Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.233/2022
1. Sri Bikash Chandra Das, son of Sri Gopendra Chandra Das, resident of
village North Padmabil, P.O.-Padmabil, P.S.-Panisagar, Dharmanagar, DistrictNorth Tripura, aged about 55 years.
2. Sri Shyamal Malakar, son of Sri Jogendra Malakar, resident of villagePecharthal, P.O.-Pecharthal, P.S.-Kanchanpur, District-North Tripura, aged
about 41 years.
3. Sri Sujit Das, son of Sri Akhsoy Kr. Das, resident of village-Samatal
Padmabil, P.O.-Samatal Padmabil, P.S.-Khowai, District-West Tripura, aged
about-49 years.
4. Sri Pradip Kumar Sarkar, Son of Sri Sachindra Kumar Sarkar, resident of
village-Taxapara, P.O.-Taxapara, P.S.-Melaghar, District-Sepahijala, aged
about 54 years.
5. Sri Subrata Jamatia, son of Sri Kripa Sindhu Jamatia, resident of villageAtharabola, P.O.-Manikya, P.S.-Radhakishorepur, District-Gomati Tripura,
aged about 41 years.
6. Sri Prakash Debbarma, son of Sri Prafulla Debbarma, resident of villageNaliabari, P.O.-Champahour, P.S.-Khowai, District-Khowai, aged about 43
years.
7. Sri Nikhil Chandra Das, son of Sri Chitta Ranjan Das, resident of villageRatanpur, P.O.-Ratanpur, P.S.-Belonia, District-South Tripura, aged about 55
years.
8. Sri Swapan Mohan Tripura, son of Jarmasingh Tripura, resident of villageHaria Mani Roaja Para (Natin Manu), P.O.-Chawmanu, P.S.-Longtharai
Valley, District-Dhalai, aged about-39 years.
9. Sri Jayanta Tripura, son of Sri Thapan Tripura, resident of village-West
Patichari, P.O.-P.P. Colony, P.S.-Radhakishorepur, District-Gomati Tripura,
aged about 45 years.
10. Sri Dilip Debbarma, son of Sri Jogesh Chandra Debbarma, resident of
village-Chirakuti, P.O.-Kirtan Tali, P.S.-Kailasahar, District-North Tripura,
aged about 44 years.
11. Sri Mithan Das, son of Sri Hari Bandhu Das, resident of village-Kobra
Khamar, P.O.-Durganagar, P.S.-Ranir Bazar, District-West Tripura, aged about
43 years.
12. Sri Jyotish Debbarma, son of Sri Debendra Debbarma, resident of villageRabia Sardar Para, P.O.-Noabari, P.S.-Jirania, District-West Tripura, aged
about 42 years.
13. Sri Mithun Das, son of Sri Matilal Das, resident of village-Nabadiganta
Last near Dr. B.R Ambedkar High School, P.S.-East Agartala, District-West
Tripura, aged about 39 years.
14. Sri Palash Chakma, Son of Sri Rupendra Chakma, resident of villagePecharthal, P.O.-Pecharthal, P.S.-Kanchanpur, District-North Tripura, aged
about 47 years.
15. Sri Thakurdhan Kalai, son of Sri Darasan Kalai, resident of village-Taichan
Para, P.O.-Ampinmagar, P.S.-Amarpur, District-Gomati Tripura, aged about 42
years.
16. Sri Suman Das, son of Late Gopal Chandra Das, resident of Village-Ward
No.1, P.O.-Madhuban, P.S.-Dukli, District-West Tripura, aged about-45 years.
17. Sri Lari Mohan Tripura, son of Sri Prabin Kumar Tripura, resident of
village-Maira Satchand, P.O.-Satchand, District-South Tripura, aged about 48
years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary,
Department of Forest, Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, Department of Forest, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New
Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
3. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & HOFF, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New
Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
4. Sri Sekhar Lodh, Son of Late Pramode Chandra Lodh, resident of villageKhilpara P.O.-Khilpara, P.S.-Radha Kishorepur, District-Gomati Tripura.
