Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 129/2026
Sri Bidhan Chandra Saha, son of late Basudeb Saha, resident
of Town Indranagar, near Sanghati Sanga, Dhaleswar Road No.3,
P.O.
Dhaleswar-799007, P.S.
East
Agartala, District- West
Tripura.
….. PETITIONER
Versus
1.
The Agartala Municipal Corporation, represented by the
Commissioner,
having
its
office
at
City
Centre,
Paradise
Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001;
2.
The
Municipal
Corporation,
having
Commissioner,
his
office
at
Agartala
Municipal
Centre,
Paradise
City
Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001;
3.
The Assistant Municipal Commissioner, Central Zone,
Agartala Municipal Corporation, office of the Central Zone, City
Centre (1st Floor), Paradise Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799001;
---Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. J. Samed, Advocate
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate
26.02.2026
Yes
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (Oral)
1.
The brief facts of the case is that the petitioner is
occupying a shop premise at Ujjayanta Market, Agartala for
carrying
on
his
business
under
Touji
bearing
reference
No.21LNS0117 and License issued by the respondents. The
petitioner has also paid the upto date annual fees to the
respondents and there is no arrear, but to his surprise, the
respondents-Agartala Municipal Corporation (AMC, for short) has
taken a step for relocating the petitioner to an alternative
premise by demolishing the existing structure and construction.
It is the further case of the petitioner that earlier on the action of
the respondents regarding relocation of the shop premise of the
petitioner, the petitioner had approached this court by filing writ
petitions being WP(C) 919 of 2022, which was disposed of on
24.11.2023 and also WP(C) 250 of 2024, which was also
disposed of on 09.04.2024, in terms of the directions passed in
the Order dated 24.11.2023 in WP(C) 919 of 2022. In both the
cases,
the
respondents
representation
submitted
were
by
the
directed
to
petitioner
consider
with
a
the
further
direction upon the petitioner to comply and co-operate with the
respondent-AMC in terms of the procedural aspects. It is the
further case of the petitioner that the respondent No.3 by issuing
a notice dated 17.02.2026 directed the petitioner, including all
other shopkeepers having their business in the existing site i.e.
Ujjayanta Market, Agartala, to vacate the existing shop premise
and shift their business to the respective allotted place. By the
said notice, the respondents have summoned the petitioner for
personal hearing.
2.
Challenging the said impugned notice of eviction dated
17.02.2026, the petitioner has approached this court by means
of filing this writ petition, wherein the petitioner has sought for
the following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to
why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued, for directing
them, to transmit the records, lying with them, for rendering substantive and conscionable
justice to the petitioner, and for quashing/setting aside the impugned Notice dated
17.02.2026 (Annexure-13 supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to
why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued, for
mandating/directing them, to forthwith revoke/rescind the impugned Notice dated
17.02.2026 (Annexure-13 supra), to strictly comply with the Judgment & Order dated
24.11.2023 passed in WP(C) No.919 of 2022 (Annexure-8 supra);
(iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to
why a Writ of Prohibition and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued, for
restraining/prohibiting the respondents, from acting in any manner, in furtherance of the
impugned Notice dated 17.02.2026 (Annexure-13 supra), from initiating any eviction
proceedings, or removing structures without prior compliance of judicial directions;
(iv) In the ad interim, and thereafter, on hearing the parties, in the interim, an Order in
terms of relief (iii) supra;
(v) Call for the records appertaining to this petition;
(vi) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule Absolute in terms of (i) to (iii)
above;
(vii)Costs of and incidental to this writ proceeding;
Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court may deem (viii) fit and proper;”
3.
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. J. Samed, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-AMC.
4.
The contention of Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner is that the petitioner has been doing
his business at Ujjayanta market under valid Touji and License
issued by the respondents-AMC and he has paid the upto date
rent and tax for the said shop premise. Learned senior counsel
further argued that despite having valid touji and license, the
AMC has no authority for passing such eviction/relocation order.
Mr. Deb, has also argued that prior to passing of such direction,
no show-cause notice was issued upon the petitioner for
cancellation of his touji and also that in existence of the lease
deed, such order is vague in nature.
