Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.64 of 2024
Sri Kabir Uddin of „F‟-COY, No.20005122 RFN(GD),
13 Battalion, Tripura State Rifles (IR-IX), S/O. Mobaswar Ali,
Presently residing at-Vill. & P.O.:Kalachara,
P.S.- Kadamtala, District-North Tripura.
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Home, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Director General of Police, Tripura, Agartala, Revisional
Authority.
3. The Deputy Inspector General of Police, AP(OPS-I), Tripura,
Agartala, Appellate Authority.
4. The Commandant, 13th Bn. TSR(IR-IX),
Kanchanpur, North Tripura, Disciplinary Authority.
Subhas
Nagar,
5. The AC, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX), Enquiry Authority.
6. The Inspector General of Police, AP (OPS), Tripura, Agartala,
Revisional Authority.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Rajasree Purkayastha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. GA
Date of hearing
:
07.05.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
16.05.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The petitioner has filed the present writ petition seeking
the following reliefs:
“I) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the respondents and
each one of them to show cause as to why a Writ of
Certiorari and/or in the nature there-of, shall not be
issued, for quashing/setting aside the impugned
revisional order vide No. 9647-52(4)/F.Pers/KU/
Appeal/IGP(TSR)/22 dated 11.09.2023 (Annexure-12)
passed by the Director General of Police, Tripura,
Agartala, Respondent No.2 whereby the Respondent
No. 2 has most illegally rejected the revision thereby
upholding the impugned appellate order vide No.226064/F.Pers/ KU/ Appeal/ DIGP(AP&OPS) /21 dated
30.03.2022 (Annexure-8) passed by the Respondent
No.3 upholding the impugned order, of Compulsory
retirement of the petitioner, dated 02.10.2021 passed
by the Disciplinary authority i.e. the Respondent No.4
and further be pleased enough to quash the impugned
Enquiry Report dated 31.07.2021 submitted by the
Respondent No.5.
II) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the respondents and each
one of them, to show cause as to why Writ of
Mandamus, and/or in the nature, shall not be issued,
for mandating/directing the respondents, Respondent
No.2 in particular to recall the impugned order dated
11.09.2023 (Annexure-12) issued by the Respondent
No.2 and discharge/ acquit the petitioner from all
charges and re-instate him in his service, fair ends of
justice.
III) CALL FOR THE RECORDS appertaining to this
petition;
IV) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the
RULE ABSOLUTE in terms of i and ii above;
V) COSTS of and incidental to this proceeding;
VI) Any other RELIEF(S) as to this Hon'ble High Court
may deem fit and proper;”
2.
Heard
Learned
Counsel,
Ms.
Rajasree
Purkayastha
appearing on behalf of the petitioner. Also heard Learned Addl. GA,
Mr. Karnajit De appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
3.
Before coming to the conclusion, let us discuss about the
facts of the present petition filed by the petitioner.
3.1.
The petitioner was a TSR personnel bearing enrolment
No.20005122 Rfn(GD) of 'F'-Coy, 13th Bn. TSR (IR-IX) and posted at
Subhas Nagar, Kanchanpur, North Tripura under the kind control and
command of the respondents. He was appointed on 28.03.2000 and
since his appointment he was discharging his duties sincerely,
honestly, diligently with utmost satisfaction of the authorities without
any blemish and stigma at any point of time. The petitioner is a
married man having his wife namely Hazira Begam (39 years) and 3
(three) daughters namely Yesmin Sultana (19 years), Sahanaj Aktar
(17 years) and Nasrim Aktar (12 years). The petitioner is the only
bread earner in his family and his service was the only means of their
livelihood.
3.2.
One Smt. Khelan Bibi, D/o Khalek Miah of Vill Thakcherra,
P.O. Mahamilan, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura lodged a complaint on
27.05.2019 to respondent No.4 alleging inter alia that the petitioner
had entered into marriage with her and the petitioner was not taking
any care of said Khelan Bibi after their marriage. On the basis of the
said
complaint,
the
respondent
No.4
initiated
a
departmental
proceeding against the petitioner vide Memorandum No. 8492/F.DPNo./2019/K.U/TSR-13/ESTT/2019 dated 18.10.2019 as per Rule-14 of
the Central Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules,
1905 (for short, „CCS(CC&A) Rules‟) read with Rule-40 of Tripura
State Rifles (Discipline, Control, Service Conditions, etc.) Rules, 1986
for the alleged offense punishable under Section 12(1) of Tripura
State Rifles Act, 1983 (for short, „TSR Act, 1983‟) comprising the
following article of charges (Annexure-1 to the writ petition):
“Article of Charge-I
That the said No.20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin of
'F'-Coy, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) got married one Smt.
Khelan Bibi D/O Khalek Miah of Vill: Thakcherra, PO.
Mahamillan, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura without any
consent and intimation to his first wife Smt. Hazira
Begam on 28.01.2016 at Thakcherra. This kind of
act is prejudicial to good order and discipline of the
Rifles and punishable U/S 12 (1) of TSR Act, 1983.
Article of Charge-II
That the said No. 20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin of
'F'-Coy, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) got married one Smt.
Khelan Bibi D/O Khalek Miah of Vill: Thakcherra, PO:
Mahamillan, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura without any
prior permission from the authority while his first
wife is still living. This kind of Act is prejudicial to
good order and discipline of the Rifles and
punishable U/S 12(1) of TSR Act, 1983.”
Further, a statement of imputation of misconduct or
misbehavior on which the article of charges were framed together
with a list of documents and witnesses by which the article of charges
proposed to be sustained were issued against the present petitioner.
Prior to that, according to the petitioner, a preliminary
enquiry was conducted by the authority behind the back of the
petitioner without affording an opportunity to him(Annexure-2 to the
writ petition).
3.3.
After receipt
of
the
alleged
article of
charges,
the
petitioner submitted his written statement of defence (Annexure-3 to
the writ petition).
3.4.
Shri Robert L. Darlong, Asstt. Commandant, 13th Bn TSR
(IR-IX) was appointed as 'Inquiring Authority' to inquire into the
charges framed against the petitioner vide office order No.8742/F.DPNo.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/ESTT/2019
dated
02.11.2019
and
No.
20004003 Sub (GD) Dipak Ranjan Das was also appointed as
'Presenting Officer' vide order No.8743/F.DP-No.11/2019/K.U/TSR13/ESTT/2019 dated 02.11.2019. The Inquiry Officer Shri Robert L.
