The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. We have heard both the sides at length and perused the evidence on record of the prosecution very carefully. From the evidence on record adduced by the prosecution before the Learned Trial Court below it appears that the appellant in course of his examination failed to discredit the evidence on record of PWs1 and 2 in any manner and other witnesses of the prosecution regarding causing death of the deceased by an axe. Prosecution also has been able to prove the seized weapon of offence which has been marked as Exbt. And the appellant in spite of cross-examination of the other witnesses of the prosecution also could not in any manner raise any doubt to disbelieve the evidence on record of the prosecution. So after hearing of both the sides and from the PM examination report and also the report of SFSL and the evidence on record of PW11, Dr. Sabyasachi Nath, it is crystal clear that by the alleged weapon of offence on the alleged date and time the appellant committed murder of the deceased Rahul Tanti. Thus, it appears to us that the Learned court below rightly and reasonably found the appellant to be guilty and convicted him accordingly under Section 302 of IPC. Although in course of hearing of argument Learned counsel for the appellant took the plea that due to sudden provocation the appellant has committed the offence but in this regard from the record of the Learned court belo…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A(J)No.27 of 2024
1. Sri Dulal Tanti,
Son of Late Shatrughan Tanti,
Village: Purba Sunatala,
P.S. Khowai, District: Khowai Tripura
---- Convict-Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
(Notice to be served through the Ld. Public Prosecutor),
High Court of Tripura,
Agartala, West Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Partha Sarathi Roy, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
Date of Hearing and
date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
12.03.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
[Amarnath Goud, J]
This appeal is filed under Section 374(2) of Cr.P.C.
challenging the judgment and order of conviction and
sentence
Khowai
delivered
Judicial
by
District
Learned
in
Addl.
connection
Sessions
with
Judge,
Case
No.
S.T.(Type-1) 08 of 2021. By the said judgment and order of
conviction and sentence Learned Trial Court has found the
appellant to be convicted under Section 302 of IPC and also
sentenced him to suffer RI for life and also to pay a fine of
Rs.5000/- in default to suffer further RI for six months. It
was also order that the sentence of imprisonment shall run
concurrently.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. P.S. Roy appearing
on behalf of the appellant and also heard Learned Addl. P.P.
Mr. R. Saha appearing on behalf of the respondent.
03.
Taking part in the hearing Learned counsel
appearing for the appellant first of all drawn the attention of
the court that there is delay in lodging the FIR but no
explanation could be given by the prosecution before the
Learned Trial Court regarding delay. Learned counsel further
submitted that in this case charge was framed under
Section
of
IPC
and
to
substantiate
the
charge
prosecution in total adduced 11 numbers of witnesses and
the evidence of the witnesses of the prosecution are also
suffers from infirmities and lot of contradiction. But the
Learned court below failed to appreciate the evidence on
record properly and found the appellant to be guilty.
Learned counsel further drawn the attention of the court
that the appellant is convicted under Section 302 of IPC but
from the evidence on record it will transpire that there was
grave and sudden provocation from the side of the deceased
victim for which the offence was committed. But on the face
of evidence on record there was no scope to presume the
appellant to be guilty for the offence punishable under
Section 302 of IPC and furthermore the evidence on record
does not conclusively show the involvement of the appellant
with the alleged crime. Hence Learned counsel urged for
allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment and
order of sentence delivered by the Learned Trial Court
below.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. P.P. Mr. R.
Saha appearing on behalf of the state-respondent submitted
that from the evidence on record PWs 1 and 2 it is crystal
clear that the appellant has committed murder of the
deceased using axe on the alleged date and time. The
appellant inspite of his thorough cross-examination of the
witnesses of the prosecution save and except some minor
discrepancies could not discredit/dismantle the evidence on
record of the prosecution. Situated thus, the Learned Trial
Court below after considering the evidence on record rightly
and reasonably found the appellant to be guilty and there is
no scope to interfere with the judgment delivered by the
Learned Trial Court and urged for dismissal of this appeal.
