The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
01. 03.2023, 20.03.2023, 31.03.2023 (Annexure-7 to 15), it is revealed that warrant was not executed, and hence, issuance of proclamation order is bad and liable to be dismissed. [9] Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the respondent- State has submitted that the accused petitioner Debabrata dey @ Debu is a habitual offender. He was previously arrested in connection with Panisagar P.S. Case No2018/PNS/022 dated 20.05.2018 under Section-20(ii) of NDPS Act. He was charge sheeted in this case vide PNS P.S. C/s No 37/2019. The accused petitioner has amassed huge movable and immovable property including flat at Baguihati, North 24 parganas, West Bengal, two 10 wheeler lorry, two 4 (four) wheeler vehicle etc from the illegal trade of drugs like Phensendyl, Eskuf etc. [10] The accused petitioner is running a network of illegal drugs trading since long and he is the leader of his network. He has no any drug licence. Several raids were conducted since registration of the case to arrest accused petitioner Debabrata Dey @ Debu but he was found absconding. During investigation from the statements of witness and interrogation statements of arrested accused persons namely Manik Sarkar and Partha Dey it is established that owner of the seized contraband articles is accused petitioner and two others. FSL report confirmed that seized articles are codeine based cough syrup. [11] During …
31. 03.2023, GDE No 33 dated 24.04.2023. [13] Based on an information search and raid was conducted at Titagarh on 23.07 2023 with the assistance of Khardha P.S, North 24 Parganas, West Bengal as the accused petitioner concealed himself at north 24 Parganas. But he was not found there. The presence of the accused petitioner is very much required in the instant case since he is the mastermind of this crime, a petition has been filed before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai to issue' Proclamation and Attachment" order against absconding accused persons namely Debabrata Dey @ Debu and Apu Ranjan Das with intention to attach his property. Another petition was filed before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khiwai to issue Proclamation against accused petitioner on 01.06.2023. [14] On 01.08.2023 the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai was pleased issued proclamation against accused person Shri Debabrata Dey @ Debu for his appearance on 25.08.2023. Proclamation was duly executed on 02.08. 2023 one copy of proclamation has been affixed beside front door of house building of accused petitioner Debabrata Dey @ Debu at Bordowali near BOC and Yubak Sangha club, one copy of Proclamation has been affixed in the notice board of the office of Agartala Municipality Corporation Ward No. 33, Bordowali and one copy of Proclamation has been affixed on the front side wall Yubak sangha Club…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
Crl. Petn.No.18 of 2023
Sri Debabrata Dey @ Debu
.....Petitioner
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
The State of Tripura
.....Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
Legal Report
:
:
Mr. M. Mukharjee, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. B. Manna, Advocate.
Mr. D. Bakshi, Advocate.
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
14/09/2023
Heard Mr. M. Mukharjee, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Lodh, Mr. B. Manna and Mr. D. Bakshi, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Debnath, learned Additional Public Prosecutor,
appearing for the respondent-State.
[2]
The present petition has been filed under Section-482 of the Cr. P.C.,
for invoking the inherent powers of this Court, to prevent the abuse of the due
process of law, and for quashing/setting aside the impugned Order dated
10.07.2023, passed by the Ld. Special Judge, Khowai Tripura District, Khowai,
(Smt. S. Das), in case No. Mungiakami P.S. Case No. 15 of 2021 whereby and
whereunder, the learned Special Judge issued an order of Proclamation against the
petitioner and also set aside notice of Proclamation dated 01.08.2023, issued
against the petitioner.
[3]
The facts in brief are that, on the basis of a written complaint, a case
had been registered against the petitioner vide Mungiakami P.S. Case No. 15 of
2021, dated 30.05.2021 under Sections-21(C)/29/25 of the NDPS Act. Thereafter,
investigation was carried on in course of investigation the I.O. submitted part
charge sheet which was not accepted by the learned court. Apprehending arrest,
the petitioner filed bail application being B.A. 19 of 2023, but the same was
withdrawn. On 10.07.2023 the date was fixed for submitting investigating report in
final form, but the investigating authority did not submit the same and filed a
petition praying for issuance of proclamation and attachment against the petitioner.
[4]
Prior to this, as per prayer of the investigating authority, non-bailable
warrant was issued, but without execution of the non- bailable warrant, learned
Court below issued the proclamation order by impugned Order dated 10.07.2023.
