Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.23 of 2025
1. Sri. Dhananjay Das, son of Sri Pokan Das, resident of villageBattali, P.O. Battali, P.S. Sonamura, Sub Division-Sonamura, DistrictSepahijala, PIN-799115, aged about 32 years.
2. Sri Suklal Debnath, son of Sri Ripan Debnath, resident of VillageLaxmipur, P.O. Barpathari, P.S.Belonia, Sub Division-Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura, PIN-799155, aged about 32 years.
3. Sri Biswajit Debnath, son of Sri Matilal Debnath, resident of
Village-Sachiram Bari, P.O. Thakurchara, P.S. Baikhora, Sub DivisionSantir Bazar, District-South Tripura, PIN-799141, aged about 33
years.
4. Sri Mitan Das, son of Sri Anil Chandra Das, resident of VillageSouth Nalchar, P.O. Nalchar, P.S. Melaghar, Sub Division- Sonamura,
District-Sepahijala, PIN-799115, aged about 37 years.
5. Sri Hiranya Jamatia, son of Sri Padma Mohan Jamatia, resident
of Village-Atharabola, P.O. Manikya, P.S. Killa, Sub Division-Udaipur,
District-Gomati, PIN-799114, aged about 42 years.
6. Sri Dipankar Ghosh, son of Sri Adhir Ghosh, resident of VillageBampur, P.O. Bampur, P.S. Birganj, Sub Division-Amarpur, DistrictGomati, PIN-799101, aged about 34 years.
7. Sri Mitan Sutradhar, son of Late Shyamal Sutradhar, resident of
Village-Satdubia, P.Ο. Fatickchara, P.S. Shidai Mohanpur, SubDivision-Mohanpur, District-West Tripura, PIN-799210, aged about 35
years.
8. Sri Jiban Das, son of Sri Umesh Chandra Das, resident of VillageBhabanipur, P.O. Bhabanipur, P.S. Jatrapur, Sub Division- Sonamura,
District-Sepahijala, PIN-799131, aged about 32 years.
9. Sri Sanjib Kumar Das, son of Sri Kajal Kanti Das, resident of
Village-West Dukli, P.O. Dukli, P.S. Amtali, Sub Division-Sadar,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799003, aged about 37 years.
10. Sri Subrata Sarkar, son of Sri Sudhir Sarkar, resident of VillageLaxmi Chara, P.O. Laxmi Chara, P.S. Baikhora, Sub DivisionSantirbazar, District-South Tripura, PIN-799144, aged about 34 years.
11. Sri Anjan Sarkar, son of Sri Swapan Sarkar, resident of VillageKalshimura P.O. Kalshimura & P.S. Kalamchowra, Sub DivisionSonamura, District-Sepahijala, PIN-799102, aged about 36 years.
12. Sri Debasis Bhowmik, son of Sri Nirmal Bhowmik, resident of
Village-Sonamura Chowmuhani, P.O. & P.S.-R.K. Pur, Sub DivisionUdaipur, District-Gomati, PIN-799120, aged about 36 years.
13. Smt. Ankita Deb, wife of Sri Parthapratim Das, resident of
Village-Housing Board, Udaipur, P.O. & P.S. R.K. Pur, Sub DivisionUdaipur, District-Gomati, PIN-799120, aged about 33 years.
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary, Education Department, Government of Tripura, having his
office at Secretariat Building, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN-799006.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN799006.
3. The Commissioner & Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN799006.
4. The Director of School Education, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Shiksha Bhavan, Office
Lane, PO-Agartala, PS- West Agartala, District- West Tripura.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Pannalal Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing
:
25.04.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
06.05.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
These 13 numbers of petitioners have filed this writ
petition seeking the following reliefs:
“i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each
one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, for directing them, to transmit the records,
appertaining to this writ petition, lying with them, for
rendering substantive and conscionable justice to the
petitioners;
ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each
one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, for mandating/directing them, to forthwith
reckon the past services, rendered by the petitioners,
while determining the seniority, regular pay scale,
leave encashment, leave salary, gratuity and all other
admissible service benefits, including pension, as well
as the arrears of salary and allowances, in conformity
with the various decisions of this Hon'ble High Court;
iii) Call for the records appertaining to this writ
petition;
iv)Costs of and incidental to this writ petition;
v) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the
Rule Absolute in terms of i. & ii. above;
vi)Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court
may deem fit and proper;”
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Somik Deb assisted by
Learned Counsel, Mr. Pannalal Debbarma appearing on behalf of the
petitioners. Also heard Learned Addl. GA, Mr. Mangal Debbarma
appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
3.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
3.1.
