Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.214 of 2025
1. Sri Haripada Das, Son of Late Banamali Das of Cooperative Para,
Badharghat, P.S. A.D Nagar, P.O. Siddhi Ashram, Agartala, West
Tripura aged about 63 years of age [Ex-Assistant Inspector General of
Police (Welfare) Tripura Police]
2. Sri Ananta Das, son of Late Nandalal Das, Vill:-Birojanagar, P.O. &
P.S.-Kadamtala, North Tripura, PIN: 799261, aged about 58 years,
Presently posted as Assistant Inspector General of Police (Law &
Order), Police Head Quarters, Tripura.
3. Shri Nagendra Debbarma, son of late Kusum Debbarma,
Khakchang Residential Complex, Nandan Nagar, Agartala, P.O.
Bankumari, District: West Tripura, PIN 799006, aged about 62 Years
[Ex-Superintendent of Police, Procurement Unit, Tripura Police]
4. Shri Dilip Roy, Commandant CIAT School, KachuCherra, HQ 3rd
BN TSR Complex, Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura, Aged about 57 Years.
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary to the Government of Tripura, General Administration
(Personnel & Training) Department, having his office at Capital
Complex, Gorkhabasti, P.O.- Kunjaban, P.S.- East Agartala, SubDivision - Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
General Administration Department (Personnel & Training), as well as
the post of Secretary, Government of Tripura, Finance Department,
having his office at Capital Complex, Gorkhabasti, P.O.-Kunjaban,
P.S.- East Agartala, Sub-Division- Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin
- 799006.
3. The Director General of Police, Tripura having his office at
Akhaura Road, P.S. West Agartala, Sub-Division - Sadar, District West Tripura.
4. The Under Secretary, General Administration (Personnel &
Training), Government of Tripura, having his office at Capital Complex,
Gorkhabasti, P.O.- Kunjaban, P.S.- East Agartala, Sub-Division Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin - 799006.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Pannalal Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing
Date of delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
15.09.2025
:
30.10.2025
:
YES
Whether fit for
reporting
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The present writ petition is filed by the petitioners
seeking the following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued for directing the respondents, to transmit the
records, lying with them, for rendering substantive
and conscionable justice to the petitioner(s);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued for mandating/directing the respondents, to
forthwith repeal/rescind or call call back the
impugned order and thereafter create Senior
Selection Grade in Tripura Police Service as per
direction of the Hon'ble Single Judge and provide all
consequential benefit (monetary and physical) with
7% interest, particularly
in
favour
of the
petitioner(s) named in WPC 419 of 2021 with effect
from 15th December, 2021 as per the prevailing
direction of the Hon'ble single judge passed therein;
(iii) Call for the records appertaining to this petition;
(iv) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make
the Rule Absolute in terms of i. to iv. above;
(v) Costs of & incidental to this proceedings;
(vi) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court
may deem fit and proper;”
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Somik Deb assisted
by Learned Counsel, Mr. Pannalal Debbarma appearing on behalf of
the petitioners. Also heard Learned Addl. GA, Mr. Dipankar Sarma
appearing on behalf of the respondents-State.
3.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioners drawn the attention of this Court that initially by
means of filing a writ petition bearing WP(C) No.419 of 2021, the
petitioners who were in the post of TPS, Grade-I prayed for
implementation of the decision of the State Government to identify
at
least
7%
of
the
posts
of
TPS
cadre
or
more
for
creating/upgrading as Senior Selection Grade Post in TPS in the line
of TCS cadre, as reflected in the letter of GA(P&T) Department
dated
30.03.2007
and
to
formulate
appropriate
scheme
for
minimum two avenues of promotion in Tripura Police Service with
appropriate pay scale as per Tripura Civil Service. In the said case,
after hearing both the sides, the Learned Single Judge by judgment
and order dated 14.09.2021 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition)
disposed of the same with the following observation:
“22. Having viewed thus and for the reasons stated above,
this court directs the respondents to complete the process of
implementation of the policy decision of the government
creating the grade, namely, „TPS Senior Selection Grade‟
keeping in view the observations made by this court here-inabove, particularly, in paras 17, 18 and 19, within a period of
3 (three) months from the date when the respondents shall
receive a copy of this order either by the petitioners or from
the learned Additional GA.”
3.1.
