Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 505 of 2023
Sri Arjun Kumar Saha
S/o Ramani Mohan Saha
R/o Milan Sangha, Dayamoy
Ashram Road, P.O. & P.S: A.D.
Nagar, Agartala, District-West Tripura,
PIN-799003, Age-61 years
..…….Petitioner(s)
1.
Vs.
Tripura Jute Mills Limited,
A Govt. of Tripura Undertaking
(to be represented by the
Managing Director, Tripura
Jute Mills Limited, Hapania,
P.O: O.N.G.C, Agartala, PIN-799014)
2.
The Managing Director,
Tripura Jute Mills Limited,
Hapania, P.O: O.N.G.C,
Agartala, PIN-.799014
3.
The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Industries and Commerce,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799010
4.
The Director of Industries
and Commerce, Govt. of Tripura,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799006
…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. D Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M Debbarma, Addl. GA.
Mr. P Gautam, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
4th March, 2024.
Date of delivery of Judgment
:
23rd April, 2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The petitioner was appointed as Lower Division Clerk
under the respondent No.1 on 06.05.1985 and he went on
superannuation on 31.12.2021. During his service tenure he also
worked in the Department of Tripura Minorities Cooperative
Development Corporation on deputation for the period from
19.11.1999 to 15.06.2021. On his retirement, as per provision of
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 he was entitled to receive the
gratuity to the tune of Rs.9,56,414/- as was finally assessed by
the respondent No.1, but, he was paid only Rs.7,39,830/- by
cheque dated 11.04.2022 and rest amount of Rs.2,16,584/-was
deducted by the department on the ground that as per audited
annual accounts of Tripura Jute Mill Limited for the financial year
2020-2021 conducted by the office of the Accountant General
Rs.2,16,584/- was found lying unadjusted against the petitioner
out of which Rs.2,13,634/- was lying in suspense account and
Rs.2,950/- remained unadjusted which was paid to him for
payment of advance to the other staff.
2.
By letter dated 12.02.2022 (Annexure-2 of the writ
petition) the petitioner was asked by the Accounts Officer of
respondent
No.1
to
submit
expenditure
report
with
vouchers/adjustments against the said advance within a period of
15 days from the date of issue of notice and in turn the petitioner
submitted his reply dated 25.02.2022 (Annexure-3 of the writ
petition) requesting the respondent No.2 to furnish him the date
and year wise disbursement report for the said unadjusted amount
and to give him a scope to clarify the total matter about the said
unadjusted amount.
3.
According
to
the
petitioner,
he
already
went
on
retirement and the matter of said unadjusted amount was
unknown to him. He also stated that on some occasion he had
disbursed the salary by receiving the money from the cash section
of the Jute Mill and after disbursement he had duly submitted the
salary bill sheet with proper signatures of the workers and
accordingly the amount was duly adjusted on each occasion. But
the petitioner was not furnished with the full particulars of such
disbursement report as was requested by him by said letter dated
25.02.2022 and without giving him adequate opportunity to make
response to the allegation, the said amount of Rs.2,16,584/- was
illegally deducted from the gratuity. Thereafter, he sent a notice
dated 28.04.2022 (Annexure-5 of the writ petition) through his
advocate to respondent Nos.2 and 4 requesting them to refund his
deducted amount of gratuity, else he would take necessary legal
recourse against them.
4.
The notice got no response from them and the
petitioner then filed WP(C) No.509/2022 in this court and the said
petition was disposed of by a co-ordinate Bench vide order dated
16.05.2023 with the following direction:-
“3.
It is seen from the record that the vide
notice dated 12.02.2022, issued by Accounts
Officer, TJML, the petitioner herein was asked
to submit expenditure report along with
vouchers/adjustments. The petitioner herein
has submitted his documents with explanation
as required on 25.02.2022 but the matter is
still pending. In view of the same, without
expressing any opinion on its merit, this
present writ petition is disposed of with a
direction upon the respondents to consider the
case of the petitioner within a period of
3(three) months from the date of receipt of the
copy of this order.”
5.
In view of above said direction of this court, the
respondent No.2 issued a letter dated 10.07.2023 (Annexure-9 of
the writ petition) reiterating the above said facts but without
furnishing the required documents as were sought by the
petitioner and further stating that as the petitioner had failed to
submit any authentic paper/document against adjustment of long
pending unadjusted advance amount of Rs.2,16,584/- the said
amount was deducted from his gratuity. The letter of the petitioner
dated 25.02.2022 was disposed of in this way by respondent No.2.
6.
