Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.678 of 2023
Sri Lal Bahadur Magar Pachbhaiya
.....Petitioner
-V-E-R-S-U-SThe State of Tripura & 3 Others
.....Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
For legal reporting
:
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. B. Paul, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. A. L. Saha, Advocate.
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
02.02.2024
Heard Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
B. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner also heard Mr. M.
Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. and Mr. A. L. Saha, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
[2]
The present petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for setting aside the letter dated 11.01.2023 sent by the
respondent No.2 bank to the petitioner intimating recovery of Rs.5,50,000/- by
illegally deducted from the petitioner’s bank account. Also for directing the
respondents to refund the illegally recovered amount of Rs.5,50,000/- by
illegally deducted from petitioner’s bank account.
[3]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
i. Issue RULE NISI.
ii. Issue Rule calling upon the respondents or each one of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Certiorari quashing, cancelling, and
setting aside the impugned letter dated 11.01.2023 shall not be issued.
iii. Issue Rule calling upon the respondents or each one of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued
mandating, commanding, and directing the respondents to immediately
refund the illegally recovered amount of Rs. 5,50,000/ of the Bank account
of the petitioner, illegally.
iv. Issue rule calling upon the Respondents/ each one of them to show cause
as to why any other appropriate Writ(s), Order(s), Direction(s) shall not be
passed for complete and full relief to the Petitioner.
v. Pass necessary Order(s) as may be deem fit and proper.
AND
In case, the Respondents show cause or not after hearing your Lordships
may be pleased to make the rule absolute in terms of prayers made in para i
to iv, as above.”
[4]
The case in brief is that the petitioner joined the office of the
Directorate of Handloom, Handicrafts and Sericulture, Government of Tripura in
the year 1980 as "group D Peon" having PPO number 111819343 and was
posted at Agartala. Subsequently he was transferred to New Delhi office of the
State respondents wherefrom he had retired voluntarily, on health ground on
31.01.2018, after successfully working under the state for 37 years 9 months and
he was paid all the retiral benefits in accordance with the relevant rules.
[5]
The state of Tripura there after revised the pension and D.A to all
pensioners vide notification dated 06.11.2018, 02.03.2021 and 04.08.2022,
respectively. The petitioner approached the authority for such revised pension
and D.A but the respondent 3 all on a sudden vide communication dated
11.02.2023 informed the petitioner that an amount of Rs. 7,64,516/- was paid in
excess towards pension and as such decided to recover the same and abruptly
recovered an amount of Rs. 5,50,000/- against the principals laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court reported (2015) 4 SCC 334.
[6]
Hence, the present petition has been filed by the petitioner before
this Court for redress.
[7]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. B.
Paul, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the
petitioner was turning into his late 60’s and decided to step down from his duties
and after serving 37 years 9 months as Group-D peon, the petitioner announced
his retirement on 31.01.2018. The government of Tripura issued a notification
dated 06.11.2018 with regard to revision of pension of pensioners and family
pensioners wherein the basic pension amount as on 30.09.2018 was to be
divided by 2.25 and the amount of revised pension was to be rounded off to
nearest hundred rupees.
[8]
The Government of Tripura issued a Memorandum dated
02.03.2021 for grant of dearness relief at the rate of 3% of the basic
pension/basic family pension as admissible under Tripura State Civil Services
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2017 (Hereinafter referred to as "TSCS") to State
Government pensioners/family Pensioners effective from 01.03.2021. After the
above notification, again issued a Memorandum dated 04.08.2022 for release of
installments of dearness relief as admissible under TSCS.
[9]
In compliance of the above notifications, the petitioner on
13.10.2022 wrote a letter to the Head of Centralized Pension Processing Centre
(CPPC), SBI & letter dated 17.12.022 to the Pay and Accounts Officer-V
(Pension), Tis Hazari, Delhi informing about not receiving the revised pension
and dearness relief @ 8% i.e. (3% +5%) as per the notification dated 04.08.2022
and further requesting to release the pension in compliance of notification dated
04.08.2022.
