Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Rev. P. No. 52 of 2021
Sri Chandan Saha
…………… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
The State of Tripura and another.
…………… Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Asutosh De, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. S. Debnath, Advocate.
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
ORDER
19/01/2022
This criminal revision petition is directed against the
order dated 26.03.2021 passed by Family Court Agartala, West
Tripura in Case No. Misc. 261 of 2019 directing the petitioner to
pay monthly maintenance allowance at the rate of Rs.8,000/- to
his wife (respondent herein) in a proceeding under Section 125 Cr.
P.C.
[2]
The factual context of the case is as under:
Marriage of the parties was solemnized on 06.03.2018
as per the rites and customs of Hindu marriage. After marriage the
respondent wife accompanied her husband to his place. After few
months they developed matrimonial discord. The respondent-wife
left her husband and filed a petition under Section 125 Cr. P.C in
the Family Court at Agartala claiming maintenance allowance from
her husband. She brought several allegations against her husband
to justify her claim. According to her, she was subjected to
physical torture at her matrimonial home for dowry. On several
occasions she was beaten and forced to live outside her bedroom
for no fault of her. Ultimately, she was driven out of her
matrimonial home.
[3]
The husband contested the case by filing written
objection against the claim of his wife. In his written objection he
denied all allegations of his wife. According to him his wife
maintained extra marital relationship for which she was not at all
interested in discharging her matrimonial obligations towards her
petitioner-husband. Despite knowing the act that the petitioner
had been suffering from cancer she was always abusive to her
husband and in-laws. Ultimately, she left her matrimonial home on
her own and instituted cases one after another against her
husband and in-laws.
[4]
The learned Judge Family Court framed several issues
in the case and recorded the evidence of two PWs and 2 OPWs.
The PWs supported the case of the wife. The OPWs on the other
hand tried to impeach the case of the wife. Having appreciated
their evidence and submissions made on behalf of the parties, the
Family Court decided the case in favour of the wife (respondent
herein) by directing her husband to pay monthly sum of
Rs.8,000/- to her as maintenance allowance viewing as under:
“9)
On perusal of the entire evidence on
record, it is found that the main allegation of the
petitioner against the OP is that after happily
staying for some days in her matrimonial home,
the OP and his family members started to torture
her on demand money. PW-2 also corroborated
PW-1 that she was tortured her in matrimonial
home. It also appears that there is a counter
allegation of the OP and her in-laws that the
petitioner was reluctant to cohabit with the
petitioner as she has been suffering from female
disease and on the alleged information by the
mother-in-law of the petitioner, her father took
her to her parent‟s house for treatment in two
occasions though no medical document has been
produced to prove that the petitioner is actually
suffering from any sort of female disease as
during cross both the PWs have outright rejected
the claim of the OP and her in-laws that the
petitioner has been suffering from any female
disease. However, it is not expected from the part
of the in-laws of the petitioner that in any issue
whatsoever, the petitioner should be tortured in
her matrimonial home. Being the legally married
wife of the OP it is his duty and obligation to
maintain and arrange for her treatment but he
did not arrange for her treatment. None of the
OPW has stated that for the alleged disease they
have arranged any medical treatment of the
petitioner at any point of time, though father of
the petitioner had to arrange the treatment of his
daughter petitioner. After leaving of the
matrimonial home by the petitioner, since neither
the OP nor his family members ever made any
contract with the petitioner. OPW-1 on the other
hand, stated that his father-in-law proposed him
to stay in his house as „ghar jamai‟ which the
petitioner side denied. The OP also made counter
allegation of maintaining illicit relationship of the
petitioner but he has not proved it by any
corroborative evidence.
It appears from the deposition of OPW-1
that the OP has filed a case for RCR when his
father-in-law refused to give his daughterpetitioner but none of the OPWs have stated
anywhere that they actually approached the
petitioner and went to the parent‟s house of the
OP to bring the petitioner back to her matrimonial
home to show any endevour for bringing the
petitioner back to her matrimonial home. It also
appears from the evidence of OPW-1 that the
petitioner
had
approached
the
Tripura
Commission for Women and also filed a case
before CJM and the same was dealt by Amtali PS.
Subsequently, the petitioner filed a case u/s.
498A of IPC, in Melaghar PS vide NO. 39/2019
and also filed a maintenance case against him. It
is not expected that a married woman having no
source of income would leave her matrimonial
home without any reason and for the above
reasons, the petitioner had to leave her
matrimonial home. Therefore, from the aforesaid
facts and circumstances it can safely be
concluded that the petitioner was subjected to
torture in her matrimonial home by the OP and
his in-laws.
