The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 05.2022 Heard Ms. R Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. K De, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondents. There is no dispute about the basic facts as averred in this writ petition. The petitioner has been appointed on fixed pay of Rs.12,000/- per month in the post of Group-D (Class-IV) under Die-in-harness scheme in the Directorate of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura by memorandum dated 29.06.2020 (Annexure-A to the writ petition). According to the petitioner, he is entitled to get the fixed pay @ of Rs.16,000/- per month as the minimum in the pay scale for the regular Group-D employees. Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel has pointed out that in order to truncate the fixed pay, the respondents have relied on the memorandum dated 06.04.2002 (Annexure –D to the writ petition). The said memorandum has stipulated that in continuation of the memorandum dated 15.12.2001 (Annexure-C to the writ petition), the government has taken a decision that fixed pay in case of appointment to Group-C and Group-D employees will be 65% and 75% respectively is of the minimum of the scale of concerned post. Accordingly, the petitioner pay‟s was fixed at Rs.12,000/- on 75% of the pay of the pay scale of the direct regular Group D employee. According to Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel, this is grossly against the concept of equal pay for equal work. Even the …
160. 10.2007 such fixed pay is determined. Mr. Dey has also admitted that in recent times, some changes has been made. He has pointed out to the memorandum dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure-R2 to the reply filed by the respondents). In the said memorandum dated 16.10.2007, it has been provided that the fixed pay amount will be determined under formula of 75% of the initial basic pay in the time scale of the group-D employees and 65% of the initial basic pay in the same time scale for the group-C employees. Further, a number of fixed pay posts including supernumerary posts were also created for providing job under the die-in-harness scheme or extremist violence scheme. This contention cannot be sustained in view of the authoritative pronouncement of the apex court that the doctrine of equal pay for equal work would apply to all the temporary employees concerned so as to vest in them the right to claim wages at par with the minimum of the pay scale of the regularly engaged government employees. Thus, the determination of the fixed pay in terms of the memorandum dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure-R2 to the reply filed by the respondents), the memorandum dated 06.04.2002 (Annexure-D to the writ petition) is, therefore, interfered with and set aside in view of the principle laid down in Jagjit Singh (supra). Now, in determining the pay of the fixed pay employees who are appointed keeping the regular pa…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP (C) No. 799 of 2021
Sri Litan Shil
……..Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura & 2 Ors.
…….Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. R Purkayastha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K De, Addl. GA.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
24.05.2022
Heard Ms. R Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. K De, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondents.
There is no dispute about the basic facts as averred in this writ
petition. The petitioner has been appointed on fixed pay of Rs.12,000/- per
month in the post of Group-D (Class-IV) under Die-in-harness scheme in the
Directorate
of
Secondary
Education,
Government
of
Tripura
by
memorandum dated 29.06.2020 (Annexure-A to the writ petition). According
to the petitioner, he is entitled to get the fixed pay @ of Rs.16,000/- per month
as the minimum in the pay scale for the regular Group-D employees.
Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel has pointed out that in order
to truncate the fixed pay, the respondents have relied on the memorandum
dated 06.04.2002 (Annexure –D to the writ petition). The said memorandum
has stipulated that in continuation of the memorandum dated 15.12.2001
(Annexure-C to the writ petition), the government has taken a decision that
fixed pay in case of appointment to Group-C and Group-D employees will
be 65% and 75% respectively is of the minimum of the scale of concerned
post. Accordingly, the petitioner pay‟s was fixed at Rs.12,000/- on 75% of the
pay of the pay scale of the direct regular Group D employee.
According to Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel, this is grossly
against the concept of equal pay for equal work. Even the memorandum
dated 15.12.2020 (Annexure-C to the writ petition) has been challenged as
by the said memorandum it has been provided that Group C and Group D
posts on fixed pay basis will be available for the Die-in-harness scheme
meaning, those employment will also be guided by the government policy
that the regular pay scale will be available after completion of five years as
the fixed pay employees of that category.
Even though the said memorandum dated 29.06.2020 has been
challenged, there is no ground in respect of the constitutionality of the said
memorandum dated 26.12.2015 (Annexure-B to the writ petition). In the writ
petition, it has been averred that the appointments under the Die-in-harness
scheme shall only be made against the regular post and if required, by
creating supernumerary post.
But it has not been denied that in cases of all direct recruitments
to the regular post [borne in the Group C & D category] it is made keeping
the regular pay scale in abeyance. For the first five years only the fixed pay is
paid and no regular scale is given to the direct recruitee. Therefore, the
persons who are appointed under the Die-in-harness scheme cannot be put
on a higher pedestal inasmuch as the direct recruits are appointed on merit
whereas the appointments under the Die-in-harness scheme are made for
compassionate ground.
But the contention of Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel is
absolutely correct that such pay cannot be in defiance of the doctrine of
„equal pay for equal work‟. In this regard Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel
has relied the decision of the apex court in State of Punjab & Others vs. Jagjit
Singh and Others reported in (2017) 1 SCC 148 where in the apex court has
categorically observed that where the temporary employees are appointed
in regular selection post after undergoing through the selection process and
where though appointments of the temporary employees were not against
regular selection post but their services were used continuously with notional
breaks by the state government or its instrumentalities for a period of ten
years or more, the work was perennial in nature and having worked for a
long period, equitable right is created in their favour.