[10]
Subsequently, the Pay and Accounts Officer-V (Pension), Tis
Hazari, Delhi sent a letter to the Manager of Respondent No.4 bank forwarding
the petitioner's representation and to take necessary actions with regards to
revised pension and dearness relief of the petitioner. The internal
correspondence amongst the bank officials dated 11.01.2023 has infringed the
right of the petitioner and the respondent bank straightway without any authority
or any demand raised by the parent department has taken steps for recovery of
Rs.7,64,516/- in 165 installments @4641/-. In pursuance of the said
correspondence
dated
11.01.2023
the
respondent
bank
has
deducted
Rs.5,50,000/- and also some installments as indicated above. The petitioner has
also addressed mail to the branch manager of the respondent No.4 bank on
12.01.2023, but the same was not satisfactorily answered showing the authority
for the said deduction and the reply mail dated 13.01.2023 only indicated that
excesses payment has been made. The State-respondent has filed their counter
on behalf of respondent Nos.1 and 2 and the bank respondent Nos.3 and 4 have
also filed their counter.
[11]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner has contended that the action of the respondents in deducting the
amounts from the account of the petitioner is the one without any authority and
violative of principles of natural justice and there was no demand made by the
official respondents addressing the bank to deduct the amounts. If any mistake is
committed by the bank in making access payment, it is for the bank to give show
cause with detail statement and call for the explanation and also further demand
to remit the amount by the petitioner.
[12]
Learned Government Advocate appearing for the State respondent
has fairly contended that they have not issued any such demand directing the
respondent bank to deduct the amounts from the account of the petitioner and
pleaded ignorance of the said transaction.
[13]
Mr. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondent bank in all
fairness represented that there was no demand raised by the employer of the
petitioner that the respondent No.2 to recover any amount and to that effect no
demand was raised addressing the bank. He also submitted that access amount
paid by the bank was recovered and the same was without giving any
opportunity to the petitioner thus, to pass appropriate order further prayed to
protect the interest of the bank since, public money is involved.
[14]
It has been further contended that the respondent No.4 bank in
pursuance of the above letter deducted an amount of Rs. 5,50,000/- from the
petitioner account without petitioner's consent. It is submitted that in general
parlance,
recovery
is
prohibited
by
courts
where
there
exists
no
misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the pensioner and the excess payment
was made applying the wrong interpretation of a rule or order by the department.
Thereafter, the petitioner wrote a letter to the branch manager, demanding the
answers of his grievances.
[15]
The petitioner received email from the respondent No.2 bank
wherein the petitioner was informed that an excess pension payment of Rs.
7,64,516/- was made to the petitioner's account and an amount of Rs. 3,50,000
has been deducted towards recovery of the same. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
has held that the relief against the recovery has to be granted not because of any
right of the employees but in equity, exercising judicial discretion to provide
relief to the employees from the hardship that will be caused if the recovery is
ordered. The petitioner again on 09.02.2023 raised his grievances before the
Officer, Office of Banking Ombudsman explaining the difficulty which the
petitioner has faced because of the conduct of the respondent No.4 bank in
deducting the amount of Rs. 5,50,000/- and further requesting the respondent
No.2 bank to refund the amount deducted from the petitioner's saving account.
[16]
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel in support of his case has placed
reliance on a decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Punjab & Others v.
Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and Another, reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334,
wherein the Court has held as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein above, we may, as a
ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries
by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service
(or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire
within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been made for
a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior
post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.”
[17]
The petitioner on 19.02.2023 received an email from the
respondent No.3 requesting the petitioner to submit its reply with regards his
complaint. The petitioner on 23.02.2023 filed its reply to the above mentioned
complaint before the Officer, Office of Banking Ombudsman wherein the
petitioner has relied upon a judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
which states that the recovery of pension from the retired employee is
impermissible in law.
[18]
The petitioner has been running from pillar to post in order to
resolve the issue and to recover the hard earned money deducted from the
petitioner’s account but the same was of no use. On 05.06.2023, the petitioner
because of the undue hardship suffered a brain stroke for which the petitioner
was admitted to the Neigrihms, Shillong, Meghalaya wherein it was informed
that the petitioner’s right side of the body has been paralyzed. As the petitioner’s
condition was getting worse, the petitioner was thereafter admitted to ICU in the
Health City Hospital, Guwahati, Assam and subsequently, discharged on
17.06.2023 after paying the bill of Rs.3,48,223/-.
[19]
The impugned order suffers from material irregularities which will
result in miscarriage of justice and hence has been passed without proper
application of mind. The respondents have failed to revise the petitioner’s
pension and dearness relief as admissible under TSCS. The general parlance,
recovery is prohibited by Courts where there exists no misrepresentation or fraud
on the part of the employee.
