Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
Crl. A(J) No. 25 of 2024
Sri Harpal Singh (53 years), son of late Sukdev Singh, resident of 117/30
Gali No.1, Mayur Vihar, Gohana Road, Sonipat, P.S. Sonipat, District:
Sonipat, Haryana.
…..Appellant
-V E R S U SThe State of Tripura
….. Respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
22.07.2025
:
:
29.07.2025
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
[1]
Heard Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
also heard Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the respondent-State.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-374(2) of Cr. P.C. against
the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 16.01.2024 passed
by the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Khowai Tripura, Khowai in
connection with Case No. Special (NDPS) 37 of 2022 whereby and
whereunder, the appellant has been convicted under Section-20(b)(ii) (C) of
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 [for short, NDPS)
and thereby, sentenced him to suffer RI for a period of 14 years and to pay a
fine of Rs.1,00,000/- in default to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
another 06 months.
[3]
The Prosecution case in brief is that on 06.04.2022 at around
10:45 hours St Rathindra Debbarma (the complainant) along with P.S Staffs
including constable Bimal Debnath, SPO Parimal Debnath, SPO Amrit
Debbarma and SPO Madhuram Reang were performing vehicle checking
duty at 41 miles Naka Point. At that time while they were performing the
said duty the complainant along with his staff intercepted one 12 (Wheeler)
vehicle bearing No. HR 69C 1323 which was hailing towards Ambassa. The
complainant along with staffs checked the vehicle and found some brown
color packets concealed in a hidden chamber built in the driver's cabin of the
Truck. The complainant suspected those packets full of dry ganja and
accordingly he informed the matter to O.C Mungiakami P.S and requested
him to come to the spot to take necessary action. Thereafter O.C P.S along
with the staffs rushed to the spot and after few moments SDPO Teliamura
also reached at the spot. In the presence of SDPO Teliamura and available
police constables and SPO Staffs the complainant checked the vehicles
thoroughly and recovered total 102 brown color packets of dry ganja weight
about 456 kg from a hidden chamber in the driver's cabin of the said vehicle.
[4]
Complainant seized those recovered 456 kgs of suspected dry
ganja along with the offending Truck two key pad mobiles and some
documents by preparing seizure list in presence of SDPO Teliamura and
available witnesses from the possession of accused persons namely Naveen
who was the driver and also from one Harpal Singh who was the assistant of
the said Truck as they violated the provisions of the NDPS Act and
thereafter, the seized contraband along with the vehicle, mobile phones and
other seized documents were handed over to the O.C P.S along with the two
detained persons and a suo-moto complaint was lodged by the complainant
before O.C Mungiakami P.S. After completion of investigation charge was
framed and Prosecution adduced their respective evidences, Accused was
examined under Section 313 Cr. PC. After hearing the parties and on the
basis of written evidences and documents on record the Ld Trial Court
convicted the appellant 20 (b) (ii) (C) of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 (in short NDPS) and thereby sentenced him to suffer
Rigorous imprisonment for a period of 14 years and to pay fine of Rs.
1,00,000/-(Rupees of One Lakh) in default to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for another 06 months.
[5]
Based on the information and the suo moto complaint of SI
Rathindra Debbarma, O.C Mungiakami P.S, registered a case bearing
No.2022/MGK/012 under Section-20 (b) (ii) (C)/25/29 of the NDPS Act,
1985 and endorsed the case to SI Ranjit Das for investigation.
[6]
During the course of investigation, I.O forwarded the
documents with a prayer to the learned Special Judge, NDPS, Khowai to
pass necessary order for pre-trial disposal of 456 kgs of ganja in 102
numbers of packets in connection with the present case in presence of Drug
Disposal Committee Agartala. I.O in the course of investigation, recorded
the statement of the complainant under Section-161 of Cr.P.C arrested both
the accused persons Naveen and Harpal Singh, visited the P.O and prepared
the hand-sketch map of the P.O along with the index of the hand-sketch
map. I.O also recorded the statement of the other witnesses and the sent the
sample SFSL Narshingarh and collected the same after examination through
SDPO Teliamura.
[7]
In the course of investigation I.O under Section-67 of the
NDPS Act issued notice to the owner of the alleged vehicle and completed
all other formalities. In the course of investigation in the Court, sample was
drawn, I.O along with O.C Mungiakami P.S was present and has withdrawal
the seized contraband from the NDPS Godown. The list of sample was
drawn from the seized material on 12.04.2022 in connection with this case
which is prepared by the I.O and the sample was drawn on 12.04.2022 in the
court with his signature and the signature of J.M 1st Class, Khowai. I.O has
also given a prayer to produce the deposited NDPS Articles for the purpose
of drawing sample. The deposited NDPS articles were produced as per the
order of the court and after drawing the sample I.O had also given a prayer
for keeping the remaining stock of NDPS articles in the safe custody. After
completion of the investigation I.O has submitted charge-sheet vide C.S No.