5.
Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-AMC, has submitted that period of lease deed has
expired and the same was not renewed. Mr. Bhaumik, learned
counsel has further submitted that despite receipt of the notice
dated 17.02.2026, the petitioner did not avail the opportunity of
being heard personally and also remained un-responded, though
the petitioner has received the said notice under his signature.
Learned counsel has also submitted that in exigency of public
convenience and infrastructure improvement, the notice issued
by the respondent No.3 directing the petitioner and other
shopkeepers of that market to vacate their existing shop and
shift to alternative space is just and appropriate, hence no
interference is required.
6.
This court has perused the record meticulously. Mr.
Deb, learned senior counsel has argued that the petitioner was
not afforded with any reasonable opportunity of being heard
personally. To controvert the submission of learned senior
counsel, learned counsel for the respondent-AMC, Mr. Bhaumik
has pointed out that the petitioner in terms of notice dated
20.05.2024
without
submitted his
availing
the
representation dated
opportunity
of
05.06.2024
personal
hearing.
Subsequently, the respondent No.3 by notice dated 20.11.2024
again directed the petitioner to remain present on 26.11.2024 at
3.00 pm and on 26.11.2024 the petitioner by his application
attended before the respondent no.3 for his personal hearing and
after conclusion, the respondent No.3 passed the Order dated
26.11.2024 allocating plot No.09, measuring 108 sq.ft. at
Jackson gate in favour of the petitioner to his satisfaction. From a
close scrutiny of all the correspondences, it is revealed that the
petitioner has availed the opportunity of personal hearing before
the respondent no.3 and on conclusion his grievance was
addressed
to
by
Order
dated
26.11.2024
passed
by
the
respondent No.3 herein. The notice dated 20.05.2024 directing
the petitioner to remain present on 07.06.2024 at 11.30 a.m. to
resolve the matter in terms of the directions passed by this court
in WP(C) 919 of 2022, is reproduced hereunder:
“OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER
AGARTALA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
CENTRAL ZONE,
No.F 13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/1723-24
Dated: 20/05/2024.
NOTICE
As per the direction of Higher Authority of AMC in reference to the Hon'ble High Court
Order No. WP(C)250 of 2024 by the representation of the petitioner, Sri Bidhan Ch. Saha versus
Agartala Municipal Corporation (Respondent(s) regarding to resolved in compliance of the
Judgment & Order, dated 24-11-2023, passed by the Hon'ble High Court in WPC No. 919 of
2022.
You are hereby directed to remain present on 07-06-2024 at 11.30 a.m. to resolved
the matter, before the Office of the Assistant Municipal Commissioner, Central Zone, AMC
along with necessary relevants documents if any, failing which steps will be taken as per
provisions of Tripura Municipal Act.
To
Sri Bidhan Ch. Saha,
Ujjayanta Market, near Jackson Gate,
Infront of MTB School for compliance.
Assistant Municipal Commissioner,
Central Zone,
Agartala Municipal Corporation.
Copy to,
1. The Hon'ble Mayor, AMC for kind information.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, AMC for kind information.
Assistant Municipal Commissioner,
Central Zone,
Agartala Municipal Corporation.”
6.a.
The representation dated 05.06.2024 submitted by
the petitioner is reproduced hereunder:
“To,
The Assistant Municipal Commissioner
Central Zone
Agartala Municipality Corporation
Tripura West
Agartala.
Reference: Notice No. F.13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/1722-24 dated 20-05-2024./
Sir,
Kindly refer to your above cited Notice dated 20-05-2024.
