Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 146 of 2023
Sri Dipak Deb, Slo Sri Jagadish Chandra Deb, Vill. Dhaja Nagar, P.O. & P.S.
R.K. Pur, Tepania, Udaipur, Dist. GomatiTripura, Pin-799120.
...e....
VERSUS
Petitioner(s).
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Rural Development
Department, Government of Tripura, Secretariat Building, P.O. Secretariat,
P.S. NCC, Agartala,Dist. West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The D.M. & Collector, Udiapur, P.O & P.S.Radhalkishorepur,Gomati
District, Tripura State, Pin-799120.
3. The Chief Executive Officer (D.M. & Collector),
District Rural
Development Agency (DRDA), Udaipur, P.O & P.S.- Radhakishorepur,
GomatiDistrict, Tripura State, Pin-799120.
4. Project Director, (ADM & Collector), District Rural
Development Agency
(DRDA), Udaipur, P.O & P.S.- Radhakishorepur,Udaipur, Gomati District,
Tripura State, Pin-799120.
5. Zilla Sabhadipati, Gomati Zilla Parishad DRDA,Gomati
Tripura.
District, Udaipur,
...Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. A. R. Barman,
Advocate.
:Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
18/08/2023
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
[2]
As per the case of the petitioner he has
cum Driver from 27.12.1999 in District Rural
been engaged as Class-IV
Development Agency (DRDA),
South Tripura now DRDA, Gomati 1ripura with a
specific assignment of
driver. He claims to have been regularized in Group-D from
24.12.2012 but
Without any specific post or designation. He has continued to perform his duty
as driver. Despite several
representationsmade for promotion to the post of
driver and recommendationof the Departmental Promotion
Committee (DPC)
under the DRDA, the petitioner has not been
granted promotion till date.
Petitionerhad earlier approachedthis Court in WP(C) No. 197 of 2021
redressal of his grievances. The learned writ Court vide order dated
i.e. Annexure-1 disposed of the writ
seeking
11.05.2022
petition in the following manner:
"Having appreciated the records, this court is of the view
that the newly constituted Departmental Promotion
Committee (DPC) has recommendedonly the name of the
petitioner but mere recommendation does not create any
right in favour of any selected person to get
the
appointment. But such recommendationshall be given due
weightage and, thereafter, the order of appointment shall
be issued. The respondents have not
disputed any factual
matrix as led by the petitioner. As such, this court is
persuaded to direct the respondent No.3 to consider the
promotion of the petitionerwithin a period of 6(six) weeks
from today.
Acopy of thisorder shall be
the respondentsforthwith.
furnished by the petitionerto
In terms of the above, this writ
petition stand disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs."
|3]
It is the case of the
petitioner that vide impugned order dated
13.07.2022,the claim of the petitioner tor promotion to the
driver, even after recommendationof the
Departmental Promotion Committee
(DPC), has been rejected on the plea that the post of
in DRDA, Gomati.
higher post of
driver has been abolished
Therefore,the petitionerhas approachedthis Court.
Mr. A. R. Barman, learned counsel for the petitionersubmits that
petitionerhas been working all along in the DRDA,Gomati District and being
made to work as a driver, though as per the respondents there is no post of
dnver. In fact, it is a compulsorv exaction of work from an employee, which is
against the basic tenets of service jurisprudenceby the State, which is suppOsed
to be a modelemployer. In such circumstances,the respondent-department
cannot refuse to accede to the recommendationmade by the DPCof the DRDA
for his promotionto the post of driver. Therefore,the impugnedcommunication
may be set aside and a direction be issued upon the respondents to accord
approval to the DPC recommendationand appoints/promotehim as adriver.
Counter affidavithas been filed by the respondentsNo.1 to 4. The
respondentshave taken the following stands at paragraph 7, 8, 9 and 10 which
is extracted hereunder:
7.That, with regard to statementsmade in para 2 of the writ
petition,I say that, there is no such post in the form of DRW
Driver has been created in the DRDA. But there is a post Gr
D DRW in DRDA Gomati, where the Petitionerwas engaged
as DRW Gr-D employee.
