The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Accordingly, the order dated 22.09.2023 passed by the Learned Court below is hereby set aside.
13. In the result, the Revision Petition filed by the petitioner husband is hereby allowed subject to payment of cost of Rs. 5000/- by the petitioner husband to the respondent wife. The petitioner husband shall appear before the Learned Court below on 16.01.2024 and shall deposit the cost amount. Thereafter, the Learned Court shall make endeavor to dispose of the case latest by 31.01.2024, by giving one last scope to the petitioner husband to adduce his evidence, if any, on that day (16.01.2024) or any other day. On deposit of amount by the petitioner husband the Learned Court below shall accordingly disburse the amount to the respondent wife after obtaining proper receipt.
14. With these observations the Revision Petition is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.REV.P.No.57 OF 2023
1. Shri Dulal Deo
S/o- Lt. Gopal Deo
Resident of Vill- Lalchari, Kartik
Debbarma Para, P.O. & P.S-Ambassa,
Dist.-Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799289
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Alu Deo,
W/o- Shri Ankio Mog
Resident of Vill- Lalchari, Kartik
Debbarma Para, P.O. & P.S-Ambassa
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura, Pin- 799289
---- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of Hearing
& delivery of
:
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
22.12.2023
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Learned Counsel Ms. S. Deb (Gupta) is present for
the petitioner. Today also no step was taken by the
respondent wife inspite of receiving notice and opportunity
being given by the Court to appear.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel for the petitioner at
length. Considered. Accordingly, order/judgment is passed
today.
03.
This present petitioner has preferred this Revision
Petition under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1984
read with Section 397 of 401 of Cr.P.C., challenging the
order dated 22.09.2023 passed by Learned Judge, Family
Court, Ambassa, Dhalai in connection with case No. Criminal
Misc.(M) 08 of 2022.
04.
In course of hearing, being asked by this Court
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that by the said
order Learned Court below has closed the scope for evidence
of the petitioner husband which affected the rights of the
present petitioner because in the proceeding pending before
the Learned Court below the present petitioner has denied
the fact of his marriage with the respondent wife and
Learned Counsel also submitted that if the present petitioner
is not given the scope to adduce evidence in support of his
defence in that case he would seriously suffer an irreparable
loss and would be highly prejudiced. So, for fair ends of
justice, Learned Counsel submitted before the Court to set
aside the order and to allow the petitioner husband to
adduce his evidence before the Learned Court below for
proper adjudication of the proceeding. It
was
further
submitted that in the order of the Learned Court below, it
was mentioned that inspite of allowing opportunity for four
times the petitioner husband could not adduce his evidence
before the Learned Court. But due to absence of the Learned
Presiding
Officer
on
30.05.2023,
21.06.2023
and
25.07.2023, no hearing could take place. So, Learned
Counsel urged before the Court to allow the revision petition
for the sake of justice. She also relied upon few citations in
course of hearing.
05.
Now, before entering into the merit of this
petition, let us see what the legal position is. In this regard,
it is apposite to refer herein below the relevant provision of
Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1984.
“19(4): The High Court may, of its own motion or
otherwise, call for an examine the record of any
proceeding in which the Family Court situate
within its jurisdiction passed an order under
Chapter IX of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(2 of 1974) for the purpose of satisfying itself as to
the correctness, legality or propriety of the order,
not being an interlocutory order, and as to the
regularity of such proceeding.”
From the above legal provision, it is very much clear
that no revision can lie under sub-section (4) of Section 19
of the Family Courts Act against an “interlocutory order”.
06.
In this regard, in course of hearing, Learned
Counsel submitted that although there is bar of „revision‟
against the “interlocutory order”. But by the impugned order,
Learned Court below finally curtailed the right of the
petitioner husband to adduce any evidence and since the
petitioner husband has denied the fact of his marriage by his
written objection before the Learned Court below, in that
case, if the present petitioner husband is not given the scope
to adduce his evidence, he would seriously suffer irreparable
loss and would be seriously prejudiced and thus order dated
22.09.2023 may be treated as final order and relied upon the
following citations.
07.