Challenging the said judgment and order of the Learned
Single Judge, the State-respondents preferred an appeal before a
Division Bench of this Court which was numbered as WA No.3 of
2022 (Annexure-2 to the writ petition) and the Division Bench after
elaborate hearing of both the sides disposed of the appeal with the
following observation:
“22. We have given anxious hearing on the subject matter. It
appears that the matters in issue are not a new one rather it
is pending since 2007. It is also on record that the TCS
Officers of the State have given the benefit of SSG to their
grade by way of 25th Amendment of Tripura Civil Service
Rules 1967 in the year 2005. From the referred
communications of the Government, it is apparent on record
that the Government in the year 2007, decided to amend the
Tripura Police Service Rules, 1967 to provide the benefit of
SSG to the TPS Officers. But for some unknown reasons the
same benefit could not be extended to the TPS Officers of the
State for which the respondent-petitioners were compelled
to approach to the High Court seeking relief and accordingly,
a direction was given to form a policy. It is the admitted
position that the Court cannot direct the State Government to
frame a policy or to frame/amend any rule for the benefit of
the employees as well as the officers of the Government, but
if it is found that serious prejudice is caused, in that case the
Court cannot remain as a silent spectator. More interestingly,
in pursuance of the judgment and direction of the Hon‟ble
Single Bench, which is presently under challenge before this
Bench, a meeting under the Chair of Chief Secretary of
Tripura was held on 30.10.2021 to discuss and decide the
issue regarding creation of one grade in TPS namely “SSG”.
But in para 3, the Committee referred the observation of
2015 Cadre Review of TPS, PHQ and ultimately came to an
observation that no recommendation may be made to create
any SSG as a promotion post in TCS in line of TCS Cadre. But
the said Committee in para nos.5 and 7 made a different
contradictory findings, from which it appears that the matter
be remanded back to the State Authority to reconsider and to
rethink on the issue for coming to a definite finding
regarding the observation made by the Learned Single
Bench.
23. Learned Advocate General although referred that the
State Cabinet has taken a decision in this regard, but in this
regard nothing is apprised to the Court in detail, so, this
Court at this stage cannot form any decision on the
submission of Learned Advocate General. However, since the
formation of rule is the prerogative of the State Executive,
so, the matter is left to the discretion of the State
Government to take an appropriate decision on the subject
matter in issue.”
Referring the judgment of the Division Bench of this
Court, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the attention of this Court
that by the said judgment, the Division Bench of this Court
remanded back the matter to the State Government to take an
appropriate decision in the light of minutes of the meeting dated
30.10.2021 signed by the Chief Secretary as expeditiously as
possible and to communicate the same to the respondentpetitioners i.e. the present petitioners. But, the State authority
without implementing the direction of the Division Bench of this
Court, by an order dated 09.07.2024 (Annexure-4 infra to the writ
petition) has disposed of the matter with the observation that
“creation of a new grade namely TPS (SSG) in the TPS Rules like
TCS Rules is against the prevailing Government Policy”. Being
aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said order dated 09.07.2024,
the present writ petition is filed by the petitioners seeking the reliefs
as stated above.
3.2.
It was further submitted by Learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioners that for implementation of the judgment dated
08.04.2024 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in WA No.3
of 2022, the present petitioners submitted representation to the
Government but as no action was taken so, the petitioners filed
contempt petition before the Division Bench of this Court which was
numbered as Cont.Cas(C) No.86 of 2024 and by order dated
27.11.2024, the Division Bench of this Court disposed of the
contempt proceeding on the ground of the submissions made by the
State-respondents that the respondents-State in compliance of the
judgment and order dated 08.04.2024 passed in WA No.3 of 2022,
has
passed
the
order
dated
09.07.2024,
which
was
duly
communicated to the petitioners. The relevant paras of the said
order dated 27.11.2024 are reproduced hereunder:
“[4] On the other hand, Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A.
appearing for the respondent-State submits that in
compliance with the order dated 08.04.2024 passed in WA
No.03 of 2022, the concerned respondents decided the case
of the petitioners and an order was accordingly, passed on
9th July, 2024 and thereafter, vide letters dated 15.07.2024
and 23.07.2024, the same was communicated to the
petitioners. He, therefore, urges this Court to close the
present contempt case as the order of this Court has already
been complied with.
[5] In view of the submissions made at the Bar and on
perusal of record, the instant Contempt Petition is closed.
However, it is made clear that the petitioners will be at
liberty to challenge the order dated, 9th July, 2024 if
dissatisfied with the same and it is open for them to take
steps in accordance with law, if so advised.”
