Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.674 of 2020
Sri Arup De,
son of late Manindranath De,
resident of Ramnagar Road No.4,
Agartala, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura
---- Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 010
2. The Chairman,
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project,
TW Building (Ground Floor), P.N. Complex, P.O. Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799 006
3. The Project Advisor,
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project,
TW Building (Ground Floor), P.N. Complex, P.O. Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799 006
---- Respondent(s)
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattachrya, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Adv.
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
:
29.04.2022
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
30.05.2022
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order
The petitioner who has been serving as the Assistant
Credit Officer, being aggrieved by the memorandum dated
05.09.2014 [Annexure-13 to the writ petition] has approached
this court urging that the said memorandum dated 05.09.2014
issued by the Project Adviser, Development Unit, World Bank
Aided Rubber Project Tripura be set aside and the respondents
be directed to provide the petitioner the scale of pay of Rs.957030000/- (PB-3) with grade pay of Rs.3100/- (Pre-revised) with
other admissible allowances with effect from 05.09.2014 with
interest after deducting the salary that the petitioner has
received during the said period.
02.
By the memorandum dated 05.09.2014 it has been
communicated to the petitioner that they will be paid a fixed pay
of Rs.21,000/- (twenty one thousand) per month with effect
from 01.09.2014 without any other allowances. Consequent
thereupon
the
said
decision,
the
memorandum
under
No.F.1(2)/APPTT/DU/2008/2401-04 dated 23.12.2010 has been
treated as cancelled. But the payment already made to the
petitioner as the Assistant Credit Officer from 01.10.2011 to
31.08.2014 will not be affected or need not be reopened.
According to the petitioner the Development Unit, World Bank
Aided Rubber Project, Tripura, the development unit, in short,
has been established by the Government of Tripura to oversee
the implementation on all non-rubber social activities under the
Tribal Development Plan of the World Bank Aided Rubber Project
and also to coordinate with the activities of the government,
semi government and NGOs for implementation of non-rubber
activities under the Tribal Development Unit. According to the
petitioner, the said entity falls with the meaning of ‘State’ under
Article 12 of the Constitution of India and as such the grievance
of the petition is amenable to the writ jurisdiction.
03.
There is no dispute that by the memorandum dated
11.10.1999 [Annexure-2 to the writ petition], two posts of
Assistant Credit Officer in the scale of pay of Rs.6500-12300/was created for a period of six years with effect from October,
1999 till the end of 2005. The posts of different categories were
created under the said development unit. The development unit
was managing the scheme of alternative credit arrangement
styled as Tripura Rubber Painting Revolving Plant (TRPRS) was
finalized and approved by the Government of India and the
World Bank. Thus an amount of Rs.16 crores approximately had
flown as credit to the rubber growers from 1999-2000 to 200405. For purpose of channelizing the credit assistance to the
rubber
growers,
National
Bank
for
Agriculture
and
Rural
Development (NABARD) has formulated a Scheme and as per
the proposed scheme, the development unit has been given the
responsibility of the payment as the implementing agency. As
such, the activity of the development unit was expanded
considerably and it required the experts in the field of credit.
Thus, a post of Credit Officer in the scale of pay of Rs.10,00015001 along with Assistant Credit Officer were created.
04.
Officer
The petitioner was engaged as the Assistant Credit
by
the
letter
of
appointment
dated
21.05.2008
[Annexure-4 to the writ petition] initially for a period of one
year. Therefore, it is apparent that the petitioner joined the said
development unit on contract basis on 25.05.2007 as Assistant
Credit Officer. The petitioner was getting a sum of Rs.8,000/with effect from 01.09.2008. Thereafter by the memorandum
dated 16.12.2009 [Annexure-6 to the writ petition] issued by the
Project Adviser the monthly fixed pay of the petitioner and two
others who are serving the Assistant Credit Officer was enhanced
from Rs.8000/- to Rs.10,810/- per month with effect from
01.01.2009.
05.
In the joint meeting of the development unit held on
15.11.2010, the petitioner and another who were serving as the
Assistant Credit Officer on fixed monthly pay were accorded
regular scale of pay by allowing them the scale of pay of
Rs.9570/-30,000/- (PB-3) with the grade pay of Rs.3100/- as
per Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (ROP
Rules, 2009 for short) plus admissible allowances. The initial pay
of the petitioner in that scale was fixed at Rs.12,670/-.
Thereafter by the memorandum dated 26.08.2011 issued by the
Project Adviser, the service book of the petitioner and another
Assistant Credit Officer were opened. The petitioner and the
other Assistant Credit Officer started getting the Dearness
Allowance with the basic pay.
