The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
30. 12.2011 alleging, inter allia, that on 27.12.2011 he along with Tutan Sen came to Teliamura for purchasing Bitumen for road repairing works. Krishna Gopal Das (petitioner herein) who was involved in the execution of the said work had given him Rs.2,50,000/- in cash for this purpose. On the way one Ajit Das and Suman alias Bikash Debnath joined them. Having arrived at Ambassa they had taken lunch in Tripureswari Hotel. Thereafter Tutan Sen asked the informant to give him Rs.50,000/- and keep the remaining amount of Rs.2,00,000/- with him. They arrived at the railway station in the evening. Following a pre-plan two unknown miscreants caught hold of the informant and robbed him of Rs.2,00,000/- from his bag. His associates Tutan Sen, Ajit Das and Suman alias Bikash Debnath asked him not to divulge the incidence to anyone. Having suspected the involvement of Tutan Sen, Ajit Das and Suman alias Bikash Debnath in the alleged offence, the informant lodged FIR against them and two others. [4] Based on such FIR, Ambassa Police Station Case No.56 of 2011 under Sections 395 IPC and 27 Arms Act was registered and investigation of the case was taken up by police. [5] In the course of investigation of the case, the Investigating Officer seized cash Indian currency of Rs.1,02,000/from accused Manuj Goon and Rs.32,000/- in cash was seized from accused Sentu Das and a sum of Rs.3,000/- in cash …
9. However, the order of handing over of the amount of Rs.1,37,000/- to the Contractor Sri Krishna Gopal Das as in Para-8 of the Judgment passed by the Ld. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhalai is set aside. The amount be realized or taken back from Krishna Gopal Das by the Ld. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhalai and that amount is confiscated and be deposited to the Government Account forthwith.
10. In the result, the present appeal filed by the appellant is dismissed and its order in Para-8 of said Judgment is set aside.*****” [12] Challenging the said order of the learned Sessions Judge, Krishna Gopal Das who allegedly delivered the money to Sanjoy Sutradhar, the first informant for purchasing Bitumen from Teliamura market for road repairing works at Ambassa has filed this criminal revision petition. He has impleaded the State of Tripura as respondent No.1 and Manuj Goon as respondent No.2 in this case. The main grounds of his challenge are as under: (i) Even though the FIR lodged by Sanjay Sutradhar revealed that petitioner Krishna Gopal Das gave the money to the first informant for purchasing Bitumen, the learned Sessions Judge while hearing the appeal of accused Manuj Goon did not issue notice to him and passed an erroneous order confiscating his money to the State Government. (ii) The evidence revealed that the money belonged to him which was looted from the possession of his staff from their way to Teliamura. Despite proof of this fact, the learned Sessions Judge incorrectly confiscated the money to the State Government instead of releasing the same in his favour. (iii) The learned Sessions Judge decided the appeal without appreciation of evidence and the essential facts and circumstances of the case. [13] Counsel appearing for the petitioner has argued that the imp…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Rev. P. No. 49 of 2021
Sri Krishna Gopal Das,
S/O Lt. Khokan Chandra Das, R/O Jirania, Vidyanagar,
PO and PS Jirania, Dist- West Tripura
…………… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Principal Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, PO- Kunjaban, PS
East Agartala Sub Division- Sadar, District- West
Tripura, Pin- 799010.
2.
Manoj Goon,
S/O Lt. Dinesh Goon, R/o North Ramchandradraghat,
PS Khowai, Dist Khowai Tripura
…………… Respondent(s).
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Debajit Biswas, Advocate.
Mr. C. Debnath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P. P.
Ms. Rumela Guha, Advocate.
Ms. Sudipa Nath, Advocate
Mr. Mrinmoy Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. Manoj Kumar Biswas, Advocate.
Judgment & Order
:
18th February, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting :
No.
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(oral)
Petitioner
has
challenged
the
judgment
dated
18.01.2019 delivered by the Sessions Judge of Dhalai Judicial
District in Criminal Appeal No.3 of 2019.
