Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.814 of 2024
Sri Biswanath Dey,
Son of late Rasaraj Dey,
Resident of P.O. Arundhati Nagar,
Road No.9, Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 003
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura ,
To be represented by the Secretary/Principal Secretary,
GA (P&T) Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
2. The Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 010
3. The Deputy Director,
PWD (R &B),Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
4. The Chief Engineer,
Public Works Department,
New Secretariat Building, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:799 010
5. The Superintending Engineer,
Second Circle, Agartala,
Office of the Superintending Engineer,
Second Circle, Agartala,
Gurkhabasti, PIN: 799 010
6. The Accountant General,
Office of the Accountant General (A & E),
Agartala, Tripura, PIN: 799 006
7. The Senior Accounts Officer,
Office of the Accountant General (A & E),
Agartala, Tripura, PIN: 799 006
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman,
Senior Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Shaktimoy Chakraborty,
Advocate General
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
Ms. Pinki Chakraborty, Adv.
Mr. Pradyumna Gautam, Adv.
Mr. Debalaya Bhattacharya,
Sr. Adv.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
07.03.2025
27.03.2025
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
By means of filing this writ petition the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:
(i)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to
cause full and final payment to the Petitioner on
the basis of Ceiling Limit of Rs.10,00,000/- by
taking into account 40 years of service as
rendered by the Petitioner and the last Basic pay
of Rs.23,930/- and his Dearness Allowance of
Rs.17,708 /- after adjusting the payment already
made to the Petitioner.
(ii)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of
Mandamus
and/or
order/orders
and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to
cause payment of interest @ 9% per annum on
the balance amount of gratuity w.e.f. the date on
which gratuity became payable i.e. 30 days after
retirement from service till the date payment is
made.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of
Mandamus
and/or
order/orders
and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued whereby declaring that the Notification,
dt.
05.05.2009,
issued
by
the
Finance
Department, Govt. of Tripura, must be made in
consonance with the Payment of Gratuity Act so
far determination of gratuity and ceiling limit of
gratuity are concerned.
(iv) Make the rules absolute.
(v) Call for records.
(vi) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble
High Court considered fit and proper.
02.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Learned Advocate General Mr. S. M.
Chakraborty assisted by Ms. P. Chakraborty along with Mr.
P. Gautam, Learned Sr. G.A. appearing for the Staterespondents and also heard Learned Senior counsel Mr. D.
Bhattacharya assisted by Mr. S. Saha, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondents No.6 and 7.
03.
The gist of the petition filed by the petitioner is
that the petitioner had joined service on 11.07.1979 as LDC
under the Public Works Department. By memo dated
06.07.1979 issued by the Superintending Engineer, Coordination, Second Circle, Agartala, Tripura the petitioner
was offered a purely temporary post of LDC under the Public
Works Department for a period of three months on a
monthly pay of Rs.240/- in the scale of Rs.240-440/- along
with other admissible allowance. The petitioner later on got
promotion to a higher post and retired as UDC under the
office
of
the
Executive
Engineer,
Resource
Division,
Panchamukh, Agartala, Tripura. On attaining the age of
superannuation, the petitioner retired from service w.e.f.
29.02.2016. At the time of retirement, the last basic pay of
the petitioner was Rs.23,930/- and D.A. was Rs.17,708/and the petitioner was holding the post of UDC having in his
credit about 36 years of service. Thereafter vide memo
dated 19.08.2016 issued by the Senior Accounts Officer,
office of the Accountant General (A & E), Tripura an amount
of Rs.2,95,135/- was sanctioned to the petitioner as
provisional DCRG. An additional amount of Rs.99,710/- was
sanctioned in favour of the petitioner at a later date,
thereby making the total amount received by the petitioner
to be Rs.3,94,845/-. After his retirement regular monthly
pension
under
CCS(Pension)
Rules
has
been
sanctioned in favour of the petitioner and he is getting
regular monthly pension accordingly. On retirement from
service, the petitioner became entitled to full and final
payment of gratuity within 30 days from the date of
retirement in terms of Section 7(3) of the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972. As the petitioner retired from service on
29.02.2016, so the petitioner became liable to discharge
their obligation of causing full and final payment of gratuity
to the petitioner within the next 30 days i.e. positively by
01.04.2016 as per Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. On
retirement of the petitioner the petitioner was paid an
amount of Rs.3,94,845/- towards purported full and final
payment of gratuity. The said amount of Rs.3,94,845/- was
paid to the petitioner much beyond the statutory period of
30 days from the date of retirement from service.
04.
According to the petitioner Section-4 of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 mandate that the gratuity
shall be payable to an employee on the termination of his
employment after he has rendered continuous service for
not less than 5 years- (a) on his superannuation, or (b) on
his retirement or resignation or (c) on his death or
disablement due to accident or disease. Section 4(2) also
provides as to how the amount of gratuity payable to the
employee is to be determined. Section 4(3) stipulates that
amount of gratuity payable to the employee shall not
exceed the ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/-. According to the
petitioner the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 was amended
by the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010. The
said amendment came into force w.e.f. the date on which
the notification regarding the amendment was published in
the Gazette of India, Extraordinary Issue, Part-II, Section-3,
Sub-Section
(ii)
dated
24.05.2010.
In
view
of
the
amendment of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is Sub
Section (3) of the Section 4, the word Rs.3,50,000/- was
substituted by the word Rs.10,00,000/- thereby raising the
ceiling limit of Rs.3,50,000/- to Rs.10,00,000/-. In view of
such amendment which raised the ceiling limit of gratuity,
the petitioner became entitled to determination of gratuity
keeping in view the ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/-.
05.
