Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 183 of 2022
Sri Biman Behari Goswami
S/o Lt. Bana Behari Goswami,
Resident of Dreamz Exotica, Flat No.1A8,
VIP Road, Agartala Tripura West
PO: Kunjaban, PIN: 799006
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary Higher Education Department,
PO: Secretariat, West Tripura, PIN: 799010, Agartala, Tripura
2. The Director of Higher Education,
Government of Tripura, PO: Agartala, PIN: 799001.
---Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and date of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. C. S. Sinha, Adv.
: Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA.
: 23.05.2023.
: Yes.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (Oral)
The present writ petition is filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India for the following reliefs:
a) Admit this petition
b) Call for records.
c) Issue writ in the nature of Mandamus calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why the fixation of pension of petitioner should not
be done in the revised pay scale under the 7th Central Pay Commission
for short 7th CPC effected from 01.01.2016.
d) Issue writ in the nature of mandamus calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why the fixation of pay of petitioner should not be
done in the revised pay scale under the 7th Central Pay Commission
for short 7th CPC effected from 01.01.2016.
e) Issue writ in the nature of certiorari calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why the order dated 01.09.2021 should not be
declared bad in law and quashed.
f) Issue writ in the nature of certiorari calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why the notification dated 25.06.2019 should not be
declared bad in law for having no whispering about the fixation of pay
in the revised pay scale of 7th CPC and giving scope of arbitrary
exercise of power denying appropriate pension in the revised pay
scale of 7th CPC.
g) Pass any other relief(s) which this court deem fit and proper in this
case.
[2]
It is the case of the petitioner that he is a retired Associate Professor
in Economics. He retired from service on 01.07.2017. The 7th CPC came into effect
from 01.01.2016. But on the pretext that he has retired from service prior to
01.10.2017, neither did he get pension nor did he get benefit of revised pay under
the 7th CPC. It is also evident from the records that the petitioner had earlier
approached this court by way of filing a writ petition being WP(C)323 of 2020
urging the court to consider his case of pay revision and consequentially provide
all monetary benefits. During the pendency of the said writ petition, the petitioner
made a representation on 07.01.2020 to the respondents and the same was
rejected by the respondents on 01.09.2021. The Hon’ble Court was pleased to
dispose of the said writ petition being WP(C) 323 of 2020 by the order dated
02.03.2021 directing the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner and
communicate the said decision to the petitioner. And in the event if the
respondents do not comply that order, the petitioner will be at liberty to approach
this court. The respondents by the order dated 01.09.2021 has considered the case
of the petitioner and rejected the same. The respondents by the order dated
01.09.2021 has passed the following speaking order:
“Whereas, in the instant case, neither the State Government has
created two different groups of pensioners nor has the petitioner been
subjected to differential treatments. The petitioner got his pension
from the same date as that of other in-service faculties or other
retired faculties. Therefore, there is no question of any deprivation on
the part of the petitioner in framing scheme by the education (Higher)
Department, giving it a time of implementation from 01.10.2017.
Now, therefore, giving the above and after careful examination of the
matter, it appears that there is no sufficient ground in the claim of the
petitioner to implement the date of UGC Scheme retrospectively from
01.01.2016. Hence the claim of the petitioner cannot be accepted.”
[3]
Thus aggrieved by the same, the petitioner has filed the present writ
petition.
[4]
Mr. Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has contended
that the scheme adopted by the state of Tripura vide Notification No.F.1(499)DHE/Estt./(G)/2017/728 dated 25.06.2019 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition) is
arbitrary and discriminatory and the same needs to be set aside
on the ground
that the notification dated 25.06.2019 is inconsistent in comparison to the scheme
as framed by the University Grants Commission (UGC), Government of India vide
communication dated 02.11.2017 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition).
Mr. Sinha,
learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that the scheme of the UGC
came into effect on 01.01.2016 and the petitioner herein retired on 01.07.2017.
Therefore, according to Mr. Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner
herein is entitled for the benefits with retrospective effect from 01.01.2016.
[5]
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the respondents
filed a counter affidavit and contended that the state-respondents has not acted in
arbitrary manner. No discrimination has been made to the petitioner neither did
any inconsistency has been noticed in the scheme adopted by the State of Tripura
vide notification dated 25.06.2019 in pursuance to the said scheme adopted by
UGC which came into effect on 01.01.2016. According to him, no discrimination has
also been made in implementing the scheme of revision of pay scales (7th CPC) vide
letter dated 31.03.2022. The state of Tripura is following the scheme of UGC as
communicated vide letter dated 02.11.2017 by bringing certain modifications as
which is permissible by the main scheme came into effect on 01.10.2017 and thus
the petitioner is not entitled to claim any relief and also the benefit cannot be
extended retrospectively and prayed to dismiss the writ petition.
[6]
Heard both sides.