It has been observed in Jagjit Singh (supra) that there is no room
for any doubt that the principle of “equal pay for equal work” has emerged
from interpretation of different provisions of the Constitution. The principle has
been expounded through a large number of judgments rendered by the
apex Court. So it constitutes law being declared by the apex court. The
same is binding on all the courts in India under Article 141 of the Constitution
of India. It is fallacious to determine artificial parameters to deny fruits of
labour. An employee engaged for the same work cannot be paid less than
another who performs the same duties and responsibilities. Certainly not, in a
welfare State. Such an action besides being demeaning, strikes at the very
foundation of human dignity. Anyone, who is compelled to work at a lesser
wage does not do so voluntarily. He does so to provide food and shelter to
his family, at the cost of his self-respect and dignity, at the cost of his selfworth, and at the cost of his integrity. For he knows that his dependants
would suffer immensely, if he does not accept the lesser wage. Any act of
paying less wages as compared to others similarly situated, constitutes an
act of exploitative enslavement, emerging out of a domineering position.
Undoubtedly, the action is oppressive, suppressive and coercive, as it
compels involuntary subjugation.
Finally, the following passage in Jagjit Singh (supra) it has been
observed as follows:
“60. Having traversed the legal parameters with reference to the
application of the principle of “equal pay for equal work”, in
relation to temporary employees (daily-wage employees, ad
hoc appointees, employees appointed on casual basis,
contractual employees and the like), the sole factor that
requires our determination is, whether the employees
concerned (before this Court), were rendering similar duties and
responsibilities as were being discharged by regular employees
holding the same/corresponding posts. This exercise would
require the application of the parameters of the principle of
“equal pay for equal work” summarised by us in para 42 above.
However, insofar as the instant aspect of the matter is
concerned, it is not difficult for us to record the factual position.
We say so, because it was fairly acknowledged by the learned
counsel representing the State of Punjab, that all the temporary
employees in the present bunch of appeals were appointed
against posts which were also available in the regular
cadre/establishment. It was also accepted that during the
course of their employment, the temporary employees
concerned were being randomly deputed to discharge duties
and responsibilities which at some point in time were assigned
to regular employees. Likewise, regular employees holding
substantive posts were also posted to discharge the same work
which was assigned to temporary employees from time to time.
There is, therefore, no room for any doubt, that the duties and
responsibilities discharged by the temporary employees in the
present set of appeals were the same as were being discharged
by regular employees. It is not the case of the appellants, that
the respondent employees did not possess the qualifications
prescribed for appointment on regular basis. Furthermore, it is
not the case of the State that any of the temporary employees
would not be entitled to pay parity on any of the principles
summarised by us in para 42 hereinabove. There can be no
doubt, that the principle of “equal pay for equal work” would be
applicable to all the temporary employees concerned, so as to
vest in them the right to claim wages on a par with the minimum
of the pay scale of regularly engaged government employees
holding the same post.”
[Emphasis added]
Mr. K De, learned Addl. GA has submitted that the state has
been applying the policy in making payment of the fixed pay for the first five
years to the direct recruits and according to the memorandum dated
160.10.2007 such fixed pay is determined. Mr. Dey has also admitted that in
recent times, some changes has been made. He has pointed out to the
memorandum dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure-R2 to the reply filed by the
respondents). In the said memorandum dated 16.10.2007, it has been
provided that the fixed pay amount will be determined under formula of
75% of the initial basic pay in the time scale of the group-D employees and
65% of the initial basic pay in the same time scale for the group-C
employees. Further, a number of fixed pay posts including supernumerary
posts were also created for providing job under the die-in-harness scheme or
extremist violence scheme.
This contention cannot be sustained in view of the authoritative
pronouncement of the apex court that the doctrine of equal pay for equal
work would apply to all the temporary employees concerned so as to vest in
them the right to claim wages at par with the minimum of the pay scale of
the regularly engaged government employees.
Thus, the determination of the fixed pay in terms of the
memorandum dated 16.10.2007 (Annexure-R2 to the reply filed by the
respondents), the memorandum dated 06.04.2002 (Annexure-D to the writ
petition) is, therefore, interfered with and set aside in view of the principle
laid down in Jagjit Singh (supra). Now, in determining the pay of the fixed
pay employees who are appointed keeping the regular pay scale the
priniciple of Jagjit Singh (supra) shall be followed.
The respondents are directed that the fixed pay for the first five
years period of the appointment keeping the regular pay scale in abeyance
has to be re-determined in terms of the law declared under para 60 of the
Jagjit Singh (supra). Thus, the petitioner‟s fixed pay be redetermined at the
minimum of the pay scale of regular engaged government employees for
the said post, post will be the fixed pay of the petitioner and the petitioner
will be entitled to that fixed pay for the next five years, as he will be placed
in the regular pay scale on the following day of completion of the five years
term. Accordingly, whatever the arrears would accrue be paid to the
petitioner and the petitioner be continued to be paid in the said rate, till he
completes the five years period. Such arrears be paid within a period of four
months from the day the petitioner furnishes a copy of this order.
So far the prayer for appointing the petitioner under the regular
scale stands rejected.
In terms thereof, this writ petition is partly allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review