According to the petitioner
retirement
the
last
basic
pay
of
at
the
the time of
petitioner
was
Rs.23,930/- and his DA was Rs.17,708/-. As such, he was
entitled to 8,64,790/- as gratuity. The petitioner submitted
one representation dated 20.08.2021 to the Executive
Engineer, Resource Division, Panchmukh, Agartala raising to
pay gratuity in view of the ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/with effect from 24.05.2010. But most arbitrarily his
gratuity was calculated and paid to him and as a result, full
and final payment of gratuity was not caused to the
petitioner. Further according to the petitioner the rest
amount of gratuity should be paid to the petitioner keeping
in view of the ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/- which came
into effect from 24.05.2010. He was entitled to interest @
9% per annum. So finding no way the petitioner approached
the
Hon’ble
High
Court
by
filing
a
case
bearing
No.WP(C)112/2022. This High Court vide judgment dated
06.09.2022 dismissed the said writ petition. After that the
petitioner preferred an appeal bearing No.W.A.210 of 2022
against
the
judgment
dated
06.09.2022
passed
in
WP(C)112 of 2022. The Division Bench of this High Court
vide judgment and order dated 27.02.2024 disposed of the
writ appeal No.W.A. 210 of 2022 by giving liberty to the
petitioner to submit representation to the respondents with
all relevant documents and the Hon’ble High Court also
directed the respondents to dispose of the matter within a
period of four months. The petitioner made detailed
representation dated 29.04.2024 to the Principal Secretary,
Welfare of Schedule Caste and the Director, Directorate of
Welfare of Schedule Caste. It was further submitted that
other similarly situated persons have been visited with a
rejection orders issued by the Competent Authority rejecting
the claim of the petitioner. The respondents did not take
into consideration the ceiling limit of gratuity payable to the
State Govt. employees as revised/enhanced by the State
Government from time to time to bring parity in between
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and Rule 9 of TSCS
(Revised Pension) Rules.
06.
The Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura issued
one notification on 05.05.2009 and the said notification was
in respect to the provision regulating pension and other
pensionary benefits. By the said notification TSCS (Revised
Pension) Rules, 2009 was notified and the said Rules so far
as payment of gratuity is concerned, provides as under:
Length of Service
Less than 1 year
1 year or more but less
than 5 year
5 year or more but less
than 20 years
20 years or more
Rate of Gratuity
2 times of emoluments
6 times of emoluments
12 times of emoluments
½ (half) of every
Completed 6 monthly period of qualifying
service subject to a maximum 30 times of
emoluments.
The term revised emoluments for the purpose of
calculation of DCRG shall mean the last pay, i.e., the pay in
the pay band plus the grade pay of the employees
concerned on the date of retirement.
07.
The petitioner further submitted that the Rules,
2009 is in derogation of the letter and spirit of the Payment
of Gratuity Act, 1972 wherein the Act 1972, vide Section 4
(2) clearly provides that for every completed year of service
or part of thereof in excess of 6 months the employer shall
pay gratuity to an employee @ 15 days wage based on the
date of wages last drawn by the employee concerned, any
Rule
cannot
override
and
supplant
the
clear
and
unambiguous mandate of Section 4(2) of the Act and
moreso, the said Rules has also supplanted the provisions of
Section 4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 by fixing
the ceiling limit which is below the ceiling limit laid down by
the Section 4(3) of the Act. In determining the amount of
gratuity payable to the petitioner, in view of the provision of
Rule 8 of Tripura State Civil Service Revised (Pension)
Rules, 2009, it is provided that qualifying service of 33
years shall be taken into account for determining gratuity,
the total length of service of the petitioner was not taken
into consideration and it was against the mandate of Section
4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
08.
The petitioner further submitted that one Tarun
Kr. Sinha filed a Writ Petition bearing No.WP(C)No.204 of
2020. In the said writ petition the petitioner contended that
on retirement from service he ought to have been paid
gratuity taking into consideration the enhanced ceiling limit
of gratuity i.e. Rs.20,00,000/- which was introduced by the
amendment of Section 4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972 w.e.f. 29.03.2018. But his gratuity was paid in terms
of Rule 9 of Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pension)
Rules, 2017 on the basis of ceiling limit of Rs.10,00,000/provided by Rule 9 of Tripura State Civil Service (Revised
Pension) Rules, 2017. According to the petitioner by the
order dated 27.01.2021, Hon’ble the High Court disposed of
the
Writ
Petition
judgment/order
this
No.204/2020
High
Court
and
in
the
said
held
that
the
State
Government shall revisit Rule 9 of the Tripura State Civil
Services (Revised Pension) Rules, 2017 and to take proper
decision enhancing maximum limit of gratuity as has been
done by the Central Govt. by notification dated 29.03.2018
and this High Court also expected that parity in payment of
gratuity be maintained as has been earlier maintained by
the State Govt. in terms of Section 4(3) of the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 and until such exercise is done the
petitioner shall be paid gratuity for the time being on the
basis of maximum limit of Rs.10,00,000/-.
09.
The Learned Single Judge at the time of disposal
of the said case relied upon the judgment dated 13.02.2020
passed
in
connection
with
WP(C)No.1054/2019
(Sri
Bhupati Debnath vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.),
judgment/order dated 20.02.2020 passed in connection
with WP(C)1209/2019 (Lal Zakim Rokhum vs. Tripura
Road Transport Corporation and Ors.) and the judgment
and order dated 13.02.2020 passed in connection with
WP(C)1057 of 2019 (Smt. Mamata Singha Roy vs. State
of Tripura and Another) and it was also observed that the
revised ceiling limit of gratuity effected by the Payment of
Gratuity
Act
would
apply
to
all
the
establishment
irrespective of whether they are controlled or governed by
the State or Central Govt. as the appropriate Governing
body. Finally the petitioner took the plea that the petitioner
has been deprived of the actual entitlement of gratuity by
invoking arbitrary ceiling limit of gratuity of Rs.4,00,000/and he is entitled to a total gratuity of Rs.8,64,790/- as per
the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 with
interest @ 9% per annum. It was further submitted that as
per notification dated 08.04.1997 issued by the Joint
Secretary, Government of Tripura, Finance Department the
petitioner is also entitled to the statutory interest in case of
delay. Hence, the petitioner has filed the writ petition.
