary of the Managing Committee, Belonia, P.O. &
P.S.- Belonia, Pin-799155.
5. Sri Jiban Debnath
S/o Late Birender Kumar Debnath, Vidyapith Corner, Belonia, P.O. & P.S.Belonia, Pin-799155, District-South Tripura.
…. Respondent(s)
WP(C) No.214 of 2024
Sri Mrinal Das,
S/O Sri Gunadhar Das, Resident of 222, Kalyannagar, Dakshinpara,
Sabroom, P.O. & P.S.- Sabroom, Pin-799145, District- South Tripura.
...Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary to the Department of School Education,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O.Kunjaban, P.S.-NCC, Agartala, District-West Tripura.
2. Director of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura, Shiksha
Bhavan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School, Represented by the
Headmaster, Belonia, P.O. & P.S.- Belonia, Pin-799155, District- South
Tripura.
4. Managing Committee, Belonia Vidyapith Higher Secondary School,
Represented by the Secretary of the Managing Committee, Belonia, P.O. &
P.S.- Belonia, Pin-799155, District- South Tripura.
5. Sri Jiban Debnath
S/o Late Birender Kumar Debnath, Vidyapith Corner, Belonia, P.O. & P.S.Belonia, Pin-799155, District-South Tripura.
…. Respondent(s)
In WP(C) No.145 of 2024
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. K. Chakraborty, Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. GA
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
In WP(C) No.213 of 2024
In WP(C) No.214 of 2024
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. GA
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
21.01.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The above bunch of writ petitions involves similar and identical
questions of law and facts, and as such, these are taken up and heard together
for disposal with the consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties.
2.
In WP(C) No.145 of 2024, the petitioner, Sri Jiban Debnath has
challenged the impugned decision of Departmental Promotion Committee(for
short, „DPC’) whereby and whereunder his promotion to the post of Assistant
Headmaster under respondent no.3 was rejected. The writ petitioner of WP(C)
No.213 of 2024, Sri Sanjit Biswas and the writ petitioner of WP(C) No.214 of
2024, Sri Mrinal Das, have challenged the seniority of Sri Jiban Debnath, the
petitioner of WP(C) No.145 of 2024.
3.
Short facts enumerated from the pleadings and submissions of
learned counsel appearing for the parties are that the respondents-State had
published a seniority list for promotion to the post of Assistant Headmaster in
Belonia Vidyapith H.S School(Grant-in-aid school) vide Memo dated
23.05.2023[Annexure-1 to WP(C) No.145 of 2024]. In the said seniority list
dated 23.05.2023, Sri Jiban Debnath[petitioner in WP(C) No.145 of 2024] was
placed at serial no.1, Sri Sanjit Biswas [petitioner in WP(C) No.213 of 2024]
was placed at serial no.15 and Sri Mrinal Das [petitioner in WP(C) No.214 of
2024] was placed at serial no.5.
4.
Firstly, while dealing with the case of Sri Jiban Debnath
[petitioner in WP(C) No.145 of 2024], it is found that the DPC was held on
17.02.2024 for consideration of promotion to the post of Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress of Belonia Vidyapith H.S School, Belonia, South
Tripura and in terms of the guidelines of the Directorate of Secondary
Education issued vide Memo.No.F.15(1-44)/SE/GIA/2023(Voll-2) dated
05.10.2023, the DPC while considering the promotion in respect of Sri Jiban
Debnath had observed that, „The ACR submitted by Sri Jiban Debnath of the
said school has been found with some irregularities and the guideline issued
by the Director of Secondary Education (Grant-In-Aid Section), Agartala,
West Tripura were not followed in writing of the Annual Confidential Report
(ACR) for the purpose of the promotion to the Higher Post’. However, the
DPC had made an observation that Sri Jiban Debnath might be recommended
after removing irregularities, if he so desires.
5.
The respondents-State in their counter affidavit [WP(C) No145 of
2024] have stated at para 12 relating to observations made by the members of
DPC. The said statement reads as under:“12. That, with respect to paragraph-2.12 of the writ petition, I
humbly submit that a letter had been received on 01.03.2024 from the
DEO Belonia, South Tripura regarding the recommendation of DPC
along with relevant papers in connection with promotion to the post
of Assistant Headmaster for Belonia Vidyapith H.S. School, Belonia,
South Tripura.
The Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) observed that
the ACR as submitted by Sri Jiban Debnath of the said school has
found some irregularities.”