34 dated 31.07.2022 under Section-20 (b) (ii) (C)/25/29 of NDPS Act,
against the accused persons namely Naveen and Harpal Singh.
[8]
When the accused person entered his appearance in Court after
due compliance of Section-207 of Cr.P.C, and after hearing the learned
counsel appearing for the both sides and after perusing the material on
record charge was framed against the accused person under Section-20 (b)
(ii) (C) and under Section-25 of the NDPS Act read with Section-29 of
NDPS Act. When the contents of the charge was read over and explained to
the accused person in Hindi, he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
[9]
During the course of trial, the prosecution in order to bring
home the guilt of the accused persons examined as many as 12 (twelve)
witnesses and exhibited some material documents before the Court. On the
closure of the prosecution evidence the accused person was examined under
Section-313 of Cr.P.C and he denied the prosecution case and also declined
to adduce any defence evidence on his behalf.
[10]
Having heard both the parties and on perusal of the material
evidence on record, the learned Court below has observed as under:
“The punishment prescribed for the commission of the offence under Section
20 (b) (ii) (C ) of NDPS Act extends to rigorous imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than 10 years but which may extend to 20 years and
shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than Rs. 1,00,000/(Rupees
OneLakh) and which may extend to Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakhs).
Punishment for Section 25 of the NDPS Act and Section29 of the NDPS Act
shall be the punishment provided for that offence.
Accordingly, accused person namely Harpal Singh is convicted and sentenced
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 14 (fourteen) years and fine
of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh) in default to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for another 06 (six months), so as to send a clear message to the
society to deter other likeminded criminals to commit such crime in future.
All the sentences shall run concurrently.
The period of detention, if any, already undergone by the accused person
during the course of investigation, inquiry or trial shall be set off against the
term of imprisonment as provided under section 428 of Cr.P.C. The convict
namely Harpal Singh is already in custody and he is taken in custody.
Let the copy of the Judgment be furnished to the convict free of cost as
provided in Section 363 of Cr.P.C.
The convict Harpal Singh have been informed about his right of appeal to the
Higher Court against the judgment of conviction and sentence if he so desire,
either through his engaged Counsel or through Superintendent, Khowai SubJail.
Let a copy of the Judgment be forwarded to Ld. District Magistrate ,Khowai
as provided in Section 365 of Cr.P.C.
Destroy the seized materials in due course of law and after the expiry of the
appeal period if not destroyed already.
The case is disposed of on contest partly in connection with the convict
Harpal Singh.
Make necessary entry in the T.R”
[11]
The appellant herein, being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with
the same, has preferred this appeal before this Court for ends of justice.
[12]
Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the learned Court below held the convict appellant to be
guilty of alleged offences on the basis of no evidence in as much as the
evidence on record does not constitute the alleged offence and in no case
implicated the convict appellant in the commission of alleged offence. It has
been further contended that SI Mr Rathindra Debbarma along with some PS
Staff and SDPO were performing vehicle checking duty at 41 miles Naga
point they intercepted one 12 wheeler vehicle bearing No. HR-69-C-1323
which is a goods carrying truck and the said vehicle was proceeding towards
Ambassa. The police checked the vehicle and found some brown colour
packets that is 456 kg of suspected dry Ganja concealed in a hidden chamber
build in the driver's cabin of the said vehicle and seized those contravene but
none of the independent witness were cited as seizure witness except the
police personals, so the seizure is suspected because law mandates that
impartial inhabitant of that area are required to cite as witness for fair ends
of justice but the learned Court below failed to appreciate the same.
[13]
According to prosecution, SDPO Teliamura was requested to
come to the spot and accordingly he came there and thereafter seizure was
made which is absolutely clear violation of Section-43 of the NDPS Act.
The learned Court below has failed to appreciate that Sections-42, 50, &
52A are clearly violated during investigation and as such the prosecution
case is doubtful and the appellant is liable to be acquitted. According to the
prosecution, appellant is a co-driver of the said vehicle however he is not a
co-driver of said vehicle rather he is an assistant of the driver of the said
vehicle and the driver of the vehicle was absconded. Though not admitting
but assuming that some contrabands are recovered from the vehicle, then
also the assistant of the vehicle cannot be held responsible for that and there
is also no direct evidence against the present appellant regarding his
involvement.
