Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Rev. P. No.41 of 2023
Sri Jayeswar Namasudra,
S/O Late Joy Kumar Namasudra,
Resident of Village Dab Bari, Mechuria,
P.S – Kachu Cherra,
District – Dhalai Tripura
------Petitioner
Versus
1. Smt. Namita Sarkar,
W/o Sri Jayeswar Namasudra
D/o- Sri Harendra Sarkar,
Vill- Tulabagan, PS- Sidhai,
District – West Tripura
2. The State of Tripura
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Datta, Adv.
For Respondent No.1
:
None.
For Respondent No.2
:
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing
:
06.02.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
12.02.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This Criminal Revision Petition under Section 397
read
with
Section
of
Cr.P.C
is
filed
for
setting
aside/quashing the judgment and order dated 15.06.2023
passed by Learned Additional Judge, Family Court, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with Crl. Misc 128 of 2021.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. K. Datta for the
petitioner. At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
respondent is found to be absent.
3.
Before conclusion of the case, let us see the
subject matter of the proceeding before the Learned Court
below.
The
OP
wife
Smt.
Namita
Sarkar
submitted
an
application under Section 125 of Cr.P.C read with Section 7 of
the Family Courts Act for granting her maintenance allowance
from the petitioner-husband.
4.
It was the case of the OP-wife that her marriage
was solemnized with the petitioner-husband in the house of her
brother on 02.12.2018 according to Hindu Marriage Rites and
Customs. In the marriage, her brother gave different articles
like wooden cot, freeze, Tea-Table, Alna, Sofa Set, Showcase,
etc along with gold made ornaments like Earring, Necklace, and
cash of Rs.32,000/- to the petitioner-husband as per the
demand. But within one month of marriage, the petitionerhusband demanded Rs.2,00,000/- from the OP-wife and for that
she was subjected to torture by her husband and other family
members. After one and half month of their marriage, the OPwife found that the petitioner-husband and his elder sister-inlaw were in compromising situation in the room of her elder
sister-in-law. Seeing the same, she raised objection and on this
issue, she was also assaulted by the petitioner-husband. On this
account, so many meetings were held to resolve the issue and
in the meeting, the petitioner-husband admitted that he would
not continue such act in future and also assured not to cause
any further cruelty upon the OP-wife. The last meeting was held
on 10.10.2019 thereafter on 15.10.2019 in the morning, the
petitioner-husband along with his elder sister-in-law, elder
brother, Sri Jitendra Namasudra and his mother conjointly
assaulted the OP-wife by fist and blows. When the OP-wife to
save her life tried to took shelter in the residence of one Sushen
Namasudra but said Sushen Namasudra was not available that
time. The petitioner-husband dragged her by catching her hair
and severely tortured her and she was thrown in a longa on
that day. After that she was found herself in bed at Kulai
Hospital when after getting the information, the brother of the
OP-wife along with others came and in the Hospital, she was
admitted therein with effect from 15.10.2019 to 18.10.2019
and on that issue, one case was registered at Kachu Cherra PS
vide Kachu Cherra PS case No.10 of 2019 under Section
325/498-A/34 of IPC. After discharge from the Hospital, the OPwife went to her matrimonial home along with her brother for
staying therein but that time they did not accept her until the
demand of Rs.2,00,000/- is fulfilled and since 18.10.2019, the
OP-wife was staying in the residence of her brother.
5.
The OP-wife further took the plea that her
husband from that time did not pay any maintenance to her and
so
she
claimed
Rs.10,000/-
per
month
as
maintenance
allowance from her husband i.e. the present petitioner. It was
further asserted that the petitioner-husband is the owner of a
rubber plantation as well as he has got one auto-rickshaw and
used to earn Rs.50,000/- per month from his sources and used
to lead luxury life while the OP wife was passing her days with
severe hardships.
6.
