Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.541 of 2022
Dhananjoy Roy Mondal
S/o. Late Haribal Roy Mandal,
resident of Kumkaristilla Government Quarter No.1
at Kumaritilla Quarter Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Tripura Legislative Assembly Secretariat
represented by its Secretary at Secretariat Complex, P.O. Secretariat,
Agartala, Pin- 799010
2. The Additional Secretary,
Tripura Legislative Assembly, Secrtetariat Complex, P.O. Secretariat,
Agartala, Pin- 799010
3. Sri Abhijit Debbarma,
Section Officer (ad-hoc), Tripura Legislative Assembly, Secretariat
Complex, P.O. Secretariat, Agartala, Pin- 799010
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. C. S. Sinha, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
05.01.2024
Whether fit for reporting
No
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. C. S. Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondent nos.1 and 2.
2.
The grievance of the petitioner, Sri Dhananjoy Roy Mondal
(SC) is that he being senior to one Sri Abhijit Debbarma (ST) has not been
promoted to the post of Section Officer from the post of Office
Superintendent (Feeder Post). Admittedly, there is no dispute in the final
seniority list as on 28.02.2019 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition) wherein the
name of the petitioner, Sri Dhananjoy Roy Mondal appeared at serial no.4
and the name of Sri Abhijit Debbarma, respondent no.3 herein appeared at
serial no.5.
3.
It transpires from the record that the men at serial no.1 and 2,
both belonging to scheduled tribe community had been promoted on ad-hoc
basis to the post of Section Officer by creating supernumerary post without
disturbing the roster for UR category candidates. It is also revealed that the
man at serial no.3 of the said seniority list, namely, Sri Sanjib Biswas (SC)
was promoted to the post of Section Officer from its feeder post on ad hoc
basis against the resultant vacancy under SC category. Subsequently, in
another resultant vacancy against ST category, Sri Abhijit Debbarma was
promoted as Section Officer from the post of Office Superintendent. In the
additional counter affidavit filed by the respondents-Tripura Legislative
Assembly (for short, “TLA”), it emanates that there was no scope to
promote Sri Dhananjoy Roy Mondal (SC), the petitioner herein against the
resultant vacancy(ST) as per rule. Here lies the grievance of the petitioner.
4.
Mr. Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioner has candidly
submitted that when Harinanda Hrangkhawal (ST) and Sishir Kumar Reang
(ST) were promoted to the post of Section Officer, there were no vacant
posts for filling up the ST Posts, but to enforce the ad-hoc promotion policy
made by the Government of Tripura, the respondents-TLA felt it necessary
to create supernumerary post to promote Shri Hrangkhawal and Sri Reang
since they were senior officers than those of Sanjib Biswas, Sri Dhananjoy
Roy Mondal and Sri Abhijit Debbarma.
5.
It is pertinent to mention herein that at that point of time, no UR
category candidate was available to fill up the vacant posts under the UR
category.
6.
At this juncture, the statements made by respondents-TLA in
their additional counter affidavit dated 07.09.2023 may be reproduced
hereunder:“2. That, with regard to paragraphs-1 to 5 of the petitioner, I say
that as per record the petitioner is senior to Sri Abhijit Debbarma
who was promoted to the post of Section officer as per the
recommendation of DPC against resultant vacancy after carefully
examining recruitment rules and other service records. It is also
fact that he has made a representation for his promotion.
3. That, with regard to paragraphs-6 to 12 of the petition, I say
that as per records, there are 3 vacancies in the post of Section
Officer (UR-2; SC-1).
As per minute of DPC meeting, Sri Harinanda
Hrangkhwal(ST), Head Assistant and Sri Shishir Kr. Reang(ST),
Head Assistant have been promoted to the post of Section Officer
after creating supernumerary posts against 2 UR vacancies as there
were no UR candidates available.
In addition, Sri Sanjib Biswas(SC), Head Assistant has been
promoted to the post of Section Officer against the vacant post of
SC.
Consequent upon the promotion of Sri Rakesh
Debbarma(ST), Section Officer to the post of Under Secretary
against 1(UR) vacant post, Sri Abhijit Debbarma(ST), Head
Assistant has been promoted to the post of Section Officer(ST) as
recommended by the DPC. There has been no scope to promote Sri
Dhananjoy Roy Mandal(SC) against the resultant vacancy(ST) as
per rule.”
7.