[2]
Heard Mr. Debajit Biswas, learned advocate appearing
for the petitioner along with Mr. C. Debnath, learned advocate. Also
heard
Mr.
S.
Debnath,
learned
Additional
Public
Prosecutor
appearing for the State respondent and Ms. Rumela Guha, learned
advocate appearing for respondent No.2 along with advocates, Ms.
Sudipa Nath, Mr. Mrinmoy Debnath and Mr. Manoj Kumar Biswas.
[3]
The factual background of the case is as under:
Sri Sanjay Sutradhar of Bankimnagar, Jirania lodged a
written FIR with the Officer in-charge of Ambassa Police Station on
30.12.2011 alleging, inter allia, that on 27.12.2011 he along with
Tutan Sen
came to Teliamura for purchasing Bitumen for road
repairing works. Krishna Gopal Das (petitioner herein) who was
involved in the execution of the said work had given him
Rs.2,50,000/- in cash for this purpose. On the way one Ajit Das and
Suman alias Bikash Debnath joined them. Having arrived at
Ambassa they had taken lunch in Tripureswari Hotel. Thereafter
Tutan Sen asked the informant to give him Rs.50,000/- and keep
the remaining amount of Rs.2,00,000/- with him. They arrived at
the railway station in the evening. Following a pre-plan two
unknown miscreants caught hold of the informant and robbed him
of Rs.2,00,000/- from his bag. His associates Tutan Sen, Ajit Das
and Suman alias Bikash Debnath asked him not to divulge the
incidence to anyone. Having suspected the involvement of Tutan
Sen, Ajit Das and Suman alias Bikash Debnath in the alleged
offence, the informant lodged FIR against them and two others.
[4]
Based on such FIR, Ambassa Police Station Case No.56
of 2011 under Sections 395 IPC and 27 Arms Act was registered
and investigation of the case was taken up by police.
[5]
In
the
course
of
investigation
of
the
case,
the
Investigating Officer seized cash Indian currency of Rs.1,02,000/from accused Manuj Goon and Rs.32,000/- in cash was seized from
accused Sentu Das and a sum of Rs.3,000/- in cash was seized from
one Shibu Sarkar. Having completed the investigation of the case,
the Investigating Officer submitted the charge sheet against accused
Sentu Das alias Bikash, Manuj Goon, Shibu Sarkar and Biswajit Deb
for having committed offence punishable
under Sections 394 and
411 IPC read with Section 27 of the Arms Act.
[6]
The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Kamalpur
received the charge sheet and took cognizance of offence punishable
under Sections 394 and 411 IPC and 27 of the Arms Act on the face
of the allegations. Trial commenced against accused Sentu Das,
Manuj Goon, Shibu Sarkar and Biswajit Deb with the framing of
charges under Sections 394 and 411 IPC. No charge was framed
under Section 27 of the Arms Act.
[7]
In the course of trial, as many as 17(seventeen)
witnesses (P.W-1 to P.W-17) were examined on behalf of the
prosecution. Apart from adducing the oral evidence of the PWs
prosecution also relied on 9(nine) documents which were admitted
into evidence and marked as Exbt.1 to Exbt.9/1. On the basis of
their evidence all accused were examined under Section 313 Cr. P.C
separately. All of them claimed that they were innocent and the
charges were foisted on them. They declined to adduce any evidence
on their defence.
[8]
At the conclusion of trial against accused Sentu Das,
Shibu Sarkar and Biswajit Deb, the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial
Magistrate, Kamalpur delivered judgment on 27.07.2015 whereby
all the 3(three) accused namely, Sentu Das, Shibu Sarkar and
Biswajit Deb were found not guilty and in the result they were
acquitted of the charges. Since accused Manuj Goon (respondent
No.2 herein) was found absconding, the trial of the case against
him was kept in abeyance.