The statements made in para 20 of the counter affidavit is also
relevant in the context of the case which reads as under:“20. That, with respect to paragraph-2.21 of the writ petition, I
humbly submit that the matter of non-consideration of the petitioner
by the respondents of the said post is not acceptable as per Rules and
due to some allegations raised against the petitioner.”
6.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel appearing for the
parties have fairly submitted that in all probability there were some
mistakes in the construction of the sentence. According to learned counsel
appearing for the parties, the construction/sentence meant to say that some
irregularities were found in the ACRs of Sri Jiban Debnath [petitioner in
WP(C) No.145 of 2024]. In my opinion also, this ought to have been the
correct construction which the respondents-State wanted to state in their
counter affidavit.
6.1
It is an admitted fact that only on the basis of this observation,
the matter of promotion of Sri Jiban Debnath to the post of Assistant
Headmaster was not considered.
7.
During the course of hearing, I posed a question to Mr. P.
Gautam, learned Sr. GA appearing for the State-respondents to inform the
court about those irregularities. Mr. Gautam, learned Sr. GA has candidly
submitted that there is nothing on record. He has drawn my attention only
to the Memo. dated 16.02.2024 [Annexure R/2 to WP(C) 145 of 2024]
whereby and whereunder a three-member Enquiry Committee was
constituted to enquire and submit factual report along with specific views
within 3(three) days to the office of the District Education Officer regarding
alleged unlawful activities of Sri Jiban Debnath, Headmaster In-charge of
Belonia Vidyapith H.S School. The Committee submitted its factual report
on 24.02.2024. In the said report they had stated that they visited the school
on 19th February, 2024 and met Sri Jiban Debnath, Teacher In-charge of
Belonia Vidyapith H.S School, Journalists and the Secretary of School
Management Committee and on point basis they prepared the report and
submitted the same to the District Education Officer, South District
Education Office for consideration.
8.
After perusal of the report, as regards the complaint lodged by
the Child Welfare Committee(CWC) regarding corporal punishment of a
student of Class-XI, namely, Smt. Souramita Debnath by Sri Jiban Debnath,
it comes to fore that the Enquiry Committee, having examined Smt.
Souramita Debnath found that Sri Jiban Debnath had stated that no such
incident as alleged by CWC had happened. Regarding allegation made
against Sri Jiban Debnath that he illegally assaulted some students is denied
by him and stated that he was busy with school routine work. The
Committee found that Sri Jiban Debnath prevented some journalists from
entering into the school and misbehaved with them. At point no.4 of the
findings of the Enquiry Committee, it is stated that Jiban Debnth, though
was tested positive in Covid-19, but he came to school. In this regard, Sri
Jiban Debnath informed the Committee that he did not have any knowledge
about the report/result that he and his daughter were tested positive. The
Committee found storage of 3,400 kg rice of School MDM was damaged
due to un-hygenic and very poor condition of storage and consequently, Sri
Debnath was made responsible for the damage and also Rs.10,200/- was
imposed upon him as penalty. There are some other findings also and thus
the Enquiry Committee submitted its report on 24.02.2024.
9.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
WP(C) No.145 of 2024 has submitted that the meeting of DPC was held on
17.02.2024 and it is apparent that the report of the Committee was
submitted before the District Education Officer on 24.02.2024. So, it is
clear that on the date of the meeting of consideration of promotion of
eligible teachers for promotion to the post of Assistant Headmaster was not
before the DPC. So, it should not be taken into account for consideration of
promotion of Sri Jiban Debnath to the post of Assistant Headmaster of
Belonia Vidyapith H.S School.
9.1
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has further submitted
that the petitioner is senior to Sri Sanjit Biswas and Mrinal Das [petitioners
of WP(C) No.213 of 2024 and WP(C) No.214 of 2024 respectively].
10.
Now dealing with the claim of Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri
Mrinal Das that they are senior to Sri Jiban Debnath, it is found, that claim
is based on rule vide memo dated 07.12.2022 [Annexure-2 to the writ
petition] framed by the Directorate of Secondary Education, Government
of Tripura.
11.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samar Das, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in WP(C) No.213
of 2024 and WP(C) No.214 of 2024 drawing my attention to Clause II (b)
of Rule 5 of Grant-in-Aid (Government Aided Schools) Rules, 2005 has
submitted that though Sri Jiban Debnath entered into service much prior to
Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das, but they acquire Masters Degree
including B.Ed. degree prior to Sri Jiban Debnath. As such, as per Clause II
(b), they are senior to Sri Jiban Debnath. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned senior
counsel has taken me to the statements made in para-9 of WP(C) No.213 of
2024 where it is stated thus:“9. That, the Petitioner has completed Bachelor of Science
(Honours) in Chemistry securing 53.44% marks in 2004.