[14]
No impartial person came forward to lodge complaint against
the appellant the police lodged the suo-moto complaint developing the story
and also covering the ingredients of the NDPS Law, so the concocted FIR is
not credible at all. From the possession of appellant no contraband articles
were recovered and the appellant has no knowledge regarding the secret
chamber in the driver‟s cabin. During the course of trial prosecution
examine as many as 12 witnesses, out of which almost all the witnesses are
official staff and naturally as per the direction of the IO and SDPO they tried
to establish the case against the appellant and the entire case is false and
concocted and the appellant became a victim of circumstances.
[15]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has averred that PW-9 stated in his
deposition that inside the packets found some cut pieces of brown colored
pieces plant materials with fruiting/flowering tubs/ seeds but not segregated
the plant/leaf and the fruiting flowering tubs and seeds, so it is really
difficult to find out actual ganja in the seized packets which is most
important to find out the quantity as to how much the commercial, and non
commercial. It is most important to mention here that the leaves and body of
the ganja tree are not at all a ganja only fruit, flower tubs and seeds are
treated as a ganja. So police failed to ascertain the actual quantity of real
ganja but the learned Court below failed to appreciate the same.
[16]
There are no ingredients of Section-20 (b), (ii), (c) of NDPS
Act read with Sections-25 & 29 of the NDPS Act against the appellant. The
learned Court failed below to appreciate that no independent witnesses were
examined by the prosecution to establish the case. Prosecution is totally
failed to establish the case against the appellant and the appellant is liable to
be acquitted.
[17]
Mr. Datta, in support of his case has placed some reliance on
some judgments of the Hon‟ble Apex Court i.e. in Mangilal v. State of
Madhya Pradesh, reported in (2023) 19 SCC 364, Mohammed Khalid and
Another v. State of Telengana, reported in (2024) 5 SCC 393 and in
Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab, reported in AIR 2018 sc 3853.
[18]
In Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab, reported in AIR 2018 SC
3853, the Hon‟ble Apex Court has held thus:
“10. Unlike the general principle of criminal jurisprudence that an accused is
presumed innocent unless proved guilty, the NDPS Act carries a reverse
burden of proof under Sections 35 and 54. But that cannot be understood
to mean that the moment an allegation is made and the F.I.R. recites
compliance with statutory procedures leading to recovery, the burden
of proof from the very inception of the prosecution shifts to the
accused, without the prosecution having to establish or prove anything
more. The presumption is rebuttable. Section 35 (2) provides that a
fact can be said to have been proved if it is established beyond
reasonable doubt and not on preponderance of probability. The
stringent provisions of the NDPS Act, such as Section 37, the minimum
sentence of ten years, absence of any provision for remission, do not
dispense with the requirement of the prosecution to establish a
prima facie case beyond reasonable doubt after investigation, only after
which the burden of proof shall shift to the accused. The case of the
prosecution cannot be allowed to rest on a preponderance of
probabilities.
11. A fair trial to an accused, a constitutional guarantee under Article
21 of the Constitution, would be a hollow promise if the investigation
in a NDPS case were not to be fair or raises serious questions about its
fairness apparent on the face of the investigation. In the nature of the reverse
burden of proof, the onus will lie on the prosecution to
demonstrate on the face of it that the investigation was fair, judicious with
no circumstances that may raise doubts about its veracity.
The
obligation of proof beyond reasonable doubt will take within its
ambit a fair investigation, in absence of which there can be no fair trial. If
the investigation itself is unfair, to require the accused to demonstrate
prejudice will be fraught with danger vesting arbitrary powers in the
police which may well lead to false implication also. Investigation in such
a case would then become an empty formality and a farce. Such an
interpretation therefore naturally has to be avoided.”
[19]
In Mangilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, reported in (2023) 19
SCC 364, the Hon‟ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“15. On the issue of disposing narcotic substance in derogation of the
compliance contained in Section 52A of the NDPS Act, this Court in Union of
India v. Jarooparam, (2018) 4 SCC 334 has held as follows:
“8. What transpires from the abovequoted paragraph is that after taking out
two samples of 30 gm each, the Executive Magistrate returned the entire
remaining seized property to the investigating officer PW 6. To further
ascertain the same, we have also carefully perused the exact content of the
proceedings dated 14-10-2004 (Annexure P-5) recorded by the Executive
Magistrate, Singoli Tappa. The proceedings recorded as far as the respondent
herein is concerned, read thus:
Proceedings
14-10-2004: Case submitted. Shri Harvinder Singh, Inspector (Investigating
Officer), Narcotics Bureau, Singoli has submitted three sealed packets of
seized stuff in Crime No. 1 of 2004 under Sections 8/18 and 8/29 of the
NDPS Act, 1985. These packets were marked A, B and C and the details are
given as under:
1-A: On the packet marked “A” it was indicated that packet contains 7.200 kg
opium seized from Jaroopram, s/o Ganga Ram Bishnoi. On opening the
packet, transparent polythene bag was found, in which again two polythene
packets were found. One polythene indicated 4.000 kg and the second one
3.200 kg opium, respectively. A composite sample of 30-30 gm each have
been taken from the two packets and kept in a small plastic polythene and
marked A-3 and A-4 and sealed. The remaining seized stuff and samples
sealed as usual are handed over to the presenting officer Shri Harvinder
Singh, Inspector.
