Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.131 of 2020
Sri Jiban Krishna Saha
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and Others
……….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Mr. G.S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Mr. R. Datta, Adv.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing and
Judgment & Order
:
01.03.2023
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Chief Justice, Acting
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
as well as Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. appearing for the respondents
No.1 and 2, Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No.3
to 6 and Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondents No.7, 13, 15 to 20, 22, 23, 25 to 31, 33 to 37, 40 to 42, 44 to 56
and 58 to 64. Accordingly, notices are duly served upon the above mentioned
respondents. There is no representation for the remaining respondents. In so
far as the respondents No.43 and 57 are concerned this court by way of an
order dated 13.12.2022 allowed the petitioner to place on record two
newspapers with regard to the steps taken for publication of the notification
through substituted service as proof of service. Now, in presence of the
counsel, this matter is taken up for hearing.
2.
This is the second round of litigation. Earlier the petitioner had
approached the Hon’ble High Court being WP(C)No.310 of 2015 challenging the
recruitment rules for the post of Headmaster/Headmistress, Higher Secondary
Schools/District Inspector Schools and also for the selection process and
appointment to the post of Assistant Headmaster/Assistant Head Mistress,
Higher
Secondary
Schools
and
Headmaster/Headmistress
of
High
Schools/Inspector of Schools of the private respondents not having B.Ed.
Degree, and herein six months certificate courses like B.T/CETE/T.Ed, had been
given same status as B.Ed. Degree and had been arbitrarily treated said
certificate courses at per with the B.Ed which is a two years degree course
which is done by the state respondents arbitrarily and violating the National
Council for Teacher Education(Determination of Qualifications for Recruitment
of Teachers) Regulations, 2001 and proceeded for the appointment to the post
of Headmaster/Headmistress, High Schools/District Inspector of Schools and
also
for
appointment
to
the
post
of
Assistant
Headmaster/Assistant
Headmistress, Higher Secondary Schools, and Headmaster/Headmistress of
High Schools/Inspector of Schools through the TPSC equating the B.Ed. Degree
with the certificate courses like B.T./CETE/T.Ed, vide advertisement No.01 of
31.12.2013
issued
by
the
TPSC
and
the
private
respondents
were
recommended for the appointment who are not having the B.Ed. degree. The
said recommendation and subsequently the appointments thereof by the
respondents are completely arbitrary, illegal and are not tenable in law. On
04.09.2019 was disposed directing the petitioner to approach the respondentState, highlighting their grievances both with regard to the framing of rules as
also their non-consideration of appointment through the selection process
already undertaken. Two issues with regard to rules and another with regard to
selection process.
3.
According to the petitioner as per direction of the court the
petitioner have highlighted their grievances to the respondent-State, but the
respondent-State have not stated anything in the order dated 04.12.2019.
During the course of argument Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has referred to para-6 of the order dated 04.12.2019 where it has
been stated as follows :
“6. Sri Jiban Krishna Saha, PGT was accordingly heard. He has
reiterated the following issues mentioned in his written
representation :
(a) The eligibility criteria mentioned in the advertisement
issued by the TPSC bearing No.01 of 2014 dated 31.12.2013,
requires Masters Degree with at least 45% marks in
B.T./B.Ed./T-Ed(6 months Course) for the post of Head
Master, Higher Secondary/District Inspector of Schools. This
is as per Recruitment Rules, 2006. Thus, B.Ed. Course which is
for 2(two) years has been equated with 6(six) months
certificate of T-Ed and CETE. Moreover, CETE is a certificate
course for elementary level teachers.
(b) The National Council for Teachers Education (NCTE)
(Determination of Minimum Qualifications for Recruitment of
Teachers) Regulations, 2001, lays down that at the secondary
level the minimum qualification required is B-Ed or 4(four)
years Integrated or a qualification course. At the Senior
secondary level/Higher Secondary level the minimum
qualification required is Master’s Degree with B.Ed. or 2(two)
years integrated M.Sc.Ed or equivalent course. Thus, making
B.Ed and essential qualification for recruitment teachers
Board at Secondary and Higher Secondary level.
(c) Further, as per the notification dated 3 rd September, 2001,
it has been provided that even for appointment for teachers at
primary level basic teacher training programme of 2(two)
years duration is required and B.Ed. is not a substitute for
basic teachers training programme. Thus, recruitment of
teachers at Secondary and Higher Secondary level with 6(six)
months training is completely illegal and beyond the
guidelines issued by NCTE vide notification dated 3rd
September, 2001. Further the notification dated 3 rd
September, 2001 provides that the states having basic
teachers training courses of less than 2(two) years duration
may by 2005 conduct basic teachers training of 2(two) years
within 2005. Further as per clause 4 of the notification dated,
3rd September, 2001, it has been provided that the existing
rule of the States may be modified within a period of 3(three)
years so, as to bring conformity with the qualifications laid
down by NCTE. But the recruitment rules which has been
framed by the State for the post of Headmaster/Headmistress
Higher Secondary Schools/District Inspector of Schools vide
notification dated 31.10.2006 are not in conformity with the
NCTE notification dated 3rd September, 2001.
(d) The NCTE has also issued fresh guidelines on 12.11.2014
and as per the said guidelines also B-Ed is the minimum
qualification required for recruitment for teachers at both
secondary and higher secondary level.”
He has further stated that the Director of Secondary Education
recorded the grievances. According to the petitioner, the underlined portion of
sub-para-c and sub-para-d of para 6 not considered.
4.