[7]
It becomes relevant to incorporate the relevant portion of the scheme
vide letter dated 02.11.2017 which reads as under:
No.1-7/2015-U.II(1)
Government of India
Ministry of Human Resource Development
Department of Higher Education
New Delhi, dated the 2nd November, 2017
To
The Secretary,
University Grants Commission
Bahadurshah Zafar Marg,
New Delhi – 110002.
Subject:- Scheme of revision of pay of teachers and equivalent cadres in
universities and colleges following the revision of pay scales of Central
Government employees on the recommendations of the 7th Central Pay
Commission (CPC)
Sir,
I am directed to say that the Government of India have decided, after
taking into consideration the recommendations made by the Pay Review
Committee (PRC), constituted by the University Grants Commission (UGC),
and decision of the UGC taken at the meeting of the Commission held on 22nd
February, 2017, to revise the pay scales of teachers in the Higher Educational
Institutions under the purview of the UGC. The revision of pay scales of
teachers and equivalent academic staff shall be subject to various provisions
of the Scheme of revision of pay scales as contained in this letter and
Regulations issued by UGC and amendments thereof from time to time in this
behalf. The revised pay scales and other provisions of the Scheme are as
under:
1.……
2……
3……
4…..
5……
6……
“7. Date of Implementation :The date of implementation of the above revised
pay shall be 1st January, 2016.
8……
9…..
10…….
11……..
12…….
13…….
14…….
15…….
16. Applicability of the Scheme:
(i) ……
(ii)…..
(iii)…….
(iv) This scheme may be extended to universities, Colleges and other higher
educational institutions coming under the purview of State legislatures
provided state governments wish to adopt and implement the scheme
subject to the following terms and condition:
(a)…..
(b)…..
(c)……
(d)……
(e)……
(f)…..
(g)State governments, taking into consideration other local conditions, may
also decide in their discretion, to introduce pay higher than those mentioned
in this scheme, and shall give effect to the revised bands/scales of pay from
01.01.2016; however, in such cases, the details of modifications proposed
shall be furnished to the Central Government and Central assistance shall be
restricted to the Pay as approved by the Central Government and not to any
higher pay fixed by the State Government(s).
(h) Payment of Central assistance for implementing this Scheme is also
subject to the condition that the entire Scheme of revision of pay scales,
together with all the conditions to be laid down by the UGC by way of
Regulations and other guidelines shall be implemented by State Governments
and Universities and Colleges coming under their jurisdiction as a composite
scheme without any modification except in regard to the date of
implementation and pay scales mentioned herein above.
17. Date of implementation of revised pay and allowance and payment of
arrears.
(i) The revised pay and revised rates of Dearness Allowances under this
Scheme shall be effective from 01.01.2016.
18……
19……
20 This issues with the concurrence of Internal Finance Division vide Dy.
No3738/IFD dated 2nd November, 2017.
Yours faithfully
(Dr. K.K. Tripathy)
Director
02/11/2017
[8]
In pursuance of the above scheme, State of Tripura has issued its
scheme vide notification dated 25.06.2019 and the relevant portion is extracted
herein under:
Government of Tripura
Education (Higher) Department
No.F.1(499)-DHE/Estt(G)/2017
Dated 25th June, 2019
NOTIFICATION
Subject: - Revision of pay scales of teachers in the State Universities,
General Degree, Colleges and institute of Advance studies in
Education, College of Teacher Education (CTE), Government Music
College, Government Law College under the University Grants
Commission on the recommendation of 7th Central Pay Commission
(CPC).
The government of India, Ministry of Human Resource
Development, Department of Higher Education vide their letter No.17/2015-U.II(1) dated 2nd November, 2017 has communicated the new
scheme of revision of pay scales of Central Government employees on
the recommendations of the 7th Central Pay Commission (CPC) to the
University Grants Commission (UGC) with a copy to all the State
Governments. In the said letter it has been indicated that the revision
of pay scales of teachers and equivalent academic staff shall be
subject to various provisions of the scheme of revision of pay scales
as contained in the letter and Regulations issued by UGC and
amendments thereof from time to time in this behalf.
After careful consideration of the matter in order to attract
and retain talent in teaching profession, the Government of Tripura
has decided to introduce this scheme of revised pay structure as
recommended by the Government of India for the teachers in all State
Universities, General Degree College, Institute of Advance studies in
Education, College of Teacher Education (CTE), Government Music
College, Government Law College of the State with few modifications.
This scheme shall be applicable to teachers who were/are recruited in
the regular scale of pay through prescribed recruitment process.
The revised pay structure and other provisions of the scheme
adopted are as under:
“1……
2……
3……
4…...
“5. Date of effect: The date of implementation of the revision of pay
shall be 1st October, 2017.”
6……
7……
8…..
9……
10. Applicability of the scheme
(a) ……
(b) …..
(c)…..
(d)….