The petitioners have obtained Masters Degree in different
subjects from the Tripura University on diverse dates. Thereafter,
they have completed the course of Bachelor in Education (Special)
from the ICFAI University, Agartala. For filling up of some vacant
posts of Under-Graduate, Graduate and Post-Graduate Teachers,
under the Education Department, Government of Tripura, on monthly
fixed pay basis, advertisements were issued by the Education
Department, Government of Tripura, seeking respective qualifications
requisite therefor and in pursuance of the issuance of the said
advertisements, the petitioners became aspirants for appointment to
the post of Post Graduate Teacher & Graduate Teacher under the
Education Department, Government of Tripura. Thereafter, they
submitted requisite applications enclosing all necessary documents.
After that a selection process was initiated, and the
present petitioners along with others were duly selected for the post
of Post Graduate Teacher & Graduate Teacher under the Directorate of
Secondary
Education,
Government
of
Tripura.
The
Director
of
Secondary Education, Government of Tripura by a Memorandum
dated 24.10.2017, offered the temporary post of Post Graduate
Teacher
&
Graduate
Teacher
under
the
Education
(School)
Department, Government of Tripura to the petitioners on fixed pay
basis
thereby
postulating
the
terms
&
conditions
of
the
advertisements,
their
appointments.
3.2.
Thereafter,
in
pursuant
to
the
petitioners participated for selection to the post of Post Graduate
Teacher
&
Graduate
Teacher
and
they
had
all
the
requisite
qualifications as laid down in the Recruitment Rules, except B.Ed.
(Regular) Degree. The petitioners completed the course of B.Ed.
(Special) which was recognized by the Rehabilitation Council of India.
However, the petitioners participated in the selection process and as
such, they were selected in the post of Post-Graduate & Graduate
Teacher, but at the time of scrutiny of their certificates they were
informed that for appointment to the post of Post Graduate Teacher &
Graduate Teacher, B.Ed. (Regular) is an essential requirement and
since the petitioners are the holders of B.Ed. (Special) Degree, as
such, they were ineligible for the said post.
3.3.
Being aggrieved, the petitioners filed writ petitions bearing
WP(C) No.1050 of 2017 along with other connected writ petitions
praying for treating the degree of B.Ed. (Special) as equivalent to
B.Ed. (Regular), and thereafter, to consider the petitioners as eligible
candidates for the post of Post-Graduate Teachers & Graduate
Teachers. However, at the initial stage, when the matter came up for
hearing, the Hon’ble High Court directed that the appointments made,
if any, shall be subjected to outcome of the writ petitions and after
that, vide judgment & order dated 19.12.2018, the writ petitions were
dismissed by this Court.
3.4.
The petitioners applied for issuance of ‘No-Objection
Certificates’ for pursuing the course of B.Ed. (Regular) in Open and
Distance Learning Mode from ICFAI University, and accordingly, the
Department by issuing various memorandum accorded ‘No-Objection
Certificates’ in favour of the petitioners permitting them to get
admission in B.Ed. (Regular) Course.
3.5.
Thereafter, the petitioners filed a Review petition before
this High Court bearing Rev. Pet. No.23 of 2019, praying for reviewing
the judgment & order dated 19.12.2018 passed in the aforesaid case
alleging inter alia that by this time the Department had issued 'No
Objection Certificate' in favour of the petitioners to pursue B.Ed.
(Regular)
Course
through
Open
Distance
Mode
as
in-service
candidates. Accordingly, vide order dated 21.05.2019, considering the
prayers of the petitioners, this Court granted liberty to the petitioners
to approach the respondents who shall consider & decide the
representation of the petitioners in accordance with law.
3.6.
The petitioners made representation to the Principal
Secretary, School Education Department, Government of Tripura
communicating
the
order
dated
21.05.2019.
