Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.372 of 2024
1. Sri Goutam Choudhury,
Son of Late Makhan Lal Choudhury,
Resident of village- Ashram Chowmuhani, P.O-Dhaleswar,
PS: East Agartala, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799007,
aged about 58 years.
------ Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Commissioner & Secretary, General
Administration (Personal & Training) Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building,
P.O: Kunjaban, PS: New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala,
Dist: West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, General Administration,
Administrative Reforms Department, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Secretariat Building, PO-Kunjaban,
PS-New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala,
District-West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
3. The District Magistrate & Collector,
Unakoti Tripura District, having his office at Kailashahar,
P.O & P.S- Kailashahar, District-Unakoti Tripura.
4. The District Magistrate & Collector,
North Tripura District, having his office at Dharmanagar,
P.O & P.S- Dharmanagar, District-Udaipur Tripura.
------ Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Adwitya Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G. A.
Date of hearing
:
12.09.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
26.09.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the following
reliefs:
i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them,
to show cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, for transmitting the records, lying
with them, for rendering substantive and conscionable justice to
the petitioner, and for quashing/setting aside the impugned
Order dated 02.03.2024 (Annexure-19 supra);
ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of
them, to show cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the
nature thereof, shall not be issued, for mandating/directing them,
to
revoke/rescind
the
impugned
Order
dated
02.03.2024
(Annexure-19 supra), and thereupon, for mandating/directing
them, to forthwith drop the disciplinary proceeding, initiated
against the petitioner;
iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents
and each one of
them, to show cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the
nature thereof, shall not be issued, for mandating/directing them,
to release the balance amount of salary & allowances, apart from
the subsistence allowances, that have been withheld from him
during the period of suspension, and further for granting the
intervening promotion(s) that have been withheld from him,
because of the pendency of the departmental proceeding, with
retrospective benefit and consequential dues;
iv) Call for the records, appertaining to this writ petition;
v) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule absolute
in terms of (i) to (iii) above;
vi) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding;
vii) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon’ble High Court may deem fit
and proper;
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Ms. Adwitya Chakraborty appearing
on behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned Addl. G.A., Mr.
Dipankar Sarma appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
3.
At the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner is holding the post of District Transport
Officer, Sepahijala District and at present posted at Office of District
Magistrate & Collector, Sepahijala. The District Magistrate & Collector
on 15.09.2018 issued one show cause notice to the petitioner,
pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted his reply dated 17.10.2020
to the DM & Collector, Unakoti District, Kailashahar. The reply was
annexed with the petition as Annexure-1. But the District Magistrate &
Collector, Unakoti District issued a memorandum on 26.08.2019
rejecting the reply dated 17.10.2018 of the petitioner. The copy of
memo was annexed as Annexure-2.
Thereafter, the District Magistrate & Collector on 26.08.2019
issued a further show cause notice to the petitioner informing that no
FIR was received by Pecharthal Police Station, nor a case was
registered against the said Implementing Officer i.e., Kumar Raju
Chakma. It was further mentioned in the said show cause notice
dated 26.08.2019 that the petitioner issued a cheque bearing
No.366084 dated 08.10.2014 amounting to Rs.1,00,000/-(Rupees
One Lakh) to Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, TA for construction of Bharat
Nirman Rajib Gandhi Seva Kendra at Nabin Cherra ADC Village on the
same day, when an FIR was already lodged against Sri Kumar Raju
Chakma, TA and three other staff in Pecharthal Police Station.
Furthermore,
while
issuing
the
work
order
in
favour
of
the
Implementing Officers, it was alleged that the petitioner had not
specifically indicated the name of the Supervising Officers(AEs) and
thus there was no involvement of any Assistant Engineer(AE for short)
who could monitor and supervise the works for proper execution as
well as timely completion of the different works entrusted to the IOs.
As a result, there were gross irregularities in the implementation of
different works by the IOs and substandard quality of works. The copy
of that show cause notice was marked as Annexure-3.
After that, according to Learned Counsel, the Principal
Secretary,
General
Administration(Administrative
Reforms)
by
a
memo dated 24.08.2020 informed him that an enquiry under Rule-14
of the Central Civil Services(Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules,
1965 was required to be held against the petitioner for drawing up the
Articles of Charge. By the said memorandum, the petitioner was
directed to submit his written statement of his defence within 15
days. The memorandum dated 24.08.2020 along with the Articles of
Charge were annexed as Annexure-4. For the sake of convenience,
the relevant Articles of Charge are mentioned herein below:
STATEMENT OF ARTICLE OF CHARGE(S) FRAMED AGAINST
SRI GOUTAM CHOUDHURY, THE THEN BDO, PECHARTHAL
RD BLOCK, UNAKOTI DISTRICT.
ARTICLE-I
That Sri Goutam Choudhury while functioning as
BDO, Pecharthal RD Block during the period from
01/08/2012 to 24/02/2014 had issued the following Work
Orders in favour of Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, Technical
Assistant for implementation of various works under
MGNREGA involving large amount of fund, although he was
a contractual employee by ignoring the senior regular
Junior Engineers posted in the Block without receiving full
adjustments against the expenditure incurred in respect of
each work taken up. As a result, there are liabilities to the
tune of Rs. 35,34,627/- (Rupees thirty five lakh thirty four
thousand six hundred twenty seven) against the said works
which is a clear violation of the financial norms. There is a
malafide intention on the part of Shri Goutam Chowdhury,
TCS Gr-ll for misappropriation of Govt. fund in collaboration
with Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, T/A.