10.
The state-respondents have contested the case
by filing the counter-affidavit. In para No.10 the staterespondents have mentioned the following facts:
“10. That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph
3 to 21 of the writ petition it is stated that, the Petitioner
was offered to join in the post of Lower Division Clerk
under Public Works Department, Government of Tripura
on temporary basis for a period of 03 (three) months on a
monthly pay of Rs.240/- in the pay scale of Rs.240-8320-440/- (E.B. after 8th & 15th stage) plus othr
allowances as may be admissible from time to time and
other terms & conditions as laid down in Order
No.F.6(170)/S/4394-4495, dated 06.07.1979 of the
Superintending Engineer, Co-ordination, Second Circle,
Agartala (Annexure 1 to the Writ Petition).
Accordingly, the petitioner accepted the offer of
appointment for the post of Lower Division Clerk &
intimated the same to the appointing authority i.e.
Superintending Engineer, Co-ordination, Second Circle,
Agartala vide his letter dated 07.07.1979 (Annexure-2 to
the Writ petition). Subsequently, he had joined the post
of
Lower
Division
Clerk
on
11.07.1979
(Forenoon)(Annexure 2 to the Writ petition).
Now after 36 years months of Service rendered in the
Public Works Department, Government of Tripura Shri
Biswanath Dey, the petitioner got retired from
Government Service on superannuation on 29.02.2016 in
the capacity of Upper Division Clerk from office of the
Executive Engineer, Resource Division, Panchamukh,
Agartala & released from Government Service in the
afternoon
of
29.02.2016
vide
Office
Order
No.F.EE/RESO/DN/P(C)/148/3414-21, dated 29.02.2016
of the Executive Engineer, Resource Division, Panchmukh.
Accordingly, the pensionary benefit like Death cum
Retirement Gratuity etc. was sanctioned by the Executive
Engineer, Resource Division, Panchmukh vide Office
Order No.151, dated 04.03.2016 i.e. within 30 days from
the date of retirement of Shri Dey.
It is pertinent to be mentioned here that, when Shri
Biswanath Dey, UDC, the petitioner was retired from
Government Service on superannuation on 29.02.2016 at
that time Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pension)
Rules, 2009 was in force. The said Rule was published by
the Finance Department, Government of Tripura vide
Notification No.F.8(3)-FIN(G)/09, dated 05.05.2009
(Annexure-6 to the Writ petition). And, the said Tripura
State Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 was
applicable to him to compute leave salary, Death cum
retirement gratuity, Commutation of pension etc. In the
instant case the Petitioner didn’t ignore that at the time
of his retirement from Government Service Tripura State
Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 was in force
and his pension & pensionary benefits was guided by this
Rules.
Further, as per Rule 8 of the Tripura State Civil Service
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 Death Cum Retirement
Gratuity is described as “The existing ceiling limit of
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity is enhanced from Rs.2.00
lakhs to 4.00 lakhs for employees proceeded on
superannuation/retirement with effect from 01.01.2009.
The other conditions of the existing formula
computation of DCRG amount will remain unchanged.
of
In case of death in harness the following table shall
continue to be followed:Length of Service
Less than one year
1 year or more but less
than 5 years
5 years or more but less
than 20 years
20 years or more
Rate of gratuity
2 times of emoluments
6 times of emoluments
12 times of emoluments
½ (half) of emoluments for
every completed 6 (six)
monthly period of qualifying
service
subject
to
a
maximum of 33 times of
emoluments
The term revised emoluments for the purpose of
calculation of DCRG shall mean the last pay i.e the
pay the pay band plus the grade pay of the
employees
concerned
on
the
date
of
retirement/death.
A Detailed method of calculation of D-C-R-G as per
Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules,
2009 is furnished in Illustration No.V as stated as
stated herein below:
"An employee has retired from service on
31.1.2009 w revised basic pay Rs. 7370/- (stage of
pay Rs. 6110) the Pay Band-1 (Rs. 4530-13000/-)
plus Grade Pay 1200 on the date of retirement. He
entered in the serve on 11.3.1980. The pension &
DCRG of the employ concerned shall be reckoned
as under:
Date of entry in the Service :11.3.1980
Date of retirement : 31.1.2009
Qualifying service: 28 years 10 months 24 days =
58smp
Last Basic pay (revised): Rs. 7370/Pension :Rs. 3685/- (50% of last pay)
DCRG: 7370 X 58 = Rs. 1,06,865/- "
In the instant case, the Last Basic pay of Shri
Biswanath Dey, Ex UDC, the petitioner as on
29/02/2016 was Rs.23,930/- (in the Pay Band: 2,
Pay Band Scale: Rs.5700-24000/-, Grade pay:
4200). And, he had joined in Government Service
as on 11/07/1979. His qualifying Service is 36
Years 07 Months 19 days i.e., 66 SMP (maximum).
Therefore, as per Rule 8 of Tripura State Civil
Service (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 Death Cum
Retirement
Gratuity
amount
comes
to
=
(23930x66)+4 Rs.3,94,845/-.
Accordingly, pensionary benefit like Death cum
Retirement Gratuity etc. of the petitioner was
computed & as well as sanctioned by the Executive
Engineer, Resource Division, Panchamukh vide
letter No.F.RESO/DN/P(C)/148/3534-42, dated
04/03/2016 i.e., within 30 days from the date of
retirement of the petitioner. And, a sum of
Rs.2,96,135/- (3/4th of Gratuity amount) less
Rs.1000/- being checking of IPS i.e. amounting to
Rs.2,95,135/- as a provisional gratuity was paid to
the Petitioner vide Bill No.16, dated 05/04/2016
i.e. within 30 days from the date of retirement of
the petitioner.