Meanwhile,
the
petitioners completed B.Ed. (Regular) Course of two years duration.
In the respective Service Book of the petitioners it was also noted that
in pursuance of the ‘No Objection Certificate’, the petitioners have
completed B.Ed. Course in ODL mode under the ICFAI University. It is
the case of the petitioners that in pursuance of Article 309 of the
Constitution of India by a Notification dated 15.03.2022, Recruitment
Rules for the post of Special Educator was promulgated and Clause 7
of
the
Schedule
qualifications
of
the
requisite
said
for
Rules
postulated
appointment
by
the
way
essential
of
direct
recruitment(Annexure-8).
3.7.
Meanwhile, the Member Secretary, Education (School)
Department, Government of Tripura issued a Notification dated
11.04.2022, whereby applications were invited from Indian Nationals
having permanent residents in Tripura for selection of candidates for
recruitment to the post of "Special Educators", through "Selection Test
for Special Educator (STSE)-2022". Clause 1 of the said advertisement
postulated
the
essential
minimum
qualifications
requisite
for
appointment to the said post. According to the petitioners, even
though requests were made for determination of the fact that B.Ed.
(Special) is equivalent to B.Ed. (Regular), the matter was requested
to be placed before the Equivalence Committee, but the same was
not placed.
3.8.
After that, the petitioners again applied for issuance of
‘No Objection Certificate’ to participate through Selection Test for
Special Educator (STSE), and accordingly, the Additional Director,
Directorate of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura issued
Memorandum and allowed ‘No Objection Certificate’ in favour of all
the petitioners by memorandum dated 08.08.2022(Annexure-10).
3.9.
Consequent thereto, the petitioners participated in the
Selection Test for Special Educator (STSE) and all of them emerged
out successful. The Director of Secondary Education, Government
of Tripura issued Memorandum, thereby appointing the petitioners
to the post of Special Educator, Group C under the Education
(School) Department, Government of Tripura, on a fixed monthly
pay of Rs.20,475/-(Annexure-11). After that, the petitioners
submitted
prayers
for
accepting
their
respective
technical
resignations and upon due consideration, the Director of Secondary
Education, Government of Tripura by issuing various Memorandum,
accepted
the
Technical
Resignations
tendered
by
the
submitted
their
petitioners(Annexure-12).
3.10.
Thereafter,
the
petitioners
respective Joining Reports to the Head of the Office & DDO,
Padmapur H.S. School, Dharmanagar, North Tripura for joining to
the post of Special Educator(Annexure-13).
3.11.
The petitioners, thereafter, prayed for grant of
regular pay scale on completion of 5(five) years of service and
accordingly,
they
submitted
representations
Directorate
of
Secondary
Education,
Tripura(Annexure-14).
The
Director
of
to
the
Director,
Government
Secondary
of
Education,
Government of Tripura by memo dated 28.07.2023, informed the
petitioners that their previous appointments cannot be counted for
the purpose of past service benefits(Annexure-15).
The petitioners referred to a judgment & order (Oral)
dated 09.08.2023 passed by this High Court in WP(C) No.11 of
2023 whereby the selection of Sri Johnson Tripura, one of the writ
petitioners in WP(C) No.1050 of 2017 and other connected writ
petitions was assailed inter alia on the ground that at the time of
initial entry into the service he did not have the requisite
qualification, i.e., B.Ed. (Regular) and that he had possessed B.Ed.
(Special), and any subsequent acquisition of B.Ed. would not cure
the initial defect in the selection. However, while deciding WP(C)
No.11 of 2023, the said contention was repulsed by this Court
holding that pursuing of B.Ed. (Regular) upon permission granted
by the employer, no fault can be found with the qualification and
his selection was justified(Annexure-16).
3.12.
