Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 855 OF 2022
Sri Arup De, s/o Lt. Manindranath De,
R/o Road No.4, Agartala, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala.
……Petitioner.
Vs.
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Chairman, Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project,
TW Building (Grd. Floor), P.N. Complex, P.O. Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
3. The Project Advisor, Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber
Project, ST Corporation (1st Floor), Lake Chowmohani, Agartala.
.…. Respondents.
For the petitioner
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Counsel.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For the respondents
: Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
date of delivery of
judgment & Order
: 20.08.2024.
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for granting him regular pay scale prescribed for the post of Assistant
Credit Officer.
2.
The background facts of the instant case is that under Order dated
21-05-2008 issued by the Project Advisor, Development Unit, World Bank
Aided Rubber Project, Tripura, the petitioner was engaged in the Development
Unit purely on contract basis in the interest of public service to carry out the
works relating to loan extended under Alternative Financing Arrangement,
Accounts and Training, etc. In the said order, the remuneration of the persons
to be engaged on contract basis was fixed at Rs.3000/- per month. The service
of the petitioner was extended time to time. During the period of his service, at
one point of time one pay scale was provided to the petitioner. The petitioner
has drawn much emphasis on a memorandum dated 11 th October,1999
[Annexure-3 to the writ petition] issued by the Govt. of Tripura whereby and
whereunder two posts of Assistant Credit Officer were created in the scale of
pay of Rs.6,500-12,300/-. From the said memorandum, it is evident that the
said scale was provided for 6 (six) years w.e.f. October, 1999 till the end of
2005. Under another memorandum dated 23.12.2010 [Annexure-6 to the writ
petition], the pay scale of Assistant Credit Officer was revised with certain
terms and conditions that would be applicable w.e.f. 01.01.2011. Under this
memorandum, the pay scale of Assistant Credit Officer was prescribed as
Rs.9,570-30,000/-, Pay Band-3 along with other allowances. Thereafter, vide
memorandum dated 05.09.2014 [Annexure-12 to the writ petition], it was
communicated to the petitioner that in accordance with the decision taken by
the Governing body in the Annual General Meeting held on 29.08.2014, the
service of the petitioner was put on fixed pay basis for a sum of Rs.21,000/only per month w.e.f. 1st September, 2014 onwards without any other
allowances instead of the pay scale as prescribed under Memorandum dated
23.12.2010, which was treated to be cancelled. The State-respondents had
issued another memorandum dated 18.11.2014 creating the post of Assistant
Credit Officer in the Pay Band-3, Scale of Rs.9,560-30,000/-, Grade PayRs.3,100/- under the Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project
for the period w.e.f. 01.09.2014 to 31.03.2015 subject to the following
conditions:
(a) 50% of the outstanding loan including interest should be
recovered by 31st March, 2015;
(b) The department may go for PDR cases for recovery of the
loans though SDMs;
(c) Further continuation of the 2(two) posts will depend upon on
fulfillment of conditions as indicated in (a) above.
2.1
It is apparent that memorandum dated 18.11.2014 was issued
with the concurrence of the Finance Department dated 31.10.2014. Again,
under memorandum dated 16.05.2015 two posts of Assistant Credit Officer in
the scale of Rs.10,230-34,800, Grade Pay Rs.4600/- under Development Unit,
World Bank Aided Rubber Project for the period from 01.04.2015 to
31.03.2016 were created subject to condition that 50% of the outstanding loan
including interest should be recovered by 31st March, 2016. After completion
of said period of one year, the State-respondent had issued memorandum
dated 20-01-2017 [Annexure-15 to the writ petition] creating two posts of
Assistant Credit Officer from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 in the Pay Band-3,
Scale–Rs.10,230-34,800/-, Grade Pay Rs.4,600/- subject to condition that 50%
of the outstanding loan including interest should be recovered by 31 st March,
2017.
2.2
The grievance of the petitioner is that granting of regular pay
scale has arbitrarily been stopped to him by the respondents on the pretext that
the project has been facing financial crunch and his service is put on a fixed
pay basis. From the memorandum dated 23.08.2022, it is revealed that fixed
pay amount has been enhanced to Rs.25,000/- per month w.e.f. 01.09.2017.
2.3
The petitioner has challenged the change of salary from regular
pay scale to fixed pay by way of filing a writ petition before this Court which
was registered as WP(C) 674/2020, titled as Sri Arup De vs. the State of
Tripura & Ors. The said writ petition was disposed of vide judgment and
order dated 30.05.2022. Learned Single Judge of this Court [S. Talapatra, J, as
he then was] had made certain observations, which are according to me,
relevant to decide the merits of the instant writ petition.