5. Sri Amiya Sutradhar, son of Sri Akhil Sutradhar, resident of village-Jalbazar,
P.O.-Jalbazar, P.S.-Pani Sagar, District-North Tripura.
6. Sri Shibu Lodh, son of Sri Bhusan Chandra Lodh, resident of villageDolbari, P.O.-Dolbari, P.S.-Sabroom, District-South Tripura.
7. Sri Jhumur Chanda, son of Sri Nripendra Chanda, resident of villageChandipur, P.O.-Chandipur, P.S.-Kailasahar, District-Unakoti Tripura.
8. Sri Hemanta Debnath, son of Sri Ram Chandra Debnath, resident of villageSantipur, P.O.-Santipur, P.S.-Pecharthal, District-Unakoti Tripura.
9. Sri Nibash Deb, son of Sri Nripendra Deb. resident of village-Ompinagar,
P.O.-Ompinagar, P.S.-Amarpur, District-Gomati Tripura.
10. Sri Sukanta Sarkar, Son of Sri Kumode Sarkar, resident of villageBaikhora, P.O.-Baikhora, P.S.-Belonia, District-South Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mrs. Riya Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 09th August, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mrs.
Riya Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, and Mr.
Debalay Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate assisted by Mr.
Soumyadeep Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
The petitioners have been working on the post of Forester and
belong to Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) category. They are
aggrieved by the promotion order dated 01.01.2022 (Annexure-3 to the writ
petition) whereby ad-hoc promotions have been granted to certain persons who
are junior to them as per a seniority list dated 08.03.2016 annexed by them
(Annexure-1 to the writ petition). Earlier during course of the proceedings,
taking note of the cryptic nature of the counter affidavit without enclosing any
of the documents referred to therein, by order dated 23.06.2023 the Staterespondents were allowed to file a comprehensive counter affidavit. The same
has been filed thereafter with copy to the other side. No rejoinder thereto has
been filed. The State-respondents in their second counter affidavit have dealt
with the specific contention of the petitioners in the following manner:
"6.
That, with respect to paragraph-2.1, I say that, it is
revealed that every petitioner concern have claimed seniority serial
number arbitrarily, since the last seniority list of Forester was published
vide Memorandum No.F.2(190)/For/Estt-2012/39333-70 dated
08.03.2016.
A copy of seniority list of Forester is annexed
hereto and Marked as Annexure-R/2.
But the petitioners enclosed an unauthenticated seniority
list along with the Memo. dated 08.03.2016 (Annexure-1). As per the
original seniority list, which is placed at Annex-B, it is seen that the
seniority of Sri Bikash Ch. Das is 93 whereas, the seniority list
provided by the petitioners, it is seen that his seniority is 41. Thus, there
is doubt about the authenticity/ genuineness of the seniority list that was
provided by the petitioners. Moreover, the fact that the seniority list
submitted vide petitioner is forged one.
7.
That, with respect to paragraphs-2.2, 2.2.1 to 2.2.vi, &
2.3, 3, 3.1, 3.3, I say that, question does not arise since the Office Order
No.F.2(22)/Estt./For-2021/ADPC/FR/35378-497 dated 01.01.2022 was
in connection with the Promotion Policy, 2021.
8.
That, with respect to paragraph-2.4, I say that, on receipt
of their representations, the same was processed in a file and send to
G.A.(P&T) Department with a request to scrutinize the cases of
promotion to the post of Forest Ranger under the light of 'Promotion
Policy,21'. Notified vide No.F.2(24)-GA(P&T)/2021 dated 22.06.2021
of G.A.(P&T) Department, Government of Tripura and offer their
views for doing the needful in respect of representations. Related
portion of views of G.A.(P&T) Department is re-produced below:
"The matter has carefully examined in the GA(P&T)
Department.
The Administrative Department is advised that if any candidate
does not deprived of promotion in between two exercises i.e., para-6 &
7 of the Promotion Policy, 2021 dated, 22.06.2021, in that case their
case will not come.---"
A copy of the Note sheet is enclosed herewith and
Marked as Annexure-R/3.