Initially, before the Court of Learned Additional
Family Judge, a process of reconciliation of the matter was
taken up but that could not be settled. However, the petitionerhusband as OP contested the case by filing one written
objection denying all the assertions of his wife in her claim
petition. It was further asserted that the OP-wife was not willing
to discharge her marital duties and the petitioner-husband and
his mother were residing separately and his brother was
residing separately and the OP-wife was reluctant to do household works, rather, she was interested to spend time with one
Sushen Namasudra and she used to reside in the house of said
Sushen Namasudra in the nights also without the consent of the
petitioner-husband. Further, it was asserted by the petitionerhusband in his objection that the OP-wife created pressure upon
him to stay with his wife at her brother’s house at Tulabagan,
Mohanpur and as he refused her proposal, so in his absence,
the OP-wife used to cause torture upon his aged mother
physically using filthy languages.
7.
It was further asserted by the petitioner-husband
that at the instance of said Sushen Namasudra, the OP wife
lodged a false criminal case under Section 498-A of IPC against
him and further submitted that the OP-wife left his residence in
connivance with Sri Sushen Namasudra without his consent and
by the objection, prayed for dismissal of the proceeding. Upon
consideration of the application and the objection of the
petitioner-husband,
Learned
Court
below
determined
the
following points for decision of the case:
“Points For Determination
[10] Considering the pleadings, evidence and
submission of Ld. Counsels of both parties following
points are taken up for determination:i) Whether petitioner is the legally married wife
of OP Sri Jayeswar Namasudra?
ii)
Whether
OP
has
neglected
to
give
maintenance to the petitioner since 18-10-2019?
iii) Whether petitioner has just ground to claim
maintenance allowance from OP?
iv) Whether the petitioner is unable to maintain
herself and OP has sufficient means of income?
v) Whether the petitioner is entitled to get
monthly maintenance allowance of Rs.10,000/per month for herself from OP?”
8.
Before the Learned Trial Court, the wife-petitioner
herein the OP adduced four witnesses but no documentary
evidence was adduced by the wife-petitioner. On the other
hand, the OP-husband although submitted examination-in-chief
of 5 witnesses but failed to adduce those witnesses for their
cross-examination by the other side. Even no documentary
evidence was adduced by the OP-husband before the Learned
Court below and ultimately the Learned Additional Judge,
Family Court by judgment and order dated 15.6.2023 allowed
the
claim
maintenance
application
of
allowance
against
petitioner herein.
the
wife-petitioner
the
OP-husband
granting
now
the
9.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the operative portion of the Order of Learned
Additional Family Judge:
ORDER
[31] In the result, it is hereby held that the petition
dated 01-03-2021 lodged by the claimant-petitioner
is allowed as per sec.125(1) of Cr.P.C with effect
from the date of petition. The wife-petitioner Smt.
Namita Sarkar is awarded maintenance allowance @
Rs.8,000/- (rupees eight thousand) only per month
w.e.f. the month of March, 2021 onwards.
[32] The arrear maintenance accumulated from the
month of March, 2021 till the month of May, 2023 is
Rs.2,16,000/- (@ Rs.8,000/- X 27 months) which
the OP is liable to pay to the petitioner.
[33] O.P. Sri Jayeswar Namasudra is hereby
directed to pay the arrear maintenance of
Rs.2,16,000/- (Rupees two lakhs & sixteen
thousand) only either wholly or partly by way of 54
nos. equated monthly installments @ Rs.4,000/(rupees four thousand) only per month in favour of
the wife-petitioner Smt. Namita Sarkar with effect
from the month of June, 2023 by depositing the
same in her bank account no. 8042012056517 IFSC
Code
No.UTBIORRBTGB (maintained at Tripura
Gramin Bank, Mohanpur Sidhai Branch) within first
week of every following month of English calendar
until realization.
[34] O.P. Sri Jayeswar Namasudra is also directed
to pay the monthly maintenance allowance of
Rs.8,000/- (Rupees eight thousand) only per month
to the wife-petitioner from the month of June,2023
and onward by depositing the same in the bank
account
of
the
petitioner
bearing
no.