In Rajendra Kumar v. Rukhmani Bisen, in
Misc. Crl. Case No. 60364 of 2022 dated 02.02.2023
reported in (2023) SCC OnLine MP 2822, Hon‟ble the
Madhya Pradesh High Court in Para Nos. 16 and 17 have
observed as under:
“16. In the case of Aakansha Shrivastava
v. Virendra Shrivastava (2010) 3 MP LJ
151 Division Bench of the Madhya
Pradesh High Court has held as under:"17. Interim maintenance had been
granted under Section 125 Cr.P.C.
and the issue arose whether a
revision petition could be preferred
against that order, as it was alleged
to be interlocutory in nature. It was
held that the order of interim
maintenance was an intermediate
or quasi final order. Analogy was
drawn from Section
397 (2) of
the Cr.P.C. and the pronouncement
of the Supreme Court in Amarnath
v. State of Haryana (1977) 4 SCC
137 : AIR 1977 SC 2185 qua the
said provision was relied upon.
Thus, an order which substantially
affects the rights of an accused and
decides certain rights of the parties
was held not to be an interlocutory
order so as to bar revision."
17. In the case of Aakansha Shrivastava
(Supra) the Division Bench of this Court
further held that any order which affects
right of a person drastically and
substantially, cannot be treated as
interlocutory order and criminal revision
can be preferred under Section 19(4) of
the Family Courts Act against the order
passed on the application for interim
maintenance by the Family Court.
Further more in the Case of Rajesh
Shukla v. Meena Shukla (2005) 2 MP LJ
483, it has been held by Full Bench of
this Court while passing of maintenance
under Section 125 of Cr.P.C. in exercise
of
powers,
against
such
order
under Section 19(4) of Cr.P.C. criminal
revision should be registered. In another
case Nasreen Begum v. The State of
Jharkhand, 2006 Cri L.J. 326 has held
the Section 19(4) of the said Act make
special provision of revision with regard
to orders passed under Section 125 of
Cr.P.C. and thus revisions would lie.”
08.
In Amarnath and others vs. State of Haryana
and Another, in Criminal Appeal No. 124 of 1977 dated
29.07.1977 reported in (1977) 4 SCC 137, Hon‟ble the
Supreme Court in Para No. 6 of the said judgment further
observed as under:
“6. Let us now proceed to interpret the
provisions of Section 397 against the
historical background of these facts.
Sub- section (2) of Section 397 of the
1973 Code may be extracted thus :
"The powers of revision conferred
by Sub- section (1) shall not be
exercised in relation to any
interlocutory order passed in any
appeal, inquiry, trial or other
proceeding."
The main question which falls for
determination in this appeal is as to
what is the connotation of the term
"interlocutory order" as appearing in
sub-section (2) of Section 397 which
bars any revision of such an order by the
High Court. The term "interlocutory
order" is a term of well-known legal
significance and does not present any
serious difficulty. It has been used in
various statutes including the Code of
Civil Procedure. Letters Patent of the
High Courts and other like statutes. In
Webster's
New
World
Dictionary
"interlocutory" has been defined as an
order other than final decision. Decided
cases have laid down that interlocutory
orders to be appealable must be those
which decide 'the rights and liabilities of
the parties concerning a particular
aspect. It seems to us that the term
"interlocutory order" in Section 397
(2) of the 1973 Code has been used in a
restricted sense and not in any broad or
artistic sense. It merely denotes orders
of a purely interim or temporary nature
which do not decide or touch the
important rights, or the liabilities of the
parties. Any order which substantially
affects the right of the accused, or
decides certain rights of the parties
cannot be said to be an interlocutory
order so as to bar a revision to the High
Court against that order, because that
would be against the very object which
formed the basis for insertion of this
particular provision in Section 397 of the,
1973 Code. Thus, for instance, orders
summoning witnesses, adjourning cases,
passing orders for bail, calling for
reports and such other steps in aid of the
pending proceeding, may no doubt
amount to interlocutory orders against
which no revision would lie under
Section 397 (2) of the 1973 Code. But
orders which are matters of moment and
which affect or adjudicate the rights of
the accused or a particular aspect of the
trial cannot be said to be interlocutory
order so as to be outside the purview of
the revisional jurisdiction of the High
Court.“
Referring the aforesaid citations Learned Counsel,
drawn the attention of this Court that on 22.09.2023
although the petitioner husband was present before the
Learned Court below but he sought time for adducing witness
which was rejected by the Learned Court below and if the
present petitioner husband, who has denied the fact of his
marriage with the respondent wife is not given the scope to
adduce evidence to sustain his defence properly then the
present petitioner husband would be seriously prejudiced and
there would be miscarriage of justice. So, Learned Counsel
submitted before the Court to set aside that order for the
sake of justice.
