The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. 11.2024. On the next date, the convict appellant was sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 05(five) years and to pay a fine of Rs. 20,000/- (twenty thousands) only and in default of payment, the convict appellant to suffer imprisonment for 02(two) months for commission of offence under Section 326 of the Indian Penal Code. Learned Court below also sentenced the convict appellant to suffer simple imprisonment for 01(one) year for commission of offence punishable under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code by the sentence dated 22.11.2024 and further ordered that both the sentences stated above shall run concurrently. [8] Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment & order dated 20.11.2024 and sentence of conviction dated 22.11.2024 in connection with case No. S.T. (Type-2) 09 of 2023, the appellant has preferred this present appeal seeking the following reliefs: “i) Admit this appeal ii) Call for the records iii) Issue notice upon the Respondent, iv) After hearing the parties be pleased enough to set aside the impugned Judgment of conviction and sentence dated 22/11/2024 passed by the Session Judge, Khowai Judicial District. Khowai in case No:- Sessions Trial (Type-2) 09 of 2023 and the convict Appellant may be set at liberty. In the mean time, the conviction and sentence as aforesaid may be stayed till disposal of this appeal……………..” [9] Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel for th…
03. 12.2022, one patient namely Rathindra Debbarma was brought to Khowai District Hospital by his relative and accordingly, he examined him. P.W. 5 deposed that on examination, he found the patient with one lacerated wound on the right frontal region, measuring 2 cm x 0.3 cm into muscle depth and probably caused by a blunt object. It is further deposed by P.W. 5 that in his opinion, the alleged injury of Rathindra Debbarma was simple in nature, where-after he was discharged from the hospital on that day. He (P.W. 5) stated to have prepared one injury report in this regard and identified the same as Exbt-1 along with his signatures over the same as Exbt-1/1 and Exbt-1/2. On the same day, P.W. 5 deposed that he examined another patient namely Pandit Debbarma, who was brought to the Hospital by his relative. He stated to have examined the patient and found one lacerated wound, measuring 5 cm x 0.3 cm into tissue depth over left cheek. The witness further deposed that the patient was admitted at Khowai hospital, thereafter, he was referred to AGMC and GBP hospital, Agartala. In his opinion, the injury was caused by a probable blunt object, which was simple in nature. P.W.5 also identified the report prepared by him in this regard and identified the same as Exbt-2 along with his signatures thereon as Exbt-2/1 and Exbt-2/2. During cross-examination, P.W.5 denied the fact that he has prep…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A(J) 17 of 2025
Sri Bhupendra Debbarma
……Appellant(s)
Versus
State of Tripura
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Partha Sarathi Roy, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & order
: 03.04.2025.
Whether fit for reporting
: No
__
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
Heard Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant. Also heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP appearing for the
State-respondent.
[2]
This present appeal is filed under Section 374 (2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure against the Conviction on trial held by
the learned Sessions Judge, Khowai Judicial District, Khowai in case
No. S.T (Type 2) 09 of 2023 convicting the appellant under Section
323/326 of I.P.C. By judgment and order dated 20.11.2024, the
appellant was sentenced on 22.11.2024 in the following manner:
(i) Under Section 326 of the Indian penal code to suffer
Rigorous imprisonment for 5(five) years with fine of Rs.20,000 only
and in default of payment of such fine, convict is liable to undergo
imprisonment for 2(two) more months.
(ii) Under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code to suffer
imprisonment for a term of 01(one) year.
It has been ordered by the learned trial Court that both the
sentences would run concurrently.
[3]
The prosecution story in brief is that on the basis of a
written ejahar, lodged by the informant Sri. Parendra Debbarma,
son of late Rabi Kumar Debbarma of Porshurambari, Champahour
PS,
District
subsequently,
Khowai,
FIR
was
after
filing
of
registered
the
by
the
charge-sheet,
police
the
and
accused
Bhupendra Debbarma, son of Sri. Naresh Debbarma, faced trial for
allegedly having committed the offences punishable under Sections
323/326/307 of the Indian Penal Code (in short, the IPC).
[4]
The informant, initially, lodged his written complaint
before Champahour PS, alleging that on 03.12.2022, at about 06:
00 PM, the informant along with other villagers were gossiping at
Thaichuk Tala Market (Amtalli) and at that time, one of his local
villagers namely, Bhupendra Debbarma (accused appellant herein)
came to the spot with an iron hammer in his hand and started
hitting people indiscriminately. As a result of such hitting, it is
alleged that 05 people in the market sustained severe head injuries,
where-after, the informant managed to snatch the hammer away
from the accused, but as he tried to detain him, the accused pushed
him and fled towards the nearby jungle. It was further stated that
subsequently, other people present at the spot, shifted the victims
to Khowai District Hospital, wherefrom, one of the injured persons
Rathindra Debbarma received medical aid and 04 others were
referred to GBP Hospital, Agartala, for better treatment. The
informant further revealed the names of the victims to be (i) Mangal
Debbarma, (ii) Pankaj
Debbarma, (iii) Jalim Debbarma, (iv)
Rathindra Debbarma & (v) Pandit Debbarma.