In pursuance of Memorandum dated 28.07.2023
(Annexure-15), the petitioners submitted a reply dated 17.08.2023
to the Director of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura,
stating inter alia that even though at the time of their initial
appointments they were holding the degree of B.Ed. (Special), but
subsequently,
after
obtaining
‘No
Objection
Certificate’
they
completed the 2(two) years of B.Ed. (Regular) course which was
duly entered into their Service Books. As such, the petitioners are
entitled to get the relief as admissible to the post of Graduate
Teachers under the Education Department. Even after passing of
the judgment & order dated 19.12.2018(Annexure-3) till the date
of the issuance of the Memorandum dated 28.07.2023(Annexure15) the petitioners were allowed to continue their service, and as
such, applying the principle of legitimate expectation, the said
Memorandum
dated
28.07.2023(Annexure-15)
according
to
petitioners, cannot be sustained. Reply dated 17.08.2023 is
annexed as Annexure-17. After such detailed reply submitted by
each of the petitioners to the respective Show Cause Notices, no
action was taken. Hence the petitioners have filed the present writ
petition seeking the reliefs as stated above.
4.
The State-respondents have contested the case by filing
their counter affidavit and finally by the counter affidavit prayed for
dismissal of this writ petition. In para Nos.3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, the
State-respondents have asserted the following facts:
“3. That, in reply to para 1 to 2.3.1 of the writ
petition, I say that the Directorate of Secondary
Education had issued Offer of Appointment to the
eligible candidates for the post of Graduate Teacher
on a fixed monthly pay of Rs. 17925/- and
thereafter issued posting order vide Memorandum
dated 16.11.2017. In the said Memorandum it was
categorically mentioned that the appointment is
further subject to final outcome of the Writ Petition
lying in the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura regarding
B.Ed Special Education against the selected
candidates who did not possess general B.Ed during
selection.
5. That, in reply to para 2.5 of the writ petition, I
say that in the instant petition, the Petitioners have
referred a Writ Petition being number W.P.(C)1050
of 2017 which was disposed by Judgment & Order
dated 19.12.2018 wherein the Hon'ble Court has
observed as under :"56.
We
reiterate
that
mere
higher
qualification would not be a reason to allow
the petitioners to continue for the same is
with a different object and purpose not
sought to be achieved in terms of the
present legislation.
57. Further, what is required to be seen are
the conditions prescribed at the time of
issuance of the advertisement and not the
subsequent decision, if any, taken by the
government, modifying the conditions which
the petitioners fulfil well that is for future
and not for the past.
58. The decision in Social Jurist (supra) is
also of no consequence for it only highlights
the need for taking all measures ensuring
full education, in a holistic manner, of all
children.
59. Having observed thus, the present writ
petitions being devoid of merit, stand
dismissed."
The copy of the Judgment & Order dated 19.12.2018
is already annexed as Annexure-3 by the Petitioner
to the Writ Petition.
6. That, in reply to para 2.6 to 2.10 of the writ
petition, I say that the Petitioners had filed a review
petition being number REV.PET. No.23/2019 before
this Hon'ble Court and disposed by an Order dated
21.05.2019 as under:"The prayer being innocuous,
nature, is not opposed.
limited
in
As such, as prayed for, the present petition
is disposed of reserving liberty to the
petitioner to approach the respondents, who
shall consider and decide the petitioner's
representation expeditiously in accordance
with law.
It shall be open to the petitioner to approach
the Court for assailing the order, if so
required and desired on the same and
subsequent cause of action, in accordance
with law."
The copy of this order dated 21.05.2019 is already
annexed by the Petitioner as Annexure-5 to the Writ
Petition.
7. That, in reply to para 2.11 to 2.15 of the writ
petition, I say that on recommendation of the
Teachers' Recruitment Board Tripura (TRBT), 88
eligible candidates were appointed to the post of
Special Educator on fixed monthly pay Rs. 20475/having essential minimum qualification Graduation
along with B.Ed. in Special Education.
8. That, in reply to para 2.12 to 2.19 of the writ
petition, I say that the Director of Secondary
Education, Tripura issued a Memorandum vide No.
F.1(1-43)SE/E(NG)/2018(L-9) dated 28.07.2023
(page 321 to the writ petition) wherein the
following has laid down:"Whereas Sri Debasish Bhowmik, at present
hold the post of Special Educator under the
Directorate of Secondary Education and
posted at Bharat Ratna Atal Behari Vajpayee
Charilam H.S. School, Sepahijala District
Tripura
did
not
have
the
requisite
professional qualification (B. Ed.) as per the
advertisement of the Teachers' Recruitment
Board, Tripura and the relevant Recruitment
Rules instead he/she had B. Ed. in Special
Education which is not recognized by the
NCTE for appointment to the post of
Graduate Teacher/ Post Graduate Teacher.