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Name of work
Work order
No. & date
Estimated cost
Value of
work as per
reassessment
done by the
team
Unspecified
work done
by IO.
Liability
Construction
of
single cell box culvert
near the house of
Sukhamoy
Chakma
on Laxmancerra at
Nabinchera
ADC
Village during 201213
Brick
soling
road
from
Sonarampara
towards Govindabari
(W-6) at Nabincherra
ADC village during
2012-13
Brick soling of road
from
Rasamoy
Debnath's house to
old Forest office at
Krishnatill
at
D/Macharra
ADC
village during 201213
Construction
of
protection wall for
traditional
water
body near Machmara
ADC village during
2011-12
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/13-14/296676 dated 0706-13
Rs. 25,42,709/-
No.216802-12
dated
07-012013
Rs. 7,78,799/-
Rs.
6,88,800/-
Rs.2,60,046/-
F.17(13)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1213/16185-95
dated
06-0912
Rs. 6,53,527/-
Rs.3,47,122
/-
Rs.2,81,269/-
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1112/10885(A)
Dtd.2.3.12
&
Corrigendum
No.18(1)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1213/1288914
dt.20.3.13
Rs. 25,16,456/-
Rs.
10,11,056/-
Rs. 10,72,822/-
Total
Rs. 35,34,627/-
Rs.19,20,490/-
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, Ex-BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-II
That Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block had issued the following Cheque(s) to
Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, TA (Implementing Officer)
involving an amount of Rs. 26,10,225/- as advance without
any proper monitoring & supervision of the construction
works as well as without assessing the actual progress of
the works.
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Name of work
Work order
No. & date
Construction
of
single cell box culvert
near the house of
Sukhamoy
Chakma
on Laxmancerra at
Nabinchera
ADC
Village during 201213
Brick
soling
road
from
Sonarampara
towards Govindabari
(W-6) at Nabincherra
ADC village during
2012-13
Brick
soling
road
from
Rasamoy
Debnath's house to
old Forest office at
Krishnatill
at
D/Macharra
ADC
village during 201213
RCC retaining wall
for traditional water
body near Machmarra
ADC village
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/13-14/296676 dated 0706-13
25,42,709/-
No.216802-12
dated
07-012013
7,78,799/-
150800
152031
01.02.13
30.03.13
50000/56490/-
F.17(13)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1213/16,185-95
dated
06-0912
6,53,527/-
129824
16.10.12
88195/-
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1112/10885(A)
Dtd. 2.3.12 &
Corrigendum
No.18(1)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/1213/1288914
dtd.20.3.13
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/11-12/464353 dated 0912-11
25,16,456/-
152079
152076
151241
151278
366060
30.03.13
20.06.13
21.08.13
19.09.13
23.12.13
185900/150000/100000/40000/80000/-
150918
129091
129861
129884
15.3.13
27.9.12
15.11.12
7.12.12
100000/200000/165100/200000/-
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/12-12/4612621 dated 0912-11
Rs 32,75,699/but
int
work
order issued in
the
estimated
cost
Rs.35,59,291/-
Sri
Kumar
Raju
Chakma,
TA
129029
129824
150734
150915
366060
366084
23.7.12
16.10.12
3.1.13
15.03.13
23.12.13
08.01.14
100000/100000/250000/100000/120000/100000/-
F.17(10)/PO/
PTL/MGNREGA
/11-12/415363(A)
dated
28-11-11
10,71,929/-
Sri
Kumar
Raju
Chakma,
TA
129861
129067
15.11.12
28.8.12
35000/70000/-
Construction
of
double
cell
box
culvert
from
Dangaraibari
to
Panbagan
under
Dakshin
Machmara
ADC village
Construction of Pucca
Irrigation
Channal
from the community
fishery to 1st 750
mtr.
At
Dakshin
Machmara
ADC
village
Bharat Nirman Rajib
Gandhi Seva Kendra
at Nabincherra ADC
village
Estimated cost
(in Rs.)
Name of
IO
Sri
Kumar
Raju
Chakma,
TA
35,59,291/-
Advance amount issued to IO
Cq. No.
Date
Amount
(in Rs.)
152839
13.06.13
150540/152876
20.06.13
59000/151241
21.08.13
100000/151278
19.09.13
10000/-
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, Ex-BDO,
Pecharthal RO Block has committed misconduct, which is
quite unbecoming of a Government servant and thus, he
has violated the Rule 3 Tripura Civil Services (Contuct)
Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-III
That Si Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO, Pecharthal
RD Block had issued aforesaid Work Orders to Sri Kumar
Raju Chakma, TA for Implementation of different works
which are beyond the jurisdiction of Sectors allocated to
him vide Order No.F.1(8)/BDO/PTL/EST/2011/10,852-60
dated 14-10-2011 with a malafide intention.
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, ExBDO, Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-IV
That Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block had issued the following Work
Order(s) to Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, TA for implementation
of works which were not included in the approved Annual
Action Plan of the Block during the year 2012-13 and thus
violating the guidelines of MGNREGA.
3. Brick soling of road from Rasamoy Debnath's
house to old Forest office at Krishnatilla Dakshin Macharra
ADC village during the year 2012-13.
4. Construction of Protection wall near Machmara
Class XII School under Uttar Machmara ADC Village during
the year 2011-12.
