Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.100822 OF 2016 (PAR)
C/W. RSA CROB NO.100002 OF 2020 (PAR)
IN RSA NO.100822/2016:
BETWEEN:
YAMANAPPA S/O. DUNDAPPA MAKANI,
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIRE SHELLIKERI,
TQ. AND DIST. BAGALKOT-587101.
&APPELLANT
(BY SRI VIJAYKUMAR B. HORATTI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
DUSENGAPPA S/O. DUNDAPPA MAKANI,
AGE: 21 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,
R/O. HIRE SHELLIKERI,
TQ. AND DIST. BAGALKOT-587101.
2.
SMT. SHANTAVVA W/O. BASAPPA LOKAPUR,
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O. VAJRAMATTI, TQ: MUDHOL,
DIST: BAGALKOT-587101.
MALLIKARJUN
RUDRAYYA
KALMATH
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
3.
SMT. CHANDRAVVA W/O. DUNDAPPA MAKANI,
(SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS
RESPONDENTS 1 & 2).
&RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI S. R. HEGDE AND
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
SRI P. K. SANNINGAMMANAVAR, ADV. FOR R1 & R2;
SRI Y. R. JOGI, ADV. FOR R1)
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 R/W. ORDER XLII RULE 1 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE,
PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED
IN R.A.NO.11/2013 BY THE LEARNED 1 ADDL. SR. CIVIL JUDGE,
BAGALKOT DATED 13.07.2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND
CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED BY THE
LEARNED PRL. CIVIL JUDGE AND J.M.F.C, BAGALKOT IN
O.S.NO.198/2010 DATED 14.12.2012 IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
RSA CROB NO.100002 OF 2020:
BETWEEN:
SRI DUSENGAPPA D/O. DUNDAPPA MAKANI,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIRE SHELLIKERI,
TQ. & DIST: BAGALKOT-587204.
&CROSS OBJECTOR
(BY SRI S. R. HEGDE AND SRI P. K. SANNINGAMMANAVAR AND
SRI Y. R. JOGI, ADVOCATES.)
AND:
1.
SRI YAMUNAPPA S/O. DUNDAPPA MAKANE,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIRE SHELLIKERI,
TQ. & DIST: BAGALKOT-587204.
SMT. SHANTAVVA W/O. BASAPPA LOKAPUR,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.
2.
SHRI BASAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA LOKAPUR,
AGE: 35 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. VAJRMATTI, TQ: MUDHOL,
DIST: BAGALKOT-587313.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
3.
SRI SHIVAPPA S/O. BASAPPA LOKAPUR,
AGE: 11 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,
R/O. VAJRMATTI, TQ: MUDHOL,
DIST: BAGAKOT-587313.
4.
SRI NAVEEN S/O. BASAPPA LOKAPUR,
AGE: 11 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,
R/O. VAJRMATTI, TQ: MUDHOL,
DIST: BAGAKOT-587313.
5.
SRI VINAYAK S/O. BASAPPA LOKAPUR,
AGE: 11 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,
R/O. VAJRMATTI, TQ: MUDHOL,
DIST: BAGAKOT-587313.
SINCE RESPONDENT 3 TO 5 ARE MINORS,
THEY ARE R/BY. NATURAL FATHER
RESPONDENT NO.2.
&RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI VIJAYKUMAR B. HORATTI, ADV. FOR R1;
NOTICE TO R2 HELD SUFFICIENT;
R3, R4 & R5 ARE MINORS, R/BY R2)
THIS RSA CROB IN RSA NO.100822/2016 IS FILED UNDER
ORDER 41 RULE 22 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, PRAYING
TO ALLOW THE CROSS OBJECTION BY MODIFYING THE
R.A.NO.10/2013 PASSED BY 1ST ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
COURT, BAGALKOT DATED 13.07.2016 FILED AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED IN O.S.NO.198/2010 ON THE
FILE OF THE PRL. CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, BAGALKOT DATED
14.12.2012 BY AWARDING 1/3RD SHARE TO THE PLAINTIFF
NO.1/CROSS OBJECTOR BY ALLOWING THE CROSS OBJECTION,
IN THE ENDS OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL AND CROSS OBJECTION COMING ON FOR
DICTATING JUDGMENT, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED
THEREIN AS UNDER:
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
RSA
No.100822/2016
is
filed
by
the
defendant
questioning the judgment and decree dated 13.07.2016
passed
by
I
Addl.
Senior
Civil
Judge,
Bagalkot,
in
R.A.No.10/2013, which confirmed the judgment and decree
dated 14.12.2012 passed by the Principal Civil Judge &
JMFC, Bagalkot, in O.S.No.198/2010.
2.
RSA
Crob.
No.100002/2020
is
filed
by
the
plaintiff No.1 questioning the judgment and decree dated
13.07.2016 passed by the I Addl. Senior Civil Judge,
Bagalkot, in R.A.No.10/2013, so far as not granting equal
share as that of defendant.