8042012056517,
IFSC
Code
No.UTBIORRBTGB
(maintained at Tripura Gramin Bank, Mohanpur
Sidhai Branch) within first week of every following
English calendar month and he shall continue to pay
the same even after recovery of the arrear money
indicated above.
[35] Supply a copy of this judgment to both parties
at free of cost.
[36] Thus, the case stands allowed & disposed of on
contest.
10.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned
Counsel for the petitioner-husband submitted that before the
Learned
Trial
Court,
the
petitioner-husband
submitted
examination-in-chief of witnesses namely Priyabala Namasudra,
Tarun Namasudra, Anjana Namasudra, Rakesh Namasudra and
the petitioner-husband Jayeswar Namasudra himself but the
Learned Trial Court did not allow the petitioner-husband to be
cross-examined by the other side for which the petitionerhusband has been seriously prejudiced and urged before the
Court to remand back the case to the Learned Court below for
allowing the petitioner-husband to adduce his witnesses afresh
for conducting his defence properly. It was further submitted
that without any basis, the Learned Court below has awarded
maintenance allowance at the rate of Rs.8,000/- per month
which is too high and the petitioner-husband being a poor
person is not in a position to pay that amount. Moreso, he has
got no rubber plantation and auto-rickshaw of his own. So, if
the maintenance allowance awarded by the Learned Court
below is not modified and the case is remanded back to the
Learned Trial Court for taking evidence of the petitionerhusband afresh then the present petitioner-husband would be
seriously prejudiced.
11.
Inspite of opportunity, none appeared on behalf of
the OP-wife at the time of hearing of argument of this case. I
have perused the record and it appears that inspite of allowing
opportunity on three occasions i.e. on 17.03.2023, 18.03.2023
and 18.04.2023, the petitioner-husband i.e. the OP of the
original proceeding failed to adduce his witnesses before the
Learned Court below for cross-examination by the other side by
seeking time and ultimately, Learned Court below rejected the
application seeking adjournments and fixed the case for hearing
of argument and judgment.
12.
The present petitioner-husband did not challenge
the order of the Learned Court below regarding refusal to grant
adjournments to adduce witnesses. So, the plea taken by
Learned Counsel for the petitioner cannot be accepted at this
stage.
13.
The petitioner has challenged the proceeding
under Section 125 of Cr.P.C. So, considering the materials on
record let us proceed to dispose of the case as per law. I have
gone through the record of the Learned Court below and also
heard argument of Learned Counsel for the petitioner-husband.
14.
From the record of the Learned Court below, it
appears that there is no dispute on record in respect of the
marriage
of
the
petitioner-husband
with
the
OP-wife
on
02.12.2018 according to Hindu Marriage Rites and Customs.
The petitioner-husband as OP by his written objection did not
deny that fact. It is also on record that after the marriage both
the parties started living together as husband and wife. But
after few days, the petitioner-husband and his family started
causing cruelty upon the OP-wife seeking money. Although no
specific date was mentioned when the money was demanded
and how the petitioner-husband caused cruelty upon the OPwife and at the same time also, the petitioner-husband failed to
discard that portion of evidence of the OP-wife.
15.
It is also on record that after one and half month
of marriage, the OP wife one day found the petitioner-husband
and his elder sister-in-law in some offensive situation for which
she raised objection and for that also, the petitioner-husband
and his other family members assaulted and caused hurt to the
OP-wife and for that she was admitted in Kulai Hospital for
three days. On that issue, a specific criminal case was
registered under Section 325/498-A/34 of IPC against the
petitioner-husband and his family members. The petitionerhusband by way of cross-examination of the OP-wife and her
witnesses could not discard that portion of evidence nor could
raise any cloud to disbelieve their evidence.
16.
In course of cross-examination of the wife by the
petitioner-husband, she stated that her mother-in-law is aged
about 70 years and she led her conjugal life at her matrimonial
home for a period of 10/11 months. She also could not
specifically say the date when the OP husband i.e. the present
petitioner demanded Rs.2,00,000/-. Nothing more came out
from her cross-examination.
