Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 728 OF 2024
Sri Diptanu Deb,
Son of Late Mantu Deb, resident of Bhattapukuk,
P.O. -A.D. Nagar,P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
---Petitioner.
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the
Secretary, Secondary Education Department, Government of Tripura,
P.O.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura.
2. Director, Secondary Education,
Office of the Directorate of Secondary Education,
Office Lane, near court complex, Agartala,
West Tripura.
3. Secretary, Managing Committee,
Ramkrishna Vivekananda Vidyamandir (H.S.+2 stage) School,
Dhaleswar, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. Headmaster,
Ramkrishna Vivekananda Vidyamandir(H.S.+2 stage) School,
Dhaleswar, Agartala, West Tripura.
---Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. G.K. Nama, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Sarkar, Advocate.
Date of hearing and date of
delivery of Judgment & Order : 25.11.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. G.K. Nama, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. H. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the
State-respondents.
2.
Brief facts of the case of the petitioner are that the father of
the petitioner, namely, Mantu Deb, a Group ‘D’ employee who was
serving at Ramkrishna Vivekananda Vidyamandir (H.S.+2 stage) School,
Dhaleswar, Agartala, West Tripura, expired on 02.02.2005 in harness.
The petitioner was minor at the relevant point of time and after attaining
his majority, as asserted by him, he submitted an application for a job
under the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme on 28.02.2011, but till 2018, no
response was received by him from the respondents in this regard.
3.
Suddenly, in the year 2018, he received an information from
a reliable source that the respondents had decided to provide a job under
the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme to one Sri Abhijit Deb whose father was also
working in the said school and died-in-harness in the year 2016.
Thereafter, he met respondents Nos. 3 and 4 to know about the fate of his
application dated 28.02.2011. Then, the respondent Nos. 3 & 4 informed
him that they had sent the said application to the office of the respondent
No.2. The petitioner thereafter approached the respondent No.2
wherefrom it was replied that the said application had reached to their
office long ago and therefore it would be difficult for them to find it out
and accordingly they requested the petitioner to submit a fresh
application. Then, on 23.02.2018 itself he submitted a fresh application
along with an undertaking by the other dependent family members in
compliance with the required formalities. Other related informations
were also submitted in prescribed forms.
4.
As no response was received from the respondent No.2, he
submitted one representation on 15.03.2018 to them and thereafter an
Advocate Notice was also sent on 26.03.2018 in this regard. In response
to the said Advocate’s Notice, the Director of Secondary Education
communicated him that his application dated 23.02.2018 was rejected on
the ground that the same was not preferred within one year after the
death of the government servant.
5.
The petitioner thereafter filed a writ petition in the year
2018 bearing No. WP(C) No.586 of 2018, which was subsequently
withdrawn by him on 12.07.2022 with a liberty to seek remedies under
law. After such withdrawal of the said writ petition in the year 2022, the
present writ petition has been filed on 25.11.2024 with the following
prayers:
“i. Issue rule asking the respondents to show cause as to
why a writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof shall not be
issued directing them to provide employment on compassionate
ground under the “Die-in-harness” scheme.
ii. Issue rule directing the respondents to provide
employment to the petitioner on compassionate ground under the
“Die-on-harness” scheme.
iii. After hearing the parties make the rule in terms of
Sl.No.(i) to (ii) above absolute;
iv. Pass any other order/orders as may be deemed fit and
proper for ends of justice.”
6.
Learned counsel, Mr. G.K.Nama submits that after the
petitioner filed his first application on 28.02.2011 seeking the job under
the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme after attaining his majority, the respondents
did not respond to it and after he got the information of providing a job
to another person, immediately he went to the office of the respondent
Nos. 3 & 4 to enquire about the fate of his application in this regard.
Therefore, according to learned counsel, Mr. Nama, the respondents were
in gross default by not considering his first application submitted on
28.02.2011. Learned counsel, Mr. Nama also submits that the second
application was filed in the year 2018 as per the advice of the respondent
No.2, and as soon as it was rejected, the petitioner approached the High
Court by filing the above said writ petition without any delay. Therefore,
the petitioner was not at default on any occasion in pursuing his cause.
Learned counsel also tries to convince this Court that the scheme for
providing a job on compassionate appointment is a beneficial policy of
the government and therefore, the writ petition may be allowed with a
direction to the respondents for providing a job to the petitioner under the
‘Die-in-harness’ scheme.
7.
Learned counsel, Mr. Sarkar, appearing for the respondent
Nos. 1 and 2 argues that when the fresh application was submitted on
23.02.2018, the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme, published by the State under
Notification dated 26th December, 2015 was in force and there is a
limitation
contained
in
that
scheme
that
such
a
claim
for
employment/financial assistance under such scheme should be submitted
before the appropriate authority within 1(one) year from the date of death
of the government. But in the instant case, such an application was filed
in the year 2018 and therefore, the respondents were justified in rejecting
the claim of the petitioner.
8.