9. From the above proceedings, it is crystal clear that the remaining seized
stuff was not disposed of by the Executive Magistrate. The contraband stuff as
also the samples sealed as usual were handed over physically to the
Investigating Officer Harvinder Singh (PW 6). Also the trial court in its
judgment specifically passed instructions to preserve the seized property and
record of the case in safe custody, as the co-accused Bhanwarlal was
absconding. The trial court more specifically instructed to put a note with red
ink on the front page of the record for its safe custody. In such a situation, it
assumes importance that there was nothing on record to show as to what
happened to the remaining bulk quantity of contraband. The absence of proper
explanation from the prosecution significantly undermines its case and
reduces the evidentiary value of the statements made by the witnesses.
10. Omission on the part of the prosecution to produce the bulk quantity of
seized opium would create a doubt in the mind of the Court on the
genuineness of the samples drawn and marked as A, B, C, D, E, F from the
allegedly seized contraband. However, the simple argument that the same had
been destroyed, cannot be accepted as it is not clear that on what authority it
was done. Law requires that such an authority must flow from an order passed
by the Magistrate. On a bare perusal of the record, it is apparent that at no
point of time any prayer had been made by the prosecution for destruction of
the said opium or disposal thereof otherwise. The only course of action the
prosecution should have resorted to is for its disposal is to obtain an order
from the competent court of Magistrate as envisaged under Section 52-A of
the Act. It is explicitly made under the Act that as and when such an
application is made, the Magistrate may, as soon as may be, allow the
application (see also Noor Aga v. State of Punjab, (2008) 16 SCC 417 :
(2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 748).
11. There is no denial of the fact that the prosecution has not filed any such
application for disposal/destruction of the allegedly seized bulk quantity of
contraband material nor was any such order passed by the Magistrate. Even
no notice has been given to the accused before such alleged
destruction/disposal. It is also pertinent here to mention that the trial court
appears to have believed the prosecution story in a haste and awarded
conviction to the respondent without warranting the production of bulk
quantity of contraband. But, the High Court committed no error in dealing
with this aspect of the case and disbelieving the prosecution story by arriving
at the conclusion that at the trial, the bulk quantities of contraband were not
exhibited to the witnesses at the time of adducing evidence.
[20]
In Mohammed Khalid and Another v. State of Telengana,
reported in (2024) 5 SCC 393, the Hon‟ble Apex Court has observed as
under:
“*****
12.1. (i) That the independent panch witnesses associated with the search and
seizure were not examined in evidence and hence the entire search and seizure
proceedings become doubtful and are vitiated;
12.3. That the prosecution failed to ensure compliance of the requirements
of Section 52A of the NDPS Act inasmuch as, no sampling procedure was
undertaken before the Magistrate;
12.8. No document pertaining to deposit of the samples at the Police Station
and the transmission thereof to the FSL was exhibited on record. The samples
were forwarded to the FSL after a gross delay of more than two months and
hence, the FSL report cannot be read in evidence because the required link
evidence is missing.
17.5. PW-5 “Originally three bundles of ganja was seized from the accused
and as the Ganja was becoming dry and turning into dust, and due to the holes
of the bags it is coming out, and therefore we transferred the Ganja into 7 new
bags, which was already marked as M.O.1.” “Three samples of Ganja have
been taken by LW 10 and handed over the samples to me. We have forwarded
the three samples to FSL through A.C.P., and submitted FSL report Ex. P.11.”
“The samples were taken on 8.5.2009 and they were forwarded to FSL on
7.7.2009 i.e. after two months of taking of samples. The samples were not
deposited in the court.” “I did not file any document to show that where the
property was kept in Maalkhana. I did not produce any Maalkhana register in
this case. The property was sent to FSL after two months of its seizure. The
FSL report, does not disclose about the panch chits and seals and quantity of
samples. The property deposited in court is not having any official seals.” “I
did not report to the court till today that the ganja was getting dried up and
becoming dust, I converted them from three bundles to 7 bags for safe
custody.
24. The FSL report (Exhibit P-11) does not disclose about the panch chits and
seals and signature of the accused on samples. The property deposited in the
Court(muddamal) was not having any official seals. The witness also admitted
that he did not take any permission from the Court for changing the original
three packets of muddamal ganja to seven new bags for safe keeping.