And whereas despite Sri Debasish Bhowmik
and a group of similarly situated candidates
did not fulfil the eligibility criteria for
recruitment to the post of GT/ PGT, the
incumbent
concerned
applied
for
the
Selection Test for GT (STGT)/the Selection
Test for PGT (STPGT) as advertised by the
TRBT.
And whereas knowing the fact of ineligibility
for appointment to the post of GT/PGT, they
approached the Hon'ble High Court of
Tripura for considering B. Ed in Special
Education for appointment to the post of
GT/PGT.
And whereas all the candidates having B. Ed.
in Special Education were allowed to
participate in the selection process in
compliance with the interim Order dated
28.09.2016 wherein it had been directed:
"In the interim, it is directed that the
petitioner shall be allowed to appear in the
selection process for the post of Graduate
teacher pursuant to the advertisement dated
09.09.2016, but the result shall not be
declared in so far as the petitioner is
concerned.
And whereas after the selection test, the
incumbent concerned having B. Ed. in
Special Education was allowed to participate
in the verification exercise conducted by the
TRBT in compliance with the direction of the
Hon'ble High Court dated 19.04.2017,
wherein it had been directed: "Since the writ
petition cannot be disposed of as of now due
to the pendency of some other analogous
matters,
we
direct
the
respondent
authorities to allow the petitioner to take
part in the verification exercise to be held
tomorrow. The result of the verification
exercise will be subject to the outcome of
this writ petition."
And whereas in an interim order dated 23.08.2017,
it was directed by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura:
"On comparative reading of Annexure-10-A
and Annexure-10-B to the writ petition, we
are satisfied that the petitioner has made
out a prima facie case. Consequently, as in
our order dated 06.06.2017 passed in WP(C)
No.520 of 2017, any appointment made to
the post of Post Graduate Teacher (in
Political
Science
subject)
under
the
Education (School) Department, Government
of Tripura shall be subject to the outcome of
the writ petition."
And whereas in compliance with the Judgment &
Order dated 23.08.2017, all the candidates having
B.Ed. in Special Education and came in the merit
position in the concerned Selection Test were issued
offers of appointment as per the recommendation of
the TRBT and subsequently, such candidates were
appointed to the post of PGT/GT under this
Directorate stipulating a condition that their
appointment shall be subject to the outcome of the
Writ Petition lying in the Hon'ble Court bearing No.
W.P. (C) 1138 of 2016 and other analogues Writ
Petitions regarding B.Ed. (Special Education).
Accordingly, Sri Debasish Bhowmik joined to the
post
of
GT
Graduate
Teacher
(Secondary)
18.11.2017.
And whereas the case bearing No. W.P. (C) No.1138
of 2016 regarding the B.Ed. (Special Education) filed
by Smt. Sudipa Saha and other Vs the State of
Tripura and 71 other analogues writ petition were
dismissed by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura on
19.02.2019 with the following observation.
"Having observed thus, the present writ
petition being devoid of merit, stand
dismissed".
And whereas the Law Department, Government of
Tripura in regard to the cancellation of the
appointments of the Teachers having B.Ed. (Special
Education) opined their views as under:
"Thus, the appointments given to those
PGTs & GTS holding B.Ed. (Special
Education) have no leg to stand after this
judgment is pronounced by the Hon'ble
High Court. Obviously, as a consequence,
their appointments have to be cancelled.
Regarding those candidates who have been
given offer of appointment, but not issued
with appointment/joining letter, may also
be cancelled."
And
"In the line of the Judgment pronounced by
the High Court, the Department may not
get any alternative opinion but to issue
harsh order cancelling appointments."
And whereas, Sri Debasish Bhowmik was again
appointed to the post of Special Educator under the
Directorate of Secondary Education, Tripura in the
year 2022 after tendering technical resignation from
their previous post of GT/PGT having B.Ed in Special
Education and appointed in the year 2017. He joined
to the post of Special Educator on 20.12.2022.