Darlong, Asstt. Commandant conducted the inquiry and submitted an
inquiry report to respondent No.4.
3.5.
According to the petitioner, in course of the inquiry, no
official formalities were observed and no opportunity was given to the
petitioner to defend his case properly and finally on the basis of the
inquiry report, the respondent No.4 came to the finding that the
alleged charges under Article of Charges I and II were proved against
the petitioner. Copy of inquiry report dated 31.07.2021 is annexed as
Annexure-4 to the writ petition.
On the basis of the inquiry report, the respondent No.4
passed provisional order of punishment on 23.08.2021 in DP
No.11/2019
against
punishment
of
disqualification
the
petitioner
"removal
from
for
future
proposing
service
which
employment
provisional
major
shall
be
not
under
a
the
Government”(Annexure-5 to the writ petition).
3.6.
The petitioner had given an opportunity to make a written
representation against the report of provisional order of punishment
which according to petitioner was a mechanical one without any
reasoning and the same has no legs to stand in the eye of law.
However, after receiving the provisional order of punishment the
petitioner again submitted his written Representation (Annexure-6 to
the writ petition) but thereafter, the respondent No.4 passed final
order on 02.10.2021 in connection with DP No.11/2019 and by the
final order the major punishment of “removal from service” of the
petitioner had been reduced to “compulsory retirement from service
upon the charged official”(Annexure-7 to the writ petition).
3.7.
The final order was passed on 02.10.2021 and the copy
was supplied to the petitioner on 03.10.2021. Thereafter, the
petitioner preferred appeal on 03.11.2021. The appellate authority by
the impugned order dated 28.11.2021 rejected the appeal on the
ground that the petitioner failed to prefer the appeal within 30 days
from the date of receipt of the copy of final punishment order. Being
aggrieved with the said order, the petitioner preferred a writ petition
before this Court which was numbered as WP(C) No.14 of 2022. This
Court vide order dated 18.01.2022 directed the appellate authority to
reconsider
the
appeal
and
accordingly,
the
respondent
No.3
reconsidered the appeal preferred by the petitioner and by order
dated 30.03.2022 dismissed the same upholding the findings of
respondent No.4 (Annexure-8 to the writ petition). Thereafter, being
aggrieved, the petitioner again preferred revision petition before
respondent No.6 but by order dated 21.05.2022, the revision petition
was also dismissed/rejected by respondent No.2 (Annexures-9 and 10
to the writ petition).
According to the petitioner, the revisional order dated
21.05.2022 was passed by one Sri Soumitra Dhar, Inspector General
of Police who has previously dismissed the appeal preferred by the
petitioner by the impugned order dated 28.11.2021 as Deputy
Inspector General of Police thereby rejecting the appeal on the ground
that the petitioner had failed to prefer appeal within 30 days.
3.8.
Again, the petitioner being aggrieved approached this
Court by filing another writ petition bearing WP(C) No.695 of 2022
and this Court vide judgment and order dated 28.06.2023 quashed
and
set
aside
the
impugned
revision
order
dated
21.05.2022(Annexure-11 to the writ petition). In pursuance of the
judgment and order passed by this Court, again the respondent No.2
passed
impugned
revisional
order
dated
11.09.2023
whereby
according to the petitioner, the respondent No.2 most illegally uphold
the impugned appellate order dated 30.03.2022 (Annexure-12 to the
writ petition). According to the petitioner, the entire proceeding was
bad in law since all the orders were passed without affording any
proper legal opportunity to the petitioner. So, the petitioner by filing
this writ petition urged for setting aside all the orders passed by the
authorities and accordingly sought reliefs as stated above.
4.
On the other hand, the State-respondents contested the
case by filing counter affidavit denying the assertions made by the
petitioner in the writ petition. In para Nos.5 to 13, the Staterespondents have made the following assertions:
“5. That, with regard to statements made in
paragraph of the 2.2 writ petition, I say that, it is
fact that a complaint petition dated 27.05.2019 was
received from Smt. Khelan Bibi D/O-Khalek Miah of
village: Thakcherra, PS: Birganj, Dist:-Gomati,
Tripura on 03.06.2019 wherein it is stated that
while Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin was posted in 5th Bn TSR,
he entered into marriage with the complainant Smt.
Khelan Bibi on 28.01.2016 and they have lived
together as husband and wife. It is also stated that
she is claiming family maintenance from her
husband i.e, the Petitioner.
Thereafter, this office scrutinized the service book
of the petitioner Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin where it was
found that the name of Mrs. Hazira Begam was
recorded in his service book as the wife of the
Petitioner. Hence, this office had conducted a
preliminary enquiry into the matter by appointing
Preliminary Enquiry Officer to Sub(GD) Kanan Sinha
of
13th
Bn
TSR(IR-IX)
vide
order
No.4684/F.01(81)/TSR-13/Estt/Vol-II/2016 dated
11.06.2019.
Accordingly, Sub(GD) Kanan Sinha had conducted
preliminary enquiry against the petitioner and had
recorded statements and adduced documents like
marriage certificate, Aadhar Card and photo copy of
'Kabin Nama Patra' and submitted the enquiry
report to this office on 01.10.2019 along with
relevant documents wherein prima-facie charge was
established that the petitioner had married with
Smt. Khelan Bibi without any information and
without consent of his first wife Smt. Hazira Begam
(as per service book) and also without intimation to
his authority which is gross misconduct on the part
of the petitioner which is punishable as per section12(1) of TSR Act, 1983 and also violation of the
provisions of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
Copy of the complaint petition dated 03.06.2019 is
annexed herewith and marked as Annexure R/1.
Copy
of
vide
order
No.4684/F.01(81)/TSR13/Estt/Vol-II/2016 dated 11.06.2019 is annexed
hereto and marked as Annexure R/2.
Copy of the enquiry report is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure R/3.
6. That, with regard to statements made in
paragraph 2.3 of the writ petition, I say that, it is
fact that on the basis of the complaint received from
Smt. Khelan Bibi against the petitioner, Sub(GD)
Kanan Sinha of 13th Bn TSR was deputed to conduct
a preliminary enquiry against the Petitioner.