After issuance of the Order of Proclamation, learned Court below issued the notice
on 01.08.2023, directing the petitioner to appear before the learned Court on
25.08.2023, i.e., one month's time has not been given. Challenging the impugned
Order dated 10.07.2023 and the notice dated 01.08.2023, the instant petition has
been filed.
[5]
Mr. Mukharjee, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Lodh and
Mr. B. Manna, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that For
that, the impugned order dated 10.07.2023 is bad in law as there is no subjective
satisfaction of the learned Special Judge to the effect that the petitioner absconded
or is concealing himself so that such warrant cannot be executed upon him. It has
been further submitted that for issuing a proclamation order under Section-82
Cr.P.C., the learned court ought to have come to a conclusion that the warrant
could not be executed as the accused person was absconding or is concealing
himself so that such warrant could not be executed, but in the impugned order
there is no such satisfaction of the learned Court below, and hence, the impugned
order is liable to be interfered with.
[6]
The investigating authority at the time of filing the petition for
proclamation did not submit any evidence whereby they could prove that the
petitioner has absconded or is concealing himself so that the warrant cannot be
executed. It is trite low the section of the learned court, the prosecution the place
evidence by which the court can come to come that the accused person has
absconded is concealing himself so that such warrant cannot be executed, but in
the case, the prosecution could not lend any evidence no produce any documents
where the learned court can come to a conclusion that the accused person is
absconding or concealing himself so that such warrant cannot be executed. As the
prosecuting agency failed to comply the mandate of Section-82 CPC and the
learned court below without appreciating the same passed the impugned order
dated 10.07.2023 for issuance of proclamation, the impugned order is liable to be
interfered with.
[7]
The notice of proclamation dated 01.08.2023 is bad in law as the
proclamation notice was issued on 01.08.2023 directing the petitioner to appear
before the learned Court below on 25.08.2023 i.e. the learned court below did not
give one month's time to the petitioner for his appearance. As per mandate of
Section-82 Cr.P.C., the learned Court below ought to have given one month's time
from the date of publication of the notice for appearance. In the instant case, since
the learned Court below did not follow the mandate of Section-82 Cr.P.C., the
impugned notice of proclamation dated 01.08.2023 is also bad in law and liable to
be set-aside.
[8]
The impugned order dated 10.07.2023 for issuance of proclamation
is bad as without verifying the execution report Warrant of Arrest Id. Court below
passed the order of proclamation. In the instant case from the orders dated
21.12.2022, 04.01.2023, 17.01.2023, 31.01.2023, 14.02.2023, 15.02.2023,
01.03.2023, 20.03.2023, 31.03.2023 (Annexure-7 to 15), it is revealed that warrant
was not executed, and hence, issuance of proclamation order is bad and liable to be
dismissed.
[9]
Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the respondent-
State has submitted that the accused petitioner Debabrata dey @ Debu is a habitual
offender. He was previously arrested in connection with Panisagar P.S. Case
No2018/PNS/022 dated 20.05.2018 under Section-20(ii) of NDPS Act. He was
charge sheeted in this case vide PNS P.S. C/s No 37/2019. The accused petitioner
has amassed huge movable and immovable property including flat at Baguihati,
North 24 parganas, West Bengal, two 10 wheeler lorry, two 4 (four) wheeler
vehicle etc from the illegal trade of drugs like Phensendyl, Eskuf etc.
[10]
The accused petitioner is running a network of illegal drugs trading
since long and he is the leader of his network. He has no any drug licence. Several
raids were conducted since registration of the case to arrest accused petitioner
Debabrata Dey @ Debu but he was found absconding. During investigation from
the statements of witness and interrogation statements of arrested accused persons
namely Manik Sarkar and Partha Dey it is established that owner of the seized
contraband articles is accused petitioner and two others. FSL report confirmed that
seized articles are codeine based cough syrup.
[11]
During investigation several notices under Section-67 of NDPS Act
1985 were issued to Debabrata Dey on 14.02.2022, 10.03.2022 and 29.06.2022
but, he did not respond till date. On 24.09.2021 and 10.03.2022 visited the
residential flat named Grihangan Apartment situated at Baguiati, Kolkata but he is
also found absconding with lock and key. Finding no other alternative a petition
was filed before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai on 13.09.2022 to
issue NBWA against absconding accused petitioner Debabrata Dey @ Debu. The
learned Court of Special Judge Khowai was pleased to issue NBWA against
accused petitioner Debabrata Dey @ Debu on 14.09.2022.