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, ExBDO, Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-V
That Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block was directed to file FIR against 4
(four) nos. of Implementing Officers namely, Md. Lutfur
Rahman, RPS, Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, TA, Sri Devabahan
Chakma, VS and Sri Kakrajoy Reang, GRS vide letter No
F1(29)/DUD/MGNREGA/2012-13/V2/2223-27
dated
21/12/2013 of DM & Collector, Unakoti District and
accordingly Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal R.D. Block had also claimed that he had lodged
an FIR to the Officer In-Charge, Pecharthal Police Station
against the aforesaid 4 (four) Implementing Officers vide
letter
No.F.17(1)/PO(BDO)/PTL/MGNREGA/201314/11,390-99 dated, 08-01-2014 without mentioning
specific defalcated amount fixed against the concerned
defaulting Implementing Officers in the said F.I.R. But the
Officer-in-Charge, Pecharthal Police Station had intimated
vide letter No.6834 dated 30-07-2019 and lette No. 6988
dated 05-08-2019 to the present BDO, Pecharthal RD Block
that no F.l.R. was received b Pecharthal Police Station nor a
case was registered against the aforesaid implementing
Officers. Thus the claim made by Sri Goutam Choudhury,
TCS Gr. -II, the then BDO, Pecharthal RD Block that he had
lodged a F.I.R. in Pecharthal Police Station is quite doubtful
and misleading.
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, ExBDO, Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-VI
That Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block had issued a Cheque bearing
No.366084 dated 08-01-2014 amounting to Ps. 1,00,000/only to Sri Kumar Raju Chakma, TA for construction of the
R.D. Block of the community fishery to 1st 750 mtr at
Dakshin Machmara ADC village against 4 (four) nos. of
Implementing Officers namely, Md. Lutfur Rahman, RPS, Sri
Kumar Raju Chakma, TA Sri Devabahan Chakma, VS and Sri
Kakrajoy
Reang,
GRS
vide
letter
No.F.1(29)/DUD/MGNREGA/2012 13/V2/2223-27 dated
21/12/2013 with malafide intention for getting personal
gain/benefit.
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, ExBDO, Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
ARTICLE-VII
That Sri Goutam Choudhury, the then BDO,
Pecharthal RD Block while issuing the Work Orders in
favour of the Implementing Officers had not specifically
indicated the name of Supervising Officers (AEs) and thus
there was no involvement of any A.E. who could monitor
and supervise the works for proper execution as well as
timely completion of the different works entrusted to the
IOs. As a result, there were gross irregularities in the
implementation of different works by the IOs and
substandard quality of works.
By the above acts, Shri Goutam Choudhury, TCS, ExBDO, Pecharthal RD Block has committed gross misconduct,
which is quite unbecoming of a Government servant and
thus, he has violated the Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
The petitioner thereafter submitted his written statement of
defence on 14.09.2020 denying the assertions in the Articles of
Charge. Copy of the reply was annexed as Annexure-5.
But
thereafter,
Under
Secretary,
General
Administration(Administrative Reforms) Department, Government of
Tripura issued a notice dated 22.09.2020 and directed him to appear
before the Principal Secretary, General Administration(Administrative
Reforms) Department to appear with all the relevant documents. Copy
of the notice was annexed as Annexure-6.
Again,
the
Administration(Administrative
Principal
Reforms)
Secretary,
Department
General
issued
two
separate orders on 22.10.2020 and thereby appointing Sri Abhishek
Chandra, IAS, Special Secretary, ICA as the Inquiring Authority to
enquire into the charges framed against the petitioner and one Ranjit
Das, TCS Grade-II, Under Secretary, RD Department was appointed
as the Presenting Officer to present the case on behalf of the
Government before the Inquiring Authority. Copies of the orders were
annexed as Annexure-7.
Thereafter,
the
Under
Secretary,
General
Administration(Personnel & Training) Department issued a letter
bearing No.F.23(8)-GA(P&T)/2015(P-1) dated 21.01.2021 along with
a copy of notice dated 23.12.2020 issued by the Inquiring Authority
with a direction to appear before the chamber of Special Secretary,
ICA
Department,
Secretariat.
The
copies
of
the
letter
dated
21.01.2021 and the notice dated 23.12.2020 were annexed as
Annexure-8.
Further it
was
submitted by
Learned Counsel
for the
petitioner that the Inquiring Authority after completion of inquiry by
order dated 10.05.2021 gave the following findings(para No.2.9 of
writ petition):
2.9.
***
***
***
i. Article-I:-The charges as enumerated in Article-l for
misappropriation of Government fund by the BDO are not
substantive in nature. It is not the job of the BDO to make
the estimate & execute the work which is primarily the job
of Technical Assistant. The BDO, i.e., the petitioner herein
has not committed any misappropriation as a government
servant nor has he committed any irregularity as per the
Conduct Rules in the mentioned works. The works as
sanctioned have not been completed by the Technical
Assistant. The petitioner was transferred on 05.02.2014
and there were no irregularities of any work done by him
during his time. Thus, in Article I no charge is made out
against the petitioner.
ii. Article-II:-It has been stated that approximately
Rs.26,10,225/- in advance was given to Sri Chakma,
without physical progress of works. Hence, there was no
misappropriation by the BDO. The work has not been
completed by Sri Chakma and for non-completion of the
work, and inquiry should be conducted against Sri Chakma.