Similarly, PW-2, Arati Sarkar in her examinationin-chief by way of affidavit, tried to support the case of the OPwife but during cross-examination, she specifically stated that
the second party i.e. the present petitioner-husband demanded
Rs.2,00,000/- from the OP-wife but she could not say the date.
Nothing more came out relevant from her cross-examination.
Similarly, PW-3, Nitya Ranajan Biswas in his
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit supported the version
of the OP-wife in her claim application but during crossexamination, he only stated that he heard from his niece that
the petitioner-husband i.e. the second party had illicit relation
with his elder sister-in-law. Nothing more came out relevant
from his cross-examination.
PW-4, Bhulan Namasudra also in his examination
in chief by way of affidavit tried to support the version of the
OP-wife but during cross-examination, he stated that he has got
no documents to show regarding rubber plantation, autorickshaw, cultivating land and fishery of the second party i.e.
the present petitioner.
17.
The OP-wife, Namita Sarkar in para 10 of her
examination-in-chief
by
way
of
affidavit
stated
that
the
petitioner has got rubber plantation, auto rickshaw including
farming land and three numbers of fisheries and used to earn
Rs.50,000/- per month.
Similarly, Smti Arati Sarkar in para 7 of her
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit also reiterated the
same fact. PW-3, Nitya Ranjan Biswas in para 7 of his
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit also reiterated the
same fact and PW-4, Bhulan Namasudra in para 7 of his
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit also referred the same
contents regarding monthly income of the petitioner-husband
i.e. the OP of the original proceeding.
18.
Those witnesses as I have already stated were
tested for cross-examination by the petitioner-husband i.e. OP
of the original proceeding but their evidence could not be
shaken by the petitioner-husband before the Learned Court
below and at the same time, it is also true that the OP wife as
petitioner in the proceeding could not submit any documentary
evidence showing the actual monthly income of the petitionerhusband in support of her claim petition.
19.
Learned Court below at the time of determination
of the monthly income of the petitioner-husband came to the
observation in Para 27 of the judgment that the monthly
income of the OP husband can be assessed to Rs.30,000/- to
Rs.40,000/- and accordingly, determined the maintenance
allowance at the rate of Rs.8,000/- per month. The petitionerhusband as OP at the time of filing his statement of assets and
liabilities by way of affidavit in part 1, in column No.10 shown
his monthly income as Rs.3,000/- and in column No.16 shown
the monthly income of his mother is Rs.2,000/- as MGNREGA
worker. But, as observed by Learned Court below, this plea
cannot
be
accepted
since
the
petitioner-husband
during
recording of evidence of the witnesses of the OP-wife could not
raise any circumstances or satisfactory grounds to disbelieve
their evidence regarding his monthly income.
20.
In this regard, I would like to refer Rajnesh v.
Neha and another reported in (2021) 2 SCC 324 in case no.
Crl. Appl. No.730 of 2020 dated 04.11.2020, wherein Hon’ble
the Apex Court has given certain directions in disposal of the
maintenance proceeding and other cases under other provisions
of law in granting maintenance. In para 34 and 38, the Hon’ble
Apex Court observed as under:
“34. In Bhagwan Dutt v Kamla Devi :(1975) 2
SCC 386 the Supreme Court held that under
Section 125(1) Cr.P.C. only a wife who is
“unable to maintain herself” is entitled to
seek maintenance. The Court held : (SCC
p.392, para 19)
“19. The object of these provisions being
to prevent vagrancy and destitution, the
Magistrate has to find out as to what is
required by the wife to maintain a
standard of living which is neither
luxurious nor penurious, but is modestly
consistent with the status of the family.
The needs and requirements of the wife
for such moderate living can be fairly
determined, only if her separate income,
also, is taken into account together with
the earnings of the husband and his
commitments.” (emphasis supplied)
35. Prior to the amendment of Section 125 in
2001, there was a ceiling on the amount
which could be awarded as maintenance,
being Rs. 500 “in the whole”. In view of the
rising costs of living and inflation rates, the
ceiling of Rs. 500 was done away by the 2001
Amendment Act. The Statement of Objects
and Reasons of the Amendment Act states
that the wife had to wait for several years
before
being
granted
maintenance.