In reference to the above mentioned Notice, I, with due respect, am to state as well as
inform the following points for information of your kind honour:
That sir, I being a responsible citizen, am always ready to cooperate the Agartala
Municipality Corporation in every respects;
That sir, I being a senior citizen and poor person, have presently, been suffering from
mental depression and physical illness & weakness. I therefore, am in need of more some
times i.e. 3/4 weeks times so that I may be in a position to remain present before your kind
honour instead of the day dated 07-06-2024 (at 11-30 A.M.) as you directed vide your above
mentioned Notice dated 20-05-2024;
That sir, I being an unemployed poor person have been feeding myself and my family
members by way of earnings from my present running small business/shop situated on the
existing land of with valid permission of Touji and License issued by your kind for a long-long
years;
That sir, I, being a responsible citizen, have always been paying the rent in time and
even updated the payment (of rent) for the period from 01-04-2024 to 31-03-2025 vide the
Touji Payment Receipt No. 28809 dated 03-04-2024 copy of which is enclosed herewith for
your kind information and ready reference.
Further, I already, paid the Tax/Rent for the period of 2024-25 vide the Property Tax
Receipt 2024-25 (Property id AMCCZ23254) dated 03-04-2024 in compliance of your
instruction/direction vide the Bill No. AMCCCZ23254/2023-24/153279 dated 06-09-2023 issued
by your kind copy of which is also enclosed herewith, for your kind information and ready
reference;
That sir, I shall provide all the available necessary relevant documents to your kind at
the time of my presence before your kind honour;
That sir, I shall pray and hope that your honour would be kind enough to see my case
so that I may be in a position to pass my rest life without mental depression & financial
problem with running of my existing business:
I shall therefore, request to your kind hengur to allow me some more times i.e. 3/4
weeks so that I may present before your kind instead of the day dated 07-06-2024, in
consideration of my above stated circumstances and thus oblige me thereby.
Date, Agartala, 5th June'2024
Yours faithfully,
Enclo: As stated.
(Bidhan Ch. Saha)
S/o-Lt. Basudeb Saha
Near Jackson Gate
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001”
6.b.
After receipt of the representation dated 05.06.2024,
the respondent No.3 by notice dated 20.11.2024 again informed
the petitioner to take part in personal hearing, and the said
notice is reproduced hereunder:
“OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER
AGARTALA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
CENTRAL ZONE,
th
No.F 13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/648-650
Dated: 20 Nov’2024.
NOTICE
In persuance to the order Dated: 09-04-2024 of the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura,
Agartala in connection with the court case of WP(C) 250 of 2024 regarding the allotment of
Touji in favour of the petitioner Sri Bidhan Chandra Saha, in this regard an earlier notice with
vide no. F.13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/ 1722-24, Dated: 20th May'2024 has been already issued
and served upon the petitioner.
Whereas, in this regard the petitioner Sri Bidhan Chandra Saha did not appear in the
hearing, thereafter the case or allotment procedure in taking to resolve the compliance of the
Judgment & Order, Dated: 09-04-2024 passed by the Hon'ble High Court in WP(C) 250 of 2024
was not executed/completed.
Now therefore, as the case is remanded back to the AMC to re-enquire into the matter
above, Sri Bidhan Chandra Saha of Ujjyanta Market, near Jackson Gate, is hereby again
directed to appear before the undersigned in the office chamber (City Centre 1st floor) on 26-
11-2024 at 3:00 pm along with relevant documents failing to which ex-parte decision shall be
taken as per the law of Municipal Act..
To
Sri Bidhan Ch. Saha,
Ujjayanta Market, near Jackson Gate,
Infront of MTB School for compliance.
Assistant Municipal Commissioner,
Central Zone,
Agartala Municipal Corporation.”
6.c.
Subsequently, by an application dated 26.11.2024,
the petitioner took part in personal hearing, and the said
application is reproduced hereunder:
“To,
The Assistant Municipal Commissioner
Central Zone
Agartala Municipality Corporation
Tripura West
Agartala.
Subject: Attendance for Hearing.
Ref. No. F.13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/648-650, dated 20-11-2024
Sir,
In pursuance of the Notice vide No. F.13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/648-650. dated 20-112024 I would inform you that I have appeared before you on 26-11-2024 at 3.00 P.M.
Dated: 26/11/2024
Yours faithfully
Agartala
Sd/ Bidhan Ch. Saha
S/o-Lt. Basudeb Saha
Mobile:9862603426”
6.d.