05.
In the case at hand the prosecution was set into
motion on the basis of an FIR laid by one Sankari Tanti to
OC, Khowai PS alleging inter alia that on 17.07.2019 at
about 6.15 p.m. in the evening her younger son came back
to house and informed her that Dulal Tanti had abused her
younger son verbally and also had beaten him and used
abusive languages towards him. Hearing that, her elder son
Rahul Tanti went to the house of the accused person in
order to ask him when the accused Dulal Tanti hit the throat
of her son by the axe and that was kept on his room.
Immediately her son Rahul came out with a loud cry by
keeping his hand on his throat. The people of the locality
took him to Khowai Hospital while the attending Doctor
declared him as dead. On the basis of an FIR Khowai PS
Case No.70/2019 under Section 302 of IPC was registered
and the case was endorsed to I.O. was who on completion
of investigation laid chargesheet. The case was committed
to the court of Learned Sessions Judge, Khowai District and
the Learned Sessions Judge on 30.09.2021 framed the
charge against the appellant under Section 302 of IPC to
which he pleaded not guilty of offence and claimed to be
tried. To substantiate the charge prosecution has adduced
in total 11 numbers of witnesses.
06.
PW-1
Sankari
Tanti
is
the
informant.
She
deposed that she filed the case against the accusedappellant. The incident took place about three years back on
a day in the evening when a quarrel took place between her
younger son and Dulal Tanti. Rahul Tanti her elder son
came to interfere in the matter. Dulal Tanti is the maternal
uncle of Rahul Tanti. Thereafter, Sukla Tanti daughter of
Dual has pushed Rahul Tanti and Rahul Tanti fell down.
Thereafter Dulal came with an axe and assaulted Rahul
Tanti on his neck. After that Rahul came out from the P.O.
holding his neck and thereafter he was brought to Khowai
Hospital by an Auto where he succumbed to his injury. On
the day of incident she laid the ejahar and identified her
signature marked as Exbt.1/1. She further stated one
Pranesh had written her ejahar as per her version.
During
cross-examination
excepting
denial
nothing came out relevant.
07.
PW-2, Birendra Tanti deposed that he knew Dulal
Tanti as a neighbour and he also knows Sankari Tanti who is
his close relative and also know Rahul Tanti as his nephew.
Rahul Tanti expired. The incident took place in the evening
approximately three and half years back. That time he saw
his elder brother Govinda Tanti was wrapping clothes
around the neck of Rahul Tanti and that time he heard that
Dulal Tanti struck Rahul Tanti on his neck with an axe. They
immediately brought the victim to the houspital where he
was declared dead. He signed on the Surathal report and
identified his signature on the Surathal report marked
Exbt.2/1.
During cross-examination save and except denial
nothing came out relevant.
08.
PW-3, Mahendra Tanti deposed that Rahul Tanti
is the son of Sankari Tanti who expired. In front of this
witness the I.O. has seized one blood stained axe, one
blood stained blue colour plastic and one broom. The
articles were seized from the house of Dulal Tanti. One
Ramesh Tanti was also present when I.O. seized the same.
He identified his signature on the seizure list marked
Exbt.3/1 and seized articles namely blood stained axe,
blood stained blue colour plastic, blood stained mud and
broom which were marked as Exbt.MO-1 (series). Later on,
he heard that Dulal Tanti killed Rahul Tanti by an axe which
was recovered.
During cross-examination he was confronted with
the statement that he stated to I.O. later on he could know
Dulal Tanti killed Rahul Tanti and the said portion of
statement was not found in the statement recorded by I.O.
Nothing more came out relevant.
09.
