Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.697 of 2024
Sri Deb Kumar Majumder,
S/o Late Babatosh Majumder,
Vill.- Gandhigram, PS. Airport, Agartala,
Dist. West Tripura,
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Union of India
Represented by Inspector General
Ftr. B.S.F. Salbagan, Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Commandant,
74 Bn. B.S.F. presently situated at Gandidham,
Dist.- Kutch District State-Gujarat
Pin.-370240
(Notice to be served office of the I.G., B.S.F,
Frontier Salbagan, P.S- Airport, Agartala, Pin.-799012
Dist.- West Tripura)
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Chandrasekhar Sinha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
22nd April, 2025.
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Chandrasekhar Sinha, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Bidyut Majumder,
learned Dy. S.G.I. appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The allegation of the petitioner is that he being a
constable in BSF, was posted at Frontier Head Quarters of BSF,
Salbagan, Agartala, Tripura and due to advent of Covid-19 he
was given out leaving permission to stay outside the campus of
the BSF Authority to any nearer place. According to him, he was
peacefully discharging his duty till 2020, but suddenly on
24.08.2020 he met an accident wherein he received severe head
and chest injuries and as a result he was not in a position to
make any communication with his Authority and due to such
injuries he was not even able to indentify his relatives also. It is
further stated by the petitioner that in June,2020 the petitioner
received a letter from Frontier Head Quarters of BSF, Salbagan,
Agartala, Tripura that he was given such out leaving permission
on condition that whenever he would be called upon to attend
duty he would do so, but on 26.05.2020, he was attempted to be
communicated through mobile phone to attend such duty, but
there was no response from his side and therefore the period
from 24.03.2020 to 26.05.2020 when he was on outliving
permission, was considered as his Earned Leave and from
27.05.2020 his absence was treated to be without permission or
leave. As that letter of the respondents was not responded by
him nor he joined the duty, he was directed for immediately
reporting to his head quarter.
[3]
Then on 10.09.2021 by one application he requested
the respondents for his posting at Salbagan which was rejected
by them informing that he was already dismissed from service
w.e.f. 13.11.2020. It is also the grievance of the petitioner that
no copy of such dismissal order was ever furnished to him and,
therefore, he made another application on 16.01.2023 to get the
copy of such dismissal order and getting no response, the
present writ petition has been filed for quashing/cancelling said
dismissal order dated 13.11.2020 (issued by respondent no.2).
[4]
Mr. Chandrasekhar Sinha, learned counsel strenuously
argues that as per Rule 22(2) of Border Security Force Rules,
1969 Departmental proceeding is required to be initiated before
imposing punishment of dismissal, but same was not done in this
case and thereby terminating him illegally from his service.
According to Mr. Sinha, learned counsel proper procedure was
not
followed
by
the
Authority
before
such
imposition
of
punishment and, therefore, such dismissal order is violative of
principle of natural justice and hence same is required to be set
aside.
[5]
Mr. Sinha, learned counsel also relies on a decision of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Dhanajaya Reddy versus
State of Karnataka (2001) 4 SCC 9 wherein at para 23 it was
observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court that where a power is given
to do a certain thing in a certain manner, the things must be
done in that way and or not atall. According to Mr. Sinha, learned
counsel, service of a show-cause notice upon the petitioner as
per Rule 22 was mandatory which was not done in this case.