No.3
On conclusion of personal hearing, the respondent
by
his
Order
dated
26.11.2024
allotted
plot
No.09
measuring 108 sq.ft. at Jackson subject to certain conditions.
The order dated 26.11.2024 is as under:
“OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT MUNICIPAL COMMISSIONER
AGARTALA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
CENTRAL ZONE,
No.F 13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/664
Dated: 26.11.2024.
ORDER SHEET
Case: Allotment of space at Southern side of Tulsibati School
Name of Applicant: Sri Bidhan Ch. Sahu, S/o. Lt. Basudeb Saha
Date of Hearing: 26-11-2024
Ref. No. F.13(C)/SC/CZ/AMC/2021/648-650, dated 20-11-2024
On this day, 26-11-2024 at 3.00 p.m. the matter relating to allotment of Touji at
Southern side of Tulsi bati School in favour of Sri Bidhan Ch. Saha, S/o. Lt. Basudeb Saha was
taken up for hearing before the undersigned.
It is placed on record that on previous occasions during the process of allotment of
Touji conducted through lottery system on 07-03-2024 Srl Saha remained absent cespite due in
imation. Consequently, the allotment process was completed through lottery and allotment of
plots were given to eleven (11) eligible parties.
Subsequently, Sri Saha approached the Hon'ble Court seeking appropriate relief in the
matter vide case No. WP(C) 250 of 2024.
During the course of hearing, the relevant records and documents were examined. It is
observed that the allotment of earlier notified had already been allotted to the aforesaid
eleven (11) parties through a duly conducted lottery process.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, and in view of the submissions
made during hearing, it is hereby ordered that Sri Bidhan Ch. Saha, S/o. Lt. Basudeb Saha be
allowed plot No. 09, measuring No. 108 sqft. at Jackson gate, subject to the following
conditions:
1) The allotment shall be provisional and subject to verification of all requisite documents and
compliance of formalities.
2) The allottee shall strictly adhere to the terms and conditions prescribed by the Agartala
Municipal Corporation.
3) No encroachment beyond the allotted area shall be permitted under any circumstances.
4) The allotment shall be liable to cancellation In case of any violation of conditions or
suppression of facts.
The matter stands disposed of accordingly.
Assistant Municipal Commissioner
Central Zone
Agartala Municipal”
6.e.
Hence,
from
the
above
correspondences,
the
petitioner has left with no scope to urge that he was not provided
with any opportunity of being heard personally since the said
correspondences clearly demonstrates that he has been noticed
by the respondent No.3, to hear him personally, and to that the
petitioner has appeared and was heard by the respondent-AMC
personally and thereafter by Order dated 26.11.2024, the
petitioner was allotted plot no.9 measuring 108 sq.ft. at Jackson
gate subject to his satisfaction. Thus, the direction passed by this
court in WP(C) 919 of 2022 was considered by the respondentsAMC, and after hearing the petitioner personally and after
allocating a plot of land by the respondent No.3, the proceeding
with regard to the Notice dated 17.02.2026 was initiated by the
respondent No.3. The entire fact was suppressed the petitioner in
all manner in the instant writ proceeding which proves that the
petitioner has approached this court with unclean hand.
6.f.
Considering the submission of learned counsel for the
respondent that opportunity was given to the petitioner and he
has attended the hearing and his signature is also available on
the proceeding sheet, when this court to this factual aspect,
inquired Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel, for the petitioner, he, in
all fairness submitted that his client i.e. the petitioner did not
apprise him on this aspect and expressed his grievance that his
client was not fair to him.
7.
There is no dispute with regard to issuance of touji,
license in favour of the petitioner and also the petitioner has paid
all the rent and taxes as upto date. However, from the Memo
dated 27.10.2022, it is seen that the respondent no.3 invited the
shop keepers of Jackson gate area to participate in the
distribution of space for construction of stall through lottery
meaning thereby the respondents-AMC was supposed to relocate
space to the petitioner and others for carrying on their business
on the land owned by AMC. Challenging the Memo dated
27.10.2022, the petitioner filed writ petition before this court
being WP(C)919 of 2022, and the said writ petition was disposed
of on 24.11.2023 with some directions to the respondents and
the petitioner. Subsequently, on 04.03.2024, the respondent No.