“18. …….While scanning the records, on that count the
memorandum dated 18.11.2014 has been noticed. In the said memorandum,
it has been stated that one post of Credit Officer in the PB-3 [Rs.957030,000/-] under the Development Unit had been sanctioned by the
Government of Tripura. But the said creation was subject to the following
three conditions:
“ (a) 50% of the outstanding loan including interest should
be recovered by 31st March, 2015.
(b) The department may go for PDR Cases for recovery of the
loans though SDMs.
c) Further continuation of the 2(two) posts will depend upon
on fulfillment of condition as indicated in(a) above.”
Finally, the Society has been founded by the Government of Tripura
for a special purpose - for channelizing small credits to the rubber growers
and recovery of the said amount so that the bank does not find their credit at
jeopardy.
19. It is therefore clear that the posts were tenure-based [contract]
posts from the specialized cadres of Tripura Gramin Bank and Tripura State
Cooperative Bank Limited. Creation of the posts as claimed by the petitioner
does not mean the said post was created in the regular establishment with
regular scale of pay. On the contrary, the post was created as the contract
posts in the recommended pay scale. The petitioner has relied on, as stated
earlier, on the memorandum dated 16.12.2009 [Annexure-6 to the writ
petition]. This court would like to refer to the memorandum dated
23.12.2009, wherein it has been categorically stated as follows:
“In accordance with the decision adopted in the meeting of
the Governing Body and Annual General meeting of the Development Unit,
World Bank Aided Rubber Project, Tripura held on 15.11.2010, Basic pay of
Rs.12670/- in the scale of pay Rs.9570-30000 with pay band PB-3 and grade
pay Rs.3100/- as per Tripura Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and
following admissible allowances for the following Assistant Credit Officers,
Development Unit, World Bank Aided Rubber Project, Tripura is hereby
sanctioned w.e.f. 01.01.2011 as indicated below. Other terms and conditions
will remain unchanged.
SL
Name
of
Incumbent
and
Designation
Payband
scale
Grade
pay
(Rs.)
1.
Sri Arup De
Asstt.Credit
Officer
Rs.957030000Pay
bandPB-3
No.
D.A.
24%
(Rs.)
HRA
10%
(Rs.)
CA
(Rs.)
Total
(5+6+7+8)
Basic
pay
(3
+4)
Rs.
12670
17303
2.
Sri
Rajib
Achariya
Asstt. Credit
Officer
Rs.957030000Pay
bandPB-3
12670
17303
The expenses towards pay and other allowances shall be
borne by the Development Unit out of service charge and bank interest
earned by the Development Unit and the pay shall be paid in cash to the
Assistant Credit Officers.”
20. Therefore, it is apparent that THE fund that is created for
purpose of payment of pay and other allowances shall be managed by the
Development Unit from service charge and bank interest. The petitioner has
challenged the impugned memorandum dated 05.09.2014 [Annexure-13 to
the writ petition] after a considerable lapse of time. By the representation
dated 16.06.2020 and the reminder dated 28.07.2020 [Annexure-17 to the
writ petition], it has been urged for releasing the regular pay scale in their
favour. But the respondents have denied the same by projecting the financial
position. All the relevant records have been produced before this court and it
appears that the respondents does not hold a good financial position and in
terms of the project frame-work, the pay and allowance of the petitioner was
supposed to come from the fund constituted of the service charge and
interest from the bank. The amount that has been kept in the bank has been
revealed by the respondents. In the consideration of this court, the said
amount is very meager. As such, this court is not in a position to direct the
respondents to release the regular pay scale to the petitioner for his holding
the post of Assistant Credit Officer on contract basis directly. However, the
respondents are directed to review the financial position in order to extend
the regular scale having due regard to the scale that was earlier released to
the petitioner in terms of the decision of the Annual General Meeting of the
Development Unit [the Society] which was held on 15.11.2010. The Nodal
Officer of the Government shall also explore the possibilities of placing
additional fund for that purpose. The said exercise shall be completed within
a period of 6(six) months from the date when a copy of this order shall be
placed before the respondents.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.”
3.
In earlier round of litigation, the learned Single Judge held that
the post of Assistant Credit Officer is a tenure-based post. I am unable to take
a different view. In my opinion, there cannot be any disagreement that the post
of Assistant Credit Officer is a tenure-based post subject to fulfillment of
certain conditions. However, in view of the directions passed by learned
Single Judge of this Court in WP(C) No.674/2020 supra, the respondents had
considered the matter and issued memorandum dated 23.08.2022 whereby and
whereunder it was communicated to the petitioner that his representation for
granting regular pay scale could not be acceded to due to financial condition
the respondents are facing presently.
