Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.185 of 2025
Sri Charmajoy Tripura,
S/O- Sri Chetrang Tripura,
R/o- Khagendra Roaja Para,
P.O.- Harincherra,
P.S.- Ambassa,
Dist.-Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289.
…. Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented be the Secretary to the
Govt. of Tripura,
Public Works Department (PWD),
New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala,
District- West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The District Magistrate & Collector,
Dhalai District, Jawaharnagar,
Ambassa
District- Dhalai Tripura,
PIN-799289.
3. The Block Development Officer,
Ambassa R.D. Block, Ambassa,
District-Dhalai, Tripura, PIN-799289.
4. The Executive Engineer,
D.W.S. Circle, Ambassa Division,
Jawaharnagar, Ambassa,
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289.
5. The Chairman,
Ambassa, Block Advisory Committee,
Dist.-Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289.
6. Sri Karkajoy Tripura,
S/o- Sri Rone Kumar Tripura
R/o- Khagendra Roaja Para,
P.O.- Harincherra, P.S.- Ambassa,
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289.
…….Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Kabrabam Dhirendra Singha, Adv.
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
Mr. Herojit Debbarma, Adv.
Date of Hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
27.01.2026
:
30.01.2026
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This writ petition is filed by the petitioner seeking
the following reliefs:(a)
to admit this petition,
(b)
call for the records,
(c)
issue Rule, calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why a writ in the nature of Certiorari
should not be issued quashing and setting aside the
impugned office letter dated 29.11.2024 whereby the
name of the petitioner as Pump Operator at Khagendra
Roaja Para under Gurudhan Para VC has been dropped
though selected earlier and replaced by the name of
the private respondent No.6. (Annexure-E) AND/OR,
(d)
to show cause as to why a writ in the nature of
Mandamus
should
not
be
issued
directing/
commanding the respondent authorities to recall the
impugned office letter dated 29.11.2024 whereby the
name of the petitioner as Pump Operator at Khagendra
Roaja Para under Gurudhan Para VC has been dropped
and replaced by the name of the private respondent
No.6. (Annexure-E), AND/OR,
(e)
to issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus or
pass
any
other
appropriate
order
or
direction
directing/commanding the respondent authorities to
appoint the petitioner to the post of Pump Operator at
Khagendra Roaja Para under Gurudhan Para VC as per
the
office
letter
vide
No.F.8(26)/BDO/AMBS/PANCH/2024-25/1897 Dated
08/10/2024 issued by the respondent No.3 forthwith,
(reflected in Annexure-E) AND/OR,
(f)
to issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus or
pass any appropriate order or direction directing /
commanding the respondent
authorities either to
appoint the petitioner to the post of Pump Operator or
to pay appropriate compensation in lieu of his land or
to vacate the land of the petitioner peacefully within a
stipulated period as may be fixed by this Hon‟ble
Court.
-AND-
(g)
after hearing the parties, be pleased to make
the Rule absolute and/or pass such further order(s) as
to Your Lordships may deem fit and proper.
-AND(h)
In the interim, it is graciously prayed that
pending disposal of the Rule the execution/operation
of
the
impugned
office
letter
dated
29.11.2024
dropping the name of the petitioner and any attempt
so made to appoint the private respondent in place of
the petitioner to the post of Pump Operator at
Khagendra
Roaja
Para
under
Gurudhanpara
VC,
Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura may be stayed and/or pass
such further order(s) as to Your Lordships may deem
fit and proper.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Kabrabam Dhirendra
Singha appearing on behalf of the petitioner. Also heard
Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. Karnajit De appearing on behalf of the
State-respondents and further heard Learned Counsel, Mr.
Herojit Debbarma appearing on behalf of the respondent No.6.
But inspite of service of notice none appeared on behalf of the
respondent No.5.
03.
Singha
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel, Mr. K. D.
appearing
for
the
petitioner
submitted
that
the
petitioner is a person belonging to ST (Scheduled Tribe)
community of Tripura and a poor jhumia (Jhum cultivator)
family and he is Class-VIII passed. In the year 2010,
Government of Tripura allotted plots of land to the petitioner
measuring 8.00 acre situated at Khagendra Ruyaja Para under
Gurudhan Para Panchayat, Tehasil/ Taluka-Ambassa, District
Dhalai, Tripura and on the basis of that Khatian bearing
No.2/9, Plot No.48/p was created and the Type of Forest-RF
classified as Type of Land- Tilla and it was under the Scheduled
Tribes and other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of
Forest Rights) Rules, 2007. It was also submitted that since
2010 the petitioner has been occupying the said land (Reliance
was placed upon Annexure-A and Annexure-B in this
regard).