3.3.
Referring the judgment and order dated 08.04.2024, it
was further submitted by Learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioners that initially regarding the creation of TPS
Senior Selection Grade, the Under Secretary, GA(P&T) Department,
Government of Tripura had sent one communication to the DGP
Tripura on 30.03.2007. For the sake of convenience, the relevant
communication dated 30.03.2007 is reproduced hereinbelow:
“NO.F.10(5)-GA(P&T)/04
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION ON (PERSONNEL & TRAINING)
DEPARTMENT
________________
Dated, Agartala, the 30th March, 2007
To
The Director General of Police,
Tripura, Agartala.
Subject: Amendment of Tripura Police Service Rules, 1967.
Sir,
I am directed to inform you that it has been
decided by the Government to create a new grade, namely
“Senior Selection Grade” in the Tripura Police Service, almost
in line with that of the T.C.S. The duty posts in the Senior
Selection Grade of Tripura Police Service will be 7% of the
total Cadre strength.
I would, therefore, request you to kindly initiate a
proposal indicating the 7% duty posts in the Senior Selection
Grade proposed to be created in Tripura Police Service.
An immediate response is earnestly requested.
Yours faithfully
(A. Debnath)
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura.”
3.4.
Thereafter, the GA(P&T) Department further made one
communication to the DGP Tripura on 27.09.2008. The extract of
the said communication is also narrated hereinbelow:
“NO.F.10(5)-GA(P&T)/04
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION ON (PERSONNEL & TRAINING)
DEPARTMENT
________________
Dated, Agartala, the 27th September, 2008
To
The Director General of Police,
Tripura, Agartala.
Subject: Amendment of Tripura Police Service Rules, 1967.
Sir,
I am directed to this Department‟s letter of even
number dated 30th March, 2007 (copy enclosed for ready
reference) on the subject cited above and to state it has been
decided by the Government to create a new grade, namely
“Senior Selection Grade” in the Tripura Police Service, almost
in line with that of the Tripura Civil Service. The duty posts in
the Senior Selection Grade of Tripura Police Service will be
7% of the total Cadre strength.
I would, therefore, request you to kindly initiate a
proposal indicating the 7% duty posts in the Senior Selection
Grade proposed to be created in Tripura Police Service.
An immediate response is earnestly requested.
Enclo: As stated
Yours faithfully
(M.L. Das)
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura.”
3.5.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
also
submitted
that
in
compliance of the said communication dated 27.09.2008 the
authorized
officer
on
behalf
of
DGP
Tripura
had
made
a
communication dated 23.10.2008 to the Under Secretary, GA(P&T)
Department,
Government
of
Tripura
proposing
to
create
numbers of posts towards implementation of the policy decision of
the Government considering 7% of the total cadre strength of 262
nos. of TPS Officers. For convenience, the said communication is
reproduced hereunder:
“No.41461/TPS Rules/PHQ.2005
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
TRIPURA:AGARTALA
Dated, Agartala, the 23th Oct‟ 2008
To,
The Under Secretary,
GA(P&T) Department,
Govt. of Tripura,
AGARTALA
Subject: Amendment of Tripura Police Service Rules, 1967.
Sir,
Kindly
refer
to
your
letter
No.
F.10(5)th
GA(P&T)/04, dated 27 September, 2008 on the above noted
subject.
On perusal of our record, it is seen that no such
correspondence is received at this office. However, there was
a proposal from PHQ for creating of Super Selection Grade
posts in Tripura Police Service, (10% of the total Cadre
strength) vide this office No F.P & A/Genl-I/PHQ/05 346-47
dated 3rd January, 2008. (copy enclosed for ready
reference).
The present Cadre strength of Tripura Police
Service Officers 262 and 7% of this comes to a total, 18
posts for Senior Selection Grade. This is matching with the
total Non-IPS Cadre SP/CO, Level posts available in
Police/TSR presently. (Annexure-“A”).
In view of this the decision of the State Govt.
towards creation of Senior Selection grade in Tripura Police
Service against these posts may implemented, similar to
Super Selection grade in Tripura Civil Service with parallel
Pay Scale.
Yours faithfully
Enclo: As stated
(Arindam Nath)
Asstt. Inspr. Genl of Police (HQr)
For Director General of Police Tripura
VACANCY POSITION OF SP/COMDT. LEVEL OFFICERS OF
TRIPURA POLICE AS ON OCTOBER, 2008.