4.
Feeling aggrieved by the said memorandum dated 23.08.2022,
the petitioner has approached this Court again urging that he should be paid
regular pay scale as prescribed under the memorandum dated 23.12.2010.
5.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has strongly argued that two posts of Assistant
Credit Officer had been created by the Government of Tripura with regular
pay scale. Sudden stoppage and non-granting of the said regular pay scale to
the petitioner holding the post of Assistant Credit Officer is illegal, arbitrary
and discriminatory and thus violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India. The crux of submission of learned senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the petitioner is that once regular pay scale is granted, it cannot be
withdrawn under any circumstance. It is further argued that the nature of post
is permanent in nature and as such, the petitioner is entitled to regular pay
scale.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents submits that from the nature of creation of the posts, it is apparent
that the said posts of Assistant Credit Officer are tenure-based. Further, when
the financial position of the Project was found good the respondents created
these two posts with pay scale subject to fulfillment of certain conditions. He
has drawn the attention of this Court that initially the petitioner was engaged
on contract basis for fixed pay of Rs.3,000/- per month and thereafter, with the
extension of the period of the contract service, the remuneration has been
increased. Sometimes, the Government had created post of Assistant Credit
Officer providing certain pay scale in the Pay Band-3 along with other
allowances. Since the terms and conditions of granting pay scale could not be
fulfilled by the petitioner and due to heavy loss suffered by the Development
Unit, the Government was forced to stop sanctioning and granting of any pay
scale. However, enhanced his salary to Rs.25,000/- per month. From the
memorandum relating to creation of posts of Assistant Credit Officer, it is
apparent that at every time Government had created the said post of Assistant
Credit Officer prescribing certain pay scale for a period of only one year. So,
the nature of creation of post of Assistant Credit Officer clearly suggests that
it is tenure-based post having no permanent status and that was so on contract
basis.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties and also have perused the observations and findings of learned
Single Judge while disposing of the writ petition being numbered WP(C)
674/2020. As I said earlier, there cannot be any disagreement that the post of
Assistant Credit Officer is purely a tenure-based post. Sometimes, considering
the financial position, pay scales were prescribed. It is also revealed that the
said post was created for one year and thereafter it was extended time to time
and every after one year there was new creation of the said post of Assistant
Credit Officer prescribing certain pay scale and that also subject to fulfillment
of certain conditions. In my considered view, the nature of the creation of post
coupled with occasional grant of pay scale on certain conditions keeping in
view the financial position of the Project would not confer any statutory right
upon the petitioner to claim such pay scale.
8.
I have further taken note of the submissions of learned senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner that the way the respondents had dealt
with the directions passed in the writ petition supra, it could not be proper and
cannot be said to be a genuine consideration.
9.
I have perused the memorandum dated 23.08.2022 [Annexure-19
to the writ petition]. While considering the directions of learned Single Judge
of this Court, the Project Advisor, Development Unit, WBARP, Tripura had
observed thus:
“…..Sri De, Assistant Credit Officer on 27-06-2022 has
submitted representation to the Principal Secretary, Tribal Welfare
Department, Govt. of Tripura and others seeking restoration of regular
scale of pay in view of the said Order of Hon’ble High Court, Tripura by
setting aside the Memorandum dated 05-09-2014 with all consequential
and ancillary benefits.
From fund status of Development Unit, World Bank Aided
Rubber Project is a project based unit, Tripura which has to pay back
Tripura State Co-op. Bank Ltd. Rs.2.19 Crore while recovery the same
from the user, it reveals that it has no sufficient fund to provide regular
scale of pay to him.
Further, as per recruitment order Sri De is not eligible for
regular scale of pay as he was recruited on contract basis only for project
duration.
It is, therefore, ordered that the contractual engagement of
Sri Arup De, Assistant Credit Officer is hereby issued with effect from the
date of issue of this Memo. for further period of 11(eleven) months with
one day break before re-engagement.
This has got approval of the Principal Secretary, Tribal
Welfare Department, Government of Tripura vide U.O. No.740, dated 2507-2022.”
10.
Having perused the above consideration, undertaken by the
Project Advisor, Development Unit, WBARP, I find that the authority
concerned while considering the judgment and order passed by this Court had
taken into account the financial position of the Development Unit, WBARP
and it is categorically stated that there is no fresh fund to provide regular scale
of pay to him.