Thereafter, being aggrieved thereby the petitioner has
filed the present writ petition seeking following reliefs:
“I.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus
and/or
order/orders, direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay interest @7% per annum for
deferred
payment
of
gratuity
amount
of
Rs.7,39,830/- w.e.f. 01.02.2022 to 19.04.2022.
ii.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus
and/or order/orders, direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby quashing the
Notice, dated, 12.02.2022, issued by the Accounts
Officer, TJML.
iii.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus
and/or order/orders, direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby quashing and
cancelling the letter, dated, 10.07.2023, issued by
the Managing Director, Tripura Jute Mills Ltd.
iv.
Call for the records pertaining to the instant
Writ Petition from the custody of the Respondents.
v.
Make the Rules absolute after hearing the
Parties Pass any other order/orders as this Hon,ble
High Court may consider fit and proper.”
7.
Mr. P Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner
contended that in view of the Section 13 of the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1982, any such deduction from the amount of
gratuity was not permissible. Learned Sr. counsel also argued that
the matter of so called adjustment was of the year 1994 and 1995
but till retirement of the petitioner the department did not agitate
the issue and after his retirement they had suddenly come up with
such demand which had no legal basis and according to learned
Sr. counsel, even the petitioner was not given opportunity to
scrutinize the matter and to give proper explanation, if any, for the
same. Learned Sr. counsel also relied on a decision of a coordinate Bench of this court passed in Mr. Lala Darlong vs.
Tripura Gramin Bank & ors. in WP(C) No.712/2017 decided
on 25.09.2008 to bolster his submission.
8.
Learned counsel of the respondent Nos. 1 & 2 Mr. P
Gautam, submitted a short written note of his argument and also
contented that the said amount of Rs.2,16,854/- was lying
unadjusted on the part of the petitioner which was public money,
and therefore, same could not be allowed to be drained out.
9.
According to Mr. Gautam, learned counsel after the said
matter was detected in the annual accounts of the Jute Mill, the
notice was duly sent to the petitioner but he failed to give any sort
of explanation for the same, and therefore, the said amount was
deducted from his gratuity. Learned counsel Mr. Gautam has also
relied
on
a
office
memorandum
bearing
No.28/91/2022-
P&PW(B)(1) dated 20.10.2023 issued by the Department of
Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare, Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances and Pensions, Government of India whereby the Under
Secretary to the Government of India in view of Rule 67 of the
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules 2021 requested all the
Ministries and Departments to ascertain the dues payable by a
government servant due for retirement on superannuation and to
adjust the same against the amount of the gratuity as payable to
the said government servant. In reply thereto, Mr. Roy Barman,
learned Sr. counsel argued that Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules 2021 had no applicatiton in Tripura and therefore the said
memorandum was irrelevant for the purpose of this case.
10.
In view of the submissions and counter-submissions as
made by the learned counsel of the both sides and the pleadings of
the parties, the questions that arise for decision in this case are- i)
whether deduction of any Govt. dues payable by a government
servant to the Department, from his gratuity is permissible and ii)
whether proper opportunity was provided to the petitioner to
either submit his adjustment of the dues or to explain the reason
of such non-submission, before such amount was deducted from
his gratuity amount.
11.
The relevant provision regarding the protection of
gratuity of a government employee as enumerated in Section 13 of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 reads as under:13. Protection of gratuityNo
gratuity
payable under this Act [and no gratuity payable
to an employee employed in any establishment,
factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway
company or shop exempted under Section 5]
shall be liable to attachment in execution of
any decree or order of any civil, revenue or
criminal court.
12.
This provision, as it appears on its plain reading,
prohibits attachment of any gratuity payable under this Act or any
gratuity payable to an employee in any establishment, factory,
mine, coalfield, plantation, port, railway company or shop as
exempted under section 5 of the Act, in execution of any decree or
order of any civil, revenue or criminal court. Therefore, such
protection against such attachment has been restricted by the law
makers only in respect of any execution of any decree or order of
any such court. But such prohibition has not been extended in the
matter of adjustment/recovery of any Govt. dues payable by an
employee to their department. Therefore, the petitioner cannot
claim any such protection with the aid of Section 13 of the Act.
13.
In the case of said Lala Darlong (supra) as relied on
by learned Sr. counsel Mr. Roy Barman, this court also observed
that Section 13 of the Act might not have any direct bearing in the
said case inasmuch as the said provision created prohibition
against the court from execution of the decree against the amount
of gratuity. In that case, the petitioner was an employee of Tripura
Gramin Bank and forfeiture of gratuity in case of such bank
employee was not permissible in case of dismissal from the service
on account of any misconduct except in cases where such
misconduct caused financial loss to the Bank and in that case too,
such forfeiture was permissible to that extent only, as per
Regulation 69 of Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees)
Service Regulation Act, 2001 and based on above said regulation,
the respondents in that case were directed not to recover the
outstanding amount of the loan from the gratuity as they had
other remedies available for recovery of the same. Thus, the said
decision is of no aid to the petitioner in the instant case.
14.
Recently, in the Steel Authority of India Limited vs.