[5]
registered
On receipt of the charge-sheet, a case was then
by
the
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate,
Khowai,
vide
No.PRC(WP)12 of 2023 and after taking cognizance, made over the
same to the Court of learned J.M. 1st Class, Khowai, for disposal
according to the law. Later, on 10.05.2023, learened J.M. 1st Class,
Khowai, committed the case for trial in the Sessions Court and it
was made over to the then Court of Asst. Sessions Judge, Khowai,
Tripura. Learned Court of the Sessions Judge, Khowai, Tripura
received the Case record on 15.07.2024 from the then Court of
learned Asstt. Sessions Judge, Khowai and proceeded accordingly.
[6]
facie
Upon hearing both the sides and considering the primacase,
charge
against
the
accused
under
Sections-
323/326/307 of the IPC was framed against the accused. At the
time of hearing about the matter and the contents of the same, the
accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. And the
prosecution, to prove its Case, examined as many as 16 P.W.s.
[7]
On perusal of material evidence on record, learned Court
below by its judgment and order dated 20.11.2024 held that the
accused be acquitted and set at liberty on benefit of doubts from
the charge levelled against him under Section 307 of the IPC.
However, the prosecution proved the accusation against the present
convict appellant Sri Bhupendra Debbarma under Section 323/326
of Indian Penal Code and the learned Court below found the
accused guilty for the offence punishable under Section 323/326
IPC. The
next
date
was
fixed
for hearing
of sentence on
22.11.2024. On the next date, the convict appellant was sentenced
to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 05(five) years and to pay a fine
of Rs. 20,000/- (twenty thousands) only and in default of payment,
the convict appellant to suffer imprisonment for 02(two) months for
commission of offence under Section 326 of the Indian Penal Code.
Learned Court below also sentenced the convict appellant to
suffer simple imprisonment for 01(one) year for commission of
offence punishable under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code by
the sentence dated 22.11.2024 and further ordered that both the
sentences stated above shall run concurrently.
[8]
Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment & order
dated 20.11.2024 and sentence of conviction dated 22.11.2024 in
connection with case No. S.T. (Type-2) 09 of 2023, the appellant
has preferred this present appeal seeking the following reliefs:
“i) Admit this appeal
ii) Call for the records
iii) Issue notice upon the Respondent,
AND
iv) After hearing the parties be pleased enough to set aside
the impugned Judgment of conviction and sentence dated
22/11/2024 passed by the Session Judge, Khowai Judicial
District. Khowai in case No:- Sessions Trial (Type-2) 09 of
2023 and the convict Appellant may be set at liberty.
AND
In the mean time, the conviction and sentence as
aforesaid
may
be
stayed
till
disposal
of
this
appeal……………..”
[9]
Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel for the appellant submits
that P.W. 7, namely Sri Ranjit Debbarma deposed before the
learned trial Court that on 03.12.2022 at about 6.00 P.M, he was
inside his shop situated at Parsurambari market and he saw some
people were gossiping in front of him. At that time, the accused
Bhupendra Debbarma came to the market with an iron hammer in
his hand and started assaulting all of them with the same randomly
as a result of which, they sustained injuries. But in cross
examination, P.W. 7 admitted that at the alleged time of incident,
he closed his shop out of fear and he could not see the manner in
which the incident took place. He submits that learned trial Court
failed to appreciate the same.
[10]
It is further contended by the learned counsel for the
appellant that the P.W 10 and P.W 11 who are the seizure witnesses
deposed that on that day they went to Parshurambari along with
the I.O. of this Case, who seized one iron hammer in their
presence. They stated that the I.O. prepared one seizure list in this
regard
where
they
put
their
signature.
But,
during
cross
examination they said that the articles were not sealed at the spot
and that they also did not signed the article as such. The PWs
further
admitted
in
their
cross
examination
that
such
type
of hammer and wooden stick are available in the market and in any
village. The witnesses also confirmed that at the time of seizure,
many local people were present at the place of occurrence and that
one of them handed over the articles to the I.O. but, the trial Court
below did not consider the said fact. Learned counsel, therefore,
urges this Court to set aside the impugned judgment & order and
sentence passed by the learned Court below and the appellant be
set at liberty.
[11]
On
the
contrary,
Mr.
Raju
Datta,
learned
P.P.
representing the State opposes the submission made on behalf of
the appellant. He, submits that learned Trial court on examination
of all the evidences has sentenced the convict-appellant and thus,
the sentence passed by the learned Court below should not be
interfered with and the present appeal filed by the appellant is liable
to be dismissed.
[12]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
material evidence on record.
[13]
For the purpose of taking decision with regard to the
case in hand, this Court feels it necessary to examine the deposition
of some witnesses who deposed their respective statements before
the learned trial Court.