Sl. No.
3.6.
POSTs
SANCTIONED
CADRE
EX-CADRE
POSTED
VACANCY
1.
AIG (Pers)
-
-
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
SP (Security)
SP (Traffic)
CO.CTI
CO.BW HG Bn
CO.SAF
CO. 1st TSR
CO. 2nd TSR
CO. 3rd TSR
CO. 4th TSR
CO. 5th TSR
CO. 6th TSR
CO. 7th TSR
CO. 8th TSR
CO. 9th TSR
CO. 10th TSR
CO. 11th TSR
CO. 12th TSR
-
-
Learned Senior Counsel again referring the judgment
and order dated 08.04.2024 submitted that after a long exercise
and considering the organizational requirement, the DGP Tripura
had proposed to abolish few posts in Grade-I of Tripura Police
Service and also proposed for restructuring the posts to meet up
the requirement of the Department, which were earmarked in
communication dated 20.05.2019 made by the DGP to the
respondents-State of Tripura. It was also submitted that in para
No.5.1 of the said communication dated 20.05.2019 it appears that
30(thirty) new posts of TPS, SSG were proposed to be created.
Furthermore, it was revealed that the duty posts in the SSG,
Tripura Police Service would be 7% of the total cadre strength,
according to the policy decision of the Government which will be
within
the
proposed
30(thirty)
posts.
The
parameters
for
considering eligibility for promotion to the post of TPS, SSG were
drawn at Para No.7 of the communication dated 20.05.2019
wherein it was proposed that the TCS and TPS Officer who complete
five years of service in the TPS, Grade-I would be considered for
promotion to TPS, SSG. It was also argued by Learned Senior
Counsel that a meeting of the Empowered Committee of the State
under the Chairmanship of the then Chief Secretary of Tripura was
held on 04.06.2020, wherein the issues were taken up for
discussion on various points including proposal for amendment of
Tripura Police Service Rules and also the review of pay structure of
Tripura Police Service, Grade-I Officers and it was decided that:
“Decision:- (i) It is decided in the meeting that TPS Senior
Selection Grade may be created observing all rules and
regulations and accordingly necessary posts for this grade
will be identified.
(ii) Since, there is bar in promotion of government
employees due to pending SLP at Hon‟ble Supreme Court
regarding reservation policy, no promotion to the next higher
post can be considered now. However, government
employees may be considered for giving full duty charge to
the higher category posts indicated by pay level in the
respective service.
(iii) xxx”.
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted
that the high power committee of the State Government on
principle decided to create TPS, SSG but no effective step was
taken. Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of this
Court that in the original writ petition i.e. WP(C) No.419 of 2021
filed by the petitioners, the contesting State-respondents by filing
their affidavit in para No.9 mentioned that:
“9. That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph 7 of
the writ petition it is stated that the state Government in the
GA (P&T) Department has taken a step for this purpose.
However, it is a policy decision matter and as such the
matter is under process.”
3.7.
It was also argued that the Learned Single Judge in the
original writ petition, on the basis of undertaking of Learned Addl.
G.A. disposed of the writ petition with a direction to the State
Authority to complete the process of creation of grade for TPS, SSG
within a period of 3(three) months. Thereafter, as per direction of
Learned Single Judge, a meeting was chaired by Chief Secretary,
Tripura. The minutes of the meeting were annexed by the Stateappellants with a copy of affidavit in the writ appeal. Referring the
same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the decisions taken in
the minutes of the meeting are contradictory to each other. Learned
Senior Counsel also pointed out that Learned Advocate General at
the time of hearing in the said appeal referred Para No.3 of the said
minutes of the meeting but Learned Advocate General did not
submit anything regarding the last part of Para Nos.5, 6 and 7 of
the said minutes of the meeting dated 30.10.2021 wherein the
burden was shifted to the shoulder of DGP, Tripura. For the sake of
convenience, the entire copy of the said minutes of meeting dated
30.10.2021 is reproduced hereunder:
“MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 30TH OCTOBER, 2021
AT 11.00 AM I/C WITH CREATION OF ONE GRADE IN
TRIPURA POLICE SERVICE NAMELY, SENIOR SELECTION
GRADE
Officials present:(i) The Director General of Police, Tripura
(ii) The Pr. Secretary, GA(P&T) Department
(iii) The IGP (Admin), Tripura
(iv) The AIGP (HQ) & (Esst.). Tripura
(v) The Addl. Secretary, GA (P&T) Deptt
The Chief Secretary, Tripura was on chair.