8. That, with regard to para 4, Isay that, no post was created
in DRDA, Gomati for engagement DRW cum Driver as
stated by the petitioner. Department is not avware bout the
appointmentof SriDipak Deb as DRW cum Driver. It is also
beyond the Jurisdiction of Project Director, DRDA, Gomati
to appointment Sri Deb as DRW cum Driver without prior
approval of the Rural Development Department. The
Petitioner was enrolled as DRW Driver of DRDA Gomati of
SI. No.700 of the memo issued from the Finance
Department
vide No.F. 10(12)-FIN/(G/207(Part-I)dated
15.12.2012
with regulationof service of DRWs/Casualetc
workers of the
DRDA, Gomatiin the year 2012.
received the proposal from the
9. That, the department has
Sri Dipak Deb,
DRDA, Gomati to regularized service of
anything mentioned
DRW Driver as Group-D without having
Driver. Accordingly,his
that he was appointed as DRW cum
Department as Group-D
proposal was sent to the Finance
Department Memorandum
with the approval of the Finance
10(12)-FIN/(GY2007(Part-I)dated 15.12.2012 of
Vide No.F.
prior approval
the Joint Secretary,Finance Department with
Department File No. F.11(25)RD
of the RD
SGSY/2012(PY1119-37on dated 09.12.2012.
writ petition I
That, in response to para 5 of the
of the petitioner,a
say that., after receiving the representation
10.
DPC was held on 30.08.2020
where the name of the
promotion to the
petitioner as Group-D was considered for
Administrative
post of Driver subject to approval of the
to the
Departmnent. And the same was communicated
District)
Chairman (Zilla Sabhadipati,Zilla parishad, Gomati
Gomati
DRDA,
vide
letter
No.
1(160)
DRDA
(G)/ESTT/2012-13/48-49dated 21.08.2020. The Chairman
(Zilla Sabhadipati, Zilla Parishad, Gomati District), has
vetted vide his letter No. 1(2) DRDA (G)/ESTT/2018-19/66
67, dated 26.08.2020 with direction to take necessary action
letter
as per rule. Accordingly after receiving the aforesaid
from the Chairman the matter was sent to the Director
(Projects), SLMC of SGSY, RD Department vide this office
letter
No.1(160)DRDA(GVESTT/2012-13/70-71 dated
08.09.2020.
Copy of the vide letter No.1(160)DRDA(G)/ESTT/2012
13/48-49 dated 21.08.2020 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/1.
Copy of the vide letter No.1(2) DRDA (G)/ESTT/2018
19/66-67,dated 26.08.2020 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/2.
Copy of the letter No.1(160)DRDA (GYESTT/2012
13/70-71 dated 08.09.2020 is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/3.
10.That, in response to para 6, 7 and 8 of the writ petition I
say that, DRDA, Gomati had constituted DPC and
recommended for promotion of the petitioner,Group-D to the
post of Driver, Group-C without prior permission of RD
Departmentor Finance Department.It is also to be mentioned
Gomati DRDA was
here that the temporary post of Driver in
per
remained vacant since February, 2005 and abolished as
issued of Finance Department vide. No.9(2)
the memo
FIN(C)/2017/2265-2409, dated 07. 12.2019. The State
Government vide Memo No.F.2(24)/GA(P&T)/05/Voll-II)
dated 01.04.2017 decided to hold up promotion till disposal
of the petitions pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court or
until further order whichever is earlier.
Copy of the Memo vide No.9(2)-FIN(C)/2017/2265-2409,
dated 07.12.2019 is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure
R/4.
Copy of the Memo vide No.F.2(24)/GA(P&T)Y05/Voll-II)
dated 01.04.2017 is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure
RI5.
[6]
It is also averred in the later paragraphs that in the judgment in
WP(C) 197 of 2021 this Court clearly observed that mere recommendationof
DPC does not constitute any right of promotion.DPC, DRDA Gomati was
constituted on 20.08.2020to recommend the promotion of Sri Deb but they
have not followed the due process as the State Government has held up
promotions till disposal of the petitions pending in the Supreme Court.