3.
Rank of parties is referred to as per their
rankings before the trial court.
4.
It is the case of plaintiffs that Dundappa is the
original propositus, who has two wives namely, Ningavva
and Chandravva.
Defendant is the son of Ningavva and
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
Dundappa and plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are the children of
Chandravva and Dundappa. Therefore, it is contended that
the plaintiffs are also children of Dundappa and hence
entitled to equal share as that of the defendant and hence,
filed the suit for partition claiming 3/4th share jointly in the
suit schedule properties.
The trial court has decreed the
suit in part declaring that the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are
entitled for 1/6th share each and defendant is entitled to half
share + 1/6th share in the suit schedule properties.
5.
the
Being aggrieved by this judgment and decree,
plaintiffs
have
preferred
the
regular
appeal
in
R.A.No.10/2013 and defendant has filed R.A.No.11/2013
before the first appellate court.
The first appellate court
has dismissed both the appeals thereby confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the trial court.
6.
The
No.100822/2016
No.100002/2020.
defendant
and
plaintiffs
has
have
preferred
RSA
filed
Crob.
RSA
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant/defendant in
RSA No.100822/2016 submitted that the plaintiffs are not
children of Dundappa and hence, they are not entitled to
any share in the suit schedule properties.
It is submitted
that the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are children of other persons
through Chandravva as Chandravva lived with other family
members in the village. Therefore, submitted that plaintiff
Nos.1 and 2 are not children of Dundappa and Chandravva
and as such, decreeing the suit is not correct.
Therefore,
prays to set aside the judgment and decree passed by the
Courts below and dismiss the suit.
8.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the cross
objectors/plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 submitted that the plaintiff
Nos.1 and 2 are the children of Chandravva and Dundappa
and Dundappa married Chandravva after the death of first
wife Ningavva.
Therefore, Chandravva is the legally
wedded wife of Dundappa and through them the plaintiff
Nos.1 and 2 were born, therefore the marriage between
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
Dundappa and Chandravva is legally valid one and the
plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are legitimate children, but the trial
court has wrongly held that the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are
illegitimate children. Therefore, prays for equal share in all
the suit schedule properties as that of Yamanappa, the
defendant.
9.
This Court has framed the following Substantial
Question of Law in RSA No.100822/2016:
<Dundappa,
the
propositus
died
on
15.04.2009 without leaving behind female class-I
heir. The plaintiffs are said to be the illegitimate
sons of Dundappa. In these circumstances,
whether the Courts below are justified in law even
after amendment to Section 6 of Hindu Succession
Act, to apply the doctrine of notional partition to
give 1/6th share to each of the plaintiffs?=
10.
This Court in RSA Crob. No.100002/2020 has
framed the following substantial questions of law:
<Whether the Courts below was justified not
granting equal share to the cross objectors 3 plaintiff
No.1 and his sister since the marriage of the plaintiff
No.3 was solemnized with Sri. Dundappa, after the
death of his 1st wife?=
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
11.
The rival contentions as per the learned counsel
for the appellant/defendant are that Chandravva is not
legally wedded wife of Dundappa and plaintiff Nos.1 and 2
are not children of Dundappa. Whereas it is the contention
of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 that they are the children of
Chandravva and Dundappa and Dundappa has married
Chandravva after the death of the first wife Ningavva.
Therefore, plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are legitimate children of
Dundappa.
12.
The trial court has held that the plaintiff Nos.1
and 2 are illegitimate children since during the subsistence
of first marriage and lifetime of Ningavva, Dundappa
married
Chandravva
and
therefore,
the
trial
court
categorized the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 as illegitimate children.
Accordingly, granted half share and plus 1/6th to the
defendant and 1/6th share each to the plaintiffs, which is
confirmed by the first appellate court.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
13.
The question for consideration in this appeal is,
whether Chandravva married Dundappa after the death of
first wife Ningavva or not?
Though the defendant has
contended that plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are not children of
Dundappa through Chandrava, there is no evidence from
defendant in this regard.
Ex.P-4 is death certificate of
Dundappa. Ex.P-7 is the birth certificate showing the name
of Dundappa as father.
14.
The learned counsel for the appellant/defendant
submitted that there is no pleading in the plaint that
Chandravva married Dundappa after the death of first wife
Ningavva, but admittedly Ningavva is the first wife and
Chandravva is second wife and whether, plaintiff Nos.1 and
2 are to be categorized illegitimate children. Therefore, in
this context the crucial crux of the factual matrix involved is
to be considered on the basis of the oral evidence.
15.
The plaintiffs have relied on the judgment and
decree passed in M.C.No.3/1996 as per Exs.P-5 and P-6 to
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
show that Chandravva is the wife of Dundappa.