It is to the credit of the petitioner that an amount,
approximately Rs.9.00 lakhs was recovered from the said
work, and the report was submitted by the petitioner on
the negligence of the departmental works to the DM &
Collector office with complete details of the money that
was recovered. The BDO, i.e., the petitioner herein had
recovered money to the tune of Rs.9.00 lakhs. Thus, there
is no malafide intention on the part of the petitioner as he
had taken steps for recovery. Thus, he is not found guilty
on these charges.
iii. Article-III:-A BDO can allocate to any Technical
Assistant for implementation in any area in his jurisdiction.
Hence, in doing so, the petitioner has not violated any
Conduct Rules.
iv. Article-IV:- The works were sanctioned by the
Panchayat & BDO, in the interest of the Block. As per
report, it is almost complete & 60% of the work near
Machmara Class XII School was completed during his
tenure. Hence, no case is made out against the petitioner.
v. Article-V:-Even though, the formal FIR for registering the
case against the IO was not done by the petitioner, but
since, he had informed the OC, In-charge to impose the
recovery & register a case against the IO, it may be treated
as a procedure lapse and not a malafide intention on the
part of the petitioner.
vi. Article-VI:- The petitioner has taken necessary steps to
recover the said amount on this work and an amount of
Rs.8,25,715/- has already been recovered. There was no
malafide intention on the part of the petitioner. As 300
meter work was already completed & money allotted for
was duly spent, there is no violation on the part of the
petitioner for not dismissing Sri Chakma, for his gross
errors & misconduct.
vii. Article-VII:- In the Block, there was no AE posted
during the tenure of the petitioner. There have been
reports on monitoring done by the Executive Engineer, RD
from time to time. Thus, there is no irregularity nor any
misconduct of the petitioner nor has he violated any of the
Conduct Rules.
Copy of the order dated 10.05.2021 was annexed as
Annexure-9.
Again Learned Counsel submitted that the District Magistrate
& Collector, Unakoti District on 30.01.2014 issued a memorandum
mentioning that there was a callous attitude of Sri Kumar Raju
Chakma in executing the works under the Pecharthal RD Block, as
such, it was ordered to terminate the service of Sri Kumar Raju
Chakma and to lodge FIR against him. Copy of the memorandum was
annexed as Annexure-10.
4.
Learned Counsel further submitted that in pursuance of the
order dated 10.05.2021(Annexure-9), the Principal Secretary, General
Administration(Administrative Reforms) Department issued an order
dated 28.07.2021 noting that the inquiry was not done as per Rule14(23) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965, and as such, as per Rule-15(2)
of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965, the Disciplinary Authority disagreed with
the findings of the Inquiring Authority and directed for fresh inquiry
against the petitioner by appointing Sri Sriram Taranikanti, IAS,
Principal Secretary, Transport Department as Inquiring Authority to
enquire into the charge framed against the petitioner. Copy of the
order dated 28.07.2021 was annexed as Annexure-11.
But according to Learned Counsel surprisingly again the
Principal Secretary, General Administration(Administrative Reforms)
Department thereafter by a further order dated 17.01.2022 appointed
the Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries as Inquiring Authority to
enquire into the charges framed against the petitioner. Copy of the
order was annexed as Annexure-12.
After that, the Inquiring Authority issued a letter to the
petitioner fixing 02.07.2022 for the purpose of inquiry into the
charges framed against the petitioner. Copy of the letter dated
27.06.2022 was annexed as Annexure-13.
The Inquiring Authority recorded the Preliminary Statement of
the petitioner dated 05.08.2022 which was annexed as Annexure-14.
5.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel that on the date
fixed for hearing the Presenting Officer remained absent. The
Secretary,
General
Administration(Administrative
Reforms)
Department by order dated 16.03.2023 appointed Sri Pradip Acharjee,
TCS Additional Secretary, Revenue Department as the Presenting
Officer. Copy of the order dated 16.03.2023 was annexed as
Annexure-16.
6.
Being aggrieved, thereafter the petitioner preferred a writ
petition before this High Court which was marked as WP(C) No.708 of
2023 and this High Court after hearing the parties by order dated
11.12.2023 disposed of the same with the following observation:
“[6] A bare perusal of the record and reading of Rule 15(2)
of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 it appears to this court that the
impugned order dated 28.07.2021 is passed without any
reason and it is not in consonance with the Rule 15(2) of
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and hence the same is set aside.
[7] However, if the respondents desire, it is open for them
to pass a speaking order within a period of one month from
the date of receipt of the copy of this order. It is needless
to observe that any order passed in pursuance of the order
dated 28.07.2021 automatically stands dissolved.
[8] With the above observation and direction, this present
writ petition stands disposed of. As a sequel, stay, if any,
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also stands
closed.”
Copy of the order of the High Court was annexed as
Annexure-17.
7.
The petitioner thereafter submitted a representation to the
Principal Secretary General Administration(Administrative Reforms)
Department on 14.01.2024 with a request to comply the order dated
11.12.2023 passed by this High Court. Representation was annexed
as Annexure-18.
But
Disciplinary
instead
of
Authority
complying
the
i.e.
the
order
11.12.2023,
Secretary,
the
General
Administration(Administrative Reforms) Department issued an order
dated 02.03.2024 remitting the case under Rule 15(1) of the
CCS(CCA) Rules to the Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries for
further inquiry into the charges framed against the petitioner from the
stage-II, i.e. (inspection of records as mentioned in Annexure-III
onwards). The copy of the impugned order dated 02.03.2024 was
annexed as Annexure-19 which the petitioner has challenged before
this High Court by filing this writ petition.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner at the time of hearing
drawn the attention of the Court that the petitioner has got a good
prima facie case to be interfered with by exercising the jurisdiction
provided under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and urged for
allowing this writ petition.