04.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner further submitted
that in the year 2020 the respondent authorities approached
the petitioner to set up a Drinking Water Supply Pump under
the Government’s Innovative Scheme over the said land of the
petitioner and as the petitioner urged for compensation that
time, it was assured that the petitioner would be given
appointment as Pump Operator of the said Water Supply Pump
as a owner of the said land. On assurance the land was given
by him and accordingly the respondent authorities constructed
pump house over the land of the petitioner. It was also
informed by the respondent authorities to the petitioner to
submit application for his appointment as Pump Operator and
accordingly the petitioner submitted representation which was
duly received by respondent Nos.3 and 4. Further reliance was
placed in this regard on Annexure-C and Annexure-D.
05.
It was later on informed to the petitioner that he
would be given appointment shortly as Pump Operator at
Khagendra Ruyaja Para under Gurudhan Para VC and according
to the petitioner he was officially selected as Pump Operator of
the said Khangendra Ruyaja Para Pump Machine by office order
dated 08.10.2024 issued by the respondent No.3 but the copy
of the same was not supplied to him. But reference of the
same could be gathered from Annexure-E. But surprisingly
the petitioner came to know that vide office letter dated
29.11.2024 (Annexure-E) the respondent No.6 has been
appointed as Pump Operator for the said pump machine most
illegally without giving any opportunity of being heard to him.
Knowing the same fact the petitioner visited the office of the
respondent
authorities
and
submitted
representation
on
01.02.2025 (Annexure-F) but no action was taken.
06.
Further representation was made to the Assistant
Engineer,
DWS,
Ambassa
Sub-Division,
Ambassa,
Dhalai
Tripura with a copy to respondent No.5 (Annexure-G). But
inspite of that no action was taken. So under compelling
circumstances the petitioner has filed this petition before this
Court.
07.
It was further submitted that, in this regard the
villagers of the village set a public meeting on 14.02.2025
wherein respondent No.6 namely, Sri Karkajoy Tripura and Sri
Kinadhan Tripura who were appointed as Pump Operators were
invited to attend but those persons did not attend the meeting
and in this regard resolution was taken by the villagers
(Annexure-H) and the same was also submitted to the
authority but inspite of that also no action was taken.
08.
The respondents-State contested the writ petition
by filing one counter-affidavit wherein in Para Nos.4, 5 and 6 it
was submitted as under :-
“4. That, accordingly, since from issue of the said
Notification
the
Concerned
Panchayat
/BAC/ADC
committees were engaging persons for operation of
water supply scheme under Dhalai District also &
subsequently as per decision taken by the Tripura
State Government the department issued their wages
from
grant-in-Aid
BDOs‟/Executive
fund
Officers
to
the
directly
concerned
through
LOC
accordingly the concerned BDOs are making their
monthly wages according to their attendance. In this
connection, as per said guide line, State Government is
not responsible or eligible for engagement of any
Pump Operator.
5. That, as per the above guideline a letter from BDO,
Ambassa was received along with a resolution duly
approved
by
BAC
Chairman,
Ambassa
wherein
Petitioner was appointed as pump operator under
Innovative water supply scheme at Khagendra Roaja
Para on 08-10-2024. Thereafter another letter from
BDO, Ambassa was received on 29-11-2024 wherein
the name of the petitioner was dropped. Accordingly
action was taken up from the Executive Engineer, DWS
Division, Ambassa. It is pertinent to mentioned here
that the matter of selection of pump operators for
operation of such water supply schemes are totally
taken up by Panchayat basis, a resolution of selected
candidates
is
approved
by
BAC
Chairman
and
forwarded by BDO‟s to the PWD(DWS) for payment of
monthly wages.
6. That, with regard to para 7, I say that the issue is
not related to the PWD (DWS). Panchayat Raj &
Autonomous District Council Bodies that the concerned
Panchayat/BAC/ADC committees is fully responsible
for selection/engagement of person for operation &
mtc. Of water supply scheme in Rural areas.”
09.
Respondent No.6 also submitted counter-affidavit
and submitted that since 2021 he was discharging his duties as
Pump Operator of the said village. But surprisingly regarding
his appointment in the year 2021, the said respondent could
not submit any documentary evidence before this Court.