Further it is to mention that, there were a total of 34 nos.
of post vacant for promotion from Forester to Forest Ranger where, for
UR there were 18 posts, for ST-11, SC-5. As per rule 7 of promotion
policy 2021, the exercise was conducted where 3 nos. SC category
candidate were in the zone of consideration as per seniority & merit and
therefore 3 nos. Supernumerary post were created as 8 nos. of SC
candidates were also considered for promotion. The last SC candidate
considered for promotion was Sri Dhruba Das (Seniority-92). Since Sri
Bikash Das was at seniority 93, he could not be considered for
promotion even after creation of supernumerary post (3 nos). Thus, he
is not eligible for promotion as per rule 6 & 7 of ad-hoc promotion
policy.
Copy of promotion policy as well as DPC minutes
is annexed hereto and Marked as Annexure-R/4 &
R/5 respectively.
9.
That, with respect to paragraph-2.6, 3.4 to 3.5, I say
that, there is no comments about Rule 9(2) of the Tripura Scheduled
Castes & Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992. The Tripura
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules 1992 para
9(2) stated here that, the Selection Committee/ Selection
Board/Departmental Promotion Committee will consider the suitability
of the candidates, the details of whom are furnished by the appointing
authority and recommend a combined list of all categories of candidates
found suitable for promotion in order of their merit which shall be the
determining factor about the inter seniority of the candidates after
promotion.
Provided that a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe
candidates who occupies on merit or seniority-cum-fitness etc. an
unreserved point of the 100 point roster in the combined list, shall not
be shown against any reserved point.
Provided further that at the time of recommending
candidates for promotion to any post, the names against unreserved
(Vacant post) shall first be recommended in order of their merit or
seniority or seniority-cum-fitness de, as the case may be and then the
names against reserved (vacant posts) shall be recommended.
The Office Order No.F.2(22)/Estt./For-2021/ ADPC/ FR/
35378-497 dated 01.01.2022 was issued in connection with the
Promotion Policy, 2021.
10.
That, with respect to paragraph-3.2, 4 to 6, I say that,
There is no comment about Clause 11 and 12 of the Schedule appended
to the Notification, dated 27/07/2021 regarding Recruitment Rules for
the post of Forest Ranger under the Forest Department, Government of
Tripura.
It may be added here that there is no post namely "Forest
Officer"."
3.
During course of submission, Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior
counsel appearing for the petitioners, has relied upon the seniority list annexed
by the respondents where the petitioners' positions are at Sl. Nos.93, 94, 96, 99,
100, 101, 102, 104 to 110, and 112 to 114. The seniority list contains the status
of individual incumbents, the date of birth, the date of first entry in
Government service, date of last promotion, date of appointment to the present
post and whether confirmed in service or not. As per the Column-4 containing
the status of individual incumbents of the cadre, all these petitioners belong to
the SC/ST category. As per the stand of the respondents, the seniority list
annexed by the petitioners is not correct. The promotional exercise was
undertaken by the DPC in terms of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 (hereinafter referred to as "the
Reservation Act, 1991) and the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Reservation Rules, 1992 (hereinafter referred to as "the Reservation Rules,
1992), specifically Rule 9(2) of the Reservation Rules, 1992 and also the
promotion policy dated 22.06.2021 against 34 nos. of posts with the following
breakup:
SC-05, ST-11 and UR-18 posts.
4.
According to the respondents, as per Rule 7 of Promotion Policy,
2021, the exercise was conducted where 3(three) number of SC category
candidates in the zone of consideration as per seniority and merit were there
and for them 3(three) nos. of supernumerary posts were created. As such, (5 +
3)=8 numbers of SC candidates were promoted. The last SC candidate
considered for promotion was Sri Dhruba Das (Seniority number-92). The first
petitioner herein Sri Bikash Das is at Sl. No.93 in the seniority list and,
therefore, could not be promoted even after creation of 3 (three) supernumerary
posts.
5.
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate assisted
by Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-State,
submits that the DPC minutes at pages-126 to 133 would show that eligible
candidates who had completed 5(five) years of service in the cadre of Forester
and had also passed the final examination at Forest Training Institute, Hatipara,
Gandhigram, Agartala were considered and promoted against the quota, i.e.