10)
The document as Exbt.1 is the reply of RTI
filed by the petitioner from where it is ascertained
by the Municipal Counsel, Melaghar that the
Trade License bearing No. 501 Dt.05.06.2018 is
in the name of Chandan Saha under Melaghar
Municipal Council and Exbt.2 is the copy of Trade
Licence of Chandan Saha, the OP herein and it
also appears that the License was issued by Chief
Executive Officer on 05.06.2018. But from the
Exbt.‟B‟ it appears that the Trade License bearing
No.62 in the name of Uttam Saha was issued
from the Melaghar Municipal Council for the
period from 24-06-2015 to 31-03-2016 on 24-062015 by the Chief Executive Officer, Municipal
Council which is issued prior to the date of issuing
the Trade License in the name of the OP,
Chandan Saha. Therefore, it can clearly be
ascertained that the Trade License for the shop
named „Ram Krishna Bastralaya‟, Melaghar is
currently lying with Chandan Saha and he is
presently the owner of the said shop named „Ram
Krishna Bastralaya‟. Therefore, it can be
presumed that OP being the owner of garment
shop has sufficient means to maintain his wife.
Hence, the income of the OP is fixed at
Rs.20,000/- per month.
But it is fact that the OP has not been
paying any maintenance to the petitioner though
he is under obligation to pay maintenance to his
wife-petitioner.
11)
Therefore, situated thus, the OP, Sri
Chandan Saha is hereby directed to pay
Rs.8,000/- per month as maintenance to the
petitioner Smt. Dipanjali Saha w.e.f, 03-05-2019
and send the same to the Savings Bank Account
of the petitioner, payable within 10th day of every
English Calendar month until further order.
12)
In view of the above, the instant case is
hereby disposed of on contest.
13)
Supply copy of this order to both the
parties for taking necessary steps.
14)
[5]
Make necessary entries in the TR.”
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said order of the
Family Court, the husband has filed this criminal revision petition
for quashing the order.
[6]
Appearing for the husband, Mr. Asutosh De, learned
Advocate submits that the family Court came to an erroneous
finding without appreciation of evidence. Counsel contends that no
evidence was led to prove that the husband is the owner of
Ramkrishna Bastralaya at Melaghar. The wife led some evidence to
establish that her husband had a trade license in his name issued
from the Melaghar Municipal Council. But she could not lead any
evidence to prove that he was the owner of Ramkrishna
Bastralaya.
Counsel
submits
that
Ramkrishna
Bastralaya
at
Melaghar is actually owned by his elder brother where petitioner
works as the employee. It is contended by Mr. De, learned
advocate that the husband has been suffering from cancer over a
quite long period of time. He has been incurring huge monthly
expenses for treatment. Even though such facts were pleaded by
the husband in the Family Court and evidence was also led by him
to prove the said facts, the Family Court asked him to pay a huge
sum of monthly maintenance allowance to his wife without any
proof of his income. Mr. Asutosh De, learned counsel of the
husband, therefore, urges the court for setting aside the impugned
order. Counsel however, submits that since the wife of the
petitioner has no means of income, petitioner is ready to maintain
his wife and despite his difficulties he would pay a monthly sum of
Rs.5,000/- to his wife by depositing the same in the bank account
of his wife.
[7]
Even
though
the
wife
has
received
notice
and
appointed Sri Sudipta Shekhar Debnath as her advocate, none
appears for her when the case is taken up for hearing.
[8]
The record demonstrates that the husband pleaded
before the Family Court that he had been suffering from cancer.
He also led evidence in this regard. It is also true that no evidence
has been led by his wife to prove the income of her husband.
Moreover, there is no evidence to prove that the husband is the
owner of Ramkrishna Bastralaya at Melaghar. Since the husband
volunteers to pay Rs.5,000/- to his wife, this Court is of the view
that in the given facts and circumstances of the case, it would be a
fair amount particularly when no proof has been adduced in
respect of the income of the husband.
[9]
The petitioner-husband is therefore, directed to pay
monthly maintenance allowance of Rs.5,000/- to his respondentwife by depositing the same in her individual bank account within
the first week of every succeeding month. The arrear falling due
w.e.f. 03.05.2019 till 31.12.2021 at the monthly rate of Rs.5,000/may be paid in installments. The number of installments for paying
the arrear shall be determined by the Family Court, Agartala after
hearing the parties. The monthly maintenance allowance of the
month of January, 2022 at the rate of Rs.5,000/- shall be paid by
the
petitioner by depositing the same in the individual bank
account of his wife within 7th day of February, 2022 and the
allowance for the forthcoming months shall be paid likewise.
[10]
In terms of the above, the criminal revision petition is
disposed of. Communicate the order to the parties. Send back the
LC record.
JUDGE
Dipankar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review