06.
By the memorandum dated 16.01.2013 the Project
Adviser released further instalment of DA @ 5% with effect from
01.07.2012 over the revised pay structure. Thereafter, by the
memorandum dated 27.05.2013 issued by the Project Adviser
another instalment of DA with effect from 01.12.2012 over the
revised pay structure was released. The petitioner has asserted
that against the sanctioned regular posts, the petitioner was
appointed as Assistant Credit Officer, but all on a sudden by the
memorandum dated 05.09.2014 [Annexure-13 to the writ
petition] it was ordered that the petitioner will be paid the fixed
pay at Rs.21,000/- per month with effect from 01.09.2014
without any further allowances. The said memorandum dated
05.09.2014 had brought an end of the benefits generated by the
memorandum dated 13.12.2010. However, it had been declared
that the amount that was drawn by the petitioner will not be
recovered. It has been asserted by the petitioner in para-17 of
the writ petition that by the memorandum dated 18.11.2014
[Annexure-14 to the writ petition] the Tribal Welfare Department
conveyed the sanction of the post of Assistant Credit Officer in
the scale of pay of Rs.9570/--30000/- (PB-3) with grade pay of
Rs.3100/- under the development unit, the World Bank Aided
Rubber Project for the period from 01.09.2014 to 31.03.2015
subject to the conditions as laid down in the said memorandum.
The entire text of the said memorandum dated 18.11.2014
[Annexure-14 to the writ petition] is extracted considering its
ramification in the controversy.
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
TRIBAL WELFARE DEPARTMENT
(ESTABLISHMENT SECTION)
No.F.1-525./TW/ESTT(Part)/2013/18219-24
Dated, Agartala, The 18/11/2014
MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Creation of posts of Asstt. Credit Officer under
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project.
The undersigned is directed to convey the sanction of the
Government to the creation of the post of Asstt. Credit Officer in the Pay
Band – 3, Scale Rs.9570-30,000/-, Grade Pay-Rs.3100/- under
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project for the period w.e.f.
01-09-2014 to 31-3-2015 subject to the following condition:(a) 50% of the outstanding loan including interest should be
recovered by 31st March, 2015.
(b) The department may go for PDR cases for recovery of the
loans though SDMs.
(c) Further continuation of the 2 (two) posts will depend upon
fulfillment of condition as indicated in (a) above.
The expenditure will be debitable from World Bank Aided
Rubber Project.
This is issued with the concurrence of the Finance Department
U.O. NO. 1283/Fin(G)/2014 dated 31-10-2014.
Sd/- Illegible
Under Secretary to the
Govt. of Tripura”
It
has
been
contended
by
the
petitioner
that
by
the
memorandum dated 16.05.2015 [Annexure-15 to the writ
petition] the Government of Tripura had allocated the post of
Assistant Credit Officer in the said scale with the grade pay, as
shown before, for the development unit. The said post was
created with due concurrence from the government.
07.
The petitioner was in the regular pay scale during
the period from 23.12.2010 to 05.09.2014. But after the
memorandum dated 05.09.2014 was issued, the petitioner was
again made the officer on fixed pay. The petitioner has therefore
contended that from the memorandum dated 18.11.2014, the
memorandum dated 16.05.2015 and the memorandum dated
20.01.2017 as issued by the Tribal Welfare Department it has
transpired that the post of Credit Officer was created in the
regular pay scale. The said post of Assistant Credit Officer had
been sanctioned following the procedure. Having noticed the said
development, the petitioner had approached the competent
authority for restoring his regular pay scale against the post
created by the Tribal Welfare Department and to release the
regular pay scale with effect from 05.07.2014. The petitioner had
filed the representation on 16.06.2020 and thereafter, to push
the matter
rigorously,
he
had filed the
reminders
dated
28.07.2020 and 16.06.2020. But his regular pay scale was not
restored.
08.
Having situated thus, the petitioner has challenged
the said memorandum dated 05.09.2014 [Annexure-13 to the
writ petition] and urged for direction on the respondents to
provide him the regular scale of pay of Rs.9570/-30000/- (PB-3)
with grade pay of Rs.3100/- with other admissible allowances.
09.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
quite emphatically submitted that when the regular post is
available and the petitioner was accommodated in such regular
pay scale, as would be evident from the memorandum dated
16.12.2009 [Annexure-6 to the writ petition], the respondents
who provided the regular pay scale by adjusting the appointment
of the petitioner against the created post, are passive in this
matter. Even they have not responded to the representations
filed by the petitioner.