23. Contrary to the evidence of PW-1, PW-5 stated that three samples of ganja
were taken out by Sub-Inspector LW- 10 and were handed over to the witness
who forwarded the same to the ACP for sending it to FSL. In crossexamination, the witness admitted that he did not file any document to show
that the property was kept in malkhana. The malkhana register was not
produced in the Court.
[21]
Stating thus, learned Sr. counsel submits that the prosecution
has not been able to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt and urged this
Court to allow this appeal and set aside the impugned Judgment and Order
of conviction.
[22]
On the contrary Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the
respondent-State has submitted that the accused person is indulged in
possession and transportation of commercial quantity of contraband items
and such act is nothing but corroding the society specially the young
generations so no leniency or mercy should be shown to the accused person
and considering the severity of the crime sufficient punishment should be
inflicted upon the accused person. In support of his case, he has placed his
reliance on some recent judgments of the Hon‟ble Apex Court as well as this
Court i.e. in Bharat Ambale v. State of Chattisgarh, reported in 2025 SCC
online SC 110, in Rizwan Khan v. State of Chhattisgarh, reported in
(2020) 9 SCC 627, in Kallu Khan v. State of Rajasthan, reported in (2021)
19 SCC 197 and in Shri Karanjit Das v. The State of Tripura in Crl. A(J)
No.29 of 2023.
[23]
In Bharat Ambale v. State of Chattisgarh, reported in 2025
SCC online SC 110, the Hob‟ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“33.Even in cases where there is non-compliance with the procedural
requirements of Section 52A, it does not necessarily vitiate the trial or warrant
an automatic acquittal. Courts have consistently held that procedural lapses
must be viewed in the context of the overall evidence. If the prosecution can
otherwise establish the chain of custody, corroborate the seizure with credible
testimony, and prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, the mere noncompliance with Section 52A may not be fatal. The emphasis must be on
substantive justice rather than procedural technicalities, and keeping in mind
that the salutary objective of the NDPS Act is to curb the menace of drug
trafficking.
50.We summarize our final conclusion as under: (I) Although Section 52A is primarily for the disposal and destruction of
seized contraband in a safe manner yet it extends beyond the immediate
context of drug disposal, as it serves a broader purpose of also introducing
procedural safeguards in the treatment of narcotics substance after seizure
inasmuch as it provides for the preparation of inventories, taking of
photographs of the seized substances and drawing samples therefrom in the
presence and with the certification of a magistrate. Mere drawing of samples
in presence of a gazetted officer would not constitute sufficient compliance of
the mandate under Section 52A sub-section (2) of the NDPS Act.
(II) Although, there is no mandate that the drawing of samples from the seized
substance must take place at the time of seizure as held in Mohanlal (supra),
yet we are of the opinion that the process of inventorying, photographing and
drawing samples of the seized substance shall as far as possible, take place in
the presence of the accused, though the same may not be done at the very spot
of seizure.
(III) Any inventory, photographs or samples of seized substance prepared in
substantial compliance of the procedure prescribed under Section 52A of the
NDPS Act and the Rules / Standing Order(s) thereunder would have to be
mandatorily treated as primary evidence as per Section 52A sub-section (4) of
the NDPS Act, irrespective of whether the substance in original is actually
produced before the court or not. (IV) The procedure prescribed by the
Standing Order(s) / Rules in terms of Section 52A of the NDPS Act is only
intended to guide the officers and to see that a fair procedure is adopted by the
officer in-charge of the investigation, and as such what is required is
substantial compliance of the procedure laid therein.
(V) Mere non-compliance of the procedure under Section 52A or the Standing
Order(s) / Rules thereunder will not be fatal to the trial unless there are
discrepancies in the physical evidence rendering the prosecution‟s case
doubtful, which may not have been there had such compliance been done.
Courts should take a holistic and cumulative view of the discrepancies that
may exist in the evidence adduced by the prosecution and appreciate the same
more carefully keeping in mind the procedural lapses.
(VI) If the other material on record adduced by the prosecution, oral or
documentary inspires confidence and satisfies the court as regards the
recovery as-well as conscious possession of the contraband from the accused
persons, then even in such cases, the courts can without hesitation proceed to
hold the accused guilty notwithstanding any procedural defect in terms
of Section 52A of the NDPS Act. (VII) Non-compliance or delayed
compliance of the said provision or rules thereunder may lead the court to
drawing an adverse inference against the prosecution, however no hard and
fast rule can be laid down as to when such inference may be drawn, and it
would all depend on the peculiar facts and circumstances of each case.
(VIII) Where there has been lapse on the part of the police in either following
the procedure laid down in Section 52A of the NDPS Act or the prosecution
in proving the same, it will not be appropriate for the court to resort to the
statutory presumption of commission of an offence from the possession of
illicit material under Section 54 of the NDPS Act, unless the court is
otherwise satisfied as regards the seizure or recovery of such material from
the accused persons from the other material on record.