09.
I have perused Section 19(4) of the Family Courts
Act. The law is very clear that in respect of “interlocutory
order” there is no legal scope to file any revision petition
before the appropriate Court under Section 19(4) of the
Family Courts Act. I have also gone through the principles of
the aforesaid citations relied upon by the petitioner husband.
It appears to me that the Learned Court below by that order
finally closed the right of the petitioner to adduce evidence in
support of his defence.
10.
Thus, it appears to me that by the said order the
right of the petitioner husband to adduce evidence has been
affected/closed, finally, which in my considered view cannot
be treated as an “interlocutory order”. Hence, I am of the
considered opinion that revision petition would lie against
that order before the Court. Now, coming to the merit of the
petition, it appears that by order dated 25.04.2023 after
recording evidence of the respondent wife the case was
posted for cross-examination of OPWs on 30.05.2023. But on
30.05.2023, the Learned Presiding Officer was on leave. So,
the case was further posted for cross-examination of OPWs
on 22.09.2023 and on that scheduled day (although as per
order sheet it appears that the order was passed on
21.06.2023) due to absence of Presiding Officer the case was
further posted for cross-examination of the OPWs on
25.07.2023. And again on that day also the Presiding Officer
of the concerned Court was on leave, so, the case was again
posted for cross-examination of OPWs on 24.08.2023 and on
that day the present petitioner sought time to adduce
evidence which was considered fixing 22.09.2023 as final
chance for OPWs and on 22.09.2023 the petitioner O.P
although present but his witnesses were absent. So, Learned
Court below rejected the petition and posted the case for
hearing of arguments on 19.10.2023 and after that on
19.10.2023 the case was further posted for judgment/ final
order on 29.11.2023. By this time, the record was called for.
11.
From the aforesaid orders, it appears that the
proceeding before the Learned Court below was delayed not
for the fault of the petitioner husband but due to absence of
the regular Presiding Officer and the case could not be
disposed of. On 22.09.2023 the petitioner husband although
appeared but he could not appear with his witnesses. On that
day, Learned Court below could record his evidence also and
could grant adjournment for adducing witnesses, if any, on
the next day, but that was not done. More so, since the
petitioner
husband
has
denied
his
marriage
with
the
respondent wife, so, it appears, by that order, the right of
the petitioner husband has been affected which ought to
have considered by the Learned Court below. So for proper
adjudication of the proceeding before the Learned Court
below, it appears that one more opportunity be given to the
petitioner husband of this Revision Petition to adduce
evidence. The respondent wife inspite of serving of notice did
not
appear the
Court. So, considering the facts and
circumstances, this Court feels it prudent to set aside the
said order dated 22.09.2023 passed by the Learned Court
below.
12.
Accordingly, the order dated 22.09.2023 passed
by the Learned Court below is hereby set aside.
13.
In the result, the Revision Petition filed by the
petitioner husband is hereby allowed subject to payment of
cost of Rs. 5000/- by the petitioner husband to the
respondent wife. The petitioner husband shall appear before
the Learned Court below on 16.01.2024 and shall deposit the
cost amount. Thereafter, the Learned Court shall make
endeavor to dispose of the case latest by 31.01.2024, by
giving one last scope to the petitioner husband to adduce his
evidence, if any, on that day (16.01.2024) or any other day.
On deposit of amount by the petitioner husband the Learned
Court below shall accordingly disburse the amount to the
respondent wife after obtaining proper receipt.
14.
With these observations the Revision Petition is
disposed of.
15.
A copy of this order be communicated to the
Learned Court below immediately along with the LCR.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2023.12.22 17:47:18
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review