Accordingly, Sub(GD) Kanan Sinha had conducted
preliminary enquiry against Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin
and recorded statements and adduced documents
like marriage certificate, Aadhar Card and photo
copy of 'Kabin Nama Patra' and submitted the
enquiry report to this office on 01.10.2019. along
with relevant documentary evidences wherein
prima-facie charge was established that Rfn(GD)
Kabir Uddin had married with Smt. Khelan Bibi
without any information and consent of his first wife
Smt. Hazira Begam (as per service book) which is
gross misconduct on the part of No.20005122
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin as per TSR Act, 1983.
During the course of preliminary enquiry, on
28.06.2019, Sub(GD) Kanan Sinha has enquired the
genuineness of marriage certificate vide No.MRC/
2016/02717 dated 30.08.2016 in respect of Rfn(GD)
Kabir Uddin from the SDM, Amarpur, Gomati Tripura.
The SDM, Amarpur, Gomati, Tripura vide letter
No.F.9
(12)/SDM/AMP/MRG/
SFC/
2019/Vol
No.2/1328 dated 08.08.2019 has intimated that the
marriage certificate of Md. Kabir Uddin S/OMobeswar Ali of Kalachara and Mrs. Khelan Bibi
D/O- Mr. Khalek Miha, M/O-Fatema Begam, VillageThakchara, Amarpur, Gomati District was issued
from
SDM
Office,
Amarpur
vide
letter
No.MRC/2016/02717 dated 30.08.2016.
On the basis of preliminary enquiry report submitted
by Sub(GD) Kanan Sinha, a Articles of Charges
Memorandum vide No.8492/F.DP No.11/2019/
K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019 dated 18.10.2019 along with
necessary annexure-I,II,III & IV were issued to the
petitioner and the same was acknowledged by the
charged official on 21.10.2019 with proper
signature.
In the said Memo, the petitioner was directed to
submit a written statement of his defence and also
to state whether he would desire to be heard in
person within 10 days of the receipt of the Memo
dated-18.10.2019. On receipt of the said Memo, the
charged official i.e, the Petitioner had submitted his
written statement of defence on 29.10.2019 stating
that Smt. Khelan Bibi along with her family
members has conspired against him and he had not
married Smt. Khelan Bibi. He had denied the article
of charge-I & II leveled against him. The written
statement of defence dated 29.10.2019 was not
considered by the Disciplinary Authority.
Thereafter, Shri Robert L. Darlong, AC, 13th Bn TSR
was appointed as 'Inquiring Authority' to inquire
into the charged framed against the Petitioner vide
order
No.8742/F.DP
No.11/2019/K.U/TSR13/Estt/2019 dated 02.11.2019 and No.20004003
Sub (GD) Dipak Ranjan Das, 13th Bn TSR was
appointed as 'Presenting Officer' vide order
No.8743/F.Dp No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dt.02.11.2019.
During the course of enquiry, the inquiry officer Shri
Robert L. Darlong, Asstt. Commandant had
conducted the DP enquiry, observing all formalities
and giving reasonable opportunities to the charged
official No20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin from time
to time to defend the charges framed against him
and completed the enquiry. The petitioner had
participated in the instant enquiry right from 1st day
of hearing to till the last day of hearing. During the
course of enquiry of the instant DP, the charged
official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin was asked to nominate
Defence Assistant but declined to nominate Defence
Assistant despite several opportunities given to him.
Principle of natural justice has been duly observed
in each stages of this enquiry. Finally, the inquiry
officer Shri Robert L. Darlong, AC, 13th Bn TSR has
submitted his findings on 31.07.2021 after
completion of the enquiry stating that the article of
charges-I & II framed against him have been
'proved'.
Copy
of
vide
letter
No.F.9
(12)/SDM/AMP/MRG/SFC/2019/Vol
No.2/1328
dated 08.08.2019 alongwith certificate for marriage
issued by SDM, Amarpur are annexed herewith and
marked as Annexure R/4.
Copy of the Memorandum vide No.8492/F.DP
No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dated
18.10.2019 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/5.
Copy
of
the
vide
order
No.8742/F.DP
No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dated
02.11.2019 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/6.
Copy of the vide order No.8743/F.Dp No.11/2019/
K.U/TSR-13/ Estt/2019 dt.02.11.2019 is annexed
hereto and marked as Annexure R/7.
Copy of the enquiry report is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure R/8.
7. That, with regard to para 2.4 of the Writ Petition,
I say that, it is fact that on receipt of the Memo vide
No.8492/F.DP No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/ 2019
dated 18.10.2019, the charged official No.20005122
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin has submitted his written
statement of defence on 29.10.2019 stating that
Smt. Khelan Bibi alongwith her family members has
conspired against him and he had not married Smt.
Khelan Bibi. He had denied the article of charge-I &
II leveled against him. The charges had been
framed against the Charged Official Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin based on Preliminary enquiry Report on which
is Prima-facie charge of the fact of 2nd marriage
with the complainant Mrs. Khelan Bibi was
established. Therefore, the charges were not
concocted and baseless. The written statement of
defence dated 29.10.2019 was not considered to the
Disciplinary Authority.
8. That, with regard to para 2.5, I say that, it is fact
that, Shri Robert L. Darlong, AC, 13th Bn TSR was
appointed as 'Inquiring Authority' to inquire into the
charged framed against the charged official vide
order
No.8742/F.DP
No.11/2019/K.U/TSR13/Estt/2019 dated 02.11.2019 and No.20004003
Sub (GD) Dipak Ranjan Das, 13th Bn TSR was
appointed as 'Presenting Officer' vide order
No.8743/F.DP No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dt.02.11.2019.
9. That, with regard to para 2.6, I say that, the fact
is that,
(i) During the course of enquiry of the DP all legal
formalities was duly been observed by the inquiry
officer Shri Robert L. Darlong, AC, 13th Bn TSR.
(ii) Charged Official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin was given
ample opportunity to particiapate actively in the DP.
He had signed in all the Daily order sheet of the DP
enquiry which means that he had participated in the
enquiry.
(iii) He was asked to nominate Defence Assistant to
assist him in the DP enquiry but he declined. A copy
of letter dated-02.01.2020, written statement
declining to appoint defence assistant of the
petitioner and order sheet dated-12.01.2020 are
annexed hereto and marked as Annexure R/9.
(iv) All documents which the charged official had
sought been provided with acknowledgment receipt.
(v) Ample scope was given for cross examination of
witnesses in all the stages but only one witness was
cross examined by the charged official. He declined
to cross examine in all other witnesses.