Petitioner did Masters in Science (Chemistry) securing 54.20%
marks in 2006. Petitioner also did B.Ed. course in the year
2008. The Petitioner thereafter joined in the post of Post
Graduate Teacher in Chemistry under Respondent No.-3.
Needless to mention here that Petitioner also did M.Ed. in
2014. On the contrary Respondent No.-5 entered in the service
under Respondent No.-3 on 13/06/1997 as an Assistant Teacher
in Physics. The Respondent No.-5 had completed Graduation in
Physics (Honours) but obtained Masters degree in different
subject i.e. Education in 2015, which is not relevant subject and
obtained B.Ed. degree in the year 2013. The Respondent No.-5
did his B.Ed. degree without approval from the Government i.e.
the Respondent No. 1 and 2. It is required to mention here that
Respondent No.-5 being the Teacher-in-Charge of Respondent
No.-3 suppressed those facts to the Respondent No. 1 to 4 while
preparing the Final Seniority List and as a sequel DPC runs
with this wrong Seniority List. Respondent No.-5 also
suppressed these facts to the Hon'ble Court in W.P.(C) 145 of
2024.”
11.1
Drawing
my
attention
to
the
above
statements,
Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel has mainly submitted that Sri Sanjit
Biswas and Mrinal Das have obtained Masters Degree and B.Ed degree,
the requisite qualifications for consideration of promotion to the post of
Assistant Headmaster much prior to obtaining of Master degree and B.Ed
degree of Sri Jiban Debnath [petitioner in WP(C) No.145 of 2024]. So,
according to learned senior counsel, Sri Jiban Debnath should be treated as
junior to Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das, since he obtained the
requisite qualification for consideration of promotion subsequent to Sri
Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das. To support his submission, Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel has relied upon the decision of
Supreme Court rendered in Madhavi Vs. Chagan &Ors., Civil Appeal
No.3966 of 2020 [arising out of SLP (Civil) No.9611 of 2019].
12.
I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the parties and also perused the documents attached to the
writ petitions and counter affidavits.
13.
To consider the above three writ petitions, in my opinion,
following points are necessary to be determined:I.
Whether the findings and decisions of the DPC are
tenable in law?
II.
Whether Sri Jiban Debnath [petitioner in WP(C) No.145
of 2024] is senior to Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal
Das [petitioners in WP(C) no.213 of 2024 and WP(C)
no.214 of 2024, respectively] in terms of Clause II (b) of
Rule 5 of Grant-in-Aid (Government Aided Schools)
Rules, 2005 as amended up-to-date?
14.
To deal with the first point, whether the decision of DPC is
tenable in law, I may take note of the grounds taken by the members of
DPC in its meeting held on 17.02.2024. On scrutiny of the observation
made by DPC, it is clear that DPC rejected the consideration of promotion
of Sri Jiban Debnath to the post of Assistant Headmaster on the ground
that they found some irregularities in the ACRs of Sri Jiban Debnath.
Astonishing feature is that, the DPC has not outlined as regards the
irregularities found in the ACRs of the petitioner (Jiban Debnath).
15.
In course of hearing, the respondents-State have not produced
any records relating to the ACRs of the petitioner, Sri Jiban Debnath to
substantiate the irregularities. In the counter affidavit also there is no
mention of the irregularities. In addition, if there were some irregularities
found in the ACRs of Sri Jiban Debnath, next question naturally will be
whether the petitioner was communicated about those irregularities found
in his ACRs. In this regard also the respondents-State could not furnish any
document to substantiate the fact that it was ever communicated to Sri
Jiban Debnath. In view of this, even if DPC found some irregularities in
the ACRs of the petitioner, then it would not be considered as a ground for
rejecting the consideration of promotion of Sri Jiban Debnath to the post of
Assistant Headmaster. It is settled preposition of law that any adverse
remark/entry made in the ACR of an employee must be communicated to
such employee, otherwise it will not have any impact or effect on the
service of the government employee.
16.
Another important feature I have noticed that even if there were
some complaints against Sri Jiban Debnath, those were found to be postdated, i.e. DPC held its meeting on 17.02.2024, but complaint was lodged
on 24.02.2024, so this complaint could not be considered by DPC when its
meeting was held on 17.02.2024.
17.