8.
The
Writ
petition
has
been
contested
by
the
State-
respondents by filing one counter affidavit denying the assertions of
the writ petitioner in the writ petition and it was the plea of the Staterespondents that as per due process of law, the order dated
02.03.2024(Annexure-19) was issued for further inquiry into the
alleged Articles of charge against the petitioner and there is no scope
to interfere with the same at this stage and urged for dismissal of this
writ petition.
9.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India reported in 1971 (2) SCC 102 [titled as K. R. Deb Vs. The
Collector of Central Excise, Shillong dated 07.04.1971], wherein
in para No.12, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“12. It seems to us that Rule 15, on the face of it, really
provides for one inquiry but it may be possible if in a
particular case there has been no proper enquiry because
some serious defect has crept into the inquiry or some
important witnesses were not available at the time of the
inquiry or were not examined for some other reason, the
Disciplinary Authority may ask the Inquiry Officer to record
further evidence. But there is no provision in Rule 15 for
completely setting aside previous inquiries on the ground
that the report of the Inquiring Officer or Officers does not
appeal to the Disciplinary Authority. The Disciplinary
Authority has enough powers to re-consider the evidence
itself and come to its own conclusion under Rule 9.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the order dated 02.03.2024 suffers from infirmity
which is in violation of Rule 14(23) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 and by
issuing order dated 02.03.2024, the respondent authority did not
comply with the mandatory provision of Rule 15(2) of CCS(CCA)
Rules. Learned Counsel submitted that in view of the principle of law,
there is scope for interference of the order dated 02.03.2024 by this
Court by issuing writ of mandamus for cancelling the Departmental
Proceeding against the petitioner.
10.
Learned Counsel further referred another citation of the
Hon’ble Apex Court reported in (2014) 10 SCC 589 [titled as Vijay
Shankar
Pandey
Vs.
Union
of
India
and
another
dated
22.09.2014] wherein in Para No.24 and 25, Hon’ble the Apex Court
further observed as under:
“24. Be that as it may, the question is whether the
disciplinary authority could have resorted to such a
practice of abandoning the enquiry already undertaken and
resort to appointment of a fresh enquiring authority (multimember)? The issue is not really whether the enquiring
authority should be single member or a multi-member
body, but whether a second inquiry such as the one under
challenge is permissible. A Constitution Bench of this Court
in K.R. Deb v. CCE:(1971) 2 SCC 102, examined the
question in the context of Rule 15(1) of the Central Civil
Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1957. It
was a case where an enquiry was ordered against a SubInspector, Central Excise (the appellant before this Court).
The enquiry officer held that the charge was not proved.
Thereafter the disciplinary authority appointed another
enquiry officer "to conduct a supplementary open inquiry".
Such supplementary inquiry was conducted and a report
that there was "no conclusive proof" to "establish the
charge" was made. Not satisfied, the disciplinary authority
thought it fit that "another enquiry officer should be
appointed to inquire afresh into the charge".
25. The Court in K.R. Deb(supra) held that: (SCC p. 105,
paras 12-13)
"12. It seems to us that Rule 15, on the face of it,
really provides for one inquiry but it may be possible
if in a particular case there has been no proper
enquiry because some serious defect has crept into
the inquiry or some important witnesses were not
available at the time of the inquiry or were not
examined for some other reason, the disciplinary
authority may ask the enquiry officer to record
further evidence. But there is no provision in Rule 15
for completely setting aside previous inquiries on the
ground that the report of the inquiring officer or
officers does not appeal to the disciplinary authority.
The disciplinary authority has enough powers to
reconsider the evidence itself and come to its own
conclusion under Rule 9.
13. In our view the Rules do not contemplate an
action such as was taken by the Collector on 13-21962. It seems to us that the Collector, instead of
taking responsibility himself, was determined to get
some officer to report against the appellant. The
procedure adopted was not only not warranted by
the Rules but was harassing to the appellant. "
(emphasis supplied)
and allowed the appeal of K.R. Deb(supra)
Referring the same, Learned Counsel drawn the attention of
the Court that as per Rule 15, there is no scope for completely setting
aside the previous inquiries on the ground that the report of the
Inquiring Officer does not appeal to the Disciplinary Authority rather
the Disciplinary Authority has enough power to reconsider the
evidence itself and comes to its own conclusion under Rule 9 and
Learned Counsel further referred para No.26 of the said citation
wherein it was observed by Hon’ble the Apex Court as under:
“26. It can be seen from the above that the normal rule is
that there can be only one enquiry. This Court has also
recognised the possibility of a further enquiry in certain
circumstances enumerated therein. The decision however
makes it clear that the fact that the report submitted by the
enquiring authority is not acceptable to the disciplinary
authority, is not a ground for completely setting aside the
enquiry report and ordering a second enquiry.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the petitioner further
stated that as per normal rule there can be only one enquiry but there
is possibility of further enquiry in certain circumstances enumerated
therein but the disagreement of the disciplinary authority with the
report submitted by the enquiring authority cannot be a ground for
completely setting aside the enquiry report and ordering a second
inquiry. So, Learned Counsel urged before the Court for considering
this principle in deciding this writ petition.
11.