(vi) It is not fact the enquiry was one sided and exparte. It is evident from the enquiry report and
evidences/documents attached with the enquiry
report that enquiry was fair and principle of natural
justice was extended to the charged official during
the DP proceeding.
(vii) It is not fact that charged official was not
allowed to participate actively in the enquiry. It is
evident from the enquiry report and documents
bearing signatures of the charged official that ample
reasonable opportunity of being heard was given to
the petitioner.
After completion of the enquiry, the inquiry officer
Shri Robert L. Darlong, AC, 13th Bn TSR had
submitted his findings of the enquiry stating that
the article of charges-I & II framed against him
have been 'proved'. There is no lapse in the process
of the instant DP. Principle of natural justice has
been observed in each stages of this DP proceeding.
Therefore, the findings of Inquiry Officer is proper
and legally tenable as per documentary evidences
on records.
As per documentary evidences on records, the
charged official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin conducted a
second marriage with Mrs. Khelan Bibi on
28.01.2016 contacted without consent of his 1st
wife while the 1st wife was still alive and 2nd
marriage was solemnized without any permission of
his competent authority which is violation of Rule21(1)(2) of TCS(Conduct) Rules, 1988 read with
section-11(n) of TSR Act, 1983 and punishable
under section-12(1) of TSR Act, 1983.
10. That, with regard to para 2.7 of the writ petition,
I say that, it is fact that, after careful examination of
the findings of the enquiry officer and evidences on
records, the Disciplinary Authority concurred with
the findings of the Inquiry Officer and accordingly,
proposes imposition of major punishment of
"Removal from Service" vide order No.9166/F.DP
No.11/2019/K.U/ TSR-13/ Estt/ 2019 dated
23.08.2021 (upon the petitioner No.20005122 ExRfn(GD) Kabir Uddin. The petitioner was given
opportunities for making representation, if any,
against the provisional punishment order or to
appear in person before the Disciplinary Authority
within 15(fifteen) days from the date of receipt of
the provisional punishment order.
It is not fact that the Inquiry Authority did not
appreciate the oral & documentary evidence
adduced by the petitioner. The fact is that the
charged official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin had submitted
a mutual compromise letter signed by Mrs. Khelan
Bibi(complainant) to the Commandant, 13th Bn TSR
and received on 02.07.2021 in which it is stated that
the complaint submitted by the complainant Mrs.
Khelan Bibi against Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin(charged
official) has been mutually compromised. But mere
compromise between offender and victim does not
negate occurrence of the misconduct committed by
the Petitioner which was already committed in
2016. Therefore, the contention of the petitioner to
set aside / quash the provisional punishment due to
compromise between both parties order dated
23.08.2021 is found not justified.
Copy of the vide order No.9166/F.DP No.11/ 2019/
K.U/ TSR-13 /Estt /2019 dated 23.08.2021 is
annexed hereto and marked as Annexure R/10.
Copy of the mutual compromise letter signed by
Mrs. Khelan Bibi is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/11.
11. That, with regard to para 2.8 of the writ petition,
I say that, it is fact that after receiving provisional
punishment order dated 23.08.2021, the petitioner
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin had submitted a representation
dated 09.09.2021 to the Disciplinary Authority i.e.
Commandant, 13th Bn TSR that he prayed to
consider his submission and requested to recall the
provisional order of punishment dated 23.08.2021
and further prayed for fully exemption from the
charges levelled against him. During the course of
enquiry, the charged official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin
has been asked to nominate Defence Assistant but
he declined despite of opportunities given to him.
The charged official was given the opportunities to
inspect the documents in the DP file. The charged
official had not given any requisition for additional
documents or defence witnesses in spite of being
given the opportunity to do so. During the course of
final hearing of the DP enquiry, the charged official
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin had stated that he was given
all reasonable opportunities in the course of the
proceedings and also stated that he had no claims or
objections. The Inquiry Officer conducted hearing of
all witnesses & recorded their statements in
presence of P.O (Presenting Officer) & C.O (Charged
Official) on different dates, and cross examination
of witnesses were done by the charged official
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin. Copies of Statement of
witnesses recorded in the hearing were supplied to
the charged official Rfn (GD) Kabir Uddin duly which
were signed by him. No any lapse was found in the
process of the DP enquiry. Principle of natural
justice has been duly observed in each stages of this
enquiry.
The charged official Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin has
submitted a mutual compromise letter signed by
Mrs. Khelan Bibi (complainant) to the Commandant,
13th Bn TSR and received on 02.07.2021 in which it
is written that the complaint submitted by
complainant Mrs. Khelan Bibi against Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin (charged Official) has been mutually
compromised. However, misconduct by the charged
official had already occurred in 2016 for which the
DP was a initiated and enquired into. Without
occurrence of any incident of misconduct, there is
no question of mutual compromise by both parties.
And it is well settled law that mere compromise
between the two parties does not negate the
occurrence
of
misconduct
he
had
already
committed. The act of accused Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin amounts to gross misconduct and violation of
CCS(CCA) Rules-1965 and also Rule-21(1)(2) of
TCS(Conduct) Rules-1988.
Further, on 11.09.2021, the petitioner Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin has also submitted an Affidavit duly signed by
Khelan Bibi vide serial No.653/9/2021 dated
10.09.2021 which was duly Notarized wherein Mrs.
Khelan Bibi had stated that the complaint was
lodged due to misunderstanding and wished not to
proceed further. By which it is clearly understood
that misconduct was committed.
The DP was initiated for violation of provision of
Rule of CCS(CCA) Rules-1965 for misconduct
committed by the petitioner Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin. It is immaterial whether the complainant
Mrs. Khelan Bibi is interested or not interested to
proceed further. It is a Departmental Enquiry and
once it is proved that misconduct was committed,
punishment must be imposed upon the delinquent.
On 12.09.2021, Smt. Hazira Begam wife of Rfn(GD)
Kabir Uddin has submitted an application praying to
retain her husband Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin in TSR
service. Finally, after careful examination of the
case and considering all the aspects, in exercise of
the power conferred under section-12(1)(h) of TSR
Act, 1983, keeping in view of his children's future
and family economic condition, the Disciplinary
Authority i.e. Commandant, 13th Bn TSR had reduced
the proposed major punishment of 'Removal from
service" which shall not be a disqualification for
future employment under the Government to
'Compulsory Retirement" from service upon Charged
Official No.20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin of 'F'Coy,
13th Bn TSR vide order No.11203/F.DP No.11/2019/
K.U/ TSR-13/ Estt/ 2019 dated 02.10.2021.