This Court has given due consideration to the submissions
of learned counsel of both sides and also has gone through the materials
placed in the record including the above said ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme
notified on 26.12.2015.
9.
It appears that the deceased died in the year 2005 and
according to the petitioner, he became major in the year 2011 and
thereafter he submitted one application in the year 2011 and another
fresh application in the year 2018. The first question, which is required to
be taken into consideration is whether the rules which were prevailing at
the time of death of the deceased will be applicable or the rules which
were in force at the time when the application of such compassionate
appointment was filed, will be applicable in this case. The three-Judge
Bench of the Apex Court in the case of N.C. Santhosh Vs. State of
Karnataka & Ors, AIR 2020 SC 140 : (2020) 7 SCC 617, held that the
norms as prevailing on the date of consideration of the application for
such a compassionate appointment should be the basis for consideration
of claim of compassionate appointment. The relevant paragraph Nos. 19
and 20 of this decision are extracted here-in-below:
“19. In the most recent judgment in State of H.P. v. Shashi
Kumar [State of H.P. v. Shashi Kumar, (2019) 3 SCC 653 : (2019) 1
SCC (L&S) 542] the earlier decisions governing the principles of
compassionate appointment were discussed and analysed. Speaking
for the Bench, Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, J. reiterated that appointment to
any public post in the service of the State has to be made on the basis
of principles in accord with Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and
compassionate appointment is an exception to the general rule. The
dependants of a deceased government employee are made eligible by
virtue of the policy on compassionate appointment and they must fulfil
the norms laid down by the State's policy.
20. Applying the law governing compassionate appointment culled
out from the abovecited judgments, our opinion on the point at issue is
that the norms, prevailing on the date of consideration of the
application, should be the basis for consideration of claim for
compassionate appointment. A dependant of a government employee,
in the absence of any vested right accruing on the death of the
government employee, can only demand consideration of his/her
application. He is, however, disentitled to seek consideration in
accordance with the norms as applicable, on the day of death of the
government employee.”
10.
In view of above said decision, the claim of the petitioner
for such job under the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme is being examined in the
light of the relevant scheme which was prevailing at the time of
consideration of his application. In fact, when his application dated
23.02.2018 was being considered by the respondents, the scheme as
admitted by both the parties, published under the Notification dated
26.12.2015 was in force. It appears that Rule 9 of the said scheme put an
embargo to the job seeker that claims for employment/financial
assistance under the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme should be submitted before
the appropriate authority within one year from the date of death of the
government servant, and the eligibility in all respect shall be determined
as on the date of death of the concerned employee.
11.
From the materials as placed in the record, it also appears
that after the petitioner applied for such a job under the ‘Die-in-harness’
scheme on 28.02.2011, he did not pursue the matter till 2018 though
according to him, the respondents did not respond to his such
application. Even, during the period of at least 7 years i.e. upto 2018, he
did not approach any Court or authority pursuing his such claim.
Therefore, his first application is not tenable both on the ground of delay
and laches and also on the ground that he without pressing first
application, submitted a fresh application again in the year 2018.
12.
It is also evident that after he got information of providing a
job to a third party in the year 2018 in the said school, suddenly he
became alert and started searching about the fate of his previous
application. Therefore, his laches or inaction in pursuing his own cause
for such a long period could not be dislodged by him. Even his
subsequent application dated 23.02.2018 also creates the impression that
it was not a communication made in continuation of his previous
application filed in the year 2011, rather, said application was filed
making a fresh claim for such job under the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme.
Therefore, necessary informations through prescribed formats with the
required undertaking were also submitted by him along with said
application.
13.
Learned counsel, Mr. Nama relies on a decision of a
Division Bench of this Court in the case of Subham Dey Vrs. The State
of Tripura & Ors.(WA 45 of 2014), decided on 22.11.2018, wherein, on
the date of death of the deceased employee, the petitioner was aged about
7 years or so, and on attaining the age of majority within stipulated
period of one year, he submitted application for the benefit under the
‘Die-in-harness’ scheme. In that situation, the Court held that the action
of the State in rejecting the petitioner’s application on the ground of
delay was unsustainable at law. However, in distinction thereto, in our
case in hand, the fresh application was submitted by the petitioner in the
year 2018 i.e. much beyond the period of one year of his attaining
majority.
14.
It is fact that in the year 2018 itself he submitted writ
petition before this Court on rejection of his application by the
respondents submitted in the year 2018 but, after withdrawal of the said
writ petition on 12.07.2022, there is a delay of further two years in
approaching the Court through the present writ petition.
15.
Therefore, it is also evident that his approach was again very
lackadaisical when he withdrew the previous writ petition.. Above all, as
discussed, the scheme prevailing during the year 2018 itself create a bar
to provide any job to the petitioner under the ‘Die-in-harness’ scheme as
it was submitted much after the stipulated period of one year. Thus, the
petitioner is not entitled to the relief as prayed for.
16.
In view of the above, the writ petition is dismissed. Interim
application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.11.27 18:23:44 +05'30'
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review