[14]
P.W.s 1, 3, 4, 6 & 9 are the victims who deposed before
the trial Court below almost in a similar manner. They stated that
on 03.12.2022, at about 5:30/6:00 P.M. while they were gossiping
in the market of Porshuram Bari (Amtali) at that time, the accused
Bhupendra Debbarma appeared there with an iron hammer in his
hand and the accused then started assaulting them with that
hammer randomly, as a result of which, they sustained injuries.
P.W. 7, an eye-witness, also corroborated the statements made by
the victims that the accused appeared with an iron hammer in his
hand and then started assaulting them.
[15]
P.W. 5, the Medical Officer of Khowai District Hospital
deposed
that
on
03.12.2022,
one
patient
namely
Rathindra
Debbarma was brought to Khowai District Hospital by his relative
and accordingly, he examined him. P.W. 5 deposed that on
examination, he found the patient with one lacerated wound on the
right frontal region, measuring 2 cm x 0.3 cm into muscle depth
and probably caused by a blunt object. It is further deposed by P.W.
5 that in his opinion, the alleged injury of Rathindra Debbarma was
simple in nature, where-after he was discharged from the hospital
on that day. He (P.W. 5) stated to have prepared one injury report
in this regard and identified the same as Exbt-1 along with his
signatures over the same as Exbt-1/1 and Exbt-1/2. On the same
day, P.W. 5 deposed that he examined another patient namely
Pandit Debbarma, who was brought to the Hospital by his relative.
He stated to have examined the patient and found one lacerated
wound, measuring 5 cm x 0.3 cm into tissue depth over left cheek.
The witness further deposed that the patient was admitted at
Khowai hospital, thereafter, he was referred to AGMC and GBP
hospital, Agartala. In his opinion, the injury was caused by a
probable blunt object, which was simple in nature. P.W.5 also
identified the report prepared by him in this regard and identified
the same as Exbt-2 along with his signatures thereon as Exbt-2/1
and Exbt-2/2.
During cross-examination, P.W.5 denied the fact that he has
prepared the injury reports of aforesaid victims without proper
examination.
[16]
P.W. 15, the Medical Officer of Trauma Care Center,
AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala in his deposition stated that on
04.12.2022, he examined and treated two patients namely, Pankaj
Debbarma and Pandit Debbarma, who were referred from Khowai
District Hospital to GBP hospital, Agartala, with alleged history of
physical
assault,
in
connection
with
Champahour
PS
Case
No.2020/CPH/024, dated 04.12.2022. The witness further deposed
that on examination, he found Pankaj Debbarma conscious and well
oriented and also prescribed NCCT of his brain and after receiving
the report, he found that the patient suffered acute extradural
hemorrhage on the right frontal region; acute focal contusion injury
in the right frontal lobe; multi focal fracture over the right frontal
parieto occipital bone and fracture of right nasal bone. According to
P.W. 15, X-ray report of the chest further revealed right scapula
fracture (un-displayed) over the right scapular spine and in his
opinion, all the injuries were grievous in nature caused by probable
blunt and heavy object. The witness also identified his report
prepared and submitted in regard to the victim Pankaj Debbarma as
Exbt-10 and his signatures thereon as Exbt-10/1 (series). P.W. 15
also stated that on examination of the other patient Pandit
Debbarma, he found him conscious and well-oriented and NCCT of
his face with 3D construction was advised. P.W.15 identified his
report prepared in regard to the victim.
During cross-examination, the P.W. 15 denied that he had
submitted his report without proper examination.
[17]
On perusal of record and upon hearing the submissions
made by both the parties, this Court is of the view that the
impugned order dated 20.11.2024 passed by the Court below
convicting the accused under Section 323/326 of the IPC needs no
interference. However, in so far as the sentence of the Court below
dated 22.11.2024 in case No. S.T. (Type-2) 09 of 2023 awarded to
the accused appellant herein to suffer rigorous imprisonment for
05(five) years for the offence punishable under Section 326 is
concerned, the same is on the higher side. This Court is of the
considered opinion that the same should be reduced to one year’s
rigorous imprisonment under Section 326 of the IPC instead of
rigorous imprisonment for five years. Thus, the appellant is hereby
sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for a term of one year
and also to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand
Only) in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for 02(two) more
months for commission of the offences punishable under Section
326 IPC. Accordingly, the impugned sentence dated 22.11.2024
awarded by the Court below is modified to the extent as indicated
above. It is needless to mention that the period of detention already
undergone by the convict shall be set off and apart from the above
observation made by this Court, all other aspects of the impugned
judgment & order and the sentence passed by the learned Court
below shall remain unaltered.
In view of the above, the instant appeal is partly allowed
and thereby, the same is disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous
application(s), pending if any, shall also stand closed.
Send down the LCR.
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2025.04.07 18:27:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review