The contention of the petitioner Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin is false and concocted beyond content of the
fact and without evidences on records.
Copy of the representation dated 09.09.2021 is
annexed hereto and marked as Annexure R/12.
Photocopies of the statement of witnesses
annexed hereto and marked as Annexure R/13.
is
Copies of the daily order is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure R/14.
Copy of the letter of Smt. Hazira Begam wife of
Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin is annexed hereto and marked
as Annexure R/15
12. That, with regard to para 2.9 of the writ petition,
I say that, final order of punishment vide
No.11203/F.DP No.11/2019/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dated 02.10.2021 issued by the Disciplinary
Authority upon the petitioner Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin
was based on witnesses and documentary evidences
of marriage certificate issued by SDM, Amarpur and
Kabin Nama signed by Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin and
Mrs. Khelan Bibi in presence of 02 witnesses as per
Muslim customs. The witnesses had deposed during
the course of DP proceeding and documentary
evidences were collected by the Inquiry Officer.
It is also mention that on 29.06.2021, the petitioner
Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin brought and submitted one
compromised letter in plain paper signed by the
complainant
Mrs.Khelan
Bibi
wherein
the
complainant Mrs. Khelan Bibi stated that Ex-Rfn(GD)
Kabir Uddin and herself entered into mutual
compromise on the case and she is willing to
withdraw her complaint. Such petition by the
complainant preponderance misconducts which
were mentioned in the Article of charges. Had there
not been any occurrence of misconduct, there is no
question of mutual compromise between both the
parties time and again.
Therefore, the contention of the petitioner is
concocted and baseless which is not acceptable as
per statement of witnesses and documentary
evidences on records. Had he not been contacted
into marriage with Mrs. Khelan Bibi on 28.01.2016,
why he should brought a mutual compromised from
the complainant Mrs. Khelan Bibi on 29.06.2021 and
also submitted an Affidavit duly signed by Khelan
Bibi vide serial No.653/9/2021 dated 10.09.2021
which was duly Notarized before the Notary public,
Udaipur, Gomati Tripura on 10.09.2021 wherein it is
stated that she had by misunderstanding lodged
complaint against Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin. She also
stated that she is no more interested to proceed
with the complaint. Because, she had settled the
matter with the charged official mutually.
Now, the question is about documentary evidences
of second marriage contacted by Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin with Mrs. Khelan Bibi and the same was
solemnized by signing 'Kabin Nama' and marriage
certificate of both Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin and Mrs.
Khelan Bibi was issued by SDM, Amarpur. In the DP
inquiry all witnesses and evidences established that
Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin contacted second marriage
with Mrs. Khelan Bibi in the year 2016 while his first
wife was still living and without her consent. It is
also established that Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin
solemnized the second marriage with Mrs. Khelan
Bibi without permission of his Disciplinary Authority.
Finally, after careful examination of the case and
considering all the aspects, in exercise of the power
conferred under section-12(1)(h) of TSR Act, 1983,
keeping in view of his children's future and family
economic condition, the Disciplinary Authority i.e,
Commandant, 13th Bn TSR had reduced the proposed
major punishment of 'Removal from service" to
'Compulsory Retirement" from service upon the
Charged Official No.20005122 Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin
of 'F'Coy, 13th Bn TSR vide order No.11203/F.DP
No.11/ 2019/ K.U/ TSR-13/ Estt/ 2019 dated
02.10.2021.
Therefore, contention of the accused Ex-Rfn(GD)
Kabir Uddin has no merits for consideration.
13. That, with regard to para 2.10, I say that, It is
fact that Ex-Rfn(GD), Kabir Uddin of 13th Bn TSR
preferred an appeal petition dated 03.11.2021 to the
Appellate Authority(i.e. DIG, AP(Ops-I), Tripura
against the final order of compulsory retirement
from service issued by the Commandant, 13th Bn
TSR
vide
No.11203/F.DP.No.11/2019/K.U/TSR13/Estt/2019 dated 02.10.2021 for setting aside &
quash the final order dated 02.10.2021 passed by
the Commandant, 13th Bn TSR and to re-instate him
in TSR service. But, he failed to submit his appeal
petition within the stipulated period of 30 days time
against the punishment order. He had submitted his
appeal petition after 31 days. Accordingly, the
Appellate Authority had regretted the said appeal
vide
order
No.10529-33/Appeal/KU/DIGP,
AP(Ops)/2021 dated 28.11.2021 as per the
provision laid-down in Rules-46(3) of TSR(DCSC
etc.) Rules, 1986.
On being aggrieved with the above appeal order
dated 28/11/2021, Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin, 13th Bn
TSR has filed a writ petition vide No. WP(C) 14 of
2022 before the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura
against the above appeal order for condonation of
his delay in submission of appeal. Accordingly,
Hon'ble High Court has passed a judgment & order
dated
18/01/2022
that
"This
Court
draws
interference that the Appellate Authority did not
invoke the jurisdiction as conferred by the proviso
to Rule-46(3) of the said rule and did mechanically
dismiss the appeal for being barred by limitation.
The appeal is filed by the petitioner along with the
application for condoning delay are remanded to the
Appellate Authority for due consideration and for
doing substantive justice". Copy of above judgment
order dated 18.01.2022 has been received from
AIGP
(Crime)
Tripura
vide
No.443/R.16/
PHQ/LC/2022 dated 25.02.2022 and same has been
sent to the Appellate Authority (i.e. DIGP, AP(OpsI), Tripura with request to take necessary action on
the judgment order dated 18.01.2022 passed by the
Hon'ble High Court of Tripura vide this office letter
No.3242-44/F.DP No.11/19/K.U/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dated 07.03.2022.
As per direction of the Hon'ble High Court, the
Appellate Authority has considered condonation of
delay in submission of appeal by Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir
Uddin, 13th Bn TSR and appeal petition dated
03.11.2021 submitted by him was entertained.