10.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. appearing for the
respondents
raised
a
preliminary
objection
regarding
the
maintainability of the writ petition contending that the impugned
memorandum was issued on 05.09.2014 and the writ petition
has been filed on 03.10.2020. Thus the cause for filing the writ
petition has become stale and this court may not lay hand on
such cause for purpose of reopening an issue which has been
settled by efflux of time.
11.
The respondent No.1 has filed a separate reply and
the respondents No.2 & 3 have filed a combined reply resisting
the prayer of the petitioner. The respondent No.1 in his short
reply has admitted that the regular scale of pay for the post of
Assistant Credit Officer was granted to the petitioner in terms of
the decision of the meeting of the governing body held on
15.11.2010. But the petitioner was originally appointed on
contract basis to act as the Assistant Credit Officer under the
development unit to carry out the works, related to credit as a
means of alternative financing arrangement. Later on, he was
converted to a fixed pay Officer on monthly pay of Rs.21,000/-.
By the memorandum dated 05.09.2014, the regular pay scale
was withdrawn and fixed pay of Rs.21,000/- was introduced. The
petitioner, however, continued in the service.
12.
In this reply, a memorandum dated 29.07.1999 has
been referred to, to contend that the two posts of Credit Officer
and Assistant Credit Officer were sought to be filled up by the
suitable eligible officer, either from Tripura Cooperative Bank or
Tripura Gramin Bank depending on the availability of the suitable
officers, on deputation or on contract basis. For implementation
of the alternative financing scheme or arrangement under the
World Bank Aided Rubber Project it required to carry out the
recovery campaign. There had been necessity of the experts in
the line of managing credit, particularly recovery of loans (the
credit from the defaulting loanees). At one point of time
Rs.2,11,81,286.67/- was the unrecovered loan amount. The said
amount was to be recovered from the rubber growers and as a
result of that, the Credit Officer and the Asst. Credit Officers
were proposed to be engaged. But in the entire reply, this court
does not find any relevant materials on why these two officers
cannot be given the regular pay scale as proposed by the
development unit itself. However, with the reply, the respondent
No.1 has produced minutes of the meeting of the governing body
held on 29.08.2014. The agenda item No.11 is relevant for our
purpose and the same is therefore is reproduced hereunder:
“Agenda Item No.11: Regarding regular pay scale of Asstt.
Credit Officers of Development Unit, WBARP under ROP Rules,
2009.
The Governing body has reviewed the decision taken in
the last Annual General meeting held on 15-11-2010 and after
detailed discussion, the Governing body resolved that
Assistant Credit Officers of Development Unit who were
engaged on contract basis on fixed pay prior to 15-11-2010
will be paid a fixed sum of Rs.21,000/- (Rupees twenty-one
thousand) only per month with effect from 1st September,
2014 onwards without any other allowances.”
13.
The facts as narrated in the writ petition by the
petitioner, have nowhere been contradicted by the respondent
No.1, even not by the respondents No.2 & 3 who filed a separate
reply. The reply of the respondents No.2 & 3 is of paramount
importance as the said reply has come from the development
unit of the said project. They have stated that at a subsequent
meeting of the governing body held on 29.08.2014, the
development unit had reviewed its earlier decision and resolved
that Assistant Credit Officers of the development unit who are
engaged on contract basis will be paid a fixed sum of
Rs.21,000/- per month with effect from 01.09.2014 and the said
decision was circulated by the memorandum dated 05.09.2014
[Annexure-13 to the writ petition].
14.
In view of the said decision, the pay scale as
provided to the petitioner was withdrawn by the memorandum
dated 05.09.2014. In the memorandum dated 29.07.1999, it
was clearly indicated that the post of Credit Officer and Assistant
Credit Officers may be filled up by suitable/eligible officers either
from Tripura State Cooperative Bank (TSCB) or Tripura Gramin
Bank (TGB) depending on and subject to the availability of
suitable officers on deputation/contract basis. The memo dated
29.07.1999 shows ‘the fund to be required for meeting the
establishment charge/pay and other allowances etc., of the
aforesaid staff. It has been clearly mentioned that the sumwould
be met up out of the service charges to the extent of 1.5% of
the loan amount, as provided in the scheme which is not the
correct fact, rather it is an inadvertent mistake and has to be
replaced with ‘1.5% of the Interest amount’, as there was/is no
provision under ‘Guidelines for implementation of Alternative
Financing Scheme under World Bank Aided Rubber Project’
wherefrom it could be said that the Development Unit can
retain/utilize service charge of more than 1.5% of the loan
amount rather it is service charge/retention of 1.5% of interest,
as it would also be evident from para-(o) of the Guidelines. They
have also referred to the recovery statements as published on
31.01.2015, 31.03.2016 and 31.03.2017 in comparison to that
of the realization of loan as recorded in the audited accounts
from the financial years 2014-15 to 2016-17 vis-a-vis the
performance of the concerned employees in terms of target
assigned to them for 50% recovery of outstanding loan including
interest could not be achieved. Therefore, a huge amount of
Rs.12,49,50,632.59 including interest is still recoverable form
the borrowers/rubber growers as on 30.09.2020.