And, the rest amount (Rs.3,94,845.00 Rs.99,710/Rs.2,95,135.00) was paid to the Petitioner on
19/08/2016 by the office of the Accountant
General (A&E), Tripura, Agartala (Annexure 4 to
the Writ Petition).
Further in para No.13-15 the State-respondents
have averred that:
13. That, in regard to the statements made in
paragraph 30 to 36 of the writ petition it is stated
that, the Petitioner had join to the Government
Service to post of Lower Division Clerk under
Public Works Department, Government of Tripura
as per terms and conditions laid down to his offer
of appointment issued by Superintending Engineer,
Co-ordination, Second Circle, Agartala vide his
Order
No.F.6(170)/S/4394-4495,
dated
06/07/1979 (Annexure 1 to the Writ petition).In
the above mentioned offer of appointment at Point
No. 2(IV) of Terms of appointment it was clearly
mentioned that "Other condition of service will be
governed by the relevant rules and orders in force
from time to time". Accordingly petitioner accepted
the offer of appointment for the post of Lower
Division Clerk & intimated the same to the
appointing authority i.e. Superintending Engineer,
Co-ordination, Second Circle, Agartala vide his
letter dated 07/07/1979 (Annexure 2 to the Writ
petition). Subsequently he had joined in the post of
Lower Division Clerk on 11/07/1979 (Forenoon)
(Annexure -2 to the Writ petition). In this case the
petitioner had joined in to Government Service in
Public Works Department, Government of Tripura.
Hence, from the common observation it can be said
that Rules and Regulations as adopted or revised
time to time by the Government of Tripura for its
employee is also applicable to him.
Further, Finance Department, Government of
Tripura
vide
Notification
No.F.1(3)FIN(G)/77,dated 08/08/1978 has adopted the
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 which
shall be applicable to the Government Servants
including the petitioner in connection with the
affairs of the Government of the Tripura State
subject to certain modification.
as Further, as per CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
adopted in the state of Tripura the Pension & other
pensionary benefits like Death cum Retirement
Gratuity etc. is rationally guided by Rule 2 read
with Rule 45, Rule 50, Rule 54 & Rule 55 etc. of the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. In the instant case like
other State Government employees, the Petitioner
also comes under the purview of above rule 2, Rule
45 & Rule 50 and is rationally applicable to him as
because Government of Tripura has adopted the
aforesaid CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 for its
employees on 08/08/1978 i.e., prior to joining of
the petitioner in Public Works Department under
Government of Tripura.
In the instant case petitioner's pension & other
pensionary benefit shall also be governed by the
Rules and Regulation as adopted by the
Government of Tripura in the light of Central Civil
Services Pension Rules, 1972 & as well as Tripura
State Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009
(Annexure- 10 to the Writ Petition).
Further,
eligibility
to
Death-Cum-RetirementGratuity and family pension is governed by Rule
45of CCS Pension Rules, 1972 is describe as
follows:"(1) A Government servant who has opted
for clause (b) of Rule 42 shall be eligible for
the
death-cum-retirement
gratuity
as
admissible under rule 50 and family pension
as admissible under rule 54 or rule 55.
(2) The pension as admissible under rule 44
shall be reduced by the pension equivalent
of such gratuity to be calculated in
accordance with the table prescribed by the
Governor
under
the
Civil
Pensions
(Commutation) Rules, applicable to the
Government
servant
at
the
time
of
retirement".
Further, Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is described
as "An Act to provide for a scheme for the payment
of gratuity to employees engaged in factories,
mines,
oilfields,
plantations,
ports,
railway
companies, shops or other establishments and for
matters
connected
therewith
or
incidental
thereto".
Further, as per Sub- Section (3) (a) of Section-1 of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, it is clearly
stated that "it shall apply to every factory, mine
oilfield, plantation, port and railway company".
Further, as per Sub- Section (3) & Sub- Section (4)
of Section-2 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972,
it is clearly stated that " in any establishment,
factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway,
company,shop, to do any skilled, semi skilled or un
skilled, manual, supervisory, technical or clerical
work, whether the terms of such employment are
expressed or implied. and whether or not such
person
is
employed
in
a
managerial
or
administrative capacity but does not include any
such person who holds a post under the Central
Government or a State Government and is
governed by any other Act or by any rules
providing for payment of gratuity".
In the instant case, the Petitioner is a regular
employee of the State Government worked in
Public Works Department under Government of
Tripura. Even Public Works Department (R&B)
Government of Tripura is not an under taking
company or public sector Unit under the
Government of Tripura, rather it is a pensionable
Department under the State Government.
Hence entire Rules Regulations & norms of
calculation of Gratuity as governed by Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 as well as amended by the
Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010 shall
not be applicable in case of the Petitioner.
14. That, in regard to the statements made in
paragraph 37 to 39 of the writ petition it is stated
that, the petitioner had joined in Government
Service on 11/07/1979 under Public Works
Department, Government of Tripura & got retired
from Government Service in the capacity of UDC on
superannuation on 29/02/2016 i.e. prior to
publication of Tripura State Civil Service (Revised
Pension) Rules, 2017 which came into force on
01/04/2017.
And, as per Rule 9 of Tripura State Civil Service
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2017 Death Cum
Retirement Gratuity is described as "The existing
ceiling limit of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity
shall stand enhanced from R. 4.00 lakhs to 10.00
lakhs for employees proceeded on superannuation
/retirement on or after 01.04.2017. The other
conditions of the existing formula of computation
of DCRG amount will remain unchanged".
But, in the instant case, the Petitioner had retired
from Government Service prior to effective date
i.e., 01/04/2017. Hence, the petitioner is not
entitled to get the Death Cum Retirement Gratuity,
keeping in view the existing ceiling limit of
Rs.10,00,000/- of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity.