Considering the facts & evidences on records, the
Appellate Authority upheld the punishment of
'Compulsory retirement from service‟ passed by the
Commandant,
13th
Bn
TSR
vide
order
No.11203/F.DP No.11/2019/KU/TSR-13/Estt/2019
dated 02.10.2021 to Ex-Rfn(GD) Kabir Uddin, 13th
Bn TSR. The appeal petition submitted by ExRfn(GD) Kabir Uddin, 13th Bn TSR stands disposed
off. The petitioner is at liberty to appeal before the
Reviewing Authority, if he is not satisfied with this
order vide DIGP, AP (Ops-I) order No.2260-64/
F.Pers/KU/Appeal/DIGP (AP & OPS)/21 dated
30.03.2022.
Copy of the order No.10529-33/Appeal/KU/DIGP,
AP(Ops)/ 2021 dated 28.11.2021 is annexed hereto
and marked as Annexure R/16.
Copy of the order vide DIGP, AP (Ops-I) order
No.2260-64/F.Pers/KU/Appeal/DIGP (AP&OPS)/21
dated 30.03.2022 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/17.”
Finally, the State-respondents by filing their counter
affidavit prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
5.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the petitioner
has drawn the attention of this Court that the punishment imposed
upon the petitioner was very much disproportionate and the
respondent
authorities
without
affording
any
reasonable
opportunities as required by law has most arbitrarily imposed
punishment upon the petitioner which violated the principles of
natural justice. Further, referring Annexure-14, a copy of the
application submitted by one Khelan Bibi being the alleged second
wife of the petitioner addressing to the Commandant, 13th Bn TSR,
Subashnagar, Kanchanpur, North Tripura supported by a copy of
affidavit, Learned Counsel for the petitioner further drawn the
attention of this Court that in spite of filing the application no
lenient view was taken by the respondent authority and the
authority passed the impugned order which was finally upheld by
the appellate authority as well as by the revisional authority for
which the interference of the Court is required. Learned Counsel,
Ms. Purkayastha again submitted that since the petitioner is a
Mohammedan personnel so as per the Mohammaden law, he is
permitted to marry 4(four) ladies but the authority concerned
without considering the factual aspects imposed disproportionate
punishment which needs to be interfered with. Learned Counsel in
support of her contention also relied upon one citation of the
Hon‟ble
High
Court
of
Madhya
Pradesh
in
WP(C)
No.1723/2007[titled as Hem Singh vs. Union of India dated
21 June, 2018] wherein the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in the
last para has observed as under:
“Not only this, in another case decided by Manipur
High Court in the case of Union of India & three
others v/s Mohammad Jakir Hussain 2015 SCC
Online Mani 67, a similar view has been taken in
respect of Constable of CRPF and the punishment of
dismissal has been set aside.
Not only this, in the case of Rameshwar Kumbhakar
v/s State of M.P. & Another passed in W.P.
No.3816/2006 decided on 24.03.2015, again in case
of second marriage during the life time of the first
wife, a similar view has been taken by this Court
and the punishment of dismissal from the services
has been substituted to that of withholding of one
increment with cumulative effect.
Resultantly, the present writ petition also stands
allowed. The punishment of dismissal is substituted
to that of withholding of one increment with
cumulative effect. The Constable/petitioner will not
be entitled for backwages, however, he will be
entitled for continuity in the services and for all
other consequential benefits. The respondents are
also directed to reinstate the petitioner within thirty
days from the date of receipt of certified copy of this
order in case he has not attained the age of
superannuation.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
since the punishment imposed was disproportionate so, for the
sake of justice the interference of the Court is required to
quash/set
aside
the
impugned
orders
and
to
convert
the
punishment of major penalties to minor penalties.
6.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. GA appearing on
behalf of the State-respondents first of all has drawn the attention
of this Court to Annexure-R/1 i.e. the initial complaint lodged by
one Khelan Bibi to the Commandant of 13th Bn TSR wherein she
alleged that when the petitioner was posted at Amarpur and
attached to 5th Bn TSR, he married said Khelan Bibi. On the basis of
that complaint preliminary enquiry was conducted, article of
charges were framed, departmental proceeding started and finally
the respondent No.4 imposed major penalties upon the petitioner.
Learned Addl. GA has further drawn the attention of this Court
referring Rule 21 of TCS Rules, 1988 wherein the following
provision is made:
“21. Restriction regarding marriage
(1) No Government employee shall enter into, or
contract, marriage with a person having a spouse
living; and
(2) No Government employee having a spouse
living, shall enter into, or contract, a marriage with
any person;
Provided that the Government may permit a
Government employee to enter into, or contract, any
such marriage as is referred to in clause (1) or
Clause (2) if it is satisfied that(a) such marriage is permissible under the personal
law applicable to such Government employee and
the other party to the marriage; and
(b) there are other grounds for, so doing;
(3) A Government employee who has married or
marries a person other than of Indian nationality
shall
forthwith
Government.”
intimate
the
fact
to
the
Referring the same, Learned Addl. GA submitted that
there was no evidence on record that before conducting marriage
with said Khelan Bibi, the present petitioner obtained permission
from the authority concerned. So, the penalty was rightly imposed
upon the petitioner by the authority being a member of the
disciplined force. Learned Addl. GA has further drawn the attention
of this Court that the conduct of the petitioner also violates Section
12 of the TSR Act, 1983. The relevant portion of Section 12 of the
TSR Act, 1983 provides as under:
“12. Departmental Punishments.
(1) The Commandant or any other authority as may
be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made under
this Act, impose on a member of the rifles one or
more of the following punishments for disobedience,
negligence in duty, remissness in the discharge of
any duty or other misconduct which is prejudicial to
good order and discipline of the Rifles, that is to
say:Minor Punishments:
(a) deprivation of acting or officiating rank;
(b) fine of any amount not exceeding one
month's pay and allowances;
(c) confinement to quarters or camp for a
term not exceeding twenty eight days;
(d) confinement in quarters guard for not
more than twenty eight days with or without
punishment drill or extra guard or fatigue or
other duty;
(e) removal from any office of distinction or
special emolument in the Rifles;
(f) censure or severe censure;
Major Punishments:
(g) reduction in substantive rank;
(h) compulsory retirement;
(i) removal from service which shall not be a
disqualification for future employment under
the Government;
(j) dismissal:
Provided that punishment specified in clause (d)
shall not be imposed or any member of the Rifles
who is of or above the rank of a Lance Naik:”
Learned Addl. GA again drawn the attention of this Court
that in view of the provision of the TSR Act, 1983 there was no
illegality or infirmity conducted by the authority of the present
petitioner. So, legally there is no scope to interfere with the
findings of the disciplinary authority, appellate authority and the
revisional authority. Learned Addl. GA also referred Annexure-R/4
i.e. the communication of SDM Amarpur, Gomati District to
Subedar (GD) Kanan Sinha, PEO, 13th Bn TSR (IR-IX) wherein the
SDM Amarpur forwarded a copy of certificate of marriage of the
petitioner with said Khelan Bibi. Learned Addl. GA in course of
hearing also submitted that during the entire proceeding nowhere
the present petitioner disputed or denied his marriage with said
Khelan Bibi and during the entire proceeding nowhere the petitioner
took the plea that his marriage with his first wife namely Hazira
Begam was dissolved at any point of time as per the Mohameddan
law through any Court of Justice. So, practically there was no
suitable ground of defence on the part of the petitioner in response
to the proceedings drawn up against him to prove his innocence.