PW-4, Biswajit Dey conducted videography in the
P.S in the house of one Tanti at Sunatala. He stated that a
person has been assaulted by an axe and was killed and the
said scene was reconstructed through his videography. He
prepared two numbers of C.D cassette and identified the CD
cassette marked Exbt MO-2 series. Four numbers of
photographs about the place of occurrence which was taken
by him also produced before the court in an envelope which
after identification by the witness was marked as Exbt.MO-3
(series). The seized articles were seized on 24.07.2019 and
during
seizure
Sekhar
Bhattacharjee
and
Ashish
Chakraborty were present and the witness identified his
signature on the seizure list marked Exbt.4/1.
During cross-examination he stated that he did
not
submit
any
licence
before
the
I.O.
regarding
photography. Nothing more came out relevant.
10.
PW-5, Sekhar Bhattacharjee on 24.07.2019 at
about 15.00 hours at Khowai P.S. the I.O. of this case has
seized two C.D cassettes in his presence when reported of
Dainik Sambad, Ashish Chakraborty was also present and
those CD cassettes were seized in connection with murder
case. One person who does videography has given the CD
cassette and he identified his signature in the seizure list
marked Exbt.4/2.
During cross-examination he stated that he was
not examined by I.O.
11.
PW-6, Ashish Chakraborty deposed that he was a
press-reporter by profession. On 24.07.2019 at about 1500
hours at Khowai P.S. the I.O. of this case has seized two CD
cassettes in his presence from one Biswajit Dey @ Badal.
One Shekhar Bhattacharjee was also present with him at
the time of seizure. The witness identified the seizure list
which was marked as Exbt.4/3.
During cross he stated that he was not examined
by the I.O.
12.
PW-7, Pranesh Ranjan Debroy deposed that on
17.07.2019 as per instruction of one Sankari Tanti he had
written one ejahar in his own hand-writing and the contents
of the ejahar was read over to the informant and being
satisfied the informant put her signature in the ejahar. The
witness identified the ejahar marked as Exbt.1 and the
signature marked Exbt.1/2.
During cross-examination he stated that he was
examined by I.O. and further stated he belongs to Ward
No.2 and Dulal Tanti belongs to Ward No.3 and Sankari
Tanti also lives in Ward No.3.
13.
PW-8, Dr. Arnab Debbarma deposed that on
17.07.2019 at around 7.00/7.15 hours in the evening he
was posted as a Medical Officer in Khowai District Hospital.
On that date and time some persons came with an injured
patient and he inquired them and found the name of the
patient as Rahul Tanti aged about 20 years. After that he
could know from the relative of Rahul Tanti and his mother
that around 5/6.00 p.m. due to altercation maternal uncle
of Rahul Tanti namely Dulal Tanti has assaulted Rahul Tanti
with an axe as a result of which Rahul Tanti expired.
During cross nothing came out relevant.
14.
PW-9, Dr. John Debbarma conducted the post-
mortem of the deceased Rahul Tanti. He deposed that on
18.07.2019 he was posted as a Medical Officer of Khowai
District Hospital. On that day he conducted the post-mortem
of the deceased Rahul Tanti and prepared the report. The
patient was brought dead and he conducted the post
mortem report. While conducting the post mortem report
there were frothy blood in right and left ventricles of heart
of the deceased. There was one lacerated would over the
neck going above downwards from left to right across mid
line measuring 8 cm x 0.3 cm x Muscle depth with
involvement of the neck vessels and one linear abrasion
over right fore arm extensor surface size measuring 4 cm x
0.1 cm, 8.6 cm above the wrist. At the end he opined that
the cause of death is due to air embolism homicidal in
nature, time since death 16 to 17 hours. Air embolism
means entry of air in the large vessels of neck resulting in
obstruction of vessels of the heart. Such injury can be
inflicted in the neck with the help of sharp cutting weapon.
The is the said post mortem report in three pages which
marked as Exbt.5 (series) in three pages prepared by him
and he identified his signature marked as Exbt.5/1. He also
identified his signature in the seizure list marked as
Exbt.6/1. He also identified his signature in the command
certificate marked as Exbt.7/1.