According to Mr. Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioner, the
respondents-TLA to implement the policy of the Government of Tripura
ought to promote the petitioner by creating supernumerary post since no post
fell vacant under SC category before the promotion of the respondent no.3,
Sri Abhijit Debbarma to the post of Section Officer on ad-hoc basis.
8.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties.
9.
Before I delve into the merits of the submissions of learned
counsel appearing for the parties, I deem it necessary to extract relevant
portions laid down in the notification dated 22.06.2021 issued by the
General Administration (Personnel & Training) Department, Government of
Tripura to effectuate the promotion of the employees of the Government of
Tripura to bring efficiency in administration. At Para 8(ii) of the said
notification, it is laid down that- “Ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be
considered keeping in view of the latest available seniority list of the feeder
post/grade subject to condition that he/she is otherwise suitable & eligible
for promotion”. Under Para 8(v), it is stated that- “To create supernumerary
posts, administrative Department shall assess the number of posts to be
created to materialize the promotion as per above procedure and inform the
total number of posts so determined to Finance Department. No further
concurrence of Finance Department is required”. It is further stated under
Para 8(vii) that- “The ad-hoc appointment on promotion as per guidelines
illustrated above shall be started in the highest grade of a cadre/service
first. Due to such promotion, the resultant vacancies shall be added with the
vacancies in the lower grade, and to be filled up subsequently.
From the above relevant policies of the Government under the
notification dated 22.06.2021, it is clear that Government can create
supernumerary posts in addition to the number of posts to materialize the
promotion of the employees.
10.
Coming to the context of the case, the respondents-TLA had
created 2 supernumerary posts to promote the senior most persons holding
the post of Office Superintendent considering the fact that they were the
senior most persons as per the final seniority list, and furthermore, at that
point of time there were no vacancies for ST category candidates for
promotion to the post of Section Officer. Two posts were found vacant
against UR category candidates. But, no candidate was available to fill up
the post under UR category. In that situation, the respondents-TLA did not
want to disturb the roster position meant for UR category persons and they
created supernumerary posts for effectuating the promotion of Sri Harinanda
Hrangkhawal (ST) and Sri Sishir Kumar Reang (ST). During the process,
one post of Section Officer under SC category fell vacant and respondentsTLA had filled up this post by Sri Sanjib Biswas whose name appeared at
serial no.3 of the final seniority list dated 28.02.2019. Subsequently, one
Rakesh Debbarma was promoted to the post of Under Secretary from the
post of Section Officer resulting one vacancy of ST category candidate. To
fill up this resultant vacancy under ST category candidate, the respondentsTLA did not consider the promotion of the petitioner Sri Dhananjoy Roy
Mondal who belongs to SC category, but, considered the promotion of
Abhijit Debbarma who was junior to the petitioner.
11.
In my considered view, to promote Abhijit Debbarma to the
post of Section Officer before the promotion of the petitioner did not follow
the terms of the promotion policy laid down under Para 8(ii) and 8(v) of the
notification dated 22.06.2021, vis-à-vis the precedence made by the
respondents-TLA in the cases of consideration of promotion of Harinanda
Hrangkhawal and Sri Sishir Kumar Reang. Admittedly as per the final
seniority list dated 28.02.2019, the petitioner was senior to Abhijit
Debbarma, so following the precedence made by respondents-TLA they
ought to have considered the promotion of Dhananjoy Roy Mondal, the
petitioner herein by way of creating another supernumerary post.
In the opinion of this Court, on this aspect, the submission of
Mr. Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioner appears to be reasonable.
12.
Keeping in mind the precedence made by the respondents-TLA
in promoting Sri Harinanda Hrangkhawal and Sri Sishir Kumar Reang, I
direct the respondents-TLA to apply their mind on this aspect and consider
the promotion of Sri Dhananjoy Roy Mondal, the petitioner herein by
creating supernumerary post of Section Officer. Accordingly, I remit the
matter to respondents-TLA to revisit the grievance of the petitioner since it
appears to be genuine, considering the precedence made by the respondentsTLA in promoting Harinanda Hrangkhawal and Sri Sishir Kumar Reang
maintaining the seniority position at the level of Office Superintendent from
which promotion was made to the post of Section Officer.
13.
The entire exercise shall be made within a period of 3(three)
months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
With the aforesaid observation and directions, the instant writ
petition stands disposed.
JUDGE
Digitally signed
SANJAY
SANJAY byGHOSH
2024.01.12
GHOSH Date:
17:08:16 +05'30'
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review