Upon
considering these two documentary evidences, it is revealed
that
Chandravva
has
filed
matrimonial
case
seeking
maintenance against Dundappa. In the said M.C.No.3/1996
the Court has observed according to the averments made in
the petition that the marriage of Dundappa and Chandravva
is Udiki marriage (union of two bodies). Therefore, in the
said case recognizing Chandravva as wife of Dundappa has
ordered maintenance.
This is the only document that is
placed by the plaintiffs to prove that Chandravva is the wife
of Dundappa, but this is not sufficient to hold that
Chandravva married Dundappa after the death of Ningavva.
16.
the
Upon considering oral evidence of DW2 and DW4,
aspect
of
Chandravva
whether
she
has
married
Dundappa after death of Ningavva or not, is to be
considered on all its preponderance of probabilities. When
there is no documents placed in the suit regarding whether
the marriage of Chandravva with Dundappa was solemnized
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
after the death of Ningavva or not, then the oral evidence of
the witnesses is considered.
The defendant No.1 is
examined as DW1 who has totally denied that Chandravva
is the second wife of Dundappa and the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2
are the children of Dundappa only.
17.
The DW2 to DW4 are examined on behalf of the
defendant. DW2 to DW4 in their examination in chief have
denied that Dundappa married Chandravva after the death
of first wife Ningavva, but upon consideration of cross
examination of DW2 it is admitted that Dundappa had lived
along with Chandravva. It is admitted as follows:
<ªÉÄÊvÀ zÀÄAqÀ¥Àà ZÀAzÀæªÀé JA§ÄªÀªÀ¼À£ÀÄß ElÄÖPÉÆArzÀÝ, .=
18.
Then upon considering the evidence of DW4, he
has admitted that after the death of Ningavva the first wife,
Dundappa has accompanied <one woman=.
The other
evidence of DW2 to DW4 are regarding denial of the
marriage between Dundappa and Chandravva, but upon
considering these two admissions as above discussed, on all
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
its preponderance of probabilities, one thing is proved that
Dundappa had lived with Chandravva and after the death of
Ningavva, Dundappa has accompanied a woman and here a
woman is nothing but Chandravva and it has to be
considered on all its preponderance of probabilities as
Chandravva lived with Dundappa as wife after death of
Ningavva. Therefore, considering these evidence Dundappa
had lived along with Chandravva after the death of his first
wife Ningavva.
Chandravva had also instituted a divorce
petition as per Ex.P-6 stating that her marriage with
Dundappa is Udiki marriage.
19.
Upon considering all the evidence on record on
all its preponderance of probabilities, it is proved that
Dundappa married Chandravva or in other words, lived
along with Chandravva for long span of time and therefore,
plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 were born to Dundappa through
Chandravva. In order to controvert this evidence, there is
no evidence placed by the defendant.
Therefore, the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
evidence in this regard is to be accepted that plaintiff Nos.1
and 2 are children of Dundappa through Chandravva as
Dundappa
lived
with
Chandravva
and
recognized
Chandravva as second wife after death of Ningavva the first
wife. In this regard, the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are also to be
considered as legitimate children as that of defendantYamanappa as per Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act,
1956. In this regard, the trial court has committed an error
in observing that just because Dundappa had two wives it
means Dundappa married deceased Chandravva during the
subsistence of his marriage with his first wife Ningavva and
the trial court coming to conclusion without evidence on
record and therefore, wrongly categorized the plaintiff Nos.1
and 2 as illegitimate children without any evidence, is
perverse in nature.
But as discussed above, on all its
probabilities it is proved that Chandravva is recognized as
second wife of Dundappa and the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are
children of Chandravva and Dundappa, therefore, in this
regard, both the Courts have committed an error and as
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
such, orders passed by both the Courts have to be
interfered with. Accordingly, I answer that both the Courts
are not justified in applying the doctrine of notional partition
to give 1/6th share to each of the plaintiffs and also the
Substantial Questions of Law are answered that
the
marriage between Chandravva and Dundappa is solemnized
after death of first wife Ningavva.
Therefore, the plaintiff
Nos.1 and 2 and defendant are entitled to equal share of
1/3rd share each in the suit schedule properties.
20.
For the reasons aforestated, I proceed to pass
the following:
ORDER
(i)
RSA No.100822/2016 is dismissed and RSA
Crob. No.100002/2020 is allowed-in-part.
(ii)
The judgment and decree dated 13.07.2016
passed
by
I
Addl.
Senior
Civil
Bagalkot,
in
R.A.No.10/2013
judgment
and
decree
dated
Judge,
and
the
14.12.2012
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:362
RSA No. 100822 of 2016
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2020
HC-KAR
passed by the Principal Civil Judge & JMFC,
Bagalkot, in O.S.No.198/2010, are hereby
set aside.
(iii)
The plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 and defendant are
entitled for 1/3rd share each in the suit
schedule properties.
(iv)
Draw decree accordingly.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
DR /CT-AN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review