During
cross-examination
nothing
came
out
relevant.
15.
PW-10, Md. Chayad Uddin is the I.O. He deposed
that on 17.07.2019 he was posted at Khowai P.S as S.I. On
that day this case was endorsed to him for investigation. He
identified the signature of Debananda Reang being his
colleague marked Exbt.1/3. Said Debananda Reang filled up
the printed FIR form. The witness identified the printed FIR
form marked Exbt.8 as a whole and signature of Debananda
Reang marked as Exbt.8/1. He deposed that the case being
endorsed to him he came out from the police station and
visited Khowai Hospital and consulted with the on duty
Medical Officer and made arrangement for shifting the dead
body of the deceased Rahul Tanti in the morgue. He
prepared the surathal report and identified the said surathal
report marked Exbt.2 as a whole and his signature marked
Exbt.2/2. He went to the P.O. and prepared hand sketch
map with index and recovered axe from the P.O. along with
one jharu. He also seized one plastic article for putting dirty
articles along with blood stained marked by preparing a
seizure list. He identified the seizure list marked Exbt.3 and
his signature marked Exbt.3/2. He further stated that the
said articles were seized in presence of the witnesses
Mahendra Tanti and Ramesh Tanti. He also examined both
Mahendra Tanti and Ramesh Tanti and recorded their
statement under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. He prepared the
hand sketch map with index and identified the same marked
Exbt.9 and signature in the hand sketch map marked
Exbt.9/1. The index of the P.O. marked Exbt.10 and the
signature marked Exbt. 10/1. He further stated that two CD
cassettes
prepared
by
one
Biswajit
Dey,
professional
photographer and he seized those CD identified the seizure
list marked Exbt.4 as a whole and the signature on the
seizure list marked Exbt.4/4. He identified the CD cassette
marked as Exbt.MO-1 (series). He further stated that during
the course of investigation he proceeded towards Sunatala.
He caused arrest of accused. He arranged for reconstruction
of the crime scene and also recorded the statement of the
witnesses Sukla Tanti and Shipra Tanti. The blood of the
deceased over filter paper was taken from the body of the
deceased and in this respect he prepared a seizure list in
presence of seizure list witness and the said seizure list
marked as Exbt.6 as a whole and the signature marked as
Exbt.6/2. On 19.07.2019 at about 1500 hours the then
SDPO Sankar Ch. Das arrived as the PS for arranging a
committee in connection with the case and in presence of
Sankar Ch. Das Swapnajit Sarkar and one Manik Sarkar
went to the P.O. for reconstruction of the crime scene. In
presence of Swapnajit Sarkar and Manik Sarkar one
disclosure statement of the accused was prepared and the
said disclosure statement after identification was marked
Exbt.11 as a whole and the signature in the disclosure
statement was marked Exbt.11/1. He also identified the
pointing out memorandum prepared by him which was
marked as Exbt.12 as a whole and the signature marked as
Exbt.12/1. He also received post-mortem report from Dr.
John Debbarma of Khowai Hospital. He also prepared the
forwarding report of the exhibits in three pages which after
identification was marked as Exbt.13(series). He further
stated that in course of investigation he received Forensic
report
from
the
State
Forensic
Science
Laboratory,
Narsingarh and after receiving the forensic report he laid
chargesheet.
During cross-examination he stated that he has
not marked anything on the body of the axe but the witness
volunteered that in the packet holding the axe he has given
his signature. The CD cassette which marked as Exbt.MO1
(series) bears the signature of Biswajit Dey, the producer of
the C.D cassette. He has not seized the licence of Biswajit
Dey. He further stated that he had not cited Bikram Das
who cordoned the place of occurrence as a witness nor cited
Swapnajit Sarkar, Sankar Ch. Das and Sabyasachi Nath and
Manik Sarkar as a witness of the case.
16.
PW-11 Dr. Sabyasachi Nath deposed that on
24.07.2019 he was posted as Senior Scientific Officer in S.