2.
A threadbare discussion was held on the judgment
and order of the Hon‟ble High Court of Tripura in connection
with W.P.(C) No.419 of 2021 wherein the Hon‟ble High Court
issued a directive to the State Respondent for creation of one
grade namely TPS SSG in TPS Rules within a period of
3(three) months from the when the representation received
from the petitioner alongwith a copy of the order. During the
discussion, the following points were emerged:(i) The Committee examined the decision taken by the
Empowered Committee for Coordination and Policy Initiative
(ECCPI) and it is observed that a decision has been taken in
that meeting towards creation of Tripura Police Service
Senior Selection Grade after observing all rules and
regulations and to identify the post for this grade.
In the said meeting of ECCPI, there was also a decision
for allowing financial incentive to the Government employees
holding the higher posts of higher pay level with full duty
charge since, there is a bar on promotion of Government
employees due to pending SPL before the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court regarding Reservation Policy. But, recently State
Government has framed a Promotion Policy for allowing adhoc promotion as one time measure pending finalization of
SLP before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India.
During the discussion in the meeting, the Committee
feels that the Empowered Committee for Coordination and
Policy Initiative (ECCPI) is not appropriate forum to
recommend creation of TPS SSG. Moreover, the said decision
of the ECCPI can neither be termed as Government decision
nor it is a decision of legislature. Moreover, for cadre review
of any service there is a provision of cadre review committee
and its specified procedure.
(ii)
In the year 2007, there was decision of the
Government for creation of TPS SSG in TPS Rules. After that
the cadre has been reviewed and enhanced in the year 2010
as per proposal of PHQ. In the said proposal of PHQ
reference has not been made for creation of TPS SSG. Though
creation of TPS SSG was not considered but cadre review of
the TPS Rules was done after the decision during the year
2007.
(iii)
It was also discussed in the meeting that during
year 2015, for cadre review of TPS, PHQ has viewed as
follows “since Police is a uniformed service which reflects on
discipline, command and control, it must be ensured that
creation of a separate SSG dies not affect the command
structure of the hierarchy. It may also be noted that TPS
officers in Gr-I (after completion of 3 years) and Senior
Selection Grade, if created will have to hold the post in the
rank of SP only. It is therefore, not recommended to create
separate posts of SP/AIG rank (SSG Posts) among the SP
rank posts (TPS Gr.I). It is to mention that if District SP
posts are generally cadre posts in the IPS and any
earmarking of the District SP posts as SSG posts would
prevent the posting of TPS Grade-I officers to the post of
District SP.
Further, it will also create and issue regarding wearing of
proper ranks on the uniform among IPS/TPS officers.
Considering the above, it is not recommended to create
any SSG as a promotion posts in TPS inline of TCS Cadre.”
(iv)
The issue of comparison between the TCS & TPS
cadre schedule in the context of creating TPS SSG has been
examined and discussed at length. It is observed that TCS &
TPS cadre services rules are totally different one. Because,
nomenclature and posting are also different. Thus prospect
in carrier progression in TCS & TPS are un-comparable. As
such, there may not be equity in the two cadre services.
Generally, TPS Gr-II officers are posted as SDPO (SubDivisional Head) in the Sub-Division, whereas a TCS Gr-II
officer is posted as Dy. Collector/BDO etc. Similarly, TPS Gr-I
officers are posted as Addl. SP and SP in the District after
3(three) years of service in TPS Gr-I whereas TCS Gr-I
officers are posted as SDM in the Sub-Division. And the
officers from TCS SSG are being posted as Addl. DM i.e. at
district level though it is not independent district charge like
a Superintendent of Police of TPS Gr-I. Generally it has been
observed that TCS SSG officers are being considered
promotion to IAS after 25-30 years or more. At present,
there are few officers from 1990 batch of TCS who are yet to
get promotion to IAS, whereas, some TPS officers of 1998
batch have already promoted to IPS during the year 2014
and so on.
(v) The cadre review instruction/guideline of the Govt.
has been consulted in the meeting. It has been observed that
as per guidelines of Cadre Review of Cadre Services Rules,
the proposal would be formulated to the extent possible in
consultation with the representative of Service Associations.