10.
At the time of hearing, Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. K.
De appearing for the respondents-State submitted that the
decision was taken based on the recommendation of Chairman,
Ambassa, BAC. But surprisingly the Chairman, BAC inspite of
receipt of notice did not appear before the Court. But the
State-respondents in the counter-affidavit did not deny the fact
of ownership of the land by the present petitioner. Even the
respondent No.6 also did not deny the said fact. Rather from
the counter-affidavit it appears that, initially the petitioner was
appointed
by
the
respondent
No.3
on
08.10.2024
but
thereafter another letter was received from BDO, Ambassa RD
Block, Dhalai District on 29.11.2024 wherein the name of the
petitioner was dropped. But in this regard, the petitioner was
not heard personally even no written communication was made
to him.
11.
Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner at the
time of hearing relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in East Coast Railway and Another
Vs. Mahadev Appa Rao and Others reported in (2010) 7
SCC 678 wherein in Para Nos.23 and 24 of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed as under:“23. Arbitrariness in the making of an order by an
authority can manifest itself in different forms. Nonapplication of mind by the authority making the order
is only one of them. Every order passed by a public
authority must disclose due and proper application of
mind by the person making the order. This may be
evident from the order itself or the record
contemporaneously maintained. Application of mind is
best demonstrated by disclosure of mind by the
authority making the order. And disclosure is best
done by recording the reasons that led the authority to
pass the order in question. Absence of reasons either
in the order passed by the authority or in the record
contemporaneously maintained is clearly suggestive of
the order being arbitrary hence legally unsustainable.
24. In the instant case the order passed by the
competent authority does not state any reasons
whatsoever for the cancellation of the typing test. It is
nobody‟s case that any such reasons were set out even
in any contemporaneous record or file. In the absence
of reasons in support of the order it is difficult to
assume that the authority had properly applied its
mind before passing the order cancelling the test.”
12.
Reference was made on another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in MSR. Maneka Gandhi Vs.
Union of India and Another reported in (1978) 1 SCC 248
wherein in the last part of Para Nos.8 and 9 of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed as under:“8. ……..The principle of audi alteram partem, which
mandates that no one shall be condemned unheard, is
part of the rules of natural justice. In fact, there are
two main principles in which the rules of natural
justice are manifested, namely, nemo judex in causa
sua and audi alteram partem. We are not concerned
here with the former, since there is no case of bias
urged here. The question is only in regard to the right
of hearing which involves the audi alteram partem
rule. Can it be imported in the procedure for
impounding a passport?……….
9. ……..Thus, the soul of natural justice is „fair-play in
action‟ and that is why it has received the widest
recognition throughout the democratic world. In the
United States, the right to an administrative hearing is
regarded as essential requirement of fundamental
fairness. And in England too it has been held that „fairplay in action‟ demands that before any prejudicial or
adverse action is taken against a person, he must be
given an opportunity to be heard. The rule was stated
by Lord Denning, M.R. in these terms in Schmidt v.
Secretary of State for Home Affairs : (1969) 2 Ch D
149 – “where a public officer has power to deprive a
person of his liberty or his property, the general
principle is that it has not to be done without his being
given an opportunity of being heard and of making
representations on his own behalf”. The same rule also
prevails in other Common-wealth countries like
Canada, Australia and New Zealand. It has even gained
access to the United Nations (vide American Journal of
International Law, Vol. 67, page 479). Magarry, J.,
describes natural justice “as a distillate of due process
of law” (vide Fontaine v. Chastarton : (1968) 112
Solicitor General 690). It is the quintessence of the
process of justice inspired and guided by „fair-play in
action‟. If we look at the speeches of the various law
Lords in Wiseman’s case, it will be seen that each one
of them asked the question “whether in the particular
circumstances of the case, the Tribunal acted unfairly
so that it could be said that their procedure did not
match with what justice demanded”, or, was the
procedure adopted by the Tribunal „in all the
circumstances unfair‟? The test adopted by every Law
Lord was whether the procedure followed was fair in
all the circumstances and „fair-play in action‟ required
that an opportunity should be given to the tax-payer
“to see and reply to the counter-statement of the
Commissioners” before reaching the conclusion that
“there is a prima facie case against him”. The inquiry
must, therefore, always be : does fairness in action
demand that an opportunity to be heard should be
given to the person affected?”
