Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
Crl. A(J) No. 02 of 2022
1.
Sri Kanulal Debnath, son of late Paresh Chandra Debnath,
resident of village Ghilatali, Deb Para, P.O. Kalyanpur, P.S.
Khowai, District: Khowai Tripura, at present in Khowai Sub-Jail,
Khowai Tripura.
…..Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
The State of Tripura.
….. Respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. B. Banerjee, Advocate.
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
17.05.2023
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant and Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor, appearing
for the respondent-State.
[2]
The instant appeal is directed against the judgment and order
of conviction and sentence dated 30.08.2019 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Khowai Tripura, in connection with case No. S.T. (T-1) 31
of 2018, whereby and whereunder, the appellant has been convicted under
Section-304 (Part-I) of IPC and thereby, sentenced to suffer Rigorous
Imprisonment for 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs. 5000/- with default
stipulations.
[3]
The factual background of the prosecution case is that on the
basis of a written complaint lodged by the complainant namely, Sri Gopal
Debnath (brother of the deceased) stating inter-alia that on 26.06.2018 at
about 0700 hours the accused Kanulal Debnath assaulted his wife namely,
Dipali Debnath at Ghilatali, in his kitchen room with an iron rod (sabol), as
a result, Dipali Debnath sustained grievous injuries on her person and,
thereafter, immediately shifted to GBP Hospital by her son and brother and
during treatment at GBP Hospital, Agartala said Depali Debnath
succumbed to her injuries.
[4]
On the basis of the said complaint, Kalyanpur P.S. Case
No.2018/KLN/036, dated 26.06.2018 under Sections-326/302 of IPC was
registered and S.I. Sri Lalzuithara Darlong took up the investigation of this
case and after completionof investigation he laid charge-sheet vide No.39
of 2018, dated 30.10.2018 under Sections-326/302 of IPC against the
accused, the appellant herein.
[5]
The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, khowai after
taking cognizance of offence under Sections-326/302 of IPC complied the
provision of Section-209 of Cr. P.C. committed the case to the Court of
Sessions as the case is exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions,
Khowai, Tripura after furnishing copies to the accused as required under
Section-207 of Cr. P.C.
[6]
On receipt of the case record by this Court on 21.12.2018, this
Court framed charge under Section-302 read with ection-34 of IPC against
the accused appellant explaining the contents of charge to him translating
the same in Bengali to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
[7]
To substantiate the charge, prosecution has adduced as many
as 17 witnesses including the complainant of this case mentioned in the
appendix attached herewith. The prosecution also relied upon some
documentary evidence as well as material object which were also marked
as exhibits in connection with the present case as reflected in the attached
appendix. The defence case was that of total denial of the allegation of the
prosecution and as such the convict-appellant during his examination under
Section-313 of Cr. P.C, pleaded his innocence and denied to adduce any
witness in support of his defence.
[8]
After hearing both the parties, the learned Court below found
that the appellant is guilty for committing offence punishable under
Sections-304 (Part-I) of IPC and thereby sentenced his as stated supra. For
the purpose of reference, the observation of the Court below may be
reproduced hereinbelow:
“In discussing the evidence of prosecution witnesses I already stated it that
PW-2 who is the star witness of this case specifically deposed in his
evidence that in the early morning there was a quarrel in between the
deceased and the accused who are his parents. He did not explain any
specific reason of that quarrel. It is not the case of prosecution that earlier to
the said incident the conduct of the accused towards the deceased was not
good. Not a single witness deposed about the motive of the crime. Since the
intention to kill the deceased is not proved by prosecution but infliction of
fatal injury on the head of deceased which caused her death has been proved,
I am of the view that accused deserve some consideration in the matter of
conviction. Os having my die consideration of all these facts and
circumstances, I find and hold that this a fit case where for the commission
of offence by the accused he can be convicted under Section-304 (Part-I) of
IPC.
Finally I hereby convict Sri Kanulal Debnath under Section-304 (Part-I) of
IPC for his commission of murder of the deceased namely, Dipali Debnath.
Considering the submission of both sides I hereby convict Sri Kanulal
Debnath under Section-304(Part-I) of IPC and sentence him to suffer RI for
10 (ten) years and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (rupees five thousand) i.e. to
suffer SI for 2(two) months.”