While drafting the proposal, all issues like expected changes
in the organizations activities, automation, amendment in
the business process, requirement planning, plugging the
skill gaps, cadre structure, career progression, financial
implications etc. must be analyzed and made part of the
proposal. So, DGP, Tripura shall take views of all
stakeholders of the Tripura Police Service towards creation
of new grade namely TPS SSG in TPS Rules as common
interest is involved in expansion of cadre by creating new
grade.
(vi)
The committee has also opined that some financial
benefits may be given to the TPS Gr-I officers if they are not
getting any promotion after considerable time to IPS inspite
of having all requisite/eligibility for promotion. Matter of
provisioning Dynamic Career Progression or MACP may be
examined to provide financial benefits to TPS Officers if they
are not getting promotion or uplift during service tenure in
TPS Gr-I level.
(vii) DGP, Tripura shall identify the posts keeping in
view of all contexts of service conditions on analysis of cadre
allocation of existing IPS and TPS posts and shall examine
the requirement of creating new grade in the TPS Rules.
Meeting ended with thanks to all.
Sd/Chief Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
3.8.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
Division Bench of this Court by the said judgment dated 08.04.2024
(Annexure-2 to the writ petition) although asked the State
Government to take appropriate decision in the lights of the
minutes of the meeting dated 30.10.2021 but no such action was
taken by the State-respondents rather the State-respondents
passed the impugned order dated 09.07.2024 (Annexure-4 infra to
the writ petition). In the said order nothing was mentioned
regarding compliance of the judgment and order of the Division
Bench of this High Court rather in the last part of the order dated
09.07.2024 it is stated that the State authority reiterated the
minutes of the early meeting dated 30.10.2021 and subsequent
decision of the Cabinet dated 29.09.2022. But, surprisingly the said
decision of the Cabinet was never communicated to the petitioners.
Even regarding compliance of the judgment and order of the
Division Bench no further decision was taken by the State
Government which shows arbitrary action on the part of Staterespondents and cannot be legally appreciated. So, Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioners urged for setting aside/quashing the said
order dated 09.07.2024 issued by the respondents-authority.
3.9.
It was also submitted by Learned Senior Counsel that
Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in The State of Tripura &
Anr. vs. Samudra Debbarma & Ors., reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1844 [in Civil Appeal No.4467-4468 of 2023] in para
No.4 stated as under:
“4. In all the above matters, the controversy revolves around
the abrupt cancellation of the recruitment process of TPS and
TCS governed by the respective rules which are pari materia
to each other. Since the recruitment for the posts of TPS and
TCS had commenced and controversy involved is similar,
looking into the similitude of the origin and controversies in
all the aforesaid appeals, we have proposed to take up all
these appeals analogously and the same are being dealt with
by this common judgment. Since the appellant in Civil Appeal
Nos. 4467-48 and 4469 of 2023 is the State of Tripura and
the appellant in Civil Appeal No. 4471 of 2023 is a
recruitment candidate, we shall be referring to the
candidates collectively as „Candidates‟ and the State of
Tripura as „State‟.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted
that in view of the observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India, the rules governing TCS and TPS cadres are pari materia to
each other. It was also submitted by Learned Senior Counsel that
as alleged in order dated 09.07.2024, the decision of the Cabinet is
also subjected to judicial scrutiny in view of the judgment stated
above (supra). Finally, Learned Senior Counsel urged for allowing
the writ petition filed by the present petitioners by cancelling the
said order dated 09.07.2024.
4.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. GA appearing on
behalf of the State-respondents strongly countered the submissions
made by Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and drawn the
attention of this court that the Division Bench of this Court in the
aforenoted judgment dated 08.04.2024 in WA No.3 of 2022 did not
issue any direction upon the State Government to implement the
direction rather it was directed by the Division Bench of this Court
to consider the proposal of the petitioners which has been duly
considered by the respondents-State and accordingly, the order has
been issued on 09.07.2024. As such, the present writ petition is not
maintainable for quashing/setting aside the said order dated
09.07.2024.
4.1.
In support of his contention, Learned Addl. GA relied
upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Ravikumar Dhansukhlal Maheta & Anr. vs. High Court of
Gujarat & Ors., reported in (2024) 11 SCC 424 wherein in para
No.80, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“80. However, in India, no government servant can claim
promotion as their right because the Constitution does not
prescribe criteria for filling seats in promotional posts. The
legislature or the executive may decide the method for filling
vacancies to promotional posts based on the nature of
employment and the functions that the candidate will be
expected to discharge. The courts cannot sit in review to
decide whether the policy adopted for promotion is suited to
select the “best candidates”, unless on the limited ground
where it violates the principle of equal opportunity under
Article 16 of the Constitution.”