[6]
Mr. Majumder, learned Dy S.G.I., on the other hand,
submits that the petitioner was attached with Frontier Head
Quarters of BSF, Salbagan, Agartala, Tripura w.e.f. 13.05.2015
and was working as Constable (Sweeper now designated as Safai
Karmachari). According to learned Dy S.G.I., the petitioner was
granted out leaving permission for keeping his family outside
Frontier Head Quarters of BSF, Salbagan, with admissible HRA as
he was residing within one km radius from BSF Campus and from
23.03.2020 onwards, due to nationwide lockdown for Covid-19
pandemic, he was verbally directed to remain outside the
campus, but due to exigency of service he was called on duty on
26.05.2020, but neither he picked up the phone call nor he did
reported to Frontier Head Quarters of BSF, Salbagan. According
to learned Dy. S.G.I., thereafter three letters by registered post
were sent to him on 27.05.2020, 11.06.2020 and 04.08.2020
asking him to join the duty, but he did not and, therefore, a court
of enquiry was constituted to investigate into the circumstances
owing to his such absence without leave w.e.f. 26.05.2020 and
an
apprehension
Superintendent
of
roll
was
Police,
also
West
issued
Tripura
lateron
to
to
the
apprehend
the
petitioner and to hand him over to the nearest BSF Head
Quarters, but then also the petitioner did not join.
[7]
Thereafter,
Mr.
Majumder submits,
the court
of
enquiry suggested in September, 2020 to initiate a disciplinary
action as per BSF Act and Rules against the petitioner for his
absence without leave w.e.f. 26.05.2020. According to Mr.
Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I., in consequence thereof, a showcause notice dated 30.09.2020 was issued to the petitioner which
was duly received by him, but he did not come forward to give
any reply and ultimately vide the impugned order punishment of
dismissal from service was imposed on him.
[8]
Learned Dy. S.G.I. submits that the BSF Authority in
strict compliance of sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 of BSF Rules, 1969
terminated the petitioner from the service and there was no
lapse on their part in compliance of the provision of said rules.
Learned Dy. S.G.I. also refers to a decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Union of India and Others versus P.
Gunasekaran (2015) 2 SCC 610 to gain support that under
Articles 226/227 of the constitution the High Court should not go
into the proportionality of the punishment unless the same
shocks its conscience. Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I. further
relies on another decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court rendered in
Union of India and Others versus Datta Linga Toshatwad
(2005) 13 SCC 709 wherein the dismissal of a CRPF personnel
on the ground of overstaying beyond the leave period was
confirmed with observation for treating him as a deserter. The
relevant paragraph no.8 of said decision is extracted hereunder:
“8. The present case is not a case of a constable
merely overstaying his leave by 12 days. The
respondent took leave from 16-6-1997 and never
reported for duty thereafter. Instead he filed a writ
petition
before
the
High
Court
in
which
the
impugned order has been passed. Members of the
uniformed
forces
cannot
absent
themselves
on
frivolous pleas, having regard to the nature of the
duties enjoined on these forces. Such indiscipline, if
it goes unpunished, will greatly affect the discipline
of the forces. In such forces desertion is a serious
matter. Cases of this nature, in whatever manner
described, are cases of desertion particularly when
there is apprehension of the member of the force
being called upon to perform onerous duties in
difficult terrains or an order of deputation which he
finds inconvenient, is passed. We cannot take such
matters
lightly,
particularly
when
it
relates
to
uniformed forces of this country. A member of a
uniformed force who overstays his leave by a few
days must be able to give a satisfactory explanation.
However, a member of the force who goes on leave
and never reports for duties thereafter, cannot be
said to be one merely overstaying his leave. He must
be treated as a deserter. He appears on the scene
for the first time when he files a writ petition before
the
High
Court,
rather
than
reporting
to
his
Commanding Officer, We are satisfied that in cases
of this nature, dismissal from the force is a justified
disciplinary action and cannot be described as
disproportionate to the misconduct alleged.”
[9]
Lastly, learned Dy. S.G.I. relies on another decision of
the Single Bench of this Court in case of Prasenjit Das versus
The Union of India & Ors. in WP(C) No.843 of 2020 wherein
also another Constable of BSF after enjoying twenty days leave
did not join the duty and remained unauthorized absent for
months together. Ultimately the BSF Authority issued a showcase notice and dismissed him from the service without pension.
In that case the plea of the said BSF personnel was that owing to
his mother’s illness he could not join the duty in time. Learned
Coordinate Bench of this Court in that case rejected the writ
petition without interfering with such dismissal Order. The
relevant paragraph nos. 8, 9 & 10 of said judgment are extracted
hereunder for useful reference:
“8.