[9]
The appellant herein, being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with
the impugned judgment and order of conviction dated 30.08.2019, has
preferred this present appeal for ends of justice.
[10]
Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that PW-1 stated that on 26.06.2018 I.O. seized one Shaval
(crowbar), one gamcha and some blood sample collected from the kitchen
of the deceased in his presence under a seizer list and he put his signature
in it. PW-1 also identifies the seized shaval and gamcha before the Court. It
has been further stated that he heard that the accused assaulted his wife
with a shabal and thereby wife of the accused succumbed to her injuries in
GBP Hospital Agartala. But, the cross examination he stated that he did not
put signature on the seized shaval and gamcha but the learned Court below
most whimsically believed that statement and convicted the appellant
herein.
[11]
PW-2, Sri Surajit Debnath deposed that on 26.06.2018 at
about 06.00 am he was in his house and at that time his mother Dipali
Debnath was making roti in their kitchen and accused was engaged in
quarrel with his mother on some domestic affairs. He further deposed that
at that material time he just came out of the wash room and saw that the
accused and the deceased quarrelling each other.
[12]
It has been further submitted that while PW-2 was on the main
road he heard sounds from their kitchen immediately he noticed his father
was going out of the house. He deposed that at the material time of their
quarrel, except his father and the deceased none were in their kitchen. He
rushed back to his house and say his mother was lying there on the ground
in the kitchen with some bleeding injuries over her forehead and on her
fact. Subsequently, she was shifted to GBP hospital and during the
treatment his mother was succumbed to her injuries. After death of his
mother, police prepared a report over the dead body of his mother and on
26.06.2018 police seized some blood stain gauze cloth wherein the blood
sample of his deceased mother was collected by the medical officer at the
time of her post-mortem and those were kept in a sealed envelope.
[13]
But, in his cross examination he has stated that there are few
house besides their house and main road is in the West of their house. He
voluntarily stated that his elder brother was in the house of his maternal
aunt on that day but, he has not disclosed the name of his elder brother and
the name of his material aunt.
[14]
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has drawn our
attention to the deposition of PW-5 wherein, it has been stated that on
26.06.2018 her brother reported her over telephone that her mother was
severely assaulted by her father with a crowbar in her parent’s kitchen. She
further stated that her mother was shifted to GBP hospital by her brother
and maternal uncle and on the way of GBP hospital. But, in her cross
examination she has uttered name of another brother and she never made
any statement regarding the role of her another brother.
[15]
PW-6 Sri Dulal Debnath in his examination-in-chief has stated
that on 26.06.2018 he was in the house and taking some food in the
morning and at that relevant time suddenly he heard shouting of his sister
i.e. the deceased herein and her son Surajit Debnath from their house
immediately he rushed to their house and while he was entering into their
house, he found his brother in law Kanulal Debnath, the accused-appellant
running out of his house and went towards the West. Thereafter, while he
entered into their dwelling hut, he found his sister lying on the ground in
the kitchen with severe injury over her face and head and a crowbar was
found beside her with some blood stain.
[16]
Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel has contended that the learned
Court below believed the testimony of PW-2 and 6 and considered them
most important witnesses of his case but, the learned Court below utterly
failed in appreciating the facts and circumstances of the case as there exists
serious discrepancies and contradiction between the statement of the PWs.
The learned Court below without considering the fact that the prosecution
has totally failed to prove the case against the convict-appellant beyond
reasonable doubt, convicted the appellant without any legal evidence and
was swayed by whim.
[17]
Per-contra, Mr. S. Debnath, learned P.P. has opposed the
submission of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant and
submitted that the prosecution case is well proved by the evidence of
PWs.2, 3, 6, 9, 11, 12 and 15. The death is well proved, weapon used in the
death also proved by prosecution beyond all reasonable doubt.
[18]
In view of the submissions canvassed by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties as reflected above, let us make a short survey of
the evidence and material placed on records to justify the conviction and
sentence declared against the accused-appellant under Section -304 (Part-I)
of IPC. After perusal of the material evidence on record and the
circumstances as sketched herein, the main object which needs to be
discussed is that whether there was any predetermined intention of the
accused to kill his wife. There is presumption that a man knows the natural
and likely consequence of his acts.