Learned Counsel again relied upon another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2011) 4 SCC 589
[titled as Union of India and others Vs. S. K. Kapoor dated
16.03.2011] wherein in para Nos.5 and 7, Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“5. It is a settled principle of natural justice that if any
material is to be relied upon in departmental proceedings, a
copy of the same must be supplied in advance to the
charge-sheeted employee so that he may have a chance to
rebut the same.
7. In the aforesaid decision, it has been observed in SCC
para 25 that "the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the
Constitution of India are not mandatory". We are of the
opinion that although Article 320(3)(c) is not mandatory, if
the authorities do consult the Union Public Service
Commission and rely on the report of the Commission for
taking disciplinary action, then the principles of natural
justice require that a copy of the report must be supplied in
advance to the employee concerned so that he may have an
opportunity of rebuttal. Thus, in our view, the aforesaid
decision in T.V. Patel case:(2007) 4 SCC 785, is clearly
distinguishable.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that in the
case at hand since the initial report of the Inquiring Authority was not
accepted by the Disciplinary Authority, so, it was the duty of the
Disciplinary Authority to supply a copy of the report in advance to the
petitioner for affording him an opportunity of rebuttal which was not
followed in this case.
12.
Again, Learned Counsel referred another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2006) 9 SCC 440 [titled as
Lav Nigam Vs. Chairman & MD, ITI LTD. and another dated
03.04.2006]
wherein in para No.9, 10 and 11, Hon’ble the Apex
Court further observed as under:
“9. Challenging the orders of the respondent authorities
the appellant filed a writ petition before the High Court.
The appellant specifically raised the issue that the
disciplinary authority was obliged to give a separate showcause notice if the disciplinary authority differed with the
inquiry officer. The High Court also held that there was no
need to give two separate show-cause notices one before
the disciplinary authority found against the employee while
differing with the view of the inquiry officer, and another
against the proposed punishment. It was further held that
the two notices could be combined in one. The writ petition
was accordingly dismissed.
10. The conclusion of the High Court was contrary to the
consistent view taken by this Court that in case the
disciplinary authority differs with the view taken by the
inquiry officer, he is bound to give a notice setting out his
tentative conclusions to the appellant. It is only after
hearing the appellant that the disciplinary authority would
at all arrive at a final finding of guilt. Thereafter, the
employee would again have to be served with a notice
relating to the punishment proposed.
11. In Punjab National Bank v. Kunj Behari Misra:(1998) 7
SCC 84, a Bench of this Court considered Regulation 7(2) of
the Punjab National Bank Officer Employees' (Discipline
and Appeal) Regulations, 1977. The Regulation itself did
not provide for the giving of any notice before the
disciplinary authority differed with the view of the enquiry
officer. This Court held: (SCC p. 97, para 19)
"The result of the aforesaid discussion would be that
the principles of natural justice have to be read into
Regulation 7(2). As a result thereof, whenever the
disciplinary authority disagrees with the enquiry
authority on any article of charge, then before it
records its own findings on such charge, it must
record its tentative reasons for such disagreement
and give to the delinquent officer an opportunity to
represent before it records its findings. The report of
the enquiry officer containing its findings will have to
be conveyed and the delinquent officer will have an
opportunity to persuade the disciplinary authority to
accept the favourable conclusion of the enquiry
officer. The principles of natural justice, as we have
already observed, require the authority which has to
take a final decision and can impose a penalty, to
give an opportunity to the officer charged of
misconduct to file a representation before the
disciplinary authority records its findings on the
charges framed against the officer."”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that in case
of disagreement, it is only after hearing the petitioner, the disciplinary
authority would proceed further which was not followed in this case.
13.
Finally, Learned Counsel for the petitioner has drawn the
attention of the Court that the order dated 02.03.2024 was issued by
the respondent authority in violation of the statutory rule which
cannot be sustained in the eye of law and also the settled principles of
law observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in series of judgments and
finally
urged
for
dismissal/setting
aside
the
said
order
dated
02.03.2024 issued by the respondent authority by allowing this writ
petition.
14.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. G.A. for the State-
respondents at the time of hearing referred one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India reported in (2015) 1 SCC 661 [titled as
State Bank of India Vs. Boa Penji dated 10.10.2014] wherein in
para Nos.9, 12 and 15, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“9. A bare perusal of Para 23.7.2 of the Procedure for
Taking Disciplinary Action makes it quite clear that once a
departmental enquiry has commenced against an officer, it
would be desirable if the enquiry officer is not changed.
However, if there is a good reason for changing the enquiry
officer, a change may be made but reasons for doing so
should be recorded.
12. On the contrary, the first part of the said paragraph
postulates the change of an enquiry officer provided
reasons are given for doing so. It is clear that by no stretch
of imagination can the first part of the said paragraph be
read otherwise than as being directory in nature. No doubt,
it is desirable that a departmental enquiry started by a
particular enquiry officer should be concluded by him or
her. But if there are reasons for changing the enquiry
officer, there cannot be any bar in doing so.
Conclusion
15. In the circumstances, we set aside the judgment and
order:Boa Penji v. SBI, Writ Appeal No.20(AP) of 2011,
decided on 7-3-2012(Gau) passed by the High Court and
hold that the first part of Para 23.7.2 of the Procedure for
Taking Disciplinary Action: Award Staff is not a mandatory
provision. However, we emphasise the mandatory
requirement of recording reasons by the Bank for changing
an enquiry officer during the continuance of a departmental
enquiry against an officer. In the facts of the present
appeal, the appointment of a fresh enquiry officer was
inevitable. The failure of the Bank to record reasons for
changing the enquiry officer did not vitiate the enquiry
against Penji.”