(IX) The initial burden will lie on the accused to first lay the foundational
facts to show that there was non-compliance of Section 52A, either by leading
evidence of its own or by relying upon the evidence of the prosecution, and
the standard required would only be preponderance of probabilities.
(X) Once the foundational facts laid indicate non-compliance of Section
52A of the NDPS Act, the onus would thereafter be on the prosecution to
prove by cogent evidence that either (i) there was substantial compliance with
the mandate of Section 52A of the NDPS Act OR (ii) satisfy the court that
such non-compliance does not affect its case against the accused, and the
standard of proof required would be beyond a reasonable doubt.”
[24]
In Rizwan Khan v. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2020) 9
SCC 627, the Hob‟ble Apex Court has observed ad-infra:
“12. It is settled law that the testimony of the official witnesses cannot be
rejected on the ground of non-corroboration by independent witness. As
observed and held by this Court in catena of decisions, examination of
independent witnesses is not an indispensable requirement and such nonexamination is not necessarily fatal to the prosecution case, [see Pardeep
Kumar].
[25]
In Kallu Khan v. State of Rajastha, reported in (2021) 19 SCC
197, wherein, the Hob‟ble Apex Court observed as under:
“14. At this state, the argument advanced by the appellant regarding nonproduction of contraband in the court due to which benefit of doubt ought to
be given to accused, is required to be adverted to. In the case of State of
Rajasthan vs. Sahi Ram (2019) 10 SCC 649, this Court held that when the
seizure of material is proved on record and is not even disputed, the entire
contraband material need not be placed on record. It is not a case in which the
appellant has proved beyond reasonable doubt that while sending the samples
for forensic tests, seals were not intact or the procedure has been materially
not followed by protecting the seized substance or was not stored properly, as
specified in the case of Mohan Lal (supra) in which case the directions were
given to be followed on administrative side. However, in the facts of the
case, the said judgment is not of any help to appellant.
15. Similarly, in the case of Than Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020) 5 SCC
260, this Court observed that if seizure is otherwise proved and the samples
taken from and out of contraband material were kept intact; the report of
forensic expert shows potency, nature and quality of contraband material,
essential ingredients constituting offence are made out and the nonproduction
of contraband in the Court is not fatal. As discussed above, the appellant has
failed to show that findings recorded by two Courts suffer from any perversity
or illegality on the said issue and warrant interference.”
[26]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and the observations made by the learned Court
below, for a definite conclusion, let us revisit the material evidence once
again. It reveals on scrutiny of the evidence of the witnesses that the defence
case is nothing but the denial of the entire prosecution evidence. No strong
and credible specific case could be made out on behalf of the defence to
rebut the prosecution case. Some omissions and exaggerations are found in
the evidence of the witnesses but such omissions and exaggerations also
failed to shake the credibility of the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
and these omissions and inconsistencies are also not material and are
incidental. We cannot become oblivious of the fact that capacity of a person
to observe a fact and retain the same in his memory and reproduce the same
differs from another. In the process of reproducing the facts from memory
there may be some incidental variations which do not go to the root of the
main fact.
[27]
During argument learned counsel argued that P.W-1 and P.W-2
has stated the number of the vehicle wrongly and P.W-1 could identify only
one accused. It has been further argued that P.W-2 and P.W-3 has not stated
anything about the seizure and about the accused persons. P.W-4 has not
stated about who gave the packet that he handed over to the SFSL
Narsingarh and who has sent him for deposit the packets to SFSL
Narshingarh. According to learned counsel P.W-5 has not stated anything in
the examination-inchief in Misc case connection the ganja was received and
I.O has not recorded his statement under Section-161 of Cr.P.C. P.W-6 has
not stated about the number of the vehicle and he has deposed that the
articles were seized on the following day. According to learned counsel no
independent witnesses were cited in this case. It has been contended that
P.W-7 was not examined under Section-161 of Cr.P.C and this witness has
not stated who lodged the complaint and according to him there is noncompliance of Section-57 of the NDPS Act. Learned Counsel further
submitted during argument that P.W-8 has not stated who lodged the suomoto complaint and the witness has not stated anything regarding the drawal
of sample. The witnesses were examined at different dates so there is defect
in the investigation and thus the accused is liable to be acquitted.
[28]
Refuting the submission of learned counsel appearing for the
appellant, the learned P.P. has submitted during argument that the accused
person is hailing from outside the State of Tripura and there is no previous
enmity between the police personnel and the accused person. According to
learned P.P NDPS Act is a special Act and the police investigation is not
similar with other investigation as done in IPC and other crimes. In NDPS
Case Special Procedure is followed in connection with the investigation and
there is technicality in such cases and special mandate is to be followed as
given in the Act. According to him the present case is not related to any
murder or other crimes under IPC, and hence it is not necessary to record the
statement of the witnesses under Section-161 of Cr.P.C in a single date. The
provisions of Sections-57, 52A are fully complied with and in this case
provisions of Section-43 is applicable so considering the whole aspect
according to learned P.P., the prosecution is successful in proving the case
against the accused person and is liable to be convicted.