Moreover the Petitioner had also claimed that he is
entitled to get Death Cum Retirement Gratuity
keeping in viewthe Ceiling Limit of Rs. 10,00,000/as per Section 3 of Sub Section (II) of the Payment
of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010 which came
into effect on 24/05/2010.
The Petitioner was a regular State Government
employee worked in Public Works Department
under Government of Tripura and the Public Works
Department (R&B) Government of Tripura is not an
under taking company or public sector Unit under
State Government of Tripura rather it is a
pensionable
Department
under
the
state
Government. Hence, the entire Rules Regulations &
norms of calculation of Gratuity as governed by
Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010 shall
not be applicable for determination of Death Cum
Retirement Gratuity in case of the Petitioner.
In the instant case when the petitioner was retired
from Government Service on superannuation on
29/02/2016 at that time Tripura State Civil Service
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 was in force. The
said
Rule
was
published
by
the
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Tripura
vide
Notification
No.F.8(3)-FIN(G)/09,
dated
05/05/2009(Annexure- 10 to the Writ Petition).
And, the said Tripura State Civil Service (Revised
Pension) Rules, 2009 was applicable to him to
compute leave salary, Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity, commutation of pension etc. Accordingly
Death cum retirement gratuity was Computed
followed by the manner as prescribed in Rule 8 of
Tripura State Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules,
2009 (Annexure- 10 to the Writ Petition).
Now, as per Rule 8 of Tripura State Civil Service
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 (Annexure- 10 to
the Writ Petition) Death Cum Retirement Gratuity
is described as "The existing ceiling limit of Deathcum-Retirement Gratuity is enhanced from Rs.
2.00 lakhs to 4.00 lakhs for employees proceeded
on superannuation/retirement with effect from
1.1.2009. The other conditions of the existing
formula of computation of DCRG amount will
remain unchanged". Accordingly, the pensionary
benefit like Death cum Retirement Gratuity etc. in
respect of the petitioner was sanctioned by the
Executive
Engineer,
Resource
Division,
Panchamukh
vide
letter
No.F.RESO/DN/P(C)/148/3534-42,
dated
04/03/2016 i.e. within 30 days from the date of
retirement of Shri Dey.
And,
a sum
of
Rs.2,96,135/-(3/4th of Gratuity amount) less
Rs.1000/- being checking of IPS i.e. amounting to
Rs.2,95,135/- as a provisional gratuity was paid to
the Petitioner vide Bill No.16, dated 05/04/2016
i.e. within 30 days from the date of retirement of
Shri Dey.
Further, from the Notification No.F.8(13) Fin (G)86
dated 08/04/1997 of the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura (Annexure 16 to the Writ
Petition) it is apparent that in case of nonpayment
of Gratuity beyond 3 months after the gratuity
becomes due and up to 1 year 7% per annum
interest rate may be imposed. But, such claim of
the petitioner doesn't hold good because a sum of
provisional gratuity amounting to Rs.2,95,135/was paid to the Petitioner vide Bill No.16, dated
05/04/2016 i.e. within 30 days from the date of
retirement of the petitioner & rest amount
Rs.99,710/- ( Rs.3,94,845.00 Rs.2,95,135.00) was
paid to the Petitioner on 19/08/2016 (Annexure-4
to the Writ Petition) by the office of the Accountant
General (A&E), Tripura, Agartala within 3 months
from the date of receipt of the letter.
Further, the Petitioner was a State Government
employee worked under a pensionable department
like Public Works Department.
But, in case of WP(C) No.1091/2021 filed by one
Shri Samir Kumar Ghosh was an employee of
Agartala
Municipal
Corporation
and
WP(C)
No.1054/2019 was filed by one Shri Bhupati
Debnath who was an employee of Tripura
Handloom
and
Handicrafts
Development
Corporation
Limited,
similarly
WP(C)
No.1057/2019 was filed by one Smt.Mamata
Singha Roy was an employee of Fish Farmer
Development Agency.
From the above reading, it is crystal clear that, the
above mentioned petitioners were not the regular
employees under the State Government Office of
Government of Tripura directly & due to which they
do not come under the purview of Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 as adopted in the
state of Tripura on 18/09/1978 i.e. date of Gazette
notification. Hence, in those cases concept of
computation of Death Cum Retirement Gratuity
may not be followed.
But, in this case the petitioner is a regular
employee appointed substantively to Civil Services
and posts in connection with the affairs of the
State of Tripura which are borne on pensionable
establishment i.e., Public Works Department,
Government of Tripura & he cannot deny to accept
the Rules & regulation as adopted by the State
Government from time to time. Therefore, in the
case of the petitioner Death cum retirement
gratuity was computed as per Rule 8 of Tripura
State Civil Service (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009
(Annexure- 10 to the Writ Petition) which was in
force at the time of retirement from Government
Service & is found to be justified.
Therefore, from the comparative study it is crystal
clear that, case of the petitioner is not squarely
fitted to the above mentioned petitioners & for this
reason entire Rules Regulations & norms of
calculation of Gratuity as governed by Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 as well as amended by the
Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010 shall
not be applicable in case of the Petitioner.
Further, it is to be mentioned that as per the
averment made by the petitioner, he joined a post
which has been created under Public Works
Department and he also served the Public Works
Department till his retirement. Since he is an
employee who served a post under the State
Government Department (not a PSU) so he is
covered by the CCS (Pension) Rules as adopted in
the State of Tripura read with TSCS (Revised
Pension) Rules, as in force at the time of his
retirement. He cannot claim benefit beyond the
prescribed Pension Rules so as to suit his needs.
Further, the Payment of Gratuity Act is applicable
to ports, railways, oilfields, shops etc. The Public
Works Department, Government of Tripura does
not come under the ambit of those establishments.
Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled to gratuity
as per Payment of Gratuity Act. Neither the
formula prescribed in the gratuity Act for
calculation for gratuity can be extended to the
petitioner in contravention of settled Rules.
Further that, as per averment of the petitioner, he
retired in the year 2016 and he is drawing pension
as per the TSCS (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009.
Therefore, it is clear that he is not drawing pension
under EPF Act. Since it is clear that he is not under
the ambit of EPF Act, therefore, it established that
the petitioner do not come in the ambit of Payment
of Gratuity Act. As a result of these factors, the
petitioner has been allowed with DCRG as per Rule
45 of adopted Pension Rules read with relevant
clause of TSCS (Revised Pension) Rules.
Now in the year 2016, TSCS (Revised Pension)
Rules 2009 was in force. Since the petitioner
retired in 2016 so he should be guided by TSCS
(Revised Pension) Rules 2009. Under TSCS
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2009 there is no
provision of adding up Dearness Allowance to Basic
Pay for determining the gratuity amount. Also the
TSCS (Revised Pension) Rules prescribe Rs. 4.00
lakhs as the higher limit of gratuity. So, the
petitioner has been paid the gratuity amount of Rs.
3,94,845/- keeping conformity with the adopted
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 by the State of Tripura
read with TSCS (Revised Pension) Rules, 2009.
Further, that at the time of retirement of the
petitioner during 2016, the Revised Pension Rules
2017 was not in force because it came into force
only w.e.f. 01.04.2017. Though under Revised
Pension Rules 2017 the gratuity limit was revised
to Rs. 10.00 lakhs but the same cannot be
extended to the petitioner as because he retired on
2016 which is much before the implementation of
Revised Pension Rules 2017. Therefore, the benefit
of gratuity as determined by the Department in
favour of the petitioner holds good as per the
Revised Pension Rules 2009 which was effective
during the time of his retirement.
It is not a correct proposition of the petitioner to
fit the formula of gratuity calculation as prescribed
under Payment of Gratuity Act in the framework of
the TSCS (Revised Pension) Rules as because the
genesis of these two Rules as well as their
applicability is substantially separate.
Further, the cases cited by the petitioner like Samir
Ghosh[in WP(C) 1091 of 2021], Bhupati Debnath
[in WP(C) 1054 of 2019], Lal Zakhim Rokhum [in
WP(C) 1209 of 2019], Mamta Singha Roy [in
WP(C) 1057 of 2019] etc., involve persons who
were serving under PSUs (like TRTC, AMC etc.).
PSUs may not be treated at par with Government
Department like Public Works Department.
Further, that in the case of Sri Tarun Kumar Sinha,
the State Government had preferred an appeal
before the High Court of Tripura and, the Hon'ble
Division Bench of the High Court of Tripura vide
interim Order dated 12/04/2022 passed in IA 01
of 2022 in connection with Writ Appeal WA 61 of
2022 has stayed the Judgment & Order dated
27/01/2021 delivered in WP(C) 204 of 2020 by the
Ld. Single Judge in which the concerned petitioner
was directed to be allowed payment of gratuity @
Rs. 20.00 lakhs as per the Payment of Gratuity Act.
Further, in the case of Sri Tarun Kumar Sinha, the
State Government had also preferred a Civil Appeal
Nos. 9198-9199 of 2018 before the Supreme Court
of India. And, the matter is pending before the
Apex Court for hearing.
Hence, in the light of the aforesaid circumstances,
there is no cause of action on the part of the
petitioner to claim gratuity in terms of the
Payment of Gratuity Act.
15. That, in regard paragraph 40 to 43 to the
statements made in of the writ petition, it is stated
that, the instant Writ Petition has no merit and
same is liable to be dismissed in limine for the
reasons mentioned in the foregoing paragraphs.”
11.
The respondents No.6 and 7 also have submitted
separate counter-affidavit. In para No.8-12 to the counteraffidavit the said respondents No.6 and 7 in have made the
following assertions:
“8. That, with respect to Paragraphs No.8 to 15, I say
that the authority of Gratuity subject to ceiling limit of
Rs.4,00,000 as per ROP’2009 of Notification vide
No.F.8(3)-FIN(G)/09, dated 05.05.2009 was issued by
the Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, and the
Answering Respondents have calculated taking into
account the Basic pay only for the purpose of calculation
of the Gratuity as per rules as per ROP’s Notification,
Amendment etc. issued by the Finance Department, Govt.
of Tripura from time to time.
9. That, with respect to Paragraphs No.16 and 17, I say
that the Gratuity has to calculated i.e. Rs.29,970x66/4=
Rs.4,94,505/- subject to maximum Rs.4,00,000/- as per
rules of Notification, Amendment etc. issued by the
Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura under ROP’2009
and for which the ceiling limit of Gratuity was
Rs.4,00,000/-.
10. That, with respect to Paragraph No.18, I say that the
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura, Agartala vide common
Judgment and Order dated 06.09.2022 in WP(C) 106 of
2022, WP(C)109 of 2022, WP(C)111 of 2022, WP(C)112
of 2022, WP(C)113 of 2022, WP(C) 114 of 2022,
WP(C)115 of 2022 and WP(C)116 of 2022, opined that
the writ petitions merit no consideration and accordingly
dismissed the demand of final payment of Gratuity of the
petitioner.
11. That, with respect to Paragraphs No.19 to 20, I say
that the ceiling limit of Gratuity Rs.10,00,000/- is
admissible for those who have retired/died on or after
01.04.2017 as per ROP’2017, but the petitioner was
retired from his service on 30.04.2015 under ROP’2009
and for which the ceiling limit of Gratuity was
Rs.4,00,000/-.
12. That, with respect to Paragraph No.21, I say that as
per Notification issued by the Finance Department vide
No.F.8(13)/Fin(G)/86,
dated
08.04.1997
hereby
mentioned that interest on gratuity shall be payable @
7% per annum for period from beyond 3 months upto
one year.”