Learned Addl. GA has also drawn the attention of this Court
referring para No.22 of the counter affidavit wherein it was
mentioned that in course of the proceeding the petitioner (A.O)
himself admitted and stated that he was given all the opportunities
in course of the proceedings and he had no claim or objection. In
support of his contention, Learned Addl. GA also relied upon one
citation of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2009)
8 SCC 310[titled as State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. v. Man
Mohan Nath Sinha & Anr. decided on 17th August, 2009]
wherein in para No.15 Hon‟ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“15. The legal position is well settled that the power
of judicial review is not directed against the decision
but is confined to the decision-making process. The
court does not sit in judgment on merits of the
decision. It is not open to the High Court to
reappreciate and reappraise the evidence led before
the inquiry officer and examine the findings
recorded by the inquiry officer as a court of appeal
and reach its own conclusions. In the instant case,
the High Court fell into grave error in scanning the
evidence as if it was a court of appeal. The approach
of the High Court in consideration of the matter
suffers from manifest error and, in our thoughtful
consideration,
the
matter
requires
fresh
consideration by the High Court in accordance with
law. On this short ground, we send the matter back
to the High Court.”
Learned Addl. GA further relied upon another citation of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2021) 3 SCC
806[titled as Boloram Bordoloi v. Lakhimi Gaolia Bank & Ors.
decided on 8th February, 2021] wherein in para No.11, Hon‟ble
the Apex Court observed as under:
“11. We are of the view that the judgment of this
Court in ECIL [ECIL v. B. Karunakar, (1993) 4 SCC
727 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 1184] is not helpful to the
case of the appellant. Further, it is well settled that
if the disciplinary authority accepts the findings
recorded by the enquiry officer and passes an order,
no detailed reasons are required to be recorded in
the order imposing punishment. The punishment is
imposed based on the findings recorded in the
enquiry report, as such, no further elaborate
reasons are required to be given by the disciplinary
authority.
As the
departmental appeal
was
considered by the Board of Directors in the meeting
held on 10-12-2005, the Board's decision is
communicated vide order dated 21-12-2005 in Ref.
No. LGB/I&V/Appeal/31/02/2005-06. In that view
of the matter, we do not find any merit in the
submission of the learned counsel for the appellant
that the orders [Boloram Bordoloi v. Lakhmi Gaolia
Bank Writ Appeal No. 361 of 2008, order dated 3-42009 (Gau)] , [Boloram Bordoloi v. Lakhimi Gaonlia
Bank, WP (C) No. 219 of 2006, order dated 8-6-2007
(Gau)] impugned are devoid of reasons.”
Referring the same, Learned Addl. GA further submitted
that there is very least scope on the part of the Court to interfere
with the findings of the disciplinary authority as because legally
there is very little scope to re-assess or re-appreciate the evidence
on record and furthermore, the petitioner himself failed to show
any rebuttable evidence on record to disprove the fact of marriage
with said Khelan Bibi. Moreso, the certificate issued by SDM
Amarpur itself shows that the petitioner got married with said
Khelan Bibi and during the entire course of proceedings nowhere
the petitioner has challenged the said fact. The petitioner also did
not take any effort to nullify the said certificate of marriage dated
30.08.2016 issued by the SDM Amarpur and as such, Learned Addl.
GA in summing up urged for dismissal of the writ petition.
7.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides at
length and perused the documents relied upon by the petitioner
which were annexed with the writ petition and also the documents
relied upon by the State-respondents annexed with the counter
affidavit.
8.
After hearing both the sides, it appears that the
petitioner was a TSR personnel and initially he was posted at
Kanchanpur. He was appointed on 28.03.2000. Later on he was
posted at Amarpur and was attached to 5th Bn TSR where he got
married with said Khelan Bibi and resumed conjugal life. The
certificate of marriage issued by SDM Amarpur dated 30.08.2016
also confirms the said fact. It is also on record that the petitioner
has got his first wife and three daughters and during subsistence of
his marriage with Hazira Begam, he married said Khelan Bibi.
However, from the submission of Learned Counsel for the petitioner
and also from the documents relied upon by the petitioner nowhere
it is found that the petitioner before conducting marriage with said
Khelan Bibi ever took any permission from his authority or the
government regarding performance of his second marriage with
said Khelan Bibi which contravenes Rule 21 of the TCS Rules, 1988
and provision of Section 12 of the TSR Act, 1983. I have also
perused the citation referred by Learned Counsel for the petitioner
of the Hon‟ble High court of Madhya Pradesh. The fact of that case
is different from the facts of the present case. As such, the spirit of
the said judgment cannot be applied in the instant writ petition.
9.
On the other hand, I have also gone through the
citations referred by Learned Addl. GA at the time of hearing of
arguments. It is settled position of law that there is very little scope
on the part of this Court to interfere with the findings of the
departmental authorities in a departmental proceeding. If there are
any serious irregularities or illegalities, in that case only the Court
can interfere.
Here, in the given case after hearing both the sides
nowhere I find that the proceeding initiated by the Departmental
authority was illegal, inoperative and not binding upon the
petitioner. So, on the face of record it appears that the petitioner
has failed to satisfy this Court to interfere with the punishment
imposed by the respondent No.4 upon the petitioner but at the
same time as a Court of Justice it is also necessary to see whether
the punishment imposed by respondent No.4 was justified or not.
10.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for
the petitioner submitted that considering the imputation, the
punishment imposed upon him was harsh and disproportionate
which caused serious prejudice to the petitioner and the same also
violated the principles of natural justice. On the other hand,
Learned Addl. GA opposed the same.