15.
reply
The respondents No.2 & 3 have produced with the
the
statements
dated
31.01.2014
[Annexure-R/4],
31.03.2016 [Annexure-R/5] and 31.03.2017 [Annexure-R/6].
They have also produced the audit report and balance sheet from
the period from 2014-15 and 2016-17 [Annexure-R/7 to R/9]. It
has been asserted that as per the guidelines, tenure of the
scheme is 14 years inclusive of 6 years grace period upto 2014.
However, outstanding loan amount including interest could not
be paid to the Tripura State Co-operative Bank Ltd. due to nonrealisation/recovery of dues form the borrowers. As such, the
repayment schedule of loan has been re-scheduled upto 2019 by
increasing tenure in two spells i.e. in the year 2011 and 2018.
The Development Unit, in addition to the recovery campaigns
spearheaded by Assistant Credit Officers, 173 names of defaulter
loanees had been referred to the Certificate Officers (S.D.M.s)
for
instituting
PDR
cases
on
total
default
amount
of
Rs.2,11,81,286.67. An amount of Rs.10,58,867/- had also been
paid to Certificate Officers (SDMs) being 5% processing fees.
Additionally, the Assistant Credit Officers had been given
recovery target but, despite all efforts, recovery was not
satisfactory. Development Unit had accordingly resolved to settle
the loan amount with Tripura State Co-operative Bank Ltd. on
30.05.2018
by
paying
the
principal
amount
of
Rs.2,61,02,696.59/- at a time and payment of settled amount of
interest (Rs.2.58 crore) within a period of two years i.e. by May,
2020. However, within the target date of two years, settled
interest amount could not be repaid to the said Bank and as on
date, an amount of Rs.2,31,90,000/- is still to be paid to the
Bank.
16.
On the other hand, as per cash analysis as on
30.09.2020,
the
fund
position
of
different
accounts
is
Rs.75,08,204.82/-. Detailed fund positions are indicated at
Annexure-R/12 to the reply filed by the respondents No.3 & 4.
They have also stated further that it would be apparent from the
said cash analysis that an amount of Rs.7,43,117.26 (including
4% margin/service charge) only is in the Savings Bank Account
No.12727 (Loan Recovery Amount) maintained with TSCB Ltd.
Agartala Branch, whereas an amount of Rs.2,31,90,000/- as
balance being the interest is payable to Tripura State Cooperative Bank Ltd. according to one time settlement, due date
of which has expired in the month of May, 2020. That apar, the
Unit has other liabilities.
17.
Having appreciated the records as well as the
submission of the learned counsel for the parties, this court
would make some initial observations viz.:
(i) That the petitioner was appointed in the scale of pay of
Rs.9570/-30,000/- in PB-3 with the grade pay of Rs.3100/- in
terms of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules,
2009 by the memorandum dated 23.12.2010 [Annexure-7 to
the writ petition].
(ii)
It
appears
from
the
memorandum
dated
29.07.1999
[Annexure-3 to the writ petition] that the Department of Tribal
Welfare created two posts of Assistant Credit Officer in the scale
of pay of Rs.6500-12,300/- . The petitioner was appointed for
the period from 01.05.2008 to 30.04.2009 as Assistant Credit
Officer by virtue of the order dated 01.05.2008 [Annexure-4 to
the writ petition]. In the same terms and conditions and for the
same period the other Assistant Credit Officer namely Sri Rajib
Acharya was also engaged.
(iii) It is apparent from the memorandum dated 16.12.2009 that
the pay of the Assistant Credit Officer Development Unit has
been enhanced from Rs.8,000/-10,810/- per month with effect
from
01.01.2009.