[29]
On the point of compliance of Section-42 of the NDPS Act,
learned P.P. submits that the same is not required in the context of the case
because police did not receive any prior information about the contraband
item but the same was found during checking. On non-compliance of
Section-57 of the NDPS Act, the learned PP relied upon para-9 of Gurbax
Singh v. State of Haryana wherein, it is stated that “It is true that provisions
of Sections-52 and 57 were directory. Violation of these provisions would
not ipso facto violate the trial or conviction.” Learned P.P. has further
submitted that the appellant was arrested by the I.O., the detailed report was
submitted by the I.O. and inventory was also prepared by the I.O. Some
minor wrongs are there in the proceeding but the same is not fatal.
[30]
On the point of inventory not being prepared at the spot,
learned P.P. submitted that though there is some procedural fault, the same
was prepared by the I.O. certified by the Magistrate and sent to SFSL with
seal and cover. As such, there is no chance of manipulation. Further, the
SFSL certified that the seized items were contraband items i.e. ganja not
other things.
[31]
It is admitted position that the appellant herein was the co-
driver of the vehicle from which the contraband items were seized. All the
witnesses who made search, seizure, and arrest have unequivocally stated
that the accused-appellant herein was the co-driver of the vehicle at the time
of the search and contraband items were seized from the vehicle which was
in possession of the accused-appellant. On the point of non-compliance of
Sections-52 and 57 of the Act, this Court considering the principle given by
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court is convinced with the submission of learned P.P.
It is evident that the samples were drawn in the presence of the Magistrate
and sent to the SFSL and as per the report, the samples were positive for the
presence of 'Ganja‟. This Court aligns with the submission of the learned
P.P., that though there is some minor procedural fault, but, the same is not
fatal and prosecution has been able to prove that the accused-appellant
herein was found in conscious possession of 456 kgs of dry „Ganja‟ in 102
numbers of packets which he was transporting in the said vehicle.
[32]
Further, this Court is of the opinion that as the packets
containing contraband items were multiple and the same could have been
hidden in multiple locations inside the vehicle, it explains the minor
discrepancy among the deposition of the witnesses on the location of the
contraband item inside the vehicle. However, the depositions of the
witnesses are unequivocally clear that the said contraband items were found
inside the crime vehicle. Furthermore, the Judgments as cited by the learned
P.P. support and strengthen the case of the prosecution. In the light of the
above discussion and evidence, this Court is of the opinion that the
Judgments as cited by the learned counsel appearing for the convictappellant are not relevant to the facts of this case.
[33]
Even without any prior information, the police put routine
Nakabandi near forest barrier when narcotic product was recovered from the
accused in a vehicle on transit in a public place. Hence, such a case would
be covered under Section-43 and not under Section-42. The present case is
based almost on the same fact as it is evident from the evidence of P.W-1 SI
Rathindra Debbarma. In this case as per evidence of P.W-1, it is found that
on 06.04.2022 when SI Rathindra Debbarma along with other police
personnel at about 10:45 hours were on vehicle checking duty at 41 miles
Naka Point on the National Highway they intercepted one twelve wheeled
vehicle though this witness as deposed the number of the vehicle wrongly.
On Checking the vehicle in presence of SDPO and O.C Teliamura P.S they
recovered 102 packets of dry ganja weighing 456 kgs. The driver and the
co-driver of the vehicle was detained and in the presence of the witnesses
P.W-1 seized the vehicle by preparing a seizure list which is marked as
Exbt. 1 and Exbt.1/1. Thereafter, he went to the P.S from the spot along with
the seized vehicle and contraband and handed over both the accused persons
before O.C P.S and lodged a suo-moto complaint.
[34]
It is clear from the deposition of P.W-1, P.W-2, P.W-3, P.W-6,
P.W7 and P.W-8 that when the police were performing vehicle checking
duty they intercepted the alleged vehicle and from the vehicle 102 numbers
of packets of ganja weighing 456 kgs was recovered. The police personnel
were on vehicle checking duty and there was no prior information to them
about the transportation of contraband items through the alleged vehicle,
thus this can only be described as a recovery by chance, since they were
neither looking for drugs nor expecting to find drugs carried by anybody. It
is a pure case of chance recovery and it was not necessary for the police
officers to comply with the provisions of Section-50 of the Act. The version
P.W-1, P.W-2, P.W-3, P.W-6 and P.W-7 P.W-8 corroborates the entire
scenario of search and seizure which was carried in presence of P.W-7
Sonacharan Jamatia and P.W-8 Sri. Goutam Debbarma who are SDPO of
Teliamura P.S and O.C Mungiakami P.S. SDPO is a Gazetted officer and
the entire search and seizure was made in his presence.