11.
In this regard, I would like to refer one citation of
Division Bench of this Court reported in 2016 SCC OnLine Tri
259[titled as Ghulam Nabi Shergujri v. The Union of India &
Anr. decided on 4th April, 2016] wherein in para Nos.6 to 12 this
High Court observed as under:
“6. As far as contracting a second marriage during
service is concerned, that is governed by Rule 21 of
the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964
which are applicable to the BSF also and this rule
reads as follows : “21. Restrictions regarding marriages(1) No Government servant shall enter into,
or contract, a marriage with a person
having a spouse living; and
(2)
No Government servant, having a
spouse living, shall enter into, or
contract, a marriage with any person:
Provided that the Central Government may
permit a Government servant to enter into, or
contract, any such marriage as is referred to in
Clause (1) or Clause (2), if it is satisfied that(a) such marriage is permissible under
the personal law applicable to such
Government servant and the other
party to the marriage; and
(b) there are other grounds for so doing.
(3) A Government servant who has married or
marries a person other than of India
Nationality shall forthwith intimate the fact
to the Government.”
7. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 21 clearly provides that no
Government servant, having a spouse living, shall
enter into, or contract, a marriage with any person.
The proviso to this rule like the proviso to Rule 7 of
the BSF Rules also empowers the Central
Government to permit a Government servant to
enter into, or contract a second marriage, if it is
satisfied that such marriage is permissible under the
personal law and there are grounds for entering into
the second marriage.
8. The main argument raised on behalf of the
petitioner is that since second marriage is
permissible under the Muslim Personal Law and
furthermore, since the Government has the power to
grant such permission, the conduct of the petitioner
could not be treated to be misconduct and,
therefore, the services could not be terminated. We
are not in agreement with this submission. In case
of any Government employee who has a spouse
living and such person wants to enter into a second
marriage which is permitted under his personal law,
he must approach the Central Government or the
authorities concerned with a prayer in which it
should be clearly spelt out that as per his personal
law he is entitled to enter into a second marriage
and secondly, that such second marriage is
necessary for certain reasons. It is for the
Government to decide whether permission should be
granted or not. It is not for the employee to decide
himself without approaching the Government that
he is entitled to get married a second time. This by
itself is misconduct and contracting a second
marriage without the permission of the Central
Government, even if permissible under the personal
law, clearly amounts to misconduct and, therefore,
the BSF was entitled to take disciplinary action in
terms of Rule 22 of the BSF Rules.
9. Having held so, we are clearly of the view that the
punishment imposed upon the petitioner is grossly
disproportionate to the misconduct committed by
him. We must keep in mind the fact that the
petitioner had already rendered 18 years of service
before he contracted into the second marriage. He
was terminated after he had completed almost 20
years of service. In the reply, there is no allegation
that there was any other complaint against the
petitioner. No doubt, his act of marrying a second
time without seeking permission of the Government
is misconduct but can it be said that this misconduct
is so severe that he should be dismissed from
service which would mean that he would virtually be
entitled to no pensionary or other benefits.
10. The petitioner has pleaded that he was not
aware of the provisions of Rule 21 of the CCS
(Conduct) Rules. Ignorance of law is no excuse but
at the same time, we cannot ourselves ignore the
hard truth that a large number of employees are not
aware of the details of the rules. Whatever be the
case, the petitioner is a person who served the BSF
for about 20 years and the allegation against him is
that he misconducted himself by contracting a
second marriage while his first spouse was living.
This is not a criminal offence of bigamy because the
personal law permits such conduct. Misconduct is
the technical misconduct in not seeking permission
of the authorities concerned. We are, therefore, of
the opinion that though the misconduct of the
petitioner is serious enough to warrant his noncontinuation in service but it is not so serious as to
warrant forfeiture of all his service benefits.
11. It is true that normally the writ Court does not
interfere in matters of punishment and does not
impose a punishment by itself but we are clearly of
the view that this is one of those glaring cases
where the punishment is totally disproportionate to
the misconduct.
12. Therefore, keeping in view the facts and
circumstances of the case, we feel that the interest
of justice will be served if punishment of
compulsory retirement is imposed upon the
petitioner instead of punishment of dismissal from
service. The impugned orders are modified
accordingly. The petitioner shall be deemed to have
been compulsorily retired from the date of his
dismissal from service.”
In the said case this Court converted the punishment of
“dismissal from service” to punishment of “compulsory retirement”.
Here,
in
the
instant
case,
the
punishment
of
“compulsory
retirement” is imposed upon the petitioner which in my considered
view was not proper. At the same time on perusal of the counter
affidavit and the annexed documents submitted with the counter
affidavit, specifically Annexure-R/11 it appears that the respondent
authority at the time of imposition of punishment did not consider
the same. Admittedly, second marriage is permissible under the
Muslim Mohammedan personal law. Here, in the case at hand there
is no other evidence on record that in discharging duties the
petitioner conducted any other misconduct which was detrimental
to the interest of the department and furthermore the punishment
was imposed after rendering almost 20 years of sincere service in
the department by the petitioner. But since the present petitioner is
a government servant so he is definitely guided by Rule 21 of the
TCS Rules, 1988 and in this case, the petitioner suppressed the fact
of his second marriage with the department and before conducting
marriage he did not obtain any permission from the authority.
Thus, he has committed misconduct. However, if he is sent to
compulsory retirement, in that case definitely the punishment
would cause severe hardship to him and his entire family.
Situated thus, it appears to this Court that since the
punishment imposed upon him appears to be disproportionate so
the matter be remanded back to the authority concerned to
reconsider the matter in respect of imposition of punishment
considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also
considering the representation submitted by said Khelan Bibi i.e.
Annexure-14 (Annexure-R/11 relied upon by the respondents).
12.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed. All the orders passed by the disciplinary authority,
appellate authority and revisional authority are accordingly stands
set aside. The matter is remanded back to the respondent No.4 i.e.
the appointing authority of the petitioner to reconsider the matter
of imposition of punishment upon the petitioner and thereafter to
issue a fresh order of punishment to the petitioner, if necessary by
calling the interested parties of the proceeding.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
4(four) months from the date of passing of this judgment and
order.
With this observation, the instant writ petition stands
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.05.17
A DATTA Date:
16:03:59 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review