[9]
After accused Manuj Goon was brought to the Court,
the case was tried against him and the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate,
Dhalai
Judicial
District,
Ambassa
(after
the
establishment of new judicial district) by his judgment and order
dated 20.03.2019 passed in PRC(WP) 35 of 2018 found him not
guilty and acquitted him of both the charges. With regard to the
disposal of the cash seized from the accused persons, the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate directed that the seized currency of
Rs.1,37,000/- be handed over to its original owner namely, Krishna
Gopal Das (PW-12) who is the petitioner herein.
[10]
Aggrieved by the order of disposal of the said currency
in favour of Krishna Gopal Das, said accused Manuj Goon though he
was acquitted of the charges, filed an appeal against the judgment
and order dated 20.03.2019 passed by the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate challenging the order of disposal of the cash currency.
[11]
Learned Sessions Judge heard the appeal and in his
judgment and order dated 18.01.2019 in Criminal Appeal No.3 of
2019, viewed that since there was no proof of seizure of the said
amount of money from the possession of Manuj Goon he was not
entitled to get back the said amount of money. The learned
Sessions Judge did not also agree with the view of the trial Judge
for releasing the seized cash currency in favour of Krishna Gopal
Das (petitioner). Consequently, the learned Sessions Judge by the
impugned order confiscated the money to the State. Accordingly,
the learned Sessions Judge dismissed his appeal viewing as under:
“****8. From the deposition of PW-8 (Gauranga
Das) it appears that he has been dealing in grocery
business in Ambassa and Cr. Appeal No.3 of 2019
Rs.32,000/- seized from his house does not belong
to the accused Sentu Das, his son, but the money
belongs to him only. From the evidence on record,
nothing is clear about the source of money in case
of accused Manuj Goon, though Rs.87,000/- +
Rs.15,000/- = Rs.1.02,000/- was clear that it was
seized from Manuj Goon being produced by him as
stated by the Investigating Officer (PW-14) of the
case. It is on record that the accused has been
acquitted by the order probably for no proof of
seizure from the possession of the accused, but the
principle has to be applied in case of delivery of the
amount also. Hence, the appeal is dismissed.
9. However, the order of handing over of the
amount of Rs.1,37,000/- to the Contractor Sri
Krishna Gopal Das as in Para-8 of the Judgment
passed by the Ld. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Dhalai
is set aside. The amount be realized or taken back
from Krishna Gopal Das by the Ld. Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Dhalai and that amount is confiscated
and be deposited to the Government Account
forthwith.
10. In the result, the present appeal filed by the
appellant is dismissed and its order in Para-8 of
said Judgment is set aside.*****”
[12]
Challenging the said order of the learned Sessions
Judge, Krishna Gopal Das who allegedly delivered the money to
Sanjoy Sutradhar, the first informant for purchasing Bitumen from
Teliamura market for road repairing works at Ambassa has filed this
criminal revision petition. He has impleaded the State of Tripura as
respondent No.1 and Manuj Goon as respondent No.2 in this case.
The main grounds of his challenge are as under:
(i)
Even though the FIR lodged by Sanjay Sutradhar
revealed that petitioner Krishna Gopal Das gave the
money to the first informant for purchasing Bitumen,
the learned Sessions Judge while hearing the appeal of
accused Manuj Goon did not issue notice to him and
passed an erroneous order confiscating his money to
the State Government.
(ii)
The evidence revealed that the money belonged
to him which was looted from the possession of his staff
from their way to Teliamura. Despite proof of this fact,
the learned Sessions Judge incorrectly confiscated the
money to the State Government instead of releasing the
same in his favour.
(iii) The learned Sessions Judge decided the appeal
without appreciation of evidence and the essential facts
and circumstances of the case.
[13]
Counsel appearing for the petitioner has argued that
the impugned judgment of the learned Sessions Judge is liable to
be set aside since the decision is not based on evidence. Counsel
submits that Krishna Gopal Das is the true owner of the stolen
money which was proved during the trial of the case and, therefore,
the whole amount of money seized during the investigation of the
case should be returned to Krishna Gopal Das.
[14]
Ms.