More importantly, there is no record or evidence that any
disciplinary proceeding was initiated or pending at the time when
necessary process for consideration of promotion to the post in question
was placed before DPC. Upon examination of the facts, I am unable to
discern any valid grounds for denying his eligibility for consideration for
promotion.
18.
Ultimate finding is that, on the date of consideration of
promotion there was no complaint of irregularities against Sri Jiban
Debnath before the DPC. Hence, the first question is determined in favour
of Sri Jiban Debnath and on factual context of the present case the
rejection of the Sri Jiban Debnath for consideration of promotion to the
post of Assistant Headmaster on the basis of the observation made by DPC
is bad, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. Therefore, the decision of the DPC is legally
unsustainable and is liable to be set aside.
19.
Now, coming to the next point for determination whether Jiban
Debnath is senior to Sanjit Biswas and Mrinal Das. At the outset, I have
gone through Clause II (b) of Rule 5 of Grant-in-Aid (Government Aided
Schools) Rules [here-in-after referred to as „GIA Rules, 2005‟], which
reads as under:“b) Appointment to the post of Assistant Headmaster/Assistant
Headmistress shall be made on promotion from among the Post
Graduate Teachers (PGT) of concerned GIA School having at
least Seven years regular teaching experience and requisite
qualification, i.e. Post Graduate (Master degree) with 50%
marks including B.Ed through the duly Constituted
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) approved by the
Director of Secondary Education. Promotion shall be made
strictly according to seniority cum merit cum ACR.”
19.1.
On meticulous reading of the said Clause (b), I find that it has
four parts which are as under:-
“(a) Promotion will be made from among the Post Graduate
Teachers (PGT) of concerned GIA School having at least Seven
years of regular teaching experience.
(b) Requisite qualification is Post Graduate (Master degree) with
50% marks including B.Ed.
(c) Matter of promotion will be considered by a Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) to be approved by the Director of
Secondary Education.
(d) Promotion shall be made strictly according to seniority-cummerit-cum ACR”
20.
Admittedly, the respondents-State have published final
seniority list of eligible teachers for consideration of promotion to the post
of Assistant Headmaster vide memo dated 23.05.2023 [Annexure-1 to
WP(C) 213 of 2024]. The relevant part of seniority position settled in the
final seniority list is as under:S.N
Name
P.Band
Date
o
of
/G.P./
Birth
Emplo
Scale
yees
of Pay
of
Date
of
Educational
Superannua
Qualfication
tion
year along with % of
Marks
in
with
Master
Degree
Design
copy of the mark
ation
sheet
Joining
of
Date
is
with
Hon‟s/
to
(a
B/Ed./T.Ed.
Whet
Etc
her
ure of
result
SC/S
the
publication
T &
emplo
date)
Other
yee
s
concer
(with
Contact No.
be
Signat
ned
enclose)
1.
Jiban
Debnat
30.11.196
13.06.1997
30.11.2029
h, PGT
B.Sc. (Hons) Physics
B.Ed.
(02
(53.13% 1991), M.A.
year)
Edu, (52.60%, 2015)
04/07/2013
B.Sc. (Hons) Physics
B.Ed.
49.67%, 2002, M.Sc.
year)
Mathemetics (55.7%,
24/11.2005
OBC
943652648
Sd/-
(TIC)
5.
Mrinal
Das,
02.01.198
22.03.2006
31.01.2041
PGT
(01
SC
943651745
Sd/-
2004)
15.
Sanjit
Biswas
, PGT
19.04.198
03.11.2008
30.04.2043
B.Sc.
(Hons),
B.Ed.
year)
53.44%),
M.S.c,
Chemistry
(54.20%) 2006
(01
30.09.2008,
Med.
(06.03.2014
)
UR
961242432
Sd/-
21.
Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das have challenged the above
seniority list in their respective writ petitions. The main plea taken by Sri
Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das while challenging the seniority of Sri
Jiban Debnath is that they acquired/possessed Master Degree including
B.Ed much prior to attainment of Master Degree and B.Ed degree of Sri
Jiban Debnath. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioners in WP(C) 213 of 2024 and WP(C) 214 of 2024
admitted that Sri Jiban Debnath had entered into service in the year 1997,
that is, much prior to the entry of service of Sanjit and Mrinal. Here, the
question is whether acquisition of degree/requisite qualification would be
the sole criteria for consideration of promotion to the post of Assistant
Headmaster in terms of Clause II (b) of Rule 5 of Grant-in-Aid
(Government Aided Schools) Rules, as amended up to date.