Consequently, the Amendment Act introduced
an express provision for grant of “interim
maintenance”. The Magistrate was vested
with the power to order the respondent to
make a monthly allowance towards interim
maintenance during the pendency of the
petition. Under sub-section (2) of Section
125, the court is conferred with the discretion
to award payment of maintenance either from
the date of the order, or from the date of the
application. Under the third proviso to the
amended Section 125, the application for
grant of interim maintenance must be
disposed of as far as possible within sixty
days from the date of service of notice on the
respondent.
36. The amended Section 125 reads as under:
“125. Order for maintenance of wives,
children and parents.- (1) If any person
having sufficient means neglects or
refuses to maintain-
(a) his wife, unable to maintain
herself, or
(b) his legitimate or illegitimate
minor child, whether married or
not, unable to maintain itself, or
(c) his legitimate or illegitimate
child
(not
being
a
married
daughter)
who
has
attained
majority, where such child is, by
reason of any physical or mental
abnormality or injury unable to
maintain itself, or
(d) his father or mother, unable
to maintain himself or herself.
a Magistrate of the first class may, upon
proof of such neglect or refusal, order such
person to make a monthly allowance for the
maintenance of his wife or such child, father
or mother, at such monthly rate as such
Magistrate thinks fit, and to pay the same to
such person as the Magistrate may from time
to time direct:
Provided that the Magistrate may order
the father of a minor female child
referred to in clause (b) to make such
allowance, until she attains her majority,
if the Magistrate is satisfied that the
husband of such minor female child, if
married, is not possessed of sufficient
means :
Provided further that the Magistrate
may, during the pendency of the
proceeding regarding monthly allowance
for the maintenance under this subsection, order such person to make a
monthly allowance for the interim
maintenance of his wife or such child,
father or mother, and the expenses of
such proceeding which the Magistrate
considers reasonable, and to pay the
same to such person as the Magistrate
may from time to time direct:
Provided also that an application for the
monthly allowance for the interim
maintenance and expenses of proceeding
under the second proviso shall, as far as
possible, be disposed of within sixty days
from the date of the service of notice of
the application to such person.
Explanation. – For the purposes of this
Chapter,(a) "minor" means a person who,
under the provisions of the Indian
Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875); is
deemed not to have attained his
majority;
(b) "wife" includes a woman who
has been divorced by, or has
obtained a divorce from, her
husband and has not remarried.
(2)
Any
such
allowance
for
the
maintenance or interim maintenance and
expenses of proceeding shall be payable
from the date of the order, or, if so
ordered, from the date of the application
for maintenance or interim maintenance
and expenses of proceeding, as the case
may be.
(3) If any person so ordered fails
without sufficient cause to comply with
the order, any such Magistrate may, for
every breach of the order, issue a
warrant for levying the amount due in
the manner provided for levying fines,
and may sentence such person, for the
whole, or any part of each month's
allowance for the maintenance or the
interim maintenance and expenses of
proceeding, as the case may be,
remaining unpaid after the execution of
the warrant, to imprisonment for a term
which may extend to one month or until
payment if sooner made:
Provided that no warrant shall be issued
for the recovery of any amount due
under this section unless application be
made to the Court to levy such amount
within a period of one year from the date
on which it became due:
Provided further that if such person
offers to maintain his wife on condition
of her living with him, and she refuses to
live with him, such Magistrate may
consider any grounds of refusal stated by
her, and may make an order under this
section notwithstanding such offer, if he
is satisfied that there is just ground for
so doing.
Explanation. – If a husband has
contracted
marriage
with
another
woman or keeps a mistress, it shall be
considered to be a just ground for his
wife' s refusal to live with him.
(4) No wife shall be entitled to receive
an allowance for the maintenance or
interim maintenance and expenses of
proceeding, as the case may be, from her
husband under this section if she is living
in adultery, or if, without any sufficient
reason, she refuses to live with her
husband, or if they are living separately
by mutual consent.
