Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) NO.13 OF 2024
Sri Maran Debnath.
…… Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. R. Datta, Advocate.
Mr. S. Nag, Advocate.
Mr. H. Das, Advocate.
Mr. S. Debnath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 20.05.2025.
Whether fit for reporting : NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
(T. Amarnath Goud, J)
This is an appeal filed under Section 374(2) of the
Cr.PC against the impugned Judgment and Order of conviction
and sentence dated 01.12.2022 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, Khowai, Tripura, in Case No. ST (T-1) 08 of 2022, whereby
and whereunder the appellant has been convicted under Sections
302 and 323 of the Indian Penal Code (in short IPC) and
sentenced to suffer life imprisonment for the offence punishable
under Section 302, with a fine of Rs. 5,000/- with default
stipulation. He has been also sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.
1,000/- for the offence punishable under Section 323 of IPC, and
in default of payment, he shall suffer SI for a period of one
month.
2.
The facts of the case in brief are that on
16.02.2021, on the day of "Saraswati Puja" at about 09:30 a.m.,
the informant Rajkumar Debnath was at his home. At that time,
the convict appellant was about to go out on a bike with his
daughter Sikha Debnath. The mother of the appellant i.e. the wife
of the informant forbade the appellant from going out with the
bike. When she forbade Maran i.e the appellant herein, he
attacked his mother with a piece of wood on her head and leg in
the presence of the informant. She sustained serious bleeding
injuries. After that, appellant himself took the informant and his
wife to Khowai Hospital for treatment. They were then referred to
GB
Hospital
at
Agartala
for
better
treatment.
Appellant
accompanied them. By this time, Ajit Debnath and the brothersin-law rushed to GB Hospital and the appellant fled away. Though
the informant was discharged from the hospital, his wife was
admitted. On 19.02.2021, the wife of the informant, namely
Suniti Debnath, succumbed to her injuries. It is alleged that due
to the attack by the appellant, his mother died. As the informant
was busy with treatment, the lodging of the FIR was delayed. On
20.02.2021 at about 23:10 hours, on receipt of the ejahar, a case
was registered being Khowai PS Case No. 2021/KHW/020 dated
20.02.2021 under Sections 326/302 of IPC.
3.
The case was entrusted to SI Subendu Das for
investigation. During the investigation, he visited the place of
occurrence and prepared a hand-sketch map with a separate
index, seized the concerned articles by preparing seizure lists,
collected the SFSL report, obtained the post-mortem examination
report, recorded statements of witnesses under Section 161 of
CrPC, arrested the accused person, namely, Maran Debnath, and
arranged for recording the statements under Section 164(5) of
CrPC of the witnesses. Thereafter, on completion of investigation,
a prima facie case having appeared, he submitted a charge-sheet
bearing No. 01/2022 under Sections 323/302 of IPC dated
16.01.2022 against Maran Debnath to stand trial.
4.
During the trial, upon consideration of the
record and the documents submitted therewith and after hearing
submissions from both sides, charge was framed against the
accused under Sections 302 and 323 of IPC. Upon hearing the
matter and contents of the charge, he pleaded not guilty and
claimed to be tried.
5.
To prove the case, the prosecution examined
as many as 14 witnesses.
6.
At the time of examination under Section
313(1)(b) of CrPC, the accused denied all the incriminating
materials which appeared in the prosecution evidence.
7.
After hearing both parties, the learned Court
below convicted the appellant under Sections 302 and 323 of IPC
and sentenced him as stated above.
8.
Being highly aggrieved and dissatisfied with
the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence dated
01.12.2022 passed by the learned Sessions Judge Khowai
Tripura, in Case No. ST (T-1) 08 of 2022, the appellant preferred
this appeal.
9.
Heard
Mr.
Ratan
Datta,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appellant, as well as Mr. R. Saha, learned Addl.
P.P., appearing for the respondent.
10.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant submitted that the findings of the learned Trial Court
are unjustified, perverse, and not supported by the evidence on
record. It is contended by the learned counsel that the incident in
question occurred suddenly and without any premeditation. There
existed no prior history of animosity or dispute between the
appellant and the deceased, which would suggest any motive or
intention to cause death. The entire episode was a result of a
sudden loss of control in the heat of the moment. It is further
submitted that immediately after the occurrence, the appellant
himself took the injured to Khowai Hospital for initial medical
treatment and thereafter accompanied her to GB Hospital for
better medical care. This conduct of the appellant is indicative of
his shock and remorse, and negates any theory of deliberate
intent or malice aforethought. Learned counsel further submitted
that the evidence of PW-6 (daughter of the deceased) is
inconsistent
and
unreliable.