Relying upon the same, Learned Addl. G.A. has drawn the
attention of the Court that in view of the aforesaid principle of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, there was no bar for conducting
fresh inquiry in the present case, as such there is no merit in the writ
petition filed by the present petitioner.
15.
Learned Addl. G.A. again referred another citation of Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India reported in (1999) 1 SCC 733 [titled as
Union
of
India
and
others
Vs.
P.
Thayagarajan
dated
24.11.1998] wherein in para No.8, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed
as under:
“8. A careful reading of this passage will make it clear that
this Court notices that if in a particular case where there
has been no proper enquiry because of some serious defect
having crept into the enquiry or some important witnesses
were not available at the time of the enquiry or were not
examined, the disciplinary authority may ask the enquiry
officer to record further evidence but that provision would
not enable the disciplinary authority to set aside the
previous enquiries on the ground that the report of the
enquiry officer does not appeal to the disciplinary
authority. In the present case, the basis upon which the
disciplinary authority set aside the enquiry is that the
procedure adopted by the enquiry officer was contrary to
the relevant rules and affects the rights of the parties and
not that the report does not appeal to him. When important
evidence, either to be relied upon by the Department or by
the delinquent official, is shut out, this would not result in
any advancement of any justice but on the other hand,
result in a miscarriage thereof. Therefore we are of the
view that Rule 27(c) enables the disciplinary authority to
record his findings on the report and to pass an appropriate
order including ordering a de novo enquiry in a case of the
present nature.”
Referring the same, Learned Addl. G.A. has drawn the
attention of the Court that in the given case, there was no bar in
holding de novo inquiry, since the Disciplinary Authority was not
satisfied with the findings of the Inquiring Authority.
16.
Finally, Learned Addl. G.A. submitted that the present writ
petitioner could not project any case before this Court for invoking
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and there
was no infirmity in the order dated 02.03.2024(Annexure-19) issued
by the respondent-State Authority and as such, Learned Addl. G.A. in
conclusion of argument, urged for dismissal of this writ petition.
17.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the writ
petition and the documents annexed with the writ petition and also
perused the counter affidavit filed by the respondent-State and the
citations referred by Learned Counsel of both the sides. In this case,
initially a Disciplinary Proceeding was initiated against the present
petitioner on some Articles of Charge and accordingly Inquiring
Authority was appointed and the Inquiring Authority after conclusion
of inquiry found the charges not proved and gave its finding, but the
Disciplinary Authority was not satisfied with the finding of the initial
Inquiring Authority and ultimately appointed another person as
Inquiring Authority to further inquire into the charges. In the
meantime, the petitioner approached to the Hon’ble High Court and
the Hon’ble High Court by order dated 11.12.2023(Annexure-17) was
pleased to set aside the order dated 28.07.2021(Annexure-11) issued
by the Disciplinary Authority and directed the respondent authority to
pass a speaking order within a period of one month from the date of
receipt of copy of order and further ordered that any order passed in
pursuance of order dated 28.07.2021 will also automatically stands
dissolved. After that, the petitioner submitted one representation to
the respondent authority on 24.01.2024 (Annexure-18) with a request
to comply the judgment dated 11.12.2023 passed by this High Court
in WP(C) No.708 of 2023 and thereafter the respondent authority
further remitted back the case to the Inquiring Authority i.e. the
Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries for further inquire into the
charges framed against the petitioner from the stage-II i.e. inspection
of records as mentioned in Annexure-III onwards by order dated
02.03.2024
(Annexure-19)
petitioner before this Court.
which
has
been
challenged
by
the
18.
Now, here in this writ petition, this Court is to decide as to
whether the order dated 02.03.2024(Annexure-19) issued by the
authority can be legally sustained or not at this stage. To answer this
question now let us refer the relevant Rule 15 of CCS(CCA) Rules,
1965 which are reproduced hereinbelow:
“15. Action on the inquiry report
(1) The Disciplinary Authority, if it is not itself the
Inquiring Authority may, for reasons to be recorded by it in
writing, remit the case to the Inquiring Authority for
further inquiry and report and the Inquiring Authority shall
thereupon proceed to hold the further inquiry according to
the provisions of Rule 14, as far as may be.
(2) The Disciplinary Authority shall forward or cause to be
forwarded a copy of the report of the inquiry, if any, held
by the Disciplinary Authority or where the Disciplinary
Authority is not the Inquiring Authority, a copy of the
report of the Inquiring Authority together with its own
tentative reasons for disagreement, if any, with the
findings of Inquiring Authority on any article of charge to
the Government servant who shall be required to submit, if
he so desires, his written representation or submission to
the Disciplinary Authority within fifteen days, irrespective
of whether the report is favourable or not the Government
servant.”
On perusal of Rule 15(1), it appears that if the Disciplinary
Authority is not itself the Inquiring Authority may, for reason to be
recorded by it in writing, remit the case to the Inquiring Authority for
further inquiry and report and the Inquiring Authority shall thereupon
proceed to hold the further inquiry according to the provision of Rule14 as far as the case may be. Here in the case at hand Disciplinary
Authority is not the Inquiring Authority. So, the Disciplinary Authority
remitted the matter to the Inquiring Authority for further inquiry and
report. In this regard as already stated, this High Court, by judgment
and order dated 11.12.2023 was pleased to set aside the earlier order
dated
28.07.2021
i.e.