Now, therefore, in compliance with the Judgment
and order of the Hon'ble High Court, Tripura and in
view of the aforesaid legal advice, Sri Debasish
Bhowmik, Special Educator is hereby asked to
explain as to why their previous appointment to the
post of Graduate Teacher (Secondary)/ Post
Graduate Teacher having B.Ed. in Special Education
appointed in the year 2017 under the Directorate of
Secondary Education will not be cancelled and as to
why the previous service rendered by him/her will
not be treated as eligible for counting of past
service benefits.
Sri Debasish Bhowmik, Special Educator, Bharat
Ratna Atal Behari Vajpayee Charilam H.S. School,
Sepahijala District Tripura should submit his/her
reply within 10 (ten) days from the date of receipt
of this memo. Otherwise, the decision will be taken
exparte.
9. That, in reply to para 2.20 to 2.22 of the writ
petition, I say that the W.P.(C) No. 11 of 2023 was
dismissed by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura vide
Judgment and Order dated 08.09.2023 wherein the
Hon'ble Court has made some baservations that :"3. Respondent No.4 has pursued the B.Ed.
(Regular) upon permission granted by the
employer and has also acquired that
qualification. Later on, he approached this
Court in WP(C) No.87 of 2023 with a prayer
for granting regular scale of pay upon
completion of 5 years of service. The
learned Writ Court vide order dated
10.02.2023 directed the respondents to
consider his representation. Petitioner
herein has however, approached this Court
in the year 2023 after 5 years of the
appointment. The journey of litigation on
the issue of qualification of B.Ed. (Special
Education) is the ground taken for excusing
her for the delay in approaching this Court.
But delay apart, now from the averments
and documents on record, it is apparent
that following the settled principles in case
of such nature, the petitioner being the
youngest amongst 5(five) candidates in UR
category was not appointed though all of
them had same 91 marks. She appears to
have remained silent on her grievance for a
period of 5 years where after she has
approached this Court in the year 2023. It
is not a case of the petitioner that anyone
having lesser marks than the petitioner has
been appointed in the same exercise in the
subject of History in UR category.
4. The second plea raised by the petitioner
vis-à-vis respondent No.4 is also not
acceptable for the reason that the services
of the respondent No.4 and such other
candidates who possessed the educational
qualification of B.Ed. (Special Education) on
the cut-off date of advertisement were
protected by virtue of the Division Bench
judgment of this Court rendered on
19.12.2018 in the case of Smt. Sudipa Saha
(supra). The respondent No.4 seems to
have acquired the qualification of B.Ed.
(Regular)
after permission
from the
employer during his service. At this stage,
it is, therefore, not open to question the
eligibility criteria of the respondent No.4
for the purposes of annulment of his
appointment and allow the petitioner to be
accommodated on the said post.
5. Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned
Government Advocate appearing for the
respondents-State, has also informed that
beyond the select list of 87, unfilled
vacancies out of total 123 vacancies for the
subject of History have been carried to
subsequent recruitment exercise. In that
case, the plea of the petitioner to consider
herself for the unfilled vacancies also
cannot be entertained at this length of
time.
6. As such, this Court does not find any
merit in the writ petition which is
accordingly dismissed."
Further, I say that the State Respondents have
carefully examined of the grievance of petitioners
and they were asked to submit their replies to the
Directorate with appropriate documents in support
of their claim with reference Memo dated
28.07.2023 issued by the Directorate. Thereafter,
the matter referred to the Government for
consideration of their claim which is under
examination and decision.”
5.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel has
drawn the attention of this Court that the case of the present
petitioners is covered by an order of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India bearing WP(C) No.132 of 2016 and in the said order, Hon’ble
the
Apex
Court
have
discussed
elaborately
regarding
the
appointment of Special Teachers. As such, the said order is very
much relevant for decision of the present case. Learned Senior
Counsel in support of his submission further submitted that all the
petitioners of this case have/had requisite qualifications for which
they were appointed but, later on, it was informed to them that for
selection to the post of Post Graduate Teacher and Graduate
Teacher, B.Ed. (Regular) was essential. The petitioners were
holding the degree of B.Ed. (Special) and as such, they obtained
‘No Objection Certificate’ from the Department, and thereafter,
they completed the 2(two) years course of B.Ed. (Regular), and the
said fact has been duly entered in their Service Book. According to
Learned Senior Counsel, the petitioners are entitled to regular pay
scale with effect from the respective dates on which they have
completed their 5(five) years of service.