Further,
by
the
memorandum
dated
23.12.2010 [Annexure-7 to the writ petition] the basic pay of the
petitioner was fixed @Rs.12670/- in the scale of pay of
Rs.9570/-30,000/-.
18.
It would be evident from the memorandum dated
27.05.2013 that 7% of Dearness Allowance was released with
effect from 01.12.2012 over the revised pay structure. The
amount was released provisionally in favour of the petitioner and
the other Assistant Credit Officer. While scanning the records, on
that count the memorandum dated 18.11.2014 has been
noticed. In the said memorandum, it has been stated that one
post of Credit Officer in the PB-3 [Rs.9570-30,000/-] under the
Development Unit had been sanctioned by the Government of
Tripura. But the said creation was subject to the following three
conditions:
“(a) 50% of the outstanding loan including interest should be
recovered by 31st March, 2015.
(b) The department may go for PDR Cases for recovery of the
loans though SDMs.
(c) Further continuation of the 2(two) posts will depend upon
on fulfillment of condition as indicated in(a) above.”
Finally,
the
Society
has
been
founded
by
the
Government of Tripura for a special purpose - for channelizing
small credits to the rubber growers and recovery of the said
amount so that the bank does not find their credit at jeopardy.
19.
It is therefore clear that the posts were tenure-based
[contract] posts from the specialized cadres of Tripura Gramin
Bank and Tripura State Cooperative Bank Limited. Creation of
the posts as claimed by the petitioner does not mean the said
post was created in the regular establishment with regular scale
of pay. On the contrary, the post was created as the contract
posts in the recommended pay scale. The petitioner has relied
on, as stated earlier, on the memorandum dated 16.12.2009
[Annexure-6 to the writ petition]. This court would like to refer
to the memorandum dated 23.12.2009, wherein it has been
categorically stated as follows:
“In accordance with the decision adopted in the meeting of
the Governing Body and Annual General meeting of the
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project, Tripura
held on 15.11.2010, Basic pay of Rs.12670/- in the scale of
pay Rs.9570-30000 with pay band PB-3 and grade pay
Rs.3100/- as per Tripura Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules,
2009 and following admissible allowances for the following
Assistant Credit Officers, Development Unit, World Bank Aided
Rubber Project, Tripura is hereby sanctioned w.e.f.
01.01.2011 as indicated below. Other terms and conditions
will remain unchanged.
SL
Name
of
Incumbent
and
Designation
Pay band
scale
Grade
pay
(Rs.)
1.
Sri Arup De
Asstt. Credit
Officer
Sri
Rajib
Achariya
Asstt. Credit
Officer
Rs.957030000 Pay
band PB-3
Rs.957030000 Pay
band PB-3
No.
2.
D.A.
24%
(Rs.)
HRA
10%
(Rs.)
CA
(Rs.)
Total
(5+6+7+8)
Basic
pay
(3
+4)
Rs.
12670
17303
12670
17303
The expenses towards pay and other allowances shall be
borne by the Development Unit out of service charge and
bank interest earned by the Development Unit and the pay
shall be paid in cash to the Assistant Credit Officers.”
20.
Therefore, it is apparent that THE fund that is
created for purpose of payment of pay and other allowances
shall be managed by the Development Unit from service charge
and bank interest. The petitioner has challenged the impugned
memorandum dated 05.09.2014 [Annexure-13 to the writ
petition]
after
a
considerable
lapse
of
time.
By
the
representation
dated
16.06.2020
and
the
reminder
dated
28.07.2020 [Annexure-17 to the writ petition], it has been urged
for releasing the regular pay scale in their favour. But the
respondents have denied the same by projecting the financial
position. All the relevant records have been produced before this
court and it appears that the respondents does not hold a good
financial position and in terms of the project frame-work, the pay
and allowance of the petitioner was supposed to come from the
fund constituted of the service charge and interest from the
bank. The amount that has been kept in the bank has been
revealed by the respondents. In the consideration of this court,
the said amount is very meager. As such, this court is not in a
position to direct the respondents to release the regular pay
scale to the petitioner for his holding the post of Assistant Credit
Officer on contract basis directly. However, the respondents are
directed to review the financial position in order to extend the
regular scale having due regard to the scale that was earlier
released to the petitioner in terms of the decision of the Annual
General Meeting of the Development Unit [the Society] which
was held on 15.11.2010. The Nodal Officer of the Government
shall also explore the possibilities of placing additional fund for
that purpose. The said exercise shall be completed within a
period of 6(six) months from the date when a copy of this order
shall be placed before the respondents.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands disposed
of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review