Meanwhile, the promotional post of driver has got abolished in DRDA,
Gomati.Therefore, the benefit of promotion to the post of driver may not be
extended to SriDipak Deb, Group-D, DRDA, at Gomati.
(7]
It has been further averred that DRDA
Administration Schenme
was discontinued with effect from 01.04.2022 by the Ministry of Rural
Development, Govt. of India vide letter No.R20015/2/2020-DRDA,It is also
stated that the petitioner was appointed under DRDA as Daily Rated Worker
(DRW). He was regularized on 24.12.2012 as Group-D employee. However,
after abolition of DRDA, the Ministry has not released any fund and disbursed
the monthly salary of all the staffs of DRDA who were deputed in Tripura
Livelihood Mission (TRLM) as well as in Rural Development Department.
Under the above circumstances, the Department is not in a position to bear the
extra financial burden by consideringpromotionof the petitioner.
Mr. K. De, learned additional GovernmentAdvocate relying upon
[8]
the contents of the counter affidavit has strongly opposed the prayer of the
petitionerfor grantof pronmotion to the post of driver in DRDA, Gomati on
the
basis of recommendationof the DPCof DRDA, Gomati District.It is submitted
that learned writ Court has on the previous occasion also observed that mere
recommendation by the
DPC does not create a legal right for seeking
promotionon the post of driver in DRDA, Gomati District.
[9]
Ihave considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the pleadings placed from the records. The facts and
documents noticed hereinabove, do clearly make out that the DRDA
AdministrationScheme has been discontinuedwith effect from 01.04.2022 by
the Ministry of Rural Development, Govt. of India. The Ministry has not
released any fund or disbursed the monthly salary of all the staffs of DRDA
who were deputed in 'Tripura Rural LivelihoodMission as well as in Rural
Development Department. The Department has also taken a stand that the
DRDAcould not have recommended the promotion of petitioner to the Rural
Development Department without its approval in the absence of any sanction
nost of driver in DRDA or any financial burden being
undertaken by the
departmentfor payment of salary and other
allowancesto such an employee of
DRDA. The employeesof DRDA are not in the
[10]
rolls of the State Government.
It, therefore,appears that only on the basis of
recommendationof a
DPCconstitutedby DRDA, the claim of petitioner for
promotionto the post of
driver has been recommended to the Rural Development
Department. Since
there is no post in existence in the DRDA for driver and the DRDA
AdministrationScheme has been discontinuedwith effect from 01.04.2022 by
the Ministryof Rural Development,Governmentof India, the respondent State
Authorities cannot be saddled with the financial liability and administrative
responsibilityto bear the burden which is likely to be created on account of
promotion of an employee of the DRDA to the post of driver which is non
existent. The stand of the respondents-State, therefore, appears to be
unambiguoushaving sound legal basis. In such circumstances,as has also been
observed by the writ Court in the previous writ petition i.e. WP(C) No.197 of
2021, writ petitioner cannot claim a legally enforceable right for being
promotedto the post of driver in DRDA. As such, this Court does not find any
merit in the writ petition.
[11]
However, at the end Mr. Barman, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that inthe absence of a regular sanctionedvacant post of
driver, the DRDA may be directed not to compel the petitionerto work on a
nonexistentpost of driver in the DRDA. Since the observationsand the reasons
recorded hereinabove are confined to the main relief prayed for by the writ
petitionerregardingpromotionto the post of driver in DRDA, Gomati Distriet,
this Court does not intend to make any observationson the instant plea of the
petitioner.It is for the petitionerto raise his grievances in this regard before the
competent authority of DRDA, Gomati District who may take a call thereupon,
as per law.
[12]
As such, the writ petition,being devoid of merit, is dismissed.
Pending application(s),if any, also stands disposed of.
Apaseuk teumas Sugk
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH),CJ
Munna S
MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2023.08.23 16:36:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review