3 herein, issued another Memo inviting the petitioner and others
to participate in fresh lottery process for distribution of space
from the existing place to south side of MTB school. The
petitioner after receipt of such memo challenging the same filed
another writ petition being WP(C)250 of 2024 before this court
on the ground that he was not provided with reasonable
opportunity of being heard personally, and by order dated
09.04.2024, the said writ petition was disposed of in terms of the
directions passed in WP(C) 919 of 2022. Surprisingly, the
application dated 26.11.2024 and order dated 26.11.2024 clearly
reveals that the petitioner has availed the opportunity of personal
hearing before the respondents-AMC and after such hearing the
petitioner was re-allocated with plot no.9 measuring 108 sq.ft. at
Jackson gate subject to his satisfaction. Further, on perusal of
the affidavit filed with the writ petition, this court does not find
anywhere that the petitioner has disclosed the fact of his
appearance before the respondent-AMC and he has entirely
suppressed the said fact.
8.
From the Memo dated 27.10.2022 and 04.03.2024
alongwith other correspondences it can safely be presumed that
the respondents-AMC has taken all possible measures to provide
alternative space to the petitioner which by Order dated
26.11.2024 is clearly revealed, for doing his business in shop no.
9 measuring 108 sq.ft. at the location of Ujjayanta market.
Further, the land on which the petitioner is doing his business is
owned exclusively by AMC, and only upon issuance of Touji, the
petitioner is entitled to carry on his business since long.
Considering the project of Smart City Mission, the respondentsAMC has undertaken various development works including
widening of road for convenience of public in interest and for
such public convenience and development infrastructure the
steps taken by respondent-AMC remain undisputed. Further, this
court is of the view that the act and action of the petitioner is
serious in nature and manner in which he has suppressed the
fact before this court, is unfair since he has not approached this
court with clean hand
9.
Thus, it transpires that the petitioner has availed
alternative efficacious remedy in respect of his grievance raised
in the writ petition. Moreover, it also appears that the writ
petition earlier filed by the petitioner were disposed of with
direction upon the respondents to afford opportunity to the
petitioner of being heard personally which has been complied
with by the respondents to the satisfaction of the petitioner, and
the same would be well established from the correspondences, as
quoted here-in-above. However, it appears that the present
petitioner
has
not
disclosed the
material
fact
of availing
opportunity of personal hearing in the aforesaid writ petitions
filed before this Court. Moreover, I find substance in the
arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the respondentsAMC that the petitioner has not disclosed about appearance
before the respondents-AMC. It also appears that the petitioner
has suppressed the material facts and thereby made an attempt
to obtain an order of status quo from this court. Thus it appears
that he has also made an attempt to invoke the writ jurisdiction
by suppressing the material fact and therefore, in view of the
aforesaid position, the present writ petition deserves to be
dismissed. It is trite law that a writ petition is liable to be
dismissed for suppression of fact when a litigant fails to disclose
material information, acts dishonestly, or misleads the court,
violating the principle of "clean hands” which tentamounts to
abuse of the legal process.
9.
The discretion exercised by the Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is extraordinary, equitable and
discretionary. While exercising the extraordinary power, the
Court shall necessarily bear in mind the conduct of the parties.
Needless to say, the conduct of the petitioner herein is nothing
but playing fraud on the court as well on the other side by
suppressing material facts to gain undue advantage. Hence, in
the considered opinion of this Court, the petitioner, who has
approached this Court with unclean hands, by suppression all
material facts is not entitled to any relief from this Court.
10.
In view of the same, the instant writ petition is liable
to be dismissed, for the above reasons. Accordingly, the same
stands dismissed. As a sequel, the interlocutory application(s), if
any, also stands closed.
JUDGE
SAIKAT
KAR
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2026.02.27
15:27:07 -05'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review