5.1.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that initially
the petitioners were selected to the post of Post Graduate Teachers
& Graduate Teachers, but after scrutiny of the certificates of the
petitioners, the respondents came to the conclusion that degree of
B.Ed. (Special) holders are not eligible for the said posts, whereas
as per the Recruitment Rules & the advertisement, the petitioners
were covered by the eligibility criteria. It was further submitted
that in spite of that deficiency, the petitioners pursued B.Ed.
(Regular) Course and as soon as they obtained the B.Ed. (Regular)
certificate/professionals
qualification,
their
deficiency
stood
removed and such removal of deficiency must relate back to the
respective dates of initial entries of the petitioners. It was also
submitted by Learned Senior Counsel that the judgment & order
dated 09.08.2023 of this High Court has attained finality as the
respondents-State have not challenged the said judgment & order
and on the basis of the said judgment & order and the principles
therein, the petitioners are entitled to get the benefit of past
service for getting the benefit of regularization. Learned Senior
Counsel also submitted that after completion of 5(five) years of
service, the present petitioners are entitled to the benefits as
admissible to other Post Graduate and Graduate Teachers. As such,
no
action
can
be
taken
upon
memorandum
dated
28.07.2023(Annexure-15). Learned Senior Counsel also submitted
that the appointments of the teachers having B.Ed. (Special) were
cancelled but after obtaining B.Ed. (Regular) Degree which has
been entered in the Service Books of each of the petitioners, they
are entitled for regularization. In addition, Learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that although the petitioners did not have the
requisite degree at the time of appointments, but they acquired the
same after taking ‘No Objection Certificate’ from the Department
and rendered 5(five) years of continuous service and even after
passing of the judgment & the order dated 19.12.2018(Annexure3) till the date of the issuance of memorandum dated 28.07.2023,
the petitioners were allowed to continue in their service. As such,
Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the same comes under the
principle of legitimate expectation but the department is showing
unjustified reasons after getting long service from the petitioners.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further
submitted
that
the
present
petitioners had filed writ petition bearing No.WP(C) No.87 of 2023
before this Court and by order dated 10.02.2023 the writ petition
was disposed of with a direction to the petitioners to submit
representation and accordingly, representations were submitted but
only
after
presentation
of
the
petition
for
contempt,
the
memorandum dated 28.07.2023(Annexure-15) has been issued.
Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the petitioners are
serving in the post of Special Educators and as per Recruitment
Rules(Annexure-8) and the advertisement(Annexure-9) they had
the requisite qualification at the time of initial entry into the
service. So, their claim for regularization cannot be faulted with
and thus, Learned Senior Counsel urged for allowing the writ
petition.
6.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. GA, Mr. Mangal
Debbarma referring the counter affidavit submitted that the present
petitioners are not entitled to get the relief as prayed for and the
order of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Rajneesh Kumar Pandey &
Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. passed in WP(C) No.132 of 2016
relates to the contractual/ad-hoc employees. As such, the principle
of the said order is not applicable to the case of the present
petitioners and as such, the petitioners are not entitled to any
reliefs in this case.
7.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the
documents annexed with the petition and also the citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India referred by both the parties at the
time of argument.
8.
Admittedly, in this case all the petitioners were initially
having B.Ed. (Special) Degree instead of B.Ed. (Regular) and with
reference to offer of appointment dated 24.10.2017, all the
petitioners joined to the post of Graduate Teacher on different
dates i.e. on 17.11.2017, 18.11.2017, 20.11.2017 and 24.11.2017.
However, in course of verification of certificates later on it was
found that the petitioners did not have the degree of the
B.Ed.(Regular) Course. After that, the present petitioners filed writ
petitions bearing WP(C) No.1050 of 2017 along with other
connected writ petitions before this Court and by a common
judgment & order dated 19.12.2018 a Division Bench of this Court
dismissed all the writ petitions. Thereafter, one Manik Bhowmik
filed a review petition bearing Rev. Pet. No.23 of 2019 which was
also disposed of by order dated 21.05.2019. Thereafter, another
review petition bearing Rev. Pet.No.51 of 2019 was filed which was
also disposed of by order dated 29.05.2019 with a direction to
approach to the respondents. In the meantime, after obtaining ‘No
Objection Certificate’ from the department, the present petitioners
pursued B.Ed. (Regular) Course and accordingly, obtained B.Ed.