[20]
In reply to the above submissions made by the learned senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner, Mr. A. L. Saha, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent-bank has submitted a written argument before this Court
wherein, it has been contended that the petitioner used to receive his pension
through his account maintained in the State Bank of India, Office of the pay &
accounts officer No. 5 (Pension) Govt. of National Capital Territory of Delhi,
Treasury Building. Tis Hazari, Delhi-110054 by communication dated
21/11/2022 requested the Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Tis Hazari
Court Complex, Delhi- 110054 to revise the petitioner's pension and his
Dearness Relief. Accordingly pension and Dearness Relief was calculated by the
State Bank of India and same was paid. Subsequently it was unearthed that there
was mistake in calculation and excess pension (DR) has been paid to the
petitioner. The petitioner is entitled to get DR at the rate of Tripura State Govt.
Rules. But, by mistake he was paid pension at the rate of 6th CPC applicable to
the central Govt. pensioners.
[21]
State Bank of India, Centralized Pension Processing Centre, Delhi-
110006 has informed to the Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Parliament
Street Branch, Regal Building, New Delhi-110001 that pension of the petitioner
had been paid with DA rates of 6th CPC without any mandate and therefore
recovery of Rs. 7,64,516.00 is to be recovered in 165 installments of Rs.
4,641.00 till the amount recovered fully. Thereafter Rs. 5,50,000/- was debited
on 12.01.2023. This was done on the strength of letter of undertaking dated
03.12.2018 received from the petitioner and the remaining amount is being
recovered @ Rs. 4,641/- per month.
[22]
The relationship between the petitioner and the State Bank of India
is that of a banker and customer and as such on the principle of restitution in
case of error, mistake the bank can recover the excess amount paid to the
pensioner. Section-72 of the Indian Contract Act also mandates that:
"72. Liability of person to whom money is paid or thing delivered by
mistake or under coercion or as a result of fraud, etc.
A person to whom money has been paid, or anything delivered, by mistake
(whether of fact or law) or under coercion, or who obtains such payment or
delivery by fraud or misrepresentation or by the exercise of undue
influence, must repay or return it."
[23]
The judgments relied upon by the petitioner is not applicable in the
instant case. Those cases are has decided the question of recovery by employer
from the employees where there is no statutory embargo. But in the instant case
relationship is between a banker and a customer. There is also statutory mandate
in favour of the bank to recover excess amount paid to the customer.
[24]
Now, it is seen from the record that admittedly the petitioner is a
pensioner and he is entitled for pension and the respondent bank has released the
amounts and the petitioner is entitled for withdrawing the same. It is further seen
from the record and also from the pleadings as fairly admitted by the
respondents that there is no demand raised from the employer to the bank and
also the bank has not issued any demand to the petitioner indicating him about
the said action of recovery. Since, it is violative of principles of natural justice,
this Court finds fault with the action and the manner in which the respondent
bank has taken steps for recovery of the amount by deducting a sum of
Rs.5,50,000/- also some other installments as contended by the petitioner. The
findings as observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court and in plethora of decisions,
more particularly, in Rafiq Masih (supra) has consistently held that the excess
amount, which is not paid on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the
part of the employee, are not recoverable later on.
[25]
Accordingly, the writ petitioner is entitled for the reliefs as sought
for and accordingly, the writ petition is allowed directing the respondent bank to
remit back the amount that have been withdrawn from the account of the
petitioner along with interest @6% and cost of Rs.25,000/- payable to the
petitioner as the bank has committed grave error in saying goodbye to the legal
requirements. As such, the respondent bank shall, within a period of three
working days refund the amount of Rs.5,50,000/- which has been debited from
the account of the petitioner along with interest @6% and also pay a cost of
Rs.25,000/- to the petitioner. That apart, any amount that has been debited from
the account of the petitioner, the same shall be credited back to the account of
the petitioner within the time as stipulated above with interest, since the action
of the respondent bank is unauthorized and there is no demand from any
government department made or any other authority made any claim as legally
enforceable debt against the petitioner and the same be debited from his bank
account by the respondent bank. Learned counsel for the respondent bank has
placed his reliance on Section-72 of the Indian Contract Act which is, according
to this Court, has no relevance to the facts and circumstances of the present case.
[26]
However, in the event, if the bank feels that the petitioner is liable
to pay back on account of access drawal, it is always open for the bank to
provide the petitioner’s statement of account and all particulars in this regard
and make demand by giving show cause notice and call for his explanation and
then to take steps to recovery of amounts, if so advised.
[27]
In terms of the above, the present writ petition preferred by the
petitioner, stands allowed and disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous
application(s) pending, if any, shall stand closed.
T. Amarnath Goud, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.05
11:05:02 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review