Annexure-11,
by
which
the
Disciplinary
Authority disagreeing with the findings of the Inquiry Authority
decided for fresh inquiry against the petitioner and appointed one Sri
Sriram Tarani Kanti, the then IAS, Principal Secretary, Transport
department as Inquiring Authority to inquire into the charges framed
against the petitioner. In the meantime, Department issued another
order
dated
17.01.2022
(Annexure-12)
and
appointed
the
Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries as Inquiring Authority in
partial modification of the earlier order dated 28.07.2021 but again on
02.03.2024 the Disciplinary Authority again issued another order
appointing Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries for further inquiry
into the charges against the petitioner in partial modification of the
earlier order dated 17.01.2022 (Annexure-12).
Further, on bare perusal of aforesaid Rule-15(2) it appears
that the Disciplinary Authority shall forward or cause to be forwarded
a copy of report of the inquiry, if any, held by the Disciplinary
Authority or where the Disciplinary Authority is not the Inquiring
Authority, a copy of the report of the Inquiring Authority together with
its own tentative reasons for disagreement, if any, with the findings of
Inquiring Authority on any Article of Charge to the Government
servant who shall require to submit, if he so desires, his written
representation or submission to the Disciplinary Authority within
fifteen days. But on bare perusal of said order dated 17.01.2022
(Annexure-12) and subsequent order dated 02.03.2024 (Annexure19) which is impugned before this Court, it appears that at the time of
issuing the order on 02.03.2024, Rule 15(2) of the CCS(CCA)
Rules,1965 has not been complied with by the Disciplinary Authority
which has caused severe prejudice to the petitioner.
19.
In this regard, a Division Bench of this High Court in a case of
Dhiman Singha Vs. State of Tripura and Ors. dated 22.09.2015
reported in (2015) 2 TLR 900 in para Nos.7, 10, 11 and 12 observed
as under:
“7. Sub-rule (1) of rule 15 envisages a situation where the
disciplinary authority is itself not the inquiring authority.
On going through the report of the Inquiry Officer, if the
disciplinary authority finds that further inquiry proceedings
should be held then it must record its reasons for coming to
such a finding and thereafter it must remit the case to the
inquiring authority for further inquiry and report the matter
to
the
disciplinary
authority.
Therefore,
what
is
contemplated under this sub-rule is a further inquiry which
obviously means a continuation of the old inquiry but not a
fresh or de novo inquiry. The language used is very specific
that the disciplinary authority after recording its reasons in
writing can remit the case to the Inquiry Officer. Remission
of a case means that it must be sent back to the same
authority to proceed further in accordance with law.
Officers may change but the authority must remain the
same. The words, 'remit' and further inquiry' leave no
manner of doubt that what is contemplated under rule
15(1) is the continuation of the old inquiry by the same
authority which conducted the inquiry earlier.
10. Rule 15(2) deals with a different situation. This
contemplates a situation where on the evidence on record
and without any further evidence being recorded the
disciplinary authority is of the view that the finding
recorded by the Inquiring Officer exonerating the
delinquent official is against the evidence of law. In such a
case, the disciplinary authority is directed to indicate and
give its prima facie or tentative reasons for disagreeing
with the report of the inquiring authority and then
communicate the reasons to the delinquent official giving
him a chance to put forth his case and answer the queries
of the disciplinary authority.
11. Thereafter, the disciplinary authority is required not
only to consider the inquiry report but also it's own
tentative reasoning as well as the reply given by the
delinquent official. After considering all three the
disciplinary authority has a right to form his own opinion
on the basis of the evidence. This does not envisage the
holding of any fresh inquiry but only on the basis of the
evidence already recorded by the Inquiring Officer the
action is to be taken.
12. There is no rule which permits the disciplinary
authority to start a fresh inquiry. In the present case, the
disciplinary authority did not follow any of the above two
options. In case the disciplinary authority was of the view
that the statements of some material witnesses had not
been recorded or that some material evidence had not been
taken into consideration then the disciplinary authority
should have recorded these reasons and then could have
remitted the matter to the Inquiring Officer to carry out the
further enquiry in terms of rule 15(1). This has not been
done. What has been done is to order a fresh Inquiry
Officer and start de novo inquiry which is not permissible
under the law. The procedure followed is totally illegal. We,
therefore, have no option but to set aside the entire inquiry
proceedings and quash the order dismissing the petitioner
from service.”
From the aforesaid citations, it also appears that here in the
case at hand when the Disciplinary Authority was not satisfied with
the findings of the initial Inquiring Authority, in that case, it was the
duty of the Disciplinary Authority to indicate and give its prima facie
or tentative reason for disagreement with the report of the Inquiring
Authority and then communicate the reasons to the petitioner giving
him a chance to put forth his case and answer the queries of the
Disciplinary Authority which has not been followed in this present case
by the Disciplinary Authority and thus it appears that the subsequent
order dated 02.03.2024 suffers from infirmities and not in accordance
with law and the procedure followed is totally found to be illegal and
non-compliance of the provision of Rule 15(2) of CCS(CCA) Rules,
1965 for which in the considered opinion of this Court the order dated
02.03.2024 is illegal not binding upon the petitioner and the same is
liable to be set aside.
20.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed. The order dated 02.03.2024 (Annexure-19 of the writ
petition) is found to be illegal, inoperative and not upon binding upon
the
petitioner
and
the
same
stands
set
aside
and
quashed
observations,
this
writ
petition
stands
accordingly.
With the above
disposed of.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.10.03 13:39:54
-07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review