(5) On proof that any wife in whose
favour an order has been made under
this section is living in adultery, or that
without sufficient reason she refuses to
live with her husband, or that they are
living separately by mutual consent, the
Magistrate shall cancel the order.”
(emphasis supplied)
37. In Chaturbhuj v Sita Bai :(2008) 2 SCC
316 this Court held that the object of
maintenance proceedings is not to punish a
person for his past neglect, but to prevent
vagrancy and destitution of a deserted wife
by providing her food, clothing and shelter by
a speedy remedy. Section 125 CrPC is a
measure of social justice especially enacted
to protect women and children, and falls
within the constitutional sweep of Article
15(3), reinforced by Article 39 of the
Constitution.
38. Proceedings under Section 125 CrPC are
summary in nature. In Bhuwan Mohan Singh
v. Meena :(2015) 6 SCC 353 this Court held
that Section 125 CrPC was conceived to
ameliorate the agony, anguish, financial
suffering of a woman who had left her
matrimonial home, so that some suitable
arrangements could be made to enable her to
sustain herself and the children. Since it is
the sacrosanct duty of the husband to provide
financial support to the wife and minor
children, the husband was required to earn
money even by physical labour, if he is ablebodied, and could not avoid his obligation,
except on any legally permissible ground
mentioned in the statute.”
From the aforesaid principle of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court it appears that the object of the
maintenance proceeding is not to punish a person a person for
his past neglect, but to prevent vagrancy and destitution of a
deserted wife by providing her food, clothing and shelter by a
speedy remedy. It was further observed that it is the sacrosanct
duty of the husband to provide financial support to the wife,
even by physical labour, if he is able bodied and could not avoid
his obligation, except
on any
legally
permissible ground
mentioned in the statute.
Further in para 84 of the said judgment in
Rajnesh(supra), it was further observed:
“84. The Delhi High Court in Bharat Hegde v.
Saroj Hegde :2007 SCC OnLine Del 622 laid
down the following factors to be considered
for determining maintenance: (SCC OnLine
Del para 8)
“1. Status of the parties.
2. Reasonable wants of the claimant.
3.
The
independent
income
and
property of the claimant.
4. The number of persons, the nonapplicant has to maintain.
5. The amount should aid the applicant
to live in a similar lifestyle as he/she
enjoyed in the matrimonial home.
6. Non-applicant’s liabilities, if any.
7. Provisions for food, clothing, shelter,
education, medical attendance and
treatment, etc. of the applicant.
8. Payment capacity of the nonapplicant.
9. Some guesswork is not ruled out
while estimating the income of the nonapplicant when all the sources or
correct sources are not disclosed.
10. The non-applicant to defray the
cost of litigation.
11. The amount awarded under Section
125 CrPC is adjustable against the
amount awarded under Section 24 of
the Act.” ”
From the above principle, it appears that in
determining
maintenance,
the
aforesaid
factors
to
be
considered by the Court.
21.
Here, in the case at hand, although, the OP-wife
all along took the plea that her husband has got his monthly
income around Rs.50,000/- and the petitioner-husband has got
rubber plantation, auto rickshaw, income from cultivation, etc.
But in this regard, not a single piece of documentary evidence
has been adduced by the OP-wife before the Learned Court
below. The petitioner-husband although took the plea that his
earning is Rs.3,000/- per month but in this regard he has failed
to adduce any satisfactory cogent evidence on record before the
Learned Court below and the Learned Court below thus
discarded that plea of the petitioner-husband that his monthly
income is Rs.3,000/- per month and determined the amount of
compensation at the rate of Rs.8,000/- per month. Learned
Court below also came to the observation that his monthly
income can be assessed to Rs.30,000/- to Rs.40,000/- per
month but it is not clearly explained as to how the Learned
Court below assessed the amount of monthly income of the
petitioner-husband at the time of disposal of the proceeding. At
the same time, it is also true that the petitioner-husband being
a able bodied person cannot not avoid his responsibility to
maintain his wife i.e. the OP of this proceeding since she is the
legally married wife of the petitioner-husband and there was no
dispute on record in this regard.