While
PW-6
claimed
that
the
appellant assaulted the deceased all over her body with a piece of
firewood. But, both PW-1 and PW-2 deposed that PW-6 had
informed them that the deceased had sustained a single blow on
her head. Furthermore, PW-6, in her cross-examination, admitted
that she could not recall whether she had informed the police that
the deceased was beaten all over the body. These material
contradictions in the prosecution witnesses cast serious doubt on
the reliability of the prosecution’s version. Lastly, it is submitted
that the conviction under Section 302 IPC is wholly unsustainable.
At best, the facts of the present case may attract the provisions
of Section 304 Part II IPC, as the act was done without any
intention to cause death. Accordingly, the appellant is entitled to
the benefit of a modified conviction under Section 304 Part II IPC.
To support his case, learned counsel relied
upon para-20 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment reported
in AIR 2017 SC 1150 titled as Arjun and anr.etc.etc. Vs.
State of Chhattisgarh. The same is reproduced herein:“20. To invoke this exception (4), the
requirements that are to be fulfilled have been laid down
by this Court in Surinder Kumar vs. Union Territory of
Chandigarh (1989) 2 SCC 217; (AIR 1989 SC 1094, Para 6),
it has been explained as under:“7. To invoke this exception four requirements must be
satisfied, namely,
(i) it was a sudden fight; (ii) there was no premeditation;
(iii) the act was done in a heat of passion; and (iv) the
assailant had not taken any undue advantage or acted in a
cruel manner. The cause of the quarrel is not relevant nor is
it relevant who offered the provocation or started the
assault. The number of wounds caused during the
occurrence is not a decisive factor but what is important is
that the occurrence must have been sudden and
unpremeditated and the offender must have acted in a fit of
anger. Of course, the offender must not have taken any
undue advantage or acted in a cruel manner. Where, on a
sudden quarrel, a person in the heat of the moment picks
up a weapon which is handy and causes injuries, one of
which proves fatal, he would be entitled to the benefit of
this exception provided he has not acted cruelly…………..”
11.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant to
support his argument further relied upon the Judgment of this
Court bearing No.CRL.A(J) No.02 of 2022 titled as Sri Kanulal
Debnath and The State of Tripura dated 17.05.2023.
12.
On the other hand, learned Mr. R. Saha,
learned Addl. P.P., appearing for the respondent submits that the
convict appellant caused multiple hit due to which the victim
succumbed to his injures and the Judgment and Order of
Sentence as passed by the Court is just and proper and needs no
further interference.
13.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
14.
P.W.-6, Miss Sikha Debnath (the sister), and
P.W.-7, Shri Rajkumar Debnath (the father), stated that the
accused took the deceased victim to the hospital after the
incident. They are the eye-witnesses. P.W.-7 is an eye-witnesscum-victim. He also stated that he was taken to the hospital but
was released early. Both P.W.-1 and P.W.-2, in their depositions,
stated that P.W.-6, i.e., an eye witness of this incident informed
them that the appellant took a piece of firewood and struck the
victim-deceased on the head. So, there is no mention of multiple
blows by the convict-appellant, as allegedly stated by P.W.-6
immediately after the incident, according to the accounts of P.W.1 and P.W.-2. Even during cross-examination, P.W.-6 stated that
she could not remember whether she had told the police that her
brother had delivered blows on the whole body of her mother.
15.
This Court, after evaluating all the evidence
on record, is of the view that the incident happened on the spur
of the moment. The testimonies of P.W.-6 and P.W.-7, who stated
that the convict took the victims to the hospital after the incident,
also point to his remorse and shock, which indicates that the
convict did not intend to cause the incident, but it occurred
spontaneously. It was out of fit of anger and due to sudden
provocation
he
got
furious
and
attacked
his
parents
indiscriminately. Later, he took them to hospital for treatment.
There is no antecedent of wrongful behavior. Thus it can be
considered as an act of culpable homicide not amounting to
murder under Section 299 of IPC and punishment under Section
304(2) of IPC would be up to 10 Years of imprisonment or fine or
both under the said offence.
17.
Furthermore, just after the incident,
P.W.-6, the sister, who reported the incident to P.W.-1 and P.W.2, did not mention multiple blows by the convict-appellant to the
deceased victim. This omission further creates doubt in the mind
of the Court. As such, taking into consideration the observations
laid
down
in
Arjun
and
Anr.
etc.
etc.
vs.
State
of
Chhattisgarh (supra) by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court
is of the opinion that the offence committed by the convictappellant warrants a sentence of 7 (seven) years under Section
304 of the IPC, and the period already undergone by the convictappellant shall be set off. Accordingly, the same is ordered in
favour of the appellant and he shall be released after completion
of his sentence, if not required in any other case.
16.
As such, the impugned Judgment and Order of
conviction dated 01.12.2022, as given by the Court below, is
modified to the extent indicated above.
17.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated.
Pending application(s), if any also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
suhanjit
signed
RAJKUMAR Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2025.05.22
SINGHA
15:08:40 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review