(Regular) degree from ICFAI University. After obtaining B.Ed.
(Regular) degree they again applied for the post of Special
Educator
against
the
advertisement
dated
11.04.2022
after
obtaining ‘No Objection Certificate’ and were selected later on.
Accordingly, their offer of appointment for the post of Special
Educator was issued on 23.11.2022 and in pursuance of that offer
of appointment all the writ petitioners joined their respective place
of posting on 20.12.2022 on fixed pay basis. In the meantime they
also obtained ‘No Objection Certificate’ before applying for the post.
It is also on record that when the present petitioners earlier joined
to the post of Graduate Teacher, they were also given the
appointment on fixed pay basis at the rate of Rs.17,925/- (revised)
per month being 75% of basic pay [Level-9 of Tripura State pay
matrix, 2017] and subsequently, vide memo dated 23.11.2022 i.e.
the offer of appointment, the petitioners were again appointed to
the post of Special Educator, Group-C on fixed pay basis at the rate
of Rs.20,475/- (revised) per month. The present petitioners have
prayed for reckoning the past service rendered by them while
determining the seniority, regular pay scale, leave encashment,
leave salary, gratuity and all other service benefits including
pension as well as arrears of salary and allowances, etc in
conformity with the various decisions of this Court. It is also to be
mentioned here that after obtaining the technical resignation, the
petitioners applied for the post of Special Educator and after
obtaining ‘No Objection Certificate’ from the department, they also
pursued B.Ed. (Regular) which was also entered in their Service
Books. According to the petitioners they have completed 5(five)
years of continuous service and even continued their service after
the passing of judgment & order dated 19.12.2018 till the date of
issuance of memorandum dated 28.07.2023.
It
is
also
the
case
of
the
petitioners
that
the
respondents-State had never pleaded that the writ petitioners were
ineligible for regularization and their services were liable to be
terminated, rather the respondents allowed them to continue their
service. According to the petitioners, since as per direction of this
Court,
they
obtained
‘No
Objection
Certificate’
from
the
department, so, there is no scope on the part of the respondentsState to deny/refuse the benefit of past service rendered by the
petitioners to their respective posts.
9.
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Rajneesh Kumar
Pandey(supra) gave certain directions to the Central Government
as well as the State Government regarding the appointment of
Special Educators and also the method of selection of those Special
Educators by forming/constituting screening committee but on
perusal of the said order it appears that the said case before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court was for contractual/ad-hoc employees. In
the said order, the Hon’ble Supreme Court specifically observed
that benefit of pay scale will only be prospective and not
retrospective i.e. from the date of their appointment after selection.
10.
Here, in the case at hand, both the parties relied upon
the same order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. By this time
the present petitioners have completed 5(five) years of service.
11.
After going through the counter affidavit submitted by
the respondents and also upon hearing the submissions made by
the Addl. GA appearing on behalf of the respondents-State, it
appears that there is no scope to deny the fact of past service
rendered by the petitioners but, since the petitioners were initially
appointed on fixed pay basis, in the opinion of this Court, the
benefit of past service rendered by the petitioners cannot be
considered at this stage. Moreover, the petitioners also failed to
show B.Ed. (Regular) degree in course of verification of their
documents, as such, on the basis of their initial appointment made
in the year 2017, the benefits of past service as alleged to be
rendered by the petitioners cannot be extended to them who
although by this time have obtained B.Ed. (Regular) degree from
ICFAI University and got selected against the advertisement dated
11.04.2022 for the post of Special Educator on fixed pay basis. The
petitioners cannot be granted the benefits of past service simply on
the ground of continuation of their service for more than 5(five)
years and also on the ground that their names have been entered
in the Service Books. As such, the present petitioners are not
entitled to the reliefs as prayed for in this writ petition.
12.
In the result, this writ petition filed by the present
petitioners bears no merit. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed
being devoid of merit.
This writ petition is disposed of accordingly.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.05.07
A DATTA Date:
17:36:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review