As per sub-rule (1) of Rule 22
when it is proposed to terminate the service of a
person other than an officer, he would be given
an opportunity by the competent authority to
show-cause in the manner specified in sub-rule
(2) before dismissing or removing him from
service.
As
per
sub-rule
(2)
when
after
considering the reports on the misconduct of the
concerned person the competent authority is
satisfied that the trial of such a person is
inexpedient
or
impracticable
but
further
retention of the person in service is undesirable,
it would so inform him along with all the reports
adverse to him and call upon him to submit his
explanation and defence in writing. As per subrule
(3),
the
competent
authority
after
considering the explanation and defence, if any
may remove or dismiss the person from service
with or without pension.
9.
Sub-rule (1) of Rule 22 thus is the
source of power of a competent authority to
dismiss or remove a member of the force. Subrule (2) essentially lays down the procedure
when
the
ordering
competent
trial
of
the
authority
instead
of
concerned
person
for
alleged misconduct, decides to exercise the
power of removal or dismissal on the ground
that
his
further
retention
in
service
is
undesirable. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 22 provides for
the punishments which the competent authority
can
impose
after
following
the
procedure
prescribed in sub-rule (2). When sub-rule (2) of
Rule 22 refers to satisfaction of the competent
authority of inexpedience or impracticability of a
trial of such a person, if necessarily as reference
to Section 19 of the BSF Act which as noted,
prescribes
punishment
upon
conviction
by
Security Force Act of a person who commits any
of the offences provided in the said Section
including of absenting himself without leave.
The appellate authority has also elaborated on
this aspect of the matter and he recorded that in
view of the prolonged absence from duty the
trial of the employee by the Court of inquiry was
found
inexpedient.
At
the
same
time,
his
retention in service was found to be undesirable.
Hence, the action under sub-rules (2) and (3) of
Rule 22 of dismissal from service.
10.
Petition is, therefore, dismissed.”
[ 10 ]
Said judgment was challenged by the said writ
petitioner in WA No.153 of 2021 and the Division Bench of this
Court also affirmed the judgment of Leaned Writ Court vide
judgment dated 20.09.2023.
[ 11 ]
The Court has taken into consideration the
submissions of both the learned counsel and also taken note of
all the decisions as referred above. This Court has also
meticulously gone through the record. The basic challenge as to
the dismissal Order of the petitioner is that no notice to showcause was served upon him before such harsh order of dismissal
was passed by his Authority. However, the respondents have
submitted copy of said show-cause notice dated 29.09.2020
along with the copy of the related acknowledgment card which
shows that said show-cause notice was duly received by the
petitioner under his own signature. Therefore the contention of
the petitioner is that no show-cause notice was served upon him
is contrary to the record.
[ 12 ]
Mr.
Chandrasekhar
Sinha,
learned
counsel
also
submits that as per sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 it was incumbent
upon the Department to furnish all the adverse report against the
petitioner along with said show-cause notice, but same was also
not done in the instant case. However, as it appears, no such
specific plea is taken by the petitioner in the writ petition.
Moreover, the respondents in their counter affidavit have
categorically stated that copy of proceeding of Court of Inquiry
was furnished to the petitioner alongwith said show cause notice
and therefore, same has now become a disputed question of fact.
Moreover, it appears that after receipt of show-cause notice, the
petitioner did not submit any reply there against, or even did not
think it necessary to appear before his Authority and, therefore,
non-furnishing of adverse report, if any as alleged, has not
affected him any way. If such reports were not furnished to him
in terms of provision of sub-rule (2) of Rule 22, he could very
well ask the Department to furnish the same immediately to
enable him to submit proper explanation against said show-cause
reply.