Rumela
Guha,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent No.2, Manuj Goon vehemently opposes the contention
of the counsel of the petitioner. It is argued by Ms. Guha that the
Investigating
Officer
(PW-14)
who
conducted
investigation of the case categorically stated in the
the
whole
charge sheet
that Rs.1,02,000/- was recovered and seized from the possession of
Manuj Goon (respondent No.2). In one spell Rs.87,000/- was
recovered and seized from him and in the second spell Rs.15,000/was recovered from his possession. Counsel submits that the
Investigating Officer very categorically repeated this fact in his
evidence during the trial of the case. The learned Sessions Judge
also referred to such statement of the Investigating Officer with
regard to seizure of the said amount of cash currency from the
possession of respondent Manuj Goon in the impugned judgment
delivered by him. Counsel contends that since neither the charge
under Section 394 nor the charge under Section 411 IPC has been
proved against Manuj Goon, he is entitled to the recovery of the
whole amount of money which was erroneously seized from his
possession.
[15]
The matter with regard to disposal of property pending
the trial of a case and at the conclusion of trial is dealt with under
Chapter XXXIV, Cr.P.C from Sections 451 to Section 459. Section
452 Cr. P.C provides for disposal of property at the conclusion of
trial which reads as under:
“452. Order for disposal
conclusion of trial.
of
property
at
(1)
When an inquiry or trial in any Criminal
Court is concluded, the Court may make such order
as it thinks fit for the disposal, by destruction,
confiscation or delivery to any person claiming to
be entitle to possession thereof or otherwise, of
any property or document produced before it or in
its custody, or regarding which any offence appears
to have been committed, or which has been used
for the commission of any offence.
(2)
An order may be made under sub- section
(1) for the delivery of any property to any person
claiming to be entitled to the possession thereof,
without any condition or on condition that he
executes a bond, with or without sureties, to the
satisfaction of the Court, engaging to restore such
property to the Court if the order made under subsection (1) is modified or set aside on appeal or
revision.
(3)
A Court of Session may, instead of itself
making an order under sub- section (1), direct the
property to be delivered to the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, who shall thereupon deal with it in the
manner provided in sections 457, 458 and 459.
(4)
Except where the property is livestock or is
subject to speedy and natural decay, or where a
bond has been executed in pursuance of subsection
(2), an order made under sub- section (1) shall not
be carried out for two months, or when an appeal
is presented, until such appeal has been disposed
of.
(5)
In this section, the term "property" includes,
in the case of property regarding which an offence
appears to have been committed, not only such
property as has been originally in the possession or
under the control of any party, but also any
property into or for which the same may have been
converted or exchanged, and anything acquired by
such conversion or exchange, whether immediately
or otherwise.”
[16]
In the instant case, even though petitioner Krishna
Gopal Das is claiming to be the owner of the seized property
(money), there is absolutely no evidence in support of his claim.
The trial Court did not believe the prosecution case for which all the
accused were found not guilty and acquitted of the charges. On the
other hand, the Investigating Officer in the charge sheet submitted
by him as well as in his evidence has categorically stated that
during the investigation of the case he recovered and seized
Rs.87,000/- in one spell and Rs.15,000/- in another spell from the
possession of accused Manuj Goon. As stated, neither the charge of
robbing or of dishonestly receiving and retaining stolen property
could
be
established
against
said
Manuj
Goon.
In
these
circumstances, claim of Manuj Goon to the delivery of said property
in his favour has merit. The learned Session Judge committed error
by confiscating the amount of money which was actually recovered
and seized from the possession of Manuj Goon who was found not
guilty after a full trial of the case.
[17]
In view of the above, the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Dhalai, Ambassa is directed to return the seized
currency of Rs.1,02,000/- in favour of accused Manuj Goon on
verification of his identity and on his furnishing an indemnity bond
indemnifying all future claims, if any. Remaining amount of the
seized currency stands confiscated to the State Government.
[18]
In terms of the above, criminal revision petition stands
disposed of. Send down the L. C. record.
JUDGE
Dipankar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review