The Director of Secondary Education only stated in their order
that the petitioner have secured only 109 marks whereas the last selected
candidate has secured 113.5. So, the petitioner cannot be selected. The
grievance of the petitioner is that if the present petitioner cannot get selection
than the private respondents also cannot get the appointment because they
are also not eligible.
5.
The grievance of the petitioner is that the representation of the
petitioner have been rejected on the ground that TPSC through due process
prepared the select list among the candidates whose qualification is in
conformity with the impugned recruitment rules, but silent about the
recruitment rules which is against the NCTE Regulation, 2001 and affirmed the
appointment of the private respondents who were not having the B.Ed. degree,
but recommended by the TPSC, though it is admitted by the authority that the
recruitment rules is bad in law and illegally framed by the Government but as
the petitioner though have the qualification of the B.Ed. degree and other
requisite qualifications but not been recommended by the TPSC, he cannot be
considered for the appointment to the posts.
6.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. appearing for the respondents
No.1 and 2 during the course of his argument has referred to a judgment of
the apex Court in D. Sarojakumari versus R. Helen Thilakom and Others
reported in (2017) 9 SCC 478. He has referred to paras-4 to 12 of the
judgment which reads as under :
“4. The main ground urged on behalf of the appellant is that
Respondent No.1 having taken part in the selection process
could not be permitted to challenge the same after she was
unsuccessful in getting selected. The law is well settled that
once a person takes part in the process of selection and is not
found fit for appointment, the said person is estopped from
challenging the process of selection.
5. In Dr. G. Sarna vs. University of Lucknow & Ors. : (1976) 3
SCC 585 the petitioner after appearing in the interview for the
post of Professor and having not been selected pleaded that
the experts were biased. This Court did not permit the
petitioner to raise this issue and held as follows :“15.We do not, however, consider it necessary
in the present case to get into the question of
the reasonableness of bias or real likelihood of
bias as despite the fact that the appellant knew
all the relevant facts, he did not before
appearing for the interview or at the time of the
interview raise even his little finger against the
constitution of the Selection (1976) 3 SCC
585 Committee. He seems to have voluntarily
appeared before the committee and taken a
chance of having a favourable recommendation
from it. Having done so, it is not now open to
him to turn round and question the constitution
of the committee……”
6. In Madan Lal & Ors. vs. State of J&K & Ors.: (1995) 3 SCC
486 , the petitioner laid challenge to the manner and method
of conducting viva-voce test after they had appeared in the
same and were unsuccessful. This Court held as follows :“9…….Thus the petitioners took a chance to get
themselves selected at the said oral interview.
Only because they did not find themselves to
have emerged successful as a result of their
combined performance both at written test and
oral interview, they have filed this petition. It is
now well settled that if a candidate takes a
calculated chance and appears at the interview,
then, only because the result of the interview is
not palatable to him, he cannot turn round and
subsequently contend that the process of
interview was unfair or Selection Committee
was not properly constituted……”
7. In Manish Kumar Shahi vs. State of Bihar : (2010) 12 SCC
576 , this Court held as follows :“16…….Surely, if the petitioner’s name had
appeared in the merit list, he would not have
even dreamed of challenging the selection. The
petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
only after he found that his name (1995) 3 SCC
486 (2010) 12 SCC 576 does not figure in the
merit list prepared by the Commission. This
conduct of the petitioner clearly disentitles him
from questioning the selection and the High
Court did not commit any error by refusing to
entertain the writ petition.”
8. In the case of Ramesh Chandra Shah and others vs. Anil
Joshi and others : (2013) 11 SCC 309 the petitioners took part
in the process of selection made under the general Rules.
Having appeared in the interview and not being successful
they challenged the method of recruitment itself. They were
not permitted to raise such an objection. This Court held as
follows :“24. In view of the propositions laid down in
the above noted judgments, it must be held
that by having taken part in the process of
selection with full knowledge that the
recruitment was being made under the General
Rules, the respondents had waived their right
to question the advertisement or methodology
adopted by the Board for making selection and
the learned Single Judge and the Division
Bench of the High Court committed grave error
by entertaining the grievance made by the
respondents.”
9. Same view has been taken in Madras Institute of
Development Studies and Another vs. Dr. K. Sivasubramaniyan
and others : (2016) 1 SCC 454.
10. The Kerala High Court did not note the above mentioned
judgments and ignored the well settled position of law in
rejecting the specific plea raised by the appellant herein that
the appellant could not raise the issue that no direct
recruitment should have been conducted once she had applied
for and taken part in the selection process by direct
recruitment.
11. As far as the present case is concerned an advertisement
was issued by Respondent No.6 inviting applications for the
post of Music Teacher in Samuel LMS High School. Respondent
No.1 did not raise any objection at that stage that the post
could not be filled in by direct recruitment and she should be
considered for promotion. Not only that, she in fact, applied
for the post and took part in the selection process. After
having taken part in the selection process and being found
lower in merit to the appellant, she cannot at this stage be
permitted to turn around and claim that the post could not be
filled in by direct recruitment. The reasoning of the learned
Single Judge in rejecting the objection is not in consonance
with the law laid down by this Court. In view of this we need
not go into the other issues raised.
12. We, therefore, allow these appeals and set aside order
dated 25.07.2003 of the learned Single Judge and dismiss the
writ petition O.P.No.36563 of 2002 as being not
maintainable.”
Having heard the counsel for the parties, this court does not find
any merit in the present writ petition and accordingly, the same stands
dismissed. The petitioner is at liberty to avail remedies under law if any against
the impugned orders.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review