Finally the respondents by their counter-affidavit
prayed for dismissal of this writ petition with the plea that
this present writ petition is not maintainable.
12.
The crux question to be decided in this writ
petition as to whether the state government employees are
entitled to get the benefit of the ceiling limit as prescribed
under the Payment of Gratuity Act in respect of payment of
gratuity
on
their
retirement.
Admittedly
the
present
petitioner is a retired government employee. He retired
from service on superannuation on 29.02.2016 and this
present writ petition is the 3rd round litigation because
earlier this present petitioner filed another writ petition
before this High Court bearing No.WP(C)112 of 2022 which
was dismissed by judgment dated 06.09.2022 and after that
the present petitioner preferred appeal which was also
disposed of with a direction when the respondents to
consider the representation of the petitioner within a period
of four months and after that the petitioner submitted
representation on 29.04.2024 to the respective authority
but as the same was not considered so again the present
petitioner has been compelled to file the present writ
petition.
13.
When the present petitioner was retired from
service that time Tripura Civil Services Revised Pension
Rules, 2009 (in short Pension Rules, 2009) was in existence.
The petitioner was in the post of UDC and definitely it was
under the control of State Government. In course of hearing
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner should be entitled to get the
amount of gratuity to Rs.10,00,000/- which was made in
pursuance of the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act,
2010 under sub-Section 3 of Section-4. Learned Senior
Counsel further submitted that previously Learned Single
Judge of this court in connection with WP(C) No.204 of 2020
directed the State Government to revisit the Rule-9 of ROP
Rules, 2017 with further direction to the state government
to bring parity in determining the gratuity at par with the
ceiling limit, prescribed under the Payment of Gratuity Act.
14.
On the other hand, Learned Advocate General
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty assisted by Ms. P. Chakraborty,
Learned Counsel along with Mr. P. Gautam, Learned Sr.
G.A.
appearing
on
behalf
of
the
state-respondents
submitted that the case of the petitioner is not covered by
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 as the petitioner is not
covered as an ‘employee’ as per the definition of ‘employee’
as mentioned in the Payment of Gratuity Act. As such the
present petitioner is not entitled to get the ceiling limit of
Rs.10,00,000/- as made by the Payment of Gratuity
(Amendment) Act, 2010 in sub-section 3 of Section-4. Now
for the sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein
below the definition of employees as mentioned in Section
2(e) of the Payment of Gratuity Act which reads as under:
“2[(e) "employee" means any person (other than an
apprentice) who is employed for wages, whether the
terms of such employment are express or implied, in any
kind of work, manual or otherwise, in or in connection
with the work of a factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port,
railway company, shop or other establishment to which
this Act applied, but does not include any such person
who holds a post under the Central Government or a
State Government and is governed by any other Act or by
any rules providing for payment of gratuity;]”
15.
the
On perusal of the said definition it is clear that
law
makers
excluded
the
employees
of
state
government as well as the central government from the
applicability of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 in case
their payment of gratuity is regulated or governed by the
separate Act or Rules. Here in the State of Tripura and since
the petitioner was a state government employee and there
is no such evidence on record that the state government
has adopted the relevant provision of the Payment of
Gratuity Act. As such, it appears that the status of the
present
petitioner
as
an
‘employee’
of
the
State
Government is separated from the definition of ‘employees’
like factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway company
or shop or other establishment in respect of payment of
gratuity.
16.
In course of hearing of argument it was fairly
submitted that the petitioner was paid gratuity as per the
Pension Rules of 2009 by which he was governed and during
the service tenure the petitioner was governed by the
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised) Pension Rules, 2009
(in short Pension Rules, 2009) which makes specific
provision to regulate payment of gratuity to the employees
of the state government and Rule-8 of the Pension Rules
prescribes ceiling limit of 4,00,000/- for the employees
proceeded for superannuation/retirement w.e.f. 01.01.2009.
As already stated the petitioner was retired from service on
superannuation on
29.02.2016. Now for the sake of
convenience, I would like to mention here the relevant
provision of Rule-8 of the Tripura State Civil Service Revised
(Pension) Rules, 2009 which reads as follows:
“8.DEATH-CUM-RETIREMENT GRATUITY:
The existing ceiling limit of Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity is enhanced from Rs.2.00 lakhs to 4.00
lakhs
for
employees
proceeded
on
superannuation/retirement
with
effect
from
01.01.2009. The other conditions of the existing
formula of computation of DCRG amount will
remain unchanged.
In case of death in harness the following table
shall continue to be followedLength of Service
Less than 1 year
1 year or more but less
than 5 year
5 year or more but less
than 20 years
20 years or more
17.
Rate of Gratuity
2 times of emoluments
6 times of emoluments
12 times of emoluments
½ (half) of every
Completed 6 monthly period of qualifying
service subject to a maximum 30 times of
emoluments.
Since there is no evidence on record that the
State of Tripura has adopted the Payment of Gratuity
(Amendment) Act, 2010 specifically the provision of subsection-3 of Section 4 as such the petitioner being an
employee of the state government would be entitled to get
the benefit of gratuity as per Pension Rules, 2009 as the
petitioner retired from service while the said pension rules
was in force.
18.
The state-respondents already in their counter-
affidavit stated that the petitioner was given amount
Rs.3,94,845/- considering the ceiling limit of Rs.4,00,000/as
gratuity
following
the
notification
of
the
Finance
Department dated 05.05.2009 and by the said notification
bearing
No.F.8(3)-FIN(G)/09
the
Finance
Department
revised the pension and other pensionary benefits of the
state government employees enhancing the ceiling limit of
death
cum
retirement
Rs.4,00,000/petitioner
was
and
at
retired
gratuity
that
from
material
from
Rs.2,00,000/-
to
period
when
the
service
on
government
superannuation on 29.02.2016 the said ceiling limit of
Death-Cum-Retirement-Gratuity was in force. So it appears
to this court that the state-respondents have not committed
any error in making payment of gratuity to the present
petitioner to the extent of ceiling limit of Rs.4,00,000/-.