Referring the same, Learned Addl. GA submitted that
the subject matter of the present writ petition relates to the policy
of the State Government and this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot direct the State
Government to form any policy and furthermore the original Writ
Court i.e. WP(C) No.419 of 2021 passed by Learned Single Judge
and the writ appeal i.e. WA No.3 of 2022 passed by the Division
Bench of this court did not issue any direction upon the State
Government, rather they asked the State Government to consider
the case of the petitioners and that was not the direction. So, the
State Government was not bound by that observation. Learned
Addl. GA further referred another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in P.U. Joshi & Ors. vs. Accountant General,
Ahmedabad & Ors., reported in (2003) 2 SCC 632, wherein in
para No.10, Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as under:
“10. We have carefully considered the submissions made on
behalf of both parties. Questions relating to the constitution,
pattern, nomenclature of posts, cadres, categories, their
creation/abolition, prescription of qualifications and other
conditions of service including avenues of promotions and
criteria to be fulfilled for such promotions pertain to the field
of policy is within the exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of
the State, subject, of course, to the limitations or restrictions
envisaged in the Constitution of India and it is not for the
statutory tribunals, at any rate, to direct the Government to
have a particular method of recruitment or eligibility criteria
or avenues of promotion or impose itself by substituting its
views for that of the State. Similarly, it is well open and
within the competency of the State to change the rules
relating to a service and alter or amend and vary by
addition/substraction the qualifications, eligibility criteria
and other conditions of service including avenues of
promotion, from time to time, as the administrative
exigencies may need or necessitate. Likewise, the State by
appropriate rules is entitled to amalgamate departments or
bifurcate departments into more and constitute different
categories of posts or cadres by undertaking further
classification, bifurcation or amalgamation as well as
reconstitute
and
restructure
the
pattern
and
cadres/categories of service, as may be required from time
to time by abolishing the existing cadres/posts and creating
new cadres/posts. There is no right in any employee of the
State to claim that rules governing conditions of his service
should be forever the same as the one when he entered
service for all purposes and except for ensuring or
safeguarding rights or benefits already earned, acquired or
accrued at a particular point of time, a government servant
has no right to challenge the authority of the State to amend,
alter and bring into force new rules relating to even an
existing service.”
Referring the same, Learned Addl. GA further submitted
that in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble the
Apex Court in the aforenoted case, there is no scope on the part of
this Court to interfere with the policy decision of the State, and as
such, Learned Addl. GA urged for dismissal of the present writ
petition on the ground that the same is not maintainable.
5.
I have given anxious hearing of both sides at length and
perused the judgment and order passed by Learned Single Judge. I
have also perused the judgment and order of the Division Bench of
this Court and the references of communications made in the writ
petition as well as in the writ appeal and the documents submitted
by the petitioners in the present writ petition as well as the counteraffidavit filed by the State-respondents.
6.
Here, in the case at hand, it is the stand of the State
Government that there is no scope on the part of this Court to issue
any direction upon the State authority to form a new policy
regarding creation of cadre of TPS, SSG which is exclusively within
the executive domain of the State.
7.
However, Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
drawn the attention of this Court that although the Court cannot
direct the State authority to form any new policy, but at the same
time, the Court also cannot sit idle if the State authority fails to
obey the commitment made by them before this Court. Referring
the judgment and order dated 14.09.2021 in WP(C) No.419 of
2021, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the attention of this Court that
in the said writ petition, Learned Addl. GA specifically submitted
before the Court to allow 6(six) months time to complete the
process of implementation of the policy decision regarding creation
of new grade of TPS, SSG in the light of decision taken in the
meeting of the empowered Committee dated 04.06.2020. In the
said meeting it was decided by the authority to create a new grade
of TPS, SSG. However, the State authority without complying the
direction/observation made by the Learned Single Judge preferred
appeal before the Division Bench of this Court and the Division
Bench also remanded back the matter to the State Government to
take an appropriate decision in the light of the minutes of the
meeting dated 30.10.2021 signed by Chief Secretary, Tripura. But,
unfortunately no appropriate decision was taken in pursuance of the
said minutes of the meeting dated 30.10.2021. In Para No.3 of the
said
minute,
although
the
State
authority
gave
a
different
observation, but in Para Nos.5, 6, and 7, certain decisions were
taken which were not complied with by the State authority,
meaning thereby no decisions were taken by the State authority in
respect of Para No.5, 6, and 7 of the said minutes dated 30.10.2021
signed by the State authority, rather the said Para Nos. 5, 6, and 7
were contrary to the earlier para No.4. Learned Senior Counsel also
submitted that since from the very beginning, it was the decision of
the authority of the State Government to create a new cadre for
TPS, SSG, but for certain unknown reasons, without any justified
ground or basis, the State authority was not implementing the
same. Even after the decision of the writ appeal on 08.04.2024, in
spite of the direction of this Court, the State Government did not
take any action and by issuing a new order dated 09.07.2024,
which is under challenge, disposed of the matter referring the
earlier minutes of the meeting dated 30.10.2021 of the Chief
Secretary,
Tripura
and
the
decision
of
the
Cabinet
dated
29.09.2022, which was arbitrary, inoperative, not binding upon the
petitioners, and also total disregard of the direction passed by the
Division Bench of
this Court
in
judgment and order dated
08.04.2024 in WA No.3 of 2022.
8.
has
Thus, it appears to this Court that the State authority
taken
different
stand
on
different
times
regarding
implementation of the issues which are also contrary to each other
and it also appears to this Court that the State authority is not at all
interested to implement their own policy, for the reason best known
to them because after going through the communications referred
in the earlier writ petition and the writ appeal and also going
through the annexures submitted in this writ petition it appears that
all along the State authority was in a positive mode to consider
creation of new cadre of TPS, SSG like TCS, SSG but no conscious
decision in this regard was taken. More interestingly, even after the
judgment of the Division Bench of this High Court no new decision
has taken by the State authority rather by a fresh order dated
09.07.2024 referring the earlier minutes of the meeting dated
30.10.2021 and cabinet decision dated 29.09.2022 they have
turned down the issue of the present petitioners, which in my
considered view is totally illegal, arbitrary and indifferent attitude
on the part of the Government to bypass the earlier judgments of
Learned Single Judge and Division Bench of this Court without
issuing
any
appropriate
order
on
the
issue
of
the
present
petitioners.
9.
It is the settled position of law that the writ Court cannot
direct the executive authority to form any policy decision rather it is
the executive authority to take appropriate decisions in this regard.
But, in the case at hand, it is clear from the references which have
been mentioned in this judgment that from the very beginning the
respondent authority intended to take some decision regarding
creation of new cadre for TPS, SSG but, for any reasons no fruitful
development could took place and ultimately, in the meeting under
the chair of then Chief Secretary on 30.10.2021, some decisions
were taken. However, the points in the minutes of the meeting are
contrary to each other. So, considering all the aspects the Division
Bench of this High Court, in the writ appeal, remanded back the
matter to the Government to take appropriate decision in the light
of minutes dated 30.10.2021. But, by issuing subsequent order
dated 09.07.2024 (Annexure-4 infra to the writ petition), the Staterespondents again reiterated the same thing without giving any
specific
observation
regarding
the
decision
of
the
State
Government. Accordingly, contempt was filed against the Staterespondents and in the contempt proceeding it was submitted that
the State Government issued order dated 09.07.2024 and for that
contempt proceeding was closed. But, the said order again has been
challenged before this Court in this writ petition on the ground that
no observation was made in the said order in the light of the
judgment delivered by Division Bench of this Court which compelled
the petitioners to approach this Court for exercising writ jurisdiction.
The jurisdiction of the writ Court is limited to the extent of issuing
any direction in respect of policy matters. However, if the
respondent authority sits over the matter for indefinite period, the
Court also cannot remain as a silent spectator.
10.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioners is
hereby allowed. The memo dated 09.07.2024 (Annexure-4 infra to
the writ petition) issued by the respondent authority stands set
aside. The respondent authority is under obligation in the light of
the judgment delivered by the Division Bench of this Court in WA
No.3 of 2022 to take appropriate decision so as to address the
grievances of the present petitioners and to communicate the same
to the petitioners accordingly within a period of 6(six) months from
the date of passing of this judgment.
With this observation, the instant writ petition stands
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.10.30
A DATTA Date:
16:07:55 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review