[35]
Going through the depositions of P.W-1 P.W-2, P.W-3 P.W-
6,P.W-7 and P.W-8 it is very much clear that P.W-1 on detaining the vehicle
and finding the contraband items along with both the driver and the codriver Naveen and Harpal Singh immediately informed the matter to P.W-10
Sri.Goutam Debbarma of O.C Mungiakami P.S who informed the matter to
P.W-7 Sri.Sonacharan Jamatia SDPO Teliamura and both of them rushed to
the spot and their presence 102numbers of packets of ganja weighing 456
kgs was recovered by breaking the secret chamber of the driver‟s cabin of
the vehicle bearing No. HR 69C 1323 (Twelve Wheeler Goods carrying
Truck). From the version of the prosecution witnesses along with the seized
contraband and the vehicle, the vehicular documents, including driving
license AADHAR Card, Registration Certificate and Mobile Phone was
seized from the accused persons namely Naveen and Harpal Singh.
Thereafter a suo-moto complaint was lodged informing the matter to O.C
Mungiakami P.S which has been marked as Exbt.2 and Exbt. 2 /1. The
matter was informed to O.C Mungiakami P.S within the stipulated time
period and on the basis of which O.C Mungiakami P.S registered a case
under Section-20 (b) (ii) (C )/25/29 of NDPS Act. The printed FIR form was
filled up by P.W-8 bearing his signature which is marked as Exbt. 4 (series)
and Exbt.4/1. The version of P.W-1 is corroborated by P.W2, P.W-3, P.W-6
P.W-7 and P.W-8.
[36]
In the present case, P.W-1 has informed over telephone to O.C
Mungiakami P.S who in turn informed the matter to SDPO Teliamura and
both were present at the time of search and seizure. Thus the material of
record shows the presence of superior officer at the time of incident which is
a sufficient compliance of Section 57 of the Act. On going through the
prosecution evidence especially during cross-examination, this Court finds
that only some suggestions and denials were given, but suggestions and
denials in cross-examination are no evidence. This proposition of law is
good both in the case of prosecution and the defence. Mere hurling of some
suggestions which are denied, can hardly take the place of proof or
evidence. The law of evidence is alike both for the prosecution and for the
defence. If the accused wants to establish a certain fact, he has to lead
evidence on that score. Such suspicion cannot have any place in the realm of
appreciation of evidence. Thus, a suggestion denied by witness remains only
a suggestion and has no evidentiary value at all.
[37]
In the present case it is crystal clear that the contraband items
were recovered from the vehicle of which the appellant herein, was the codriver and he has failed to give any satisfactory ground about the availability
of contraband items in the secret alleged vehicle which clearly imports
possession of contraband items on his behalf. In most of the NDPS Cases
the moot question is about conscious possession which is found aptly related
in this case because the accused person has failed to explain regarding his
possession of recovery of contraband items from the Secret chamber of the
driver‟s cabin of the vehicle.
[38]
Having given our anxious consideration to the plea and taken
into consideration the nature and gravity of the offence proved, the Court
must balance the punishment to accuse and to keep in mind the societal
interest as well. The severe crime against society need to be dealt with
severely irrespective of age, the socio-economic status, religion, race, caste
or creed and position of the accused. The protection of interest of the society
and deterring the criminals from committing crime is the avowed object of
law. So, keeping in mind all relevant factors, particularly, the serious
dimension of the case at hand who were found in handling commercial
quantity of drugs, which has the propensity of damaging a future of many
young persons, particularly the students who are vulnerable, this Court is of
considered view that in order to keep the faith of public, in the judiciary
intact, accused person needs to be dealt with sternly commensurate with the
punishment prescribed under the statue.
[39]
Here is the case at hand; we have discussed the evidence on
record of the prosecution in detail. Now we are to conclude our decision on
the basis of material evidence on record. In our ultimate analysis, it is crystal
clear that there is no reason as to why the continuity of the chain of
circumstances and the complaint made against the appellant to be
disbelieved. The witnesses supported the entire case of the prosecution with
regard to the commission of offence by the appellant herein, thus, there is no
necessary for any interference. Consequently, we find no reason to interfere
with the observation made by the learned Court below and thus, the same is
affirmed.
[40]
In the result, the appeal stands dismissed. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Send down
the LCRs forthwith.
B. PALIT, J
A.Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2025.07.31 13:57:42 +05'30'
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review