11.
From the contents of the writ petition coupled with the supporting
documents, it comes to fore that the respondents granted pay scale to the
petitioner on some occasions subject to fulfillment of certain conditions.
Thereafter, the authorities concerned were found to be unable to provide the
pay scale as fixed by the Government time to time. Subsequently, when it was
found that it had no sufficient fund they put the service of the petitioner on
fixed pay basis.
12.
In view of this, I am unable to agree with the submissions of
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner that the respondents had
not properly dealt with the directions passed by learned Single Judge to
explore the possibilities of granting regular pay scale to the petitioner.
13.
There is yet another aspect necessary to be considered. Post of
Assistant Credit Officer is not a permanent post. From the nature of creation
of post time to time, it crystallizes that the post of Assistant Credit Officer is a
tenure-based post having different pay structures prescribed time to time.
Every after one year, the respondents used to create the said post prescribing
certain pay scale or remuneration depending upon the financial position of the
organization. Furthermore, the original engagement of the petitioner was on
contract basis and the nature of engagement has not been changed. More so, it
is a project based post.
14.
In the considered view of this Court, the petitioner cannot claim
regular pay scale on regular basis. Under memorandum dated 11 th October,
1999 two posts of Assistant Credit Officers were created prescribing pay scale
of Rs.6,500-12,300/- w.e.f. October, 1999 only for six years i.e. till the end of
2005. The petitioner was engaged on contract basis vide order dated
21.05.2008 on fixed remuneration of Rs.3000/- that is after expiry of the
period of six years. So, it is clear that the pay scale prescribed under
memorandum dated 11th October, 1999 would not be applicable to him. Vide
memorandum dated 16.12.2009 [Annexure-5 to the writ petition], the
remuneration was enhanced from Rs.8,000/- to Rs.10,810/- per month w.e.f.
01.01.2009 and it was applicable till November, 2009 i.e. for only 11 (eleven)
months. Under memorandum dated 23.12.2010 certain pay scale of Rs.9,570
to 30,000/- with Pay Band-3 was provided to the petitioner. In the said
memorandum, it is clearly stated that other terms and conditions would remain
unchanged. The benefit of granting pay scale was withdrawn vide
memorandum dated 05.09.2014 and the service of the petitioner was put on
fixed pay basis for a sum of Rs.21,000/- per month w.e.f. 1st September, 2014
onwards. Under memorandum dated 18.11.2014 [Annexure-13 to the writ
petition] the post of Assistant Credit Officer was again created after obtaining
due sanction of the State Govt. subject to fulfillment of certain conditions.
One of the important conditions was that 50% of the outstanding loan
including interest should be recovered w.e.f. 31st March, 2015. It was further
stipulated in the said memorandum that further continuation of the two posts
will depend upon fulfillment of conditions as indicated here-in-above.
15.
Under memorandum dated 16.05.2015 [Annexure-14 to the writ
petition] two posts of Assistant Credit Officer were created afresh after
obtaining approval of the Government subject to condition that 50% of the
outstanding loan including interest should be recovered by 31 st March, 2016.
The other terms and conditions remained unchanged. The said post was again
created under memorandum dated 20.01.2017 [Annexure-15 to the writ
petition] providing pay scale of Rs.10,230-34,800/- for the period from
01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 subject to condition that 50% of the outstanding
loan including interest should be recovered by 31st March,2017. Thereafter, as
I said earlier considering the financial position of the Development Unit of the
Project, the pay scale prescribing against the post of Assistant Credit Officer
was withdrawn and the service of the petitioner was put on fixed pay basis
which was enhanced upto Rs.25,000/- per month.
16.
From the aforesaid discussions, it is aptly clear that the post of
Assistant Credit Officer was never created on permanent/regular basis. After
the end of the tenure of the post, it was found to be created afresh for a period
of further 11 (eleven) months.
17.
In view of this, the post of Assistant Credit Officer is purely a
tenure-based post and having held the said post, the petitioner cannot claim for
regularization of the said post. As I have already observed, no statutory or
constitutional right is conferred upon the holder of such tenure-based post to
claim a particular pay scale. Fixation of pay against a particular post is
absolutely within the domain of the government. This Court in exercise of its
discretionary and extra-ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India cannot direct the policy makers to convert a tenure-based
post to a permanent/regular post prescribing a regular pay scale.
18.
In the light of above discussions and for the reasons recorded
here-in-above, I do not find any merit in the present writ petition.
Accordingly, it stands dismissed.
JUDGE
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review