(e)….
(f) Financial assistance from the Central Government shall be
restricted to revision of pay scaled in respect of only those posts
which were in existence and had been filled up as on 01.10.2017.
(g) Payment of Central assistance for implementing this scheme is
also subject to the condition that the entire Scheme of revision of pay
scales, together with all the conditions to be laid down by the UGC by
way of Regulations and other guidelines shall be implemented by
State Governments and Universities and Colleges coming under the
jurisdiction as a composite scheme without any modification except in
regard to the date of implementation any pay scales mentioned herein
above.
11…..
12…..
13….
14…….
15….
16…..
17. The Accountant General of Tripura is being informed.
(Saumya Gupta)
Secretary
To the Government of Tripura
25/06/2019
[9]
The relevant portion of the letter dated 31.03.2022
is extracted
herein under:
F.No.1-11/2019-U.II
Government of India
Ministry of Education
Department of Higher Education
University-II Section
New Delhi, dated 31st March, 2022
To,
The Principal Accounts Officer,
Department of Higher Education,
Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi
Subject: - Reimbursement of central share for implementation of the
scheme of revision of pay scales (7th CPC) of university and college
teachers of the Govt. of Tripura
Sir,
I am directed to say that the Government of India had revised
pay of teachers and other equivalent cadres in university and college
based on the recommendations of the 7th Central Pay Commission (7th
CPC). vide this Department’s letter No.1-7/2015-U.II(1) dated 2nd
November, 2017 and 8th November, 2017. The Central Government
had decided to provide financial assistance to State Governments
opting to revise pay scales of teachers and other equivalent cadre, as
per above said letters of this Department, by way of reimbursement,
to the extent of 50% (fifty percent) of the additional expenditure
involved in the implementation of the pay revision, for the
universities, colleges and other higher educational institutions funded
by the State Government, for the period from 01.01.2016 to
31.03.2019, subject to fulfillment of prescribed terms and conditions.
The guidelines for reimbursement of financial burden due to
implementation of revised pay scales on the basis of 7th Pay
Commission recommendations for teachers and equivalent cadres in
Universities and Colleges from 01.01.2016 had been forwarded to all
State Governments, vide letter No.1-1/2018-U.II dated 26th July,
2018 and 11th September, 2018, for information and necessary action.
2……
3.…….
4. The grant will be further subject to the following terms and
conditions:
(a)…..
(b)…..
(C)…..
(d)….
(e)……
(f)……
(g)…..
(h) payment of central assistance for implementing this scheme is
also subject to the condition that the entire scheme of revision of pay
scales, together with all the conditions to be laid down by the UGC by
way of Regulations and other guidelines shall be implemented by
State Governments and Universities and Colleges coming under their
jurisdiction as a composite scheme without any modification except in
regard to the date of implementation and pay scales mentioned herein
above.”
5……
6…..
7……..
8…….
9…..
10. Principal Accounts Office is requested to issue necessary Advice to
Reserve Bank of India, Central Accounts Section, Nagpur immediately
for crediting the above amount to Tripura Govt’s account, under
intimation to the undersigned.\
Yours faithfully
(Ghanshyam)
Under Secretary to the Govt. of India”
[10]
During the course of the argument on the point of arbitrariness, Mr.
Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has contended that the action of
the State of Tripura in implementing its scheme w.e.f. 01.10.2017 instead of
01.01.2016 as adopted by UGC is arbitrary, contrary and inconsistent to the main
scheme of the UGC. He further contended that the benefit which has been
extended to the other employees in pursuance to the scheme adopted by the state
of Tripura vide notification dated 25.06.2019 has not been extended to the
petitioner herein and as such it is in violation of natural justice and discriminatory.
[11]
This court is not inclined to appreciate the argument on the point of
arbitrariness since the scheme as adopted by UGC categorically indicates that it
“may be” extended and not “shall be” extended to the universities, colleges and
other higher educational institutions coming under the purview of state legislatures.
If the option had been given to the state for exercising its discretion, it cannot be
said that the state shall implement the scheme in toto. For the reasons mentioned
in the scheme, the state government has indicated its compliance of the scheme
and the commencement of its date i.e. 01.10.2017.
[12]
The argument as advanced by Mr. Sinha, learned counsel for the
petitioner regarding the discrimination faced by the employees of the state of Tamil
Nadu and West Bengal, this court is not inclined to consider the argument on the
point of discrimination faced by the employees in the other states. It is evident
from the records that the Government of India has categorically mentioned in its
scheme adopted by UGC on 01.01.2016 that the option to implement the scheme
of UGC in each state depends on its administration. Therefore, this court feels that
no arbitrariness is made out and the petitioner has failed to make out his case
regarding discrimination.
[13]
In view of the above discussion, this court has no hesitation to hold
that the petitioner has failed to make out his case. Therefore, for the reasons as
stated above, this writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review