F. S. L Tripura. On that day their office received one sealed
parcel containing five exhibits marked as A to E in
connection with Khowai P.S Case No.2019/KHW/070 dated
17.07.2019 under Section 302 of IPC and accordingly he
conducted
examination
on
the
said
exhibits
in
biology/serology division of their laboratory during the
period from 25.07.2019 to 29.07.2019. On examination he
opined that blood stains of human origin were detected in
the exhibits A, B, C and D. After examination in the serology
division stained portions of all the five exhibits were
forwarded to DNA typing division for generation of DNA
profile and he identified the report in the single page which
bears his signature marked Exbt.14 as a whole and his
signature marked Exbt.14/1. He further stated that he also
worked with Subhankar Nath, Deputy Director in the same
office and the portion of five exhibits marked Exbts. A, B, C,
D and E which were forwarded from biology serology
division to DNA typing division were subsequently examined
in DNA typing division by Dr. Subhankar Nath and he
submitted his report containing six pages. He further stated
that details of the exhibits, procedure of examination,
results and conclusion are there in his report. He identified
the report of DNA typing division containing six pages
prepared by Dr. Subhankar Nath which was marked as
Exbt.15(series) and the signature of Dr. Subhankar Nath in
each page marked as Exbt.15/1. He further stated that after
examination
of
both
the
report
from
the
biological/serological division and DNA typing division were
clubbed together and forwarded by Dr. H. K. Pratihari,
Director-cum-Chemical examiner of TFSL, Government of
Tripura. He identified the forwarding report forwarded by
Dr. H. K. Pratihari marked Exbt.16 and the signature of Dr.
Pratihari on the forwarding marked as Exbt.16/1.
During cross nothing came out relevant.
These are the sum and substance of the evidence
on record of the prosecution in respect of determination of
charge.
17.
We have heard both the sides at length and
perused the evidence on record of the prosecution very
carefully. From the evidence on record adduced by the
prosecution before the Learned Trial Court below it appears
that the appellant in course of his examination failed to
discredit the evidence on record of PWs1 and 2 in any
manner and other witnesses of the prosecution regarding
causing death of the deceased by an axe. Prosecution also
has been able to prove the seized weapon of offence which
has been marked as Exbt. And the appellant in spite of
cross-examination of the other witnesses of the prosecution
also could not in any manner raise any doubt to disbelieve
the evidence on record of the prosecution. So after hearing
of both the sides and from the PM examination report and
also the report of SFSL and the evidence on record of PW11, Dr. Sabyasachi Nath, it is crystal clear that by the
alleged weapon of offence on the alleged date and time the
appellant committed murder of the deceased Rahul Tanti.
Thus, it appears to us that the Learned court below rightly
and reasonably found the appellant to be guilty and
convicted him accordingly under Section 302 of IPC.
Although in course of hearing of argument Learned counsel
for the appellant took the plea that due to sudden
provocation the appellant has committed the offence but in
this regard from the record of the Learned court below it
appears to us that during trial the appellant did not utter
any
raise
any
point
during
the
cross-examination
of
prosecution of witnesses that due to sudden provocation the
offence was committed. Situated thus, at this stage before
the appellate court, there is no scope to accept the
submission made by the Learned Counsel for the appellant.
So, after hearing both the sides and also after going
through the evidence on record of the prosecution it
appears that the prosecution had been able to prove the
charge levelled against the appellant before the Learned
Trial Court below and accordingly the Learned Trial Court
rightly found the appellant to be guilty and convicted him.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby dismissed on contest. The judgment and order of
sentence and convict delivered by the Learned Trial Court is
hereby upheld and the same is accordingly affirmed.
Send down the LCRs forthwith along with a copy of
this
judgment.
Also
a
copy
of
this
judgment
be
communicated through the Superintendent of Jail, Kendriya
Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh to the appellant convict of this
case.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.04.05
02:16:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review