Referring
the
same
Learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner submitted that in the given case, the action of the
respondent authorities show the arbitrariness and by their
illegal act they have deprived the right of the petitioner without
offering him any opportunity or personal hearing and without
any written communication to him. So, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner urged before the Court to allow the writ petition,
applying the aforesaid principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court.
13.
Finally, Learned Counsel for the petitioner referred
another citation of the Supreme Court of India in Kumari
Shrilekha Vidyarthi and Others Vs. State of U.P. and
Others reported in (1991) 1 SCC 212 wherein in Para No.36,
the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:“36. The meaning and true import of arbitrariness is
more easily visualized than precisely stated or defined.
The question, whether an impugned act is arbitrary or
not, is ultimately to be answered on the facts and in
the circumstances of a given case. An obvious test to
apply is to see whether there is any discernible
principle emerging from the impugned act and if so,
does it satisfy the test of reasonableness. Where a
mode is prescribed for doing an act and there is no
impediment in following that procedure, performance
of the act otherwise and in a manner which does not
disclose any discernible principle which is reasonable,
may itself attract the vice of arbitrariness. Every State
action must be informed by reason and it follows that
an act uninformed by reason, is arbitrary. Rule of law
contemplates governance by laws and not by humour,
whims or caprices of the men to whom the governance
is entrusted for the time being. It is trite that „be you
ever so high, the laws are above you‟. This is what
men in power must remember, always.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Counsel
further
submitted that from the facts and circumstances of the case it
will transpire the arbitrariness of the respondent authorities in
rejecting the name of the petitioner as Pump Operator and to
include respondent No.6 as Pump Operator in place of the
petitioner
inspite
of
issuing
his
engagement
order
on
08.10.2024.
14.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the petitioner’s documents annexed with this writ petition and
the counter-affidavit submitted by the respondents-State and
private respondent No.6. As already stated, the respondentsState in the counter-affidavit in Para No.5 specifically admitted
that on 08.10.2024 the petitioner was appointed as Pump
Operator
under
Innovative
water
supply
scheme
under
Khagendra Roaja Para but thereafter his name was dropped
and respondent No.6 was recommended for appointment. But
in this regard no personal hearing was given to the petitioner.
Even no written communication was made to him by the
respondent authorities. Admittedly, the petitioner could not
produce the document dated 08.10.2024. Respondent No.5
also inspite of receipt of notice did not come before this Court
to challenge the same which also shows its arbitrariness to
delete the name of the petitioner from engaging him as Pump
Operator for the respective village. The respondent No.6
admittedly in the year 2024 by order dated 29.11.2024 was
appointed as Pump Operator in place of the petitioner. But the
plea taken by the said respondent that he was engaged in the
year 2021 was not supported by any documentary evidence.
Although it was the admitted position that, he undergone
training earlier. There is no evidence on record that for
acquiring/using the land of the petitioner and for construction
of pump house any sort of compensation was given to the
present petitioner at any point of time. The citations referred
by the petitioner squarely cover the case of the petitioner.
15.
Thus, after hearing both the sides and also after
going through the observations referred by the petitioner in the
aforenoted cases it appears that the principles of natural
justice has been violated in respect of the petitioner by the
respondent
authorities
by
not
appointing
him
as
Pump
Operator although he was engaged/appointed on 08.10.2024
but later on without any cogent reason by subsequent letter
dated 29.11.2024 his name was deleted from the letter of
recommendation which shows arbitrariness on the part of the
respondent authorities and the same cannot be permitted in
the eye of law.
The citations referred by the petitioner are very
much applicable for decision of this case. Accordingly in
deciding this writ petition I have taken note of the said
observation made by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the present
case.
16.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner
is hereby allowed. The communication dated 29.11.2024
written by BDO, Ambassa RD Block, Dhalai District to The
Executive Engineer, D.W.S., Ambassa Division, Jawaharnagar:
Dhalai District recommending the name of the respondent No.6
as Pump Operator for the respective village deleting/dropping
the
name
of
the
present
petitioner
from
the
said
communication stands quashed/set aside accordingly. The
respondent authorities are hereby asked to appoint the
petitioner immediately to the post of Pump Operator at
Gurudhan Para VC under Innovative Scheme at Khagendra
Roaja Para immediately preferably within a period of 2 (two)
months from the date of passing of this judgment and order.
With
these
observations,
this
writ
petition
is
disposed of.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2026.01.30 17:56:58
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review