[19]
In the present case, there is no evidence to show that the
appellant has intention to kill the deceased. In fact, it was a family dispute
i.e. fighting between the husband and wife which is very much common in
nature. Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person
whose death was intended...if a person, by doing anything which he intends
or knows to be likely to cause death, commits culpable homicide by causing
the death of any person, whose death he neither intends nor knows himself
to be likely to cause, the culpable homicide committed by the offender is of
the description of which it would have been if he had caused the death of
the person whose death he intended or knew himself to be likely to cause.
[20]
The expression intention and knowledge postulate the
existence of positive mental attitude. It was further held that when and if
there is intent and knowledge, then the same would be a case under first
part of section 304 and if it is only case of knowledge and not intention to
cause death by bodily injury, then the same would be a case of second part
of section 304. In the present case the accused suddenly blow his wife
without any intention or knowledge that it could be the case of her death.
As such, according to us, the learned Court below could have been decide
the matter under Section 304(Part-II) of IPC instead of part-I.
[21]
If the act is done with knowledge that it is likely to cause
death but without any intention to cause death or such bodily injury as is
likely to cause death, the punishment is imprisonment of either description
for a term which may be extend to 10 years, or with fine, or with both
under the second part of section 304. Knowledge is a strong word and
imports a certainty and not merely a probability. The element of knowledge
is mandatory in the case for applicability of the second part of section 304.
[22]
The nature and the number of injuries as well as their location
and the weapon used lead to conclude that to a reasonable person, an attack
of the nature launched by the appellant on victim could cause his death.
While it may be difficult to delve into the mind of attacker to decode his
intention knowledge for the consequences of his actions can certainly be
attributed to him. The appellant had knowledge that his actions are likely to
cause the death. In this case, he was held guilty of culpable homicide not
amounting to murder and held liable to be sentenced under the first part of
the section 304.
[23]
In the case there was a quarrel between the accused and the
deceased. Suddenly the accused hit the deceased with a crowbar on the
head when they were quarreling each other. Only a single blow on the head
may not be sufficient to cause death. It could not be said that the accused
inflicted the blow intending to cause death. It was not discernible that the
injury was inflicted with an intention to cause death of victim or to cause
such bodily injury that it was likely to cause the death of the victim.
However, it is not clear that the act has been done by the accused with
knowledge that it would cause death.
[24]
There was free fight between the husband and the wife which
had caused death to a person. The reason of quarrel was not known to
anyone the family member of the deceased. Circumstances disclosed that
the object was to fight only and not to cause death or grievous injury to the
person. The accused assaulted and caused the death of the victim with
crowbar and relying on the prosecution witness the learned Court below
convicted him under section 304 Part-I.
[25]
Before awarding conviction against accused, the Courts should
be mindful of fact that there should be no room to suspect evidence of key
prosecution witnesses based on whose evidence conviction is being
awarded. As a general rule, while appreciating evidence in a criminal case,
Court should bear in mind, that it is not quantity, but quality of evidence
that is material. It is the duty of Court to consider the trustworthiness of
witness and evidence adduced on record and to assess the same in a prudent
manner, whether the same inspires confidence, so as to accept and act
upon, before convicting accused.
[26]
In our considered opinion, the prosecution has miserably
failed to prove that the cause of death of the wife of the appellant was the
outcome of any pre-mediation, which has led this Court to come to the
conclusion that the way the murder is caused, does not come within the
purview of the definition of Section-304 (Part-I) of IPC rather it comes
within the ambit of the definition of Section-304 Part-II of IPC.
[27]
Accordingly, we are inclined to reduce the conviction and
sentence to suffer RI for 10 years as returned by the Sessions Judge,
Khowai Tripura, and consequently, we hold that substantial justice would
be rendered if the appellant is sentenced to suffer RI for 7 years instead of
RI for 10 years. In the result, the instant appeal is partly allowed. The
appellant shall suffer RI for (seven) years which shall include the period he
already has undergone.
[28]
With the modification in the above term in regard to the
sentence of the appellant, the instant appeal stands partly allowed and thus,
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed. Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review