22.
As I noted earlier, the said Clause II (b) consists of four parts.
The first part says that
promotion to the post of
Assistant
Headmaster/Assistant Headmistress will be made among the post of
Postgraduate Teachers (PGT) of concerned GIA Schools. Admittedly, Sri
Jiban Debnath, Sri Sanjit Biswas and Mrinal Das have been discharging
their duties and responsibilities as Post Graduate Teacher in the same
School under the respondent No.3. Now, as per second part of II (b), all of
them have requisite experience of regular teaching for at least 7 years.
Now, the most important question to be dealt with as I said earlier and
strenuously argued by learned senior counsel appearing for Sri Sanjit
Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das that the date of acquiring of Master Degree and
B.Ed degree should be the criteria for determination of seniority as
stipulated in Clause II (b) of Rule 5 of the GIA Rules, 2005. Keeping in
mind the Rules of statutory interpretation, there cannot be any quarrel that,
primarily, the only duty of the court is to give effect of the literal meaning
of language of the statute. To say it otherwise, words employed in the text
of the statute are clear and plain and do not suffer from any ambiguity,
then the court must give or interpret its natural and ordinary meaning. Rule
5 of GIA Rules, 2005 being a statutory rule, the golden rule of literal
construction of statutes should be adopted by the court as indicated in
Chapter 2 of Maxwell on the Interpretation of Statutes, 12th Edition.
23.
At this juncture, I have gone through the decision of Supreme
Court in the case of Madhavi(supra). In the case of Madhavi(Supra), I
find that the promotion of teachers is governed by the Maharashtra
Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981 [for
short, „Maharashtra Rules, 1981‟]. Having perused the judgment passed in
Madhavi(Supra), I find that Maharashtra Rules, 1981 have made provision
for categorization of teachers according to the dates of acquisition of their
degrees. In the instant case, Clause II (b) of Rule 5 of the GIA Rules, 2005
do not lay down any criteria for categorizing the teachers having regard to
the date of obtaining the requisite qualifications for consideration of
promotion of teachers to the post of Assistant Headmaster. In light of the
above, the instant case is factually distinguishable from the case of
Madhavi(Supra).
24.
In the case on hand, as I said earlier, the requisite qualification
for promotion to the post of Assistant Headmaster is explicit in Clause II
(b) of Rule 5 of the GIA Rules, 2005. Under clause II (b), the only criteria
is that after obtaining the Master Degree and B.Ed degree the teachers
must have the experience of at least 7(seven) years. The said essential
qualifications are met by all the writ petitioners of the aforementioned writ
petitions. Be that as it may, in my opinion, seniority will be counted on the
basis of date of entry into the service. Admittedly, Sri Jiban Debnath
entered into the service in the year 1997 and Sri Sanjit Biswas and Mrinal
Das in 2008 and 2006 respectively.
25.
Upon careful analysis of the above two points, it is hereby held
that the findings and decisions of the DPC in its meeting held on
17.02.2024 are arbitrary and not legally sustainable. As such, the
recommendation is liable to be quashed. Accordingly, the impugned
decision of the DPC disentitling Sri Jiban Debnath [petitioner in WP(C)
145 of 2024] for promotion to the post of Assistant Headmaster is quashed
and set aside.
26.
Further, Sri Jiban Debnath [petitioner in WP(C) 145 of 2024] is
senior to Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das [petitioners in WP(C) 213
of 2024 and WP(C) 214 of 2024, respectively] as per their dates of entry
into service.
27.
Since both the questions are answered in favour of Sri Jiban
Debnath [petitioner in WP(C) 145 of 2024], he is entitled to be considered
for promotion to the post of Assistant Headmaster in Belonia Vidyapith
H.S School(Grant-in-aid school) under the respondents.
28.
The respondents are directed to constitute a Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) afresh within a period of 30(thirty) days
from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
29.
Further, the newly constituted DPC is directed to complete the
proceeding within next 30(thirty) days for consideration of promotion of
Jiban Debnath to the post of Assistant Headmaster in Belonia Vidyapith
H.S School(Grant-in-aid school) keeping in mind the discussions and the
directions passed by this court in the preceding paragraphs of the
judgment.
30.
In the light of above discussions and the reasons thereof, the
petition filed by Sri Jiban Debnath is allowed and the writ petitions filed by
Sri Sanjit Biswas and Sri Mrinal Das are dismissed.
2.
JUDGE
Rohit
SAIKA
T KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2025.02.28
15:39:54 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review