SC, ST or UR, of available vacant posts. It is the case of the respondents that
petitioners did not come into the zone of consideration as per the seniority list
against the available vacant posts of SC/ST category and as such, in this
promotional exercise they could not be promoted.
6.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners, has in rebuttal drawn the attention of this Court to Rule 9(2) of the
Reservation Rules, 1992 which is extracted hereunder:
"9. Recruitment by Promotion:
(2)
The
xxx
xxx
xxx
Selection
Committee/Selection
Board/
Departmental Promotion Committee will consider the
suitability of the candidates, the details of whom are furnished
by the appointing authority and recommend a combined list of
all categories of candidates found suitable for promotion in
order of their merit which shall be the determining factor
about the inter se seniority of the candidates after promotion.
Provided that a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe
candidate who occupies on merit or seniority or senioritycum-fitness etc. an unreserved point of the 100 –point roster
in the combined list, shall not be shown against any reserved
point.
Provided further that at the time of recommending
candidates for promotion to any post, the names against
unreserved vacant posts shall first be recommended in order
of their merit or seniority or seniority-cum-fitness etc., as the
case may be, and then the names against reserved vacant posts
shall be recommended."
According to him, the first proviso to Rule 9(2) mandates that an
SC or ST candidate who occupies on merit or seniority or seniority-cum-fitness
etc. an unreserved point of the 100 point roster in the combined list shall not be
shown against any reserved point. Taking a cue from this proviso, the attention
of the Court has been drawn to the seniority list annexed by the respondents
wherein, according to him, respondents who are of the UR category and at Sl.
Nos.116, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136 and 138, have been promoted ahead of the
petitioners. Since the petitioners occupy a position higher in the seniority list,
the available vacancies should have been filled up in order of seniority by these
petitioners in seriatim. Therefore, the order of promotion suffers from illegality
since the statutory rules could not have been superseded by the promotion
policy framed by the Executive vide notification dated 22.06.2021 in exercise
of the powers under Article 162 of the Constitution of India.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties, taken note of the relevant material facts and documents placed on the
record. The plea of the petitioners is based upon an interpretation of Rule 9(2)
of the Reservation Rules, 1992 and its proviso. A plain reading of the instant
rules along with the first proviso does give to an interpretation that in case a
Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate occupies an unreserved point on
the basis of his merit or seniority or seniority-cum-fitness in the 100 point
roster in the combined list, he shall not be shown against any reserved point.
As per the seniority list enclosed by the respondents and also relied upon by the
petitioners, none of the petitioners occupies an unreserved post as all of them
starting from Sl. No.93 till 114 have been occupying the posts reserved for SC
or ST category in the seniority list. If the contention advanced by the
petitioners is accepted, then in any such promotional exercise against vacant
post to the higher cadre, for example the Forest Ranger in Group-C, NonGazetted post in this case, the availability of breakup of vacancies for reserved
category, i.e. SC, ST and unreserved category would have no meaning as the
promotion would have to be given to the incumbents against all the vacant
posts irrespective of the reservation by following the seniority list alone. This
could lead to incongruous results.
8.
On a plain reading of the relevant rules with the promotion policy
of 2021, therefore, it does not appear that the policy of 2021 in any manner
supersedes the application of the statutory rules in this regard. In the facts of
the present case, promotion has been granted to SC and ST candidates against
the 5(five) and 11(eleven) available vacancies respectively in their quota and
3(three) supernumerary posts have been created as 3(three) SC category
candidates were in the zone of promotion as per their seniority and merit. The
last person promoted from the SC category is at Sl. No.92 whereas the first
petitioner who is the senior-most amongst the petitioners occupies the position
at Sl. No.93. As such, in the impugned promotional exercise, the petitioners
cannot allege any hostile discrimination or violation of the statutory rules and
the promotion policy of 2021.
9.
As such, this Court does not find any merit in the writ petition. It
is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
2023.08.11
PULAK BANIK Date:
12:12:20 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review