[12]
Several raids also were conducted to execute the NBWA but
Debabrata Dey @ Debu is hiding himself to escape police arrest. This refers A .D.
Nagar P.S. G.D. Entry No 34 dated 02.01.2023, GDE No 20 dated 07.01.2023,
GDE No 27 dated 26.02.2023, GDE No 23 dated 07.03.2023, GDE No 36 dated
31.03.2023, GDE No 33 dated 24.04.2023.
[13]
Based on an information search and raid was conducted at Titagarh
on 23.07 2023 with the assistance of Khardha P.S, North 24 Parganas, West
Bengal as the accused petitioner concealed himself at north 24 Parganas. But he
was not found there. The presence of the accused petitioner is very much required
in the instant case since he is the mastermind of this crime, a petition has been
filed before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai to issue' Proclamation and
Attachment" order against absconding accused persons namely Debabrata Dey @
Debu and Apu Ranjan Das with intention to attach his property. Another petition
was filed before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khiwai to issue Proclamation
against accused petitioner on 01.06.2023.
[14]
On 01.08.2023 the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai was
pleased issued proclamation against accused person Shri Debabrata Dey @ Debu
for his appearance on 25.08.2023. Proclamation was duly executed on 02.08. 2023
one copy of proclamation has been affixed beside front door of house building of
accused petitioner Debabrata Dey @ Debu at Bordowali near BOC and Yubak
Sangha club, one copy of Proclamation has been affixed in the notice board of the
office of Agartala Municipality Corporation Ward No. 33, Bordowali and one
copy of Proclamation has been affixed on the front side wall Yubak sangha Club
building, Bordowali. One copy of Proclamation has been published on the local
dailies including Dainik Sambad on 18.08.2023. But, till date accused petitioner is
absconding. He did not appear before the learned Court of Special Judge, Khowai
though proclamation was executed.
[15]
In view of overall discussions, this Court is of the considered opinion
that a citizen cannot claim/plead equities, where he himself is not following the
due process of law. As a law abiding citizen, the accused petitioner first ought to
have appeared before the Court of law once summons are issued at first stage and
at the second stage when warrants are issued, he ought to follow the procedure as
contemplated under Cr. P.C. When Section-82 proclamation is issued in Form-4,
he ought to have complied with the Court’s directions. Instead evasion of legal
procedure and challenging the proclamation order stating that Court has not
followed the procedure, this conduct of the petitioner showing disrespect towards
Court of law and also to legal procedure, which this Court is not inclined to
appreciate and has no hesitation to draw an adverse inference against the
petitioner. The word ‘abscond’ means the primary meaning of the word ‘abscond’
is to hide and when in order to evade the process of law a person is hiding from
(or even in) his place of residence, he is said to ‘abscond’.
[16]
It becomes an obligation on the part of a law abiding citizen to
respect and obey the law of the land and the Court proceedings. Generally, always
the arguments are advanced in writ petitions and in criminal cases saying the
respondent has violated the doctrine of audi alterm partem and not followed the
procedure contemplated under law and pray for indulgence. But it becomes equally
necessary to examine as to what accusation the citizen is facing and was he
approached the Court of law with clean hands. In the backdrop of the allegations
against a citizen, it would be better to decide whether he is entitled to raise such
argument. Citizens are also equally responsible to comply the requirements under
the law. Law is not one sided as if only respondents should follow. Even the
citizen/petitioner should first make out a prima facie case in his favour.
[17]
Antecedents of accused are equally important and needs to be
considered while dealing with such type of matter. This Court goes to an extent of
saying that the accused-petitioner taking advantage of one technical error he
cannot go away with clean chit. Section-82 of Cr. P.C. proclamation warrants
issued but, he is absconding, nothing prevented him to obey the Court orders. He
has not approached with clean hands. He shall appear before the concerned learned
Court having jurisdiction on or before 22.09.2023 failing which; the learned Court
may proceed under Section-83 of the Cr. P.C which deals with attachment of
property of person absconding.
[18]
Accordingly, the present petition stands dismissed. Return the case
diary.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.09.20
15:32:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review