22.
It is also on record that after desertion from the
matrimonial home the OP-wife is presently staying in the
residence of her brother at Mohanpur, West Tripura. There is
also no evidence on record that the OP-wife is earning any
income for her livelihood rather it appears that she is depending
upon the income of her elder brother and passing days in
hardships in the residence of her brother as such she is legally
entitled to get maintenance from her husband i.e. the petitioner
of this proceeding. There is also no evidence on record that the
petitioner-husband is a salaried person and furthermore, no
income certificate of the petitioner-husband is proved or
produced by the OP-wife before the Learned Court below. From
the record of the Learned Court below, it appears that the OPwife exactly could not say the actual profession of the
petitioner-husband i.e. the OP of the original proceeding. Just
the wife and her witnesses asserted that his monthly income
from auto-rickshaw, rubber plantation, fishery is Rs.50,000/-
but no documentary evidence is proved by the OP-wife in the
proceeding before the Learned Court below. At the same time
also, the petitioner-husband failed to discard that part of
evidence of the OP-wife before the Learned Court below but in
his affidavit submitted at the time of filling objection, he has
mentioned that he is a day labourer by profession/occupation
and is aged about 40 years.
Since there is no evidence on record that the
petitioner-husband was/is suffering from any illness and it was
also on record that probably he was staying with his mother
and considering the status of the petitioner-husband, it appears
that as a day labourer/cultivator or auto-driver, he used to earn
not less than Rs.20,000/- per month and it appears to this
Court that Learned Court below at the time of determination of
compensation in para 27 of the judgment wrongly assessed his
monthly income Rs.30,000/- to Rs.40,000/- per month which
needs to be modified.
23.
So, after going through the record of the Learned
Court below and considering all the circumstances, it appears
that the monthly income of the petitioner-husband as OP in the
original proceeding should not be less than Rs.20,000/- per
month, if he either earns his monthly income as a day
labourer/auto driver or as a cultivator, etc. So, taking into
consideration all aspects, his monthly income is determined not
less than Rs.20,000/- per month and considering the present
status and position of the OP-wife in my considered view, it
would be prudent if the OP-wife is awarded maintenance
allowance at the rate of Rs.7,000/- per month from the date of
petition/application i.e. from the month of March,2021 onwards.
24.
In the result, the revision petition filed by the
petitioner-husband is hereby partly allowed with modification
that the petitioner-husband shall pay maintenance allowance at
the rate of Rs.7,000/- per month from the month of March,
2021 onwards. The arrear maintenance allowance from the
month of March, 2021 upto the month of May, 2023 is
accumulated to Rs.1,89,000/- (Rs.7,000/- X 27 months) which
shall be paid by the petitioner-husband to his wife i.e. the
petitioner-wife of the original proceeding. The petitionerhusband is directed to pay the arrear amount of Rs.1,89,000/(One Lakh Eighty-nine thousand only) either wholly at one time
or partly by way of 54 numbers of equal monthly installments
as ordered by the Learned Court below at the rate of Rs.3,500/per month in favour of the OP-wife with effect from the month
of June,2023 onwards as ordered by Learned Trial Court below,
in addition to his normal maintenance allowance of Rs.7,000/per month by crediting the same in her bank account (OP wife)
no.8042012056517, IFSC code No.UTBIORRBTGB (maintained
at Tripura Gramin Bank, Mohanpur Sidhai Branch) deducting
the amount, if already paid, with a further direction to pay the
amount within first week of every succeeding month in which
the monthly maintenance allowance shall become due to the
OP-wife.
25.
With this observation, this revision petition is
disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of. Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment and
order. A copy of this judgment and order also be supplied free
of cost to the Learned Counsel of the parties for information and
compliance.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
Date: 2024.02.13 15:17:52 -08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review