[13]
It appears also that he was absent from his duty from
26.05.2020, for, nothing could be produced or shown by the
petitioner that after that date he, on any occasion, performed his
duty as was assigned to him or reported to his place of posting at
Shalbagan. Rather it appears surprisingly that on 10.09.2021 i.e.
after more than one year thereafter, he submitted one petition to
his Authority with the caption ‘Reply of letter dated 30th
August’ (year after the date is not mentioned) with a prayer that
he might be posted at Salbagan, Agartala to perform his official
duty as if he was already transferred from Salbagan, but he has
not produced any alleged transfer Order issued to him showing
his transfer from Salbagan on any occasion during said period.
Even in the said letter he also stated that in July 2016 he was
transferred to Jammu & Kashmir, but owing to his family
problems and his personal problem of illness he could not join
the duty there. When it is his case that in the year 2020 he was
already posted at Frontier Head Quarters of BSF, Salbagan,
Agartala, then what prompted him to submit such petition for his
transfer to Shalbagan in the year 2021. As indicated above, he
has also not clearly indicated the date of socalled letter of the
respondents of 30th August. Respondents clearly stated that they
never issued any such letter and petitioner also failed to produce
any such letter in the Court. Therefore, the conduct of the
petitioner appears to be suspicious and fishy.
[ 14 ]
According to the petitioner, he suffered an accident on
24.08.2020 and received injuries on his chest and brain and as
he was under treatment he could not join the duty. However, he
is totally silent as to when he had actually recovered from such
illness and even no single sheet of paper regarding his meeting
of such accident or receiving of such treatment is submitted in
the Court. Therefore, it cast a serious doubt about genuineness
of his claim of illness.
[ 15 ]
On meticulous scrutiny and also for the reasons as
discussed above, this Court does not find any infraction by the
Respondents of the provision of sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 of Border
Security Force Rules, 1969 which authorizes the Department to
dismiss somebody from service without trial of such person under
Border Security Act, 1968. Section 11 of Border Security Force
Act, 1968 also empowers any officer of rank of Deputy InspectorGeneral to dismiss or remove any person from the service under
his command other than an officer or a subordinate officer of
such rank or ranks. Here in this case also impugned dismissal
order was passed by Deputy Inspector-General of BSF.
[ 16 ]
In similar nature of case i.e. in WP(C) No.843 of 2020
as discussed above, the Court did not interfere with such
dismissal Order on similar ground of unauthorized absent which
was further affirmed by the Division Bench of this Court.
Considering all these aspects, this Court finds no merit in the writ
petition
[ 17 ]
Mr. Chandrasekhar Sinha, learned counsel submits
that the petitioner vide his letter dated 16.01.2023 (Annexure-3)
prayed for furnishing him the copy of dismissal order but said
prayer of the petitioner is still undisposed of by Inspector
General, BSF, Salbagan. Mr. Sinha, learned counsel also submits
that after receipt of copy of the said dismissal order, the
petitioner intends to file petition under rule 28(A) of BSF Rules,
1969 and therefore, the petitioner may be given a liberty to file
the petition under said provision. So far the first point i.e. nonfurnishing
of
copy
of
dismissal
order
is
concerned,
the
respondents have asserted in their counter affidavit that such
copy of dismissal order was sent to the petitioner by registered
post with copy to the SHO of Airport Police station with a request
to hand it over to the petitioner on proper receipt and therefore,
same is also a disputed question of facts which cannot be decided
in this forum. Anyway, for convenience of the petitioner, the
respondents are directed to transmit a copy of said dismissal
order to the petitioner by registered post, A/D within 07 days of
receipt of this order. So far the second prayer for granting
liberty to the petitioner to file petition under rule 28(A) of BSF
Rules,1969 is concerned, option is always there to him to submit
the same before the appropriate authority, if he so desire and he
neednot require to ask for any such liberty. However, it is
clarified that this judgment will not stand as a bar against filing
of the same unless same is barred by any other provision of
law/rules.
With such observations, the writ petition is dismissed being
devoid of any merit.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SATABDI DUTTA
SATABDI DUTTA Digitally
Date: 2025.04.24 15:06:25 +05'30'
Riki
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review