Raghbendra Singh & Ors., reported in (2021) 18 SCC 272 the
Hon’ble Supreme court observed that penal rent for occupying the
quarters beyond the specified period can be adjusted against the
dues payable to the employee including his gratuity. Reference of
another judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court rendered in Secy., ONGC
Ltd. v. V.U. Warrier, (2005) 5 SCC 245 was made therein and
one of the relevant paragraphs is extracted below:
21.
In Jarnail Singh v. Secy., Ministry of Home
Affairs [(1993) 1 SCC 47 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 119 :
(1993) 23 ATC 642] this Court had occasion to
consider the provisions of the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972. The definition of “pension”
included gratuity under Rule 3. Rule 9 conferred on
the President right to withhold or withdraw pension
in certain circumstances. The order was passed
against the appellant withholding pension and the
entire amount of death-cum-retirement gratuity
otherwise admissible to him. The direction was given
on serious irregularities found to have been
committed by the appellant. The appellant challenged
that order unsuccessfully before the Central
Administrative Tribunal. He, therefore, approached
this Court. His contention was that an amount of
gratuity could not have been withheld. Negativing
the contention, the Court held that the power to
withhold gratuity was conferred on the President
under the relevant rules and hence, such action could
not be said to be illegal. According to the Court, there
could be adjustment of government dues against the
amount of death-cum-retirement gratuity payable to
government servant.
In view of above there is no bar regarding recovery of
any outstanding amount/dues from the amount of gratuity payable
to the petitioner by the respondent Nos.1 & 2. The Point no.1 is
decided accordingly.
15.
The basic allegation against the petitioner is of non-
submission of adjustment in respect of Rs.2,16,584/-. From the
Annexure-R(9) and R(10) of the counter affidavit of respondent
Nos.1 & 2, it appears that in the list of suspense account as on
31.03.1994 an amount of Rs.2,13,747.53 is shown against the
name of the petitioner and in the list of advance to the staff as on
31.03.1995, an amount of Rs.1200/- is reflected against the name
of the petitioner. But the above said documents or other
documents as submitted from the side of respondent nos. 1 & 2,
do not reflect the detailed particulars based on which such
amounts were shown against the name of the petitioner. Despite
the specific requests made by the petitioner to respondent no.2
vide his letter dated 25.02.2022, the date and year wise payment
disbursement report of such unadjusted dues were also not
furnished to him.
16.
The matter was very old one and till the year 2022 the
respondent Nos. 1 & 2 remained silent and did not take any action
in this regard, unless same was detected by the Audit Authority,
which is no doubt a lapse on their part. It is also very natural for a
person to forget a matter relating to the year 1994 and 1995,
more particularly when he has gone on retirement on 31.12.2021
and he has no longer any access to the official documents. Unless
sufficient
particulars
and
necessary
facts
relating
to
such
unadjusted amount are provided to him giving him reasonable
opportunity to either submit the adjustment or to offer explanation
for non-submission of the same, deduction of any such amount
from his gratuity or from other post retirement benefits will be
inequitable, harsh and violation of natural justice. Even no notice
except the notice dated 12.2.2022 asking him to submit the
adjustment report was also issued to the petitioner giving him
scope to submit his explanation before such deduction was made
from gratuity. Point No. 2 is decided accordingly in favour of the
petitioner.
17.
In view of above, the writ petition is disposed of with
the following directions:
i)
The respondent Nos. 1 & 2 shall furnish detailed
particulars of the unadjusted amount to the petitioner including
the copies of the document(s) as sought by him vide his letter
dated 25.02.2022 (Annexure 3 of the writ petition) and also any
other available document(s) as required by the petitioner, within
four weeks from the receipt of this order enabling the petitioner
either to submit proper adjustment thereof or to submit his
explanation, if any, in this regard.
ii)
If the adjustment/explanation, if any, is duly submitted
by the petitioner to the satisfaction of respondent nos.1 & 2 within
four weeks from receipt of said required document(s), the
respondent No.1 & 2 will immediately release the deducted
amount of gratuity of Rs.2,16,584/- to the petitioner within further
four weeks from the date of receipt of such explanation or
adjustments, alongwith interest thereupon @7% per annum
computing from the date after expiry of 30 days of his retirement
till payment is made.
iii)
Failure on the part of the petitioner to submit proper
adjustment of the said amount or to give proper explanation for
non-submission of such adjustment within the aforesaid period as
stipulated, such deduction of Rs.2,16,584/- shall be treated to be
valid.
iv)
The petitioner will have the liberty to approach proper
forum again in respect of any further grievance(s) in relation to
this matter in issue.
The writ petition is disposed of accordingly with above
said directions.
Pending applications, if any, also stand(s) disposed of.
JUDGE
SATABDI DUTTA
Satabdi
Date: 2024.04.24 14:05:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review