Now we are to see the observation of the judgment made
by Learned Single Judge in connection with WP(C)204 of
2020 as advanced by Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy
Barman in course of argument that by the said judgment
the state-respondents were directed to consider the matter
of payment of gratuity bringing parity with the Central Act
in respect of determination of ceiling limit of gratuity. I have
also gone through the said judgment. For the sake of
convenience I would like to refer herein below the relevant
paragraphs of the judgment which runs as follows:
“9. Having appreciated the submissions of the
learned counsel appearing for the parties, an
apparent conflict between Rule-9 of the Tripura
State Civil Services (Revised Pension) Rules, 2017
and Section-4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act
has emerged. Since, the Central Government has
enhanced the maximum limit of gratuity to
Rs.20,00,000/- by the notification as stated above
and it is noticed that in the past the state has
followed the maximum limit for payment of
gratuity coterminus to what had been determined
by the Central Government, there is a pressing
necessity to revisit the said provision. In view of
the definition of “employee” as provided in
Payment of Gratuity Act and for separation of
power [6] between the Central Government and
the
State
Government
in
respect
of
the
employment and other related areas regarding the
state government employees, no doubt that the
state government has the authority to determine
the pay and allowances and other benefits of the
state government employees. But Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 being a piece of central
legislation has its own sway. Therefore, the state
government is not expected to take a contrary
stand, even though, the notification determining
the maximum limit of the payment of gratuity Act
has been issued by the Central Government
pursuant to the power conferred by Sub-Section-3
of Section-4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
10. A former notification for amendment by the
state government would dispel the confusion that
is reigning for the time being. In defining
„employee‟, it has been provided that the central
government and the state government employees
have been excluded from the definition of
employee for purpose of the Payment of Gratuity
Act, 1972 if their payment of gratuity is regulated
by the separate Act or the Rules. Those employees
who are working under the central government or
the state government would stand excluded from
the definition of employee [see Section-2(1) of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972], in the event if
their payment of gratuity is governed by any other
Act or by any Rules providing for payment of
gratuity. In the present case, the state government
employees are governed by Tripura State Civil
Services (Revised Pension) Rules, 2017. As such,
the petitioner may not be treated as „employee‟
for general purpose of applying the provisions of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.”
19.
On perusal of the said judgment of the Learned
Single Judge i.e. another Coordinate Bench of this High
Court it appears that by said judgment Learned Single
Judge did not issue any direction to the state-respondents
to amend the Rule-9 of the Tripura State Civil Services
(Revised Pension) Rules, 2017 rather asked the Govt. to
revisit the Rule-9 to bring parity. Until and unless the said
rule is amended or there is any specific amendment in the
Payment of Gratuity Act specifically the definition of Section
2(e) i.e. ‘employees’ it appears that it would be difficult on
the part of the state-respondents to consider the claim of
the present petitioner. From the Act of 1972 it is clear that
the said act was enacted to provide payment of gratuity to
the
employees
plantation,
engaged
port,
railway
in
factories,
companies,
mines,
shop
or
oilfield,
other
establishment and for the matters connected therewith and
incidental there to.
20.
After going through the Payment of Gratuity Act
it appears that in Section 1(3) of the said Act it was
mentioned the name of the ‘organization’ where the act
would apply. Further Section 2(a) defines ‘appropriate
government’, Section 2(d) defines ‘controlling authority’,
Section
2(f)
defined
‘employer’,
Section
2(g)
defines
‘factory’, Section 2(i) defines ‘major port’, Section 2(j)
defines ‘mine’, Section 2(k) defines ‘notification’, Section
2(l) defines ‘oilfield’, Section 2 (m) defines ‘plantation’,
Section 2 (n) defines ‘port’ and Section 2(p) defines ‘railway
company’. From the definition of the aforesaid provisions it
is crystal clear the legislature at the time of making of laws
clearly intended to apply and extended the benefit of to the
employees of the aforesaid organization only including the
employees of the establishment belonging to or under the
control of central government or the state government but
excluded the person who holds post under the central
government or the state government and are governed by
other act or by any rules providing for payment of gratuity
have not been brought within the ambit of Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972.
21.
Further, for determining the maximum ceiling
limit of gratuity to an employee it is entirely rests upon the
policy matter of the Government and until and unless the
rule is amended by the state or any amendment is made in
the original Central Act at the instance of the State
Government the maximum limit of gratuity of amounting to
Rs.10,00,000/- as per Payment of Gratuity(Amendment)
Act, 2010 cannot be directed to be given to the petitioner by
the State-respondents. So the matter requires decision of
the State Government. There is no dispute on record that
the present petitioner is governed by Rule-8 of the Pension
Rules of 2009 as an employee of the state government in
respect of payment of gratuity.
22.
Situated thus, at this juncture invoking the
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
this court does not find any scope to direct the State
Government to make any policy decision in this regard. But
it is open for the state government to consider the matter if
the government so desires. In the light of the discussions
made above, the present writ petition bears no merit and
accordingly the same stands dismissed. No order is passed
as to costs. However, the present petitioner may approach
to the State department to consider his grievance if he is so
advised. Further it is clarified that if interest or anything
remains pending in that case the petitioner shall be at
liberty to claim for interest in view of the notification of vide
No.F.8(13)Fin(G)/86
dated
08.04.1997
of
the
Finance
Department to the appropriate authority and in that case
the respective authority shall consider the matter of interest
if it is found that the petitioner is actually entitled to get the
same.
With this observation, this writ petition stands
disposed of.
Pending applications, if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.04.07
23:47:36 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review